Artwork for podcast Women in The Coaching Arena
183 | The Lead Magnet Strategy Every Coach Needs to Build Their Email List
Episode 18320th August 2026 • Women in The Coaching Arena • Joanna Lott
00:00:00 00:16:17

Share Episode

Shownotes

If social media disappeared tomorrow, would you still have a way to reach your ideal clients? In this episode, Jo shares why building an email list is one of the smartest investments you can make in your coaching business, and exactly how to get started, even if you have zero subscribers today.

Timestamps:

00:00 - Why Every Coach Needs an Email List

01:35 - Create Your First Lead Magnet

04:00 - Solve One Small Problem

06:00 - The 5 Welcome Emails

08:45 - Your Weekly Newsletter

11:20 - Mistakes to Avoid

13:10 - Build an Email List That Lasts

“Social media is rented land. Your email list is all yours.” - Jo Lott

Create one simple lead magnet this week. It doesn’t have to be perfect - it simply has to help one person take one meaningful step forward.

Join The Honest Edit, my weekly newsletter for coaches

Useful Links

Learn about The Business of Coaching programme

Signature Solution Course

Download the Free Digital version of Coaches' Planner (NEW edition 2026)

Free Essential AI Toolkit – 2 Must-Have Prompts for Coaches

How to secure more coaching clients' free training

Download the 12 ways to get clients now

Connect with Jo on LinkedIn

Rate and Review the Podcast

If you found this episode of Women in the Coaching Arena helpful, please do rate and review it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.

If you’re kind enough to leave a review, please do let Jo know so she can say thank you. You can always reach her at: [email protected]

Enjoyed This Episode?

Don’t Miss the Next One! Hit subscribe on your favourite podcast app to be notified each time a new episode of Women in the Coaching Arena.

Transcripts

Speaker:

Social media is rented land.

2

:

You don't own it, the algorithm

changes, your reach drops, and there's

3

:

absolutely nothing you can do about it.

4

:

I have experienced this firsthand.

5

:

Posts that would've done brilliantly

a year ago just don't do well anymore.

6

:

But your email list is all yours.

7

:

No one can take it away from you.

8

:

There is no algorithm for

email, no platform update

9

:

that's gonna mess up your life.

10

:

My list is around 2,300 people at

the moment, and I still get a huge

11

:

proportion of my clients from email.

12

:

Welcome back to Women

in the Coaching Arena.

13

:

I am Jo Lott.

14

:

Today, we are talking about how to

build an email list, even if right now

15

:

you have zero subscribers and the whole

tech thing feels a bit overwhelming.

16

:

I remember that feeling really

well, and I sent my husband and

17

:

kids away for three full days so I

could do my first email list build.

18

:

It genuinely took from 7:00 AM to

:

19

:

So even though I put it off for a little

while, it really is worth your time.

20

:

So let me walk you through

exactly how to do this.

21

:

To build an email list, you need

a reason for people to join.

22

:

Generally, people won't sign up because

you say, "Subscribe to my newsletter."

23

:

You really need to be offering

them something valuable in

24

:

exchange for their email address.

25

:

You may know this as a lead magnet.

26

:

So I, for example, have a coach's planner.

27

:

I have another one called

12 Ways to Get Clients.

28

:

I have a quiz.

29

:

I have so many other lead magnets,

which is a way of inviting

30

:

people to step towards you.

31

:

Often, the simplest lead

magnet really works.

32

:

There are three types of lead magnets

that work really well for coaches.

33

:

So one is a short guide or checklist,

something like five steps to landing

34

:

your next job, something that people

can actually use straight away A lot

35

:

of the people in my program will do

something that's far too big picture,

36

:

and then I always give the feedback,

we need to be micro-specific here.

37

:

Solve one tiny, tiny problem versus,

you know, how to find your purpose or

38

:

something that's so wide that people just

can't get that quick win quick enough.

39

:

One of my clients, Claire, created

a new lead magnet and got four

40

:

new signups in her very first

week, not thousands, but four.

41

:

So here the message is appreciate

every single subscriber.

42

:

Don't think, "I'll start writing

to my list weekly when I have

43

:

hundreds of subscribers."

44

:

Treat these people like gold and

treat them like you will if you had

45

:

thousands of people on your list.

46

:

A mini training or video can really

work well because it can also

47

:

double up as a deep nurture tool.

48

:

So I, for example, have a 15-minute

webinar that people can watch, so then

49

:

they can make progress in their business

and also get to know me in the process.

50

:

Create something that's genuinely

useful that will give people a

51

:

taste of you and how you coach.

52

:

The last one I will mention here that

my clients have recently become hugely

53

:

successful with are using AI bots as

lead magnets In my program, I have a

54

:

training and a specific bot that will

help you create your own custom bot.

55

:

So one of my clients, Andy, has done

really well, got his out immediately,

56

:

and the best thing is it will help

people maybe identify their strengths

57

:

or their next career move, but it will

also say, "If you're really struggling

58

:

with this, book a call with Andy.

59

:

Here's his Calendly link."

60

:

So it's out there working

for him all of the time.

61

:

But here is the key with any lead

magnet, a micro problem beats broad.

62

:

So five steps to landing your

first coaching client is so much

63

:

better than everything you need

to know about a coaching business.

64

:

I learnt this firsthand because my first

ever lead magnet was called 10 Essential

65

:

Steps to Start a Coaching Business.

66

:

Obviously, everybody needs to

know the steps, or so I thought.

67

:

I got a trickle of

subscribers over a year or so.

68

:

Then I did a different lead magnet,

which was called 12 Ways to Get Clients

69

:

Now, Steps that You Can Take in Less

Than 15 Minutes, and I got an absolute

70

:

flurry of subscribers because everyone

wants a quick win, and we as coaches

71

:

want to help people have the full

big transformation, but the way of

72

:

the world is we just want quick wins.

73

:

So give them that quick win,

and then they might come to you

74

:

for the bigger transformation.

75

:

So please don't overthink

this lead magnet thing.

76

:

First lead magnet can

be a simple Google Doc.

77

:

It doesn't need to be perfectly

designed or professional, but

78

:

the value is in the content.

79

:

Just get something out there and

make it pretty sometime later.

80

:

Right, so you have your lead

magnet Now you need people to

81

:

actually find it and sign up.

82

:

There are three main places for this.

83

:

Firstly, your social media, so

at the bottom of your posts or

84

:

in the comments, try and bring

people towards your lead magnet.

85

:

Not every post, because maybe that would

be annoying, but regularly, consistently.

86

:

I'm talking several times a week here.

87

:

In your LinkedIn featured

section is another great way.

88

:

You can directly link to a link, so don't

choose post here, choose link, and people

89

:

will directly go to your lead magnet link.

90

:

Finally, speaking, networking,

podcasts, and anything else

91

:

you're doing, essentially.

92

:

So at the end of your talk or

whatever it is you're doing, then

93

:

try and think about what lead

magnet would be a perfect next step.

94

:

Here are the five emails that

every new subscriber should get.

95

:

Once someone signs up, you have

about 48 hours where they are most

96

:

interested in you, most engaged, and

most likely to read what you send.

97

:

So you need a welcome sequence, which is a

series of emails that go out automatically

98

:

over the first couple of weeks.

99

:

Here's what I would include.

100

:

So email one is the welcome.

101

:

Send it immediately with their

gift, their lead magnet, whatever

102

:

it is they signed up for.

103

:

Tell them about you.

104

:

Tell them what to expect.

105

:

Keep it warm and keep it short.

106

:

Email two is your story, why you.

107

:

And in this one, the idea

is to repel or rally.

108

:

So feel free to share

your actual opinions.

109

:

If they're your type of person,

they will stay on your list.

110

:

If they aren't your type of

person, they will unsubscribe,

111

:

and that is what we want.

112

:

The more you try and keep everybody

happy, the less likely it is that you

113

:

will connect with your actual people.

114

:

Email three is your best piece of content.

115

:

For example, I have recently weaved

in my top-rated blog post, which is

116

:

called How to Start a Coaching Business,

because it's number one on Google,

117

:

so people obviously find it valuable.

118

:

So it was a bit crazy that I hadn't

really put that in my emails when it

119

:

is my best piece of content out there.

120

:

It helps people to think, "Okay,

she really knows her stuff and

121

:

knows how to break it down for me."

122

:

Email four, let's talk proof now, so

share a client story or testimonial.

123

:

Feel free to show a real transformation.

124

:

It doesn't always need to

be the big, shiny kind.

125

:

Sometimes people want a

believable transformation.

126

:

Email five is your invitation, so

tell them how they can work with you.

127

:

Don't avoid this step.

128

:

If they are on your list, they

probably have the problem that you

129

:

solve, so it's your duty to let

them know how you can help them.

130

:

So they are the basis of

your nurture sequence.

131

:

And honestly, you never know when the

right person is going to come along.

132

:

One of my favorite stories is Melissa.

133

:

She found me, signed up, received my

welcome sequence, and bought on email two.

134

:

That doesn't happen often, so don't

think you can just do these five

135

:

emails and everyone will sign up.

136

:

Just know that they are prime to talk

to people that are ready to buy now.

137

:

But most people aren't ready

to buy now, so don't forget to

138

:

actually continue to nurture your

list every single week for years.

139

:

I know that's harsh, but it's reality,

and I've been emailing my list

140

:

every week for around six years now.

141

:

Why your newsletter

doesn't have to be perfect.

142

:

So I send out the Honest Edit every

single week, and I'll be honest, it took

143

:

me years of emailing consistently before

I even gave my newsletter a proper name.

144

:

I did this in the last nine months or so.

145

:

I was always a bit envious when I'd

receive someone else's newsletter with

146

:

a lovely name and a clear identity,

but it took me a really long time to

147

:

figure out what I wanted mine to be.

148

:

So if you haven't named yours

yet, you're feeling overwhelmed

149

:

by the whole thing, that's fine.

150

:

Just start now and get perfect later.

151

:

So what do you actually

write, you may be asking?

152

:

Here's a simple approach.

153

:

One useful thing, maybe an insight,

a framework, something that come

154

:

up in your coaching sessions.

155

:

Ideally, something that

they can actually use.

156

:

The idea in all of our marketing

is that people just start slowly,

157

:

slowly improving their problem.

158

:

So much so, they start thinking maybe

this thing could work out for me.

159

:

So for example, if they're a leader

and you start sharing how to have a

160

:

difficult conversation, and they try

it and it works, then instead of them

161

:

being less likely to buy from you, they

actually think, "Wow, I actually did

162

:

that, and it made a big difference.

163

:

What else could they help me with?"

164

:

So the idea is to help your ideal

client take tiny, tiny steps

165

:

up that staircase towards you.

166

:

One personal thing you could share

in your newsletter is something

167

:

that's going on in your world.

168

:

I think with AI now, we're all

desperately craving real life, so

169

:

something that makes that person know

that this is a real email that you've

170

:

written and you are a real human

being, not just a name in their inbox.

171

:

Finally, do include your next

step, so an invitation to hit

172

:

reply is always a good one.

173

:

If you are wanting to lead them

somewhere else, like your website or your

174

:

podcast or your workshop, then do that.

175

:

Even when you think no one's reading

and there's hardly anyone on your list,

176

:

and actually use this to your advantage.

177

:

The best thing about having a really

small list is that you can actually

178

:

personally email them, so you can

get their name and manually send a

179

:

welcome email as well if you wanted to.

180

:

So feel free with it whilst we

set the sequence up so you have

181

:

some sort of automated system.

182

:

Really just be creative and know

you can keep in touch with these

183

:

people in all sorts of ways.

184

:

So let's tackle quickly

what might get in the way.

185

:

So I don't know what to write is

something I hear about all the

186

:

time, and I've covered that here.

187

:

Write about things you're annoyed

about, something that happened this

188

:

week, maybe a mistake that you made.

189

:

You will never run out of material

if you're constantly asking yourself,

190

:

"What did I learn this week?"

191

:

Next up is nobody will sign up.

192

:

Start with those you know,

maybe your former clients.

193

:

Send your lead magnet to

them, your existing contacts.

194

:

I personally send mine to new LinkedIn

connections as well in a really nice way,

195

:

and that depends on what sort of lead

magnet you have as to whether you can

196

:

carry that off without looking pushy.

197

:

But I genuinely believe my

planner is super useful, so I

198

:

have no qualms in sharing it.

199

:

And just know your first 50 subscribers

will be likely people that already know

200

:

you, and that is brilliant because they

are the most likely to become clients.

201

:

The final thing I hear often

is, "I don't want to be one of

202

:

those annoying people emailing."

203

:

If they signed up That means they

want to hear from you, so you

204

:

are not annoying them, you are

serving them and providing value.

205

:

And if somebody unsubscribes,

that's actually great because they

206

:

weren't your person to begin with.

207

:

Your list will get more focused,

which is exactly what you want.

208

:

So one thing you can do after

today's episode is create your first

209

:

lead magnet, or if you have one

already, review it and just see it

210

:

from that person who signs up eyes.

211

:

I looked at a client's lead

magnet yesterday, and I'm probably

212

:

her ideal client, like I'm

really interested in her work.

213

:

But her lead magnet was so complex that

despite me trying to read it to give

214

:

her feedback, often I just couldn't read

it because it was a really long, maybe

215

:

six-page article, a bit like a book.

216

:

And when I've just signed up for a

quick lead magnet, I want a quick win.

217

:

I'm not in a place where I can sit down

for 30 minutes and read an article.

218

:

So really do think about how you can keep

it simple and give people a quick win.

219

:

The tech is a bit more of a minefield.

220

:

In my program, I provide a pre-built

funnel template, so you have the sign-up

221

:

page, thank you page, and the emails

already attached in a tech platform.

222

:

So that helps people

get this over the line.

223

:

But even with that, it does

take head space for the tech,

224

:

and know that that's normal.

225

:

But once it's done, it will

continue to work for you for years.

226

:

It's one of those things that you feel

like never doing, and in six months' time,

227

:

you will realize you've built something

incredibly powerful, a direct line to

228

:

people who have actually opted in and

said that they want to hear from you.

229

:

That is worth more than

10,000 Instagram followers.

230

:

If you are not on my email list yet,

I send out the Honest Edit every

231

:

single week with practical advice

for building your coaching business.

232

:

I will share the link in the

description, and I look forward

233

:

to seeing you over there.

234

:

So see you next week, and like I

always say, trust yourself, believe

235

:

in yourself, and be the wise gardener

who keeps on watering the seed.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube