Entrepreneur, author, and Founder / CEO of Vanderbloemen Search Group, William Vanderbloemen, explains the dynamics of creating an irresistible workplace, the 3 main reasons people leave their jobs (4 for millennials), what Saturday morning cartoons have to do with job retention, why most cultural problems boil down to hiring problems, the difference between culture and core values, how to assess the 8 key areas of workplace health or toxicity, and gives several quick exercises for pinpointing what your culture is.
My guest that we have for you today I'm super excited
Host:about William Vanderbloemen. His company Vanderbloemen Search
Host:Group wins all these crazy awards. They were like number 23
Host:best search firm in the country number three best. Third Best
Host:Place to Work in Houston. He writes for Forbes has a weekly
Host:column there. He's got a couple books that are out. He's also
Host:got degrees from Wake Forest at Princeton from Theological
Host:Seminary. I mean, just a total awesome guy mover and shaker.
Host:And his new book is called Culture Wins: The Roadmap to an
Host:Irresistible Workplace. So William, welcome to the show.
William Vanderbloemen:Wow, that I hope people don't believe
William Vanderbloemen:everything you just said. That was awesome. Great to be with
William Vanderbloemen:you, man.
Host:Yeah. So in terms of creating an irresistible
Host:workplace, why do people leave? Like if you have to boil it
Host:down? What causes people to leave?
William Vanderbloemen:Sure, sure. Well, so we did a whole
William Vanderbloemen:lot of research for this book we did, we took time to say, Hey,
William Vanderbloemen:we've won a lot of awards for a great place to work. And that
William Vanderbloemen:led people to say, Can you write about this Forbes asked us to
William Vanderbloemen:write about this. And then we said, well, we can tell our
William Vanderbloemen:story about how we built a culture, we actually had to
William Vanderbloemen:reverse engineer, we were like, how did we do that? So we
William Vanderbloemen:stepped back. And he said, I guess we did this and this and
William Vanderbloemen:this. And we sort of intuitively fell into what we've got. But we
William Vanderbloemen:said, You know what other books are out there. But let's not
William Vanderbloemen:just tell our story. Let's get up underneath the hood of all
William Vanderbloemen:the great cultures we can find. So I took a stack of magazines
William Vanderbloemen:that were award winning lists of award winning companies for
William Vanderbloemen:culture, handed them to a young employee at our firm, and said,
William Vanderbloemen:Go find the email addresses of all the CEOs and get me at least
William Vanderbloemen:100 phone appointments so that we can study and it did and what
William Vanderbloemen:we've been covered with some best practices. So getting back
William Vanderbloemen:to your question, what we also uncovered, there are lots of
William Vanderbloemen:studies on the internet, which are all true if they're on the
William Vanderbloemen:internet, right? And the baseline like the most common
William Vanderbloemen:answer to how many people in America like their job, the most
William Vanderbloemen:common answer is two out of three Americans hate their job,
William Vanderbloemen:not modestly dislike not Oh, I can't wait till hump day is
William Vanderbloemen:over, or I need some more time off, I hate their job. And so
William Vanderbloemen:like what in the world is causing that? And we found a few
William Vanderbloemen:common answers. First of all, people don't leave jobs, they
William Vanderbloemen:leave managers. turnover is usually a problem with
William Vanderbloemen:management and not a problem with we don't have enough ping
William Vanderbloemen:pong tables, or whatever the thing is for culture. The second
William Vanderbloemen:thing we found was, people leave the job because they don't know
William Vanderbloemen:what their job is. If people say, I don't know what I'm
William Vanderbloemen:supposed to get done. And then the third thing we found is
William Vanderbloemen:people leave a job is because once they do know what they're
William Vanderbloemen:supposed to get done, they aren't equipped with the tools
William Vanderbloemen:or resources to actually go get it done. So you know, people sit
William Vanderbloemen:around, like, I don't know what success is. And then it finally
William Vanderbloemen:gets defined. I can't get there. And I don't like my manager. So
William Vanderbloemen:I hate my job. Now, a fourth reason you're, you're, I think,
William Vanderbloemen:still a millennial, and what I'm learning about millennials,
William Vanderbloemen:because I'm not one is if there's no why behind the what
William Vanderbloemen:I'm out, there's got to be a cause. Behind the what we're
William Vanderbloemen:doing, you know, the Simon Sinek talk that's been seen 18
William Vanderbloemen:bajillion times. Now, I should start with why that whole why
William Vanderbloemen:behind the what is a big deal? And I think, well, that's the
William Vanderbloemen:fourth place answer right now. I bet in 10 years, it's number
William Vanderbloemen:one, because that millennial generation is starting to
William Vanderbloemen:dominate the workforce just by sheer numbers. So I think you're
William Vanderbloemen:gonna see an even bigger shift. So the answer your question is
William Vanderbloemen:people leave managers, not jobs. But I think within 10 years,
William Vanderbloemen:it's gonna be people will leave if you don't have a cause for
William Vanderbloemen:what you're doing.
Host:Are people job hopping more?
William Vanderbloemen:Totally. And not just job hopping, career
William Vanderbloemen:hopping? And you're talking about a generation and you can
William Vanderbloemen:blame me and say those millennials? Or you can drop
William Vanderbloemen:back and say, Well, why is that? So you know, the generation
William Vanderbloemen:before where you do 35 years at Ford, and you retire with the
William Vanderbloemen:gold watch and all that. That's the generation that grew up with
William Vanderbloemen:radio, and then by later in their career, they had three TV
William Vanderbloemen:stations to choose from. Now, think about your life, think
William Vanderbloemen:about somebody 10 years younger than their life. You know, when
William Vanderbloemen:I talk to older groups, I often say I'm old enough, I'm mid 40s.
William Vanderbloemen:That for me, my favorite part of the week when I was a kid was
William Vanderbloemen:Saturday morning. And the younger part of the room looks
William Vanderbloemen:at me like what in the world are you talking about? The older
William Vanderbloemen:brother room just nods and it you know why? And all the old
William Vanderbloemen:people say the cartoons were on right you look at a millennial
William Vanderbloemen:and say what are the cartoons on? What are you talking about?
William Vanderbloemen:I just watch what I want. Again, an on demand. I watch it on
William Vanderbloemen:YouTube. I watch it we're so you, you've got a generation
William Vanderbloemen:that's grown up in a world of infinite options. So why
William Vanderbloemen:wouldn't they see their career as a span of years full of
William Vanderbloemen:infinite options? It's just natural. So I think you will see
William Vanderbloemen:not just job hopping but career hopping and that's Where I
William Vanderbloemen:found, you know, as we studied what makes a great culture? And
William Vanderbloemen:who's sinking money into it, and why are they spending money on
William Vanderbloemen:it? When I interviewed CEOs, I got a lot of different answers
William Vanderbloemen:about why I spend money on culture. But the number one
William Vanderbloemen:answer that every one of them answered was retention. The
William Vanderbloemen:money I spend on culture always pays for itself because people
William Vanderbloemen:stay longer than they would have otherwise, maybe that means they
William Vanderbloemen:stay eight years instead of four, not 35 with a gold watch,
William Vanderbloemen:but but when you start running the numbers of what it cost to
William Vanderbloemen:replace people in the end of this loss, retention is the ball
William Vanderbloemen:game for the future of the American workplace.
Host:What are some of the numbers like, what's the cost?
William Vanderbloemen:Well, yeah, I mean, you can justify
William Vanderbloemen:anything you want, you can find a study on the Internet that
William Vanderbloemen:will give you any number you want. But but we try to read a
William Vanderbloemen:whole lot and then boil it down to a transferable principle. And
William Vanderbloemen:what what we found is just for round numbers sake, $100,000
William Vanderbloemen:employee, which is a high level employee, should they leave and
William Vanderbloemen:will not will not even factor in Is it a good leave, or a bad
William Vanderbloemen:leave? Is it $100,000 employee leaving will probably cost you a
William Vanderbloemen:quarter million dollars. And that's how I did soft costs all
William Vanderbloemen:wrapped together. And so it's and it's gonna happen, I mean,
William Vanderbloemen:turnover happens in turnover, and always bad, you're gonna
William Vanderbloemen:fast growing organization, you probably got people that were
William Vanderbloemen:great when you had 40 employees. But when we got to 100, they
William Vanderbloemen:couldn't, couldn't hang. And that's not their fault. It's
William Vanderbloemen:just different. It's a different company. But if you can mitigate
William Vanderbloemen:the amount and frequency of turnover, especially unnecessary
William Vanderbloemen:turnover, then your ROI goes up. I talked to one CEO of a
William Vanderbloemen:software company, he's up in New York City, and they have a very
William Vanderbloemen:particular software solution that they sell. They're three
William Vanderbloemen:companies that all sell the same type of solution, right? And all
William Vanderbloemen:three of them sell it at the same price. They sell to the
William Vanderbloemen:same market, there's no product differentiation, and he's a $20
William Vanderbloemen:million company. And he said last year, he spent roughly $2
William Vanderbloemen:million on culture. I'm like, what, why in the world? He said,
William Vanderbloemen:well, because my EBIT da was 60 some percent higher than his
William Vanderbloemen:competitors. I said, What do you mean your earnings is, is better
William Vanderbloemen:than your competitor? You got the same price point, same
William Vanderbloemen:solution said, Did you do more sales? Nope. Same revenue. He
William Vanderbloemen:said, In our industry, we're notorious for churning through
William Vanderbloemen:people, the average churn rate is about 38%. And I've got my
William Vanderbloemen:churn rate down to one and a half percent. So if you think
William Vanderbloemen:he's got 200 People 38% means 76. People would leave me
William Vanderbloemen:normally every year and my other two competitors, they lose 76
William Vanderbloemen:people every year. What are you going to charge me? Well, you
William Vanderbloemen:have to do 76 searches, what have I got to do to train 76 new
William Vanderbloemen:employees? How much momentum do I lose, and morale that drops
William Vanderbloemen:when these people are walking out the door? I spent $2 million
William Vanderbloemen:people love working here I fly my whole team to a big retreat,
William Vanderbloemen:I spend money on things, not competitors don't, my people
William Vanderbloemen:stay. And the fact that they stay makes us more profitable,
William Vanderbloemen:even though we're not charging one penny more and not selling
William Vanderbloemen:one widget more.
Host:So what really makes them stay? I mean, is it just the
Host:inverse of why they leave? Is that why they stay?
William Vanderbloemen:I think a lot of it is inverse, you get
William Vanderbloemen:people who actually want to be at work. I think when you say
William Vanderbloemen:you know the culture doesn't belong to a corporate entity, it
William Vanderbloemen:belongs to a person, the companies that I studied that
William Vanderbloemen:got serious about defining what their cultural values were
William Vanderbloemen:started hiring around those cultural values. So that up, put
William Vanderbloemen:it this way, you know, everybody's crazy. And if you
William Vanderbloemen:haven't figured that out, then you know, you will. So it's not
William Vanderbloemen:finding people who aren't crazy to work for you. It's finding
William Vanderbloemen:people who are the same kind of crazy as you. And when you start
William Vanderbloemen:hiring, where you've got a tribe of people that are similar,
William Vanderbloemen:well, then you're gonna have personality clashes because
William Vanderbloemen:people are broken. And that's just the way the world is. But
William Vanderbloemen:at least you're in the same tribe. And the manager is not
William Vanderbloemen:insufferable. So frankly, most cultural problems are really a
William Vanderbloemen:hiring problem. And I think that companies that have gotten it,
William Vanderbloemen:right, the ones that have gotten it, right, frankly, are mostly
William Vanderbloemen:newer companies, because they've been able to build from the
William Vanderbloemen:ground up, you know, a company two, three generations deep or a
William Vanderbloemen:couple 100 years old. The culture is pretty hard to turn
William Vanderbloemen:on a dime. And if you've got a real problem, it takes a long,
William Vanderbloemen:long time. But the other the other interesting thing about
William Vanderbloemen:why people stay, you talked about millennials, job hopping
William Vanderbloemen:Barna, you know, this group, they're a polling and surveying
William Vanderbloemen:group pretty well known and they asked a question of people born
William Vanderbloemen:in different decades. Here's the question, pretend your young
William Vanderbloemen:adult 22 years old, what do you want to have accomplished by the
William Vanderbloemen:time? You're 35? Great question. Right. So every group that
William Vanderbloemen:answered except Millennials had almost identical, the same top
William Vanderbloemen:five answers. Here's what they want to get done. They wanted to
William Vanderbloemen:by the time that 35 We want to get married, start a family,
William Vanderbloemen:owned a home, be on a secure job track and have some financial
William Vanderbloemen:peace. Millennials? Have those top five answers, how many of
William Vanderbloemen:them hit their top five? Just one, financial peace. So what
William Vanderbloemen:does that mean for the workplace and for culture, what that means
William Vanderbloemen:is you're hiring people who probably aren't near their
William Vanderbloemen:family probably don't have a family to go home to probably
William Vanderbloemen:haven't locked into a career yet, and probably see their
William Vanderbloemen:workplace as the closest thing they're gonna have to a family.
William Vanderbloemen:And so if you find a workplace, that's just, frankly, hell bent
William Vanderbloemen:on building a culture where that family can feel like they're
William Vanderbloemen:more connected than just their work and connected through a
William Vanderbloemen:cause, and connected to the cultural code, well, then people
William Vanderbloemen:are gonna stay, and they'll put up with highs and lows
William Vanderbloemen:economically a lot better. And they'll put up with rising
William Vanderbloemen:health care costs, and all those things a lot better. If this is
William Vanderbloemen:my family, I don't have a wife and kids to go, this is it. And
William Vanderbloemen:it's a cause I believe in and a well defined culture. And the
William Vanderbloemen:people here are somewhat like me in terms of belief and how we
William Vanderbloemen:function and the companies that I studied that got that right,
William Vanderbloemen:have very few turnover issues.
Host:So getting into the practical, how do we actually
Host:keep people? How do we create retention?
William Vanderbloemen:I think it all depends on what's the old
William Vanderbloemen:advice of I forget which Greek philosopher it was that his his
William Vanderbloemen:best advice was know yourself. And I think if a company will
William Vanderbloemen:take time to drop back and know themselves, and then build all
William Vanderbloemen:those bells and whistles around that, then that that will make a
William Vanderbloemen:difference in here. So I'm guessing that a lot of your
William Vanderbloemen:listeners have businesses that already have what they call core
William Vanderbloemen:values. But are they cultural values? And when you say
William Vanderbloemen:cultural, you know, you think what, what is a culture, and
William Vanderbloemen:lots of different definitions are out there. But it's the
William Vanderbloemen:traditions and symbols and behaviors that are passed along
William Vanderbloemen:from one generation to the next without thinking about it. And
William Vanderbloemen:and if a company can can get a hold of those customs and
William Vanderbloemen:traditions and behaviors? And what is it that that we do
William Vanderbloemen:that's good, and then build the ping pong table in the vending
William Vanderbloemen:machine in the Yogen. Stir all that around that well, then that
William Vanderbloemen:is a win. And here's a really practical question to ask if
William Vanderbloemen:you're saying we do have core values, but they're not cultural
William Vanderbloemen:values. They don't describe how we behave. They don't describe
William Vanderbloemen:our customs. They just say things like, excellence. I'm so
William Vanderbloemen:tired of excellence being a core value, I want to find the
William Vanderbloemen:company that says, you know, mediocrity is really what we're
William Vanderbloemen:after. But, but like, a cultural value is more how do we behave?
William Vanderbloemen:It's the how we get our work done. And the question that a
William Vanderbloemen:company can ask all of its employees to start the
William Vanderbloemen:conversation is this, you can say, Look, when we are
William Vanderbloemen:functioning at our very, very best. What do we do as a team
William Vanderbloemen:that's common to us, but uncommon to other teams we see
William Vanderbloemen:around us. Because there's some quirkiness that you guys share
William Vanderbloemen:when you do your best for us. It's like responding with almost
William Vanderbloemen:dysfunctional speed. Like, don't you have a life form getting
William Vanderbloemen:back to me so fast? But you know, that's, that's our deal.
William Vanderbloemen:And it's been a signature for us. And we didn't even realize
William Vanderbloemen:that we went through this exercise. When we're functioning
William Vanderbloemen:at our best, what do we do as a team that's common to us? That's
William Vanderbloemen:uncommon to others. And long story short, through the process
William Vanderbloemen:of building cultural values. We named it as ridiculous
William Vanderbloemen:responsiveness. That's our deal. And, you know, we interview for
William Vanderbloemen:it, we, we do sneaky bad stuff, during interviews to see if
William Vanderbloemen:somebody's got the same dysfunction we do. If they're
William Vanderbloemen:really ridiculously responsive. If they are, they're gonna fit
William Vanderbloemen:if they're not, they're probably a great employee for somebody
William Vanderbloemen:else.
Host:Yeah, before we go, where should people go? If if they
Host:want to kind of learn about Culture Wins? And where would
Host:you point people?
William Vanderbloemen:You can go to culturewins.org And find
William Vanderbloemen:the book there. If you're really interested in other things about
William Vanderbloemen:us, you can go to vanderbloemen.com and it just
William Vanderbloemen:spell it just like that.
Host:It's clear and obvious and easy to spell, and there's a lot
Host:of vowels.
William Vanderbloemen:You know, we bought probably 300 domain
William Vanderbloemen:names when we started. And we hired an SEO consultant and
William Vanderbloemen:said, which one of these I don't want to name it after me, don't
William Vanderbloemen:be my name on the door. And he came back and he said, I got
William Vanderbloemen:good news and bad news. I got the great website for you.
William Vanderbloemen:You're not going to like it. So bad news. He said, We need to
William Vanderbloemen:use your last name. Your last name is so screwed up that you
William Vanderbloemen:can misspell it 200 different ways into Google and it'll feed
William Vanderbloemen:back to you so we just went with that. So misspell it however you
William Vanderbloemen:want vanderbloemen you'll you'll find your way or there or
William Vanderbloemen:culturewins.org.
Host:Smart. Alright, William. So what's the first thing? The
Host:first step?
William Vanderbloemen:That's a great question. We tried to
William Vanderbloemen:answer that while we were writing the book. There's really
William Vanderbloemen:two layers to culture. The first thing you have to ask yourself
William Vanderbloemen:is is this a healthy place to work? It is toxic. That's a
William Vanderbloemen:whole different conversation. And then defining values. So to
William Vanderbloemen:help people know, are we functioning? Well, we did some
William Vanderbloemen:research, we found eight key areas of health or toxicity. And
William Vanderbloemen:we built online assessment. So if people go to the culture
William Vanderbloemen:tool.com, they'll find a free online assessment. They can have
William Vanderbloemen:their whole team, take the test, we'll send you back a report
William Vanderbloemen:that shows you how you measure up, what's your median score,
William Vanderbloemen:where you work, what's better, what's worse, and how do you
William Vanderbloemen:measure up against all the other businesses that have come and
William Vanderbloemen:taken this test? So that's the culturetool.com.
Host:I love it. Thank you for sharing this this as interesting
Host:perspective to have from somebody who has a full time
Host:living of talking to people that are coming and going in and out
Host:of companies.
William Vanderbloemen:Thanks so much. I appreciate you having me
William Vanderbloemen:on.