Backdropped by a Irish jam session, Cari Guerin joins Bobby and Gary for her story! From growing up in small town Wisconsin to becoming a certified cicerone, Cari just loves a good beer.
PATREON SUPPORT
patreon.com/respectingthebeerpodcast
FACEBOOK GROUP
https://www.facebook.com/groups/respectingthebeer
QUESTIONS?
Email us at respectingthebeer@gmail.com
--
CHAPTERS
00:00 Welcome to Respecting the Beer!
00:54 Cari Guerin Beer Origins
03:33 Wisconsin Drinking Laws
06:10 Craft Beer Education
09:48 Cask And Sour Culture
12:21 Breaking Into The Industry
13:24 Stalking To Get Hired
15:08 Bar Staff Are Everything
16:04 Cicerone Levels Explained
18:51 Why Get Certified
19:35 Beer vs Wine Complexity
21:24 Consistency and Big Brewers
23:46 Favorites at McFleshman’s
26:02 200 Breweries and Top Picks
27:55 Costa Rica Jungle Brewery
29:06 Desert Island Beer Pick
30:24 Building the Perfect Flight
34:00 Support us on Patreon!
--
CREDITS
Hosts:
Bobby Fleshman - https://www.mcfleshmans.com/
Allison Fleshman -https://www.instagram.com/mcfleshmans/
Joel Hermansen
Gary Ardnt - https://everything-everywhere.com/everything-everywhere-daily-podcast/
Music by Sarah Lynn Huss - https://www.facebook.com/kevin.huss.52/
Recorded & Produced by David Kalsow - https://davidkalsow.com/
Brought to you by McFleshman's Brewing Co
Hello everybody.
Gary Arndt:This is Gary Arndt and welcome to another episode of Respecting the Beer with me again, as usual is the Master of Hops and Malt Space and time.
Gary Arndt:Bobby Fleshman.
Gary Arndt:Happy to be here for an impromptu episode.
Gary Arndt:And as you can hear in the background, probably there's a lot of Irish music going on.
Gary Arndt:So there's that.
Gary Arndt:And our guest back on the other side of the, the microphone after being on the other side and not on the other side.
Gary Arndt:Carrie Guerin, we never really got to talk to when she was a guest.
Gary Arndt:She was kind of running a taste testing for us.
Gary Arndt:So we wanna get into the details of how you got into beer, how you got into this business.
Gary Arndt:So why don't you give the superhero origin story of how you got your start?
Cari Guerin:Whew.
Cari Guerin:So, um, I like to tell people that my background, I have the drinking trifecta.
Cari Guerin:I am a German Irish
Gary Arndt:liver disease.
Gary Arndt:Oh, sorry, go ahead.
Cari Guerin:That's maybe future, I don't know.
Cari Guerin:But I'm German, I'm Irish, and I was raised in a small town in the middle of Wisconsin.
Cari Guerin:That is the drinking trifecta.
Cari Guerin:Um, my dad was a German man who kept his beer next to the refrigerator, not in the refrigerator, and I truly cannot remember my first sip of beer.
Cari Guerin:I was very little.
Cari Guerin:It was never something that was off limits to me, so I just, it was always a normal part of my life growing up.
Cari Guerin:So I've always.
Cari Guerin:Had I've acquired a taste very young.
Bobby Fleshman:Home was New London.
Cari Guerin:New London.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Which becomes New Dublin this time of year.
Bobby Fleshman:Right.
Cari Guerin:Celebrate.
Cari Guerin:It does become Dublin every March.
Cari Guerin:Yes, it does.
Bobby Fleshman:So there's plenty, plenty of beer to
Gary Arndt:celebrate there.
Gary Arndt:There are, there are Irish communities around here, but not a lot.
Gary Arndt:New London And Freedom is it, are the only ones that
Gary Arndt:Yes,
Cari Guerin:I believe Freedom is also
Gary Arndt:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:That, that have like a, an Irish background.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:New London has really embraced the Irish.
Cari Guerin:For sure.
Gary Arndt:But Germans are a dime a dozen here.
Cari Guerin:Uh, kind of, yeah.
Gary Arndt:Germans, Polish, Dutch were kind of a lot of the
Cari Guerin:in the, in, in the Fox cities.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:When we were looking to open the brewery, we found that 75% of everyone that lives.
Bobby Fleshman:The Fox Valley.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:Claims German descent.
Cari Guerin:Oh
Bobby Fleshman:sure.
Bobby Fleshman:And I think 28% claim Irish percent.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:So, or Irish descent.
Bobby Fleshman:So it
Gary Arndt:sense are the largest ethnic group in the United States.
Gary Arndt:Most people don't know that.
Bobby Fleshman:Yep.
Bobby Fleshman:Hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:Fair
Gary Arndt:enough.
Gary Arndt:And the reason is it has to do with World War I. It became very unfashionable to be German in the United States.
Gary Arndt:And there was actually a period of 18 months where there were more lynchings of Germans than African Americans.
Cari Guerin:Oh wow.
Gary Arndt:Um, because if you were German, and so the town of New Berlin in Wisconsin that used to be New Berlin and New Berlin, they simply changed the pronunciation and there were cities that changed their name.
Gary Arndt:People that, uh, there were German, uh, newspapers and like Oshkosh and around there they stopped doing that and that's when everything became very anglicized.
Gary Arndt:Hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:There you have it.
Gary Arndt:And World War II didn't help.
Gary Arndt:I did not know that.
Gary Arndt:That was just right.
Gary Arndt:Fueled the fire.
Gary Arndt:But by that time, a lot of the, the dehumanization had already happened.
Bobby Fleshman:Speaking of beer, Carrie, we're back on your origin stories.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:Sorry.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:So your parents abused you, fed you alcohol at a young age.
