Geri Fitz:
00:00:05
Welcome to Changing Academic Life.
2
:
00:00:08
I'm Geraldine Fitzpatrick, and this is
a podcast series where academics and
3
:
00:00:12
others share their stories, provide
ideas, and provoke discussions about what
4
:
00:00:18
we can do individually and collectively
to change academic life for the better.
5
:
00:00:29
welcome to part two of a
discussion with Susan Dray and
6
:
00:00:35
it's a really special discussion.
7
:
00:00:40
. She continues to reflect on a lot
of her professional and personal
8
:
00:00:43
experiences, but it gets much more
personal and real, and she talks about
9
:
00:00:49
things around, value of empathy in
listening and listening with heart.
10
:
00:00:54
And she talks a lot about mentoring
and her approaches to that, and also
11
:
00:00:59
talks a lot about service and community.
12
:
00:01:05
But just mentioning those labels
doesn't do justice to the ways
13
:
00:01:11
in which Susan talked about it.
14
:
00:01:15
And I also include some of our
unofficial discussion at the end,
15
:
00:01:19
which I share with her permission.
16
:
00:01:22
Because she continues to talk about some
of the losses that she's experienced and
17
:
00:01:27
some of the health challenges and life
challenges that she's had to navigate.
18
:
00:01:31
And again, just the quality
of the person comes through.
19
:
00:01:35
And as Susan says
20
:
00:01:40
Susan: I think everybody
needs support, quite frankly.
21
:
00:01:43
Yes.
22
:
00:01:43
I think very, very few people
understand and realize how
23
:
00:01:47
special they are, you know?
24
:
00:01:50
And what matters is who you are.
25
:
00:01:54
Because who you are is going to mean
that what you do is important and
26
:
00:01:59
makes a difference, and has an impact.
27
:
00:02:03
Geri Fitz: And Susan has
definitely had an impact.
28
:
00:02:08
So we'll start here a little bit back
from where we left off in part one,
29
:
00:02:13
and I really hope you enjoy this very
special part two with Susan Dray.
30
:
00:02:18
You're very self-reflective in the
whole practice, in the way you've talked
31
:
00:02:22
about being aware of the potential
blinders and also, again, that curiosity
32
:
00:02:29
that enables you to be surprised.
33
:
00:02:32
Yeah.
34
:
00:02:32
Because what you said, you don't
know, you've got the blinders
35
:
00:02:35
. And then you hit them and
36
:
00:02:36
Yeah.
37
:
00:02:37
Susan: When you hit them, it can feel
like you're a failure in that moment.
38
:
00:02:42
And if you let that take over
your mindset at that point
39
:
00:02:48
then you miss the surprises.
40
:
00:02:51
And I've now learned that every
time I do a study, regardless of
41
:
00:02:56
where the first couple of people,
I'm gonna feel really stupid.
42
:
00:03:02
Geri Fitz: And that's okay.
43
:
00:03:03
Susan: And that's okay.
44
:
00:03:04
You know, learning to sit with
discomfort, I think is a really big deal.
45
:
00:03:11
And then when you're uncomfortable
listening deeply with your heart,
46
:
00:03:20
you know, really, really focusing
on understanding as much as you can.
47
:
00:03:25
Which is , they compete with each other.
48
:
00:03:28
You know, that's a struggle.
49
:
00:03:29
That's always a struggle.
50
:
00:03:31
Geri Fitz: Can you say more about that?
51
:
00:03:35
Susan: Well,
52
:
00:03:37
so in the beginning of, of
53
:
00:03:42
the township study, for instance,
we were trying to understand what
54
:
00:03:46
they did with money in general.
55
:
00:03:49
And.
56
:
00:03:51
I have a client with me.
57
:
00:03:52
I'm trying to create an experience
that's a good experience for her.
58
:
00:03:56
We are also working with a local vendor.
59
:
00:03:58
Of course, we never, ever
would do that on our own.
60
:
00:04:02
We worked with the local vendor.
61
:
00:04:03
They consulted on the screener
and they did the recruitment,
62
:
00:04:08
and then they went with us.
63
:
00:04:10
Mm.
64
:
00:04:10
And had a facilitator, and two
translators so that they could switch
65
:
00:04:14
off because we tried to, as much
as possible, use local language.
66
:
00:04:19
Not always possible,
but as much as possible.
67
:
00:04:23
And it was so hard in the beginning
to just relax enough and allow myself
68
:
00:04:33
to feel the discomfort and not just
react by going, ah, you know, just.
69
:
00:04:41
Use it as information.
70
:
00:04:42
Oh, this is, this is
important information here.
71
:
00:04:45
Yeah.
72
:
00:04:45
You're learning stuff that you
wouldn't be learning otherwise.
73
:
00:04:48
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
74
:
00:04:49
Susan: Um, and that's
why you're uncomfortable.
75
:
00:04:51
Yeah.
76
:
00:04:52
It's that discrepancy.
77
:
00:04:53
Geri Fitz: How would you talk to
someone about listening with your heart?
78
:
00:04:56
Because that sounds so key for lots
of things, not just doing field work.
79
:
00:05:01
Susan: Mm.
80
:
00:05:01
Mm-hmm.
81
:
00:05:04
I think that's kind of me.
82
:
00:05:09
Mm.
83
:
00:05:09
You know, that, that's kind of who I am.
84
:
00:05:13
So listening with the heart
means to me being empathetic.
