Artwork for podcast Star-Spangled Studies
S2E10 - 1920s
Episode 10 β€’ 1st August 2025 β€’ Star-Spangled Studies β€’ Dr. G.
00:00:00 00:48:10

Share Episode

Shownotes

Follow Along & Stay Connected

Stay connected with Dr. G and the podcast community:

πŸ“˜ Facebook

πŸ“Έ Instagram: @star_spangled_studies

Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and share Star-Spangled Studies with fellow history lovers!

Transcripts

Speaker:

The great war was over

the world in America.

2

:

With it had been irrevocably altered

and in its wake, a profound yearning

3

:

for calm, a return to simpler times

after war spread across the nation.

4

:

This sentiment found its voice in

the presidential campaign of:

5

:

and its champion in Warren g Harding.

6

:

He had a promise, his promise.

7

:

A return to normalcy.

8

:

America's present need is

not heroics, but healing.

9

:

Not nostros, but normalcy, not

revolution, but restoration.

10

:

Not agitation, but adjustment.

11

:

Not surgery, but serenity.

12

:

Not the dramatic but the dispassionate.

13

:

Not experiment, but

equipoise, not submergence.

14

:

In internationality.

15

:

But sustainment in triumphant nationality.

16

:

End quote, Harding's words

delivered to the home market

17

:

Club of Boston in May of 1920.

18

:

Struck a chord with the nation.

19

:

The nation was exhausted by the global

conflict, by the social reforms of

20

:

the progressive era and by a series of

domestic crises that seem to signal.

21

:

Anything but peace between 1918

and:

22

:

pandemic had claimed the lives of

nearly 700,000 Americans hitting

23

:

almost 20% of the population.

24

:

Lucian Van Vert, a Native American nurse

volunteering in Washington DC during the

25

:

pandemic wrote of Soldiers Dying by the

Dozens, that was her quote, and a city

26

:

where all public life, that means schools,

churches, theaters, had ground to a halt.

27

:

This was a trauma etch deep

in the national psyche.

28

:

Then there was the red summer of 1919,

a period of intense racial violence

29

:

that erupted in at least 25 cities,

including Chicago and Washington.

30

:

DC.

31

:

The Chicago race riot alone sparked by

the drowning of a black teenager named

32

:

Eugene Williams after he had crossed an

Ivis invisible line at a segregated beach.

33

:

It lasted 13 days, leaving 38 dead.

34

:

23 African Americans and 15 whites

while injuring over 500 more and leaving

35

:

a thousand black families homeless.

36

:

This wave of violence underscored the

raw, unresolved racial tension simmering

37

:

beneath the surface of American life.

38

:

Adding to the instability.

39

:

The immediate post-war period saw

an economic downturn with national

40

:

unemployment soaring to 20%, and farmers

facing catastrophic bankruptcy rate.

41

:

So Harding's call for normalcy was less

a reflection of the existing reality

42

:

and more of a potent political appeal

to a deep seated desire for respite.

43

:

But the very forces unleashed by the

war, the economic shifts, the experiences

44

:

of returning soldiers, the heightened

nationalisms and the widespread

45

:

disillusionment made a simple return

to the pre-war state and illusion.

46

:

I.

47

:

The war had mobilized American industry

and society on an unprecedented

48

:

scale, and these changes couldn't

be reversed, including the new roles

49

:

for women and other minorities, and

it just wasn't feasible to go back

50

:

to some kind of pre-war normal.

51

:

I.

52

:

The psychological scars of war

with the pandemic and the red scare

53

:

created a volatile social landscape.

54

:

Normalcy was the promise, but the

:

55

:

So to talk about the 1920s, this decade,

it cannot be understood in isolation.

56

:

It was profoundly shaped by the

legacy of the preceding eras.

57

:

The failures of reconstruction,

for instance, cast a long shadow.

58

:

The inability to secure, lasting

civil and economic rights for

59

:

African Americans in the South.

60

:

Leading to the entrenchment of Jim

Crow, the exploitative sharecropping

61

:

system, the pervasive racial terror

we've talked about in previous episodes.

62

:

Well, these directly fueled the great

migration as hundreds of thousands

63

:

of African-Americans move north,

seeking economic opportunity, as

64

:

well as an escape from southern

oppression, lynching violence.

65

:

They carried these unresolved national

wounds with them reshaping urban

66

:

centers, and they laid the groundwork

for a new cultural expression as well

67

:

as continued racial conflict even in the

North as the national archives itself.

68

:

Notes regarding this earlier exo

duster movement that we talked about.

69

:

The failure of reconstruction led to what

Carter g Woodson called quote slavery in

70

:

a modified form, and it compelled many

to seek refuge and opportunity elsewhere

71

:

in the nation away from the south.

72

:

This same dynamic propelled the

larger waves of this great migration.

73

:

Simultaneously, the industrial

behemoth that was forged in the Gilded

74

:

Age provided the technological and

nomic engine that powered the:

75

:

The era's newfound mass

production coming out of the war.