Cari Guerin:I guess you could say that, but Sure.
Gary Arndt:And I should add, for those of you listening outside of Wisconsin, that is perfectly legal here.
Cari Guerin:Absolutely it is.
Gary Arndt:Yeah, it is.
Gary Arndt:Your parents can serve you alcohol.
Gary Arndt:Yep.
Gary Arndt:And in fact, at Mc Fleishmans, so long as your parent is here.
Gary Arndt:Yes.
Gary Arndt:I think you technically have to give it to
Cari Guerin:the parents.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Cari Guerin:I was gonna say, as a beer tender, I cannot serve a beer to a minor, but I can give it to their parents and they can give it to their child.
Bobby Fleshman:And then how does it, I think between 18 and 21 there's a loophole.
Cari Guerin:No, there used to be.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, is it?
Cari Guerin:Okay.
Cari Guerin:They close that.
Cari Guerin:So it used, the law used to state that, if, I'm trying to remember how it was, um, if you were a minor.
Cari Guerin:You could drink with your parents, which meant once you turned 18, you were no longer a minor.
Bobby Fleshman:Right.
Cari Guerin:But the law was changed eight to 10 years ago, I think it was.
Cari Guerin:Um, they changed the word minor to underage.
Bobby Fleshman:Got it.
Bobby Fleshman:Okay.
Bobby Fleshman:Close the loophole
Cari Guerin:for
Bobby Fleshman:a while.
Bobby Fleshman:I thought that that was, that
Cari Guerin:existed for a while.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Cari Guerin:You could.
Cari Guerin:You could drink if you were nine, but not if you were 19.
Bobby Fleshman:Right.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:There's a lot of weird things about Wisconsin because of the Tavern League.
Gary Arndt:Where in one hand it's, it's just a state of anarchy.
Gary Arndt:You can do whatever you want.
Gary Arndt:And then the other hand, you can't do anything.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Like many of the neighboring states have legalized marijuana.
Gary Arndt:We probably never will.
Gary Arndt:You cannot mail beer in or out of the state.
Gary Arndt:Right.
Gary Arndt:But you can whine.
Gary Arndt:Um, yeah.
Gary Arndt:It's just these weird things.
Gary Arndt:It is weird.
Gary Arndt:That's Wisconsin.
Bobby Fleshman:I grew up in Oklahoma, so these weird things I was, I was drowning in them before we moved.
Cari Guerin:Oh my gosh.
Cari Guerin:I remember when I started here and I remember asking you and Allison about what our policy was for minors and the horrified looks on your faces.
Cari Guerin:Like, what are you even talking about?
Cari Guerin:Of course, we're not gonna give beard to a minor
Bobby Fleshman:In what universe?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Like, okay.
Bobby Fleshman:And
Gary Arndt:they had no clue what the law was?
Cari Guerin:No.
Cari Guerin:They, they had never heard this before.
Cari Guerin:They were like, what?
Cari Guerin:Why would we do such a thing?
Bobby Fleshman:Oh.
Bobby Fleshman:In a state that doesn't even refrigerate above three point beer.
Bobby Fleshman:We were, we were still adjusting for sure.
Gary Arndt:Okay.
Gary Arndt:So that's your, your childhood.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Gary Arndt:You become an adult Yep.
Gary Arndt:Of legal age.
Cari Guerin:Mm-hmm.
Gary Arndt:Uh, what was the story after that then?
Cari Guerin:Um, well, you know, growing up with that, I had kind of acquired that taste.
Cari Guerin:I've always really enjoyed the flavor of beer.
Cari Guerin:Um,
Gary Arndt:this isn't you writing in your dream book, like, I'm gonna work at a bar.
Cari Guerin:No.
Cari Guerin:Oh gosh, no.
Cari Guerin:Definitely not.
Cari Guerin:Um, but you know, in college I had a couple friends that were home brewers.
Cari Guerin:Um, I have some family members at home brewed, I personally never have, which is kind of weird to me.
Cari Guerin:But, um.
Bobby Fleshman:Shadow
Cari Guerin:day.
Cari Guerin:Yeah,
Bobby Fleshman:that's coming.
Bobby Fleshman:Shadow day.
Bobby Fleshman:Everybody's gonna get to jump in.
Cari Guerin:My, I got married, had kids.
Cari Guerin:Um, I taught my husband about craft beer 'cause he was the Bud Light drinker, which nothing.
Cari Guerin:No dissing Bud Light.
Cari Guerin:There is a time and a place for every beer out there.
Cari Guerin:I have drank my share of bush lattes.
Cari Guerin:Um, but I've just always appreciated the flavors and, and the.
Cari Guerin:The different arrays of flavors.
Cari Guerin:There's just something out there for every time and every place and every person.
Gary Arndt:I have sat on the other side of the bar many times here and I have seen people come in first time here and they literally, that's what they order.
Gary Arndt:Not knowing that
Cari Guerin:Sure.
Gary Arndt:They make everything here.
Gary Arndt:It's like, oh, well what's the closest you have to Bud Light?
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:And 'cause that's all they know.
Cari Guerin:Yep.
Gary Arndt:And I think that's for a lot of people, it's not like that's a taste preference.
Gary Arndt:It's literally, it's just,
Cari Guerin:that's all they know.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:It truly is.
Cari Guerin:And that's really fun behind the bar when, when I can get somebody who, and we're always gonna have those people that, Nope, that's all I want.
Cari Guerin:Gimme your state street, whatever.
Cari Guerin:But when I get those people that are willing to step outside and try something different and, and that is so much fun for me when I can.
Cari Guerin:Or the person who comes in is like, I don't like beer.
Cari Guerin:What, what?
Cari Guerin:What are you gonna serve to me?
Cari Guerin:Like, okay, let me ask you a couple questions.
Cari Guerin:Let me see what I can figure out and if I can find something that they like, and then they're like, oh my gosh, I didn't know I liked beer.
Cari Guerin:I like beer.
Cari Guerin:It's fun.
Bobby Fleshman:The, in, in the wine world, you only have, and there's a certain art and romance to it.
Bobby Fleshman:You only have grapes, water, and sometimes no yeast because they just go, they're spontaneously fermented.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, but in, in the beer world, we're working with four ingredients actively.
Bobby Fleshman:We have, we have malt, the hops, the water in the yeast.
Bobby Fleshman:Yep.
Bobby Fleshman:That gives us so much more to work with.
Bobby Fleshman:And the way, my gosh, that malt comes so many different things in is that's been pre, we don't give these malters enough credit.
Bobby Fleshman:The guys that take the malt, the barley from the field, and they go through the germination process and the toasting and the kiln mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:They generate all these flavors and colors that we take credit for as brewers.
Bobby Fleshman:We blame those guys when things go south.
Bobby Fleshman:We always say these fucking monsters, they, they, they threw us, we throw them under the bus.
Bobby Fleshman:Let's say it that way.
Bobby Fleshman:They do so much work.
Bobby Fleshman:But yeah, in the beer world, we have so much more to work with.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, there's, there, there really is something for almost everybody out there.
Cari Guerin:There's a flavor that we can find for you.
Bobby Fleshman:We can go as sour as you want.
Bobby Fleshman:We can go as hoppy as you want.
Bobby Fleshman:Yep.
Bobby Fleshman:And every multi,
Gary Arndt:a lot of people have never had anything like a sour.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah, true.
Gary Arndt:They wouldn't think of that as beer.
Gary Arndt:True.
Bobby Fleshman:And we do traditional sours here for the most part.
Bobby Fleshman:And that, and that's a very different animal than, uh, a, a fruited sour where you'll dump, I don't wanna say dump, but there's, there's a way that you can make beers sour really quickly.
Bobby Fleshman:And there's a way you have to go the long route and, and they, they're very different.
Bobby Fleshman:So yeah, there's, they're puckering.
Gary Arndt:I've been many like convenience stores around here and you go into their beer cooler and I looked once
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Every beer they had was just a light lager.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, absolutely.
Gary Arndt:That's all they were.
Gary Arndt:And that is what to most people, what beer is.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:Cult 45 era.
Gary Arndt:Absolutely.
Gary Arndt:They've never had.
Gary Arndt:A caspi probably.
Cari Guerin:Oh gosh.
Cari Guerin:Oh my gosh.
Cari Guerin:Can, can we get cask
Bobby Fleshman:at QuickTrip?
Cari Guerin:Oh my gosh.
Bobby Fleshman:You think we could talk
Cari Guerin:QuickTrip?
Cari Guerin:If I had to go cask the first two years I worked here, if I had a dime for every time somebody came back up to the bar with their, their dimple mug of tall mast or mild or whatever that cask beer was and was like, Hey.
Cari Guerin:This beer is warm and flat.
Cari Guerin:Oh, no, that's, that's, that's what it is.
Cari Guerin:That's, that's beer
Bobby Fleshman:translation.
Bobby Fleshman:This is, this beer isn't Miller Life.
Cari Guerin:They just didn't understand what it was.
Cari Guerin:And, you know, that was one of the things that was a little bit of a shift for me coming here, was the educating of, of our, our clientele.
Cari Guerin:Because people didn't know what Cask beer was.
Dave:Mm-hmm.
Cari Guerin:And so to have to.
Cari Guerin:That was, that was another part of it.
Cari Guerin:Or even with the sour beers, a lot of people I had come, same thing.
Cari Guerin:People would come and be like, we think something might be wrong with your beer.
Cari Guerin:It's really, really sour.
Cari Guerin:Well, 'cause it's a sour beer.
Cari Guerin:And, and the educating was, was a really, it still is, it's still a fun thing to do.
Bobby Fleshman:And once in a while, I've talked about how Steve from Stone Arch, uh, he, he didn't say this so much, but.
Bobby Fleshman:He implied that if he had a chance to, he would open a pub like we have opened here.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Where we could, we could focus on ca scale.
Bobby Fleshman:And he, he and I talked about this before we opened this and we knew it'd be uphill.
Bobby Fleshman:And it has been uphill, but it's paid off.
Bobby Fleshman:It's created, oh my gosh.
Bobby Fleshman:Quiet the following.
Bobby Fleshman:We
Cari Guerin:downstairs.
Cari Guerin:Yes, there is definitely a, uh, a hauler.
Cari Guerin:Cult of the cask, if you will.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah, there is definitely what, what we call 'em, pinhead.
Bobby Fleshman:I call 'em pinhead.
Cari Guerin:Pinhead.
Cari Guerin:I like
Bobby Fleshman:because the
Cari Guerin:small, the smallest
Bobby Fleshman:version of a cask is called a pin.
Gary Arndt:I, I've
Bobby Fleshman:never
Cari Guerin:had a, or they could be our f firkin patrons.
Bobby Fleshman:There's so many F word combinations.
Gary Arndt:I never had a sour beer before I came here.
Gary Arndt:Ever.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Um, and it's probably my favorite style of beer now.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Or at least some of like the Berlin or Weis, the gsa, the, I love the gsa.
Bobby Fleshman:It comes from that sort of that wine cider quadrant a little bit, yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Of the palette.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:So that makes sense.
Cari Guerin:We even within that, that Ultima, the, oh
Bobby Fleshman:yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:So we do that wine.
Bobby Fleshman:Many people,
Cari Guerin:I get people that beer that say they don't like beer, and they're like, this is not beer.
Cari Guerin:I'm like, yeah, it is.
Bobby Fleshman:And it's a beer that really doesn't have a category.
Bobby Fleshman:I mean, there's very few beers like that in the world.
Bobby Fleshman:So it's a good crossover that way.
Cari Guerin:It's a fun one.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Gary Arndt:So when did you get your first job in the industry,
Cari Guerin:actually?
Cari Guerin:Oh, I used air quotes
Gary Arndt:around
Cari Guerin:industry.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:It was,
Bobby Fleshman:put that in the, in the transcripts, air quotes were
Cari Guerin:years, I don't even know if it was, I don't know how many years ago, 10 plus years ago.
Cari Guerin:Um, I was a regular at Stone Arch and, uh.
Cari Guerin:One.
Cari Guerin:Andy?
Cari Guerin:Yep.
Cari Guerin:He's now one of the, now he's like a, he's
Bobby Fleshman:GM over
Cari Guerin:there.
Cari Guerin:He's the brewer.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:He's, he's a head brewer over there and,
Bobby Fleshman:and no, he is a
Cari Guerin:full
Bobby Fleshman:blown
Cari Guerin:GM now.
Cari Guerin:Oh, he's the GM now?
Cari Guerin:Yeah, he's the whole thing.
Cari Guerin:Wow, okay.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, he was, he was a bartender and he was bartending in the tap room, and I was hanging out one day and he's like, man, I just wish I could get a Saturday off.
Cari Guerin:I'm like, I'll bartend for you.
Cari Guerin:And it was kind of a joke, but then he's like, really?
Cari Guerin:You want to, I'm like, yeah, actually I do.
Cari Guerin:And so they threw me behind the bar and.
Cari Guerin:It's all downhill from there.
Bobby Fleshman:It's all plateau from there.
Bobby Fleshman:It's all, yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:It's an industry where, yeah, you can look at it either way.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:I kind of got thrown into it and I loved it, and here I am,
Bobby Fleshman:and then she started stalking us and 20.
Bobby Fleshman:Six, oh gosh.
Bobby Fleshman:16, seven
Cari Guerin:something
Bobby Fleshman:Right after, whenever the news broke.
Cari Guerin:Well, because at that point is right when you were leaving there.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, that's right.
Cari Guerin:I left there.
Cari Guerin:I was just coming into that place.
Cari Guerin:And you were leaving
Bobby Fleshman:to build this place.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:And I heard of this being who was called Bobby and heard all these things about Bobby, and that's
Bobby Fleshman:on
Cari Guerin:his birth certificate, how much he knew about it.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Cari Guerin:Birth certificate, how much he knew about beer and, and all, all this stuff.
Cari Guerin:And then I, at one point I had heard that he was opening a brewery, so I did stock him on, on Facebook, found the brewery, and I messaged him and I said, Hey, here, you're opening a brewery.
Cari Guerin:No, you're not anywhere near hiring somebody, but when you get to that point, please reach out to me 'cause I'm gonna work for you.
Bobby Fleshman:When we finally sit down to do an interview, it really felt like a foregone conclusion, and it was me and Layla.
Cari Guerin:I think Shane was part of it too.
Bobby Fleshman:Maybe Shane was there.
Bobby Fleshman:I think he was too.
Bobby Fleshman:Think we were sort of the first three people working here the whole time and, and yeah, it felt very, very ceremonial at that point.
Gary Arndt:I've, I've had interviews like that.
Gary Arndt:Uh, the internet company used to have in the nineties.
Gary Arndt:I remember our guy who was our top programmer, he came in, uh, we used a, a, a platform that was really new at the time, and he had, he just, his, his resume.
Gary Arndt:Was a stack of code that he had written and it was like here, and I was looking at, I was like, you figured out ways to do things that aren't in this package yet.
Gary Arndt:No one has figured out how to do this.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:It's like, yeah, he, he never got a college degree.
Gary Arndt:Best, like I said, best programmer, we had best employee.
Gary Arndt:Like if he had any, at any point ever come to me and said, I want a raise, I'm like, okay, I have to.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Because we're screwed without you!.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:And we, we talk about this a lot, how the, the person standing behind the bar is the last one to touch the beer, and the only one that a lot of people ever have contact with.
Bobby Fleshman:I should
Gary Arndt:say Carrie touches the beer.
Gary Arndt:She'll put her finger in it
Bobby Fleshman:and everything.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, yeah.
Cari Guerin:Oh, any chance I get,
Bobby Fleshman:wait, we, if we ever get Mike on this, we have to make sure we're not literal.
Bobby Fleshman:So Mike's another one of our original og, which is
Cari Guerin:he's number two.
Cari Guerin:Id
Bobby Fleshman:like number two to
Cari Guerin:remind him that he is number two
Bobby Fleshman:and he's coming back for more hours these days.
Bobby Fleshman:It's like what's old is new.
Bobby Fleshman:But yeah, these people are everything for us up there.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, they know us only by the face of Carrie or Mike or whoever is standing behind that bar and if they touch their beer or not.
Gary Arndt:Um, so one of the things we wanted to talk to you about is that you are a cone,
Cari Guerin:a level one.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Gary Arndt:And so explain what that is.
Gary Arndt:'cause a lot of people, it's, it's a word they probably haven't come across.
Gary Arndt:Sure.
Cari Guerin:So it's, it's, I liken it for people who know a sommelier in the wine world is the equivalent of a Cicerone in the beer world.
Cari Guerin:Um, cone is a. I don't even remember how many levels there are now.
Cari Guerin:I think there are four now.
Cari Guerin:I think there's four levels because
Bobby Fleshman:there was such a huge gap from
Cari Guerin:two to three.
Cari Guerin:It
Bobby Fleshman:was stupid.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Level, level four, you can control beer with your mind,
Cari Guerin:basically.
Cari Guerin:Basically.
Cari Guerin:That's kind of where it is.
Cari Guerin:There's like 18
Bobby Fleshman:people in the world that have it.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:So ridiculous.
Cari Guerin:Something I'll never see, uh, level one certified beer server.
Cari Guerin:It's just how it, it fits with what this place is.
Cari Guerin:It is learning how to respect the beer.
Cari Guerin:It's learning how to pour it properly.
Cari Guerin:It's learning what a, a clean glass looks like.
Cari Guerin:It's learning, um, if, if the beer's not pouring properly, what, how to troubleshoot.
Cari Guerin:It's learning how to help people find a beer that they are going to enjoy.
Cari Guerin:Um, so that's that level one.
Cari Guerin:Level two is just learning so many things about beer that.
Cari Guerin:There's a big test that you have to take for the level two.
Cari Guerin:I'm, I'm hoping to someday take it.
Cari Guerin:Um, but
Dave:you got
Cari Guerin:this, you got, there's a written test that's just all sorts of beer knowledge.
Cari Guerin:But then there's a practical, and I liken it to, if you've ever seen the movie Napoleon Dynamite, where he is tasting the milk and he's like, this cow got into a field of onions.
Cari Guerin:And it's being able to taste these beers and tell what's wrong with them or what style it is.
Cari Guerin:And if you have a couple be, you're just
Gary Arndt:like,
Bobby Fleshman:do you have tots?
Cari Guerin:I mean, that's always a fair thing.
Cari Guerin:That's, that's like a pallet cleanser.
Cari Guerin:Those tots,
Bobby Fleshman:I always remember the, the movie, uh, sideways.
Cari Guerin:Oh yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:He convinces him that
Cari Guerin:No Low.
Bobby Fleshman:Well, there's, there's a moment where he convinces him that, to, to, that, that there's like, was it crayon or, or Eraser?
Bobby Fleshman:Eraser,
Cari Guerin:I think maybe
Bobby Fleshman:eraser.
Bobby Fleshman:And he convinced him of it, and then he slapped him in the back of the head because he was just leading him on Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:To see how much bullshit he would buy into Oh, oh, yeah.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Have you seen the uh, apple TV series drops of God?
Bobby Fleshman:No.
Cari Guerin:No, I
Gary Arndt:haven't.
Gary Arndt:I recommend it.
Gary Arndt:It's in English, Japanese, and French.
Gary Arndt:It's about the world's greatest wine connoisseur.
Gary Arndt:He dies and his daughter and the son he had in Japan that nobody knows about, have to compete
Cari Guerin:Oh geez.
Gary Arndt:For his estate, which is like a hundred million dollars collection of wine.
Gary Arndt:Whew.
Gary Arndt:And season two just started.
Gary Arndt:So
Bobby Fleshman:good tv.
Cari Guerin:Nice.
Gary Arndt:Uh, so why get a Cron certification?
Gary Arndt:What, what is the point of it?
Bobby Fleshman:I should, oh, go ahead interjecting just a little bit.
Bobby Fleshman:I think the Cron program exists because, was it Ray Daniels that started it?
Bobby Fleshman:And I think Randy Moser might have been involved as well.
Bobby Fleshman:I think Randy Moer was involved based in Chicago.
Bobby Fleshman:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:They, based in Chicago realized there wasn't, there really wasn't an analog in the beer world.
Bobby Fleshman:For what Somalia was, just to reinforce your point and, and that beer is the every man's woman's drink.
Bobby Fleshman:Over the course of history, but in reality, there's so much sophistication that could be celebrated.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:I think that's why they made it, they wanted to tell people in this way by, by creating this, this certification.
Bobby Fleshman:But anyway, so why this
Bobby Fleshman:real
Bobby Fleshman:Sure.
Bobby Fleshman:And
Cari Guerin:going off that and, and what I'm about to say is not a dis on wine at all.
Cari Guerin:I love wine, but
Gary Arndt:No, go
Cari Guerin:ahead.
Cari Guerin:Disarm wine.
Cari Guerin:Um,
Bobby Fleshman:has, you know what, you know, has wine makers drink while they're waiting for the wine to finish
Cari Guerin:beer?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:True story.
Cari Guerin:Wine.
Cari Guerin:Has very limited number of ingredients.
Cari Guerin:You're not gonna introduce adjuncts into your wines typically.
Cari Guerin:Um, it's, it's grapes.
Cari Guerin:It's water.
Cari Guerin:I mean it, it's very limited ingredients.
Cari Guerin:Beer, yes.
Cari Guerin:If you're looking at the Rhine Heitz Gobot, that beer Purity Law, that's just those four ingredients
Bobby Fleshman:not brought, just to call back another episode, Bob, business Opportunity.
Cari Guerin:But there's all these other things that can get introduced into beer and on, on top of that, if you look just to look at a hop.
Cari Guerin:There are how many different hops?
Cari Guerin:Well over a hundred different times, 150 times of different hops, and it's, it's ridiculous and can use them.
Cari Guerin:One hop in a beer.
Cari Guerin:You can use two hops in a beer.
Cari Guerin:All the, the unlimited number of combinations of, of things.
Cari Guerin:So beer is very, very complex.
Cari Guerin:And,
Bobby Fleshman:and the caveat is, none of us are wine makers by trade.
Bobby Fleshman:We, we've dabbled in wine, so we don't mean to talk down to that industry.
Cari Guerin:Not
Bobby Fleshman:at all.
Cari Guerin:Not at
Bobby Fleshman:all.
Bobby Fleshman:Lot.
Bobby Fleshman:Lot.
Bobby Fleshman:Not a
Cari Guerin:lot.
Cari Guerin:That, that's why I said, I'm not saying this as a, anybody with wine,
Gary Arndt:wine making money, farming.
Cari Guerin:Sure.
Cari Guerin:And
Bobby Fleshman:that's kind of how they market their industry too.
Bobby Fleshman:I mean
Gary Arndt:that's, you know, I, I
Cari Guerin:think there's more, more chemistry and artistry and beer.
Gary Arndt:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Because you're not, you're, you're selecting your ingredients from a much bigger menu.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Whereas
Cari Guerin:there's
Gary Arndt:so many more different combinations.
Gary Arndt:Your average wine maker is gonna have a vineyard and maybe they may blend grapes from some nearby vineyards.
Gary Arndt:Mm-hmm.
Gary Arndt:But it's not like, oh, we're buying something from the other side of the world.
Cari Guerin:Right.
Gary Arndt:They're just, you know, and then they, they mash it and then they let it
Bobby Fleshman:say, and I find, I find there's a lot more leniency and very batch variation because we talk about vintage and we celebrate the years.
Bobby Fleshman:That's not how beer is.
Bobby Fleshman:No.
Bobby Fleshman:And I've said that many times.
Bobby Fleshman:You gotta be able to execute the same product year by year, regardless of how that product came out of the field.
Cari Guerin:Oh yeah.
Cari Guerin:There is definitely something with beer to be said for consistency and that's, um, when I hear people dis the big beer makers, the Miller, the Budweiser, um.
Cari Guerin:There is something truly to be said for the consistency in those big mass producing breweries to be able to grab a Bud light off a shelf and you know exactly what you're gonna get every single time.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Cari Guerin:That is not easy to do.
Cari Guerin:So there's, I mean, I'm, I'm never gonna dis the mass producers.
Cari Guerin:I don't necessarily drink a lot of that 'cause I like craft beer, but there is something to be said for those mass produced beers.
Gary Arndt:Oh, I've noticed it here and I, I think I've, I've told Bobby there are times where I've had something amber or something where mm-hmm.
Gary Arndt:For whatever reason, that batch is particularly good.
Cari Guerin:Sure.
Gary Arndt:It's not that other ones are bad, but sometimes it's just like it goes to 11.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:And, and
Cari Guerin:sometimes I, okay.
Cari Guerin:Question for Bobby on this then.
Cari Guerin:I feel like sometimes it's maybe that you weren't able to get a particular hop.
Cari Guerin:And you have to substitute with something else.
Cari Guerin:I,
Bobby Fleshman:I was about to point that out.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, on our scale, we don't have access to the ingredients, the lot sizes that, that these big brewers do, and we are navigating that.
Bobby Fleshman:The other thing though, on our scale, we're only entering our, our eighth year and a lot of these macro brewers we're talking about are 200 years old.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:And they've had that many years to dial in their recipe.
Bobby Fleshman:Right.
Bobby Fleshman:So as much as I get shit for fucking with recipes.
Bobby Fleshman:It's part of what it takes to, to, to develop your, your menu and then to execute on that is where the technician's hat comes on, comes into play.
Bobby Fleshman:And you have to be able to, to repeat that recipe once it's, once it's been, uh, uh, embraced by the, the people that spend their money.
Bobby Fleshman:So, yeah, I think the, the big guys have have realized who they are, and now they've gone into technician mode for the last a hundred plus years.
Gary Arndt:So you, uh, presented a fe to Comli to Bobby, uh, that you would work here.
Gary Arndt:So what is your, and we talked about this on a previous episode.
Gary Arndt:What is your favorite beer at Mc Fleishmans?
Cari Guerin:Oh, that's such a hard question because I love so many of the beers that they make here.
Gary Arndt:Then let me flip it.
Gary Arndt:What is your least favorite beer?
Cari Guerin:Oh, my least favorite.
Cari Guerin:Um,
Gary Arndt:the ones like, yeah, it's not my thing.
Cari Guerin:I, there are a couple different ones.
Cari Guerin:I'm, I'm not a big fan of a wild sour.
Cari Guerin:Um, if they get into a little too much funk, not my thing.
Cari Guerin:Um, if you start using the terms wet horse blanket to describe a beer, it's just, I'm, I don't care for that.
Cari Guerin:And I know some people love it, and it's a very traditional style.
Cari Guerin:I can appreciate it for what it is.
Cari Guerin:I'm not gonna ever order that beer.
Cari Guerin:Um,
Bobby Fleshman:so people love that
Gary Arndt:stuff.
Cari Guerin:And
Bobby Fleshman:yeah, for people listening, that's, uh, that's, it's now since been, uh, identified as a yeast.
Bobby Fleshman:It's called Myis.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Which means British fungus.
Bobby Fleshman:If you're breaking that word down.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, and it's what was found in the staves of barrels over time.
Bobby Fleshman:So a lot of your porters and IPAs, and you name it, finished this way over time.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, for sure.
Bobby Fleshman:And, and so they would, they would actually start blending new and old, and this is how some of your porters came about at the pub.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:They would blend the new and old, which is gonna really south and the really fresh stuff.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Cari Guerin:So not, not my, not my style.
Cari Guerin:Um, oh.
Cari Guerin:I, I don't, I, I appreciate the stones throw.
Cari Guerin:It's, it's, or, or, yeah, the stones throw.
Cari Guerin:It's just, it's not my beer.
Cari Guerin:It's a great beer.
Cari Guerin:People love it.
Cari Guerin:I am so happy that people love it.
Cari Guerin:It's just not my, my style.
Cari Guerin:Um, I tend to lean more toward.
Cari Guerin:A little bit bigger beers.
Cari Guerin:I shouldn't even say that though.
Cari Guerin:'cause I love a good Kolsch or a good pilsner.
Gary Arndt:What are you drinking right now?
Cari Guerin:I am, I'm drinking the public house pint dry Irish Soat
Bobby Fleshman:with a soundtrack playing in the
Cari Guerin:background with, with the I, yeah.
Cari Guerin:It felt right in the moment with the Irish music playing.
Gary Arndt:So in addition to working here, being a cerone, uh, you've also visited a great many breweries in the state of Wisconsin.
Cari Guerin:I have.
Cari Guerin:I, I have.
Gary Arndt:So 200 plus.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Gary Arndt:I didn't even know there were that many.
Gary Arndt:Um,
Cari Guerin:and not all of them in Wisconsin.
Cari Guerin:Some are outside of
Gary Arndt:Wisconsin.
Gary Arndt:Do you have
Cari Guerin:tasted, but
Gary Arndt:how many beers?
Gary Arndt:Probably,
Cari Guerin:oh, what did I say?
Cari Guerin:Like 3,400 plus.
Cari Guerin:Something like that.
Gary Arndt:So fl men's aside, what are your favorite breweries in the state?
Gary Arndt:Gimme a time.
Cari Guerin:Oh, in the state?
Gary Arndt:Five.
Cari Guerin:Um, yeah.
Cari Guerin:I love Central Waters.
Cari Guerin:I love the, the space.
Cari Guerin:I love when it's, I've
Gary Arndt:heard that a lot.
Cari Guerin:Summertime.
Cari Guerin:The one, the Amherst, the Milwaukee one is fantastic too.
Cari Guerin:It's beautiful old church building.
Cari Guerin:It's gorgeous.
Cari Guerin:But the Amherst location grabbing a beer sitting outside.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, their anniversaries next
Cari Guerin:Saturday.
Cari Guerin:It is.
Cari Guerin:It's 'cause coming Saturday.
Cari Guerin:Need get
Bobby Fleshman:tickets.
Bobby Fleshman:I got,
Cari Guerin:yeah, I
Bobby Fleshman:got you.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Excited.
Cari Guerin:I got
Gary Arndt:EIP tickets.
Bobby Fleshman:You do.
Cari Guerin:Nice.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Denny.
Bobby Fleshman:Denny.
Cari Guerin:Oh, nice.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh man.
Cari Guerin:It's gonna be a fun time.
Cari Guerin:We all know the same
Bobby Fleshman:guy.
Bobby Fleshman:This is
Cari Guerin:one guy.
Cari Guerin:We all got the same guy.
Cari Guerin:But to grab a beer out there in the summer and sit outside is just, it's, it's my happy place.
Cari Guerin:Um, I, I love going there.
Cari Guerin:Um, outside of Wisconsin, they're
Bobby Fleshman:also a really environmentally
Cari Guerin:friendly They are, yes.
Cari Guerin:Brewery as well.
Cari Guerin:Yes.
Cari Guerin:They're super, super, super green, which is amazing.
Cari Guerin:And
Bobby Fleshman:their barrel
Cari Guerin:aged beers
Bobby Fleshman:are just,
Cari Guerin:um,
Bobby Fleshman:I was just
Cari Guerin:gonna go into that Unparalleled.
Cari Guerin:Their, their barrel program is phenomenal.
Cari Guerin:The stuff they're putting out in the barrels is just world class, I think.
Cari Guerin:Um, and I, and I know a couple of the people that, that are there.
Cari Guerin:They are great people that work there.
Cari Guerin:Um.
Cari Guerin:Yeah, I just, I love going there.
Cari Guerin:It's just, I can go, I can take a deep breath and relax when I go there.
Cari Guerin:Um, so many other breweries, there's some, so many great breweries in Wisconsin.
Cari Guerin:Um, but like outside, I'm gonna, I'm gonna put this one in.
Cari Guerin:The most surprising brewery I ever stumbled upon was actually in the jungles of Costa Rica.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:You showing me pictures of this place?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:This, there was a brewery out in the middle of the jungle, surprising
Gary Arndt:the fact that there even
Cari Guerin:was a brewery.
Cari Guerin:It was, well, that was surprise number one.
Cari Guerin:But the bigger surprise was that I had one of the best cultures I have ever had in my life.
Bobby Fleshman:It doesn't hurt that the
Cari Guerin:amazing
Bobby Fleshman:that the weather was what it was.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, for sure.
Bobby Fleshman:It must have matched perfectly
Cari Guerin:for Oh yeah.
Cari Guerin:It was perfect weather for that.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:But it was, so the lacing on the beer was amazing, but literally just out in the open, not even in a building, it was out in the open in the middle of the Costa Rican jungle.
Bobby Fleshman:Love that.
Cari Guerin:It was so cool.
Gary Arndt:And someone said, this is a good place for a brewery.
Gary Arndt:Let's
Cari Guerin:do
Gary Arndt:it.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:It was so fun to go there.
Bobby Fleshman:And they're making, well, it's, it's sort of a lagger, it's a cool fermented ale.
Bobby Fleshman:So, yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:In the middle of Costa Rica.
Bobby Fleshman:It's crazy.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:I don't know how they, how they lagger that beer.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Because it was like 90 degrees.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:But it was so good.
Gary Arndt:And your favorite non Mc Fleshman Beer year.
Cari Guerin:Um, okay.
Cari Guerin:I, I will, I'll give you my, my Desert Island beer.
Cari Guerin:Uh, Bell's two hearted.
Gary Arndt:How
Cari Guerin:do
Bobby Fleshman:you
Gary Arndt:spell that?
Cari Guerin:Bells.
Cari Guerin:Bells Brewery.
Gary Arndt:Okay.
Cari Guerin:Two Hearted Ale.
Bobby Fleshman:Two hearted is a, it's a fish right?
Bobby Fleshman:In the,
Cari Guerin:I think so.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:The fish is a lo, the logo is a fish for that day.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:They named it after that fish.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Two hearted.
Bobby Fleshman:And it's, it's arguably the best.
Cari Guerin:It's
Bobby Fleshman:double IPA in the United States.
Bobby Fleshman:It's
Cari Guerin:so freaking good.
Cari Guerin:It's just hits.
Cari Guerin:Where's
Bobby Fleshman:the brewery
Cari Guerin:in Michigan?
Bobby Fleshman:It's, it's between Pliny the Elder, which we're gonna have an interview with the owner of Soon.
Cari Guerin:Oh fun.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, Russian River Brewing Company, but it's our, it's between that one and, uh, Bell's two Hearted as to who makes the Best West or Best American double IPA.
Bobby Fleshman:But yeah, that's a good one.
Bobby Fleshman:That's all Centennial Hops.
Bobby Fleshman:That's a, that's all
Cari Guerin:Centennial
Bobby Fleshman:Hop beer.
Bobby Fleshman:I love the Centennial Hop.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Oh, I love that little resine Danky.
Bobby Fleshman:You don't have, like, you don't have any, uh, number twos.
Bobby Fleshman:That's your number one.
Bobby Fleshman:That's
Cari Guerin:your, that's my number one's, right?
Cari Guerin:That is, that is, if I can only drink one beer for the rest of my life, that's the
Bobby Fleshman:beer, not the worst choice.
Gary Arndt:Okay.
Gary Arndt:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Final question for you.
Gary Arndt:We get people listening to the show from all over.
Gary Arndt:Let's say we had someone recently come here from OUTTA state because mm-hmm.
Gary Arndt:They wanted to meet me and I didn't know they were coming.
Gary Arndt:You're behind the bar.
Gary Arndt:They order a flight and they, you have full sure choice on what they're gonna get.
Gary Arndt:What are you gonna pour for 'em?
Cari Guerin:Uh, for sure a cask beer, depending on what's on and what else I pick is going to determine which cask beer, but for sure a cask beer.
Cari Guerin:Uh, I will probably pull something from our luer faucet because that is another beer type of pour that a lot of people don't always know about.
Cari Guerin:So I like to introduce those two different kinds of faucets or pores.
Cari Guerin:Um, gosh, it's really gonna depend on what we have on, um, okay.
Cari Guerin:I'm just gonna go with any beers that we have.
Cari Guerin:I'm probably gonna pour a, uh, a tall mask from the cask.
Cari Guerin:I'll say a Schwartz beer from the Luker so that we got a lighter and a darker, not a hildy.
Cari Guerin:Ooh, Hildy.
Cari Guerin:Ah.
Cari Guerin:We have so many really nice light beers.
Cari Guerin:And trust me, Hildy Hildy, she's my girl.
Cari Guerin:I take her on vacation with me.
Cari Guerin:I have pictures of her in Costa Rica, the beach.
Cari Guerin:I have pictures of her on the beach in Florida with me.
Cari Guerin:I have pictures of her in Cancun.
Cari Guerin:She's my girl.
Cari Guerin:I love her.
Cari Guerin:Um, but if I'm gonna do a lighter, um, beer on the cask, I'm probably gonna go darker on the looker.
Cari Guerin:Uh, then I would probably go with maybe like Pirates Cove, just because it's such a staple for us and it's just a great beer.
Cari Guerin:And then what would that fourth one be?
Cari Guerin:That's a tough one.
Cari Guerin:I might go with something kind of different that they've never experienced, like an Ultima Rose, just because it's such a unique style.
Cari Guerin:If they're giving me nothing to go on, just to give them a real total array of different stuff, couple beer flavored beers, couple not so beer flavored beers.
Bobby Fleshman:Not one.
Bobby Fleshman:I mean, of course Tall Mast, but not one west coast IPA.
Bobby Fleshman:That's fascinating.
Cari Guerin:I know, right?
Bobby Fleshman:I mean, I don't disagree with the
Cari Guerin:choice.
Cari Guerin:That's That's where, that's where I go.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:If I'm drinking a beer, typically I lean toward the west coast.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:But if given no direction, I know that's kind of can be a polarizing beer for people.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Cari Guerin:Right.
Cari Guerin:I'm probably gonna stay away from it.
Bobby Fleshman:Fair enough.
Cari Guerin:Just 'cause I like it doesn't mean everybody does.
Bobby Fleshman:Joel would not be nodding at this point.
Cari Guerin:I know he wouldn't.
Gary Arndt:To be fair, there are a lot of IPA drinkers out there.
Cari Guerin:There are,
Gary Arndt:but,
Bobby Fleshman:and they'll find
Cari Guerin:their way to those.
Cari Guerin:But if I, and I, I did throw a Tall Mast in there.
Cari Guerin:Granted it's and English IPA, but I like, I, I like to give that beer to an IPA drinker because it is so different.
Bobby Fleshman:I always love the comment when they drink tall mass, which by the way is one silver gold.
Bobby Fleshman:Gold in the last three years US open.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:And they always come back and say, that is a really interesting direction to take an IPA and I ha I just, I can't help, but you know, I don't have enough time to explain to them that that's, that statement is completely upended backwards from the truth.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:That's where it all began.
Cari Guerin:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:Alright, well that'll conclude this episode of Respecting the Beer.
Gary Arndt:The producer of Respecting the Beer is David Kalsow, and if it wasn't for David, this show would not exist.
Gary Arndt:Please join the Facebook group to get updates between the episodes and to support the show over on Patreon where you can get bits that don't make it into the regular show, as well as special things like events and special beers that are brewed only for Patreon members.
Gary Arndt:Links to both of these are in the show notes, and until next time, please remember to respect the beer.