85
:
00:05:22
, but also,
86
:
00:05:27
how do I say it?
87
:
00:05:28
I guess it's kind of listening with love.
88
:
00:05:30
A kind of honoring what the
person is saying and what they're
89
:
00:05:36
showing you in their behavior,
even when they don't match.
90
:
00:05:40
But seeing that as valuable and
then reinforcing that value.
91
:
00:05:47
And certainly when I mentor folks a
lot of what I do is it's really simple.
92
:
00:05:55
Yeah.
93
:
00:05:55
Because I think most people
have, they know what the solution
94
:
00:05:59
is, they just can't unpack it.
95
:
00:06:01
Yeah.
96
:
00:06:01
So it's just sitting and saying,
huh, that's an interesting question.
97
:
00:06:06
And then ask a follow up that then
they go into and they go, Hmm.
98
:
00:06:12
Really interesting.
99
:
00:06:13
Just kind of reinforcing that
the person is valuable, that you
100
:
00:06:18
honor them, that you respect them.
101
:
00:06:20
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
102
:
00:06:21
Susan: That you care for them.
103
:
00:06:22
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
104
:
00:06:23
And that's such a valuable gift that you
give to all of us who've had the honor
105
:
00:06:30
of interacting with you over the years.
106
:
00:06:32
Because I was actually going to go to
the mentoring because I think that,
107
:
00:06:36
when you talked about listening with
your heart, I was thinking about,
108
:
00:06:41
that's what I see you doing all the
time in any of your interactions.
109
:
00:06:45
And I'm actually just
110
:
00:06:47
Susan: You've got your hearts!
111
:
00:06:49
Geri Fitz: I'm holding up here an
orange and a purple heart stone
112
:
00:06:52
that I was gifted by Susan the last
time I saw her a few months ago.
113
:
00:06:59
And just the generosity of these little
gestures that you have as well, that
114
:
00:07:05
are ways of connecting with people.
115
:
00:07:08
And you can't put a value on that
presence in a peer community,
116
:
00:07:13
in a professional community.
117
:
00:07:14
And yeah.
118
:
00:07:16
What that gives to people.
119
:
00:07:18
Susan: Well, and there certainly are
people who dismiss it and say, you
120
:
00:07:22
don't have anything technical to offer.
121
:
00:07:24
For instance, and it's been a long
time since I've been in the field,
122
:
00:07:27
I don't have technical insights.
123
:
00:07:30
But I know how to provide support,
you know, this undergirding.
124
:
00:07:39
Yeah.
125
:
00:07:39
And also I am a cockeyed optimist.
126
:
00:07:42
I get this from my father.
127
:
00:07:46
And so I tend to see positive,
you know, positives for people.
128
:
00:07:54
And sometimes that's the most
important thing is it's gonna be okay.
129
:
00:07:58
It is going to be okay.
130
:
00:08:00
And if it's not okay, it's not done yet.
131
:
00:08:02
Geri Fitz: Hmm.
132
:
00:08:03
Susan: You know, and yeah, that's
simplistic and, but sometime, you
133
:
00:08:08
know, if somebody's deeply negative
about something, hearing a positive
134
:
00:08:12
can be for them uncomfortable and
can lead them to question their
135
:
00:08:16
cynicism, say, or whatever it is.
136
:
00:08:20
Doesn't always work,
but sometimes it does.
137
:
00:08:23
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
138
:
00:08:23
And, and so that presence in listening
with your heart is also in a way holding
139
:
00:08:27
up a mirror for people, which can be to
reflect, reflect on exactly where they're
140
:
00:08:32
coming from, as well as reflecting on
the fact that they do have the answers.
141
:
00:08:37
Susan: Exactly.
142
:
00:08:39
Exactly.
143
:
00:08:39
And it's like peeling the onion.
144
:
00:08:43
So sometimes what people need is that
kind of listening, deep listening.
145
:
00:08:49
But other times they need an opportunity.
146
:
00:08:51
So for instance, Gary Marsden
and I were very dear friends.
147
:
00:08:56
Gary was a professor at the University
of Cape Town, and he was one of
148
:
00:09:01
the key people in the early days
of HCI in Africa, South Africa.
149
:
00:09:05
But yes, Africa, I don't believe
there were HCI communities,
150
:
00:09:09
anyplace else in those days.
151
:
00:09:11
And in 2001 they had a conference.
152
:
00:09:15
Happened to be, my keynote was on 9.11,
153
:
00:09:19
the original 9.11,
154
:
00:09:21
which was an interesting
situation to be in.
155
:
00:09:24
But luckily I'd already given my
keynote when all that went down.
156
:
00:09:29
But it was.
157
:
00:09:33
Important to listen to what they
needed and what they needed.
158
:
00:09:38
First of all, there was a
deep sense of inferiority.
159
:
00:09:42
You know, Africa's inferior,
well, that's a pretty shitty
160
:
00:09:46
thing that colonialism has done.
161
:
00:09:51
Let's get rid of that.
162
:
00:09:52
So there was partly, there was no,
no, this is really interesting.
163
:
00:09:56
You know, and people that most
people have never heard of, like
164
:
00:10:00
Edwin Blake who did this amazing
work providing, game trackers, sand
165
:
00:10:09
bushman trackers in national parks.
166
:
00:10:12
They can read a leaf that's been stepped
on by an elephant half an hour ago.
167
:
00:10:23
They didn't have the language to
express this, but he developed this
168
:
00:10:28
tracker that they could then keep
track of what their observations were
169
:
00:10:32
and it raised their standing, but
also he found that they were gonna do
170
:
00:10:40
it the old western hierarchical way.
171
:
00:10:42
Right.
172
:
00:10:43
Geri Fitz: Hmm.
173
:
00:10:44
Susan: Does not work, or didn't
at that time work at all.
174
:
00:10:47
I mean, even if you ask people to show
their family tree, they would, instead
175
:
00:10:53
of like, grandparents, parents, children,
they would do parents, aunt, child,
176
:
00:11:04
uncle, grandfather, father, you know.
177
:
00:11:08
They did not have the concept
of a hierarchy, so hierarchical
178
:
00:11:13
wasn't gonna work for them.
179
:
00:11:14
And they didn't have language.
180
:
00:11:15
A written language at that time.
181
:
00:11:17
I don't know if they do now.
182
:
00:11:19
So it was all done icon graphically
with pictures of the different animals
183
:
00:11:24
that had to be accurate enough that they
could distinguish between a Springbok
184
:
00:11:28
and a, whatever else, Bok it might be.
185
:
00:11:34
Well, who knows about that work
in this, in the global north?
186
:
00:11:38
Geri Fitz: Mm.
187
:
00:11:39
Susan: Not very many people.
188
:
00:11:42
So what they needed was first of
all to be reinforced that they were
189
:
00:11:47
doing important things and they
needed a voice to the global North.
190
:
00:11:52
They needed somebody to be
saying, this work is important.
191
:
00:11:57
This work matters.
192
:
00:11:58
This is excellent work.
193
:
00:12:00
And that was me.
194
:
00:12:02
So I became the voice for Africa.
195
:
00:12:04
And Gary used to say that HCI in Africa,
they never would've been able to get the
196
:
00:12:10
kind of recognition that they have since
still not enough, but they are starting to
197
:
00:12:15
get without having that kind of conduit.
198
:
00:12:20
And that was me.
199
:
00:12:21
Geri Fitz: Mm-hmm.
200
:
00:12:21
I mean, and that's the
interstices again, isn't it?
201
:
00:12:24
Susan: Exactly.
202
:
00:12:25
Geri Fitz: In a different way.
203
:
00:12:27
Susan: Yeah.
204
:
00:12:27
It's, yeah.
205
:
00:12:28
And so sometimes what people need is
exposure or you know, so another one
206
:
00:12:35
of my mentees who was doing a PhD
on a Fulbright coming from Africa.
207
:
00:12:41
And she was doing a PhD at Iowa State.
208
:
00:12:44
And she needed a postdoc.
209
:
00:12:46
And so we were talking, I
was actually down in Panama
210
:
00:12:49
on a Fulbright at that time.
211
:
00:12:50
So we were talking and it became
clear that she was interested in
212
:
00:12:54
gender studies and I said, you
should talk to Margaret Burnett.
213
:
00:13:00
And so I hooked them up.
214
:
00:13:01
Well, she ended up doing
a, a postdoc with Margaret.
215
:
00:13:05
Geri Fitz: Oh, lovely.
216
:
00:13:05
Susan: And yeah, so it is like,
sometimes it's just that little, yeah.
217
:
00:13:09
You should talk to this, you
should talk to this person.
218
:
00:13:12
Yeah.
219
:
00:13:12
You know, that kind of thing.
220
:
00:13:14
And I think we
221
:
00:13:15
Geri Fitz: That's a lovely, extension
of your rich people skillset, that
222
:
00:13:20
networking and connecting Well, I think.
223
:
00:13:22
As well as advocating.
224
:
00:13:24
Susan: Absolutely.
225
:
00:13:25
We need more of that.
226
:
00:13:27
Geri Fitz: Mm.
227
:
00:13:28
Susan: Especially nowadays, early
career scientists and people in business
228
:
00:13:34
as well are getting totally slammed.
229
:
00:13:36
And we need to find ways to support them.
230
:
00:13:39
And that's going to require
the old proverbial village.
231
:
00:13:42
Right?
232
:
00:13:44
It takes a village to raise an early
career researcher, so to speak.
233
:
00:13:48
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
234
:
00:13:48
Any particular ideas for what we can
do right now around those challenges?
235
:
00:13:55
Susan: Well, one thing
we can do is listen.
236
:
00:13:58
Listen to their situation
and make connections.
237
:
00:14:03
And I was so excited at CHI because I
saw that this was our recent conference.
238
:
00:14:10
Our recent, yeah.
239
:
00:14:11
CHI Conference in Japan.
240
:
00:14:13
And.
241
:
00:14:14
What I saw there was this sense
that a, we have to pull together
242
:
00:14:19
to support early career people
and a real recognition of that.
243
:
00:14:23
And we're not going to let it happen
that this field gets blown apart by this.
244
:
00:14:30
And so that may mean that it
migrates to other parts of the world.
245
:
00:14:35
It may mean, and this could be a perfect
opportunity for us to raise awareness of
246
:
00:14:41
Africa because they're doing artificial
intelligence really differently there.
247
:
00:14:45
And you know, the idea that AI now
is training on a Western internet
248
:
00:14:52
Geri Fitz: Yes.
249
:
00:14:52
Susan: And has Western
culture built into it.
250
:
00:14:56
And that doesn't work in Egypt
or Kenya or Nigeria or stuff.
251
:
00:15:02
I mean, it doesn't work.
252
:
00:15:03
So their whole human centered AI
approaches are, I think, they're
253
:
00:15:08
radical, they've, they're spreading.
254
:
00:15:11
But I think that's a very consistent,
I've been hearing that from my African
255
:
00:15:15
colleagues for a good five years.
256
:
00:15:18
More than five years.
257
:
00:15:19
Yeah.
258
:
00:15:19
So I think, you know, they're really
pioneers in that and we keep reinventing
259
:
00:15:24
the wheel and think we invented it.
260
:
00:15:25
Right.
261
:
00:15:26
Nope.
262
:
00:15:26
Geri Fitz: Hmm.
263
:
00:15:28
Yeah.
264
:
00:15:29
Susan: Yeah.
265
:
00:15:30
Geri Fitz: So are you talking
particularly there about early
266
:
00:15:33
career researchers within the
American context or more generally?
267
:
00:15:37
Susan: Well, I think the American context
is particularly dire given the political
268
:
00:15:42
sense situation in the US right now.
269
:
00:15:45
But it has a ripple effect
outside the US obviously.
270
:
00:15:49
And
271
:
00:15:49
I think everybody needs
support, quite frankly.
272
:
00:15:52
Yes.
273
:
00:15:52
I think very, very few people
understand and realize how
274
:
00:15:57
special they are, you know?
275
:
00:16:00
Yeah.
276
:
00:16:00
And.
277
:
00:16:01
And so if you can just be that
mirror to reflect that back to
278
:
00:16:05
them, sometimes that's enough.
279
:
00:16:07
Yeah.
280
:
00:16:07
To help them have the courage to do what
they have to do, whatever that might be.
281
:
00:16:13
Geri Fitz: Mm-hmm.
282
:
00:16:15
Susan: And, and
283
:
00:16:15
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
284
:
00:16:16
That's beautiful Susan.
285
:
00:16:17
And there's so much
about our sector that is.
286
:
00:16:23
Continually trying to reinforce
messages of not being good enough.
287
:
00:16:26
Of being rejected of
288
:
00:16:28
Susan: Exactly, exactly.
289
:
00:16:29
Geri Fitz: The hyper competition that
290
:
00:16:30
Susan: Absolutely.
291
:
00:16:31
You know, oh, I got a CHI paper, that
means I'm part of the 10%, or whatever.
292
:
00:16:36
It's like, I've never had a CHI paper.
293
:
00:16:38
I never submitted a, I've
never submitted a CHI paper.
294
:
00:16:41
I've had case studies, I've had SIGs,
I've had panels, I've done other
295
:
00:16:47
stuff, but I've never had a paper.
296
:
00:16:48
Geri Fitz: Oh, that's wonderful.
297
:
00:16:49
So there, there are ways of
choosing your way of being in
298
:
00:16:53
peer communities isn't there?
299
:
00:16:55
Susan: Absolutely.
300
:
00:16:56
And I wouldn't get anywhere if
I tried to submit a high paper
301
:
00:17:01
because the stuff I write about
would be dismissed as you know.
302
:
00:17:06
That's not important.
303
:
00:17:07
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
304
:
00:17:08
So sounds like choosing what
difference you want to make.
305
:
00:17:12
Susan: Mm-hmm.
306
:
00:17:14
So I think it's, it's Jane Goodall,
I think, who says something like.
307
:
00:17:17
Whatever you do makes a difference.
308
:
00:17:19
You just have to decide what kind
of difference you want to make.
309
:
00:17:22
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
310
:
00:17:22
And standing confidently in that.
311
:
00:17:26
Susan: As confidently as
you can with some support.
312
:
00:17:28
A lot of help from your friends sometimes.
313
:
00:17:30
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
314
:
00:17:31
And recognizing, as you said about
standing in the discomfort of that as
315
:
00:17:35
well sometimes and not being sure and
316
:
00:17:38
Susan: Yeah.
317
:
00:17:39
And you know, I think, I think my
impression of academia, I've only been
318
:
00:17:46
in academic for, true academic for four
months when I was down in Panama teaching
319
:
00:17:51
and helping them develop curricular
around HCI and a systems engineering.
320
:
00:17:56
Now, it was really interesting.
321
:
00:17:58
So I can, I can't speak to being an
academic, I can be like an academic.
322
:
00:18:04
But my impression is that
because of scarcity and perceived
323
:
00:18:09
scarcity, there's huge competition.
324
:
00:18:12
And so there's this sort of
dog eat dog kind of thing.
325
:
00:18:18
And I see that everywhere,
not just in the US.
326
:
00:18:23
It's particularly pronounced
in the US I think.
327
:
00:18:26
And it's crazy.
328
:
00:18:29
We have different skills.
329
:
00:18:30
We're gonna fit in different places.
330
:
00:18:33
Yeah.
331
:
00:18:34
Yeah.
332
:
00:18:34
It's just, it's sad.
333
:
00:18:36
It's like when the pot gets
smaller, the dogs fight harder.
334
:
00:18:41
Yeah.
335
:
00:18:42
And
336
:
00:18:44
it's not that it's, yeah,
total peaches and cream in
337
:
00:18:47
industry either of course, but
338
:
00:18:50
Geri Fitz: No challenges everywhere and
339
:
00:18:53
Susan: Absolutely.
340
:
00:18:54
Geri Fitz: So, should look
at wrapping up, I guess.
341
:
00:18:58
Susan: Yeah, whenever.
342
:
00:18:59
Geri Fitz: Sadly, because
it's a wonderful talking.
343
:
00:19:03
What have we not talked about
that we should before we wrap up?
344
:
00:19:08
Susan: Hmm.
345
:
00:19:12
Well, I, I love mentoring, but it's
such an honor, and I could run down
346
:
00:19:21
some of the people that I've had
this incredibly wonderful, precious,
347
:
00:19:25
very precious relationship with.
348
:
00:19:28
And the whole idea of service too, where,
you know, you get so much out of it.
349
:
00:19:34
Mm-hmm.
350
:
00:19:34
It's hard to imagine
people don't just go, yeah.
351
:
00:19:39
Because you really end up, you
meet people, you have fun, you
352
:
00:19:45
have intellectual challenge.
353
:
00:19:48
You have to figure out logistics.
354
:
00:19:51
All this kind of stuff.
355
:
00:19:53
That's just so fascinating.
356
:
00:19:55
Now in the beginning with CHI.
357
:
00:19:58
So the first CHI was in Boston
in 83, and then the next one
358
:
00:20:04
was in San Francisco in 85.
359
:
00:20:06
And it, that's because the
one in Boston was in like
360
:
00:20:11
December or something like that.
361
:
00:20:12
And the next one started
in the April, May time.
362
:
00:20:15
But I have pictures of, from 85, I was
super involved at 85 and we have literally
363
:
00:20:24
a very big paper on a bulletin board and
blocks, columns for the three different
364
:
00:20:32
rooms or however many there were, and
then where you put them and then you
365
:
00:20:36
have to, you kind of swap 'em around.
366
:
00:20:39
Very physical.
367
:
00:20:40
It was totally physical, totally
different problem than we have now
368
:
00:20:47
with 5,000 people coming and all that.
369
:
00:20:50
But the comraderie that we developed
and the bonds that we developed and
370
:
00:20:56
the ways that we worked with each
other, those are consistent, you know?
371
:
00:21:01
Mm-hmm.
372
:
00:21:01
I think it's bigger job and it, there's
more burnout now, obviously with the
373
:
00:21:07
bigger job and also with the fact that
I think people have a lot of trouble.
374
:
00:21:15
Okay.
375
:
00:21:16
This is controversial.
376
:
00:21:18
Personally, I think you can
get an awful lot done if you
377
:
00:21:21
don't care who gets the credit.
378
:
00:21:24
But it's a mindset of, we have
to fight over the small crumbs
379
:
00:21:29
here, which I think is the, at
large, makes it hard to do that.
380
:
00:21:38
It makes it hard to collaborate.
381
:
00:21:40
Because, you want people to know
that this was your idea, you know?
382
:
00:21:46
And so for me, I give away ideas all
the time and most of 'em are terrible,
383
:
00:21:51
but I used to say, when I do lectures,
I, so during this lecture I'm gonna
384
:
00:21:58
say something that's really stupid and
it's your job to figure out what it is,
385
:
00:22:04
which is great.
386
:
00:22:04
Because it took all the
pressure away, you know?
387
:
00:22:07
Geri Fitz: Yeah, yeah.
388
:
00:22:09
The allowing yourself to be human.
389
:
00:22:11
Susan: Exactly.
390
:
00:22:12
Well, I think that's something
that's really hard to do.
391
:
00:22:14
Being vulnerable is, does not
come naturally to people who are
392
:
00:22:19
high achievers, who have lots
of degrees and lots of experience
393
:
00:22:24
with a combative mindset, you know?
394
:
00:22:28
Geri Fitz: And where your identity's too
bound up in those external validations.
395
:
00:22:34
Susan: Yes.
396
:
00:22:34
And in what you do.
397
:
00:22:37
And what matters is who you are.
398
:
00:22:40
Because who you are is going to mean
that what you do is important and
399
:
00:22:46
makes a difference, and has an impact.
400
:
00:22:49
And that's what I see in these
amazing people that I've had this
401
:
00:22:53
very precious relationship with,
is that they just like, wow.
402
:
00:22:56
And it's not because of me,
it is not because of me.
403
:
00:23:00
I'm just like a little, a little
background sort of or whatever.
404
:
00:23:05
But they then just take off and
they do these incredible things.
405
:
00:23:10
And they're very much interdisciplinary.
406
:
00:23:15
I have to say that I've mentored,
I don't know how many people,
407
:
00:23:20
but they're primarily women,
people in the global majority is
408
:
00:23:25
what people are using right now.
409
:
00:23:27
And women of color in the US,
people of color in the US.
410
:
00:23:31
Primarily women.
411
:
00:23:32
It's mostly women that I would work with.
412
:
00:23:34
Geri Fitz: Do people come to you and
ask explicitly if you would be a mentor?
413
:
00:23:39
And do you set it up as a
formal mentoring relationship?
414
:
00:23:43
Or is it much more emergent relational?
415
:
00:23:47
Susan: It's more emergent,
relational and you recognize it in
416
:
00:23:51
retrospect more than prospectively.
417
:
00:23:53
And, you know.
418
:
00:23:55
David says, well, are
you really a mentorer?
419
:
00:23:57
Because you don't have a
schedule and you're not talking.
420
:
00:23:59
But, I mean, there are a lot of people
right now, there are probably four
421
:
00:24:03
people that I talk with every week.
422
:
00:24:06
Wow.
423
:
00:24:06
In, Africa primarily, but you know.
424
:
00:24:12
So one of the folks I'm talk to
every week on Friday morning.
425
:
00:24:18
She just needs to have somebody
listen because she gets very little
426
:
00:24:25
validation in her university, like none.
427
:
00:24:30
And she's been forced to change
her field of study somewhat because
428
:
00:24:35
of what the university wants her to
do, if she wants to keep her job.
429
:
00:24:40
And she's very multicultural
in a very monoculture place.
430
:
00:24:48
Both country and university.
431
:
00:24:52
And she struggles with that.
432
:
00:24:54
And she also is very involved
with doing her own service.
433
:
00:24:58
And so she has issues there with dealing
with the other people who are working
434
:
00:25:04
on the conference that she's chairing or
whatever it might be, so just listening
435
:
00:25:11
means so much because she talks it
out, she answers her own questions.
436
:
00:25:16
They always do.
437
:
00:25:18
Sometimes it takes more
than one time, but yes.
438
:
00:25:20
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
439
:
00:25:22
But the gift of providing that space
for someone and that listening heart.
440
:
00:25:28
Susan: Well, people are just amazing.
441
:
00:25:30
And people in this field are
just absolutely incredible.
442
:
00:25:36
The intellect, the heart.
443
:
00:25:38
And I think probably the reason that
I mostly work with women is not just
444
:
00:25:41
because I'm a woman, but because women
are much more open to being authentic
445
:
00:25:47
and to learning how to be authentic.
446
:
00:25:49
I'm not actively modeling anything,
or, I mean, I don't think about
447
:
00:25:53
it, it's just who I am, you know?
448
:
00:25:54
Yeah.
449
:
00:25:55
So, yeah.
450
:
00:25:56
But
451
:
00:25:57
Geri Fitz: yeah, I love bringing
who you are, and I love that you
452
:
00:26:01
started off talking about the
:
1980
453
:
00:26:08
Susan: Yeah.
454
:
00:26:08
Geri Fitz: That it's 2025.
455
:
00:26:11
The ways in which your role in
the work that you're doing in the
456
:
00:26:15
industry that legitimizes your
participation in the community.
457
:
00:26:18
And then your ongoing participation Yeah.
458
:
00:26:22
That has grown out of the service
and out of the relationships.
459
:
00:26:25
And the fact that you were still
at the last big conference Yeah.
460
:
00:26:29
In April, which was Yeah.
461
:
00:26:31
Amazing to see you there.
462
:
00:26:32
Susan: Yeah.
463
:
00:26:34
It was interesting because I sat
back at that conference and I looked
464
:
00:26:38
at, at breaks and the SIGCHI lounge
was at the back of the large hall
465
:
00:26:44
where all the food was served and the
posters and all that kind of stuff.
466
:
00:26:48
And I looked at it and I said, I
recognized maybe for the first time
467
:
00:26:54
that a, well, it wasn't the first time I
recognized that I didn't know everybody.
468
:
00:26:58
There was a time when I knew
everybody in this field.
469
:
00:27:02
No more.
470
:
00:27:03
I mean, hasn't been there for a long time.
471
:
00:27:05
But I looked at the people and
realized that my role has to
472
:
00:27:15
be fundamentally different now.
473
:
00:27:17
Geri Fitz: Mm-hmm.
474
:
00:27:18
Susan: You know, I'm in
the crone phase I guess.
475
:
00:27:22
My role must be one of
simply being a support.
476
:
00:27:26
Because I'm not going to be able
to contribute to the intellectual
477
:
00:27:29
conversations that people are having.
478
:
00:27:32
That's not what I do anymore, you know.
479
:
00:27:36
I'm sure you're familiar
with the tale of indra's net.
480
:
00:27:42
I believe it's a Hindu, I'm not sure
where exactly it comes from, but
481
:
00:27:49
Indra throws a net across the world
and every place where that crosses,
482
:
00:27:55
every intersection, there's a bell.
483
:
00:27:58
And so whenever one person
moves, the whole network moves.
484
:
00:28:03
The whole network rings.
485
:
00:28:06
And I think that's really true, in
a sense that we all influence,
486
:
00:28:12
have an influence on other people.
487
:
00:28:15
Yeah.
488
:
00:28:15
And so I love that metaphor,
because I think it really gets at,
489
:
00:28:23
the whole way that I see the world.
490
:
00:28:25
it's interesting.
491
:
00:28:27
Another thing, I think you have to be
willing to be a beginner sometimes.
492
:
00:28:32
Geri Fitz: Hmm.
493
:
00:28:33
Susan: You know, and that's awkward.
494
:
00:28:35
Geri Fitz: Hmm.
495
:
00:28:35
Yeah.
496
:
00:28:36
Susan: I'm doing watercolor right now.
497
:
00:28:38
I'm starting to learn about watercolor
and it's like, oh man, is that hard?
498
:
00:28:45
And so the beginner
mind is also important.
499
:
00:28:52
Geri Fitz: Well, Susan, you said before,
it matters who you are and we're really
500
:
00:28:59
grateful for who you are and the way
that it has mattered to this community
501
:
00:29:04
in so many different ways over the years.
502
:
00:29:07
And for
503
:
00:29:08
Susan: Well, thank you so much.
504
:
00:29:08
That means so much coming from you
because you are just one of the
505
:
00:29:13
bright lights and you are a person
who gives so much to the community.
506
:
00:29:19
And so many people, when you
mention Geraldine Fitzpatrick,
507
:
00:29:23
they say, do you know her?
508
:
00:29:25
Isn't she amazing?
509
:
00:29:26
So, you know, it's important.
510
:
00:29:30
It means a lot coming from you because
I really honor and respect you.
511
:
00:29:33
I think you're amazing.
512
:
00:29:34
Thank you.
513
:
00:29:35
Geri Fitz: So, all the very best,
and thank you for your time today.
514
:
00:29:39
Susan: Well, thank you.
515
:
00:29:41
Geri Fitz: Now that may sound
like the end, but it's not.
516
:
00:29:45
After we got to this point, Susan
and I continued chatting informally.
517
:
00:29:51
And this is when she started sharing
about some very personal experiences,
518
:
00:29:57
often very painful experiences or dealing
with a lot of different adversities.
519
:
00:30:05
And they're reflections to do with loss
and getting older, and also various
520
:
00:30:11
loss and adversity experiences across
the lifespan that she's dealt with.
521
:
00:30:16
And again, you just hear this amazing
person of Susan coming through with her
522
:
00:30:24
ability to reflect and find the positive
in things and find a way through, and
523
:
00:30:31
always with an orientation to others.
524
:
00:30:35
So I asked Susan if I could
also share some of this
525
:
00:30:38
discussion and she kindly agreed.
526
:
00:30:43
So we start off here where she's talking
about sailing, which is something that
527
:
00:30:47
her and David husband really love to
do, and some of her particular health
528
:
00:30:51
challenges at the moment around that.
529
:
00:30:53
And we go on from there.
530
:
00:30:55
Susan: I have a couple of sailing
shots, which I really like.
531
:
00:30:59
Yeah.
532
:
00:30:59
Um,
533
:
00:31:02
you can learn a lot from sailing.
534
:
00:31:04
Geri Fitz: Oh, that would be a
big thing about trust as well.
535
:
00:31:09
And relationships.
536
:
00:31:10
Yeah.
537
:
00:31:10
'cause you'd have to trust, I mean, you'd
just going with the flow with the weather,
538
:
00:31:14
what you control and can't control.
539
:
00:31:17
Susan: Exactly.
540
:
00:31:18
And you know, you sometimes you
just can't get where you want go.
541
:
00:31:21
You can't, the wind is blowing
the wrong direction and
542
:
00:31:23
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
543
:
00:31:24
Susan: It's gonna be like gale force
for the next month and so you have
544
:
00:31:28
to go someplace else, you know?
545
:
00:31:30
Or you have to
546
:
00:31:30
Geri Fitz: And do you go off
sailing for months at a time.
547
:
00:31:35
Susan: Yes, we used to
before I dislocated my hip.
548
:
00:31:39
Yeah.
549
:
00:31:39
We, the longest I've been
living aboard was four months.
550
:
00:31:43
And that was primarily Intercoastal
waterway, so it was protected sailing.
551
:
00:31:49
But nowadays it's like too
dangerous for me to be on board.
552
:
00:31:54
Geri Fitz: Yeah, I know.
553
:
00:31:55
You can't risk falling again.
554
:
00:31:57
Susan: But, you know,
555
:
00:32:02
if I'm, if I am not gonna be able to sail,
then there are other things that I can do.
556
:
00:32:08
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
557
:
00:32:09
Susan: That they're different.
558
:
00:32:10
Geri Fitz: Is that, is this the
watercolor water painting part of that?
559
:
00:32:13
Susan: Yeah, watercolor is part of it.
560
:
00:32:14
And I discovered, early on, well,
in:
1987
561
:
00:32:21
Our first daughter was four and a half,
and our second daughter was diagnosed
562
:
00:32:25
at 28 weeks with, autosomal recessive
polycystic kidney disease, which is
563
:
00:32:32
not common and had never been di never
been diagnosed prenatally before.
564
:
00:32:40
So they didn't have any way of telling
us what they thought the outcome would
565
:
00:32:44
be because didn't usually happen.
566
:
00:32:47
They didn't usually find it till
kids were like four and a half five.
567
:
00:32:50
That was scary.
568
:
00:32:52
But um, you know, it
turned out that she died.
569
:
00:32:59
And
570
:
00:32:59
Geri Fitz: I'm so sorry.
571
:
00:33:00
Susan: Well, and it's, you know,
that is just such a, it is tragic.
572
:
00:33:04
And it's not that uncommon.
573
:
00:33:07
And we all have things
like that in our lives.
574
:
00:33:10
Whether it's a child or a parent
or a friend, or, for some people
575
:
00:33:14
it's stubbing their toe, you know?
576
:
00:33:16
Geri Fitz: Mm-hmm.
577
:
00:33:17
Susan: And what I learned was that,
well, the image I had was that we'd
578
:
00:33:25
taken Sarah Beth's life and we put
it on the countertop at Tiffany's,
579
:
00:33:29
high end, super expensive store.
580
:
00:33:33
Stuff I'm never gonna be able
to afford even if I wanted it.
581
:
00:33:38
And we took it and they
took away her life.
582
:
00:33:40
It was gone.
583
:
00:33:41
And I had two options at that point.
584
:
00:33:43
I could walk away.
585
:
00:33:45
Being angry and bitter my whole life.