76

:

Its dazzling consumer goods.

77

:

Its sprawling cities.

78

:

Were all.

79

:

Built upon the foundations we talked

about, laid in the 19th century.

80

:

Yet the Gilded Age also gave a legacy

of vast inequality, bitter labor

81

:

disputes, and severe urban problems

like overcrowding and poor sanitation

82

:

issues that continue to provoke social

critique and demands for reform in the

83

:

1920s, which was called The New Era.

84

:

I've used this quote before, but I'll

use it again here, speaking about

85

:

the British author Rudyard Kipling,

who had visited Chicago in:

86

:

the height of the Gilded Age, and he

described a city quote, captivated

87

:

by technology and blinded by greed, a

huge wilderness of terrible streets.

88

:

And terrible people.

89

:

His words capture the mixture of awe

and unease that industrial modernity

90

:

inspired an ambivalence that would only

ntensify in the decade of the:

91

:

Therefore, the 1920s often dubbed the

roaring twenties, or the new era was

92

:

far from a simple return to normalcy.

93

:

Instead, it was a dynamic and deeply

contradictory decade, a cultural

94

:

and social battleground where the

forces of modernity clashed with

95

:

traditional values, where unprecedented

prosperity and technological

96

:

advancement existed alongside profound

social anxieties and where new

97

:

voices of liberation and artistic

expression challenge the old order.

98

:

In this episode, we'll explore these

tensions from the assembly lines and the

99

:

airwaves that reshaped American life to

the resurgence of the KKK and the culture

100

:

wars that sought to define what it meant

to be American, all while reconnecting

101

:

and connecting these developments to the

enduring legacies of the 19th century

102

:

reconstruction and industrialization.

103

:

So let's go.

104

:

So let's imagine if we can capture

the dynamism of the:

105

:

it might best be done by thinking

about the gleaming hood of a.

106

:

Ford Model T rolling off the

assembly line, ready to transform

107

:

the American landscape and

the very rhythm of daily life.

108

:

This was the machine age and

its gears were driven by mass

109

:

production, birthing a new consumer

republic, and at the forefront of

110

:

this transformation was Henry Ford.

111

:

His relentless pursuit of efficiency

through the moving assembly

112

:

line didn't just build cars.

113

:

It kind of built a new form

of America, the innovation.

114

:

First successfully implemented at

his Highland Park Assembly plant

115

:

in 1913, dramatically slashed the

time it took to build a Model T from

116

:

over 12 hours to a mere 93 minutes.

117

:

By 1914, by 1925 Ford's factories were

churning out up to 10,000 cars a day.

118

:

This incredible output.

119

:

Increase over the decade made the

automobile, which was once a luxury

120

:

accessible to the average American.

121

:

The price of a Model T also plummeted

in:

122

:

1924 because of the mass production.

123

:

Ford himself famously declared, quote, we

believe in making 25,000 men prosperous

124

:

and contented rather than follow the

plan of making a few slave drivers in

125

:

our establishment Multimillionaires.

126

:

End quote.

127

:

This was part of his justification

for the revolutionary $5 Workday,

128

:

which he introduced in 1914.

129

:

While seemingly altruistic, this move

was also a pragmatic response to the

130

:

grueling, monotonous nature of the

assembly line work, which had led to

131

:

a staggering 370% labor turnover rate.

132

:

I.

133

:

At his Highland Park factory.

134

:

The higher wage, though, initially

a profit sharing bonus with strings

135

:

attached Ford's sociological department

was even inspected workers' homes

136

:

to ensure they lived according

to company approved standards.

137

:

It did attract and retain workers.

138

:

It also can lead.

139

:

Turned his own employees

into potential customers.

140

:

While it was a pragmatic response

for the turnover, it also has to be

141

:

reviewed in the response to labor issues

and wanting to avoid strikes as well.

142

:

Ford was smart in that aspect.

143

:

The impact of the affordable automobile

was seismic industries like glass,

144

:

steel, and rubber boomed to meet

the production demands of more cars.

145

:

The very landscape of

America began to change.

146

:

As our textbook notes quote,

street, street carb suburbs

147

:

gave way to automobile suburbs.

148

:

End quote.

149

:

Families could now live further from

urban cores leading to an explosive growth

150

:

of suburban communities with developers

designing new homes complete with

151

:

driveways and garages for their new cars.

152

:

Rural life too was transformed.

153

:

The car began to erode the profound

isolation that had characterized much of

154

:

farm existence, a trip to town once and.

155

:

All day affair by a horse and wagon

can now be done in a matter of hours.

156

:

As one farm woman succinctly put it when

asked why her family bought a car before

157

:

getting indoor plumbing in their home.

158

:

Quote, why you can't go

to a town in the bathtub?

159

:

End quote.

160

:

By 1920, a third of American

farmers owned a car using it not

161

:

just for transportation, but also

for hauling goods and even as a

162

:

source of farm machinery power.

163

:

This new mobility fostered a

roadside culture up, started to pop.

164

:

Gas stations, diners, motels, and the

ubiquitous billboards, which sprang

165

:

up to cater to the traveling public,

auto camping, or gypsy as it was

166

:

called, became a popular pastime even

among the wealthy with figures like

167

:

Henry Ford and even President Harding.

168

:

Himself partaking in the activity.

169

:

So while the automobile started to

conquer physical distance, another

170

:

invention was conquering the ether.

171

:

The radio in the 1920s radio

transitioned from a tinkers

172

:

curiosity to a household necessity.

173

:

Sales skyrocketed from about $60

million in:

174

:

By 1929, that's a sevenfold increase,

and by that year, over 10 million

175

:

American households had a radio.

176

:

It was more than just

an entertainment device.

177

:

The radio became a powerful unifying

force as our textbook highlights

178

:

it, quote drew the nation together,

blunted regional differences and

179

:

imposed similar tastes in lifestyles.

180

:

End quote.

181

:

For the first time, Americans from

coast to coast could share the

182

:

same experiences simultaneously.

183

:

They could listen to the same news, the

same music, and hear the same stories.

184

:

The reach of the radio cannot be

understated because it was unprecedented.

185

:

It penetrated even the homes where

literacy was a barrier, something

186

:

that newspapers could not do.

187

:

The writer EB White would later

recall radio's impact on rural

188

:

communities, describing it as

almost a God-like presence.

189

:

The airwaves crackled with

a variety of programming.

190

:

Musical shows were immensely popular,

bringing jazz from Harlem's Cotton

191

:

Club performed by iconic artists

like Duke Ellington and Benny

192

:

Goodman to a national audience.

193

:

Comedy shows like Amos and Andy, despite.

194

:

Perpetuating very harmful racial

stereotypes became a national phenomenon.

195

:

News, political speeches,

and play-by-play.

196

:

Sports broadcasting also

filled the airwaves.

197

:

Transforming how Americans engage

with current events in leisure.

198

:

Sitting down and listening

to a ball game by the radio.

199

:

Still one of my favorite things to do.

200

:

The first live broadcast of presidential

election results occurred in:

201

:

on the station KDKA in Pittsburgh,

and by the:

202

:

four years later, radio had become

a significant campaign tool.

203

:

So this explosion of mass produced

goods and mass media created the fertile

204

:

ground for another booming industry.

205

:

Advertising our favorite

thing, we all love ads.

206

:

The 1920s saw advertising transform

from a largely informal service

207

:

to a powerful pervasive force.

208

:

The total advertising volume in the United

States grew from about 200 million in

209

:

1880 to nearly $3 billion in 1920, and

by:

210

:

in the advertising industry itself.

211

:

Advertisers began to employ sophisticated

psychological techniques and emotional

212

:

appeals to create a desire for products

moving beyond simply responding to demand.

213

:

To actively creating that demand.

214

:

The Listerine campaign, for

example, didn't just sell mouthwash.

215

:

It sold relief from a newly minted

social anxiety of halitosis.

216

:

Coca-Cola invited customers

to pause that refreshes.

217

:

As one contemporary observer noted

quote, advertisers were no longer

218

:

simply responding to demand.

219

:

They were creating the demand end quote.

220

:

This new culture of consumption was

further enabled by the widespread adoption

221

:

of also something new consumer credit.

222

:

The mantra, buy Now, pay later took hold.

223

:

Department stores offer generous

lines of credit and installments.

224

:

Plans made big ticket items like

the automobile and new household

225

:

appliances attainable for many middle

class families who couldn't afford to

226

:

buy them wholesale with a lump sum.

227

:

By the end of the decade, an astonishing

75% of cars were purchased on credit.

228

:

The economic engine of the

:

229

:

machine of interdependent parts.

230

:

Mass production, fueled by

industrial advancement, churned out

231

:

an unprecedented volume of goods.

232

:

Mass media, particularly the radio and

national magazines, created a unified

233

:

audience for advertisers who in turn

cultivated new desires and aspirations.

234

:

The consumer credit provided the

mechanism for these desires to be

235

:

translated into purchases to be consumed.

236

:

This cycle propelled a prosperity of the

roaring twenties, but it also embedded

237

:

a reliance on continuous consumption and

debt that would have profound consequences

238

:

when the economic wind shifted.

239

:

While these technologies fostered a

national culture by breaking down regional

240

:

barriers and exposing diverse populations

to shared products and media and news,

241

:

they also paradoxically contributed

to a new form of social segmentation.

242

:

I.

243

:

The automobile, for instance, facilitated

the growth of the suburbs, which often

244

:

became segregated by class radio programs

while creating the shared experiences,

245

:

sometimes did so by reinforcing harmful

stereotypes, particularly of African

246

:

Americans in shows like Amos and Andy.

247

:

Access to these new consumer goods

and technologies was not universal

248

:

and it often reflected and reinforced

existing class and racial divides.

249

:

Thus, the very tools for forging a

national culture were simultaneously.

250

:

Inscribing new lines of division.

251

:

Amidst the roar of the engines and

the crackle of radio waves, new voices

252

:

were rising, challenging the old

norms and forging fresh identities.

253

:

The 1920s was a period of

profound cultural ferment.

254

:

Nowhere more vibrantly expressed

than that in the Harlem Renaissance,

255

:

in the emergence of the new woman.

256

:

These movements didn't just reflect

the times they actively shaped them,

257

:

offering powerful critiques and

alternative visions of American life.

258

:

So let's start with

the Harlem Renaissance.

259

:

The great migration, that vast movement

of African Americans from the rural

260

:

south to the industrial north was

more than just a demographic shift.

261

:

It was a catalyst for

a cultural revolution.

262

:

Harlem in New York City became the

epicenter of this transformation.

263

:

Its black population exploded, growing

% between:

264

:

it grew to over 327,000 people.

265

:

As one contemporary account noted,

Harlem became a destination for

266

:

African Americans of all backgrounds.

267

:

They shared common experiences of slavery,

emancipation, and racial oppression,

268

:

as well as a determination to forge a

new identity as free people end quote.

269

:

This concentration of talent,

experience and aspiration created

270

:

the fertile ground for what became

known as the Harlem Renaissance.

271

:

Now a key intellectual architect

of the Harlem Renaissance in

272

:

this movement was Allain Locke.

273

:

In his seminal 1925 essay, entered

the new Negro Locke, proclaimed

274

:

that the arrival of a black populace

imbued with a new psychology and

275

:

undergoing a spiritual emancipation.

276

:

The old Negro as Locke argued, quote,

was a creature of moral debate and

277

:

historical controversy, more of a

formula than a human being End quote.

278

:

This new Negro by contrast was

shaking off, quote, the psychology

279

:

of imitation and implied inferiority.

280

:

This was a declaration of intellectual

and cultural independence.

281

:

This new spirit found powerful

expression in literature.

282

:

Men like Langston Hughes.

283

:

Perhaps he was the most iconic

poet of the Renaissance itself, and

284

:

he championed the beauty and the

resilience of everyday black life,

285

:

infusing his work with the rhythms of

jazz and blues in his:

286

:

Negro Artist and the Racial Mountain.

287

:

Hughes challenged black artists to

embrace their heritage and resist the

288

:

urge towards whiteness, the desire to

conform to white artistic standards.

289

:

He declared, quote, we younger Negro

artists who create now intend to

290

:

express our individual dark skinned

selves without fear or shame.

291

:

We build our temples for tomorrow strong

as we know how, and we stand on top

292

:

of the mountain free within ourselves.

293

:

End quote.

294

:

His poem entitled I too, captures the

spirit of this assertive belonging quote.

295

:

I too sing America.

296

:

I am the darker brother.

297

:

They send me to eat in the kitchen

when company comes, but I laugh

298

:

and I eat well and grow strong.

299

:

Tomorrow I'll be at the

table when the company comes.

300

:

End quote.

301

:

Zora Neil Hurston, another towering

figure celebrated southern black

302

:

folk culture and explored the

multifaceted identities of black women.

303

:

Her 1928 essay how it feels to be

Colored Me offers a defiant and

304

:

individualistic perspective on race.

305

:

She famously wrote, quote,

I am not tragically colored.

306

:

There is no great sorrow damned up in

my soul, nor lurking behind my eyes.

307

:

I do not mind at all, end quote,

and with her characteristic wit,

308

:

quote, sometimes I feel discriminated

against, but it does not make me angry.

309

:

It merely astonishes me.

310

:

How can any deny themselves

the pleasure of my company?

311

:

It's beyond me.

312

:

End quote.

313

:

Claude McKay, a Jamaican immigrant,

brought a militant fire to his

314

:

poetry, his sonnet, if we must die.

315

:

Penned in response to the

red summer of:

316

:

anthem of resistance quote.

317

:

If we must die, let it not be like hogs

hunted and penned in an inglorious spot.

318

:

Like men will face the murderous

cowardly pack, pressed to the wall,

319

:

dying, but fighting back end quote.

320

:

His poem.

321

:

America in 1921 expressed a more

ambivalent yet powerful engagement

322

:

with his adopted homeland.

323

:

Although she feeds me bread of

bitterness and sinks into my

324

:

throat, her tiger's tooth, I.

325

:

Stealing my breath of life.

326

:

I will confess.

327

:

I love this cultured

hell that tests my youth.

328

:

End quote, visual artists also flourished.

329

:

Aaron Douglas often called the father

of African-American modernism, created

330

:

murals like aspects of Negro life in 1934

that depicted the historical journey and

331

:

cultural heritage of African Americans.

332

:

Blending African motifs

with modern aesthetics.

333

:

His work visually narrated the black

experience, making history and identity

334

:

accessible and instilling pride.

335

:

And then of course there was the music.

