Artwork for podcast Changing Academic Life
On Identity, Meaning, and Joyful Effort (CAL143, S8E8)
Values, strengths, knowing yourself Episode 86th May 2026 • Changing Academic Life • Geraldine Fitzpatrick
00:00:00 00:34:38

Share Episode

Shownotes

Connecting to Christian van Nieuwerburgh’s idea of “joyful effort” and discussions at the University of Graz Research Culture Campus Fest about supportive, inclusive research cultures and prioritizing meaningful work over productivity, this episode revisits an episode from January 2025 on research identity, meaningful work, and funding. I explore the tensions between our autonomy to pursue intrinsically motivating, value-driven research and systemic constraints such as funding calls, promotion criteria, shifting national priorities, and restrictive deliverables that can conflict with participatory principles. Using examples from Katta Spiel on focusing on what you want to do not what is strategic, Mark Reed’s impact principle about purpose, and Stuart Reeves on low-cost research styles, I talk about our choices to play or not play the funding “game,” including reframing proposals, and the risks of taking on less-meaningful projects. I close with reflective questions (summarized in nine steps by Rachel Ratz-Lubashevsky) to identify what “lights you up” and guide decisions.

00:34 Motivating the Relevance of Revisiting this Episode

04:56 Rachel's Summary of the 9 Simple Steps to What Lights You Up

08:28 Introduction and Reflection on Academic Freedom

09:56 Replay from Katta Spiel Part 1

10:40 Mark Reed's principle for engagement and impact

13:23 The Tension Between Personal Values, Identity and Systemic Expectations

15:07 The Reality of Funding Proposals and Strategic Game

16:40 The Impact of Funding Conditions on Research

18:27 The Dilemma of Playing the Funding Game

21:07 Choices for How to Play the Game

27:52 Choosing Not to Play the Game

29:42 Reframing Research Identity and Conclusion

Related Links:

Uni Graz Research Culture Campus Fest report and LinkedIn post about it

Rachel Ratz-Lubashevsky’s LinkedIn post summarising the 9 steps

CAL Podcast episodes I mention:

Christian van Nieuwerburgh, Johanna Stadlbauer, Katta Spiel part 1, Mark Reed and Stuart Reeves part 1

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
8. On Identity, Meaning, and Joyful Effort (CAL143, S8E8)
00:34:38
7. Christian van Nieuwerburgh on Bringing Back the Joy (CAL142, S8E7)
01:00:39
5. Bethany Wilinski (Part 1) on sabbatical, burnout and choosing rest (CAL140, S8E5)
00:53:53
3. Jen Heemstra on Accidental Leadership (CAL 138, S8E3)
00:59:44
8. LP Replay - Reflect, Celebrate, Dream (CAL135, S7E8)
00:21:17
6. Susan Dray (Part 2) on listening, mentoring, and adversity (CAL133, S7E6)
00:38:27
21. Season Reflections: Cultivating a Good Academic Life (CAL127, S6, E21)
00:18:29
19. Johanna Stadlbauer on boundaries, agency, and community building (CAL125, S6 E19)
00:56:53
18. Tina Persson on career pivots, recruitment and coaching for career security (CAL124, S6 E18)
01:07:41
17. Strengths as Superpowers - Replay (CAL123, S6 E17)
00:22:52
17. Graham McAllister (Part 2) on aligning team vision (CAL121, S6E15)
00:40:30
17. Graham McAllister (Part 1) on career pivots: academia to industry to startup (CAL120, S6E14)
00:56:14
16. Graham McAllister (Part 3) on the art and craft of writing (CAL122, S6E16)
00:31:35
11. Sharing my story with Nutan Limaye (CAL117, S6E11)
01:15:00
10. Vikki Wright on career transitions, ADHD, and learning to manage yourself (CAL116, S6E10)
01:12:24
8. Evan Peck on considered choices and career moves: from liberals arts to a research uni (CAL114, S6E8)
01:03:05
7. Özge Subașı on values, choices and care (CAL113, S6E7)
01:04:36
2. Liam Bannon (Part 2) on values & what matters
00:46:15
22. Remembering Volkmar Pipek - on being curious, being you
00:16:08
20. Jean Paul (Part 2) on leading virtual transdisciplinary teams and stakeholder engagement
00:41:57
16. On research identity, meaningful work and funding (solo)
00:26:55
6. Kirsten Ellis on shifting goalposts, motivation, flying & being a working mum with a disabled child
01:01:46
18. Alex Taylor on research at the boundaries, moving from industry to academia, the labour of academia & the power of the collective
01:13:18
22. trailer Scott Robertson on missing tenure, persevering, and connecting to mission & community
01:00:39
15. Kia Höök on challenges of success & value of slowing down and re-connecting
01:12:28
16. RW7 Job Crafting - small tweaks can make a big difference
00:21:58
5. Julie Kientz on leadership, impact, & being comfortable with being uncomfortable (Part 2)
00:44:55
20. Reflections on 2019 & 2018
00:16:32
35. Lindsay Oades on academic wellbeing, connecting to strengths, meaning and purpose, and not taking the system too seriously
01:14:43
3. Carman Neustaedter on research identity, work tracking surprises, and taking perspective
00:59:54
10. Mark Reed on mental health, love and impact
00:52:56
25. Michael Muller on principled engagements, value tensions, liking people & giving back
01:01:03
23. Evan Peck on making choices, accepting trade-offs, and liberal arts as a great middle way
00:47:25
20. Amy Ko on being reflectively self-aware, deliberately structured, & amazingly productive
00:51:50
17. Ali Black on doing academia differently...caring, connecting & becoming
01:00:32
8. Jan Gulliksen on middle management, leading autists, and building values and trust… with drama
01:14:15
10. Mike Twidale on agile research, leading from strengths, and story-telling
01:05:12
13. Jofish Kaye on industry research, having an impact, and values-driven decision making
01:07:39
11. Austen Rainer on changing cultures, leading people and values
00:58:09
13. Aaron Quigley on silent warriors, secret powers, and making the world better
00:58:21
15. RW6 Exploring your own superpowers
00:15:25