586
:
00:33:48
Or I could say, well, I can't have
what I really want, but I can have
587
:
00:33:52
something else that's wonderful.
588
:
00:33:54
And instead, and so that actually
was the point where I cracked open.
589
:
00:34:00
That's the point where I simply
couldn't be inauthentic anymore.
590
:
00:34:06
I had to just be who I was.
591
:
00:34:10
And the rest is history, as they say.
592
:
00:34:14
You know, it was, and so, I mean, I
think there's some people who aren't
593
:
00:34:18
two by four to the head learners like
me, but, if it's gonna happen, you
594
:
00:34:22
might as well learn something from it.
595
:
00:34:24
Right?
596
:
00:34:24
Geri Fitz: We're all different.
597
:
00:34:25
We're all so different.
598
:
00:34:26
Susan: We're, we're.
599
:
00:34:28
And it's, that's what
makes it so wonderful.
600
:
00:34:30
Geri Fitz: Yeah, it is.
601
:
00:34:32
It is.
602
:
00:34:33
It is.
603
:
00:34:34
One of the courses I often teach or
workshops I run for different people.
604
:
00:34:38
I talk about, crafting your, underlined,
italicised, good professional life.
605
:
00:34:45
Yeah.
606
:
00:34:45
And that the main message I'm trying
to get through is, you can be you.
607
:
00:34:53
Yeah.
608
:
00:34:54
Then, then, I can give you some
tools or tips and tricks about
609
:
00:34:57
how to reflect on who's you.
610
:
00:35:00
Mm-hmm.
611
:
00:35:01
Who you are at your best and
who you wanna be, whatever.
612
:
00:35:04
But it's okay.
613
:
00:35:05
We're all different.
614
:
00:35:06
Susan: Yeah, absolutely.
615
:
00:35:08
Yeah.
616
:
00:35:08
And you know, when I think about it,
617
:
00:35:12
my brother basically
dropped dead in February.
618
:
00:35:16
Geri Fitz: Oh.
619
:
00:35:16
Susan: And so, oh, it hasn't been fun.
620
:
00:35:19
And so I wondered when he was dying,
what did he think about his life?
621
:
00:35:26
Did he regret anything?
622
:
00:35:28
Did he feel?
623
:
00:35:29
And I realized that if I were to drop
dead right now, I've had an amazing life.
624
:
00:35:35
I've had an amazing opportunity to be with
and learn from so many amazing people.
625
:
00:35:43
And in so many different contexts
that, that richness just kind
626
:
00:35:47
of, it's kind of seeped in.
627
:
00:35:51
And so if I were to literally
drop dead right now, you know.
628
:
00:35:57
It's not what I want, but No.
629
:
00:36:00
Geri Fitz: Oh, it's a, it's a
nice point of reflection though.
630
:
00:36:04
Yeah.
631
:
00:36:05
Good life.
632
:
00:36:05
Yeah.
633
:
00:36:06
Susan: Well, I mean, I'm
getting up there in age, so, mm.
634
:
00:36:10
And I can't keep up with
the youngins anymore.
635
:
00:36:13
Geri Fitz: Yeah, yeah.
636
:
00:36:14
That's
637
:
00:36:14
Susan: all.
638
:
00:36:14
Yeah.
639
:
00:36:15
No point in trying.
640
:
00:36:17
Geri Fitz: Yeah.
641
:
00:36:17
Because
642
:
00:36:20
you are aware that it's sort
of at the pointier end of life.
643
:
00:36:24
Susan: Yeah.
644
:
00:36:24
It's your legacy.
645
:
00:36:26
What,
646
:
00:36:26
Geri Fitz: And you're only going
to be as healthy as you are now.
647
:
00:36:29
Susan: Yeah.
648
:
00:36:30
Well, you can be intellectually and
psychologically healthy or even healthier.
649
:
00:36:38
Your body may not agree with you on that.
650
:
00:36:40
My body doesn't agree.
651
:
00:36:41
Geri Fitz: Body definitely doesn't agree.
652
:
00:36:43
Susan: No, my body does not agree at all.
653
:
00:36:46
Yeah.
654
:
00:36:46
But yeah, it's, it's, it's really amazing.
655
:
00:36:52
Geri Fitz: And that is the real end
now, and Susan is really amazing.
656
:
00:37:00
I know I have so much to reflect
on after hearing the way that she's
657
:
00:37:06
navigated the various challenges
that life's thrown her way and just
658
:
00:37:11
coming through again and again.
659
:
00:37:13
Her her deep service, her deep love
of people, and her, as she says,
660
:
00:37:20
listening with heart and the importance
of being you, being who you are.
661
:
00:37:26
Not so much what you do, but who you are.
662
:
00:37:30
So much to reflect on.
663
:
00:37:32
So thank you for listening
and do share this with others.
664
:
00:37:38
I think Susan's a great role model.
665
:
00:37:43
You can find the summary notes, a
transcript and related links for this
666
:
00:37:47
podcast on www.changingacademiclife.com.
667
:
00:37:53
You can also subscribe to Changing
Academic Life on iTunes, Spotify.
668
:
00:37:58
And I'm really hoping that we can
widen the conversation about how
669
:
00:38:01
we can do academia differently.
670
:
00:38:03
And you can contribute to this by rating
the podcast and also giving feedback.
671
:
00:38:08
And if something connected with
you, please consider sharing this
672
:
00:38:12
podcast with your colleagues.
673
:
00:38:14
Together we can make change happen.