Artwork for podcast Drink Less; Live Better
241. Is compassion the opposite of pity?
Episode 24130th October 2025 • Drink Less; Live Better • Sarah Williamson - Sober Coach, Expert Speaker and Author
00:00:00 00:07:45

Share Episode

Shownotes

Anne Lamott talks about compassion and pity and portraying compassion as a connection to another's struggles versus pity as a detached, often condescending, feeling. Sarah explores some thoughts around this today - listen in!

Coaching with Sarah - All details HERE

Join my email club HERE

Buy the best-selling book Drink Less; Live Better HERE or order from anywhere you usually buy your books.

Subscribe to my 5 day Drink Less Email Series HERE

Download my Habit Tracker HERE

Did you know I've HIDDEN a podcast episode?

It's your secret weapon at 5pm if you are feeling cravings for alcohol.

You can listen HERE

BTW - If you didn't already know, I'm Sarah - Drink Less; Live Better founder, best-selling author, expert speaker, life coach and, as you already know, podcast host!

We don't have to hit rock bottom, we're allowed to want something different and we can CHOOSE to improve our lives from this point onwards. 

I work in the magic space where doubt, hope and action meet... oh.... and

PS I believe in you!

Let's get connected;

on Facebook

on insta

Check out Drink Less; Live Better for blog posts and more

Subscribe to this podcast so you don't miss an episode - also please do leave a like or review and share the love! Thank you

Found the podcast useful? I'd love to have a coffee with you - you can buy it HERE

THANK YOU!

Transcripts

-:

welcome and hello. I'm your host Sarah Williamson, and this is the Drink Less Live Better podcast.

-:

Be sure to follow me on Instagram at Drink Less Live Better and head to the website drinklesslivebetter.com where you'll be

-:

able to sign up to the five day Drink Less experiment or download my Habit Tracker and you can choose to join the email club

-:

where I share resources, wisdom, insights and glimmers of hope and joy. I hope you enjoyed this episode. Let's get straight to it.

-:

At first glance, pity and compassion sound like cousins, two feelings you might have when you see someone suffering. But are they actually opposites?

-:

Is cousin compassion the opposite of pity?

-:

Let's start with a few definitions, because words shape the way we think.

-:

Pity is often described as a feeling of sorrow for someone else's misfortune.

-:

But hidden inside pity is a subtle hierarchy.

-:

I feel sorry for you because you're beneath me in some way.

-:

There's an implicit gap between the one who pities and the one being pitied.

-:

Compassion, on the other hand, comes from the Latin, literally to suffer with.

-:

It's not about standing above someone and observing their pain.

-:

It's about stepping into their experience and recognising our shared humanity. So here's the first clue. Pity looks down. Compassion reaches across.

-:

If pity feels condescending, why do people often confuse it with compassion?

-:

Well, in English, we tend to blur the lines.

-:

If you tell someone I pity you, it rarely lands well.

-:

But if you say I feel compassion for you, the reaction is likely to be warmer. Both are responses to suffering.

-:

Both begin with noticing pain, but the paths diverge right after that moment of recognition.

-:

With pity, we stop at a distance. That poor person over there. With compassion, we move closer. That could be me. How can I support them?

-:

It's the difference between staring at someone through a window versus opening the door and stepping into the room with them.

-:

I'm going to give you two examples. First, pity.

-:

Imagine you're walking past someone experiencing homelessness.

-:

You glance at them and think, how sad. I'm glad that's not me.

-:

You might toss some spare change over, but from a place of separation.

-:

Almost like paying a fee to keep that discomfort away from you. Now, compassion. Same situation.

-:

You notice the person, but instead of turning away, you let yourself imagine their exhaustion, their hunger, their fear.

-:

Maybe you stop, ask their name, buy them some food, have a chat.

-:

Compassion doesn't require you to fix everything, but it draws you into something that's less superficial.

-:

The outer action might look similar in in either case, Maybe both people gave money, but the inner stance is worlds apart.

-:

Another example, pity might sound, oh, poor you, how terrible. That's awful. Which maybe you think sounds sympathetic. I'm not so sure.

-:

And compassion might sound like, oh, tell me more.

-:

How are you feeling about that situation or circumstance? It's open. It's asking for information. It's showing that you're truly listening. Compassion demands a level of vulnerability.

-:

If I pity you, I don't have to open myself to discomfort.

-:

I can remain safe, protected, perhaps superior.

-:

But compassion asks me to get close to you, to feel some of your pain alongside you. This can be scary for people. It threatens the illusion of control.

-:

No wonder pity is a more common response. It costs less emotionally.

-:

But the irony is that compassion, while riskier, is also more healing, not only for the person receiving it, but but for the one giving it.

-:

Neuroscience research shows that compassion activates regions of the brain linked to reward and connection, while pity often activates avoidance. Compassion makes us feel connected. Pity leaves us feeling isolated. So the challenge is real.

-:

We have to do the work from moving from looking down to standing beside someone. So back to our original question. Is compassion the opposite of pity? I'd say yes. And I'd argue for no.

-:

Yes in the sense that pity is about separation, while compassion is about connection.

-:

They pull us in opposite relational directions, but they're not opposites in the way hot opposes cold or light opposes dark.

-:

They share the same route response to suffering, but they branch off into very different outcomes. Pity freezes us at a distance. Compassion invites us closer.

-:

If you've hung around me for a while, you will know that I am not a fan of the binary.

-:

I do not think most things are black or white.

-:

Are A or B yes or no?

-:

I truly believe in the shades of grey or the technicolours in between.

-:

If pity does have an opposite, perhaps it's dignity.

-:

And if compassion has an opposite, maybe it's indifference.

-:

But when we place pity and compassion side by side, the contrast is stark enough that perhaps they almost feel like opposites.

-:

So what should we do with this?

-:

Next time you feel a wave of pity for someone or their situation, pause and ask yourself, am I standing above this person,

-:

or am I willing to stand beside them?

-:

That tiny shift from pity to compassion can transform not only how you treat others, but how you understand your own moments of pain.

-:

Every one of us will need compassion at some point. None of us wants pity.

-:

We want someone who will sit with us, not someone who will stand over us. Thank you for listening in today. Please come back again next week.

-:

Do one kind thing this week for yourself and maybe for me too. Subscribe, rate and review the podcast.

-:

If you love it, I'd be so grateful.

-:

Check out the show notes for a link to a hidden podcast episode that will help you with your 5pm cravings and details about

-:

my one to one life coaching and sober coaching programs. P.S. i believe in you.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube