Artwork for podcast The Future Herd
7: Leadership in a Volatile World with Tyler McCann
Episode 72nd March 2026 • The Future Herd • Metaviews Media Management Ltd.
00:00:00 01:03:18

Share Episode

Shownotes

Guest: Tyler McCann, Managing Director, Canadian Agri-Food Policy Institute (CAPI)

Global trade is shifting. Geopolitics is intruding into supply chains. Food is no longer just food — it is leverage, resilience, and power.

In this episode of Future Herd, Jesse Hirsh sits down with Tyler McCann, Managing Director of the Canadian Agri-Food Policy Institute (CAPI), to explore what leadership looks like in a world where stability can no longer be assumed.

Together they examine:

  1. Why the global context for Canadian agriculture has fundamentally changed
  2. The discipline of focus in a sector overwhelmed by issues
  3. How policy actually moves — and why convening matters
  4. The cultural tendency toward incrementalism in Canadian agri-food governance
  5. Why diversity of participation strengthens policy outcomes
  6. The difference between a commodity sector and a strategic one
  7. The urgent need to build domestic value-added capacity

Tyler draws on his experience inside federal government and now at CAPI to explain how coalitions form, how priorities get chosen, and where the real leverage points exist in shaping Canada’s agri-food future.

At the heart of the conversation is a simple but consequential question:

Does Canada treat agri-food as a strategic sector — or as a commodity engine navigating price cycles?

In an era of geopolitical volatility, that distinction matters.

About the Guest

Tyler McCann is the Managing Director of the Canadian Agri-Food Policy Institute (CAPI), an independent, non-partisan organization dedicated to advancing policy solutions for Canada’s agri-food system. He previously served in senior advisory roles within the federal government and operates a farm in western Quebec.

About Future Herd

Future Herd is a podcast exploring leadership, strategy, and structural change across Canada’s agri-food sector. We focus on systems, policy, innovation, and the people shaping the future of food.

If this conversation resonates, share it within your network and continue the discussion inside your organization. The future of Canadian agri-food will not arrive on its own — it will be organized.

Transcripts

Jesse Hirsh:

Hi, I'm Jesse Hirsh and welcome to the Future Herd.

Jesse Hirsh:

On today's episode, I'm joined by Tyler McCann, managing director of the Canadian

Jesse Hirsh:

AgriFood Policy Institute, CAPI, and this conversation lands at a charged moment.

Jesse Hirsh:

Global trade rules are shifting.

Jesse Hirsh:

Alliances feel less stable.

Jesse Hirsh:

Food is no longer just food.

Jesse Hirsh:

It's leverage, it's security, it's diplomacy, it's risk.

Jesse Hirsh:

The ground under Canadian agriculture isn't just moving economically,

Jesse Hirsh:

it's moving geopolitically.

Jesse Hirsh:

So the question isn't simply how we grow more or export more.

Jesse Hirsh:

The question is, do we understand the world we're stepping into?

Jesse Hirsh:

Tyler brings a rare vantage point to that question.

Jesse Hirsh:

He's worked inside federal decision making.

Jesse Hirsh:

He now convenes policy dialogues across the sector, and he speaks with the kind of

Jesse Hirsh:

clarity that comes from knowing how power actually operates, where ambition collides

Jesse Hirsh:

with bureaucracy, where ideas stall and where they unexpectedly take root.

Jesse Hirsh:

In this conversation, we wrestle with what it really means to think

Jesse Hirsh:

about the future right now, not as a slogan, as a discipline.

Jesse Hirsh:

How do you choose what matters when the list of urgent issues keeps expanding?

Jesse Hirsh:

How do you create focus in a sector that's perpetually reacting?

Jesse Hirsh:

And how do you push for policy imagination in a culture that often rewards caution.

Jesse Hirsh:

We talk about coalition building, about the temptation to stay comfortable about

Jesse Hirsh:

whether Canada is seizing this trade moment or sleepwalking through it and

Jesse Hirsh:

beneath it all is a deeper tension.

Jesse Hirsh:

Whether AgriFood sees itself as a strategic sector in a volatile world,

Jesse Hirsh:

or just another industry negotiating the next incremental change.

Jesse Hirsh:

If food is power, and indeed my friends, it is, then policy is the architecture of

Jesse Hirsh:

that power and the architecture we build now will shape far more than just margins.

Jesse Hirsh:

Here's my conversation with Tyler McCann.

Jesse Hirsh:

I.

Jesse Hirsh:

Hello Tyler.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, welcome to the herd.

Tyler McCann:

It is great to be with you, Jesse.

Jesse Hirsh:

Now, uh, you're actually the first guest, uh, we're having here in the

Jesse Hirsh:

podcast who's kind of out of our pilot phase in that all the episodes we've put

Jesse Hirsh:

together so far we're kind of still before we really got our legs and got moving.

Jesse Hirsh:

So, uh, I'm really excited today both to talk to you about, uh, the role that

Jesse Hirsh:

you have taken on within the sector.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, the value, uh, use.

Jesse Hirsh:

C in policy and policy engagement.

Jesse Hirsh:

Um, but in particular, I like starting with the first question of, you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

what does the future mean to you?

Jesse Hirsh:

Right.

Jesse Hirsh:

Do you think about the future?

Jesse Hirsh:

When I say, you know, Hey, what's the future?

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, what comes to mind?

Tyler McCann:

Uh,

Tyler McCann:

what comes to mind just.

Tyler McCann:

that the future's different.

Tyler McCann:

And that we're not ready for it.

Tyler McCann:

And a big part of what I think about every day is I think Canadian agriculture

Tyler McCann:

and foods had a really good run.

Tyler McCann:

You know, we've had, especially the last 20 years, but arguably the last 120

Tyler McCann:

years, um, have been really positive.

Tyler McCann:

The

Tyler McCann:

The foundation fundamental,

Tyler McCann:

been really strong and by and large, everyone that is kind around the system

Tyler McCann:

has, has been able to benefit from that.

Tyler McCann:

consumers.

Tyler McCann:

Processors, exporters, but we've had a pretty, pretty good go.

Tyler McCann:

But so many

Jesse Hirsh:

fundamental.

Tyler McCann:

that have been so critical to the success of the sector are a

Tyler McCann:

lot shakier than they used to be.

Tyler McCann:

And so I think it's important, I kind of understand that, to think about that

Tyler McCann:

and to think about we should be changing today the future that's coming tomorrow.

Jesse Hirsh:

Right on.

Jesse Hirsh:

And you know, I, I'm being a bit coy with the concept of leader in the

Jesse Hirsh:

sense that anyone who comes onto the podcast is in my definition of leader.

Jesse Hirsh:

But you just expressed an interesting application of leadership right there

Jesse Hirsh:

in which not only did you acknowledge the uncertainty that we're facing in

Jesse Hirsh:

the future, but yeah, quite frankly, I think you expressed a kind of courage.

Jesse Hirsh:

That, that we need to be addressing it.

Jesse Hirsh:

And I, I wanna unpack that over the course of our conversation, but I

Jesse Hirsh:

have another kind of foundational, uh, question I want to throw at you, which

Jesse Hirsh:

is what drew you to the policy world.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and while that may seem kind of self-evident to you.

Jesse Hirsh:

When I encounter a lot of farmers, a lot of food people, a lot of

Jesse Hirsh:

agricultural people, people, I feel they neglect policy.

Jesse Hirsh:

I see.

Jesse Hirsh:

They sort of see it as something for experts and not for them.

Jesse Hirsh:

And part of what I want to do today is kind of infect people with the

Jesse Hirsh:

joy of policy and, and recognize that it's actually a really fun.

Jesse Hirsh:

Space to be playing in.

Jesse Hirsh:

So what's your origin story?

Jesse Hirsh:

What's your lore?

Jesse Hirsh:

How, how, how did the world of policy, uh, attract not only your attention,

Jesse Hirsh:

but I think also your passion?

Tyler McCann:

Yeah, it's, uh, I'm not sure that there's a great compelling

Tyler McCann:

origin story, but I, so I started off, uh, working as a political staffer.

Tyler McCann:

That was my first actually, maybe, maybe it'll be, uh, take a, a couple steps

Tyler McCann:

back because I think it's, there's some.

Tyler McCann:

Context that that matters.

Tyler McCann:

Um, kind of grew

Jesse Hirsh:

Grew up,

Tyler McCann:

a beef farm in Western Quebec.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, we now, my wife and I have, um, farm, uh.

Tyler McCann:

10 minutes from where I grew up.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, I did

Jesse Hirsh:

I did my in

Tyler McCann:

in

Jesse Hirsh:

agricul.

Tyler McCann:

management and technology at McDonald College was gonna be an ag

Tyler McCann:

banker that seemed to be the career.

Tyler McCann:

Didn't necessarily wanna be a farmer, wanted to be around the

Tyler McCann:

sector, wanted to do those things.

Tyler McCann:

Um, so the plan was basically do do my diploma.

Tyler McCann:

Um, had a great time at McDonald College doing that.

Tyler McCann:

Um, then started a degree in ag economics about halfway through

Tyler McCann:

my first semester in Iowa went.

Tyler McCann:

This is not for me.

Tyler McCann:

I was not doing well in my science classes and my math class, my statistics

Tyler McCann:

class, and I was taking a global food politics class and I went, man,

Tyler McCann:

this politics stuff is a lot more interesting than all of this stuff.

Tyler McCann:

applied

Jesse Hirsh:

I,

Tyler McCann:

a political science degree and I applied

Tyler McCann:

to do the University of Ottawa,

Jesse Hirsh:

and

Tyler McCann:

it

Jesse Hirsh:

it was at the time

Tyler McCann:

so

Jesse Hirsh:

of that

Tyler McCann:

in the fall of 2005.

Tyler McCann:

There was no

Jesse Hirsh:

election

Tyler McCann:

The conservative government was elected.

Tyler McCann:

I was interested in conservative

Jesse Hirsh:

politics

Tyler McCann:

my local member of Parliament

Jesse Hirsh:

elected.

Tyler McCann:

transport Minister.

Tyler McCann:

So the summer of 2006, I was hired as a, um.

Tyler McCann:

Summer student in the Transport Minister's office.

Tyler McCann:

Um, so that was my kind of exposure to life and government for the first time.

Tyler McCann:

So I did that for the summer.

Tyler McCann:

I worked part-time then in the, in the next kind of school year,

Tyler McCann:

and then went back to working, uh, as the following summer.

Tyler McCann:

Sorry, that was 2006, 2007.

Tyler McCann:

Summer, I worked again as a student in the transport minister's office.

Tyler McCann:

That fall, that August there was a cabinet shuffle.

Tyler McCann:

Jerry Ritz was appointed agriculture minister.

Tyler McCann:

He needed staff.

Tyler McCann:

I said in the office.

Tyler McCann:

Do you know if they're looking for somebody, I would love to go do that.

Tyler McCann:

Um, and, uh, had a kind of very quick kind of process.

Tyler McCann:

Got offered a job, so I was supposed to go back to doing my bachelor's,

Tyler McCann:

uh, degree that Tuesday after Labor Day, and I started working for

Tyler McCann:

the Agriculture Minister instead.

Jesse Hirsh:

Right on.

Tyler McCann:

that was.

Tyler McCann:

Kind of the life changing moment for me was getting to go work for

Tyler McCann:

the federal agriculture minister.

Tyler McCann:

was more interested in the politics part

Jesse Hirsh:

Part of

Tyler McCann:

but uh, also interested in the

Jesse Hirsh:

agriculture.

Jesse Hirsh:

Of

Tyler McCann:

And it turns out of the

Jesse Hirsh:

Agriculture part.

Tyler McCann:

Politics of that context is actually the policy space.

Tyler McCann:

And that is kind of what got me down the road.

Tyler McCann:

I, I spent some time working for the natural resources minister, but for,

Tyler McCann:

uh, I guess would've been seven years I worked for the agriculture minister

Tyler McCann:

federally and, uh, that got me to

Jesse Hirsh:

Where I'm today.

Jesse Hirsh:

And do you miss the politics because, uh, I, it sounds to me as if what

Jesse Hirsh:

you're arguing, correct me if I'm wrong.

Jesse Hirsh:

That what makes agricultural policy unique is it has impact.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause there is a lot of the policy world, which can be abstract, can be

Jesse Hirsh:

theoretical, can be uh, you know, quite frankly when you look at the AI policy

Jesse Hirsh:

right now, highly speculative, but agricultural policy really does seem to

Jesse Hirsh:

impact real communities and real people.

Jesse Hirsh:

Is that what keeps you in it?

Tyler McCann:

Uh,

Jesse Hirsh:

this

Tyler McCann:

partly,

Jesse Hirsh:

partly and, and certainly,

Tyler McCann:

um, getting

Jesse Hirsh:

getting to work for the

Tyler McCann:

minister.

Tyler McCann:

The, the federal minister was, I often joke that like my problem,

Tyler McCann:

I've been cursed because the first job I had was the best job I've had.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, it was a chance to really have impact and that ability to have impact

Tyler McCann:

and influence decisions and outcomes has been really important for me ever since.

Tyler McCann:

Um,

Jesse Hirsh:

but.

Tyler McCann:

You know, I think that there's this space where, where policy

Tyler McCann:

is often a, a dirty word I was, was at, uh, earlier this week, uh, the Canadian

Tyler McCann:

Federation of Agriculture annual meeting, and somebody made a comment at one point

Tyler McCann:

that they said that they wanted less government intervention in the sector.

Tyler McCann:

And I think

Jesse Hirsh:

I think that's probably so

Tyler McCann:

of people that would listen would go, yeah, that makes sense.

Tyler McCann:

We want less government intervention in the sector.

Tyler McCann:

problem

Jesse Hirsh:

is

Tyler McCann:

that actually.

Jesse Hirsh:

actually

Tyler McCann:

I

Jesse Hirsh:

I don't.

Tyler McCann:

true because what you want is more government

Tyler McCann:

investment in the sector.

Tyler McCann:

What you want is more government.

Tyler McCann:

governments closed science sites.

Tyler McCann:

I bet people would like those science sites back open again.

Tyler McCann:

When the federal government is investing in r and d, they are

Tyler McCann:

intervening in the sector when they are

Jesse Hirsh:

Are regulating or.

Tyler McCann:

or keeping markets open abroad for Canadian exporters.

Tyler McCann:

That is regulating the intervening in the sector.

Tyler McCann:

And so I think when I think about kind of the policy world, I think about.

Tyler McCann:

of those positive opportunities and the positive impact that governments

Tyler McCann:

can have if it's done right.

Tyler McCann:

Um, as well as all of the negative things that kind of, the typical

Tyler McCann:

kind of, when we, when we talk about intervention is a dirty word, know what

Tyler McCann:

people have in mind, but, but it is,

Jesse Hirsh:

It's hard to think about,

Tyler McCann:

things that happen on farms across this country that

Jesse Hirsh:

don't.

Tyler McCann:

a direct kind of policy impact.

Tyler McCann:

You know, it, it, it's not like a policymaker.

Tyler McCann:

Tilling the field.

Tyler McCann:

if you think about the policy landscape around land use policy, and

Tyler McCann:

if you think about what that means in Ontario today, whether or not

Tyler McCann:

that field is farmer's field or is a condo tower is, is a policy decision.

Tyler McCann:

And so, you know, I think of that, that understanding of how critical it is, how

Tyler McCann:

much of an impact it is, how much of an influence it can have in, in the success

Tyler McCann:

or failure of farmers, is something that, yeah, really I find super interesting

Tyler McCann:

and engaging and keeps me going.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I think you just hit it on the nose.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause you're, you're absolutely right that, unfortunately not just

Jesse Hirsh:

in agriculture, I think right across society policy has gotten a bad rap

Jesse Hirsh:

that people think it's bad when instead it's just a vehicle to what you want.

Jesse Hirsh:

Like if you want less regulation, that's a policy, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

If you want more regulation, that's a policy.

Jesse Hirsh:

A, a friend of mine, vast Bednar, has this great concept of regs to riches,

Jesse Hirsh:

that regulations lead to riches.

Jesse Hirsh:

And I think the agricultural sector, more so than many others, benefits from

Jesse Hirsh:

good policy and at the same time can be disproportionately hurt by bad policy.

Jesse Hirsh:

So I, I'm curious both in the context of you kind of being on the inside

Jesse Hirsh:

of government and now, you know, kind of being, uh, within the broader, uh,

Jesse Hirsh:

ecosphere of ideas and, and engagement.

Jesse Hirsh:

How have things changed?

Jesse Hirsh:

Like how have engagement levels changed and, and how do you see, uh,

Jesse Hirsh:

organizations, whether associations who are there to try to mobilize this opinion

Jesse Hirsh:

or government itself and ministry itself?

Jesse Hirsh:

How are they responding to this changing policy environment?

Tyler McCann:

It is far more complex than it used to be.

Tyler McCann:

And so if

Jesse Hirsh:

So if you look at

Tyler McCann:

I'm not gonna have the stats right, but, uh, the federal,

Tyler McCann:

when, uh, somebody lobbies the federal government, they have to record it

Tyler McCann:

in the lobby registry, and you have to kinda indicate what it's for.

Tyler McCann:

And if you go

Jesse Hirsh:

go back to.

Tyler McCann:

in as a political staffer.

Tyler McCann:

The number of people that were registering that they were lobbying on agriculture

Tyler McCann:

issues, that they were communicating with the government about agriculture

Tyler McCann:

issues to kind of where it was.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, years later there was about a threefold increase in the number of

Tyler McCann:

people that were registering, uh, communications on agriculture issues.

Tyler McCann:

That's not, because there are three times more farmers that

Tyler McCann:

are talking to governments.

Tyler McCann:

It's because there are many different voices that are engaging on these issues.

Tyler McCann:

Right.

Tyler McCann:

And the pressures the governments face are very different.

Tyler McCann:

And yes, on one hand we've got this reality of declining farm demographics.

Tyler McCann:

Um.

Tyler McCann:

Especially when you look at the population growth that we, we've

Tyler McCann:

seen, like the Canadian farm population is, is quite tiny.

Tyler McCann:

so on one hand we see that,

Jesse Hirsh:

But there are people.

Tyler McCann:

far more interested and far more engaged on food issues

Tyler McCann:

and the pressures on governments to respond to agriculture and food issues

Tyler McCann:

today is very different than it was, you know, up in, in advanced 2015

Tyler McCann:

whenever I was in, in government.

Tyler McCann:

And I think that there's, that, a structural change in that,

Tyler McCann:

that we haven't, that the sector hasn't, hasn't gotten used to.

Tyler McCann:

There was a time when.

Tyler McCann:

When a

Jesse Hirsh:

Farmers

Tyler McCann:

farm groups in this country had an issue, they

Tyler McCann:

could fly to Ottawa, talk to the

Jesse Hirsh:

agri.

Tyler McCann:

talk to the senior leaders in the Ag department, say, here's

Jesse Hirsh:

Here's what problem

Tyler McCann:

And the ag minister in the department would go away

Tyler McCann:

and they'd fix the problem.

Tyler McCann:

It doesn't

Jesse Hirsh:

doesn't work that way.

Tyler McCann:

because there's a lot

Jesse Hirsh:

People

Tyler McCann:

a lot of different perspectives on what the problems really

Tyler McCann:

are, what the solutions are, and what the role of government is in, in fixing them.

Tyler McCann:

And

Jesse Hirsh:

not.

Tyler McCann:

that, I think the reality is there's, you know, there's a lot of really

Tyler McCann:

good, smart people inside government, but their ability to understand.

Tyler McCann:

A complex sector, uh, a difficult dynamic sector like agriculture and food,

Tyler McCann:

ability to understand that and develop solutions isn't the same as it used to be.

Tyler McCann:

So not only do you kind of face this kind of broader conglomeration of voices

Tyler McCann:

that are talking about agriculture issues, you also need to come to the

Tyler McCann:

table with better solutions than what we've, uh, had to in the past because

Tyler McCann:

the ability of government to of come up with the solutions themselves

Tyler McCann:

isn't the same as it used to be.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, and, and to what extent is speed or or responsiveness as an

Jesse Hirsh:

application of speed part of that issue?

Jesse Hirsh:

Because, I mean, certainly for me growing up, the idea that governments moving fast

Jesse Hirsh:

was an oxymoron unto itself, and yet now.

Jesse Hirsh:

Whether it's, you know, policy issues around CFIA traceability or, you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

consultations around high speed rail.

Jesse Hirsh:

It seems like the public really moves fast around the conversations they

Jesse Hirsh:

have, and that puts a lot of pressure on not just government, but policy

Jesse Hirsh:

organizations, uh, uh, to keep up.

Jesse Hirsh:

Do, do you see that tension there?

Tyler McCann:

Yeah, so I

Jesse Hirsh:

I think think it depends

Tyler McCann:

the issue and I, and some

Jesse Hirsh:

issues

Tyler McCann:

and some issues move very slow.

Jesse Hirsh:

and I think what we've a is kind the between,

Tyler McCann:

speeds is greater than it than it used to be.

Tyler McCann:

I

Jesse Hirsh:

I think

Tyler McCann:

The fast issues faster now than they are, than they were

Tyler McCann:

before, and I think the slow issues are slower than they were before.

Tyler McCann:

So if you are a priority issue, if you're dealing with something that is

Tyler McCann:

all of a sudden landed on the front page of the globe, mail is a priority

Tyler McCann:

of the Prime Minister or of his of the minister, will get attention

Tyler McCann:

and your issue will move quickly.

Tyler McCann:

But if it's not.

Tyler McCann:

It's not gonna move at all.

Tyler McCann:

I think if you look at, uh, some of the things that you mentioned, traceability

Tyler McCann:

that you just mentioned, where there were, there's this blow back that flared up as

Tyler McCann:

an issue weeks, like we're not talking, you almost could say days, all of a sudden

Tyler McCann:

overnight this, this kind of ignited and the government backed off and, and down

Tyler McCann:

quicker than they have in, in the past.

Tyler McCann:

And so I think you see, on one hand you see that happening.

Tyler McCann:

On the

Jesse Hirsh:

On the other hand.

Tyler McCann:

the Prime Minister.

Tyler McCann:

Several weeks ago, uh, in his food affordability announcement

Tyler McCann:

referenced that they're launching or they're gonna launch a, develop a,

Tyler McCann:

a national food security strategy.

Tyler McCann:

And what we hear is that they're moving very quickly on that.

Tyler McCann:

And that's not something that's gonna take years to pull together.

Tyler McCann:

As was the case when the federal government tried to develop a

Tyler McCann:

sustainable agriculture strategy, that is something that the Prime

Tyler McCann:

Minister made the commitment.

Tyler McCann:

And they're gonna act and deliver on it soon.

Tyler McCann:

And so

Jesse Hirsh:

So that.

Tyler McCann:

faster.

Tyler McCann:

and so, so again, I think it, it depends And, and unfortunately for, for more often

Tyler McCann:

than, than we would like many agriculture issues and many food issues fell into

Tyler McCann:

that second group that things have moved slower than they have in the past.

Tyler McCann:

And not only move slower.

Tyler McCann:

Um, have barely moved at all.

Tyler McCann:

And that I think, creates frustration.

Tyler McCann:

And, and I think in my mind, drives home a need for a more focused agenda

Tyler McCann:

to say we need to really understand what's important and we need to be

Tyler McCann:

able to articulate what's important.

Tyler McCann:

And we need to be able to articulate why it's important and what the

Tyler McCann:

solutions again are that are needed so

Jesse Hirsh:

So that

Tyler McCann:

not

Jesse Hirsh:

not getting all of the issues.

Tyler McCann:

this kind of slow stream of things that barely move along.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, and, and let's take a moment to kind of get into the

Jesse Hirsh:

weeds there and, and talk tactics.

Jesse Hirsh:

So, you know, capi, the Canadian Agricul Agricultural Policy

Jesse Hirsh:

Institute, is that right?

Jesse Hirsh:

Um.

Tyler McCann:

AgriFood AgriFood.

Tyler McCann:

So we

Jesse Hirsh:

Yes,

Tyler McCann:

Ag.

Tyler McCann:

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsh:

correct.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I, we, we too.

Jesse Hirsh:

Here at the future, here at our AgriFood, I need to make more of an

Jesse Hirsh:

effort to bring our food friends on.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, stay tuned to upcoming episodes.

Tyler McCann:

you had Dana, Dana's one of the, Dana's, one of the best food friends.

Tyler McCann:

We all have.

Jesse Hirsh:

We started at the top and now we gotta keep going at the top.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, not to rip off that Drake song, but how, how do you

Jesse Hirsh:

engage the, the, the ecosphere?

Jesse Hirsh:

How do you guys both prioritize the kind of policy issues that you think

Jesse Hirsh:

should be getting attention and that you think should be mobilizing

Jesse Hirsh:

resources and, and, and how do you.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, collaborate, mobilize to kind of make that happen, partly because

Jesse Hirsh:

policy does take a village agricultural policy even more so, and, and you're

Jesse Hirsh:

right, we're, we're in the world, especially now with, uh, the United

Jesse Hirsh:

States doing what it does, where every day there could be a new distraction

Jesse Hirsh:

that absorbs everyone's attention.

Jesse Hirsh:

How, how do you navigate that kind of policy environment, that

Jesse Hirsh:

kind of attention environment?

Tyler McCann:

And, and

Jesse Hirsh:

And it's interesting because

Tyler McCann:

we

Jesse Hirsh:

we're a

Tyler McCann:

team of people, uh,

Jesse Hirsh:

working in a small

Tyler McCann:

policy think tank.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, we are not, uh, we understand that we are a pretty niche thing, a

Tyler McCann:

pretty unique thing in, in the sector.

Tyler McCann:

Um, and

Jesse Hirsh:

and as much as.

Tyler McCann:

you, you

Jesse Hirsh:

Talked earlier about

Tyler McCann:

of

Jesse Hirsh:

people are

Tyler McCann:

in policy.

Tyler McCann:

One of the, one of the challenges that we have in.

Tyler McCann:

sector

Jesse Hirsh:

country, is that there are a lot different,

Tyler McCann:

doing a

Jesse Hirsh:

different things.

Tyler McCann:

in the policy landscape, and

Jesse Hirsh:

So

Tyler McCann:

there are

Jesse Hirsh:

are,

Tyler McCann:

tenets that are really important and are part of a transformation

Tyler McCann:

that we've gone through as an organization where want to be relevant and impactful.

Tyler McCann:

That's something that we think about a lot in what we can do, but we want to

Jesse Hirsh:

we make sure that we're.

Tyler McCann:

gaps and adding value, so we try and not talk about the things.

Tyler McCann:

That everybody's talking about or if we are talking about them.

Tyler McCann:

We try and do that in a way that is different and distinct and adds value

Tyler McCann:

to the existing conversation, and part of that involves respecting.

Tyler McCann:

The positions and, and kind of roles that other producer groups and, and

Tyler McCann:

other advocacy organizations play.

Tyler McCann:

Um, but we see an opportunity often to, to be a bit different.

Tyler McCann:

And one of the ways that we're different is we do try and convene and engage

Tyler McCann:

stakeholder groups when we're working on the issues that, that we do.

Tyler McCann:

I think often what we see in agriculture is that farmers often in just their

Tyler McCann:

commodities, But maybe even just with farmers tend to like to work in the farm

Tyler McCann:

community, but so many of our farm issues have these butter impacts or would benefit

Tyler McCann:

from perspectives beyond the farm gate.

Tyler McCann:

And what we try and do is bring people together.

Tyler McCann:

Now, got some feedback on a LinkedIn post recently asking about how many, why

Tyler McCann:

we didn't have more farmers in a room.

Tyler McCann:

And we're talking about ag innovation.

Tyler McCann:

Um, so we understand that that's a bit of a flock, but that's partly

Tyler McCann:

because we think that these, like the farm voice is important.

Tyler McCann:

Farm voices in the room and there were representatives

Tyler McCann:

from farm groups in the room.

Tyler McCann:

But yeah, we had other people that are there.

Tyler McCann:

And I think that, I think that one, when we talk about kind of building

Tyler McCann:

that collaboration, building more support for new ideas, more people

Tyler McCann:

around the room and engaged in that conversation is, is important.

Tyler McCann:

Um, but you go back to all of those other voices that are lobbying, the

Tyler McCann:

more people that we can get on the same page and buy into kind of what

Tyler McCann:

matters for the sector, the, the better.

Jesse Hirsh:

Now, interestingly enough, you're kind of on some levels

Jesse Hirsh:

evoking the, the, the metaphor we've used here, which is the herd, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

That there's a group of people who are all doing interesting things.

Jesse Hirsh:

A and you guys are acting a as, as the kind of, you know, colleague or or herding

Jesse Hirsh:

instrument to both see the opportunities.

Jesse Hirsh:

But also to try to bring people together.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause you did say something earlier that I want to, uh, dig deeper on.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause I do hear in, in both the leadership part of the sector, but

Jesse Hirsh:

also the policy side of the sector.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, not so much a desire for unity, but a desire for synchronicity, a desire

Jesse Hirsh:

for people kind of to work together.

Jesse Hirsh:

So that when the priority comes, there's a kind of a, a, a, a focus

Jesse Hirsh:

on resources, a focus on attention.

Jesse Hirsh:

I haven't seen that desire as strong in other sectors.

Jesse Hirsh:

Other sectors do tend to have more kind of factions or competing interests.

Jesse Hirsh:

But, but it still doesn't seem like an easy thing to pull off.

Jesse Hirsh:

Like how does that happen?

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and, and what role do you see a, a group like yours, a nimble

Jesse Hirsh:

group like yours, you know, able to play, given that a lot of the

Jesse Hirsh:

larger associations, you know, larger organizations, they move slow and they

Jesse Hirsh:

react slow and they deliberate slowly.

Tyler McCann:

Well, and, and so I

Jesse Hirsh:

I

Tyler McCann:

challenge a bit of the premise that the sector actually

Tyler McCann:

does, speaks with, with one voice.

Tyler McCann:

I, I hear a

Jesse Hirsh:

hear a lot people.

Tyler McCann:

the sector needs to speak with one voice, but, but man,

Tyler McCann:

I'm not sure often the sector is as good actually delivering on,

Tyler McCann:

on what it says it needs to do.

Tyler McCann:

And I think that the other challenge with that, Jesse, often gets to be in order

Tyler McCann:

to get on the same page, in order to get that synchronicity that you talked about.

Tyler McCann:

We end up in this lowest risk common denominator where what that one voice

Tyler McCann:

is expected to say is this kind of bare minimum, low ambitious kind of support,

Tyler McCann:

the status quo mantra that everybody can agree to because we haven't been able

Tyler McCann:

to figure out how do you reconcile often what are legitimate differences in what

Tyler McCann:

different parts of the, the sector want.

Tyler McCann:

Different regions of the country want different farm

Tyler McCann:

sizes or farm farm types want.

Tyler McCann:

And so in order to kind of deal with that, end up with this space where.

Tyler McCann:

Where we, we kind of, when we do see people making that effort, speaking with

Tyler McCann:

that one voice, it ends up so watered

Jesse Hirsh:

Down

Tyler McCann:

I really questioned kind of the full value of it.

