** Get a 50% off our online course, IBC Mastery **
With current rising interest rates, many carriers have similarly raised the interest rates on policy loans. Many whole life policy owners are wondering how this will affect their practice of The Infinite Banking Concept ®.
In this episode we talk about policy loan rates and what to expect with whole life insurance dividends as interest rates rise.
As John Montoya tells us, “interest rates are relative”.
Episode Highlights
0:00 - Introduction
0:12 - Episode beginning
2:19 - Interest rates
5:23 - Interest rates are relative
10:00 - What it means to take the control of the banking function in your life
13:01 - Taking loans
19:01 - Make sure that you’re calculating life properly
23:28 - Episode wrap-up
About Your Hosts:
Hosts John Perrings and John Montoya are dedicated to spreading the word about Infinite Banking so you can discover for yourself how you and your loved ones can benefit with a virtual streamlined process that will take you from IBC novice to sharing the strategy with friends and family... even the skeptics!
John Montoya is the founder of JLM Wealth Strategies, began his career in financial services in 1998 and is both an Authorized IBC® and Bank on Yourself® professional licensed nationwide.
John Perrings started StackedLife Financial Strategies after a 20-year career in the startup world of Silicon Valley where he specialized in data center real estate, finance, and construction. John is an Authorized Infinite Banking® professional and works nationwide.
Interested in working with us?
>> Connect with us here <<
Hello everyone.
John Montoya:This is John Montoya,
John Perrings:and this is John Perrings.
John Montoya:We are Infinite Banking Authorized practitioners
John Montoya:and hosts of the fifth Edition.
John Montoya:Episode 63.
John Montoya:In this episode, we're gonna talk about whole life insurance policy rates.
John Montoya:As many policy holders have been notified recently, policy loan rates
John Montoya:have gone up as of January 1st, 2023.
John Montoya:Is this a bad thing?
John Montoya:We'll discuss.
John Montoya:John, what are your thoughts?
John Montoya:Yeah,
John Perrings:a lot of people are getting letters in the mail telling
John Perrings:them that their policy loan interest rates are going to be going up
John Perrings:effective at the beginning of the year.
John Perrings:And this is across the board for the most part.
John Perrings:It's not just particular carriers.
John Perrings:And the reason for that is interest, general interest rates are going up and
John Perrings:I would say the, first of all, the reason we decided to do this episode in the first
John Perrings:place is because we're obviously getting some calls, asking questions about how,
John Perrings:asking us questions about how this works.
John Perrings:And you typically will see depending on the carrier, some carriers
John Perrings:will offer a fixed interest rate.
John Perrings:A lot of carriers offer variable interest rates.
John Perrings:, a couple carriers offer both, and you can decide at the time you take
John Perrings:the loan, which way you want to go.
John Perrings:So for, mostly for those variable rate holders, the rates are going up and
John Perrings:some carriers handle these increases differently so that there are carriers
John Perrings:that just raise rates anytime they want.
John Perrings:And then there are others that will only do it annually.
John Perrings:And I'm sure there's some carriers that do it in between.
John Perrings:And we wanted to do this episode because we're getting, again, we're getting
John Perrings:a lot of calls asking about it and wondering what the effect is gonna be.
John Perrings:on what they're doing with Infinite Banking, and obviously the first
John Perrings:effect is that you're gonna pay higher interest on policy loans.
John Perrings:Duh.
John Perrings:, but that's not necessarily a bad thing compared to what's going on out in
John Perrings:the general interest rate environment.
John Perrings:And so if we look at the prevailing interest rate environment, actually if
John Perrings:I can, let me go back and talk about how interest rates have been looking for the
John Perrings:past, I don't know, call it 10, 15 years and for a while for Infinite Banking.
John Perrings:The prevailing interest rates you could get from a bank were
John Perrings:typically significantly lower than a policy loan interest rate.
John Perrings:Maybe as much as a couple of points lower or a couple hundred basis points lower.
John Perrings:And so it.
John Perrings:It was a discussion that had to be had where people were like if I can
John Perrings:get a 3% loan from a bank, why would I borrow money from my, against
John Perrings:my policy loan, my cash value?
John Perrings:Why would I use a policy loan at 5%?
John Perrings:That doesn't, how does that make sense?
John Perrings:And of course there are different answers to that.
John Perrings:Some of them.
John Perrings:More softer principles based.
John Perrings:The numbers though, like of course, a 3% loan is better than a 5% loan.
John Perrings:If all things are equal, obviously that's not the case.
John Perrings:With p with policy loans, you have, the freedom to pay back whenever you want.
John Perrings:There's no payback terms.
John Perrings:So some of those benefits are there, but it was always a discussion of
John Perrings:why wouldn't I just use a bank?
John Perrings:And of course, John and I have talked about, shopping for your best money.
John Perrings:And so may maybe it.
John Perrings:The right move to use a policy loan.
John Perrings:Maybe the best move is to use a bank loan.
John Perrings:But we're starting to see some things change as interest rates are
John Perrings:going up, we're starting to see.
John Perrings:An arbitrage happened again, similar to how things were in 2000 when becoming
John Perrings:your own banker first came out.
John Perrings:So if you read Becoming Your Own Banker by Nelson Nash, which is
John Perrings:again, is the source material for everything we're talking about.
John Perrings:So if you haven't read it, you need to read it.
John Perrings:But in the book, , there was some significant arbitrage between the going
John Perrings:bank rate you could get at a bank and what you could get from your policy loan.
John Perrings:So in, in the book, he uses the example of buying cars or financing
John Perrings:equipment, and so there would be the policy loan rate was lower than what
John Perrings:it was that you could get from a bank.
John Perrings:And so we're starting to see some shift there where that might be happening again.
John Montoya:Yeah.
John Montoya:And I think just to keep.
John Montoya:Things simple.
John Montoya:And especially for the people who are learning about IBC for the first time.
John Montoya:And they may be wondering, interest rates because they are increasing.
John Montoya:Does IBC still make sense?
John Montoya:And one of the things I could hear Nelson still sane if he were around today,
John Montoya:is that interest rates are relative.
John Montoya:When rates are high for borrowing, they're also gonna be higher for saving.
John Montoya:So the fact that interest rates have increas.
John Montoya:On policy loan rates.
John Montoya:It's not across the board a bad thing, because what's gonna happen
John Montoya:is that the interest rates for saving is also going to increase.
John Montoya:Now, I know most people don't have or haven't seen what the policy rates, the
John Montoya:dividend rates were, in the eighties.
John Montoya:In particular, that was a really high interest rate environment.
John Montoya:I remember looking at older policies even early in my career seeing where
John Montoya:the dividend rates were in the eighties.
John Montoya:And it was quite unbelievable to see that they were like 14, 16%.
John Montoya:And that was during a high interest rate environment.
John Montoya:Why?
John Montoya:Interest rates are relative.
John Montoya:When rates are higher for borrowing, they're also higher for saving.
John Montoya:So even though for policy holders right now, they've seen their policy
John Montoya:loan rates jump from five to 5.5% or 5.7% depending on the carrier.
John Montoya:It's relative.
John Montoya:Again, what's gonna happen is that the maturities that the life insurance
John Montoya:companies are investing, those premium dollars in, they're gonna
John Montoya:roll over and they're going to roll over into long-term debt instruments
John Montoya:that are also paying a higher yield.
John Montoya:So what ends up happening over time is that the dividends that you receive as
John Montoya:a policy, That come from the surplus profit, they're going to increase in step.
John Montoya:So remember, interest rates are relative.
John Montoya:When rates are higher for borrowing, they're higher for saving.
John Montoya:So di the dividend scale.
John Montoya:Will start to increase in the future, you're gonna, you're gonna start to see
John Montoya:that if you have your whole life policy.
John Montoya:So it's not a bad thing.
John Montoya:It doesn't mean that IBC doesn't work, because at the end of
John Montoya:the day, what is IBC about?
John Montoya:It's about controlling your banking function.
John Montoya:And where is the best place where you can control that function?
John Montoya:John and I were talking a pre-show about, VULs and we've talked about
John Montoya:using line of credits as a potential place where you can practice IBC.
John Montoya:We, we've talked about that in previous episodes.
John Montoya:It's not that you can only do IBC for whole life policies and that's
John Montoya:what whole life is meant for.
John Montoya:Not at all.
John Montoya:You can actually practice the banking function with other financial products,
John Montoya:but the real question to ask is what makes whole life superior to practice IBC?
John Montoya:And what makes it superior is the fact that you have this fixed.
John Montoya:Component of mortality costs the level premium guaranteed for life.
John Montoya:You have the transfer of risk that is transferred from you
John Montoya:to the insurance company.
John Montoya:These mutual based companies that are guaranteed that every single year a cash
John Montoya:value is going to increase in value.
John Montoya:So you never have to worry about a margin call or you never have to worry
John Montoya:about your underlying asset going down in value or going backwards.
John Montoya:The, these are the reasons why we recommend only whole life for
John Montoya:IBC, if you're gonna practice IBC, it's gotta be a whole life policy.
John Montoya:So interest rates going up.
John Montoya:Okay.
John Montoya:It doesn't change anything because to your point, John shopping for
John Montoya:the money, we all have to do that.
John Montoya:And if you give yourself more options when you go to shop for the money, you're
John Montoya:gonna be better off as a consumer than the person who only has one option.
John Montoya:And that's the cons, the traditional bank who gets to set the terms, the
John Montoya:payment terms, and they're going to, say the interest rate is this.
John Montoya:You gotta live with those terms, come hell or high water.
John Montoya:And here's a secondary option that you can have fully under your control,
John Montoya:cuz you are the policy owner, right?
John Montoya:The insurance company is gonna put you first above everybody else.
John Montoya:So if you need access to a loan, you got guaranteed access.
John Montoya:If you need to change your payment structure to repay a loan, instead
John Montoya:of, three years, you gotta stretch it to a fourth year or a fifth year.
John Montoya:It's completely.
John Montoya:Up to you own, you, you own this policy.
John Montoya:You control your cash flow and interest rates.
John Montoya:Again, they're just relative.
John Perrings:So true.
John Perrings:And, just getting back to the control.
John Perrings:And IBC is about, again, controlling the banking function.
John Perrings:But what does that mean?
John Perrings:That means.
John Perrings:You're giving yourself options to take advantage of opportunities that come
John Perrings:your way rather than react to them.
John Perrings:So one of the big problems with typical financial planning is everyone's
John Perrings:locked into a certain trajectory.
John Perrings:They have very few options.
John Perrings:Once the market starts doing whatever the market's gonna
John Perrings:do they're in reaction mode.
John Perrings:And I'm not, again we're not bashing, having some money in
John Perrings:the market or anything like that, if that's what you wanna do.
John Perrings:But what we're doing is we're creating options for ourselves to
John Perrings:do whatever is best for us at the time based on what's happening.
John Perrings:And the idea that.
John Perrings:Well, John said something else and it and it's not about the rate, just
John Perrings:like whole life insurance is not about the rate of return, right?
John Perrings:It's about controlling the banking function and giving yourself the
John Perrings:ability to do all the things that the banks are gonna do for you.
John Perrings:But under your terms, We have a reminder in here that taking policy
John Perrings:loans, you know, does not, it's not the policy loan itself that helps
John Perrings:your policy grow faster, right?
John Perrings:It's the, it's paying a premium , so I was thinking of this longer way to explain it.
John Perrings:Paying a premium is what makes your policy.
John Perrings:It's not taking loans.
John Perrings:And if we start to think that way and we start to go back to a savings
John Perrings:mindset, these low interest rates were great for people borrowing money,
John Perrings:but they're horrible for savers.
John Perrings:All the savers out there have been getting crushed over the last decade
John Perrings:with these insanely low interest rates.
John Perrings:And so we're steering things back to.
John Perrings:So I'm actually happy interest rates are going up because for most people
John Perrings:this is going to be a huge boon to most people who are who need to save.
John Perrings:That's the number one thing.
John Perrings:Your another way to think of this is your income, your ability to earn
John Perrings:an income is your greatest asset.
John Perrings:And if you can save more of that and you're incentivized to do.
John Perrings:I think it's a great thing because as John said, interest rates are relative.
John Perrings:So whatever the interest rates are out there to borrow money,
John Perrings:we know we're going to be more efficient savers at the same time.
John Perrings:And the more we save, the more opportunity.
John Perrings:It can come our way because what does it say in the book?
John Perrings:He who has the golden rule, he who has the gold, makes the rules.
John Perrings:So if we can be more efficient savers using whole life insurance, which is a,
John Perrings:just a strategic place to store cash.
John Perrings:How much more effective can we be out there regardless of what the
John Perrings:going rate of interest on a loan is?
John Perrings:Yeah.
John Montoya:Said.
John Montoya:And I like that we did put that reminder in our notes to discuss
John Montoya:about taking loans does not magically help your policies grow faster.
John Montoya:I it's definitely a misconception for a lot of new people coming into IBC.
John Montoya:Just gotta remember, or at least try to understand that you have to separate the
John Montoya:premium paying process from the loans that you take and repaying those loans.
John Montoya:You have to have cash flow for both, right?
John Montoya:And one of my rules of thumb when taking a policy loan is if I can't pay
John Montoya:it back, I shouldn't take the loan.
John Montoya:And this works in real life too, because, if you go to the bank asking for a.
John Montoya:And you can't pay it back.
John Montoya:They're gonna ask you to document your income, your assets, your f ICO scores.
John Montoya:Why?
John Montoya:Because it's probably a Uncollateralized loan.
John Montoya:And so they, they have they need all these verification to, to determine
John Montoya:whether you're, a high quality borrower.
John Montoya:Because the higher the higher credit scores you have the lower risk you
John Montoya:are of defaulting on that loan.
John Montoya:When you take a loan from your policy there, there's none of that verification.
John Montoya:They, the insurance company's not gonna ask you for your income, your assets.
John Montoya:They already did all that.
John Montoya:Through the application.
John Montoya:There's no f ICO score that they're gonna check.
John Montoya:The reason being, your cash value is the collateral for the loan.
John Montoya:And should you happen to pass with the loan outstanding, guess what?
John Montoya:The death benefit is going to pay off that loan.
John Montoya:And the difference is, Transfer to your beneficiaries tax free.
John Montoya:So it's completely self completing, but you just have to keep in mind,
John Montoya:that loan that you take from the policy you need to be honest with yourself.
John Montoya:You need to be an honest banker.
John Montoya:One of the other tenants that we, we hit on a lot in this
John Montoya:podcast is, Nelson would always.
John Montoya:Encourage, not even encourage, you would demand it of you.
John Montoya:It's one of the four things, when it comes to IBC and I was actually thinking about
John Montoya:this earlier this week, testing myself.
John Montoya:What are the four requirements for IBC?
John Montoya:One, think long term.
John Montoya:Two, don't be afraid to capitalize.
John Montoya:Three, being an honest banker.
John Montoya:All right.
John Montoya:My point here, and then four.
John Montoya:Start eliminating traditional banks from your life.
John Montoya:You can do that when you get started with IBC because it
John Montoya:gives you that secondary option.
John Montoya:Now you can shop for the money and if you take a policy loan, be an honest banker.
John Montoya:It was a good exercise this week to quiz myself.
John Montoya:What are the four things again about IBC?
John Montoya:What are the four requirements?
John Montoya:Oh, yeah, there you go.
John Perrings:Yeah.
John Perrings:It's such sage advice and, to, to your point.
John Perrings:Making sure you can pay the loan back.
John Perrings:A lot of people jump into IBC and unfortunately, all these TikTok videos
John Perrings:and everything of people, misapplying the whole IBC principle and just
John Perrings:talking about getting rich on whole life insurance and all this stuff.
John Perrings:It's really unfortunate because, I'll talk to people, especially
John Perrings:younger people who are, more on that.
John Perrings:It gets sucked into that idea.
John Perrings:And they're like, how soon can I take a loan?
John Perrings:And because they're missing the whole point of the fact that it's not the
John Perrings:loan that is making this powerful, it's a feature that we can use to
John Perrings:make what we're doing more efficient.
John Perrings:But it.
John Perrings:It's not about borrowing instantly, like there, it's a real loan
John Perrings:You know what I mean?
John Perrings:It, it's not free money out there.
John Perrings:And so what, when you said make sure you can pay the loan back, I
John Perrings:was it triggered in my head like, we're what we're doing with Infinite
John Perrings:Banking, what's the book called?
John Perrings:It's "Becoming Your Own Banker."
John Perrings:And so if you're going to become your own banker, you need to be an honest
John Perrings:banker like you were just saying.
John Perrings:And so if you are going to be the banker for your own financial life, that
John Perrings:means you have to underwrite yourself.
John Perrings:And so I was thinking of the underwriting process and, going to a
John Perrings:bank and qualifying for a bank loan.
John Perrings:, we should qualify ourselves for our own, for the use of our own capital as well.
John Perrings:We shouldn't just go out there and just, pull money out willy-nilly or bar
John Perrings:or borrow against willy-nilly based on just whatever the whim is at the time.
John Perrings:We should underwrite ourselves and make sure that what we're doing, the,
John Perrings:there's cash flow to pay that loan back.
John Perrings:Agreed.
John Montoya:And.
John Montoya:Just thought of something.
John Montoya:I had an email come in from an existing client who asked me how much cash value
John Montoya:he had, like available loan amount.
John Montoya:And so I checked for him and let him know and let him know what the
John Montoya:process is, just as a reminder, how to go ahead and request a loan.
John Montoya:And I sent him that email and then I followed up with another email 10
John Montoya:minutes later because it dawned on me, you know what I I told him how much he.
John Montoya:Take out of his policy, but I didn't share one of my personal golden
John Montoya:rules, which is, don't borrow more than 50% of your total cash value.
John Montoya:And so I sent him that email real quick and said, my personal
John Montoya:rule of thumb is, this 50% rule.
John Montoya:And he replied back and said, why is that?
John Montoya:And I said, In this email, "because life happens."
John Montoya:And I gave him a brief rundown on the situation with my wife and how
John Montoya:having the access to additional cash values, cuz we didn't, take out 99%
John Montoya:of our cash values to go, All in on an investment or whatever the case may be.
John Montoya:We always keep ample reserves.
John Montoya:Just because you have the available cash value there doesn't mean you
John Montoya:should necessarily use all of it.
John Montoya:Because life throws us curve balls and if we're not prepared, Man, that's
John Montoya:when life will just spit you out.
John Montoya:And so just a reminder for everyone.
John Montoya:Just because you have the cash value doesn't mean that
John Montoya:you should utilize all of it.
John Montoya:If you absolutely.
John Montoya:Have to.
John Montoya:And it's a life event, of course.
John Montoya:But I, if you're jeopardizing tomorrow for what you feel is
John Montoya:a, is a great investment today.
John Montoya:I would caution you to really think long and hard about risking really everything.
John Montoya:And, you shouldn't have all your eggs in one basket anyway.
John Montoya:And for maybe some people with IBC their life savings, Make up
John Montoya:a good amount of, cash values.
John Montoya:Still balance it out with everything that you have in your portfolio and
John Montoya:just always put yourself in a position where you have access to cash is my main
John Perrings:point.
John Perrings:That's awesome.
John Perrings:And I was actually just working on a LinkedIn post because, so much
John Perrings:of the prevailing mindset around finances is around rate of return.
John Perrings:And it is a useful metric, of course, rate of return, but
John Perrings:it's vulgar in a way where the.
John Perrings:Everyone.
John Perrings:That's the only thing people think about.
John Perrings:So when they're looking at life insurance, they're evaluating the rate of return.
John Perrings:And so I was thinking like, what's the, how did you calculate, how did
John Perrings:you calculate in the divorce you're going through, in your rate of return
John Perrings:of whatever you're doing, however you're calculating, how did you
John Perrings:calculate in a six spouse or how did you calculate in, getting in a car
John Perrings:accident and not being able to work, for several months or maybe ever.
John Perrings:And so this.
John Perrings:This narrow focus on rate of return really misses a lot of what happens in life.
John Perrings:And to your point, life happens.
John Perrings:And how are you gonna be able to take advantage of opportunities
John Perrings:or areas where you need some help?
John Perrings:How can you be in the best position possible?
John Perrings:And guess what?
John Perrings:Cash helps a lot with that from a financial perspective, right?
John Perrings:The.
John Perrings:I it's a, we're getting a little bit off topic here, but it's with everything
John Perrings:going on with the economic downturn, with layoffs, everyone once again is
John Perrings:being reminded somehow they forgot since 2008 and or two, and 2000, you and I,
John Perrings:John, lived through both of those times.
John Perrings:Somehow people forgot over the last 10 years that the market doesn't always go.
John Perrings:May not be the world's id world's worst idea to have a bunch of cash
John Perrings:sitting around so you can get by if some, if something happens to your job.
John Perrings:And you know it, and it's unfortunate that.
John Perrings:That people, I've had so many conversations with people over the
John Perrings:years, over the last five years especially, where there's just been this
John Perrings:disdain for holding onto cash because you're not earning any money on it.
John Perrings:And meanwhile, co 2020 happens, covid happens, layoffs are happening.
John Perrings:And now I think people are maybe remembering why.
John Perrings:That's a good idea to hold onto some cash.
John Perrings:And another way to talk about what John's talking about.
John Perrings:So he has that golden rule of never borrowing more than half.
John Perrings:I love that golden rule.
John Perrings:And another way I'll describe it or another option is, as long as you have
John Perrings:an emergency fund, and if I could wave a magic wand, everyone have at least
John Perrings:a year's worth of income in cash, and where's the best place to soar
John Perrings:that, of course, whole life insurance.
John Perrings:If you have a year's, if you have a good emergency fund, then everything
John Perrings:over that becomes your opportunity fund.
John Perrings:And so just two ways of saying the same thing as what John's saying, Yep.
John Montoya:Totally agree.
John Montoya:We're getting into more than what we planned in this episode, so
John Montoya:probably a at a good point, unless you've got anything else you want
John Montoya:to add, maybe we can close it out
John Perrings:here.
John Perrings:No, it's good.
John Perrings:Yeah, let's close it out.
John Perrings:And just to recap with interest rates going up, what's actually happening, so
John Perrings:yeah, loan rates are increasing, but what we're gonna see is dividends will start.
John Perrings:Dividends typically trail the going interest rates.
John Perrings:So we're gonna start seeing dividends increase as well.
John Perrings:So loan rates are higher, but saving RA savings rates are also higher.
John Perrings:So what we're saying is interest rates are relative.
John Perrings:And so don't be concerned about the going rate.
John Perrings:The rates are gonna be what they're gonna be out there in the world.
John Perrings:And we're still in a good position to take advantage of things by implementing
John Perrings:the Infinite Banking Concept.
John Perrings:If you like what you're hearing and you want to wanna get more
John Perrings:information, you can head over to www.TheFifthEdition.com and right there
John Perrings:you can schedule a free 30-minute.
John Perrings:Appointment with John or myself, and you can find out how this could apply
John Perrings:in your life, or if you're one of those people that likes to just do all the
John Perrings:online research first before talking to anyone, we have a 50% discount on
John Perrings:our online course, and you can get that right at www.Thefifthedition.com.
John Perrings:Good topic today, John.
John Perrings:Thanks.
John Montoya:Yeah, it was fun.
John Montoya:It feels like it's been a while since we've sat down and talked and
John Montoya:recorded an episode with the holidays.
John Montoya:So good to get back on it.
John Montoya:And for everyone out there, thank you so much for listening.
John Montoya:It really does mean a lot to us.
John Montoya:And if I could encourage you to leave us a rating or review
John Montoya:if you're getting value from.
John Montoya:Our show.
John Montoya:Please please do leave us a rating and review because that's
John Montoya:what helps us to share this information with a wider audience.
John Montoya:So thank you in advance and look forward to connecting
John Montoya:you on the next episode, john.