Artwork for podcast The Teaching Toolbox - A Podcast for Middle School Teachers
Substitutes in the Classroom - Before and After
Episode 517th October 2023 • The Teaching Toolbox - A Podcast for Middle School Teachers • Brittany Naujok & Ellie Nixon, Podcast for Middle School Teachers
00:00:00 00:19:50

Share Episode


We all get sick. Substitutes are an inevitable part of the classroom and the education system. They stand in for teachers when the teacher has to be absent.

Preparing for a substitute may involve an emergency substitute tote, a sub binder, lesson plans, setting up the room, and more. This episode will discuss the preparations a teacher should take for a substitute, as well as second and third options.

Today we'll talk about what to do after the substitute has come and gone. Debriefing with students and co-teachers, reviewing lesson plans and notes, adjusting plans and notes, and talking with the substitute scheduling department if necessary.

Grab a pen and some paper and join us for this informative session on Substitutes in the Classroom.


Please subscribe on your favorite platform so you don’t miss an episode. Whether it’s SpotifyApple PodcastsGoogle Podcasts, or some other listening app, we encourage you to take a moment to subscribe to The Teaching Toolbox. And if you feel so inclined, we would love a review at Apple or Spotify to help other listeners find us just like you did.

This episode may contain affiliate links.

Amazon links are affiliate links from Brittany Naujok and The Colorado Classroom, LLC®. I earn a small amount from your clicks on these links.

Let's Connect

To stay up to date with episodes, check out our Facebook page or follow us on Instagram.

Join Brittany’s 6th Grade Teacher Success group on Facebook.

Join Ellie’s Middle School Math Chats group on Facebook.

Brittany’s resources can be found on her website or on TPT.

Ellie’s resources can be found on her website or on TPT.

Mentioned in this episode:

Looking for support with Classroom Management?

Grab a digital mental health check-in for free and receive classroom management support from The Colorado Classroom: Then take a look at these classroom management resources to see what is a good fit for your students:

Did you enter the giveaway?

We create this podcast for YOU! Help us make the 2nd year of the show even better by filling out our podcast survey. We're giving away 20 prizes to show our appreciation! Giveaway Survey:

This podcast uses the following third-party services for analysis:

Chartable -


Classroom - Before and After [:

Narrator: /You're listening to The Teaching Toolbox with Brittany and Ellie. Join them as they talk all things middle school.

Brittany: Hey, it's Brittany.

Ellie: And hey there, it's Ellie.

Brittany: /We're glad to have you back on the podcast. And we're here to talk about the best ways for middle school teachers to prepare for a substitute when they need to be out of the classroom. We'll share valuable insights on how to ensure that your students are engaged and focused, even when you can't be there to teach them.

earn how to make the most of [:

Ellie: /Okay, I can't say that being out of the classroom was my favorite. I often got. I don't want to say nervous, but a little bit nervous when I had to be out and not knowing exactly how things were going to go. But one thing that I tried to do to make sure things could go as smoothly as possible was to have a sub binder prepared.

So that if I had to be out, all the good stuff that the sub would need to know would be At their fingertips. I did not always do this though. There were lots of years where I scrambled at the last minute writing up my plans the night before or early early in the morning and then driving everything to school and making sure everything was set up and ready to go.

So if you're still in that boat, I would recommend starting with that sub binder and getting it done as early in the year as possible.

o did you have a sub binder, [:

Brittany: I was kind of in the same situation as you. Some years where I was really on top of it, I had a substitute binder. Or if it was required by administration and they wanted to see it, I had a substitute binder. And then other years,

I winged every absence and had to scramble at the last second and was writing subplans at four in the morning while I was dying coughing.

And yeah.

Ellie: Yeah, and that's one of those things that sometimes makes us not want to call out and take that sick day because we're like, oh my gosh I don't have anything ready to go. What are they gonna do? I can't write these plans I don't have time and then you just kind of suck it up and go into the classroom, even though you're not feeling that great.

But for the sub binder when I did finally start creating one the thing some of the things that I kept in there.

ents also had that said what [:

So the students got that at the beginning of the year and then that went into the sub binder so that the sub knew these are our routines. This is how students check in for the day. This is when they're allowed to go to their lockers. This is what their schedule is for the day, that kind of thing.

and then with a note saying students have this document too.

So they know that this is their expectation. So that was a big thing.

I had all my sections kind of tabbed so that they could easily find the seating charts for each class period. So period one would be a tab, period two would be a tab, et cetera. So we had the rosters and the seating charts and all of that kind of stuff.

Um, I kept the fire drill lockdown procedures, things like that. So if there would happen to be one that day, they could flip to that.

I included things like what fast finishers could do.

That kind of thing that we always had someplace in the classroom where there was fast finisher material. So I included that.

What other [:

Brittany: I always had a list of students that they could rely on and then students who might cause trouble.

Ellie: right. Yeah,

Brittany: So, yeah,

Ellie: That's true,

Brittany: and also, like, teachers that they could rely on if they had questions. And where their rooms were located, so like, usually a map or something,

our discipline plan was usually in there as well, so that they could follow that if there were any discipline issues, although subs tend to have their own kind of discipline plan often.

and then, how did you feel about passwords?

Ellie: I would leave student passwords in case there was some computer work that had to be done. So if students had to go on to, um, study Island, we use study Island. If they had to get in there and they had to do something and they couldn't remember their password, then,

t of those. So the sub could [:

did not tend to leave teacher passwords for anything.

were not. Getting into my computer or getting on my computer for any reason. So I did not leave passwords for myself. How about you? Mm

Brittany: Yeah, I agree with that. I, I did not like to leave teacher passwords,

I never had a school that required that.

Usually subs could access a guest portal on the computer and could get to some resources,


not usually my teaching tools. So, the computer was of little use to them. They would do attendance on paper and...

Have to work on the whiteboard and that sort of thing. So, yeah. It was a struggle for them. I know, I did a year of substitute teaching and it was not fun. Yeah.

nother episode about being a [:

Brittany: Yeah.

Ellie: That's a for future thought

Brittany: Another thing you want to include is if you have, uh, duty responsibilities at your school. Make sure you include a rotation schedule and where that duty is located. Whether it's bus or lunch or line or... Yeah,

Ellie: Yeah,

right, right. We used to have a hallway duty after lunch sometimes and and one year we had to be in the cafeteria for the last five minutes, that kind of thing. Fortunately, we didn't have bus duty, but that is definitely something that you need to include in those plans so they know where they need to be at all times.

Anything else you can think of for a sub binder?

binder Because it's valuable [:

Ellie: Yeah,

Brittany: to know.

Ellie: yeah. And

anything that's critical to your functioning day to day? That, you know, if you think about as you're going through your week, or as you're going through your day, as you're preparing your sub binder, think about all the things that you're doing, and all the things that you would need somebody else to know.

And, and that should be in that sub binder, so that they can access anything. That is part of your daily routine, part of your daily needs.

Brittany: /So speaking of what anybody would need to know How did you do lesson plans? I know some people did lesson plans very generically And it was like two pages long, and then I would do lesson plans very specifically, and mine could be anywhere from like five to twelve pages long.

Ellie: Wow, I don't think I ever had plans that were that long. But I did go back and forth between specific and generic. It really depended on the situation.

if it was [:

If we had a test or a quiz scheduled, I did put that in there and, you know, if it was at all possible, they, they still took the test or the quiz that was scheduled.

And I. I did get to the point,

after several years of teaching, where I did try to prepare my room every day before I left for the day. So that if by chance I couldn't be there, something happened, everything was already ready to go.

So I made sure my copies were done before I left for the day. I made sure things I was going to write on the board were there before the end of the day. So that if I did have to...

be absent, and I wanted to do specific plans, it was a lot easier because everything was pretty much prepped and ready to go.

t, you know, that wasn't the [:

Color by numbers were really nice because it gave A good amount of math practice, but then it also gave some coloring time, and when subs were there, sometimes that helped to fill a good chunk of time for them.

and, and the kids always enjoyed doing those, so that was,

an easy generic plan. How about your five to twelve pages of notes?

What all did you include in there?

Brittany: We were often required to have a sub tote, an emergency sub tote that they could just grab

by numbers or logic puzzles [:

Could be done on any day and get a sub through the day.

and so, I did have those, I usually had like a file thing for that, that I kept in my room.

but if I could, I wrote very specific plans. Cause most of my teaching was at a 6th grade in elementary school. And so we had a lot of kids who

were like, This



pulled for this.

You know, this special or this kid's getting pulled for the service, you know, this kid's coming into this room for, and so there was a lot of, a lot of shifting and stuff that a teacher would need to know. I felt,

and then a lot of like,

e there was a lot of what if [:

I wanted a sub to walk in and feel as comfortable as possible.

Ellie: Mm hmm. And those are some things you could put in the sub binder, but also they kind of need to be called out because if the sub doesn't get through the whole binder and see some of those things, then they're not going to know about it. So you kind of need to have it in

Brittany: Yeah.

And every day was different for us.

we never had a set schedule where, you know, well, every Monday was the same and every Tuesday was the same, but. Monday was not the same as Wednesday and not the same as Friday. And so every day of the week was different. And so, you know, once I was sick every day of the week, then I kind of had a template for the rest of the school year.

Ellie: Yeah.

Brittany: Hopefully that didn't happen very often.

the sub as much as possible [:

Ellie: Mm

Brittany: I would also,

if I knew I was going to be out, I would lay everything out on my table ahead of time and then I would sticky note 1,

Ellie: yeah.

Brittany: this is number 2, this is number 3, this is number 4,

Ellie: I would do that

Brittany: would do it in order of how they were going to use it.

So that,

so that they kind of had a system in place. They knew what to grab first, what to grab second, and so on.

Ellie: Oh good. Yeah.

would be their next item to [:

Yeah. Yeah. I love the sticky notes

teacher's best friend

/right, so you're out for the day. Or two days, or three days, or whatever. What happens when you come back after a sub being there? I think for some days you come back and it's great, and the sub leaves you this really long note. Tells you all the good things that happened, and you know, if there are bad things.

But they let you know everything. And then some subs leave. No notes, and you don't know what happened, or they just kind of check mark what happened, you know, or what, what was done on the, in the lesson plans that they, that they did it, but you don't really know for sure what happened. Did you find that too?

Some left really long notes and some left

ed, and some were just done, [:

And you kind of debrief with the kids about the lessons that they went through and, and how they went and do they need reinforcement and that sort of thing.

Ellie: And then kind of check with your co teachers or teachers on your team to see how they think the day went. You know, the sub might say, the kids were wonderful, but then your team teachers say, well, they maybe had a few issues here and there. So kind of like cross checking and making sure that things went okay and whether or not there were any issues.

tany: and then I would often [:

Then I would do that,

Ellie: Okay.

Brittany: and then I would often talk to the,

scheduler of subs

and say like, can I have this sub more often? Or can I never have this sub again?

we knew we had to be out for [:

But yeah, there were times that there were definitely people that you would prefer to not come back to be, to be your substitute.

Brittany: Yeah.

Ellie: and then like you said, adjusting plans, maybe adding something to the, the sub binder or taking something away in the sub binder that's not really necessary.

the feedback that subs give you is very, very helpful to try to make things go as smoothly as possible the next time.

Brittany: Mm hmm.

I bet, you know, neither of us have gotten a teach during COVID, but I bet the sub issue, trying to find a good sub is even harder right now because there's such a shortage of subs that you basically have to take what you get.

Ellie: Right.

t. So today we chatted about [:

Brittany: if you found this episode helpful, please screenshot it and share it on Instagram or your favorite platform. Don't forget to tag us at TeachingToolboxPodcast.

Ellie: All right, we'll talk to you next time.

Brittany: Bye.

Narrator: /You just listened to The Teaching Toolbox. Follow them on your favorite platform for more episodes and share it with a friend./




More from YouTube