Ryan Nauman hosts Zephyr’s Adjusted for Risk podcast with Dana D’Auria, Group President of Solutions and Co-CIO at Envestnet, discussing the growing role of private markets in wealth management. D’Auria explains how Envestnet combines asset management and wealth tech, then outlines key trends: companies staying private longer, increased demand from the wealth channel, and expanded use of vehicles like interval funds, tender offers, private BDCs, and private REITs. They emphasize that “semi-liquid” vehicles can become illiquid during dislocations, and highlight major risks including illiquidity, return dispersion across managers, and valuation/marking differences versus public markets that can overstate diversification metrics like correlation. D’Auria advises using specialist due diligence, evaluating tail-risk metrics, and leveraging available education from asset managers and resources such as Tony Davidow’s book.
Zephyr can help financial advisors create modern diversified portfolios learn more here.
To learn more about Envestnet here.
00:00 Podcast kickoff
01:18 Meet Dana D'Auria
03:41 Wealth tech meets investing
05:52 Why private markets boom
09:09 Diversification reality check
13:00 IPOs and index impact
16:11 Access vehicles expand
18:00 Advisor adoption spectrum
21:21 Interval funds liquidity
26:34 Key risks and due diligence
34:21 Education and wrap-up
Connect with Ryan Nauman:
Go
2
:Ryan Nauman Market Strategist Zephyr:
Hello, everyone, and welcome to
3
:Zephyr's Adjusted for Risk podcast
from the shores of Lake Tahoe.
4
:I'm Ryan Nauman, the market
strategist here at Zephyr.
5
:Investing in private markets has become
very popular for retail investors as
6
:the benefits they bring to investment
portfolios are more widely known
7
:and accessibility has increased.
8
:But the world of private markets is
vast, complex, and brings its own
9
:unique risks to investment portfolios.
10
:Well, I have on an industry expert to
help us gain a better understanding of
11
:investing in private markets and what
it m- means for financial advisors.
12
:But first, today's episode is sponsored
by the award-winning Zephyr, which
13
:helps investment professionals
make more informed investment
14
:decisions on behalf of their clients.
15
:All right.
16
:Enough from me.
17
:I've already talked enough.
18
:Let's go ahead and bring
on the star of the show.
19
:I'd like to give a very warm welcome to
Dana D'Oria, dana is the group president
20
:of solutions and co-CIO at Envestnet.
21
:Dana, thank you so much for
coming on the podcast again.
22
:I believe this is your third time.
23
:Yeah.
24
:Dana D'Auria: I'm a regular
25
:Ryan: to have you on.
26
:V- like I said, most people after about
one or two, they're about done, so
27
:I'm glad I didn't scare you away after
the first or second one, so thank you.
28
:Dana D'Auria: Not at all.
29
:Ryan: Can you please tell us a little
bit more about yourself and Envestnet?
30
:Dana D'Auria Group President of Solutions & Co-CIO Envestnet:
Sure.
31
:Yeah, so, um, my position at
Envestnet basically is running sort
32
:of the, uh, turnkey asset management
program, programs, if you will.
33
:And so, uh, what pal- falls under my
purview is, uh, all of the in-house
34
:investment management and as well as all
the relationships with our asset manager
35
:partners, which we have about six hundred
asset manager partners on the platform.
36
:Uh, and you know, the, the, um,
the, the various kind of different
37
:solutions that work within that group.
38
:Um, you know, also investment retire-
investment retirement, for example,
39
:is in my area and, um, you know, our,
our partnerships with various other
40
:outside parties all think in terms of
the asset management side of the house.
41
:And, you know, the-- to, to talk a
little more about Envestnet, I think
42
:that kinda, that lens of what my role
is, you know, take that and broaden
43
:it out and think of Envestnet as the
leading adaptive wealth tech platform
44
:that provides turnkey asset management
program services, as well as all of the
45
:surrounding ecosystem that you would need.
46
:You know, SaaS tools, if you're an
advisor managing your own portfolios
47
:and trading your own portfolios.
48
:Uh, financial planning tools,
MoneyGuide Pro in particular,
49
:wealth studios that we offer.
50
:Uh, we have Tamarac.
51
:Envestnet Tamarac is a, it, it is
a more robust even rebalancing tool
52
:that's used by many RIAs out there,
uh, to run their books of business.
53
:So a very kinda broad ecosystem
that houses various ways that
54
:advisors or home offices navigate
the advisory platform experience.
55
:Ryan: Dana, that's fantastic.
56
:I know, I follow a lot of your great
thought leadership and content, so it's
57
:interesting you said you do a lot of
thought leadership and research on markets
58
:and investments, but you also sit right
in the middle then on the technology side,
59
:so you kind of bring the two together.
60
:So how is it?
61
:Is that a challenge, kinda having
to juggle both sides of it, or is it
62
:really rewarding seeing how it brings
it all together and works together?
63
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
64
:You know, when I came to Envestnet,
my thesis was that technol- that the
65
:intersection of technology and asset
management is gonna be increasingly
66
:blurred, and I think that's played out.
67
:And so I'm, I'm really happy having an
opportunity to be in a position and at a
68
:company that really kinda navigates that.
69
:Because if you think about just, you
know, eh- eh- even if I take it a
70
:high level, um, I came from sort of
a quant background as it relates to
71
:how I engage with capital markets.
72
:My, you know, the way that I think is,
uh, a, a great way to invest is via
73
:factors and other academically derived
ways of accessing market returns.
74
:And, you know, when you think about
what those are really, in a, in a lot of
75
:ways they're sort of a commoditization
of what active management used to
76
:do using data, using technology
to better understand the market.
77
:Well, now put artificial intelligence
and machine learning into that
78
:picture, you know, just a burgeoning,
uh, swath of studies out there on
79
:how to improve upon those things.
80
:And, and so really it's just tech
is very much moved into the space,
81
:the asset management space if
you will, and vice versa, right?
82
:Asset managers increasingly
want technology efficiencies.
83
:They understand that in order to best
engage with clients, they really have to
84
:have a so- a technology solution that can
enable efficiency for the advisor, enable
85
:efficiency for the client, enable a good
story, a good reporting, uh, function
86
:if you will, so that folks understand
and also appreciate what's going on.
87
:So a lot of blurring
there and a nice place to
88
:Ryan: Yeah, exactly.
89
:And it, it, you're exactly right, a good
place to sit between, between the two.
90
:So speak of blurring of two, , emerging
of two kind of what used to be maybe
91
:separate parts of wealth management is
wealth management and private markets.
92
:Speak of evolution here, private markets,
it wasn't that long ago, four years
93
:ago, five years ago, where it really
was earmarked for institutions, ultra
94
:high net worth, endowments, and so on.
95
:Now it's merging with wealth management.
96
:What are some of the biggest trends
you're seeing play out in private
97
:markets right now with the two
and, and really coming front and
98
:center with, with wealth management?
99
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
100
:So there's a few and, uh, we
could take up the whole podcast I
101
:think on just this one question.
102
:But I'll, I'll, I'll tackle a couple.
103
:One, I think, you know, companies
are staying private for longer.
104
:They are increasingly
seeing private markets as…
105
:And, and the second one, which
is private markets are becoming
106
:more and more important to wealth.
107
:Wealth is, you know, providing another
whole basically asset pool that, you know,
108
:alternatives managers are going after.
109
:And so you, you s- you put
those two together, companies
110
:wanna stay private longer.
111
:They don't necessarily wanna
make the leap into public.
112
:Uh, and they can because there's, there's,
you know, kinda capital available in the
113
:private market space for them to do that.
114
:And so, you know, I, I think
that we can expect more of that.
115
:It's interesting, you know, kinda the
SEC rule change around reporting, right?
116
:That we're seeing, you know, kinda in
the, in the news where, uh, you know,
117
:you, you don't have to report quarterly.
118
:And one of the big reasons for that
is just, you know, for companies that
119
:are, you know, kinda on the edge around
whether they wanna go public or not,
120
:maybe it helps push them over the edge
because it reduces some of the legal
121
:requirements, the legal cost really
for all the reporting, et cetera.
122
:But just the fact that, you know,
there's a response happening fr- on the
123
:regulatory front to try to encourage
companies to go public, you know, th-
124
:it, it's sort of, uh, just kind of a
bellwether around what, you know, clearly
125
:people in not only the industry but
also even in the government think is
126
:gonna probably be a longer term trend.
127
:So that's one.
128
:And then, you know, the other side, as
I said, uh, wealth is increasingly where
129
:alternatives managers, private market
managers are seeing opportunity to grow.
130
:You know, they've, they've-- the
traditional place, um, endowments,
131
:you know, uh, um, sovereign
wealth funds, you know, very
132
:ultra-high net worth individuals.
133
:They- they've sort of
tapped a lot of that, right?
134
:And now they, they see the wealth market
and they see the opportunity to, you
135
:know, kind of bring different types
of vehicles to that market, right?
136
:And the- these vehicles have been
around for a long time, but now
137
:you're seeing just a multiple, you
know, uh, number of launches around
138
:things like interval funds or tender
offers, private BDCs, private REITs.
139
:Again, these have existed.
140
:They've been available and there
have been managers doing it.
141
:But I think what you're seeing now is
just kind of a recognition on the parts
142
:of, of a vast swath of alts managers that
these are applicable for them, that they
143
:open up a new audience for their work
and you're gonna see more and more of it.
144
:Ryan: Yeah, Dana, those
are great, great points.
145
:And going back to your first trend
that you mentioned, that companies are
146
:staying private longer, it's out there
that, there's more private companies
147
:than there are public companies.
148
:There's been that major shift
going on over recent years.
149
:And now if these companies are staying
private longer, what impact does that…
150
:Does that also force the retail or the
wealth side to be like, "You know what?
151
:If we want real diversification,
we gotta go on the private side
152
:because there's just more options."
153
:And the public side, they're
just starting to get more limited
154
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
155
:Uh, so it's an interesting question.
156
:I do think it is one of the main
drivers behind why, you know, sort
157
:of the buy side on what-- in wealth
would be interested in this trend,
158
:you know, not just the sell side.
159
:Uh, and, and, you know, I think
people want access, right, to some
160
:of the innovation that's staying
in the private space for longer.
161
:And so I do think that it kind of
forces the hand a little bit of
162
:the wealth management side to at
least look at this and understand
163
:whether it's relevant for clients.
164
:I know we'll get into the risks,
so I'll, I'll hold off on this
165
:answer talking about that.
166
:But I, but I…
167
:But as far as, you know, the reward side
or why you're doing it, 100% I think
168
:getting access to innovation that is
staying private for longer is, you know,
169
:kind of one of the top of the list.
170
:I do wanna just address the
diversification aspect of the question.
171
:So I, I certainly believe it does
diversify the portfolio, but I think
172
:some of the traditional metrics for
how diversified and-- diversifying it
173
:is can be a little overstated, um, and
maybe a lot overstated depending on,
174
:you know, what number you're looking at.
175
:So, uh, correlation for example, if
you're, if you're thinking about the
176
:correlation that you see of these
private markets with your public markets,
177
:you know, you have to bear in mind
some of the structural differences.
178
:They don't value regularly, so, you know,
the animal spirits of the market that are
179
:visible, uh, you know, in public markets
like minute-by-minute and day-by-day.
180
:If you're valuing on a
quarterly basis, you're not…
181
:You know, that, that gets
very smoothed, right?
182
:And, and that's a lo-- you know,
private markets, uh, traditionally
183
:are, are valuing on a lag like that.
184
:They are also, um…
185
:It's not a public mark, right?
186
:And that's an important
thing to understand.
187
:It's not, you know, the…
188
:It's not the, the amalgamated
response of the entire market
189
:saying what this thing is worth.
190
:It's, uh, it's, you know,
individuals basically, right, with
191
:a valuation model deciding, you
know, what is the value today.
192
:So that can create just discrepancies that
are really a real correlation difference.
193
:They're just a difference in
the way it's being valued.
194
:Now that being said, again, I still…
195
:I, I do think the diversification
benefit is absolutely there.
196
:You think about you, you know, we
encourage people to have public
197
:market small caps in addition
to just their large caps, right?
198
:Well, this is another step, right, a-away.
199
:So certainly if, if you believe in
the diversification benefits of having
200
:a broadly diversified public market
portfolio, it kind of is obvious and
201
:makes sense that, uh, well, bring
more companies in via private markets,
202
:you do get some diversifying effect.
203
:Ryan: Yeah.
204
:Dana, that's a really great point.
205
:I haven't thought about that.
206
:You just assume everyone
talks about diversification.
207
:Yes, it adds diversification, but
I haven't thought about, you got-
208
:have to rethink of what analytics
you use to measure diversification.
209
:Like correlation, obviously.
210
:Usually everyone, that's what you use to
measure diversification in a portfolio.
211
:Now, do you have to look outside that?
212
:So I'm really glad you brought
that up because that's, that's
213
:something I haven't heard and gonna
have to look at, um, and research.
214
:So that's fantastic.
215
:How are IPOs…
216
:This is big news, Dana.
217
:I mean, it's headlines
all the time about these
218
:Dana D'Auria: Where you going?
219
:Ryan: upcoming IPOs, um,
SpaceX, Anthropic, OpenAI.
220
:It's like everywhere I look, and people
are like, "How can I get involved in
221
:SpaceX and all this stuff, the IPOs?"
222
:How is that impacting private markets,
the, the release of these IPOs?
223
:Dana D'Auria: I mean, the f- so they're,
obviously they're finally going public,
224
:so I think it validates everything
we've just been talking about that if
225
:you had wanted to be a part of the, you
know, return-generating process of these
226
:companies for their early years and, and
even as they grew, you know, to ginormous
227
:levels, you had to be in private markets,
and you had to get access on top of it.
228
:Which is an important point
about private markets too, right?
229
:Just being in private markets
doesn't mean you get access.
230
:You know, you, you, it, it very much
is who is the manager, what deals
231
:are they able to get you, et cetera.
232
:Um, but putting, you know, you
know, going directly to the
233
:IPO question, I think it's…
234
:I think it speaks volumes around
how big companies can get now
235
:staying in the private space.
236
:Ultimately, if you wanna raise the kind
of money that, you know, these, these big
237
:AI-based providers, and I include SpaceX,
although it's got a, an interesting, um,
238
:you know, mosaic of a business plan that-
that's not just AI, but still, you know,
239
:very much, um, in that space, then they…
240
:you do go to public markets, right?
241
:Public markets remain, at the end
of the day, you know, kind of the
242
:biggest single place that you can raise
capital from an equity perspective.
243
:And so, you know, ultimately these
companies to- to- to be able to cash out,
244
:to be able to access much bigger capital
pools, are looking at the public market.
245
:So, you know, there will be, you
know, you'll see and, and, uh,
246
:Dana D'Auria Envestnet:
indexes are grappling with this now,
247
:you know, how quickly do you put it in?
248
:Typical rules around, hey, you don't put
in a brand-new IPO that may have been
249
:created because you don't wanna put a
tiny company in because IPOs tend to
250
:do poorly in their first year, frankly.
251
:So there's some, you know,
there's, there's some good research
252
:around, uh, the, a reason to wait.
253
:But at the end of the day, these at this
point are, are truly ginormous companies
254
:that, you know, are kinda tw- twisting
or, or I guess maybe changing our
255
:definition of what it means to go public.
256
:Ryan: Yeah, that's a great point.
257
:And the part that I'm really
watching is, like you said, how
258
:the indexes are handling this.
259
:Are they gonna cha- kinda
change the game for,
260
:you know, that the rules that have
been in place for years for these?
261
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
262
:Yeah.
263
:Yeah, and I mean, and, you know,
those rules were developed for,
264
:you know, small companies, right?
265
:Coming to market, not for these, you
know, kind of well-established, uh…
266
:Although I'll say, you know,
profitability-wise, maybe still,
267
:you know, but, but, but, you know,
very well, well-established, right?
268
:And, and gi- gigantic truly companies.
269
:Massive valuations
270
:Ryan: So let's go back, uh, the private
markets and wealth management space.
271
:Like we've been talking, they're merging.
272
:The, it used to be maybe black and white.
273
:It's now gray.
274
:Um, what is driving that inclusion in
private markets and wealth portfolios?
275
:Is it, you know, just like we talked
about, the benefits, or is it because
276
:now it's more accessible through, like
you said, we'll talk more about interval
277
:funds and the different access vehicles?
278
:What's driving this, the, the inclusion
and the merging of the two, uh, sides?
279
:Dana D'Auria: I think it's both.
280
:I, I think the supply side for
sure looking for, you know, a- an
281
:alternative pool of assets, right?
282
:And so alts managers moving into
interval funds and tender offers at
283
:a ve- at a faster rate is absolutely
them seeing the opportunity to
284
:appeal to a different audience.
285
:You also have traditional managers
either buying an alts manager or putting
286
:out alternatives content themselves.
287
:So…
288
:And, and from their
perspective, it's not a new…
289
:You know, they've already been
in the wealth market, but it's an
290
:opportunity for a higher margin
product to be sold in that market.
291
:So I think there's
absolutely a supply side.
292
:But, you know, everything we've been
talking about, I think it is coming from
293
:the other side to a certain extent too.
294
:People want access, you know?
295
:They don't want to be sort of left
out and unable to, um, get into
296
:something like, uh, a SpaceX or an
Anthropic, you know, until it, until
297
:it's, uh, gigantic and going public.
298
:And so, you know, we're, there are
certainly plenty of questions, uh,
299
:requests, et cetera, from the wealth
side to us, for example, as a tech
300
:platform around what we're building, how
we're enabling access, how we're making
301
:it easier for advisors to use these
302
:Ryan: Yeah.
303
:I'm glad you brought that up about
making it easier for advisors
304
:to access private markets.
305
:It's a perfect segue because
financial advisors, their job is, uh,
306
:hard enough just staying on top of
whether it's creating a tech stack,
307
:separating themsel- distinguishing
themselves from other advisors, all
308
:the things they have to worry about.
309
:Now they have to worry about, how
do I get access to private markets?
310
:So how are financial advisors
addressing this shift to
311
:financial mar- private markets?
312
:Are they accepting it?
313
:Are there a lot of questions?
314
:Are they looking to Envestnet for help?
315
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah, I
would say all of the above.
316
:It really does depend on the advisor.
317
:I would say you have advisors who have
sort of specialized in doing this.
318
:You know, to- advisors working in
the ultra-high net worth, uh, space,
319
:or even the high net worth space,
typically are all over this, right?
320
:And they've already navigated how
to work with their clients with
321
:traditional private placement
vehicles, so they have a path for that.
322
:Uh, for them, this advent of interval
fund and tender offer and private
323
:BDC, private REIT is maybe an easier,
more streamlined way to access for
324
:cer- for parts of their client base.
325
:And so, uh, there's,
there's benefits there.
326
:But they're already very
attuned to the private market.
327
:They know how to talk about it.
328
:They know what they're looking for.
329
:I think the other side of this, though,
is that you have that whole swath of
330
:advisors who haven't used private markets
in the past, wealth managers who, you
331
:know, maybe focus more on the mass
affluent space, have some high net worth
332
:or aspire to high net worth, and who see
an opportunity to i- if not differentiate
333
:themselves, you know, certainly keep
pace with other advisors in that space.
334
:But I think it's also worth saying there's
also a whole swath of advisors, and I,
335
:I think the move into wealth is gonna
be a slow burn because you, you know, a
336
:lot of advisors are very cautious around
this too, as they should be, right?
337
:They need to think about, you know, kinda,
uh, how they're entering that space,
338
:how they're using these vehicles, who
they're using them for, uh, because, you
339
:know, there, there obviously are risks,
and I know we'll, we'll talk- we'll
340
:hit on those, uh, later in the podcast.
341
:But advisors, you know, I talk to
advisors say, "Hey, look, I've,
342
:I've been, you know, running
money for my clients for 20 years.
343
:I've never had to use
private markets before.
344
:No- you know, I don't yet have a good
reason to think I have to do it now."
345
:And so I think you're gonna have,
you're gonna have those advisors as
346
:well who, you know, are s- are gonna be,
m- uh, later movers, and that's fine.
347
:Ryan: Yeah, that's a very good point.
348
:My-- I, I'm always on the side of,
caution or, like, being a little bit more
349
:cautious in terms of doing something new.
350
:It's like, let other people do it.
351
:Let them test the system,
and then I'll, I'll follow.
352
:But I feel as if, too, like for financial
advisors, it's so competitive to
353
:distinguish themselves from others, they
kind of have to offer some of these new
354
:products in order to say, "You know what?
355
:It's more than just offering a basic
ETF where they can-- it's commoditized.
356
:No, let's offer some of these semi-liquid
funds," which Dana, I'm gonna be honest
357
:with you, I'm not a big fan of the
semi-liquid term for some of these.
358
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
359
:Yeah.
360
:Ryan: interval funds, you
mentioned them already.
361
:So let's go a little bit
more into interval funds and
362
:BDCs and tender offer funds.
363
:What do financial advisors
need to know about these funds?
364
:Yeah, maybe they are semi-liquid,
but are they liquid enough?
365
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah, I agree with you.
366
:Um, because I think
semi-liquid, it's not…
367
:You know, they're semi-liquid
because, you know, so for example,
368
:an interval fund will redeem out
5% of its holdings once a quarter.
369
:Uh, but, you know, they're for…
370
:If you're, if you're sitting in an
interval fund and you're, you need
371
:to withdraw money in a quarter where,
you know, there's not any dislocation
372
:going on, maybe you get all the
money back that quarter, right?
373
:Because it's redeeming out,
you know, 5% at the fund level.
374
:If you're trying to redeem out when
there's a dislocation, it probably
375
:goes to proration and you don't
get all of your money, you know.
376
:You get some percentage of it, right?
377
:And so it's gonna be illiquid
when the market is dislocated,
378
:when there's worries.
379
:You know, obviously we have the, um,
whole situation with private credit that's
380
:been going on where there's concerns
about, you know, just the liquidity.
381
:Not only the liquidity, but, uh,
because private credit had, you
382
:know, a material software risk and AI
was, you know, disrupting software.
383
:You had sort of this triggering event
for folks to be concerned with whether
384
:the private credit fund that they were
in was gonna be able to be solvent.
385
:And so, you know, just that cascading
kind of a, a market problem in a
386
:particular asset class sent a lot of
people running for the exits, and if
387
:everybody runs for the exits, you know,
that of course it goes to proration.
388
:Now, the vehicles with the private
credit were more private BDCs
389
:where, um, you know, there's
not necessarily a requirement.
390
:There's, you know, sort of a, an
understanding and, you know, so
391
:it, it depends on what the vehicle,
depends on the docs of the vehicle.
392
:Um, you know, for example,
like a tender offer, you are…
393
:Y- y- y- you…
394
:The…
395
:It's at the board's discretion whether
there's liquidity that quarter, right?
396
:And so, you know, there's just, um,
there's a lot of different ways that
397
:these funds can function, but to, to
hone in on your seminal point there,
398
:semi-liquid is, should be considered
illiquid unless you're willing to
399
:go back quarter after quarter after
quarter and, and wait some time, right?
400
:So it's not liquid even in the sense
of certainly, you know, within a
401
:year I can get all of my assets back.
402
:Certainly not.
403
:Ryan: Yeah, I agree, Dana, and it's--
it goes back and just adds more
404
:to the plate of financial advisor.
405
:You brought up private credit.
406
:There's been so, so issues with private
credit, maybe over the past year,
407
:a lot of conversations, is private
credit, is it a systematic issue?
408
:Is it a bigger issue there?
409
:And part of me, it's like all investing.
410
:Yeah, there's gonna be issues in different
parts, uh, different segments of markets.
411
:But personally, I think it's more of a
mismatch of, there's not the education,
412
:not enough education for retail investors
to realize these are not liquid.
413
:Even though it says they're
semi-liquid, they're not liquid.
414
:And if you're gonna invest in these,
you gotta think five, 10 years down
415
:the road, and I, I don't think there's
that education or awareness out there
416
:because maybe the term semi-liquid.
417
:Interval funds have a ticker.
418
:When I say ticker, I
think of liquid, right?
419
:And they're not.
420
:And so to me, I think that issues
with private credit's more of
421
:a mismatch and not like retail
investors really knowing that…
422
:And now we've realized how
important liquidity is for
423
:retail investors through this
424
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
425
:I, I absolutely, um, agree with you
that there's a, there's a s- there's
426
:a strong element here of just, you
know, at the end of the day, selling
427
:a product to somebody who's accustomed
to a public market experience.
428
:And, you know, no matter how many
times the advisor may say that this
429
:is the, these are the terms, and
hopefully they are doing that, right?
430
:Uh, presumably they are, but it's
just, it just, you know, it's this…
431
:It's kind of akin to when you ask
somebody their risk tolerance and
432
:how much they can afford to lose, and
then they actually start losing it
433
:and the market's crashing, and they're
like, "Get me the heck out," you know?
434
:And, and, you know, as we know, you're
selling down when you do that, so it's
435
:not a great, not a great thing to happen.
436
:So I think much like an advisor feeling
out real risk tolerance, you've gotta
437
:be able to feel out from that client
their real liquidity, or I should
438
:say illiquidity tolerance, right?
439
:Whether they're saying, "Oh, yeah, yeah,
I want access, you know, it's fine.
440
:I understand it could get locked up."
441
:Uh, do they really understand and
are they really a good candidate for
442
:Ryan: Yeah, Dana, you're exactly correct.
443
:And you really probably don't know
until it happens and you get to
444
:that point, and then, you know,
it's too late and they're selling at
445
:the worst time or need to get out.
446
:So is illiquidity, do you think,
is that the biggest risk to
447
:investing in private markets?
448
:Or are there other risks that
maybe we don't think about enough?
449
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah, illiquidity is
probably the biggest, uh, when it--
450
:when you're talking about wealth assets
because I do think people just aren't
451
:ready for that, you know, inability to
withdraw and fear, you know, watching,
452
:watching maybe, uh, valuations in the
public side go down and they can't get…
453
:You know, they feel their
money's trapped or…
454
:And/or, you know, there, there was
just a, um, bad planning, right?
455
:Or, or something happened that was
outside of the plan where they do
456
:need the money and, um, you know, they
really can't afford to keep it there.
457
:So I think that's probably
the single biggest one.
458
:Uh, but there's other serious risks.
459
:One is dispersion in returns.
460
:You know, if you're providing private
market access through these vehicles and
461
:you're thinking about the wealth audience
at large, uh, y- you know, the dispersion
462
:in returns in a y- in a public market
asset class is, uh, demonstrably lower
463
:than it is in the private markets, right?
464
:Like multiples higher, meaning, uh, if I
get the best managers in private credit,
465
:I'm going to significantly outperform
the worst managers, you know, over a
466
:given period versus in public market
credit, there will absolutely be out
467
:for performance and underperformance,
but it won't be that wide.
468
:And so people are accustomed in public
markets, wealth, wealth clients are
469
:accustomed and advisors to looking
at an asset class and saying, "Okay,
470
:here's what this asset class returns."
471
:Now, I re- recognize I'm doing some
active management here and, uh,
472
:so and in private markets, it's
certainly active management in the
473
:sense we're talking about it, right?
474
:Whether where you're getting access
to certain securities or deals, right?
475
:So, um, if you're used to the public
market experience, you might use that,
476
:that class, so to speak, number in a
different way than you can really use
477
:it in the private markets because that
number might be meaningless r- relative
478
:to, you know, the particular holding.
479
:So it just, it means there's a lot more
due diligence that has to be done on
480
:the manager, on the fund, et cetera,
uh, that, you know, to feel comfortable
481
:with what's the realistic bogey here.
482
:I mean, if you're thinking you're
gonna get, you know- Yale endowment
483
:or CalPERS return with these
vehicles, you're probably not, right?
484
:Uh, but you may be able to, know, get
a-- get fifty basis points more than
485
:in public markets and, you know, over
years, that's pretty significant, right?
486
:And so as an advisor, it's certainly
worth kinda learning about that and
487
:figuring out if it's a possibility,
uh, to get fifty, a hundred,
488
:whatever it is, basis points more.
489
:Uh, but you know, it's not a, it's
not an asset class thing where you
490
:can just pick something from that
asset class and expect to get it.
491
:The one last risk I'll say, um,
there, well, there's many risks,
492
:but the one I-- another one I'd
highli-highlight is valuation risk
493
:and just, you know, I mentioned it
before, but these are marks, right?
494
:Uh, they're not, they're not public
market, you know, determinations
495
:of what the value of something is.
496
:And I think if you're, again, if
you're a wealth client or advisor,
497
:you're just not used to that
498
:Ryan: Yeah, that's a very good point.
499
:I love that you brought up
the dispersion of returns.
500
:You're exactly right.
501
:In research I've done in public
markets, in managers, mutual funds,
502
:ETFs, over time, like, yeah, there
might be a l- wide dispersion over
503
:a year, but over five years, that
dispersion is pretty narrow, right?
504
:But in public-- in private markets,
it's a completely different game.
505
:You're exactly right, where due
diligence is so much more important.
506
:But I'm assuming conducting due
diligence on a private manager
507
:is a whole lot different than
just looking at Sharpe ratios and
508
:information ratio on a, on a public…
509
:So do you have any tips
there for financial advisors?
510
:Or what do you think are the
most important aspects financial
511
:advisors need to consider when
they're looking at different private
512
:managers, private investments?
513
:Is it one of those things, you know what?
514
:I don't have specialty in,
let's let the specialists do it?
515
:You know, any thoughts?
516
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah.
517
:Well, I do think there's something to
be said for letting a specialist do it.
518
:If you as an advisor don't have any
experience in the space, you know, for
519
:example, our Envestnet has a, a whole,
uh, interval fund investing platform.
520
:We're, we're gonna be opening up a
tender offer, private BDC, private
521
:REIT platform where you can add these
things to unified managed accounts.
522
:And, um, we have also an in-house due
diligence where we will be publishing
523
:sort of a qualitatively followed, if
you will, uh, set of, you know, kinda
524
:cohort amongst those different offerings.
525
:So I think, you know, offerings like that
where you have professional due diligence
526
:overseeing some of this is very helpful.
527
:It doesn't negate the advisor's
need to, to look at the suitability
528
:and to understand the risks.
529
:It doesn't mean that, you know, just
because something has a due diligence
530
:check mark that it means that it's gonna
outperform or anything of the sort.
531
:Uh, it's, in fact, usually the due
diligence is more about, okay, we
532
:think this is acceptable risk that
you're, not, not no risk, you know,
533
:but acceptable risk for what the,
what the asset class, uh, entails.
534
:So I think that's a definite part of it.
535
:I think, you know, there's, it's not
altogether, you know, different from
536
:publics in that you wanna look at
history, you wanna look at the manager,
537
:you wanna look at how well they've
done, what have their, know, what
538
:have other funds that they've put out
in the space done in that space, how
539
:might it be different from the private
placements given the fact that they do
540
:have liquidity constraints, you know.
541
:If they have to pay you out, they
can't be, you know, they can't
542
:necessarily, uh, have deals that
require l- much longer duration.
543
:For example, in private equity, you
see a lot of secondaries, right?
544
:Because those are lower duration,
uh, than if you're starting, you
545
:know, from the, from the get-go.
546
:So it's, it's, it's a multi-pronged
effort, and I think, you know, some of
547
:the basics that advisors are used to,
like looking at history, um, you know,
548
:kinda looking at some of the modern
portfol- portfolio theory metrics,
549
:you know, return, obviously standard
deviation, but recognizing also that
550
:in the alt space, some of the other
metrics that you maybe don't pay as
551
:much attention to, like the third and,
you know, so return first moment, you
552
:know, risk, uh, standard deviation
second moment, but if I go to the third
553
:and fourth where I'm thinking about how
fatter the tail is essentially, right?
554
:Like, what's the skew on this?
555
:What's the likelihood that I have a
really bad event versus, you know,
556
:kinda just I, I sit in the standard
histogram, which I know Zephyr, uh, is
557
:actually fantastic at, you know, kinda,
um, sorting out those kinds of metrics.
558
:So th- so those are, um,
definitely places that I would
559
:be thinking about as an advisor.
560
:Ryan: Dana, I love it, hey,
that you brought up skewness,
561
:kurtosis, all the things we love
about the return distribution
562
:and the third and fourth moments.
563
:I love it.
564
:Dana D'Auria: In private markets,
it's all the more relevant,
565
:Ryan: Yeah, but because
you're exactly right.
566
:When in-- we talk about analytics, a lot
of times that return distribu- people are
567
:like, "No, I don't wanna get into it."
568
:You know?
569
:And, and it is very important, right?
570
:And to understand it and leveraging it.
571
:Awesome.
572
:One last thing, Dana,
and then I'll let you go.
573
:Is there one final tip?
574
:We've talked a lot
during this conversation.
575
:It's been a fantastic conversation.
576
:You shared a lot of great insight.
577
:One final tip that you can share to
financial advisors who are looking to
578
:incorporate private markets or private
investments in their client portfolios
579
:Dana D'Auria: Yeah, uh
580
:I would say avail yourself of the,
of the education that's out there.
581
:There's a lot, right?
582
:There, there are a lot of ways to get up
to speed on these, and, you know, it may
583
:be counterintuitive based on, you know…
584
:Like, what I'll say is a lot
of asset managers actually have
585
:very good curriculum on this.
586
:And I say counterintuitive
because you may be thinking,
587
:"Well, that'll be a sales pitch."
588
:But really, a lot of these asset
managers have actually put out pretty
589
:unbiased and just, um, you know,
academic sort of work or, or, um,
590
:I'll, I'll say modules and curriculums
to help get people up to speed.
591
:The- they'll…
592
:Y- you could absolutely get them to
give you the sales pitch, but they
593
:also have a lot of content that's not
a sales pitch because they too have to
594
:make sure that you actually understand
what you're getting here, right?
595
:And, and, you know, so…
596
:And I say that because maybe you don't
wanna pay for a Kaya or you don't wanna
597
:go, you know, full bore into, you know,
one of those types of, um, instruments.
598
:You can certainly, for free, get started
with one of these asset managers that
599
:are gonna te- teach you all the basics.
600
:They're gonna get, you know, a fair amount
of information across about just what are
601
:these different asset classes, how do they
work, how do the vehicles work, et cetera.
602
:And then you can decide, "Okay,
do I wanna take the next step?"
603
:Most of the wealth managers will also
require you, before you buy one of
604
:these instruments, to get through,
um, a certain level of education,
605
:may require you to have very specific
education around the individual
606
:vehicle, even in the semi-liquid space.
607
:You know, certainly for
private placements, but even
608
:in the semi-liquid space.
609
:Um, there's some great books.
610
:Um, Tony Davidow over at Franklin
Templeton has a really great book
611
:on private markets that I recommend.
612
:Again, you know, he's sorta…
613
:It- it…
614
:There's not a sales pitch there, right?
615
:It's really just what are these good
for, what is the risk of these, how do I
616
:think about these in a portfolio context.
617
:So, you know, lots of education available.
618
:Avail yourself of it.
619
:Ryan: Dana, I think that's fantastic.
620
:I'm big on education.
621
:I think that's a great way of wrapping
this up, and probably what's most
622
:important is the awareness, education.
623
:It might come to a shock to some people,
I do do some research before conversations
624
:I have, and you are exactly right.
625
:There's a lot of firms out
there that do a lot of great
626
:content that's not a sales pitch.
627
:I leverage them a lot, so fantastic stuff.
628
:Dana, thank you so much for
coming on the show again.
629
:I love having you on, all the insights
you bring, always fun conversations.
630
:Where can our audience get more
information about Investnet?
631
:Dana D'Auria: Uh, so right on our
site and certainly, uh, advisors,
632
:I, I welcome you to reach out.
633
:We have a whole team, you
know, here at Envestnet.
634
:You can go through the
website and get connected.
635
:Tell you everything you ever wanted
to know about how to access these
636
:tools, how to build a portfolio
with these tools, et cetera
637
:Ryan: Awesome.
638
:Thank you, Dana, and thank you everyone
for listening to this episode of
639
:Zephyr's Adjusted for Risk podcast.
640
:You can watch all of our other episodes
on the Zephyr YouTube channel and
641
:Spotify, as well as all the other
locations you find your podcasts on.
642
:Also, be sure to like and
subscribe to those channels and
643
:give us a follow on LinkedIn.
644
:Thank you very much, and have
a great rest of your week