They are the single biggest savings tool we have available to us. Are you using them effectively? That’s the question Host Josh Bretl explores on this episode of Retirement Equals Freedom, which is devoted to all things 401k:
You’ll come away from this episode with a whole new depth of wisdom about 401ks and why they are such a valuable – but often misunderstood – vehicle for the kind of financial growth that adds up over time to the kind of robust retirement nest egg we all want to have.
And, on an irrelevant side note, if you doubt that there are harmonica players out there making good money as well as beautiful noise, listen to "Re: Stacks," (a Bon Iver cover), performed by legendary harmonica player Grégoire Maret. As promised by Co-Host Dave Schmidt on the show, you can find one of his favorite harmonica-featured tunes of the moment here.
Like what you’ve heard? Want to spread the word? Send your friends to this pod link resource with all the latest and greatest about Retirement Equals Freedom and one-click access to your favorite platform for listening!
It's a new year and Cometeer is back in stock at the FSR freezer! Get $25 off your first order when you click this link.
And don’t forget to join the conversation at our private Facebook group, which you’ll find here.
Click here to explore the services that FSR Wealth Strategies offers and schedule a discovery call with one of the team’s CPAs. When it comes to living your best life, it’s never too early to get started!
401k plans.
Dave Schmidt:You've definitely heard of them.
Dave Schmidt:You may have had one in the past, and if still
Dave Schmidt:employed, you may still be contributing to a 401k plan.
Dave Schmidt:But are you using these really powerful savings
Dave Schmidt:tools effectively?
Josh Bretl:401ks can be quite ... Not quite, 401ks
Josh Bretl:are the single biggest savings tool that Americans have.
Josh Bretl:Most people use them, very few people know how to do it
Josh Bretl:effectively, and they let a lot of emotion come into play.
Josh Bretl:And they also think they don't have a choice of what they can
Josh Bretl:or can't be doing with it as they get closer to retirement.
Dave Schmidt:That's Josh Bretl.
Dave Schmidt:He's the owner of FSR Wealth Strategies.
Dave Schmidt:For the last 20 plus years, Josh's sole focus has been
Dave Schmidt:to help fine folks like you, make your retirement
Dave Schmidt:the best part of your life.
Dave Schmidt:Next up in the episode, Josh talks about employer matching
Dave Schmidt:and profit sharing, two great benefits of these employer
Dave Schmidt:sponsored retirement plans.
Dave Schmidt:We then follow that up by talking about the ways your
Dave Schmidt:money can get into a 401k plan, and how you can get your
Dave Schmidt:money out of, a 401k plan.
Josh Bretl:Now let's talk about how money goes in.
Josh Bretl:It has to come out of your paycheck, you can't write
Josh Bretl:a check for it, it's got to come out of your paycheck
Josh Bretl:as a payroll deduction.
Josh Bretl:And it can go either in pre-tax, you know traditional 401ks.
Josh Bretl:Or most 401ks now actually offer Roth options too, you
Josh Bretl:can put money in post-tax.
Josh Bretl:Now, you have that choice.
Josh Bretl:Now how you get money out is plan dependent, but
Josh Bretl:there are also IRS rules.
Josh Bretl:One of the big IRS rules is the 59 and a half rule.
Josh Bretl:So when you take money out, if you take it out prior to age
Josh Bretl:59 and a half, you are going to pay a penalty on that money.
Josh Bretl:If it's a traditional distribution, it's going to
Josh Bretl:be taxed plus the penalty.
Josh Bretl:If it's a Roth distribution, the gains will be
Josh Bretl:taxed plus the penalty.
Dave Schmidt:Now, there are some exceptions to those
Dave Schmidt:penalties, which we do bring up.
Dave Schmidt:And to end our conversation on 401ks, Josh and I talk
Dave Schmidt:about the pros and the cons to employers offering multiple
Dave Schmidt:401k investment options.
Dave Schmidt:These options have given the average Joe power to
Dave Schmidt:make some pretty serious investment choices.
Dave Schmidt:And if you're unable to remove emotion from the equation,
Dave Schmidt:you could be looking at some pretty stressful times ahead.
Josh Bretl:Now, the market and "professional investors",
Josh Bretl:they're really good at taking emotion out of the equation.
Josh Bretl:They're not selling when it's low and buying when it's high,
Josh Bretl:they're making good decisions, but it's not their money.
Josh Bretl:So when they created these 401k plans and they gave
Josh Bretl:people the ability to put money away, what they also
Josh Bretl:did is they gave people the problem where they had to watch
Josh Bretl:their money go up and down.
Josh Bretl:So people were making emotional decisions inside of 401k plans.
Josh Bretl:And I think people are starting to realize that this is
Josh Bretl:something that you can't just set it and forget it, you really
Josh Bretl:got to pay attention to it.
Josh Bretl:And at the same time, try and take emotion out of it
Josh Bretl:as much as humanly possible.
Dave Schmidt:We end our 401k conversation talking about
Dave Schmidt:in-service distributions.
Dave Schmidt:And as always, we have to have some fun because no one's got
Dave Schmidt:time to listen to a boring financial podcast, uh uh!
Dave Schmidt:And speaking of we, who am I?
Dave Schmidt:Hey, I'm Dave.
Dave Schmidt:Josh's longtime friend, co-host of the podcast and
Dave Schmidt:huge fan of the Buffalo Bills.
Dave Schmidt:With that being said, let me let you let me end my introduction
Dave Schmidt:so we can dig into all the nitty gritty of 401k plans.
Dave Schmidt:FSR Wealth Management is a registered investment advisor
Dave Schmidt:located in Elmhurst, Illinois.
Dave Schmidt:Information and opinions contained in this audio
Dave Schmidt:have been arrived at by FSR Wealth advisors.
Dave Schmidt:All information herein is for informational purposes
Dave Schmidt:and should not be construed as investment advice.
Dave Schmidt:It does not constitute an offer, a solicitation or recommendation
Dave Schmidt:to purchase any security.
Dave Schmidt:FSR is not providing legal, tax, accounting, or financial
Dave Schmidt:planning advice in this audio.
Dave Schmidt:These views are as of the date of this publication
Dave Schmidt:and are subject to change.
Josh Bretl:Erin and I just got back from one of our
Josh Bretl:annual conferences, Erin and Sean and I went, and it
Josh Bretl:was probably 1200 people.
Josh Bretl:600 ... Or 400 financial advisory offices.
Josh Bretl:And it was kind of a year end recap, get used to the new year.
Josh Bretl:And we actually got a compliment on the podcast.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, tell me more.
Josh Bretl:So, yeah, I was talking to one of the
Josh Bretl:guys I know there and he says, "I try and listen to
Josh Bretl:as many podcasts as I can."
Josh Bretl:And these are all financial advisor podcasts.
Josh Bretl:He goes, "Yours is the only one I actually enjoy listening to."
Josh Bretl:And he goes, "I've never met Dave, but I think
Josh Bretl:I'd like him a lot."
Dave Schmidt:Did he really say that?
Josh Bretl:He did.
Josh Bretl:Erin wasn't there for it, though.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Josh Bretl:Oh, this was awful, Dave.
Josh Bretl:So we get there, we're out in San Diego, it was beautiful.
Josh Bretl:Actually, that day it was raining miserably.
Josh Bretl:But we're staying at ... I'm not going to mention the hotel,
Josh Bretl:but we're staying at ... And it's a top brand hotel.
Josh Bretl:And we go to check in and about half an hour before we
Josh Bretl:got there, their internet and computer systems went down.
Dave Schmidt:That could be a problem.
Josh Bretl:It was a problem to the fact that that
Josh Bretl:was 10:30 in the morning.
Josh Bretl:We had a black tie, semi-formal event that evening.
Josh Bretl:We all had to get ready in other people's rooms and we
Josh Bretl:did not get our room until 10:30-11:00 that night.
Josh Bretl:So all three of us checked into our rooms.
Josh Bretl:So we checked in after the event was over with, and there was a
Josh Bretl:guy sitting there with an old school book with everything
Josh Bretl:printed out and names and he was calling the home office to
Josh Bretl:run credit cards and everything.
Josh Bretl:And the guy who was checking us in actually
Josh Bretl:had a smile on his face.
Josh Bretl:And I said to him, I go, " I'm sure you had a rough day.
Josh Bretl:How did this compare to other days?"
Josh Bretl:He goes, "Oh, there's nothing that compares to
Josh Bretl:what we went through today."
Dave Schmidt:wow.
Dave Schmidt:How about that?
Josh Bretl:So that was ... How you rely on internet
Josh Bretl:and all that stuff, so.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, totally.
Dave Schmidt:I was kind of having FOMO about not going until you mentioned
Dave Schmidt:black tie event, then I kind of dry heaved a little and I said,
Dave Schmidt:"Yeah, not a place for me."
Dave Schmidt:Because I'd have to rent something that's
Dave Schmidt:qualified as black tie.
Josh Bretl:Well, black suits work too.
Josh Bretl:Wait a second.
Dave Schmidt:I don't have a black suit.
Josh Bretl:I think the last time I wore this black suit
Josh Bretl:was to last year's event.
Dave Schmidt:Well, sounds really fancy.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, yeah.
Josh Bretl:David, how are you?
Dave Schmidt:Josh, I'm not having my gallbladder removed
Dave Schmidt:tomorrow, so better than you.
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Josh Bretl:So we're rushing in to get an episode in because I don't
Josh Bretl:know how long I'll be laid up.
Josh Bretl:They're going to suck one of my organs out of
Josh Bretl:my stomach tomorrow, so.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:You know, Cometeer, I haven't said hello to you in a while.
Dave Schmidt:And this is the Klatch roaster, I think it's a CBC blend.
Dave Schmidt:It's delicious, Josh.
Dave Schmidt:It's a dark roast.
Dave Schmidt:And we have not given him a shout-out in a
Dave Schmidt:while, yet I continue to drink a delicious coffee.
Josh Bretl:You should.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Thank you.
Josh Bretl:For Christmas, Santa thought it would
Josh Bretl:be a good idea to get the kids a karaoke machine.
Josh Bretl:Specifically, Maggie received said karaoke machine.
Josh Bretl:You know what Maggie does when she gets a microphone?
Dave Schmidt:Yells?
Josh Bretl:Yells.
Josh Bretl:Turns the volume to max and screams into the microphone.
Josh Bretl:But my son, Zachary, on the other hand, who is
Josh Bretl:a quiet boy, uses the microphone to antagonize
Josh Bretl:his brother and sister.
Josh Bretl:And he sits outside their bedroom door and he starts
Josh Bretl:talking really quietly and really irritating,
Josh Bretl:and it's usually probably some sort of poop joke.
Dave Schmidt:My man.
Josh Bretl:And the volume gets louder and louder and
Josh Bretl:louder to the point where he's like just going so fast.
Josh Bretl:And especially his brother just loses his mind at him and
Josh Bretl:... That was so me as a child.
Dave Schmidt:And Zach and I, we're starting our
Dave Schmidt:harmonica band soon, right?
Josh Bretl:So Alex is starting to take guitar
Josh Bretl:lessons, this Thursday is his first guitar lesson, and
Josh Bretl:Zach's mad that they won't give him harmonica lessons.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, poor Zachy.
Dave Schmidt:Josh, we had some ... I mean, I can't even count the
Dave Schmidt:amount of DMs and responses we had to episode 29.
Dave Schmidt:It was ... If you remember, it was IRA contributions,
Dave Schmidt:401ks and things of the sort.
Dave Schmidt:So I was chatting with Erin over coffee one day, like we
Dave Schmidt:do, and she suggested that we dive deep into 401ks.
Josh Bretl:401ks.
Dave Schmidt:Ba-bum.
Josh Bretl:Boom.
Dave Schmidt:Does that sound pretty good?
Josh Bretl:I think 401k talk will be a fun one.
Dave Schmidt:I agree.
Josh Bretl:So Dave, do you know what ... Like when they
Josh Bretl:say 401k, where'd they get ... What does that name mean?
Josh Bretl:Where does it come from?
Josh Bretl:Any idea?
Dave Schmidt:I figured it'd be maybe like the area
Dave Schmidt:code of some congressman that came up with the name.
Josh Bretl:That's actually a legitimate guess.
Josh Bretl:But it is the subsection of the Internal Revenue Code
Josh Bretl:where they talk about the tax rules associated with
Josh Bretl:... Alex: Hashtag tax nerd.
Josh Bretl:These.
Josh Bretl:So they said, "Let's just call them 401ks."
Josh Bretl:Because that's what the tax code is called, so.
Dave Schmidt:Not creative at all, but effective.
Josh Bretl:No, not at all.
Josh Bretl:So 401ks are what we refer to as employer
Josh Bretl:sponsored retirement plans.
Josh Bretl:So you can't put money into your 401K unless
Josh Bretl:your employer says you can put money into your 401k.
Josh Bretl:They set all the rules for it.
Josh Bretl:Now, 401K plans, they are a savings vehicle.
Josh Bretl:They're designed for people to save for their retirement.
Josh Bretl:It was an alternative to pension plans, we talked
Josh Bretl:about how pensions went away in the last episode.
Josh Bretl:And it's designed to give people freedom and they wanted
Josh Bretl:to give people tax benefits for saving into their 401ks.
Josh Bretl:And the only way, like I said, for you personally to put money
Josh Bretl:into your own 401k, is for your employer to have one set up.
Josh Bretl:Now most employers have one; big or small, most
Josh Bretl:employers have a 401k.
Josh Bretl:Now there's other ways that money can get in there.
Josh Bretl:Your employer can also put money in on your behalf, you can put
Josh Bretl:money in ... There's a variety of ways that they can do that.
Josh Bretl:But that's a good thing.
Dave Schmidt:Like matching.
Josh Bretl:There can be matching.
Josh Bretl:So for matching, is an example of ... They'll do a percentage.
Josh Bretl:So they may do a dollar for dollar match up to 3%.
Josh Bretl:So for example, if you made $100,000, if you put 3% of your
Josh Bretl:salary in, which is $3,000, they would match $3,000.
Josh Bretl:If you put in 5,000, they're only going to match three.
Josh Bretl:So that's a matching percentage there.
Dave Schmidt:Cool.
Josh Bretl:And they have all sorts of ways they structure
Josh Bretl:that; that could be a 50% up to 6%, it could be a 100% up to
Josh Bretl:12%, there's all sorts of ways that they can structure that.
Josh Bretl:Now the other thing they have is what they call
Josh Bretl:profit sharing contributions.
Josh Bretl:So profit sharing contributions are not matching, they
Josh Bretl:will put them in whether you put money in or not.
Josh Bretl:So a profit sharing contribution could be 3%.
Josh Bretl:So they'll say if you make $100,000, they're
Josh Bretl:going to put $3,000 in whether you like it or not.
Josh Bretl:Which ... That's a good problem to have.
Josh Bretl:And there's other small ... Safe harbor and
Josh Bretl:different things like that.
Josh Bretl:But those are the two big ones for the employer.
Josh Bretl:Now, the employer doesn't want you to put your money
Josh Bretl:in and leave right away.
Josh Bretl:They want to reward long-term employees.
Josh Bretl:So 401K rules ... By the way, the rules are governed
Josh Bretl:by what they call ERISA.
Josh Bretl:ERISA is the special Department of Labor
Josh Bretl:rules that govern 401ks.
Josh Bretl:So they say what you're allowed to do as an employer and what
Josh Bretl:you're not allowed to do.
Dave Schmidt:Not to be mistaken with the famous
Dave Schmidt:actress Alyssa Milano.
Dave Schmidt:Totally different thing.
Josh Bretl:No, this is ERISA.
Dave Schmidt:ERISA.
Josh Bretl:ERISA.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Mm-hmm.
Dave Schmidt:Sure.
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Josh Bretl:It's like Madonna, one name.
Dave Schmidt:Oh right, yeah.
Josh Bretl:But these companies don't want you to
Josh Bretl:just kind of randomly take your money out, so they have
Josh Bretl:rules that are in there.
Josh Bretl:And one of the rules is they can put a vesting schedule.
Josh Bretl:So a vesting schedule is you have to work there so long for
Josh Bretl:this money to all be yours.
Josh Bretl:Now, some of it they call vesting immediately, and
Josh Bretl:so that would be a safe harbor contribution or
Josh Bretl:something along those lines.
Josh Bretl:But some could have a 2, 3, 4 year vesting schedule.
Josh Bretl:So if you leave before that time period
Josh Bretl:... Dave Schmidt: I'm sorry.
Josh Bretl:I don't even know what you're laughing at.
Dave Schmidt:I'm thinking of something I want to say
Dave Schmidt:and it's so stupid, but it's going to be funny.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Dave Schmidt:Oh god.
Josh Bretl:You know what it does to my self-esteem when I'm
Josh Bretl:talking about vesting schedules and you just laugh at me?
Dave Schmidt:I know.
Dave Schmidt:Oh gosh.
Dave Schmidt:Oh.
Dave Schmidt:All right.
Josh Bretl:It's not going to be nearly as funny now.
Josh Bretl:You know that, right?
Dave Schmidt:No, I know it won't be.
Dave Schmidt:I don't even know if I'm going to say it now,
Dave Schmidt:but ... Vesting schedules.
Dave Schmidt:Yes.
Dave Schmidt:Go ahead.
Josh Bretl:So I have one really important thing to
Josh Bretl:add to vesting schedules.
Josh Bretl:Vesting only applies to the employer money.
Josh Bretl:Any money that you put in is 100% invested day one,
Josh Bretl:they can't keep any of that.
Dave Schmidt:They care what type of vest you wear?
Dave Schmidt:Like sweater vests or
Dave Schmidt:...? Josh Bretl: Is that really
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, yeah.
Josh Bretl:Was that as funny as you had?
Josh Bretl:Was that all that giant laugh was a sweater vest?
Dave Schmidt:In my head, it was really funny, but
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: No,
Dave Schmidt:Oh, that's nice.
Josh Bretl:They can't ... I don't think clothing
Josh Bretl:type is a discriminatory allowed by ERISA, one name.
Dave Schmidt:Right.
Dave Schmidt:Not Milano.
Josh Bretl:Now let's talk about how money goes in.
Josh Bretl:It has to come out of your paycheck, you can't write
Josh Bretl:a check for it, it's got to come out of your paycheck
Josh Bretl:as a payroll deduction.
Josh Bretl:And it can go either in pre-tax, which means the money is yet to
Josh Bretl:be taxed, it's a traditional, like we talked about in the
Josh Bretl:last episode, traditional IRAs, we have traditional you know
Josh Bretl:traditional Or most 401ks now actually offer Roth options too,
Josh Bretl:you can put money in post-tax.
Josh Bretl:Now, you have that choice.
Josh Bretl:Your employer doesn't have as much choices.
Josh Bretl:There is a new law that just went through, Secure
Josh Bretl:Act 2.0, they're trying to ... It's changing some
Josh Bretl:of that a little bit.
Josh Bretl:We'll go into more details on this in a future episode.
Josh Bretl:But most times employer money is always pre-tax.
Josh Bretl:So whenever employer money comes out, it will always be taxed.
Josh Bretl:Employee money, you could be traditional or
Josh Bretl:it could be Roth there.
Josh Bretl:Now let's talk about how you get money out.
Josh Bretl:Because the only reason you would put money in
Josh Bretl:is because someday you want to take money out.
Dave Schmidt:Not because you just want to give your
Dave Schmidt:employer extra money, but
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:And that's actually a common misconception, and
Dave Schmidt:I'm glad you said that.
Dave Schmidt:You're never giving the employer money.
Dave Schmidt:The employer can't take this money.
Dave Schmidt:The employer can't do anything with this money.
Dave Schmidt:This is money set aside for your behalf, It's not the employer's.
Dave Schmidt:But they do make the rules to when you can get money out.
Dave Schmidt:Is that fair?
Dave Schmidt:Mm-hmm.
Dave Schmidt:Fair.
Josh Bretl:So now how you get money out is plan dependent,
Josh Bretl:but there are also IRS rules.
Josh Bretl:One of the big IRS rules is the 59 and a half rule.
Josh Bretl:So when you take money out, if you take it out prior to age
Josh Bretl:59 and a half, you are going to pay a penalty on that money.
Josh Bretl:Now if it's a traditional distribution, you're going
Josh Bretl:to take money, it's going to be taxed plus the penalty.
Josh Bretl:If it's a Roth distribution, the gains will be
Josh Bretl:taxed plus the penalty.
Dave Schmidt:So potentially more?
Josh Bretl:No, just the gains, not the whole thing.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Josh Bretl:All right?
Josh Bretl:Now, there are some exceptions to the rule.
Josh Bretl:So medical expenses, disability, higher education expenses,
Josh Bretl:those are some common exceptions that are out there.
Josh Bretl:So you can pay for ... Well a common one will often be if
Josh Bretl:you're paying for your kid's school or your own schooling,
Josh Bretl:you can actually take the money out to a certain dollar amount
Josh Bretl:and use that for tuition.
Josh Bretl:So without paying the 10% penalty that's out there.
Dave Schmidt:So Carla being a government employee, 403b
Dave Schmidt:is the equivalent of a 401k?
Josh Bretl:Yeah, the rules are virtually identical.
Josh Bretl:There are small nuance-y differences, but it's
Josh Bretl:pretty much a ... A 403b is generally a 401k for
Josh Bretl:nonprofits, if you will.
Dave Schmidt:Because she's been taking out 1,500 to
Dave Schmidt:2,000 per month for my private harmonica lessons.
Dave Schmidt:So I mean, we won't be penalized for that, right?
Josh Bretl:It depends if your private harmonica lessons
Josh Bretl:are a licensed institution that ... Of higher education.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, it's at Harvard.
Josh Bretl:Oh, yeah.
Dave Schmidt:It's at Harvard school of music.
Josh Bretl:They're renowned harmonica teachers.
Josh Bretl:And it's really taking that long, huh?
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Well I was actually enrolled at Julliard, but I don't
Dave Schmidt:know, it was just a little too intense to manage both.
Josh Bretl:Did you just say Julliard?
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, I did.
Dave Schmidt:Are you questioning an artsy guy on how to
Dave Schmidt:pronounce and arts school?
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Josh Bretl:It sounded like ... I mean it sounded like a
Josh Bretl:true south side Chicagoan, like, "Is that Julliard?"
Dave Schmidt:oh gosh.
Dave Schmidt:Julliard.
Dave Schmidt:Not the Jewel's, for our south side friends, but Julliard.
Josh Bretl:I was wondering where that was coming from.
Dave Schmidt:Cool.
Dave Schmidt:So in other words, I mean, yeah, my harmonica lessons
Dave Schmidt:are probably covered because it's higher education.
Josh Bretl:Oh God.
Josh Bretl:So let's talk about what happens to your money once
Josh Bretl:you get into the 401k.
Josh Bretl:So you have investment choices.
Josh Bretl:Once the money goes inside your account and your 401k,
Josh Bretl:it's going to sit inside something and you're going
Josh Bretl:to have investment choices.
Josh Bretl:The choices of investments you have are determined
Josh Bretl:by the company.
Dave Schmidt:Your employer.
Josh Bretl:Your employer gets to determine that.
Josh Bretl:Now, they have to give you a certain number of options,
Josh Bretl:they have to be able to cover a broad enough spectrum.
Josh Bretl:Usually you'll see mutual funds, that's the most
Josh Bretl:common investment under the sun that's inside of 401ks.
Dave Schmidt:Is there a reason for that?
Josh Bretl:It's an easier diversification tool.
Josh Bretl:People are familiar with it.
Josh Bretl:One of the problems with 401k plans is it is allowing the
Josh Bretl:average Joe to make some pretty serious investment choices.
Josh Bretl:There was a study done in the early 2000s that talked about
Josh Bretl:the difference between what the average 401k participant earned
Josh Bretl:and what " the market" earned.
Josh Bretl:So going into the early 2000s, and this is coinciding with when
Josh Bretl:I started my career too, so this was really top of mind, there
Josh Bretl:was a lot of talk about the historical return to the market;
Josh Bretl:the market earns 7.5%, the market earns whatever it earns.
Josh Bretl:And there was complaints coming from 401k participants because
Josh Bretl:they weren't earning as much.
Josh Bretl:Now, the market and "professional investors",
Josh Bretl:they're really good at taking emotion out of the equation
Josh Bretl:They're not selling when it's low and buying when it's high,
Josh Bretl:they're making good decisions, but it's not their money.
Josh Bretl:So when they created these 401k plans and they gave
Josh Bretl:people the ability to put money away, what they also
Josh Bretl:did is they gave people the problem where they had to watch
Josh Bretl:their money go up and down.
Josh Bretl:So people were making emotional decisions inside of 401k plans.
Josh Bretl:now mutual funds have always been around for this because
Josh Bretl:they wanted people to diversify, they wanted people ... It's
Josh Bretl:an easier way than trying to build your own equity portfolio
Josh Bretl:or your own bond portfolio or things along those lines.
Josh Bretl:Now what they've come out with in the last 15 years
Josh Bretl:or so is these what they call target date funds.
Josh Bretl:So it's more time-based.
Josh Bretl:And I'm not a huge fan of them, but for some people they're an
Josh Bretl:okay thing that's out there.
Josh Bretl:So typically we have just mutual funds.
Josh Bretl:Now in recent years, 401ks, a lot of them have been opening up
Josh Bretl:the world of investment choices.
Josh Bretl:So they've been saying, "Hey, you can go out and
Josh Bretl:invest in whatever you want."
Josh Bretl:Which is good and bad.
Josh Bretl:It can be very dangerous.
Josh Bretl:This is real money.
Josh Bretl:So your money goes up, your money really does go up.
Josh Bretl:And if that money goes down, that's That hurts.
Josh Bretl:Deciding where your money goes is something that you
Josh Bretl:should be looking at on a constant basis, something
Josh Bretl:an advisor should be looking at a constant basis for you.
Josh Bretl:It's something that, to be quite honest, over the last
Josh Bretl:10 years hasn't been that hard because the market still
Josh Bretl:has been able to trade up, except for the last 12 months.
Josh Bretl:And I think people are starting to realize that this is
Josh Bretl:something that you can't just set it and forget it, you really
Josh Bretl:got to pay attention to it.
Josh Bretl:And at the same time, try and take emotion out of it
Josh Bretl:as much as humanly possible.
Josh Bretl:Let's talk about how we get money out.
Josh Bretl:All right?
Josh Bretl:That cool?
Josh Bretl:Can we do that?
Dave Schmidt:Oh, you're asking me if I want to know how I
Dave Schmidt:can get money out of my 401k?
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:That's a question I often get asked.
Dave Schmidt:So like yeah, I should probably know the answer to this.
Josh Bretl:So you've got the money in, you've invested it,
Josh Bretl:it's grown, and now you want the money out for whatever reason.
Josh Bretl:So there is always two times you can take money out.
Josh Bretl:Always.
Josh Bretl:One is when you leave the company.
Josh Bretl:When you leave the employer, they're always required to
Josh Bretl:let you take the money out.
Josh Bretl:All right?
Josh Bretl:The other is if you are dead.
Dave Schmidt:Oh.
Dave Schmidt:So then you're not technically personally
Dave Schmidt:taking the money out, but
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: No, no.
Dave Schmidt:But somebody else is.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Josh Bretl:Other than that, they can kind of set the rules.
Josh Bretl:So there's a few rules that quite often they
Josh Bretl:will allow you to do.
Josh Bretl:One is 401k loans.
Josh Bretl:So a loan is while you're still working.
Josh Bretl:A loan, if you take one, is eligible to
Josh Bretl:anyone who works there.
Josh Bretl:And it's exactly what it sounds like, you are loaning money
Josh Bretl:out of your 401k to yourself.
Josh Bretl:You're allowed to do a maximum of $50,000, and there's a
Josh Bretl:rate that you have to pay it back at, and it's usually
Josh Bretl:tied to the prime rate in some way, shape, or form.
Josh Bretl:But it is taken out of your paycheck.
Josh Bretl:Traditionally, you have to pay it back within five years.
Josh Bretl:So some companies make it shorter, but the longest you
Josh Bretl:can make it is five years.
Josh Bretl:And they take it out of your paycheck in equal installments.
Josh Bretl:So they amortize it like any other loan would be there.
Josh Bretl:Now, there's good and bad to this.
Josh Bretl:If you're going to take this loan out to waste the
Josh Bretl:money, it's not worth it.
Josh Bretl:But if you need this money, this can be a good spot to go because
Josh Bretl:of the fact that that interest goes back to you as well.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, it does?
Josh Bretl:So you get the interest, you get
Josh Bretl:the repayments, those go back into your account.
Dave Schmidt:so now if I'm paying an interest,
Dave Schmidt:let's say of 8%, actually I'm paying myself that 8%?
Josh Bretl:Yeah, the 8% does go back to you.
Josh Bretl:Now, there are loan fees, they charge you to take loans
Josh Bretl:out sometimes because there's administrative tasks that go
Josh Bretl:with it, but that's there.
Josh Bretl:Now you have to realize though, if for some reason you stop
Josh Bretl:making loan repayments like you get fired or you leave
Josh Bretl:or you quit for whatever reason, you have 60 days to
Josh Bretl:pay the whole thing back.
Josh Bretl:And if you don't pay it back, it's like you took
Josh Bretl:it out of your 401k, it's like a distribution.
Josh Bretl:So if you're under 59 and a half, you have to worry about
Josh Bretl:the 10% penalty and the tax.
Josh Bretl:And if you're over 59 and a half, you still have the
Josh Bretl:tax that comes due on it.
Dave Schmidt:So would it make sense, would anybody ever take
Dave Schmidt:a loan out while also still contributing to their 401k?
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:You can do both?
Josh Bretl:You can do both.
Josh Bretl:It does make a lot of sense.
Josh Bretl:The loan is only there if there's a need for you
Josh Bretl:to take that money out.
Josh Bretl:If you're going to buy a new car and that car is $30,000
Josh Bretl:and you can pay the bank 7% or you can pay yourself 7%,
Josh Bretl:I'd rather pay myself 7%.
Josh Bretl:So
Josh Bretl:... Dave Schmidt: Interesting.
Josh Bretl:Okay.
Josh Bretl:Now, if it's ... You're going to waste it on
Josh Bretl:something, it's not worth it, that doesn't make any sense.
Josh Bretl:Or you have credit card debt you want to pay off and consolidate,
Josh Bretl:it's not a bad way to do that.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Josh Bretl:But let's talk about in-service distributions.
Josh Bretl:We see this a lot in our office.
Josh Bretl:And this is people who are getting ready for retirement.
Josh Bretl:And in-service distributions, in-service just means you're
Josh Bretl:still working and distributions are ways to take money out.
Josh Bretl:Now this is ... You can do anything you want with this.
Josh Bretl:What we generally see in our office is they will take
Josh Bretl:an in-service distribution to roll it to an IRA.
Josh Bretl:And your company has to allow in-service distributions,
Josh Bretl:and you have to be older than 59 and a half to do it.
Dave Schmidt:To do it.
Josh Bretl:But if your company allows it, and most
Josh Bretl:do, you can take the money out.
Josh Bretl:And when you roll it to an IRA, then you have complete control.
Josh Bretl:You can control what your investment choices are, what
Josh Bretl:your Roth conversions are, you have complete control.
Josh Bretl:Unlike in the 401k, where you do have Your hands are
Josh Bretl:tied to what the company says you're allowed to do.
Josh Bretl:So these in-service distributions can be really
Josh Bretl:valuable for people who are getting ready to retire.
Josh Bretl:We use them a lot as people ... Like I said, as
Josh Bretl:people start coming on board with us and they still have
Josh Bretl:another year or two of working.
Josh Bretl:It's a way to jumpstart and get their planning going
Josh Bretl:that's necessary for them, so.
Dave Schmidt:And you can take like chunks out, right?
Dave Schmidt:You don't have to ... It's not an all or nothing
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: Correct.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Josh Bretl:Correct.
Josh Bretl:We'll sit down and we can say, "Hey, let's leave
Josh Bretl:this much in your 401k.
Josh Bretl:We'll move this much to your IRA with in-service distributions."
Josh Bretl:And then when they retire, then we'll take the final
Josh Bretl:distribution, and roll the rest of that to an IRA.
Josh Bretl:And when you go from a 401k to an IRA, that
Josh Bretl:is a tax-free transfer.
Josh Bretl:So it is a relatively easy thing to do.
Dave Schmidt:Hmm.
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Dave Schmidt:And limits on how often you can do it or how
Dave Schmidt:many times you can do it?
Josh Bretl:That's set by the company.
Josh Bretl:It's one of those rules that the company is allowed to set.
Josh Bretl:the US government has a limit that you're
Josh Bretl:allowed to do that once.
Dave Schmidt:Once?
Josh Bretl:Just once.
Dave Schmidt:Really?
Josh Bretl:Mm-hmm.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, okay.
Josh Bretl:But certain companies will allow you to do
Josh Bretl:it over and over and over again.
Josh Bretl:401ks can be quite ... Not quite, 401ks are the
Josh Bretl:single biggest savings tool that Americans have.
Josh Bretl:Most people use them, very few people know how to do it
Josh Bretl:effectively and they let a lot of emotion come into play.
Josh Bretl:And they also think they don't have a choice of what they can
Josh Bretl:or can't be doing with it as they get closer to retirement.
Dave Schmidt:From an employer perspective, Josh, other
Dave Schmidt:than being a great benefit to employees to offer a 401k
Dave Schmidt:like matching plan, what other benefit to an employer
Dave Schmidt:are there to offer 401ks?
Dave Schmidt:And they're not required to do it by law, but what
Dave Schmidt:are some other perks for
Dave Schmidt:...? Josh Bretl: For bigger
Dave Schmidt:about employee benefits.
Dave Schmidt:Is that what it is?
Josh Bretl:It's all trying to make employees happy.
Josh Bretl:For smaller employers, there's some tax things that they can
Josh Bretl:do and some things that may benefit the owners as well.
Josh Bretl:But again, the ERISA governs that and wants to make sure
Josh Bretl:that the benefit is equal to everybody, not just to the high
Josh Bretl:income earners or to the owners.
Josh Bretl:But for bigger plans, it's all about employee benefits.
Dave Schmidt:Right on.
Dave Schmidt:So during my research for this episode, Josh,
Dave Schmidt:I came across something.
Dave Schmidt:Have you ever heard of the 401zzz?
Josh Bretl:No.
Dave Schmidt:You haven't?
Josh Bretl:No, is that a tax code?
Dave Schmidt:No.
Dave Schmidt:The ZZZ stands for snooze fest, because you've been talking
Dave Schmidt:about 401ks for way too long.
Josh Bretl:Oh, man.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:What?
Dave Schmidt:What?
Dave Schmidt:Okay.
Dave Schmidt:Hey Mr.
Dave Schmidt:Josh, let's take a break.
Dave Schmidt:You've been talking for so long and my ears are sore.
Dave Schmidt:Let's not make them snore, listening shouldn't be a chore.
Dave Schmidt:So let's get to know Josh and Dave, and
Dave Schmidt:watch our ratings soar.
Josh Bretl:Cackaw!
Dave Schmidt:I didn't even have to ask you.
Dave Schmidt:So I am awfully proud of myself for coming up with the 401zzz,
Dave Schmidt:because I thought it was clever.
Dave Schmidt:I didn't get the guffaws that I thought I would from it, but
Dave Schmidt:I figured, hey, you know what?
Dave Schmidt:I am so well informed on 401ks.
Dave Schmidt:It's now time to pick a card.
Josh Bretl:So let's pick a card, Dave.
Dave Schmidt:Let's do it.
Josh Bretl:Let's pick a card.
Dave Schmidt:Mm-hmm.
Josh Bretl:All right.
Josh Bretl:This one
Josh Bretl:... Dave Schmidt: Wait, is Alyssa
Josh Bretl:No?
Josh Bretl:No, no.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, okay.
Josh Bretl:I'm not going to long and ramble the
Josh Bretl:entry to this card, I'm just going to ask it to you.
Josh Bretl:If you could make one of your hobbies into a profession,
Josh Bretl:which one would it be?
Dave Schmidt:Ooh, I've been talking a lot
Dave Schmidt:about harmonica playing.
Dave Schmidt:I don't think I'm quite at that point yet.
Josh Bretl:There's not many harmonica players in the
Josh Bretl:world that have actually made any money off of it.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, in the show notes I'll post
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: I mean
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:I'll post some links to some of my favorite
Dave Schmidt:modern harmonica-ists.
Josh Bretl:Oh, I'm sure our audience will be clicking
Josh Bretl:on those like crazy.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, of course.
Dave Schmidt:All right, Josh.
Dave Schmidt:So the question is, if I could turn any of
Dave Schmidt:my hobbies into a paid profession, what would it be?
Josh Bretl:Mm-hmm.
Dave Schmidt:I'd probably take my love and mastery
Dave Schmidt:of video games and make it into a profession.
Dave Schmidt:But not just video games, I'm talking about like
Dave Schmidt:80s and 90s arcades.
Dave Schmidt:Like Rampage, I could set all sorts of world records
Dave Schmidt:for Rampage and I bet you ... I'm on to something.
Dave Schmidt:People would pay to watch me play Rampage.
Dave Schmidt:Josh, I quit.
Dave Schmidt:I'm going to be a professional Rampage-ist.
Dave Schmidt:Thank you for the idea.
Josh Bretl:We grew up in the 80s and 90s and we had video
Josh Bretl:games, but the idea of making money off of them is so absurd.
Josh Bretl:And the fact that there are now legitimate video game
Josh Bretl:athletes out there ... You used to call yourself a video
Josh Bretl:game athlete, we used to make fun of you all the time.
Dave Schmidt:That's it.
Josh Bretl:Like you'd sit down and you play John
Josh Bretl:Madden Football and be like, "We're video game athletes."
Josh Bretl:And we'd be like, "Good god, go out and shoot a hoop."
Dave Schmidt:yeah.
Dave Schmidt:These kids are making millions of dollars by just
Dave Schmidt:a simple YouTube channel.
Josh Bretl:Yeah, it's crazy.
Josh Bretl:Absolutely crazy.
Dave Schmidt:Ah, I'm so jealous.
Josh Bretl:My hobby, it would actually be reliving
Josh Bretl:your childhood dream.
Josh Bretl:I'd want to be a chef.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah?
Josh Bretl:Oh yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Oh.
Josh Bretl:Oh, I love cooking and making people happy.
Josh Bretl:Maybe ... Maybe like a private chef, like in people's homes.
Josh Bretl:I want to see them smile when they eat.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, that's cool.
Dave Schmidt:I still think you and Scott Smith ... Scott, I love you man.
Dave Schmidt:I think you two, you could make a killer restaurant together.
Josh Bretl:Don't tempt Scott.
Josh Bretl:Scott wants to do that and
Josh Bretl:... Dave Schmidt: Does he still
Josh Bretl:Is that still his jam?
Josh Bretl:No, now he wants to do like a specialty coffee shop.
Josh Bretl:And he wants to have a couple really special baked items.
Josh Bretl:Like he wants to be known for coffee and the cinnamon
Josh Bretl:rolls, or something like that.
Josh Bretl:So, yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, cool.
Dave Schmidt:Josh, I would financially support your hobby of cooking.
Josh Bretl:The problem is I think I'd financially
Josh Bretl:support it too, so it's not really a good idea.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah, that's so true.
Dave Schmidt:I was sitting here drinking my Cometeer and
Dave Schmidt:... Dave relates to retirees.
Josh Bretl:You know how the
Josh Bretl:... Dave Schmidt: Yeah.
Josh Bretl:Oh, I talked over the "yeah" You'd figure 30 some
Josh Bretl:episodes in I'd stop doing that.
Josh Bretl:Do you know the get to know Josh and Dave, you sometimes
Josh Bretl:struggle to come up with an answer because you're
Josh Bretl:trying to think it through?
Josh Bretl:And you get a little nervous as I ask it?
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Josh Bretl:I get nervous every single time when
Josh Bretl:you're about to open your mouth for this section.
Dave Schmidt:I am going to say you have it much worse than
Dave Schmidt:I, because when you're reading a card ... I mean, yeah, I
Dave Schmidt:could get creative with it, but there's not much I could say.
Dave Schmidt:However, with this segment, anything goes, man.
Josh Bretl:So let's hear it.
Josh Bretl:What kind of relation do you have to 401ks
Josh Bretl:and retirees, David?
Dave Schmidt:I think it's fair to say every episode my
Dave Schmidt:Dave relates to retirees is a perfect one-to-one correlation
Dave Schmidt:to how a retiree feels about a certain topic, right?
Dave Schmidt:In this case, I mean
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: Perfect
Dave Schmidt:Perfect one-to-one correlation.
Dave Schmidt:You were teaching me earlier about what happens to your
Dave Schmidt:money inside of a 401k.
Dave Schmidt:And essentially what I gathered from that was employees, we
Dave Schmidt:have options as to how to invest that money, right?
Dave Schmidt:But we're not given too many options.
Dave Schmidt:We're given three to a dozen different options, right?
Josh Bretl:Mm-hmm.
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Well, retirees, soon to be retirees, I get it.
Dave Schmidt:We're on the same wavelength.
Dave Schmidt:When Josh, my buddy over here, takes me to a new restaurant
Dave Schmidt:or a new bar, he knows that I get overwhelmed with new menus.
Josh Bretl:You're right, you do.
Dave Schmidt:I do.
Dave Schmidt:And Josh, I would say you have mastered and memorized
Dave Schmidt:the menu of every local eatery in this area, correct?
Josh Bretl:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:So what I'm saying is when I sit down with Josh, he'll
Dave Schmidt:be like, "David, either get option A, D or F."
Dave Schmidt:And he's like, "Those are only three things you'll
Dave Schmidt:like, choose one of them."
Dave Schmidt:I'm like, "Oh, I have a choice, but not too much of a choice."
Dave Schmidt:Just like you, dear friends, have a choice with your
Dave Schmidt:401k investment, but not too much of a choice.
Dave Schmidt:Has there never been a more perfect one-to-one match?
Dave Schmidt:Take it away, my man.
Josh Bretl:Dave?
Dave Schmidt:Yeah?
Josh Bretl:I appreciate that one.
Dave Schmidt:Thank you.
Josh Bretl:I actually think you sent me ... Can I
Josh Bretl:see your paper real quick?
Dave Schmidt:Sure.
Dave Schmidt:Which one?
Dave Schmidt:My notes?
Josh Bretl:The top one.
Josh Bretl:The top one there.
Josh Bretl:And I noticed Dave has notes here today, I've never really
Josh Bretl:noticed his notes before.
Josh Bretl:And I looked over at the top and I was like,
Josh Bretl:"What does that mean?
Josh Bretl:DR2R?"
Josh Bretl:Oh, you've abbreviated Dave relates to retirees.
Dave Schmidt:Yes, I have.
Dave Schmidt:DR2R.
Dave Schmidt:And with that, full house me, baby.
Josh Bretl:So I love helping people with their retirement.
Josh Bretl:I love to see them smile and you can see almost the
Josh Bretl:sense of relief and the sense of them feeling really
Josh Bretl:good after they come out of a good meeting with us.
Josh Bretl:You also heard in the get to know Josh and Dave section,
Josh Bretl:of my desire to cook for people and make a living.
Josh Bretl:Well your Dave relates to retirees kind of took
Josh Bretl:that two and combined it.
Josh Bretl:When you go to a restaurant, they give you a menu and
Josh Bretl:kind of when you ask the waiter, sometimes you'll say,
Josh Bretl:"Hey, what do you recommend?
Josh Bretl:What's best?"
Josh Bretl:But the waiter doesn't know you.
Josh Bretl:The waiter doesn't understand you.
Josh Bretl:And so they may recommend something, they may
Josh Bretl:say, "Hey, the scallops here are phenomenal."
Josh Bretl:But you're like, "I hate scallops."
Josh Bretl:So they don't really know you and how to do that.
Josh Bretl:Dave, you're right.
Josh Bretl:When you and I go out to eat, I know you so well that I am
Josh Bretl:going to recommend something that I think you will enjoy.
Josh Bretl:And I would say that sometimes I am like your advisor there.
Josh Bretl:I am like the one who's guiding you as to what you
Josh Bretl:would like and not like.
Josh Bretl:Now, ultimately it's your decision.
Josh Bretl:You may choose to eat the scallops anyways, but I
Josh Bretl:know that scallops make your tummy feel funny
Josh Bretl:and you don't like them.
Josh Bretl:Now, I think that's also what we do for clients.
Josh Bretl:They understand that they have lots of choices out
Josh Bretl:there and anyone could help them nail it down, but what
Josh Bretl:a good advisor will do for a retiree especially is get to
Josh Bretl:know that retiree so well so that those recommendations
Josh Bretl:are geared just for them.
Josh Bretl:And you're not eating scallops.
Josh Bretl:Now, I love scallops.
Josh Bretl:So I mean if you love scallops too, that's great.
Josh Bretl:But I think, Dave, you related to retirees better than you
Josh Bretl:have in any episode to date.
Dave Schmidt:That makes me happy to hear.
Dave Schmidt:Now, for our audience of one, I don't know about you, Erin, I
Dave Schmidt:have major goosebumps right now.
Dave Schmidt:That was one of the most eloquent, most beautifully
Dave Schmidt:spoken full house moments to date, in episode 30.
Josh Bretl:That's good, because I feel like we've
Josh Bretl:rambled a snot out of this show.
Dave Schmidt:We tend to ramble a lot.
Dave Schmidt:That's why we have the edit tool.
Dave Schmidt:So what we have not been really consistent with is
Dave Schmidt:asking our listeners, what to do at the end of the episode,
Dave Schmidt:like I have two things.
Dave Schmidt:Can I share?
Josh Bretl:Please.
Dave Schmidt:Sure.
Dave Schmidt:The first thing is I would recommend go watch some
Dave Schmidt:reruns of the original Charmed starring Alyssa Milano and
Dave Schmidt:just see how it relates to ERISA, whoever ERISA is, that
Dave Schmidt:Josh keeps talking about.
Dave Schmidt:Second, I would ... Look, I would love for you, dear
Dave Schmidt:listener, to refer on of your friends to pod.link/ref.
Dave Schmidt:We mentioned this last episode
Dave Schmidt:... Josh Bretl: Pod.link/ref?
Dave Schmidt:Mm-hmm.
Dave Schmidt:We don't control this webpage, but it is a really nice kind
Dave Schmidt:of one pager that is curated by some AI robot thingy, but it
Dave Schmidt:gives a great overview of our show and all of our episodes.
Dave Schmidt:And just send them there, pod.link/ref.
Dave Schmidt:You can also send an FSRwealth.com/podcast.
Dave Schmidt:Same thing.
Dave Schmidt:But send one of your friends there.
Josh Bretl:And hopefully they can get the enjoyment
Josh Bretl:out of the Retirement Equals Freedom Podcast
Josh Bretl:that you do, dear listener.
Dave Schmidt:Hey, is Alex allowed to listen to us yet?
Josh Bretl:Nope, not yet.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, poor Al.
Josh Bretl:Give him some time.
Josh Bretl:He'll be back in it.
Dave Schmidt:Yeah.
Dave Schmidt:Well, Al, let bygones be bye-gones.
Josh Bretl:Bye.
Dave Schmidt:Oh, gallbladders.
Josh Bretl:Or ... Dave?
Josh Bretl:Dave?
Dave Schmidt:Yeah?
Josh Bretl:Like my gallbladder, let's sign off.
Dave Schmidt:Oh.
Dave Schmidt:Oh my god.
Dave Schmidt:Josh, I'm so proud of you.
Dave Schmidt:Good one.
Dave Schmidt:That's the winner, winner, chicken dinner.