Tyler McCann:

I,

Jesse Hirsh:

I I'll.

Tyler McCann:

I think that there's an important distinction when we think

Tyler McCann:

about the, how we approach these things in internally, because you

Tyler McCann:

refer to us as the Coley, but that's not the role that we want to play.

Tyler McCann:

That's not the role we try and play.

Tyler McCann:

I'm, I'm trying to kind of think of what that, what a,

Tyler McCann:

a better comparison might be.

Tyler McCann:

If you think about the hurt context we may be, are.

Tyler McCann:

Are more, I don't know, a farmer with a pale of grain that's saying

Tyler McCann:

like, here's a good idea over here.

Tyler McCann:

You guys should come here, but hopefully we're attracting, hopefully

Tyler McCann:

we're attracting people with the good ideas that, that we have.

Tyler McCann:

But, but it is, it is more of a, you know, we, we talk a lot about

Tyler McCann:

impact and, and how we kind of think about the impact that we have.

Tyler McCann:

And, and when

Jesse Hirsh:

when you were advocating for

Tyler McCann:

which is what, what we do, the

Jesse Hirsh:

impact that you have other people.

Tyler McCann:

your ideas.

Jesse Hirsh:

And so

Tyler McCann:

We try

Jesse Hirsh:

try and do that by.

Tyler McCann:

good, smart people together to come up with the ideas.

Tyler McCann:

These are not like our small team isn't the one that's aren't the ones that

Tyler McCann:

are, are figuring all of this out.

Tyler McCann:

But we have the opportunity to work with a lot of really brilliant

Tyler McCann:

people across the country.

Tyler McCann:

Bring them together, pull their ideas together, and then

Tyler McCann:

effectively distill those ideas and share them with the sector.

Tyler McCann:

And if those ideas are good and they resonate.

Tyler McCann:

They will get picked up and, and they will get, move forward.

Tyler McCann:

But, but we are, and I'll say we are, I think moving into more of a

Tyler McCann:

world where we're trying to be more of that convener more, bring more

Tyler McCann:

of those people together, see if we can build more of those coalitions.

Tyler McCann:

there really is this tension because part of that is a spirit of, I. We need

Tyler McCann:

to find kind of the coalitions of the willing that are willing to stick their

Tyler McCann:

neck out and say, look it, we think that we need to do different things and we

Tyler McCann:

need to be a bit bolder and a bit more ambitious, uh, at the end of the day.

Tyler McCann:

And that may or may not include the, you refer to it as the her.

Tyler McCann:

I think it's often this blob of organizations that, that exist,

Tyler McCann:

that, that don't always do well with bold and don't always do well with

Tyler McCann:

transformative and don't always.

Tyler McCann:

Think very far beyond where they're at, where they're at today.

Tyler McCann:

Right.

Tyler McCann:

You, you've gone through this exercise around thinking about out to 2050.

Tyler McCann:

Um, I don't think that we do well thinking out to, to 2030 at this point.

Tyler McCann:

I'm thinking about all of the change that's that's coming.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, and I, I want to talk about that change.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause you alluded to it, you know, when we started in, in, in terms of the future.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I do want to take a moment to reinforce your instinct around convening.

Jesse Hirsh:

I mean, I, I think Malcolm Gladwell a couple of decades ago maybe talked

Jesse Hirsh:

about the power of the convener.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I've witnessed it my, my whole life that there is no greater

Jesse Hirsh:

authority than the person who brings people together in the room.

Jesse Hirsh:

And that is where small organizations can have an outsized impact.

Jesse Hirsh:

Because you don't need to do the heavy lifting.

Jesse Hirsh:

You just need to do the handholding to get people in the room.

Jesse Hirsh:

And then whatever happens, you get the credit.

Jesse Hirsh:

If it's good, if it's bad, it was everyone else's fault.

Jesse Hirsh:

But I, I want to bring up something kind of controversial.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, maybe it's not controversial and that I've been noticing in the

Jesse Hirsh:

broader Canadian policy environment.

Jesse Hirsh:

Especially in light of this to what you alluded to the changing geopolitical

Jesse Hirsh:

environment we find ourselves in that there's a lack of imagination

Jesse Hirsh:

that, that we're not sufficiently brainstorming or coming up with

Jesse Hirsh:

new ideas or challenging exist.

Jesse Hirsh:

Thing ideas in a manner that lends itself to true policy innovation,

Jesse Hirsh:

or at least true policy, you know, entertainment from my perspective.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, uh is that, do you encounter that within the agricultural sector?

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause you, I, I think you almost alluded to it, and how do you deal with that?

Jesse Hirsh:

Like, how do you try to get people to be more imaginative, courageous,

Jesse Hirsh:

curious, uh, when it comes to, uh, imagining what's possible.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah,

Tyler McCann:

Yeah, so

Jesse Hirsh:

so absolutely,

Tyler McCann:

we run into this and, and it's

Jesse Hirsh:

and it's an interesting challenge because

Tyler McCann:

you know, I

Jesse Hirsh:

I think when we think about

Tyler McCann:

um, so what, one of

Jesse Hirsh:

the.

Tyler McCann:

one of the interesting ways to think about the future is are

Tyler McCann:

we facing this world of generational opportunity or are we facing this

Tyler McCann:

world of generational challenge?

Tyler McCann:

Right.

Tyler McCann:

And those are two sides of, of the same coin, but I think they're very

Tyler McCann:

different sides of, of the same coin.

Tyler McCann:

And I

Jesse Hirsh:

I think.

Tyler McCann:

is hard for people to get their heads to wrapped around because

Tyler McCann:

that is kind of, things could be better if I make these changes, but that

Tyler McCann:

requires me to be changer, uh, make these changes that requires me to, to

Tyler McCann:

be different and maybe or maybe not.

Tyler McCann:

I'm gonna get this opportunity that's out there.

Tyler McCann:

I think general cha generational challenge speaks to the fact that

Tyler McCann:

how you are today is at risk.

Tyler McCann:

And I think people wrap their heads and understand that better.

Tyler McCann:

And, and so part of, I think what we try and do and, and, and could risk

Tyler McCann:

and, and risk management and thinking about risks in the sector is, is a, is

Tyler McCann:

a big part of the work that we do is to help people understand like there are

Tyler McCann:

serious risks and what you have today is at risk and, and those fundamentals

Tyler McCann:

that have been good for you for the last.

Tyler McCann:

60 years, uh, may not be, uh, there for you in the future.

Tyler McCann:

And so we should think about that and we should think about how we respond,

Tyler McCann:

mitigate and manage those, those risks.

Tyler McCann:

But, but on all of this, when we, when we try and talk about alternatives, I

Tyler McCann:

think it's become increasingly clear just as you need to go to governments

Tyler McCann:

and say, here's what the solution looks like when you're talking to, to

Tyler McCann:

kind of audiences in, in agriculture.

Tyler McCann:

You need to say.

Tyler McCann:

Here's what the alternative looks like and here's what the impacts of the alternative

Tyler McCann:

are, and here's what the consequences of, of the alternative are, because I

Tyler McCann:

think they really need to wrap their heads around what might be different.

Tyler McCann:

uh, again, we're a small team.

Tyler McCann:

Sometimes what we wanna do is.

Tyler McCann:

Put some ideas out there, get a get reaction.

Tyler McCann:

And I, I think again, you realize that the kind of, the more maybe out louds the

Tyler McCann:

idea is the more you need to have behind it so that people don't just dismiss

Tyler McCann:

it out of head and say, no, that's too crazy, and, and or No, I'm too unsure.

Tyler McCann:

And so the more you can, can articulate this is what the ideas, this is why we're

Tyler McCann:

doing it, this is what the consequences are, the easy it is for people to

Tyler McCann:

engage with that type of content.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, and myself, what's always attracted me to policy

Jesse Hirsh:

is that freedom of imagination.

Jesse Hirsh:

And on the one hand, you're right, Canadians historically and and my career

Jesse Hirsh:

at the CBC unfortunately was rife with.

Jesse Hirsh:

This love to dismiss things that are new, love to dismiss things that don't fit

Jesse Hirsh:

into existing kind of, uh, conventions.

Jesse Hirsh:

But I do feel, to your point about a generational opportunity.

Jesse Hirsh:

Mines are open right now.

Jesse Hirsh:

People are considering things they haven't, so, you know, give

Jesse Hirsh:

a moment to, let's get right into the muck for a second.

Jesse Hirsh:

You know, if you found yourself.

Jesse Hirsh:

By accident on the same, uh, elevator, uh, with the Prime Minister.

Jesse Hirsh:

You know, if there was one issue that you wanted people to focus on that

Jesse Hirsh:

they're not one thing that we should be entertaining or debating whether

Jesse Hirsh:

policy or not, what would that be?

Jesse Hirsh:

Like?

Jesse Hirsh:

What would you instinctively pull outta your pocket of, you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

here's to use the social media cliche.

Jesse Hirsh:

Here's what people are not talking about that we need to talk about.

Tyler McCann:

So

Jesse Hirsh:

So I think that the issue is

Tyler McCann:

uh,

Jesse Hirsh:

adding value.

Tyler McCann:

I think that we have, we have too much kind of tension

Tyler McCann:

and friction around this idea.

Tyler McCann:

I think that that's changing.

Tyler McCann:

I think there's more of an openness and more of a recognition of it, but,

Tyler McCann:

but one of the, there's, when I talk about the fundamentals are changing,

Tyler McCann:

there's a couple of reference points that I go back to and one of them

Tyler McCann:

is if you look at agriculture and AgriFood, GDP, kinda the size of the

Tyler McCann:

economy that the sector represents.

Tyler McCann:

But if you look at primary agriculture share of that and value added agriculture

Tyler McCann:

share of that primary agriculture share of that continues to increase.

Tyler McCann:

There are kind of some reasons why that happens, but that inherently,

Tyler McCann:

in my mind is not a good thing.

Tyler McCann:

That means that we are losing that value added benefit and

Tyler McCann:

that value added advantage.

Tyler McCann:

you look at today in this trade moment that we're in, right?

Tyler McCann:

We are in this space where as much as we'd like to think that we don't have

Tyler McCann:

to worry about Trump tariffs because Canadian farmland can't get moved

Tyler McCann:

south, there are thousands of food manufacturing jobs in this country.

Tyler McCann:

That exists to service the US marketplace that could get moves out.

Tyler McCann:

Those are, those are exactly the type of manufacturing jobs that

Tyler McCann:

Donald Trump wants to repatriate.

Tyler McCann:

And, and so how do we think through that?

Tyler McCann:

And if you look at what actually has been kind of 10 pretty good years

Tyler McCann:

of investment in food manufacturing in Canada has largely been driven by

Tyler McCann:

market access to the United States.

Tyler McCann:

If you want to build a plant that's competitive, that's a scale, you need a

Tyler McCann:

plant that serves not just the Canadian market, but serves the US market too.

Tyler McCann:

we lose that market access advantage that we have today, don't lose those

Tyler McCann:

plants because there's a lot of new plants that are, that are in the country.

Tyler McCann:

But we may lose

Jesse Hirsh:

Lose any investment.

Tyler McCann:

future plants, and we may see the erosion of those plants.

Tyler McCann:

And so I think for a lot of reasons, we are missing out on how

Tyler McCann:

do we think about adding value to Canadian agriculture, uh, today.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and the obvious question follow up to that is

Jesse Hirsh:

like, what's the missing piece?

Jesse Hirsh:

WW what's the kind of subset of that we should be focusing on?

Jesse Hirsh:

Is it a capital issue?

Jesse Hirsh:

Is it a knowledge issue?

Jesse Hirsh:

Is it an infrastructure issue?

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and just to verify that we're, we're talking that I'm thinking

Jesse Hirsh:

about what you're talking about, you know, my gut response to

Jesse Hirsh:

that is to see more kind of on.

Jesse Hirsh:

On premises on farm processing, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

The way that a lot of people now are taking the commodities they're producing

Jesse Hirsh:

and turning it into products, you know, let alone direct to marketplace

Jesse Hirsh:

or direct to other uh, uh, producers.

Jesse Hirsh:

How do we shift that focus?

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause part of it, I agree, is policy, but I sense part of it may be psychology

Jesse Hirsh:

as well, of people understanding kind of what's, what is available to them

Jesse Hirsh:

in terms of their operations and in terms of the entrepreneurial mindset.

Tyler McCann:

You know, I think

Jesse Hirsh:

I think

Tyler McCann:

Jesse, so

Jesse Hirsh:

many.

Tyler McCann:

in agriculture and food become cultural issues we need to change

Tyler McCann:

the way we think that there's this, again, you referred to it as psychology,

Tyler McCann:

but I, but I think that there's a cultural issue and I, and I think.

Tyler McCann:

You know, uh, my old boss that I start, uh, that I worked for, the

Tyler McCann:

agriculture minister, uh, talked about farmers first all of the time.

Tyler McCann:

We need to put farmers first.

Tyler McCann:

Um, and I think it creates a dynamic that that reflects the

Tyler McCann:

mindset that we've had where the agriculture and AgriFood department

Tyler McCann:

is really the farmer department.

Tyler McCann:

We need a cultural change to realize that actually what may be

Tyler McCann:

in farmer's best interest in this country is more focused on processing

Jesse Hirsh:

Mm-hmm.

Tyler McCann:

added, and that may mean kind of the farmer priority.

Tyler McCann:

doesn't get as funded as much as it used to because the kind of

Tyler McCann:

scarce resources are going into supporting value, value added.

Tyler McCann:

but I think there's 2, 2, 2 important things I wanna add onto that.

Tyler McCann:

One is, I think we need to think about value added as

Tyler McCann:

more than just food processing.

Tyler McCann:

It is more than just food manufacturing.

Tyler McCann:

It is.

Tyler McCann:

Kind of this

Jesse Hirsh:

Range of things, sustainability, certifications,

Tyler McCann:

there's a premium available for a product that we can

Tyler McCann:

go out and capture where we can add

Jesse Hirsh:

value

Tyler McCann:

the commodity, the supply chain that way.

Tyler McCann:

And there's this big space

Jesse Hirsh:

around innovation, how

Tyler McCann:

about, how do we do things different?

Tyler McCann:

And again, that is a kind of innovation that can add value to the sector

Tyler McCann:

by driving down costs and making our farmers more competitive to

Tyler McCann:

developing new products, new markets.

Tyler McCann:

So I think that there's

Jesse Hirsh:

there's a.

Tyler McCann:

than we think about value added.

Tyler McCann:

Yes.

Tyler McCann:

Food processing is a huge part of that.

Tyler McCann:

I think

Jesse Hirsh:

I think.

Tyler McCann:

that you talked about, Jesse, is, is one of the challenges

Tyler McCann:

that we have though, is that may mean some more on farm processing, but if we

Tyler McCann:

actually wanna have scale and impact, that means big facilities and it, and

Tyler McCann:

it is this tension that we have in in the sector where, do you manage the

Tyler McCann:

difference between the big and the small?

Tyler McCann:

Now we often hear the talk about this and I, and I think Dana.

Tyler McCann:

numbers reflect this, right?

Tyler McCann:

The vast majority, whatever, 90% of food businesses are SMEs in this country.

Tyler McCann:

But we often have these 80 20 rules where yes, the vast majority of

Tyler McCann:

the total number of them are SMEs.

Tyler McCann:

The big kind of things that actually change GDP numbers that

Tyler McCann:

get noticed are big facilities.

Tyler McCann:

And so how do you find that right balance and how do you understand

Tyler McCann:

that across all of these things?

Tyler McCann:

One of agriculture's strengths is diversity that we have

Tyler McCann:

the big and the small.

Tyler McCann:

But one of agriculture's weaknesses is also the diversity that we have, the

Tyler McCann:

vague and the small, and kind of thinking through kind of one set of solutions that

Tyler McCann:

work for everybody, whether or not it's a, a small farmer tried to do on-farm

Tyler McCann:

value added or Mars and a big plant and the GTA doing the work that they're doing.

Tyler McCann:

a farmer farming a hundred acres and.

Tyler McCann:

Western Quebec or a farmer farming 6,000 acres in Saskatchewan.

Tyler McCann:

We struggle.

Tyler McCann:

I think, uh, you know, that diversity is, is a challenge,

Tyler McCann:

and trying to find something that works for all of them is, is tough.

Tyler McCann:

But,

Jesse Hirsh:

But really.

Tyler McCann:

think about how do we, no matter what we're doing,

Tyler McCann:

have this reflex around added entrepreneurship, like you talked about.

Tyler McCann:

I think it's a, like, it changes the outcomes for the

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I, I, I, I want to dig deeper into the culture piece, but as an aside,

Jesse Hirsh:

and this is kind of outside of today's conversation, I think there, it would be

Jesse Hirsh:

an interesting case study to look at how Amazon handles distribution, say just

Jesse Hirsh:

exclusively here within Canada, and to think about how some of those lessons

Jesse Hirsh:

can be applied to the Agri Food Sec.

Jesse Hirsh:

There.

Jesse Hirsh:

Because on the one hand, it reinforces your point about the need for scale of

Jesse Hirsh:

having very large centers that create the kind of optimization possible.

Jesse Hirsh:

But at the same time, Amazon has that grassroots capability to get

Jesse Hirsh:

anything I want to my door, even in the farm, uh, the moment I want it.

Jesse Hirsh:

Um, but again, I digress.

Jesse Hirsh:

I I feel that when you

Tyler McCann:

but, so,

Jesse Hirsh:

Go ahead, please go ahead.

Tyler McCann:

you, you,

Jesse Hirsh:

You, you tell me before we hit.

Tyler McCann:

that I could ask you a

Jesse Hirsh:

You can digress, please.

Tyler McCann:

Is your

Jesse Hirsh:

your experience in the sector like firm?

Tyler McCann:

learn from?

Tyler McCann:

The examples like Amazon.

Jesse Hirsh:

No, I, but I, I asked that question about imagination, uh, due

Jesse Hirsh:

to my own personal agenda that I, I do find, I come from the internet world.

Jesse Hirsh:

I come from the startup world.

Jesse Hirsh:

I come from the world where, throw everything against the wall, see

Jesse Hirsh:

what sticks right, and your constant iteration and brainstorming.

Jesse Hirsh:

I meet many people in the AgriFood sector who act that way, who live that way.

Jesse Hirsh:

To your point, we all love Dana, uh, McCauley, but I also do run into a lot

Jesse Hirsh:

of people who are still in a 19th century agrarian model of governance and of doing

Jesse Hirsh:

things, and, and that is an obstacle I think, for the sector as a whole.

Jesse Hirsh:

I called it psychology.

Jesse Hirsh:

You called it culture.

Jesse Hirsh:

I think it's a combination of, of both.

Tyler McCann:

And, and, and I guess what, what I struggle with sometimes is that

Tyler McCann:

it's not like we're reinventing the or or we don't need to reinvent the wheel.

Tyler McCann:

You know, that, that Amazon model, again, maybe it's not the best model, um,

Tyler McCann:

uh, but it's a model out there, right?

Tyler McCann:

It's so how do we understand what works or what doesn't?

Tyler McCann:

We spend a lot of time talking about innovation these days.

Tyler McCann:

I talk a lot about the Australian model.

Tyler McCann:

There is a different way of funding r and d. In Australia

Tyler McCann:

that I think is very relevant.

Tyler McCann:

There's a lot of lessons that we can learn.

Tyler McCann:

That doesn't mean that we transplant the whole thing into here, but it

Tyler McCann:

means that why don't we look at it and take the best of what works

Tyler McCann:

there and implant it into Canada?

Tyler McCann:

But often it seems like the answer to people's kind of people's first

Tyler McCann:

reaction, and so many of these times is.

Tyler McCann:

Agriculture's different or Canada's different or this

Tyler McCann:

doesn't work, this doesn't apply.

Tyler McCann:

And, and I think there, there are a lot of missed opportunities to learn

Tyler McCann:

from what others are doing and, and to think, why don't we just take what works

Tyler McCann:

somewhere else and make it work for us?

Jesse Hirsh:

Well on, on the one hand, there's table stakes, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

It it, it's why even though you and I are policy people, you and I are innovation

Jesse Hirsh:

people, we're also both farmers, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

Because that's part of what allows us to participate in the space.

Jesse Hirsh:

But when you evoke.

Jesse Hirsh:

Culture, you, you, you, you're giving me the social license to bring up what I call

Jesse Hirsh:

the 800 pound gorilla in the room, which is true from a policy perspective, and I

Jesse Hirsh:

I ain't talking about Donald Trump yet.

Jesse Hirsh:

It, it's true from a policy perspective.

Jesse Hirsh:

It's true from an economics perspective, and it's the urban,

Jesse Hirsh:

rural divide here in Canada.

Jesse Hirsh:

And I underestimated the, the extent to which that difference, uh, I, I influences

Jesse Hirsh:

everything, but when I went from living in the city to living in the country.

Jesse Hirsh:

I was shocked at how completely ignorant my city friends are about

Jesse Hirsh:

rural life and at the same time how misperceived the city is.

Jesse Hirsh:

And it strikes me, given our first pass to post politics, given the

Jesse Hirsh:

nature of how policy debates happen.

Jesse Hirsh:

This is the real problem that we have to deal with.

Jesse Hirsh:

If, to your point, we're gonna have a cooperation in which, on the one hand

Jesse Hirsh:

we're thinking about how we're funding farmers, but on the other hand, we're

Jesse Hirsh:

allocating resources to processing 'cause that benefits everybody.

Jesse Hirsh:

That gets us railways, that gets us roads, that gets us the infrastructure we want.

Jesse Hirsh:

So, uh, I'm rambling, but I, I kind of feel that this urban, rural split is

Jesse Hirsh:

tied to what we're talking about in terms of the culture and psychology piece.

Tyler McCann:

Yeah, no, absolutely.

Tyler McCann:

And uh, I've talked over the years about, The four Ps that that

Tyler McCann:

agriculture faces is challenge.

Tyler McCann:

And one of those is the politics

Jesse Hirsh:

And,

Tyler McCann:

and

Jesse Hirsh:

and that is the space where

Tyler McCann:

we

Jesse Hirsh:

we're in this world.

Jesse Hirsh:

Where there is

Tyler McCann:

strong rural urban divide

Jesse Hirsh:

where

Tyler McCann:

urban

Jesse Hirsh:

communities,

Tyler McCann:

one way.

Jesse Hirsh:

urban issues

Tyler McCann:

the attention, rural communities and writings vote the other.

Tyler McCann:

And so we live in this space where, um, it's really easy for

Tyler McCann:

the conservative party of Canada to take rural votes for granted.

Tyler McCann:

to ask where the ag platform was in the last federal election

Tyler McCann:

campaign from the conservative.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, as a former conservative staffer that contributed to platforms, it pained

Tyler McCann:

me not to see, not to see one, uh, not to see one and, and what they put out.

Tyler McCann:

And, but on the flip side, I guess the liberals had one,

Tyler McCann:

but it was very like token.

Tyler McCann:

It was kind of like from the greatest hits, uh, that I'm sure that the

Tyler McCann:

liberal ag platforms changed much in,

Jesse Hirsh:

And to your point, I think the liberals take urban

Jesse Hirsh:

voters for granted, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

I think in both cases, they're neglecting the constituencies that they

Jesse Hirsh:

should actually be properly serving.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause instead the battle is for the swing votes.

Jesse Hirsh:

The battle is for the exurban suburban edges.

Jesse Hirsh:

That kind of fall in between these lines and better policy is, is the con, sorry.

Jesse Hirsh:

Worse policy is, is the consequence.

Tyler McCann:

That and, and I think it is, um.

Tyler McCann:

You know, I, so I'm in a, I'm in a nonpartisan position now.

Tyler McCann:

I'm not involved in partisan politics, but, but I've said to increasingly said

Tyler McCann:

to people, I think one of our challenges is we need to get more, uh, more

Tyler McCann:

convinced that there are votes to be had on these issues because, you know, we

Jesse Hirsh:

We can talk about,

Tyler McCann:

great economic impact of the sector, or we

Jesse Hirsh:

we can talk about.

Tyler McCann:

in Ontario.

Tyler McCann:

There are more manufacturing jobs in food than there is in automotives.

Tyler McCann:

But if there's not a political advantage.

Tyler McCann:

It's hard to get kind of attention and engagement on it.

Tyler McCann:

And so that, that I think is just this, this dynamic and, and it's, it's a,

Jesse Hirsh:

Challenge

Tyler McCann:

the, at

Jesse Hirsh:

at the

Tyler McCann:

and, and it really is,

Jesse Hirsh:

you.

Tyler McCann:

nothing we can kind of do about it or, or, I think that there

Tyler McCann:

are some things that we can do about, first and foremost is probably how do

Tyler McCann:

we help, how do we understand that in many rural communities can benefit from

Tyler McCann:

liberal policies when they're right.

Tyler McCann:

How do we get past kind of this rural urban divide, this, this kind of piece

Tyler McCann:

that's there and how do we think about it?

Tyler McCann:

In a different context, in ways that, that, that aren't, aren't the,

Tyler McCann:

aren't the way that they used to be.

Jesse Hirsh:

Well, and, and I, I feel a, one of the mandates of

Jesse Hirsh:

this podcast, but also one of the opportunities of the sector is to

Jesse Hirsh:

be non-partisan and non-ideological, because earlier you lamented.

Jesse Hirsh:

I think legitimately so that often getting everyone on the same page means you really

Jesse Hirsh:

dumb it down and you really leave out the meatier parts of a policy opportunity.

Jesse Hirsh:

I think that we are in a position to start coming together

Jesse Hirsh:

around both methods and, uh.

Jesse Hirsh:

Priorities that allow us to achieve complexity and nuance and unity precisely

Jesse Hirsh:

because we say we don't gotta be partisan, we don't gotta be ideological.

Jesse Hirsh:

There's enough commonality and, and interestingly enough, I actually think

Jesse Hirsh:

the processing piece is part of that.

Jesse Hirsh:

I acknowledge that there are a lot of people threatened by it.

Jesse Hirsh:

There are a lot of people who feel that it could be a zero sum situation.

Jesse Hirsh:

But I think once you really kind of crunch the numbers and understand

Jesse Hirsh:

the global dynamics, processing is the area that lifts all boats, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

The, the same way that I, I kind of feel that Fin Dana's organization has

Jesse Hirsh:

a similar approach where they really want to raise all boats, and those are

Jesse Hirsh:

the policy approaches that I think it's a lot easier to get everyone on side

Jesse Hirsh:

boat, which is why, again, I'm giving you guys the, I'm, I'm saying convening

Jesse Hirsh:

is definitely the path forward to this.

Jesse Hirsh:

I'll be devil's advocate, especially since uh, uh, you are, uh, so

Jesse Hirsh:

brilliant and generous here with your time and attention.

Jesse Hirsh:

What is the obstacle to that happening, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

If, if Jesse the newbie is saying, Hey guys, if we focus on the priorities

Jesse Hirsh:

and the system and try to, you know, limit the, the partisan bickering,

Jesse Hirsh:

we can accomplish something.

Jesse Hirsh:

Am I naive or are there things here that I, I'm not seeing that would make this

Jesse Hirsh:

harder than, than what I'm imagining?

Tyler McCann:

You

Jesse Hirsh:

You know, I think.

Tyler McCann:

um.

Tyler McCann:

This is very much my kind of strong personal that, that the,

Tyler McCann:

that the challenge at the core of that is that farming is a

Tyler McCann:

tough, business farmers often are.

Tyler McCann:

Being squeezed and under threat and are worried that if they give an inch,

Tyler McCann:

somebody else is gonna take a mile.

Tyler McCann:

And you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

You know, there's.

Tyler McCann:

important context to some of those things that I see.

Tyler McCann:

So as farmers hard and struggle, but.

Tyler McCann:

average farm family is worth a lot more and makes more than the

Tyler McCann:

average Canadian family, right?

Tyler McCann:

So there's like, again, two sides to many of these coins.

Tyler McCann:

But, but

Jesse Hirsh:

But all of that.

Tyler McCann:

like the reality is again, I think that there's this, this

Tyler McCann:

pressure and when you're under the pressure all of the time, again, you may

Tyler McCann:

not be as willing to kind of embrace.

Tyler McCann:

of a focus away from you and onto somebody else.

Tyler McCann:

We run into this a lot when we talk about risk management programming in Canada.

Tyler McCann:

We have effectively had the same framework for risk management

Tyler McCann:

programs a little bit different.

Tyler McCann:

We've, I guess, more provincial companion programs in Ontario.

Tyler McCann:

There's RMPE, but there's this suite of programs across the country that have

Tyler McCann:

largely been the same for 25 years.

Tyler McCann:

The world has changed, the technology has changed.

Tyler McCann:

The other options and tools are there are different, but farmers are really

Tyler McCann:

reluctant to talk about changing to risk management programs because I

Tyler McCann:

think when they think about change to risk management programs, they

Tyler McCann:

think about fewer monies going to support their risk management needs.

Tyler McCann:

They think about they're gonna lose and, and that when you're worried

Tyler McCann:

about losing all of the time, your ability to embrace thinking

Tyler McCann:

differently really gets to be tough and it really gets to be a challenge.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I, I kind of wanna acknowledge and validate that psychology

Jesse Hirsh:

because the other thing that shocked me, uh, when I became a farmer is the extent

Jesse Hirsh:

to which farmers are constantly circled by sharks of all sorts, shapes and sizes.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, you know, I once had a farmer say, uh, frame it quite brilliantly, which

Jesse Hirsh:

is, you know, we're the only people who, uh, uh, buy retail and sell wholesale.

Jesse Hirsh:

Right.

Jesse Hirsh:

Like you're on the wrong side of all the different economic mixes.

Jesse Hirsh:

So I, I get the kind of, uh, economic paranoia, but at the same time as you've

Jesse Hirsh:

been repeating through our conversation today, times have changed, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

We're in a different world.

Jesse Hirsh:

We're still figuring that.

Jesse Hirsh:

Out.

Jesse Hirsh:

We're still, uh, uh, that's where the collaboration piece, I think is best

Jesse Hirsh:

done as the opposite of dumbing down.

Jesse Hirsh:

But of, uh, each one teach one of all of us helping each other.

Jesse Hirsh:

And that's where I wanna throw you a, a, a bit of a self-serving

Jesse Hirsh:

question, but nonetheless, uh, a a a kind of, uh, giving you respect.

Jesse Hirsh:

I love the podcast, uh, that you guys at Cap are doing with real agriculture.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause I really feel it makes.

Jesse Hirsh:

This kind of knowledge accessible podcasts are very popular amongst farmers.

Jesse Hirsh:

You can listen to it while you're doing your chores, while you're in the tractor.

Jesse Hirsh:

Social media is obviously also very popular with farmers.

Jesse Hirsh:

Um, so I'd love to hear about how that's going and, and how you feel

Jesse Hirsh:

that fits into the larger kind impact, uh, driven nature, uh, uh, of Kappy.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause I, I, I'm a fan and it's.

Jesse Hirsh:

Partly what motivated me to say, Hey, let's do more podcasting.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause I think this is how we enact that cultural change and, and, and really start

Jesse Hirsh:

to reach people and open their minds.

Tyler McCann:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

And, and one of the, the dynamics that we've got in the sector is that

Tyler McCann:

this isn't, uh, you know, the auto manufacturers where there's kind of

Tyler McCann:

five big players, and if you get their CEOs on the same page, you fixed it.

Tyler McCann:

We've, we've got, uh, 150,000 farmers in the country.

Tyler McCann:

Um, this is a very diffuse group and, and trying.

Tyler McCann:

Like, we

Jesse Hirsh:

We realize that if we wanna have,

Tyler McCann:

we need to meet people where they are and talk about the

Tyler McCann:

things that we're talking about in ways that resonate with them.

Tyler McCann:

And

Jesse Hirsh:

so the podcast,

Tyler McCann:

is, is part of that, right?

Tyler McCann:

It is

Jesse Hirsh:

how do we

Tyler McCann:

take content, make it more digestible, but also how do we

Tyler McCann:

make it available in ways that, as you say, people can listen no matter what.

Tyler McCann:

I, I,

Jesse Hirsh:

I,

Tyler McCann:

am

Jesse Hirsh:

I'm a big fan of

Tyler McCann:

to the podcast when I'm out in the tractor.

Jesse Hirsh:

what are the things that we're trying to do now on the podcast?

Tyler McCann:

with this, this most recent focus is

Jesse Hirsh:

How do we talk about,

Tyler McCann:

kinda the big ideas for change?

Jesse Hirsh:

how do we do this?

Tyler McCann:

way that hopefully is not threading?

Tyler McCann:

How do we do it in a way that's easy, that's, that's engaging, that

Tyler McCann:

you say kind of breaks things down?

Tyler McCann:

I'm trying to talk to people about.

Tyler McCann:

Um, that have big ideas.

Tyler McCann:

Some big ideas are actually kind of small, but they are

Tyler McCann:

like big transformational ideas.

Tyler McCann:

of the ideas that we, we, we just had an episode come out recently

Tyler McCann:

on, uh, embracing benchmarking and business management.

Tyler McCann:

One of, I talked about the challenges we have with risk management.

Tyler McCann:

We put a lot of money and time and focus into risk management programming.

Tyler McCann:

We put very little into proactive risk management decisions, and I think that

Tyler McCann:

there's really something to be said for.

Tyler McCann:

Man, we should take a little bit of money that's floating around in

Tyler McCann:

the ether of all of these programs

Jesse Hirsh:

Incentivize.

Tyler McCann:

uh, uh, business management benchmarking.

Tyler McCann:

How do we kind of fund the resources so that farmers could become part of

Tyler McCann:

a, a benchmarking group, could make their data available, learn from others?

Tyler McCann:

Understand this, like, like the fact that that just seems like such a simple.

Tyler McCann:

Impactful way to take a little bit of money and go a long, long way.

Tyler McCann:

So, uh, you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

that's that.

Tyler McCann:

little idea, big change.

Tyler McCann:

I think.

Tyler McCann:

Um, uh, it is, it is, it ends up being a big idea because we're not doing that.

Tyler McCann:

That, um, that's not a reflex that this idea that.

Tyler McCann:

That proactive risk management, that farmers are their own first line of

Tyler McCann:

defense is an idea that's gotten lost.

Tyler McCann:

When governments think about risk management.

Tyler McCann:

We've also talked about supply management and the future of supply management.

Tyler McCann:

That's maybe more of a bigger, more controversial idea, but, but

Tyler McCann:

we really see this need to kind of put those ideas out there and.

Tyler McCann:

And again, put them out and not in a way that says this is the solution.

Tyler McCann:

I, I really, I think this is in part, kind of informed by my, my startup in the

Tyler McCann:

politics, but I really don't think that there is a right answer on any of this.

Tyler McCann:

There are just different ideas.

Tyler McCann:

With different pros and cons and different consequences, and

Jesse Hirsh:

So.

Tyler McCann:

we'll put our ideas out there.

Tyler McCann:

We wanna create the space where we can put more ideas out there, have that

Tyler McCann:

more, understand what those pros and cons are, understand what the consequences

Tyler McCann:

are, and then people get to make their own decisions at the end of the day,

Tyler McCann:

whether or not they think that they're the right ones or the wrong ones.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and that's why I think policy is such an exciting area right now.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause on the one hand there is a kind of butterfly effect that you evoke that

Jesse Hirsh:

even the smallest idea people can go Wow.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Jesse Hirsh:

And really wrap their head around it.

Jesse Hirsh:

Then the distribution of that idea via TikTok, via Instagram, via

Jesse Hirsh:

x can happen at a rapid speed.

Jesse Hirsh:

And it's why I'd love to see more policy leaders, more ag leaders doing what you're

Jesse Hirsh:

doing, which is having these conversations on a regular basis and letting people

Jesse Hirsh:

make up their own minds, right?

Jesse Hirsh:

Letting them figure out, like get the information and, and move forward with it.

Jesse Hirsh:

Um.

Jesse Hirsh:

I, I that kind of li as we start to come to a close, it kind of brings

Jesse Hirsh:

us to the real variable throughout all of this whi, which is the United

Jesse Hirsh:

States and the Trump Administration, and granted the SMA or U-S-C-M-A,

Jesse Hirsh:

however you want to rearrange the acronym, uh, is a hot topic, uh, within

Jesse Hirsh:

agricultural circles for very good reason.

Jesse Hirsh:

But it seems to me that the constant is uncertainty.

Jesse Hirsh:

I, I'm, I'm, I'm curious to hear your thoughts.

Jesse Hirsh:

You've, I think, been alluding to it.

Jesse Hirsh:

I think it's been a through line in terms of, you know, we need to be adapting to

Jesse Hirsh:

this new world, but on a. Concrete level.

Jesse Hirsh:

I would love to hear your kind of informed perspective on kind of

Jesse Hirsh:

what's going on and, and what we should be doing to prepare for it.

Jesse Hirsh:

Both on the AgriFood level but also on the geopolitical level.

Jesse Hirsh:

'cause they're, uh, intrinsically linked.

Tyler McCann:

And I, I

Jesse Hirsh:

Encourage to go

Tyler McCann:

YouTube channel because we've had two webinars this year.

Tyler McCann:

One was an Outlook, uh, for 2026, and the other one was, was explicitly

Tyler McCann:

on geopolitics, but we, on for

Jesse Hirsh:

the

Tyler McCann:

webinar,

Jesse Hirsh:

we looked.

Tyler McCann:

farm economics.

Tyler McCann:

We looked at farm sentiment, we looked at farm policy and foreign politics,

Tyler McCann:

U-S-M-C-A was kinda the elephant in the room and all, I guess it wasn't the

Tyler McCann:

elephant in the room, it was very much called out as, as the major challenge.

Tyler McCann:

know, the FCC economist that was on the webinar effectively said,

Tyler McCann:

look at, these are our projections.

Tyler McCann:

But if Donald Trump rips up the agreement, all bets are off.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

will

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

a bad year, right?

Tyler McCann:

If you look at from the foreign politics perspective.

Tyler McCann:

You know, we understand what the year looks like.

Tyler McCann:

We understand how the year goes.

Tyler McCann:

If Donald Trump asked for something crazy on supply management,

Tyler McCann:

you know, all bets are off.

Tyler McCann:

From a political perspective, it is such a big challenge at the end of the day.

Tyler McCann:

And it's interesting because I think we are starting to see a bit of a

Tyler McCann:

shape politically, nationally, around how Canada should approach the United

Tyler McCann:

States and the rest of the world.

Tyler McCann:

I think that.

Tyler McCann:

Actually at the end of the day when it comes to the United States, the,

Tyler McCann:

the kind of perspective of the prime minister and the opposition leader

Tyler McCann:

are probably pretty similar in that we need to defend Canadian interests and

Tyler McCann:

yes, we should get a deal at all costs.

Tyler McCann:

But I think both are pretty aware that, you

Jesse Hirsh:

You know that, that, that idea,

Tyler McCann:

a tariff free deal.

Tyler McCann:

It probably not realistic at this point in time.

Jesse Hirsh:

well

Tyler McCann:

when we

Jesse Hirsh:

think about.

Tyler McCann:

what that means for agriculture and food and, and what that

Tyler McCann:

means for the broader relationship, a couple of things that I think

Tyler McCann:

are really important to understand.

Tyler McCann:

We can handle tariffs as long as we have a tariff advantage.

Tyler McCann:

you know,

Jesse Hirsh:

Like

Tyler McCann:

a 10%

Jesse Hirsh:

10% tar,

Tyler McCann:

not ideal.

Tyler McCann:

I don't think that's in anybody's interest.

Tyler McCann:

That's not, that's not great, that's not predictable,

Jesse Hirsh:

but we do have an

Tyler McCann:

compared to the rest of the world.

Tyler McCann:

And so understanding what that looks like and, and kind of the level of the

Tyler McCann:

tariff and the impact that that's there.

Tyler McCann:

So, so that doesn't necessarily mean we need to light our hair on fire,

Jesse Hirsh:

there.

Tyler McCann:

situations where we may need to light our hair on fire that

Tyler McCann:

may have really dire consequences.

Tyler McCann:

And as much as we like to talk about trade diversification.

Tyler McCann:

The reality is, is that is extremely hard in agriculture and food,

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

This isn't just a, a question about bulk commodities,

Tyler McCann:

almost every product that we produce, the best and easiest market is going

Tyler McCann:

to be the United States, and it is hard to build the infrastructure

Tyler McCann:

needed to really diversify and, and the sector today, or maybe not today.

Tyler McCann:

well probably even today, probably even today, more concentrated in the United

Tyler McCann:

States market than it was 20 years ago.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

American Free Trade Agreement kind of

Tyler McCann:

supercharged that integration.

Tyler McCann:

You talk about those investments that we've got in plants in, in Ontario.

Tyler McCann:

I mean, one, one

Jesse Hirsh:

One of the great,

Tyler McCann:

stories is bakery goods.

Tyler McCann:

I don't think people know that we're a major exporter.

Tyler McCann:

Bakery goods into the United States.

Tyler McCann:

We have a $4.5 billion trade surplus with the United States on bakery goods.

Tyler McCann:

Um, like

Jesse Hirsh:

all of that.

Tyler McCann:

on that, that meaningful market access.

Tyler McCann:

And so we need to get through this year, we need to get through the next couple

Tyler McCann:

of years with a reliable trade deal.

Tyler McCann:

And, and then we need to think through.

Tyler McCann:

If that doesn't happen, what does probably transition look like?

Tyler McCann:

And, and, and one

Jesse Hirsh:

And one of the challenges.

Tyler McCann:

all of this is.

Tyler McCann:

Kinda the predictability because even if there was a sense that maybe we may,

Tyler McCann:

something bad may happen for the next year or the next two years, there's a hope

Tyler McCann:

that return back to normal after that, then that takes some pressure off, right?

Tyler McCann:

Like, like it reduces the motivation to change and transition.

Tyler McCann:

And I think that that's really the, the challenge that we're in today

Tyler McCann:

is how do you plan for the future?

Tyler McCann:

I talked about change, talked about the future, but, but how

Jesse Hirsh:

How do you.

Tyler McCann:

that future's gonna look like when.

Tyler McCann:

When it hasn't, hasn't arrived yet.

Tyler McCann:

When there are kind of big differences and, and where there are, where

Tyler McCann:

there's kind of the length and, and the duration of that changes and unknown.

Tyler McCann:

The final point, Jesse, that I think is really important is, or maybe two points.

Tyler McCann:

One, we have more leverage than we think that we do.

Tyler McCann:

And I really do think that that's, that often gets lost in this, is that,

Tyler McCann:

um, you know, if you look at the, kind of the technical arrangements.

Tyler McCann:

What's that happens this summer is a review process and as part of that

Tyler McCann:

review process that, that any one member of the agreement could provide

Tyler McCann:

a notification, but that effectively starts a 10 year clock That, that

Tyler McCann:

the agreement only ends 10 years ago.

Tyler McCann:

But

Jesse Hirsh:

But there is another alternative,

Tyler McCann:

is somebody just gives the six months notice to

Tyler McCann:

say they're walking away, but.

Jesse Hirsh:

that will have devastating.

Tyler McCann:

on the US economy.

Tyler McCann:

Like the president may threaten that, but I dunno,

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

it's gonna happen.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah.

Tyler McCann:

so like,

Jesse Hirsh:

So, so like understanding the.

Tyler McCann:

that we have is really important um, and, uh,

Tyler McCann:

happens, I forgot what the, the other part I was gonna make is, but

Jesse Hirsh:

Oh, sorry.

Tyler McCann:

The other thing, the other thing is that, and

Tyler McCann:

this is I guess part of the.

Tyler McCann:

Part of the leverage.

Tyler McCann:

But, but I think that if you look at what a lot of, we have more allies

Tyler McCann:

in the United States and, and even on something like supply management,

Tyler McCann:

if you look at what the US dairy industry is saying, you know, they're

Tyler McCann:

not asking for the end of the system.

Tyler McCann:

That's not what they want.

Tyler McCann:

And so I think it's really important to understand, you know, the, the

Tyler McCann:

president's got his own views, his own, his own desires on these

Tyler McCann:

things, but I think it's important.

Tyler McCann:

For Canadians to understand more of the facts and kind of look beyond the

Tyler McCann:

hysteria that we seem to live in, in this space to know what is the dynamic

Tyler McCann:

that we're really operating in when it comes to, to customer renegotiation.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, although potentially contentious follow up, do you think

Jesse Hirsh:

the federal government, uh, uh, values or prioritizes the AgriFood

Jesse Hirsh:

sector compared to all the other competing agendas that they need to

Jesse Hirsh:

be looking at in this, uh, uh, chaos?

Tyler McCann:

So the, the Prime Minister went to China and

Jesse Hirsh:

Effectively trade.

Tyler McCann:

for canola.

Tyler McCann:

You know, like that says a lot to me.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, I mean, let's be honest that I don't think that would've happened

Tyler McCann:

into the past Prime Minister.

Tyler McCann:

You can get

Jesse Hirsh:

Mm-hmm.

Jesse Hirsh:

Kind of

Tyler McCann:

arguments

Jesse Hirsh:

about.

Tyler McCann:

of the scale and the understanding and, and kind of the

Tyler McCann:

trade-offs that were there, but, The Prime Minister came back from China with

Tyler McCann:

Scott Mo kind of locked arm in arm and

Jesse Hirsh:

Mm-hmm.

Tyler McCann:

to what he was doing.

Tyler McCann:

that says a lot to me, I think, about how the current, uh,

Tyler McCann:

government is thinking about it,

Jesse Hirsh:

Is very different.

Tyler McCann:

than when it comes to supply management.

Tyler McCann:

And I think, uh, the unfortunate reality that heard for.

Tyler McCann:

Producers in the sector understand and appreciate is that government

Tyler McCann:

is gonna put the Canadian economy at risk to protect supply management.

Tyler McCann:

And so if the US said, and I don't think that this is what's gonna happen, but

Tyler McCann:

if Donald Trump said, we're gonna leave everything the same, you're gonna get

Tyler McCann:

your tariff free access, but you need to tear down all of your dairy protections.

Tyler McCann:

I think it's a very easy decision for the Prime Minister to make.

Jesse Hirsh:

And, and I, from the scuttlebutt that I'm reading amongst the

Jesse Hirsh:

agricultural sector, the, the concern is there, there's a lot of people who

Jesse Hirsh:

are doing the kind of game theory you're doing of trying to anticipate this.

Jesse Hirsh:

This has been an absolutely fantastic conversation.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, if only because it indulges my own kind of desire to reinforce the value of.

Jesse Hirsh:

Policy as a playground for anybody and everybody.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, because I, I, I think one of the truisms that we've teased out

Jesse Hirsh:

is that there aren't crazy ideas.

Jesse Hirsh:

There's just boring debates, and that debates get more interesting

Jesse Hirsh:

when you have more ideas.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, any final thoughts or, you know, uh, uh, things you kind of want to leave

Jesse Hirsh:

us on, especially a, as we kind of.

Jesse Hirsh:

Think about what our audience, the through line for our audience, which

Jesse Hirsh:

is, you know, we need leadership, we need new kinds of leadership.

Jesse Hirsh:

That's kind of what I've been hearing you, uh, hearing you talk

Jesse Hirsh:

about and say throughout this.

Jesse Hirsh:

So, anything you wanna leave us with,

Tyler McCann:

Yeah, I think

Jesse Hirsh:

we

Tyler McCann:

we

Jesse Hirsh:

leaders that are prepared, make

Tyler McCann:

When I

Jesse Hirsh:

talk about.

Tyler McCann:

change that's there, it means that we're gonna

Tyler McCann:

need to do things differently.

Tyler McCann:

And again, I think we've had the luxury of not having to make big, tough decisions.

Tyler McCann:

I think our governments have not had to make big, tough decisions.

Tyler McCann:

I think our farm leaders have not had to make tough decisions.

Tyler McCann:

I think farmers make decisions every day on their farms.

Tyler McCann:

Deciding things, making choices be that hard.

Tyler McCann:

But if we wanna really unlock the full potential of the sector, we

Tyler McCann:

need to be prepared to make, make some decisions, make some choices.

Tyler McCann:

That's what's in front of us.

Tyler McCann:

And I think to your point, that's where advocating for ideas, putting different

Tyler McCann:

thoughts out there, helping, making sure people are making informed decisions is a

Tyler McCann:

big part of the role that we're playing.

Tyler McCann:

And something that I get really excited about.

Jesse Hirsh:

Right on a big Canadian salute to you.

Jesse Hirsh:

Our, uh, uh, automated audience has been enthralled with this conversation.

Jesse Hirsh:

Uh, where can people learn more, uh, about Cap?

Jesse Hirsh:

About you, Tyler, about the work you guys do?

Tyler McCann:

Yeah,

Jesse Hirsh:

Yeah, they could go

Tyler McCann:

our website and sign up for our mailing list.

Tyler McCann:

website is CAPI ipa.ca.

Tyler McCann:

Uh, sign up to our mailing list.

Tyler McCann:

That is the best place to stay tuned with all that we're doing the.

Tyler McCann:

But they should also go check out our YouTube channel, our webinars go there.

Tyler McCann:

There's some pretty good content.

Tyler McCann:

Our podcasts are, our episodes are there as well, and they should check

Tyler McCann:

that out and people should feel free to engage with us on kind of all the

Tyler McCann:

social medias and all of these things.

Tyler McCann:

I maybe not often the best on it, but, but one of the things that we really wanted to

Tyler McCann:

do is encourage more debate and dialogue.

Tyler McCann:

So the more people that are talking about the work that we're doing, telling

Tyler McCann:

us where they think that we're right, telling us where they think that we're

Tyler McCann:

wrong, um, that makes us really happy.

Tyler McCann:

We always appreciate the, appreciate the feedback and engagement.

Jesse Hirsh:

Right on.

Jesse Hirsh:

Thank you.

Jesse Hirsh:

That was my conversation with Tyler McCann from the Canadian

Jesse Hirsh:

AgriFood Policy Institute.

Jesse Hirsh:

What I really appreciated about this exchange is the

Jesse Hirsh:

refusal to drift into fatalism.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yes, the trade environment is volatile.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yes, geopolitical pressures are intensifying.

Jesse Hirsh:

Yes, policy processes can feel slow, fragmented, cautious,

Jesse Hirsh:

but there is also movement.

Jesse Hirsh:

There are coalitions forming.

Jesse Hirsh:

There's momentum building.

Jesse Hirsh:

There are ideas gaining traction.

Jesse Hirsh:

There are people inside and outside government who understand

Jesse Hirsh:

that food is not peripheral.

Jesse Hirsh:

It's foundational.

Jesse Hirsh:

If there's a thread running through this conversation, it's this.

Jesse Hirsh:

The future is not something that arrives.

Jesse Hirsh:

It's something that gets organized.

Jesse Hirsh:

Organized through focus, organized through courage, organized through institutions

Jesse Hirsh:

willing to convene hard conversations and not flinch when complexity shows up.

Jesse Hirsh:

The AgriFood sector in Canada has more leverage than it sometimes realizes.

Jesse Hirsh:

The question is whether we use this geopolitical moment to think bigger

Jesse Hirsh:

about value added production, about resilience, about sovereignty, about

Jesse Hirsh:

the kind of leadership this era demands, or whether we settle for incremental

Jesse Hirsh:

adjustments while the world reorders itself around and maybe without us.

Jesse Hirsh:

Momentum is building.

Jesse Hirsh:

The stakes are rising, and the opportunity is real.

Jesse Hirsh:

If this conversation sparked something for you, hey, share it.

Jesse Hirsh:

Push it into your networks.

Jesse Hirsh:

Start a conversation in your own organization about what future

Jesse Hirsh:

you are actually building toward.

Jesse Hirsh:

This is the future herd and we're just getting going.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube