If you enjoyed this breakdown, please consider supporting the show. Your donations help me keep the podcast going...from research, to production, to hosting, to all the caffeine that fuels the late-night writing sessions. Every single contribution truly helps this show stay alive and keep growing. I'm listing my Venmo and Buy Me a Coffee links below.

Support the Podcast

Venmo: @HHHpodcast

Buy Me a Coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/hhhpodcast

Your generosity genuinely means the world to me. To all of you who listen, message me, share episodes, and support the show — thank you. This community is what keeps Heists, Hustles, and Homicide moving forward.

What happens when small-town secrets get weaponized? In this Wrap Sheet follow-up, Steve dives back into the Circleville Letters case—the bizarre saga of poison-pen notes that rocked a quiet Ohio town for decades. From Paul Freshour’s questionable conviction, to the unnerving detail that the letters kept coming even after he was behind bars, this episode unpacks the paranoia, the psychology, and the gossip-fueled chaos that turned neighbors into suspects. Steve shares his hot takes, lesser-known details, and theories about whether one person—or an entire community—was behind the most infamous letter-writing campaign in American crime history.

Grab your coffee, lock your mailbox, and buckle up—this is one Wrap Sheet you won’t forget.

And don’t miss the tease for next week’s episode: the sticky, multimillion-dollar Great Canadian Maple Syrup Heist.

#HeistsHustlesHomicide #TheWrapSheet #TrueCrimePodcast #CirclevilleLetters #SmallTownSecrets #UnsolvedMystery #TrueCrimeCommunity #CrimePodcast #ColdCaseFiles #PodcastDrop