336

:

The 1920s was undeniably the jazz

age, and Harlem was, its beating heart

337

:

innovators like Duke Ellington and

Louis Armstrong revolutionized American

338

:

music and I can't stress that enough.

339

:

Ellington himself captured the allure of

the place, saying Harlem in our minds had

340

:

the world's most glamorous atmosphere.

341

:

We had to go there.

342

:

End quote, venues like the Cotton

Club became legendary, though they

343

:

often embodied a central paradox

of the era showcasing incredible

344

:

black talent in the music on stage.

345

:

To exclusively white audiences.

346

:

It was a stark reminder of

the pervasive segregation.

347

:

Even within this cultural blossoming

and even in the north, black culture

348

:

was being celebrated and consumed,

yet often on the terms dictated bias.

349

:

Segregated society, highlighting

the complex interplay of artistic

350

:

freedom, economic necessity.

351

:

Racial Inequality Magazines like The

Crisis published by the NAACP under the

352

:

editorial leadership of WEB Du Bois and

literary editor Jesse Redmond Faucet.

353

:

An opportunity published by the

National Urban League with Charles S.

354

:

Johnson at the helm played a crucial

role in nurturing and promoting this

355

:

new wave of black writers and artists.

356

:

Often through literary contests and

providing a platform for their work to

357

:

be published, these publications were

vital in shaping and disseminating

358

:

the ideas of the Harlem Renaissance.

359

:

Parallel to the emergence of the new

Negro, the:

360

:

the new woman, the iconic image of the

flapper with her bobbed hair, short

361

:

skirts, makeup, and a penchant for

smoking cigarettes, drinking cocktails,

362

:

and dancing to jazz symbolized a

broader challenge to the Victorian

363

:

norms of femininity and domesticity.

364

:

The new woman was more than

just a fashion statement.

365

:

She represented a deeper shift in women's

roles and aspirations, significantly

366

:

fueled by the achievement of national

th Amendment in:

367

:

Feminist and socialist Crystal

Eastman in her:

368

:

Now we can begin articulated a

forward-looking agenda with the vote.

369

:

One she argued the real fight for women's

freedom could commence for Eastman.

370

:

This meant quote, how to arrange the

world so that women can be human beings

371

:

instead of being destined by the accident

of their sex to one field of activity.

372

:

Housework.

373

:

Child raising.

374

:

She called for economic independence,

a revolution in the early training and

375

:

education of both boys and girls to

dismantle traditional gender roles in

376

:

domestic labor and voluntary motherhood

through access to birth control.

377

:

She quip men will not

give up their privilege of

378

:

helplessness without a struggle.

379

:

End quote.

380

:

Women's activism in the 1920s

extended into various spheres.

381

:

They were prominent in peace movements

with organizations like the Women's

382

:

Peace Party, which became the US

section of the Women's International

383

:

League for Peace and Freedom, and

they advocated for international

384

:

cooperation and military disarmament.

385

:

They lobbied for labor

regulations and child welfare.

386

:

A significant legislative victory was

the Shepherd Toner Act of:

387

:

provided federal funds for maternal and

child health clinics, a landmark piece

388

:

of social welfare legislation heavily

influenced by women's advocacy groups like

389

:

the Women's Joint Congressional Committee.

390

:

This act demonstrated the newfound

political leverage of enfranchised

391

:

women and their commitment to

social reform providing a model for

392

:

future federal state partnerships.

393

:

I.

394

:

In addition to these was Margaret Sanger,

who was a leading figure in the birth

395

:

control movement and in founding of

the American Birth Control League in

396

:

1921, tirelessly campaigning for women's

reproductive rights, despite facing

397

:

legal challenges and social opposition.

398

:

Her work, however, was complicated by her

association with the eugenics movement.

399

:

In 1920, Sanger stated that birth

control is nothing more or less

400

:

than the facilitation of the

process of weeding out the unfit and

401

:

preventing the birth of defectives.

402

:

This alignment though Sanger

reportedly opposed eugenics along

403

:

purely racial lines, tarnished her

legacy and highlighted the complex

404

:

and sometimes troubling intersection

of 20th century reform movements.

405

:

The era's exuberance and excesses

also drew sharp criticism from some of

406

:

America's leading literary figures who saw

hollowness beneath the glittering surface.

407

:

Sinclair Lewis in novels like Main Street

and Babbitt Satirize, the conformity,

408

:

materialism, and anti-intellectualism of

small town and middle class American life.

409

:

His character George f Babbitt, A

prosperous real estate broker in

410

:

the fictional city of Zenith, became

an archetype of the unthinking

411

:

self-satisfied American businessman.

412

:

Lewis, through babbitt's voice

in a speech captured this mindset

413

:

quote, here's the specification of

the standardized American citizen.

414

:

We're not doing any boasting, but

we like ourselves first rate, and

415

:

if you don't like us, look out.

416

:

Better get undercover before

the cyclone hits town.

417

:

End quote.

418

:

Maybe the best well known as f Scott

Fitzgerald's, the Great Gatsby in

419

:

1925, which offered a poignant critique

of the American dream exposing its

420

:

corruption by wealth and class, and

the moral decay of the jazz age.

421

:

Jay Gatsby's, tragic

pursuit of Daisy Buchanan.

422

:

A symbol of old money in an idealized

past, ends in disillusionment and death.

423

:

The novel's famous closing lines

resonate with a sense of striving

424

:

against an elusive dream quote.

425

:

So we beat on boats against the current

born back ceaselessly into the past End

426

:

quote, Nick Caraway, the narrator observes

Daisy's failure to live up to Gatsby's,

427

:

quote, colossal vitality of his illusion.

428

:

A powerful commentary on the

nature of aspiration and reality.

429

:

And then there was HL Menkin, the

sage of Baltimore, whose biting satire

430

:

filled the pages of the American

Mercury Menkin relentlessly attacked

431

:

American conformity Puritanism, and

what he derisively termed the Bois Z.

432

:

He famously quip.

433

:

Democracy is the theory that the

common people know what they want

434

:

and deserve to get it good and hard.

435

:

End quote.

436

:

Speaking of American Puritanism, he

wrote, quote assumes that every human

437

:

act must be either right or wrong,

and that 90% of them are wrong.

438

:

End.

439

:

Quote, these writers, each in

their own way, held up the mirror

440

:

to the 1920s America reflecting

not just its achievements.

441

:

But also its anxieties and hypocrisies.

442

:

So let's move on to the

backlash in the division.

443

:

The culture wars of these 1920s,

the roaring twenties were.

444

:

Just about jazz and flappers beneath

the surface of prosperity and

445

:

cultural innovation, deep-seated

anxieties about the rapid pace of

446

:

change fueled a powerful backlash.

447

:

This was a decade of profound cultural

conflict pitting urban modernism

448

:

against the rural traditionalism,

science against fundamentalist religion,

449

:

and a diversifying America against

a resurgent exclusionary nativism.

450

:

Politically speaking, the 1920s were

dominated by a trio of conservative

451

:

Republican presidents, Warren g Harding,

Calvin Coolidge, and Herbert Hoover.

452

:

They shared a largely pro-business

ideology emphasizing limited government

453

:

regulation and fiscal conservatism.

454

:

Harding, as we had heard, were promised

that return to normalcy, Calvin Coolidge

455

:

famously tack turn encapsulated the

era's economic philosophy with the

456

:

often quoted though contextually nuanced

phrase, quote, the chief business of the

457

:

American people is business End quote.

458

:

He delivered this to the American Society

of Newspaper Editors in:

459

:

statement underscored the centrality

of commerce in the National Identity.

460

:

Coolidge's administration with Andrew

Mellon as Secretary of the Treasury

461

:

championed significant tax cuts,

particularly for the wealthy, under

462

:

the belief that this would trickle

down and stimulate the economy.

463

:

While Coolidge favored a light hand in

business regulation, his administration

464

:

did sign the radio act establishing a

federal oversight of the radio, this

465

:

new, uh, medium, and he blocked farm

relief bills like the McNary Hogan.

466

:

Believing that market forces rather

than government intervention would

467

:

be the best help for farmers.

468

:

Herbert Hoover, who had served as

Secretary of Commerce under Harding

469

:

and Coolidge before his own presidency,

promoted what he called associational

470

:

a system of voluntary cooperation

between government and business.

471

:

In his 1928 speech on the principles in

ideals of the United States government,

472

:

Hoover championed the American system of

quote, ordered liberty, freedom, and equal

473

:

opportunity to the individual end quote.

474

:

Arguing this individual initiative

was the engine of American progress.

475

:

He warned against government overreach

stating bureaucracy is ever desirous of

476

:

spreading its influence and its power

free speech does not live many hours

477

:

after free industry and free commerce die.

478

:

This economic philosophy prioritizing

business and individual enterprise defined

479

:

the Republican leadership of the decade.

480

:

However, this era of Republican

dominance was also marred by scandal,

481

:

most notably the Teapot dome scandal.

482

:

During Harden's administration,

secretary of the Interior, Albert Fall

483

:

was convicted of accepting bribes for

secretly leasing federal oil reserves

484

:

at Teapot Dome, Wyoming, and Elk kills

California to private oil companies.

485

:

Fall became the first US cabinet

member to be imprisoned for

486

:

crimes committed in office.

487

:

Though Harding himself was not

personally implicated and he.

488

:

Passed away before any

damage could be done to him.

489

:

His awareness of corruption within

his own Ohio gang and his failure to

490

:

act severely damage his reputation

and public trust in the government.

491

:

Had he not passed away prematurely,

he might have had more problems.

492

:

He.

493

:

Another backlash of this era was the

anxieties that the new era itself

494

:

manifested, and it manifested in a

virulent wave of nativism and violence

495

:

with the disturbing reemergence.

496

:

The Ku Klux Klan, the second clan,

was born in:

497

:

membership in the early 1920s, and it

claimed millions of members, not just

498

:

in the South, but across the nation,

and particularly in the Midwest.

499

:

This new clan broadened its targets beyond

African Americans to include Catholics,

500

:

Jews, recent immigrants, and especially

those from Southern and Eastern Europe.

501

:

Hiram Evans, a dentist who became the

Imperial Wizard of the Klan, articulated

502

:

his ideology in his 1926 article.

503

:

The Klan fights for Americanism.

504

:

He proclaimed the Klan spoke

for quote, the great Mass of

505

:

Americans of the old pioneer stock.

506

:

Whom he defined as belonging

to the Nordic race.

507

:

Evans argued that these quote old stock

Americans had felt their traditional moral

508

:

standards, the sanctity of the Sabbath,

the home and chastity had been eroded by

509

:

what he called strange ideas and aliens.

510

:

The Klan's definition of Americanism was

explicitly exclusionary based on quote.

511

:

Loyalty to the white race, to

the traditions of America and

512

:

to the spirit of Protestantism.

513

:

Their slogan, Evan stated, was

Native white Protestant supremacy.

514

:

End quote.

515

:

The Klan's method included

intimidation, but also violence such

516

:

as lynching, arson, beating, and

significant political maneuvering.

517

:

They wield a considerable political

power in states like Indiana,

518

:

where Grand Dragon David C.

519

:

Stevenson, boasted quote,

I am the law in Indiana.

520

:

As well as in Oregon where

the Klan was instrumental in

521

:

efforts to ban Catholic schools.

522

:

This resurgence could be understand

as a direct backlash against

523

:

the very diversification and

odernization that defined the:

524

:

The Klan's targets, Catholics, Jews,

immigrants, the new Negro were the

525

:

embodiment of a changing America that

threatened the perceived cultural and

526

:

social dominance of white Protestants.

527

:

Now the anxieties of the 1920s also

ignited a fierce battle between religious

528

:

fundamentalism and scientific modernism.

529

:

Most famously, this was dramatized

in the Scopes trial of:

530

:

It's often been called the Monkey Trial.

531

:

And this courtroom showdown in

Dayton, Tennessee pitted the

532

:

renowned lawyer, Clarence Darrow.

533

:

Defending high school teacher John

Scopes for teaching evolution, and

534

:

he went up against the three-time

presidential candidate and

535

:

fundamentalist champion William Jennings.

536

:

Bryan, who assisted the prosecution.

537

:

The trial became a national

media spectacle, the first to be

538

:

broadcast live on radio by WGN.

539

:

Journalists, including the acerbic HL

Mankin of the Baltimore Sun descended

540

:

upon Dayton with Mankin, famously

dubbing it monkey Town, and he ridiculed

541

:

Brian and the fundamentalist cause.

542

:

Darrow declared quote, scopes isn't

on trial, civilization is on trial,

543

:

and he framed it as a fight for

intellectual freedom against bigotry.

544

:

Brian during Darrow's relentless

cross-examination about biblical

545

:

literalism proclaimed, I'm simply

trying to protect the word of God

546

:

against the greatest atheist or

agnostic in the United States.

547

:

While scopes was ultimately

found guilty, a verdict later

548

:

overturned on a technicality.

549

:

The trial exposed deep divisions

in American society over science,

550

:

religion, and education, and many

saw darrow's grilling of Brian as a

551

:

SI symbolic victory for modernism.

552

:

The scopes trial was a flashpoint for the

broader rise of Christian fundamentalism.

553

:

This movement gaining traction in the

early 20th century emphasized biblical in

554

:

errancy and vehemently opposed Darwin's

theory of evolution and other aspects

555

:

of modern, uh, thought that they saw as

undermining traditional Christian values.

556

:

Leaders like William Bell Riley,

founder of the World, Christian

557

:

Fundamentalist Association in 1919, and.

558

:

Fiery evangelists like Billy Sunday

who proclaimed quote, Christianity

559

:

and patriotism are synonymous terms

and hell and traitors are synonymous.

560

:

End quote.

561

:

They mobilized conservative Christians

against what they perceived as societal

562

:

decay from this roaring twenties.

563

:

They aim to quote, hold the line

against change in American culture.

564

:

How can we talk about the 1920s

without talking about prohibition?

565

:

The noble experiment.

566

:

This was another major cultural

battleground of the:

567

:

The 18th Amendment ratified in

:

568

:

which banned the manufacturer sale

and transportation of intoxicating

569

:

liquors, defines stringently as

anything containing over 0.5%

570

:

alcohol.

571

:

Motivations were mixed.

572

:

Progressive era desires to curb

social ills associated with alcohol,

573

:

as well as anti-immigrant sentiment.

574

:

Targeting the drinking cultures of

ethnic groups and the moral fervor

575

:

of rural Protestant Americans.

576

:

Clashing with urban lifestyles

led to the banning of alcohol.

577

:

Enforcement of the Volted Act

proved immensely challenging.

578

:

The result was widespread.

579

:

Flouting of the law bootlegging.

580

:

The illegal production and sale of alcohol

became a massive underground industry,

581

:

speakeasies the secret bars and nightclub.

582

:

Proliferated in cities becoming

iconic symbol of the era's defiance.

583

:

This illicit trade fueled the rise

of organized crime with figures like

584

:

Chicago's Al Capone earning fortunes

an estimated $60 million annually from

585

:

bootlegging and speakeasies for Capone.

586

:

The era saw a corresponding rise

in gang violence notoriously

587

:

exemplified by the St.

588

:

Valentine's Massacre in Chicago of 1929.

589

:

Prohibition also led to increased

corruption within law enforcement and

590

:

a general disrespect for the law and

the ultimate weakening of public trust.

591

:

So while America grappled with

its internal culture wars,

592

:

the new ominous ideology was

taking root in Europe fascism.

593

:

In October, 1922, Benito Mussolini and

his black shirt staged their march on

594

:

Rome leading to Mussolini's appointment

as prime minister and the subsequent

595

:

consolidation of fascist power in Italy.

596

:

Americans reactions to Mussolini's

Rise were varied and they were complex.

597

:

Some segments of the American press

and public expressed admiration for

598

:

Mussolini, particularly for fascism,

staunch anti-communism, and its perceived

599

:

restoration of order in discipline.

600

:

The Kansas City Star in August of

:

601

:

Mus Lee's fascism with quote.

602

:

100% Americanism.

603

:

End quote.

604

:

Mussolini himself in an interview with the

Dallas Morning News emphasized discipline

605

:

and work as his guiding principles.

606

:

Others, however, viewed the rise of

fascism with measured unease, fearing

607

:

its militaristic rhetoric, and the

potential for another European war, as was

608

:

noted by the Forth worth star Telegram.

609

:

These early American responses often

interpreted fascism through a domestic

610

:

American lens, sometimes praising

its perceived strength in combating

611

:

radicalism or promoting national

unity, while often underestimating its

612

:

inherent dangers and its fundamental

departure from democratic principles.

613

:

This foreshadowed the complex and

often hesitant response by Americans

614

:

to the growing threat of fascism.

615

:

In the 1920s, in the 1930s,

even leading up to World War ii.

616

:

So the 1920s, then this decade that began

with a plea for normalcy and ended on

617

:

the precipice of the Great Depression.

618

:

It was, as we've seen anything but normal.

619

:

It was an era of dazzling

technological innovation.

620

:

The automobile and the radio forever

altered the fabric of American life.

621

:

It created a mass consumer culture

fueled by new advertising techniques

622

:

and the seductive promise of credit.

623

:

It was an era of profound cultural

renaissance as the new Negro of Harlem

624

:

proclaimed a new racial consciousness

and artistic vibrancy, and the new

625

:

woman challenged traditional gender

roles demanding new freedoms in their

626

:

social, economic and personal lives.

627

:

I.

628

:

Yet this new era was an

age of deep contradictions.

629

:

The prosperity was unevenly

distributed, and the decades innovations

630

:

were met with fierce resistance.

631

:

Conservative politics sought to reign in

the perceived excesses of modern life.

632

:

The Ku Klux Klan experienced a terrifying

resurgence preaching a doctrine of quote,

633

:

native, white, Protestant supremacy.

634

:

End quote, against the backdrop

of increasing immigration

635

:

and black migration.

636

:

The scopes trial became

a national referendum on

637

:

science versus fundamentalist

Christianity and prohibition.

638

:

The noble experiment bred organized

crime and widespread disrespect for

639

:

the law even as America looked inward.

640

:

The rise of fascism in Europe

cast a long and ominous shadow.

641

:

The 1920s then was a

critical turning point.

642

:

The battles fought over cultural

values, racial equality, the role of

643

:

women, the definition of Americanism,

and the relationship between tradition

644

:

and modernity were not resolved.

645

:

Instead, they laid the groundwork

for the economic catastrophe.

646

:

Of the Great Depression, our next

episode, as well as the global conflict

647

:

of World War ii, the episode after

that, and many of the social and

648

:

cultural debates that continue to

resonate in American society today.

649

:

The echoes of the jazz age with its

vibrant creativity and its stark

650

:

divisions can still be heard as HL Menkin.

651

:

One of the era's sharpest critics

observed, quote, the whole aim of

652

:

practical politics is to keep the

populace alarmed and hence glamorous,

653

:

to be led to safety by menacing it

with an endless series of hob, goblins,

654

:

all of them imaginary end quote.

655

:

Perhaps the Hobb goblins of the 1920s

were not entirely imaginary, but

656

:

reflection of a nation grappling with

its own rapidly changing identity.

657

:

Thanks for coming out to

Star Spangled Studies.

658

:

I'm Dr.

659

:

G.

660

:

I'll see y'all in the past.

Follow

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube