Most scary stories serve as a warning, but which one’s should be taken seriously? Lily tests Chase’s intuition in this week’s episode as she asks him to guess whether or not 4 unrelated stories are based on true events or are just Urban Legends. Which stories are true or false? Find out as they tackle the Bunny Man of Northern Virginia, the Ghost Car of Georgia, the Scream Murder of Pocatello, Idaho, and the Phantom Hitchhiker of Black Horse Lake, Montana.