Artwork for podcast Mindful Builder
Budget vs Brief: What It Really Costs to Build
Episode 7214th July 2025 • Mindful Builder • Matthew Carland and Hamish White
00:00:00 00:25:36

Share Episode

Shownotes

"We love the design, but can you make it cheaper?"

Every builder has heard this request, and it highlights one of the biggest challenges facing our industry today. The gap between what clients want and what they can afford is widening, leaving architects, builders, and clients frustrated. We need to talk about why this is happening and what we can actually do about it.

The solution requires cooperation between clients, architects, and builders from day one. Everyone needs to understand pricing complexities, and we need to work towards realistic briefs that align with financial realities without compromising quality or sustainability.


This means involving builders in early design conversations, establishing clear budget parameters upfront, and maintaining open communication throughout the process. When all parties understand the constraints and possibilities, better outcomes become achievable.


The industry is evolving, and those who embrace collaborative approaches will be best positioned for success.



LINKS:


Connect with us on Instagram:   @themindfulbuilderpod

Connect with Hamish:

Instagram:  @sanctumhomes

Website:   www.yoursanctum.com.au/


Connect with Matt: 

Instagram: @carlandconstructions

Website:  www.carlandconstructions.com/

Transcripts

Speaker:

we're at the Archie Expo . We're actually in a little room built by Jira panel.

Speaker:

If you can't see, it's.

Speaker:

Pretty much been branded everywhere.

Speaker:

What is

Speaker:

Dura panel before we carry on?

Speaker:

So, JIRA

Speaker:

panel, it's a, from my understanding, isn't a compressed straw board,

Speaker:

so it's waste product.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So I know a little bit about it because we've actually had Derek,

Speaker:

on the SBA before one of our webinars, and it's actually waste

Speaker:

product that typically gets burnt.

Speaker:

they bring it in and they.

Speaker:

They heat compress it.

Speaker:

Oh wow.

Speaker:

I didn't know it was waste product.

Speaker:

No, it's all waste product.

Speaker:

And then the lignin within the, so as they steam it up and compress

Speaker:

it, like the lignin within the straw then binds it all together.

Speaker:

So there's actually no binders in here.

Speaker:

there's a lot of products out there.

Speaker:

The expo hamon, I'll probably walk around the next day.

Speaker:

We might even do like a recap at the end of it of just some sort cool stuff we saw.

Speaker:

But there are so many awesome products like this that are

Speaker:

really pushing the market.

Speaker:

I think coming up.

Speaker:

You know, the other thing, I don't know how the fuck we got our

Speaker:

own bloody podcast booth at the

Speaker:

expo and you know, it's just shit work sometimes.

Speaker:

Like, it's just, we put the feelers out.

Speaker:

I think it's probably a good point to start, right?

Speaker:

I, I think sometimes we don't stop and celebrate where we're at and

Speaker:

we're always trying to find that next thing that we want to do.

Speaker:

And we have, and between me and you, there's a million different conversations

Speaker:

going at once and ideas flowing around.

Speaker:

But I Do you know

Speaker:

what I was actually thinking on the car, right?

Speaker:

On the way here.

Speaker:

I actually think it's surprising that we actually get anything done.

Speaker:

'cause I think that you and I have had so many conversations about

Speaker:

yours and mine different roles within the, within the podcast.

Speaker:

And we landed on something and then all of a sudden I'm doing

Speaker:

this and then you are doing that.

Speaker:

And then we've, so anyway, it's happening.

Speaker:

We're in a soundproof.

Speaker:

Box.

Speaker:

Now we are actually gonna have Derek Layfield, who is the owner of Jira Panel.

Speaker:

He's gonna come on and we'll get him to better explain what this is.

Speaker:

But this, from what I understand, is actually a kit.

Speaker:

So if you are interested in, having your own, I guess, soundproof kit,

Speaker:

if your kid plays drums or whatever.

Speaker:

This is, this

Speaker:

is what you want.

Speaker:

Or you just got a screaming baby like I'm about to have and might put one in these

Speaker:

in the middle of my house, screaming room.

Speaker:

Maybe I'll put all three of my kids in there.

Speaker:

Well, they act, they actually joked yesterday.

Speaker:

Um.

Speaker:

The organizer, Ash, who set us up with this, she's like, maybe we can turn

Speaker:

this into a screaming room and charge like $5, $5 a minute if you're just

Speaker:

going nuts trying to get stuff done.

Speaker:

This podcast episode, we are gonna, we're gonna try to keep

Speaker:

this one a little bit short.

Speaker:

It's more of just a bit of an update on where we feel the

Speaker:

industry's at at the moment.

Speaker:

I know Ham, I get a lot of comments about asking my opinion

Speaker:

a lot, especially through social media on where things are at.

Speaker:

I probably take more of a glass half empty approach.

Speaker:

Well, that's great.

Speaker:

'cause I usually take a half glass.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So

Speaker:

I think between this conversation here is a pretty good mix.

Speaker:

I, I have an opinion at the moment that this pricing thing is expensive

Speaker:

and we, we, Hamish and I are trying to really hard to work out how

Speaker:

to navigate this conversation.

Speaker:

It's not an easy one because we know we're gonna get picked apart.

Speaker:

We're probably gonna do maybe a good series with some, some estimators, some

Speaker:

quantity surveyors, people who have maybe built and how they felt like, and just

Speaker:

really try to draw the process out and a big understanding of where things are

Speaker:

coming in and why they're so expensive.

Speaker:

And you know what I was actually thinking, I actually might say some controversial

Speaker:

stuff during this episode as well, which I kind of try and remove myself from.

Speaker:

But I do have something that I do wanna bring up later on, and it's

Speaker:

designers and architects putting their opinion of cost forward,

Speaker:

Let's just start with that.

Speaker:

I actually think it's a really good point.

Speaker:

when we're involved as a project clients, like why do we need you involved?

Speaker:

We've got the architect and it's like.

Speaker:

I always say that we are there to talk about build-ability,

Speaker:

structure, and costings mm-hmm.

Speaker:

That's what we know.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

And we know it.

Speaker:

And our expertise and performance.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And I kind of think that's Yes, yes.

Speaker:

But I feel that's assumed now when people come to us.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But the costing is a big one because we, how can we expect architects, and

Speaker:

I think there's an unfair expectation on architects to know what things cost.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I think the issue, what happens is.

Speaker:

They're seeing so many different price and stuff, they just assume

Speaker:

things, oh, this is what it should cost, or this is what it does cost.

Speaker:

Or we think it should cost, but don't actually understand

Speaker:

the behind the scenes stuff.

Speaker:

and look, I, I agree with this sentiment to a point, you know, architect design,

Speaker:

and look, just for the record, this is not about poo-pooing on architect designers.

Speaker:

'cause you know, we all have our place within this pre-construction.

Speaker:

Process, right?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We're not designers.

Speaker:

That's the thing.

Speaker:

We're not designers.

Speaker:

But I think when an architect turns around and goes, well, that's expensive compared

Speaker:

to what?

Speaker:

Well, that's exactly right.

Speaker:

And I think this is what I guess what I want to try and, get to and I think

Speaker:

this is why I was a bit apprehensive about talking about cost with you.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It's a bit of a minefield when we start talking about cost because obviously

Speaker:

we're coming from a builder's point of view and like my initial kind of

Speaker:

response is, well, that's what it costs because we've just costed it.

Speaker:

So that's what the cost is

Speaker:

and, and if this is one thing I always say to clients, like, if I could get

Speaker:

your cost at a point where you are happy with, I would click my thing

Speaker:

and I can click my things and do it.

Speaker:

I'd do it tomorrow because it saves us so much time, the amount of effort

Speaker:

we have to put in to get just, just.

Speaker:

Pull every dollar outta that project to get it on on site.

Speaker:

The value management piece is actually the biggest part of our preconstruction.

Speaker:

It's probably, I would say

Speaker:

it's 50% of my personal time as, as my job.

Speaker:

Well, it's okay.

Speaker:

It might be 50% of your time.

Speaker:

It's almost 80% of Dan's time.

Speaker:

It's probably 30% of Robert's time.

Speaker:

And then you add me in there as well.

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah.

Speaker:

Like that is a huge amount of energy that we put into costing and, and maybe

Speaker:

that's a good thing to touch on because we just don't go, alright, here's a

Speaker:

square meterage, there's the price.

Speaker:

Like we dive deep, we turn rocks over.

Speaker:

We, we try and find the best value for our clients when we're costing a project.

Speaker:

And the reality is we might get to a number which doesn't

Speaker:

fit within their budget.

Speaker:

And I think that's, the budget meets brief.

Speaker:

The conversation is really important.

Speaker:

Um, and it's a really hard one to navigate because I feel so sorry for architects

Speaker:

because from what I understand, I've done a bit of investigation into this recently.

Speaker:

I think they're obliged by their code that they have to design the brief.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So it's not fair to them as well to put pressure on them to say, Hey.

Speaker:

Uh, the clients come to, I want four bedrooms or what?

Speaker:

Three bras and blah, blah, blah.

Speaker:

My next one had a mud room and another one had a theater.

Speaker:

So let's add this all in.

Speaker:

So they draw it all out.

Speaker:

They go, we know you can't afford this, but we're gonna show you.

Speaker:

And then the thing is, they also show them what their, their budget can get them.

Speaker:

But they always fall.

Speaker:

People fall in love with them.

Speaker:

One that they can't afford.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And now they're stuck.

Speaker:

They can't go backwards.

Speaker:

And I really, I really do feel for architects and a lot of

Speaker:

the ones we work with, like.

Speaker:

I'm just thinking of the two girls.

Speaker:

I share the office with Circle Studios, like they're getting builders in instantly

Speaker:

and they are so good at not commenting on price, like we just did a price for them.

Speaker:

I don't think I've got one question back on any number in that line item other than

Speaker:

like, thank you for putting that together.

Speaker:

And they understand where every line item is coming from.

Speaker:

We are also working with a quantity surveyor to run those numbers as well.

Speaker:

So when we get them.

Speaker:

Like, this isn't really my numbers coming in.

Speaker:

I'm getting what industry data tells us we are putting our special touch on it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Adjusting it going, we don't need that.

Speaker:

We don't need that.

Speaker:

We can change that.

Speaker:

And then we're putting the price together.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Getting some things quoted.

Speaker:

So we'll always send out windows early on.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

This is, this is in your kind of, I guess, opinion of cost stage.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And I just, and

Speaker:

I, and the thing is like that's where I'm getting to.

Speaker:

There's so much effort that goes into that conversation and that,

Speaker:

that putting a price together.

Speaker:

For someone to then come out in a whim, like a building designer

Speaker:

and go, oh, that's too expensive.

Speaker:

But they're compared to what?

Speaker:

there's, there's thinking something is expensive.

Speaker:

right now we, we are looking at cars, right?

Speaker:

you know, the cars that I would like to buy now from a growing

Speaker:

family 10 years ago, Ferrari.

Speaker:

That's my car, that's my, that's my quoting car.

Speaker:

Sorry.

Speaker:

You know what I mean?

Speaker:

That mid-age

Speaker:

life, crisis 40, 45 near the convertible.

Speaker:

Well, that's two,

Speaker:

it's two years away.

Speaker:

But you know what I mean?

Speaker:

Like I look at, you know, so we're looking at a 200, 300 series of

Speaker:

anchors The moment, and then even secondhand ones like 120,000.

Speaker:

Yeah, right.

Speaker:

That's a lot of freaking money.

Speaker:

But I don't think it's expensive.

Speaker:

It's just what it costs.

Speaker:

So this is a very good point.

Speaker:

I'm gonna find something that I found recently.

Speaker:

I got sent this Facebook group about, essentially people

Speaker:

talking about costs of building.

Speaker:

And there was one comment in here that, and I can't take credit for, for what

Speaker:

they said, because I was like, this is just one of the most true things ever.

Speaker:

And the person that wrote it's name was Ryan, so I'm not gonna give you his last

Speaker:

name, but, i'm gonna read out what he said because it really challenged my

Speaker:

thinking on building costs, and I've never thought of it this way, but it kind

Speaker:

of answers where I think things are at.

Speaker:

He said asking a custom builder to give a square meter price is like

Speaker:

asking how much a shopping trolley full of groceries is gonna cost.

Speaker:

The only way of knowing exactly how much a trolley would cost is when every item is

Speaker:

in it is known and has been fully costed at the register, and that involves a fixed

Speaker:

price quote from say, the supermarket.

Speaker:

It's the same as a builder.

Speaker:

They go out, they get all their quotes they put together and they

Speaker:

go to their supplies and trades and get the final estimate.

Speaker:

There's no real difference.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I think that, for me that was this big aha moment where in life we're so happy

Speaker:

just to go the supermarket and scan things that have a higher, way, higher

Speaker:

markup rate than we put on our building.

Speaker:

It's just a huge amount of money we have at the end of it.

Speaker:

So I think it was actually merely a Lee who came up with that analysis.

Speaker:

Really?

Speaker:

Because I heard Yeah.

Speaker:

Oh, okay.

Speaker:

It was a while ago.

Speaker:

And what, what's really great about using that analogy is

Speaker:

that we, we all shop, right?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We all go up and down the aisles and we all have a, have a list of the things

Speaker:

that we want when we first go in there.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But Matthew.

Speaker:

Do you just pick up random things along the way because

Speaker:

you're like, oh, I want that.

Speaker:

I

Speaker:

do sometimes, but the thing is I know I'm paying for it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But what I'm saying is we do this and sometimes even subconsciously,

Speaker:

that the list that we go on, go in with can sometimes differ when we

Speaker:

get, well, there's more on that list when we get to the cash register.

Speaker:

It's the same when we're designing a home.

Speaker:

You might go in with your list of.

Speaker:

You know, likes or wants or needs.

Speaker:

And then along the way the designer might go, well, what about this?

Speaker:

And then what about that?

Speaker:

And this is no, no, no stab at a designer.

Speaker:

But as a designer, their role is to, to put in front of the clients

Speaker:

what they think that they want.

Speaker:

The biggest difference between, going shopping is you can actually

Speaker:

see the prices of these things.

Speaker:

We can't see the prices of those things when we're adding these things in.

Speaker:

When you are going through that design phase, that's where the builder comes

Speaker:

into it, because the builder can then help you understand what impact

Speaker:

those things have on your price.

Speaker:

I don't think the designer can do that.

Speaker:

No, I don't.

Speaker:

And I don't think they, they should, and I'm pretty sure architects aren't

Speaker:

actually able to give advice on pricing.

Speaker:

I'm, I, I also think that's within their like constitution.

Speaker:

And, and look the awesome ones that we work with, like they're pretty good.

Speaker:

Like they'll push you and so they should push us on price to be creative

Speaker:

so they, at the same time, I think the builders just also PPO on an

Speaker:

architect because they go, well, the architect's trying to bust me on price.

Speaker:

It's like, Hey.

Speaker:

Yeah, but if you were to go through that item, that item's quite expensive.

Speaker:

Surely we can, they're not saying do it cheap, but they're saying, how else can

Speaker:

it be creative to get the same result?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

It's like, and it's using the shopping analogy again, is where

Speaker:

you might go in to buy your pasta.

Speaker:

I might want to go get that beautiful pasta from Italy that's, I know

Speaker:

that fancy one that I sometimes get that's $12 for a pack of spaghetti.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But sometimes like, actually that's expensive at the moment.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

You know what?

Speaker:

I'm just gonna go buy the $2 package, but I'm still getting the same thing.

Speaker:

It's a little bit different.

Speaker:

It's probably not as good, but it, it's, you've sometimes gotta settle

Speaker:

and that's my biggest thing to, to clients is you've gotta this,

Speaker:

it's gotta be give and take and.

Speaker:

It's a hard process.

Speaker:

Like we've had, I think I was calculating the other day, seven

Speaker:

and a half million dollars worth of work since November last year.

Speaker:

We've had projects fall over.

Speaker:

Mm. And I know I'm not the only one.

Speaker:

I know that so many people are in this No, same position.

Speaker:

I think building's as hard as it's ever gonna get.

Speaker:

I know there's massive changes coming in from an insurance perspective and the,

Speaker:

owner's first access to insurance and building, I think that's gonna push price

Speaker:

up, especially in the commercial sector.

Speaker:

I think that there's, there's a number of change.

Speaker:

I think the next year gonna really dramatically change the way we look

Speaker:

at building, and you're about to go through building your house, I'm doing

Speaker:

mine at the moment, stuff's expensive.

Speaker:

And I'm looking at it being like, geez, that's very overvalued.

Speaker:

I'm getting looked after very well on some certain things.

Speaker:

I just can't see, and this is why I'm glass half empty.

Speaker:

It's like I just can't see this price increase and it's

Speaker:

not increasing like it was.

Speaker:

I just can't see this price staying the way it is in building for much longer.

Speaker:

My, my glass half full approach to that is, is look, when you're backed into the

Speaker:

corner, it creates innovation and change.

Speaker:

And I think that's where the industry's going at the moment.

Speaker:

So what you're gonna see is you're gonna see more competitive, and

Speaker:

I'm, and I'm talking specifically to the high performance market.

Speaker:

More competitors are gonna come in,

Speaker:

but I don't, I think this is where we get caught.

Speaker:

Caught in the whole high performance market.

Speaker:

I don't think it's custom architecture.

Speaker:

Custom architecture is expensive.

Speaker:

It's the high performance element is not, it's maybe an extra one to 2%.

Speaker:

I'm gonna say passive house is definitely 20% on a build.

Speaker:

Mm. And in most cases.

Speaker:

If it's sometimes, if it's as if you've got a Chase passive

Speaker:

house certification, but do

Speaker:

Do you know what is gonna happen?

Speaker:

People are gonna start looking overseas.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And probably, and we've spoken about it, particularly China.

Speaker:

And then what's gonna happen?

Speaker:

People are gonna start losing sales to China.

Speaker:

It's gonna force innovation.

Speaker:

It's gonna force change, it's gonna force efficiencies.

Speaker:

So I don't think building price is gonna come down.

Speaker:

I don't think it's gonna skyrocket up as it has been or will be.

Speaker:

One thing that I probably will say just a second, back to the designers

Speaker:

thing, and again, take this however you want, designers and architects who are

Speaker:

listening to this, instead of saying that that's expensive, why don't you say,

Speaker:

help me understand that cost, because if we can help you understand that cost.

Speaker:

As soon as someone says that's expensive, like I know I have a

Speaker:

physical reaction to a corner, I'm just like, well, hang on a minute.

Speaker:

No, I'm not the one that designed this.

Speaker:

I'm just costing what's drawn.

Speaker:

But if we can help you understand the cost, then we can work

Speaker:

collaboratively to try and work out how we can find a more cost effective

Speaker:

solution saying it's expensive.

Speaker:

It doesn't get anywhere.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It's, it's the language.

Speaker:

And I remember listening to a podcast and a diary of a CEO and how you've

Speaker:

gotta approach conversations where if you just say to someone I disagree

Speaker:

immediately, they're back in a corner.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Where if you, if you can make that conversation more proactive and,

Speaker:

um, encourage the open sort of Yeah.

Speaker:

Collaborative collabor dialogue.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Like if we can sit there and be like, okay.

Speaker:

You've looked at this cladding, you've been told it's a hundred dollars a

Speaker:

square meter, but we've come in at 300.

Speaker:

The reason why is the clips behind it to install this are

Speaker:

another $50 a square meter.

Speaker:

The rail that we have to use as per the installation guide is this.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

The sales person has probably gone out to the architect and told them,

Speaker:

Hey, yeah, this is what the cladding costs for getting to tell them all

Speaker:

the little bits and pieces around it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And all of a sudden that's not.

Speaker:

The, they, the architect, are being blindsided, so when we run them through

Speaker:

that, they're like, ah, that makes sense.

Speaker:

Mm. Also, labor's so expensive I've started running numbers and I'm probably

Speaker:

saying about 40 to 45% of a whole project's cost is directly to labor.

Speaker:

10% of being GST, the overheads and margin being part of that.

Speaker:

So the, the huge cost of building is actually labor.

Speaker:

And that's something that we can't change unless there's huge innovation,

Speaker:

which we always talk about it.

Speaker:

And it's prefabrication.

Speaker:

It's really, it's stuff like potentially this

Speaker:

robots.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And humanoid humanoid robots.

Speaker:

Yeah, I just think that we're gonna get to a point where there's gonna

Speaker:

be things that like that, and I don't think trades like plumbing are gonna

Speaker:

go into robots or anything like that, but I can, I can, I can see something

Speaker:

like a painter, like there's a machine that goes around and paints, and

Speaker:

I feel that the construction industry's reasonably safe for the next 10

Speaker:

years from AI and robotic innovation.

Speaker:

On site.

Speaker:

On site, yes.

Speaker:

Yeah, on site in backend.

Speaker:

I think there's a lot of changes that will happen.

Speaker:

we're kind of digressing a little bit 'cause you need to touch on, you know,

Speaker:

how we can bring the prices down.

Speaker:

One's prefabrication and one's efficiency in building.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

If we can ex expedite the process, remove the red tape.

Speaker:

The red tape's another thing.

Speaker:

the quicker something's done, the less it's gonna cost.

Speaker:

'cause your overheads come down, your supervision comes

Speaker:

down, your risk comes down.

Speaker:

Your risk profile comes down 'cause you're on site less.

Speaker:

So innovation and efficiencies, and whether that's through AI or

Speaker:

whether that's through robotics, is has to be where the, where it goes.

Speaker:

So I've got two things that I think.

Speaker:

One is, I think there's too many people in the last few years who have

Speaker:

tried to get constructions booming and they're adding another layer before we

Speaker:

can get our hands on it as builders.

Speaker:

So you, for example, you buy something from the manufacturer, they sell it

Speaker:

to a supplier, they sell it to someone else, they sell it to someone else,

Speaker:

and then we get our hands on it.

Speaker:

There's four people along the way putting their margin on it.

Speaker:

I see a world coming up very quickly where someone like, for example, a

Speaker:

timber merchant, we don't have to go through say a Mitre 10 or a Bowen.

Speaker:

We can go directly to the timber company because at the end of the day, those

Speaker:

companies can actually increase their, their price on it because they're not

Speaker:

having three or four people along the way.

Speaker:

They can still give it to us cheaper than what we can buy

Speaker:

from anywhere else and just.

Speaker:

Cut in between.

Speaker:

I think there's way too many in between people in construction.

Speaker:

Everyone's trying to make a really quick dollar on it

Speaker:

during, especially during COVID.

Speaker:

Everyone's trying to make it harder to get products, and I think if we can cut people

Speaker:

out along the way, that's a huge one.

Speaker:

I just dunno if that'll happen though, because I feel like I hear what you're

Speaker:

saying and maybe there is some lost efficiencies there from it going from one

Speaker:

person to another, to another, to another.

Speaker:

I can't see that happening 'cause that's how the world's worked in the last

Speaker:

how many?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But construction, I feel, especially in Victoria, like, I think there's

Speaker:

40,000 jobs that are gonna come out of nowhere soon because we don't have any

Speaker:

more tunnel and rail that's happening.

Speaker:

So they're gonna have those people have to go somewhere and those

Speaker:

companies still need to sell concrete and plaster and whatever.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So what's gonna happen is like, I don't know, I've already had people like

Speaker:

borrow and stuff start reaching out to me directly to be like, Hey, like

Speaker:

can we tell you about our product?

Speaker:

Like.

Speaker:

James Hardy directly, like it's like, Hey, you wanna know about me now?

Speaker:

Like, interesting, you don't wanna know about me when you guys

Speaker:

are doing well, it's when you guys are starting to get quiet.

Speaker:

So I can see a world where you just call James Hardy, for example, and we are

Speaker:

gonna buy directly through you guys.

Speaker:

And rather than I have to go through the distributor then go to say the

Speaker:

Mire 10 or someone, and then we gonna hands on it and there's, there's 30%

Speaker:

and then another 30% margin on it.

Speaker:

And then we get it.

Speaker:

And then the reality is, as a builder, we, we've got our margin on it so we can then.

Speaker:

Potentially cut the costs there.

Speaker:

I think that's, I think, and that's a whole probably conversation itself.

Speaker:

I think the other one comes down to massive changes through bank

Speaker:

and legislation, insurances.

Speaker:

And I think this moves in more in line with the rest of the world is where we

Speaker:

have a contract that is, and we've been looking at this a bit recently, is we

Speaker:

can run at a fixed price contract mm-hmm.

Speaker:

With a fixed margin, uh, like a fixed margin.

Speaker:

But it's kind of like a bit of a cost plus where, if the timber, it costs

Speaker:

what it is, we show you the receipt, but our margin is fixed, so we don't

Speaker:

have any benefit if it goes up or down.

Speaker:

We just have our fixed margin.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And I think that's an area where we can start to potentially cut cost.

Speaker:

'cause as a builder, we can reduce our risk on not having to inflate something.

Speaker:

So for example, a project with joinery, you might be on site for 12 months, 13

Speaker:

months before you order your joinery.

Speaker:

You just pay what it's worth.

Speaker:

I think that's, yeah.

Speaker:

This is an

Speaker:

interesting, an interesting one beginning you to touch on the banks there.

Speaker:

Banks are really apprehensive about costing, rising fall contracts

Speaker:

and that is like cost plus.

Speaker:

So.

Speaker:

Cost plus, I think will work for cash clients.

Speaker:

And I don't think it's gonna work for, finance clients.

Speaker:

this is the thing is if we have a fixed price, we don't benefit from it.

Speaker:

And if, if things go up and down, like there's gotta be some form of like, we,

Speaker:

we can't continue to be banks for the, banks, for the clients and the bank.

Speaker:

That's the half the issue.

Speaker:

I agree.

Speaker:

Look, we, we recently completed a successful cost plus project with

Speaker:

exactly that fixed price margin.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

The cost of material was a cost of material.

Speaker:

We put no markup on it.

Speaker:

It was, it was what it was.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And it, yeah, and I think that's, it allows us to, as builders, maybe

Speaker:

move projects faster onto site.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

If we can get really good costings, we can maybe skip that

Speaker:

whole last estimate to something.

Speaker:

We can do a really good early one and keep it moving faster.

Speaker:

Actually

Speaker:

almost feel that going into a cost plus contract.

Speaker:

And if any, is there any clients out there wanting do a cost plus contract with us?

Speaker:

I'm actually gonna spend longer costing your project.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I, I, I'd be, I'd probably set it up in a different way where I'd

Speaker:

want to have all my estimates and show you, hey, this is what we want.

Speaker:

I think on the provision of like, if we go cost plus, it's not,

Speaker:

let's get four plumbing quotes.

Speaker:

It's like, no, we still wanna use our plumber 'cause we trust

Speaker:

him and we know he's gonna do it.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And we know we can trust him compared to John the plumber up

Speaker:

the road who's half the price.

Speaker:

But we dunno what's included in Yeah.

Speaker:

And how he's gonna deal with people on site.

Speaker:

So I think there's, you know what

Speaker:

that's, you touched on something really interesting there, like.

Speaker:

When we are costing projects, we're typically only putting it out to

Speaker:

one supplier or one trade because we have a known relationship with them.

Speaker:

See, I'm for the first time starting to see what else is out there, and it's

Speaker:

hard conversation to have with your trades, but I think that we need to

Speaker:

like, so I think there's a part where sometimes maybe builders get, we don't

Speaker:

get comfortable, but it's always good having two and as we grow as well, you,

Speaker:

you some, like, I can't have the same joiner doing all my work because I can't

Speaker:

have 'em at two places at once either.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Look, I, I agree with 'em.

Speaker:

I, I agree with you, but what we're not doing, and look, we, and for

Speaker:

disclosure, we've done a, you know, on a couple of larger projects that we've

Speaker:

costing at the moment, you know, they're north of 3 million and I guess for

Speaker:

the client, we've gone out and tested.

Speaker:

The price because we want to benchmark that against something.

Speaker:

But I don't play them off.

Speaker:

I don't tell.

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

And I'll use my join as an example, just as 'cause I'm looking at some join right

Speaker:

now, but I don't go to, Hey, company A and company B, you're both pricing

Speaker:

against each other come in the cheapest.

Speaker:

I just go, Hey, can you just both price it, get it back and be like, I think

Speaker:

in this case I look at the schedule and go, I think that one will come in here.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And go.

Speaker:

I think that's gonna be the best value at that time for that client.

Speaker:

I know each joiner, I'm just using them as an example.

Speaker:

They might get a Polytech, one might get better Polytech price and

Speaker:

one might get a better lax price.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

So it, we just have to navigate that.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Look, price is a tricky one and I think, I think we're gonna

Speaker:

chat with some estimators that we've used in the past coming up.

Speaker:

Yeah, we could do, I think what we could do, we could start

Speaker:

with something like Pro Calc.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I know you've worked with Pricer Plan, I've worked with Rapid Qs,

Speaker:

we've got Tara from, art House.

Speaker:

And then we can start to have Avera and we can even potentially try and bring

Speaker:

him in as all as a conversation and let them take the, what they're seeing.

Speaker:

'cause they're kind of across the, the country too.

Speaker:

Like whilst we're in Victoria and then as builders we can have the

Speaker:

conversation like then how do we navigate it and hopefully potentially give.

Speaker:

More understanding on what goes into a project, because I know, I know, I

Speaker:

do know that architects really respect the work that we put in and the stuff

Speaker:

that we'll flag and, and we'll come up with ways to potentially go, Hey,

Speaker:

this is how we could value management.

Speaker:

We don't, I think there's, there's, it's a scary topic to navigate because

Speaker:

people, I think have a misconception that builders are just, they're

Speaker:

just putting so much margin on the project, making so much money.

Speaker:

I'm gonna go on the record right now and say.

Speaker:

the money that drops out the bottom.

Speaker:

At the end of the day, I work so fucking hard for, believe me when I say that

Speaker:

and you know, is there a potential as builders to, earn a good living living?

Speaker:

Absolutely.

Speaker:

But the risk of also going backwards on a project is, can be catastrophic as well.

Speaker:

And look how many builders have gone under in Victoria.

Speaker:

Exactly.

Speaker:

That's showing.

Speaker:

They're not making crazy amount of money.

Speaker:

You want your builder to make money.

Speaker:

You want your builder to be profitable.

Speaker:

So they're around.

Speaker:

So they're there to fix problems in the future and that's why we get awesome

Speaker:

clients, and I know we, we see so many builders being like, oh, my clients suck.

Speaker:

It's the reason we have such good a relationship with our

Speaker:

clients because they value us.

Speaker:

They trust us.

Speaker:

They've paid a good amount of money to get a good build.

Speaker:

They get that, and then we're still around to have that

Speaker:

conversation post construction.

Speaker:

Like a project we just finished, was at mid last year, there was

Speaker:

three other houses being built in the street at the same time.

Speaker:

One of them was being built.

Speaker:

It actually, we, They started before us.

Speaker:

They just finished and the builder said to them when they kept the client being,

Speaker:

this is what the client told me, they kept saying, Hey, how come it's taken so long?

Speaker:

And the builder goes, just be lucky that I'm still around.

Speaker:

My dad was saying at a guy at work, they had, he had quoted timber in the build.

Speaker:

They put aluminum in and he's like, whatcha gonna do about it?

Speaker:

Because they just wanted to get cost back.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

So the thing is like that also comes at a cost.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I think when we talk about building prices, that what

Speaker:

something might look on paper.

Speaker:

It's also the reputation and we, we go back to the conversation

Speaker:

earlier about the industry and.

Speaker:

The budget meets brief.

Speaker:

I think part of that budget meets brief conversation is speaking to our

Speaker:

clients that how they've done it in the past and how they achieved it.

Speaker:

I think that is a really important thing where most clients will

Speaker:

probably reach out and say, Hey, like what was the bill quality?

Speaker:

Like?

Speaker:

How are they on site?

Speaker:

Like, that's our bread and butter.

Speaker:

That's easy.

Speaker:

The question I'd be asking is like, how do they go getting a project to

Speaker:

budget and what challenges did you have?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I think that's a really important conversation to have.

Speaker:

I. What tools were at the disposal?

Speaker:

Was it a stressful process?

Speaker:

Which I can tell you straight away, it is a stressful process.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I think the more time you spend in pre-construction, the less

Speaker:

stressful the actual building Yes.

Speaker:

Is gonna be.

Speaker:

Now I reckon we, um,

Speaker:

wrap this one up,

Speaker:

wrap this one up because we have a whole bunch of other podcasts

Speaker:

that we are gonna record.

Speaker:

We got over

Speaker:

the next few days.

Speaker:

We have people like Justin.

Speaker:

Justin, FCP.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

From, yeah.

Speaker:

PHCP down Tasie Pro Climb, not Pro Climb Performance Membranes.

Speaker:

We have Devin from Performance Membranes, Jake from the Tous

Speaker:

Tools and Performance Membranes.

Speaker:

David Kustra, the reluctant owner of Fence and Panel coming on.

Speaker:

Yeah, we've got Dura Panel coming in.

Speaker:

Yeah,

Speaker:

we've got, um, interior designer.

Speaker:

Yeah, interior Shivani from

Speaker:

Madison Interiors.

Speaker:

we'll wrap this one up.

Speaker:

We're super excited for the content we're gonna bring you over the next few days.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube