On this installment of the RRH, we’ve got the fab Dr. Jim Kanichirayil. Jim is currently a Talent Strategy Evangelist at Circa. He’s co-host of the Cascading Leadership podcast. Today Jim and I dig into all that is backwards about the employee/employer relationship. And what great leaders are doing about it.
Topics Discussed:
What exactly is it that’s fundamentally broken about today’s talent marketplace ? (3:50)
What is driving change within our organizations now? (7:17)
Does the arc of the universe bend towards justice? (12:41)
What’s wrong with the bs indoctrination about the employee/employer relationship? (13:42)
What do Millenials and Gen Z most care about when choosing an organization to work with and for? (15:45)
For more Guest:
For more Amy:
What's up human.
Amy:Welcome to the revenue real hotline.
Amy:I'm Amy UFF check.
Amy:More importantly.
Amy:I'm excited.
Amy:You decided to join us.
Amy:Today.
Amy:I know you've got a ton of options and I appreciate you.
Amy:This is a show about all the hard and uncomfortable conversations
Amy:that arise while generating revenue and how to think or rethink what
Amy:you're doing, why you're doing it.
Amy:And then of course, How to execute differently.
Amy:And like I said, I'm happy you decided to come along for the ride.
Amy:Don't forget to follow the show wherever you listen.
Amy:So you can be notified each time a new episode drops.
Amy:And do me a favor friend.
Amy:Don't tell anybody about the show.
Amy:Let's keep it our little secret.
Amy:I'm Amy UFF check.
Amy:This is the revenue real hotline.
Amy:Enjoy
Amy:Dr.
Amy:Jim Kenny.
Amy:Triol welcome to the revenue real hotline, sir.
Amy:It's so strange, man.
Amy:I feel like I know you all already, like have a deep, like relationship with you,
Amy:but what is this our first, second time?
Amy:Like actually solo talking.
Jim:Yeah, I think, uh, I think you and I met on, uh, Andy's first
Jim:kickoff call for sell the sell without selling out launch team.
Jim:And then, uh, we had a handful of conversations and then we're in
Jim:a couple of the same communities.
Jim:Yeah, this is probably a second conversation, but, uh, I think like live.
Jim:Yeah,
Amy:yeah.
Amy:Yeah.
Amy:I feel like I've been slacking with you at least every other day since January.
Amy:So now we can make it, you know, public official with a podcast episode, Dr.
Amy:Jim, why don't you start by sharing with our listeners a little bit about
Amy:who you are and what you do every day, and then we'll dive right in.
Jim:I think the best way to describe myself, is to narrow
Jim:it down and say, look, I, I.
Jim:Work and act as if I'm gonna drop dead tomorrow.
Jim:And I learn as if I'm gonna live forever.
Jim:And that pretty much defines my, my cadence.
Jim:Now in terms of the actual work that I do, um, I currently, uh, am
Jim:one of the sales managers at CERCA.
Jim:So we are a SaaS technology platform, but we are an end to
Jim:end talent strategy solution.
Jim:And we take a DEI first approach to the marketplace.
Jim:Whereas most of our other competitors are generally operating
Jim:on the talent acquisition side.
Jim:We operate from acquisition.
Jim:Development, retention.
Jim:We don't do anything on the exiting side.
Jim:But we are a full, uh, life cycle talent solution which gives us a,
Jim:a unique place in the marketplace.
Jim:And that's, before we talk about our diversity first approach to the market.
Jim:So what we do is we allow organizations to find more talent.
Jim:Find more diverse talent.
Jim:And then as an offshoot or a downstream impact of that, you're better able
Jim:to retain your talent because you're more diverse and you have more
Jim:representation within your organization.
Jim:And,
Amy:and so all that is absolutely fabulous.
Amy:And you're sitting under the all seeing eye of carton or,
Jim:uh, yep.
Jim:We, we are , we are under the all seeing eye of Carman listeners
Amy:listener.
Amy:Wait, hold on, Jim.
Amy:I listeners, I'm looking, we're talking about Jim's background right now.
Amy:And Jim, I don't think I've ever seen anybody that pulls in.
Amy:What are those like vintage toys up there too?
Amy:Somehow?
Amy:What are
Jim:those?
Jim:They're, uh, they're not vintage, but I have a, a fair
Jim:amount of, uh, of Funko pops.
Jim:I have a couple of McFarland toys, so I have, uh, spawn figure.
Jim:Uh, I have ink who is from bat band beyond.
Jim:I have a Bobba Fe that's made out of nuts and bolts.
Jim:That's pretty cool.
Jim:Uh, and then I have a ton of books and other, you know,
Jim:tchotchkes hanging around.
Jim:Very,
Amy:very interesting.
Amy:Okay.
Amy:So I love this and I could talk about that all day.
Amy:But I wanna go back to this diversity thing.
Amy:Let's start with a high level overview of what your take of the current state
Amy:of, let's say diversity and exclusion.
Jim:So I think I can talk in general about the talent marketplace, uh,
Jim:from a, from a broad perspective.
Jim:Yeah, let's do it.
Jim:I, I, I make no bones about it.
Jim:I think, uh, I.
Jim:Talent and hiring and, and the way things are done are fundamentally broken.
Jim:Right.
Jim:Um,
Amy:he would, I agree about that.
Amy:So I'm, I'm a little bit sad cuz it's like, I'm trying to bring more people
Amy:that I disagree with on the show, but like you get up on that soapbox, sir.
Jim:And I'm gonna give context.
Jim:So most of my career has been spent.
Jim:In the staffing and recruiting space or in the technology sales space.
Jim:So I, I, I have a particular sort of world viewer experience
Jim:within both of those spaces.
Jim:And I nerd out about all of this talent strategy stuff where I'm one
Jim:of the only people that actually has terminal research on retention internal.
Jim:My study was on how leadership style and leadership training impacts
Jim:employee retention and turnover.
Jim:So my brand, when I talked to anybody involved in a hiring position comes
Jim:from that lens of not only being a theoretician, but also a practitioner
Jim:uh, that's actually helped put hundreds and hundreds of people to work.
Jim:And one of the consistent challenges that happen that's
Jim:happened throughout my career.
Jim:And it still happens now is.
Jim:People get tied into a particular box that is engineered by whoever is
Jim:involved in talent acquisition or job design, and saying, if you don't fit
Jim:nicely into this box, um, we're not even gonna have a conversation with you.
Jim:And I have a fundamental disagreement with that approach because it's not about
Jim:like the checklist that you check off.
Jim:It's what do you deliver?
Jim:What have you done from an outcomes based perspective?
Jim:And that's how I talk to internal talent acquisition HR.
Jim:That's how I actually recruit and hire, uh, for people on my team is.
Jim:I don't care about how much time and seat criteria you've had through your career.
Jim:It's what have you delivered?
Jim:What's been the outcome that is consistent or representative of
Jim:the outcome that I'm seeking.
Jim:That's the best predictor of success, not these time and seat metrics,
Amy:Okay.
Amy:So I like, I love that Jim.
Amy:I love that.
Amy:Assessment, but, but I also, what I love also love about 2022
Amy:is it's the year of execution.
Amy:Yeah.
Amy:And like in many ways on the show, like I'm, I'm getting kind of bored
Amy:of talking about all this stuff.
Amy:That's not bored, but like, I, we could spend all day talking about
Amy:the problem and where it came from.
Amy:And, and frankly, I'm, I'm interested to do that, but I'm also very excited to hear
Amy:your take on what's working right now.
Amy:You know, how people are.
Amy:Injecting more fairness, I guess you could say into the process, or
Amy:maybe fair is the wrong word, but just like trying something different.
Amy:And what I love about this circa tagline, right?
Amy:Which is that.
Amy:Elite diverse teams drive transformation.
Amy:And I, I that's been my personal experience.
Amy:I, I see that.
Amy:But then I look at the current state of our tech sales floors and it's
Amy:still very much not diverse at all.
Amy:But anyway, what are you excited about?
Amy:What are you, what are you seeing this year that's different or better
Amy:in how companies are approaching?
Amy:I guess the solution,
Jim:I think there is a snowball effect that is just starting.
Jim:and it's starting because people are actually being VO more vocal about what
Jim:they stand for and what they believe.
Jim:And I have these conversations all the time about encouraging people on my
Jim:teams and just people in my network that, you know, you don't have to be at
Jim:a certain level to have a point of view.
Jim:You know, whatever you're passionate about, whatever you care about, you know,
Jim:put that out in the world because that's gonna impact a bunch of other people
Jim:that are probably saying, or thinking the same thing, but are afraid to say it.
Jim:So you have to create the opportunity for these things to be said out loud.
Jim:And then that's how you start impacting change.
Jim:So to your question about, what am I excited about?
Jim:This is actually in like LinkedIn is a great model for it or place for it.
Jim:You're actually seeing people at all levels of experience sharing
Jim:their stories and their journeys.
Jim:And that's starting to have a trickle up effect on organizational strategies and
Jim:philosophies when it comes to hiring.
Jim:So you referenced this earlier, you said that, Hey, you know, there's
Jim:all this stuff going on from a diversity and inclusion perspective.
Jim:And when I look at tech sales, they seem to be lagging.
Jim:And that's not surprising because when you think about broader tech
Jim:sales and how they operate within marketplaces and within communities,
Jim:They're looking for a certain profile.
Jim:You have to go to the right school.
Jim:You have to, you know, know somebody within, uh, the organization.
Jim:You have to have a certain pedigree.
Jim:And generally, if, if you're looking at a baseline requirement of having
Jim:a college degree to enter into sales, and the guys that train you talk
Jim:about it, Omar and Sunil, talk about this, uh, pretty extensively that
Jim:automatically locks you into an upper middle class or higher demographic
Jim:that you're recruiting from mm-hmm
Jim:But when you look at what are the core competencies required
Jim:for being successful in sales?
Jim:What is it?
Jim:It's curiosity,
Amy:curiosity, continuous learner resilience.
Amy:Yep.
Amy:Yep.
Amy:Um, likes to win, right?
Amy:Yeah.
Amy:Not to say money, like when operated or money motivated, but there's
Amy:a competitive aspect to yep.
Jim:All of those.
Jim:Yeah.
Jim:Yeah.
Jim:So when, when we look at how organizations and tech are hiring, or
Jim:at least, uh, predominantly have been hiring, they operate with the belief
Jim:that those attributes that you just listed off are exclusive to an upper
Jim:middle class or higher upbringing.
Jim:And that's simply not true.
Jim:Well,
Amy:I'm gonna, I wanna add to that too, cuz I, I just did a
Amy:post about this, this past week.
Amy:Like my, my only post on LinkedIn is whatever it's getting
Amy:taxing, but it needs to happen.
Amy:But anyway, does selling SAS require.
Amy:A special set of selling skills.
Amy:That one can only acquire while selling SA question mark.
Amy:Because I happen to believe that when you cultivate the skills to create
Amy:something from nothing, cough, revenue, cough, that translates universally.
Amy:But I believe that a lot of people still have this mindset that like there's so.
Amy:Special about selling SAS, which is nonsense.
Amy:And so that, I think that that's a piece of it, but I, I also, I, how do
Amy:you take ego out of this conversation?
Amy:How do you take the trickle down effects from the way that we are allocating
Amy:venture capital dollars, right.
Amy:Which starts at the fucking top, you know?
Amy:And so then, and you know what Dr.
Amy:Jim, I can also, I've been able to find actually a lot more empathy for.
Amy:The subconscious bias associated here.
Amy:That is just as I'm starting to root out my.
Amy:Then I look at, I think it's the IMF has their economic participation
Amy:index line that they do.
Amy:We're moving backwards.
Amy:And the United States is literally one of the worst in first world countries.
Amy:And again, we're not making any fucking progress and it's been like 30 years
Amy:since we've all been talking about this.
Amy:And I said, I wouldn't get up on a soapbox or be mad about it because
Amy:I wanna be hopeful and I am hopeful.
Amy:But again, like it's just that ego that harbors, this thought that like
Amy:selling sass is harder or different.
Amy:Is absolutely another piece of the, the pie.
Amy:And then we can even look at the demographics that are starting to play
Amy:out on the SD R AE front or frontline managers, SDR managers, and AE managers.
Amy:But with that, I'm gonna pause.
Amy:Like, what's
Jim:say you, sir.
Jim:So I might, I might challenge you on a, on a couple of those points, so, okay.
Jim:I, I think when, and, and, and I don't know if, uh, if you were
Jim:just saying it for a factor, if, if you really believe it.
Jim:I think, uh, I think if you, if you think.
Jim:You know, Hey, we're not moving the needle and it's been 30 years.
Jim:I think there are, you know, there has been movement in the
Jim:right direction, but you have to, oftentimes when people say that
Amy:I'm talking.
Amy:Yeah.
Amy:All right.
Amy:Let me clarify.
Amy:Yeah, because I don't wanna take away from the progress that has been made.
Amy:I'm talking about the leadership stats.
Amy:Yeah.
Amy:That the demographics at the leadership level in particular, um, that then
Amy:make the decisions about that trickle up that you were talking about.
Amy:And.
Amy:That piece in particular is,
Jim:is the thing.
Jim:Yeah.
Jim:So when you're looking at leadership within organizations and senior
Jim:leadership within organizations, it's a, it's still pretty monochro,
Jim:but it's a it's it's moving in, in, in the direction that it should.
Jim:Now we can have discussions or arguments or debates about the pace of change
Jim:and what that needs to look like.
Jim:But I think it was president Obama who said the arc of the
Jim:universe always bends to justice.
Jim:And that's a true statement.
Jim:And you know, some people that know me really well are gonna find it ironic
Jim:that I'm quoting president Obama, but you know, there's value in that statement.
Jim:So those things are moving in the right direction because more people
Jim:are talking about it and you know what, I'm a gen Xer and a lot of my,
Jim:uh, Demographic or my age, demographic rolls their eyes at things that
Jim:millennials and generation Z care about.
Jim:If you look at the changes that are happening and all the progress that are
Jim:happening, it's actually millennials and generation Z that are driving it.
Jim:They're the ones that have been saying for a period of time
Jim:that this stuff is screwed up.
Jim:When you look at things like the employer, employee relat.
Jim:you know, we, and, and, and, you know, this ties into your overarching point
Jim:about things are moving too slow.
Jim:Things are moving too slow because we've been like indoctrinated into
Jim:a bunch of BS that just isn't true.
Jim:Like.
Jim:My generation gen X, we came up in the era of if you work hard and you know,
Jim:you do all this stuff, you'll get ahead.
Jim:Just keep your head down.
Jim:And, and people notice
Amy:you.
Amy:Yeah, don't forget about that.
Amy:Gold.
Amy:Yeah, the pension and that gold watch for, you know, retiring.
Jim:I didn't come in in the pension and gold watch, but that mentality yeah.
Jim:Was, was very much evident in our generation.
Jim:And it was the millennials and generation Z who had serious economic
Jim:upheavals that happened when they were coming up in the world of work
Jim:that said, That's all horse shit.
Jim:Um, I, I don't typically like swear in these things, but, you
Amy:know, wait, be welcome to the revenue real hotline.
Amy:And I'm also from Jersey.
Amy:So you could say whatever the fuck you want on my side, Dr.
Jim:Jim.
Jim:Um, so, so it was, it was them that called it out.
Jim:And now you see a fundamental shift in the employee, employer relationship,
Jim:and as it should be one of the things that I always talk about with
Jim:my is that we're all free agents.
Jim:So my role as a leader of an organization or a leader within an organization is
Jim:to understand what your big picture moonshot is and help you achieve
Jim:those things in service of our collective mission as an organization.
Jim:But you're only gonna be here for a period of time.
Jim:So I'm, I'm like deliberately getting rid of that mentality that when you join an
Jim:organization, you're gonna be here until you die, because that's the, that's the
Jim:stuff that I had indoctrinated into me.
Jim:And actually, when you look at the talent marketplace and the hiring marketplace,
Jim:there are a lot of people in hiring that still think about things that same way.
Jim:Oh, this person's moved from job to job every six to 12 months.
Jim:They're.
Jim:You know, a fit, they're a
Amy:job hopper.
Amy:They're not a, a quality candidate.
Amy:quality human.
Jim:Yes.
Jim:And you know what?
Jim:That's bullshit too.
Jim:No demographic is monolithic.
Jim:So I will introduce that caveat, but what do millennials and
Jim:generation Z care highly about?
Jim:Like all of the surveys that are out there say that their, one of
Jim:their biggest attraction factors is the ability to make an impact
Jim:at the dusk level and organizations that are doing well by doing good.
Jim:so that person who is moving roles every six to 18 months or whatever,
Jim:what if they are driven by making an impact they're brought in for a type
Jim:of impact, they make that impact.
Jim:And then go to the next thing, because they're not the type of
Jim:person that just wants to sit around and keep the lights on.
Jim:Like, I can totally identify with that.
Jim:So you have all of these broken ways of thinking.
Jim:I think all of that factors into.
Jim:I guess the scope of the challenge.
Jim:And we can't expect the scope and breadth of this challenge.
Jim:Like we're talking about fundamentally transforming the
Jim:way people think about things.
Jim:Yeah.
Jim:Right.
Jim:and that means stripping away all of the decades of indoctrination in
Jim:terms of what hiring looks like, what a, what a, what a good candidate.
Jim:And I'm using air quotes looks like.
Jim:So that takes work.
Jim:And it only happens if people like you and me and everybody else are
Jim:loud about, Hey, this is backwards.
Jim:Hiring and especially in sales has nothing to do with time and seat it.
Jim:It's all about aptitude and attitude.
Jim:Mm-hmm and then you can teach them the skill mm-hmm . The the,
Jim:the mechanics of a complex sale, that's teachable your attitude and
Jim:your aptitude to figure stuff out.
Jim:That's what's not teachable.
Jim:And that's how I actually interview for people to join on my.
Amy:It's and yet we like this whole idea that talent is a
Amy:scarcity thing is, is prevalent.
Amy:And this one is a little bit dated.
Amy:This was a Miller Hyman study.
Amy:It was a, they do a talent report every year.
Amy:Um, I think this is maybe like two, three years ago at this point, but I
Amy:remember seeing red when I read this Dr.
Amy:Jim, because it was like, a bunch of CROs.
Amy:Do you have, do you believe that you have enough talent on your team this year?
Amy:To do what needs to be done.
Amy:And it was some ungodly number, like in the, the high eighties,
Amy:low nineties that said we, no, I don't have the talent on my team.
Amy:And I just, again, I remember feeling rage in that moment because it's
Amy:like, whose responsibility is that?
Amy:But it brings it back to like awareness.
Amy:I'm totally with you, right?
Amy:You gotta, you gotta be aware of what you need to change or, uh, especially
Amy:when it comes to yourself in your thinking, which is why I have a
Amy:show about uncomfortableations and the most uncomfortable conversation
Amy:that we will ever have in this business is with ourselves.
Amy:But that said whether or not someone wants to acknowledge that.
Amy:I don't wanna use the word wrong, but that there's room for improvement
Amy:in how they're interpreting, how they've been interpreting.
Amy:Mm-hmm, something for their entire life.
Amy:How, the way that they've been interpreting that's gotten them.
Amy:The results that they've gotten for better or worse is wrong.
Amy:And that is, um, that's a tall order
Amy:that wraps in.
Amy:Installment of the revenue real hotline.
Amy:I'd like to thank my guest for being so damn real and for sharing their insights
Amy:and for, of course, being so much fun.
Amy:And I'd like to thank you two listeners.
Amy:It means the world.
Amy:And I appreciate you.
Amy:If you have any thoughts or comments or experiences, you feel inclined to share
Amy:head straight over to revenue, rail dot.
Amy:There's a new join.
Amy:The conversation feature on the right side of the page.
Amy:I am old damn ears.
Amy:Final thought.
Amy:We are introducing a coaching aspect to the show.
Amy:So anyone who's brave enough to dig into an account strategy
Amy:or outbound strategy session.
Amy:That's where we kick things off.
Amy:Please do follow the show wherever you listen to your podcast.
Amy:So you'll always have the latest episode downloaded.
Amy:If you want to contact me.
Amy:I'm at Amy at revenue, rail.com.
Amy:If you wanna follow me on social Twitter is Amy underscore UFF check,
Amy:and LinkedIn is linkedin.com/amy UFF.
Amy:Check.
Amy:This episode was produced by the fabulous Neen Feedler rock, man.
Amy:And I appreciate you too friend.
Amy:And of course, whatever you do, don't tell anybody about the show.
Amy:Let's keep it our little secret.
Amy:Until next time, all I'm Amy re hub check.
Amy:This is the revenue real hotline, happy selling.