Artwork for podcast Whispers of the Past - The Hidden History of St. Eustatius
Awakening from the Echoes of the Past 2000-2025
Episode 1224th May 2025 • Whispers of the Past - The Hidden History of St. Eustatius • Fi de Wit
00:00:00 00:43:51

Share Episode

Shownotes

In Awakening from the Echoes of the Past, we explore Stacia’s transformation from 2000 to 2025. From the quiet rumble of the Quill to the deep impact of 10-10-10, we trace how memory, gender, and governance intertwine. Featuring reflections from Governor Francis, historians, elders, and heritage experts, this episode uncovers the emotional legacies of post-emancipation grief and the unspoken costs of resilience. What happens when silence is no longer enough? How do women lead, heal, and preserve in the face of historical fracture? Through personal truths and public shifts, we ask what it takes to move from survival to liberation and how the echoes of the past can guide a freer future.

Produced by Simpler Media

Transcripts

Speaker:

>> : What I like about Stacia?

Speaker:

You are free.

Speaker:

I am free. And

Speaker:

you can move how you want,

Speaker:

where you want, when to go.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Welcome to Whispers of the Past. I'm your host,

Speaker:

Fitavit. In this episode, awakening from

Speaker:

the echoes of the past, we step into the

Speaker:

2000s to 2025.

Speaker:

We begin with the land, volcanic,

Speaker:

alive. Beneath the soil of

Speaker:

Cintastasias, the quail sleeps. But

Speaker:

its silence is never empty. It

Speaker:

reminds us that even dormant truths still

Speaker:

carry pressure. And so does history.

Speaker:

These past 25 years have brought seismic

Speaker:

shifts. 10, 10, 10.

Speaker:

Constitutional change, the rise of women's

Speaker:

leadership, and the reckoning with enslaved,

Speaker:

unspoken legacy. But

Speaker:

transformation doesn't only take place in

Speaker:

parliaments or policies. It lives in

Speaker:

memory, in silence, in

Speaker:

the body, in the stories shared

Speaker:

across generations, in the voices

Speaker:

that until now lived on in the margins.

Speaker:

In this episode, we walk with those

Speaker:

voices, from governors and

Speaker:

grandmothers to historians and

Speaker:

heritage experts. We follow

Speaker:

the thread of gender and governance.

Speaker:

And we ask what happens when the past

Speaker:

speaks and we finally listen.

Speaker:

Before we talk about the people, the

Speaker:

politics or the power shifts,

Speaker:

we first look to the land.

Speaker:

Sintostatius, known for its quiet

Speaker:

rhythms and deep rooted resilience,

Speaker:

stands atop a sleeping giant.

Speaker:

Beneath the fertile hills and winding roads

Speaker:

of this tiny Dutch Caribbean island lies

Speaker:

the Quill, a dormant volcano

Speaker:

whose very presence reminds us that

Speaker:

transformation is always shimmering below the

Speaker:

surface. As we step into

Speaker:

the 21st century, the story of modern

Speaker:

day Stacia begins not only with laws and

Speaker:

leaders, but with the earth itself.

Speaker:

The landscape, both literal and symbolic,

Speaker:

continues to shift. We begin with

Speaker:

archaeologist Dr. Stelton, who explains

Speaker:

to us the Quill and what's to come.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Stelton: So the Quill is dormant. So

Speaker:

the Quill is what's called the stratovolcano. The

Speaker:

Quill's last eruption was about 1600 years

Speaker:

ago. And it's not a matter of if, but when it will

Speaker:

erupt again. Because the process, that one

Speaker:

tectonic plate sliding under the other is a continuing

Speaker:

process that is ongoing to this day. Right?

Speaker:

So as we speak, pressure is building

Speaker:

up underneath our little island and underneath

Speaker:

St. Kitts and underneath Ceiba and, and underneath

Speaker:

Montserrat, et cetera, et cetera. And at some point the

Speaker:

volcano will erupt again. It's just a matter of when. We don't know.

Speaker:

It could be 10 years from now, could be a hundred, or it

Speaker:

could be 500 or 1,000. We just. Yeah, there's no way of knowing. Even

Speaker:

though the volcano will erupt again, that does not necessarily mean, of course,

Speaker:

that the island will be destroyed or something like that.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: Right.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Stelton: It could be that there is a pyroclastic flow of hot

Speaker:

ash and gas that goes the other way. And even if

Speaker:

there is an explosion of that involves lava or

Speaker:

molten rock, that doesn't necessarily mean that it will engulf the whole

Speaker:

island.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Just as pressure beneath the surface builds quietly

Speaker:

until something must give, so too did the

Speaker:

political and social changes of early 2000.

Speaker:

Stacia begin to gather force.

Speaker:

In 2010, known across the Dutch

Speaker:

Caribbean as 101010 Sint

Speaker:

Eustace officially became a special

Speaker:

municipality of the Netherlands.

Speaker:

This was not a decision made lightly, nor a path

Speaker:

chosen freely. But in the face of

Speaker:

uncertainty, local voices,

Speaker:

especially those of women, rose with

Speaker:

clarity and conviction. It is

Speaker:

here we turn to Mrs. M. Sutekow, a long

Speaker:

term resident and one of the founders of the

Speaker:

center of Archaeology and research,

Speaker:

who reflects on the transformation of

Speaker:

governance, the evolving role of women in

Speaker:

politics and what it meant for Stacia to

Speaker:

step into a new identity, one shaped

Speaker:

by both resistance and reinvention.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: Well, of course, um, Stacia

Speaker:

continued to grow in the early 200,000

Speaker:

2010 we became part

Speaker:

of Holland. Um, 101010

Speaker:

will always be a date that we work from,

Speaker:

from backward and forward.

Speaker:

Good things came about. I think that our

Speaker:

education system, in our medical system

Speaker:

to a certain extent have mainly the

Speaker:

educational system have improved greatly.

Speaker:

Um, women were very much involved in that

Speaker:

period of time, in the transition and the transfer

Speaker:

over to, uh, our current

Speaker:

form of government. A lot of women

Speaker:

politicians during that period started their own

Speaker:

parties. Um, Nora

Speaker:

Snake for one, Ingrid Whitfield.

Speaker:

Other people who have been really

Speaker:

prominent in the political

Speaker:

landscape of Statia came to the forefront

Speaker:

in those periods of time.

Speaker:

Um, we have to have nothing but

Speaker:

pride and respect for the way the women on

Speaker:

the island and we can proceed on

Speaker:

m. Of course our Alita Francis as

Speaker:

governor, Governor Frances has made a huge

Speaker:

difference in that. This is a time

Speaker:

when I think the

Speaker:

women's role was more

Speaker:

appreciated and more seen. We have really

Speaker:

wonderful young female politicians coming

Speaker:

up now that we should be very proud of.

Speaker:

In the early 2000s

Speaker:

this was, I think one of the biggest things

Speaker:

that happened is that suddenly the

Speaker:

women in politics and station was really well

Speaker:

recognized

Speaker:

and the landscape on the island has

Speaker:

changed tremendously.

Speaker:

Um, it has become a lot more

Speaker:

expensive to live here. It has

Speaker:

become a time when there is a lot

Speaker:

of political, uh,

Speaker:

differences on the island.

Speaker:

I don't want to be critical, but I

Speaker:

think that the whole transfer could have

Speaker:

been done differently. Um, and

Speaker:

I think that there were a lot of mistakes made by the

Speaker:

Dutch during that period of time. But

Speaker:

I also think that people need

Speaker:

to realize that this was not Stacia.

Speaker:

We chose to become part, uh, stay part of the Netherlands until

Speaker:

that choice was not realistic if the other islands

Speaker:

weren't willing to do that. But the people of

Speaker:

Stacia spoke very

Speaker:

strongly that what they wanted for

Speaker:

themselves was something different than

Speaker:

what eventually happened. And

Speaker:

I think that we can say that with pride because

Speaker:

I think that we were not influenced

Speaker:

by the outside. Uh, we made a choice even

Speaker:

if it was unrealistic, even if we couldn't accomplish

Speaker:

it because of the other islands, uh, not supporting it.

Speaker:

That says we

Speaker:

can voice for ourselves what we

Speaker:

want.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): As the dust settled after 1010 10, the

Speaker:

true architects of Stacia's new era began to

Speaker:

emerge. Not only in government chambers,

Speaker:

but in classrooms, community spaces,

Speaker:

and across kitchen tables, where women

Speaker:

shaped the spirit of governance long before it

Speaker:

was ever written in law.

Speaker:

Mrs. Sutaka reminds us that the island

Speaker:

political reorientation can came with growing

Speaker:

pains, but also with pride, especially

Speaker:

in the visibility and the voice of women.

Speaker:

By the early 2000, Stacia

Speaker:

stood at a crossroads between what it had

Speaker:

been and what it might become.

Speaker:

The 10-10-10 transition

Speaker:

marked not just a constitutional shift, but

Speaker:

a deeper redefinition of identity,

Speaker:

responsibility and leadership.

Speaker:

The voices that helped navigate this moment

Speaker:

were not always loud, but they were steady,

Speaker:

present and often feminine.

Speaker:

The groundwork for women political leadership had been

Speaker:

laid in decades past, and a

Speaker:

new generation stepped into the public life.

Speaker:

Those roots began to bloom.

Speaker:

Governor Frances doesn't just reflect on that

Speaker:

journey, she embodies it. Her story

Speaker:

traces the movement of women from domestic life

Speaker:

into decision making roles, anchoring

Speaker:

Stacia's transformation in a legacy of

Speaker:

leadership shaped not by power, but by

Speaker:

service.

Speaker:

>> : Um, the role of women began

Speaker:

to change more from domestic work

Speaker:

to taking positions in government and in

Speaker:

politics. I think one of the changing

Speaker:

moments in women becoming more

Speaker:

involved, for instance, in government affairs in

Speaker:

1988. In

Speaker:

1988, Ingrid Whitfield became

Speaker:

the first female commissioner on

Speaker:

St. Eustatius. It was a big deal back then,

Speaker:

and I think it was two years later. In

Speaker:

1991, Ingrid Whitfield and

Speaker:

Leonora Snake Gibbs became the two first

Speaker:

women in the Island Council of St.

Speaker:

Eustatius. So that was a changing moment,

Speaker:

um, for women in politics on St.

Speaker:

Eustatius and throughout the

Speaker:

decades, we also see where

Speaker:

women began to take the top positions in

Speaker:

government. If you look now, today we, um,

Speaker:

have a lot of women in the top positions. Uh,

Speaker:

so women play a leading role in

Speaker:

the development of statia. While,

Speaker:

um, we see now, um, with the last

Speaker:

elections that we had in April

Speaker:

2022, I believe it was

Speaker:

for the first time in the history all three political

Speaker:

parties were headed by women.

Speaker:

I don't want anyone to underestimate the

Speaker:

role of women in station society.

Speaker:

It's just that women lead differently. And the

Speaker:

majority of the station women that I know, they lead

Speaker:

from a position of service and

Speaker:

not from a position of power.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Stacia's women had long moved from the margins to the

Speaker:

forefront, Leading not only in government

Speaker:

chambers, but in classrooms, cultural

Speaker:

spaces, and the daily act of care.

Speaker:

Yet even as visibility increased, the

Speaker:

deeper work of healing had only just begun.

Speaker:

Because not all legacies are visible. Some live

Speaker:

in silence,

Speaker:

Intergenerational silences shaped by post

Speaker:

emancipation grief, where families

Speaker:

navigated trauma without words.

Speaker:

In Stacia, as in much of the Caribbean,

Speaker:

certain truths were never spoken out loud.

Speaker:

Culturally silenced by shame, survival,

Speaker:

or the belief that forgetting might protect the next

Speaker:

generation. But

Speaker:

silence does not erase impact.

Speaker:

Beneath what we often call resilience, Governor

Speaker:

Francis reminds us lie unspoken currents of

Speaker:

transgenerational trauma. Patterns of pain,

Speaker:

separation, and normalized behaviors rooted

Speaker:

in slavery's long shadow. If we are to

Speaker:

move towards real freedom, we must begin

Speaker:

not with blame, but with conversation.

Speaker:

And not just about what was done, but about what

Speaker:

was left behind.

Speaker:

>> : You know, I started off the story with our

Speaker:

women staying behind, uh, and as our

Speaker:

men went abroad to work,

Speaker:

but also, um, even in modern

Speaker:

day Stacia, uh, it has become such a norm

Speaker:

for a man to have several families.

Speaker:

Again, that is also part

Speaker:

of slavery, where you had the breeding farms, you

Speaker:

know, um, the men were

Speaker:

forced to, especially if he looked

Speaker:

strong and good, beautiful teeth, um, was

Speaker:

forced to be a breeder, a good

Speaker:

breeder, and had to breed,

Speaker:

um, new slaves because

Speaker:

after a while it became too costly

Speaker:

to transport, um,

Speaker:

humans from Africa

Speaker:

to the Caribbean and other parts of the world. So

Speaker:

if you had really good looking slaves and who was strong,

Speaker:

um, that was promoted. And so

Speaker:

those are also some of the cultural,

Speaker:

um, aspects, the trauma

Speaker:

that has been normalized

Speaker:

and the behavior has been normalized. So we

Speaker:

still see it today. That causes a lot of pain.

Speaker:

We, we have become accepting to it.

Speaker:

But I can tell you it is rough for children growing up,

Speaker:

um, sometimes not having the same name,

Speaker:

um, as their, or their

Speaker:

mother, not having the same name

Speaker:

as their father, uh, they not having

Speaker:

the same name as their father.

Speaker:

We talk a lot about the Station resilience.

Speaker:

Um, and it's good to be resilient, but

Speaker:

in the resiliency, it's good also to have the

Speaker:

conversations because you can be strong,

Speaker:

appear to be strong, but there can be so many

Speaker:

underlying unspoken stories

Speaker:

and truths. Um, so you don't want to

Speaker:

have a resilience of appearance

Speaker:

or appearing that you're resilient when underneath

Speaker:

there are all these currents that are still,

Speaker:

um, there. The pain,

Speaker:

um, the anger. Um, so,

Speaker:

um, I'm hoping that in the years to come,

Speaker:

as I said to you, there are

Speaker:

many stations, all types of

Speaker:

stations. And there are those among us

Speaker:

who really want to have that deep

Speaker:

conversation that can make us really feel

Speaker:

truly liberated, truly free from

Speaker:

the past. Will it ever happen? I don't

Speaker:

know. But at least we, uh, must start a conversation.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): What we inherent isn't only land,

Speaker:

language or legacy. It's also

Speaker:

behaviors, silences and ways of

Speaker:

survival. Governor Francis peels

Speaker:

back the layers of modern life on Stacia to

Speaker:

show how transgenerational trauma and post

Speaker:

emancipation grief have etched themselves

Speaker:

into family patterns, gender dynamics

Speaker:

and community life. When the past

Speaker:

isn't spoken, it finds other ways to

Speaker:

speak through unspoken grief, through

Speaker:

patterns we inherent without question, and through

Speaker:

children who carry the weight of intergenerational

Speaker:

silence without even being told why.

Speaker:

But truth telling, she reminds us,

Speaker:

begins with reflection. It takes

Speaker:

courage to question what we've accepted,

Speaker:

to sit with the quiet ache beneath resilience,

Speaker:

especially in a place where resilience itself

Speaker:

has long been a badge of honor, but

Speaker:

sometimes also a mask.

Speaker:

And so the question what does

Speaker:

healing look like in a matrifolkial society

Speaker:

where women have carried so much?

Speaker:

Governor Frances continues as she shifts the lens

Speaker:

towards the next generation, tracing how gender

Speaker:

roles and expectations passed down through

Speaker:

generations impacts how we raise boys

Speaker:

and girls today, what we get taught,

Speaker:

what gets forgotten and what gets passed

Speaker:

on.

Speaker:

>> : We've lost a lot that is

Speaker:

typically us. Uh, but it

Speaker:

also has a lot to do with, with the way

Speaker:

we raise our children. I won't only blame it

Speaker:

on the exposure to other cultures or

Speaker:

American tv. It's also the way we are raising

Speaker:

our children. For some reason,

Speaker:

we raise our young girls in a more, uh,

Speaker:

traditional way. Um, you know, helping around

Speaker:

the house, cleaning, um, ironing,

Speaker:

doing, you know, we call it chores.

Speaker:

I don't consider it chores. I consider it preparing us

Speaker:

for a life on our own. You know, one day you're

Speaker:

going to grow up, you're going to need to know to cook, you're going to need to know to clean. You're going

Speaker:

to need to know how to iron. So while we prepare our young women

Speaker:

for that, unfortunately we don't do it enough,

Speaker:

um, with our young men. So um,

Speaker:

I don't know where we went wrong, but that is also

Speaker:

part of our own contribution to where we are now

Speaker:

and the gap that we see in our

Speaker:

young people,

Speaker:

um, losing

Speaker:

a lot of the true values

Speaker:

of what we stand for. Um, do we

Speaker:

give the right examples of how we speak

Speaker:

to m, um

Speaker:

our women? Do we give the right

Speaker:

example about how we treat our

Speaker:

women? Um, I

Speaker:

speak a lot to

Speaker:

young men and I try

Speaker:

to find out why they don't want to

Speaker:

commit, you know, in relationships.

Speaker:

And they are so fearful of

Speaker:

commitment. And

Speaker:

um, again

Speaker:

that is something that is continuing

Speaker:

for so many years and it's causing a lot of pain

Speaker:

in our community because

Speaker:

uh, our women never truly feel respected and honored

Speaker:

while they give so much and they deserve

Speaker:

more than they are getting. And

Speaker:

um,

Speaker:

again,

Speaker:

education, awareness,

Speaker:

communication. We have a lot

Speaker:

of work to do because our men are ah, still

Speaker:

so much inside that they

Speaker:

are afraid to express. They are afraid to show

Speaker:

up vulnerable, afraid to show

Speaker:

up tender, they're afraid to show up caring. And again,

Speaker:

where does that come from? Can we blame it only

Speaker:

on tv or is it again related to

Speaker:

our past and the way we were

Speaker:

treated? So um, it's

Speaker:

a lot of work that we have to do because it's

Speaker:

showing itself in our community

Speaker:

in a way that the uh, generations that

Speaker:

will come will take part.

Speaker:

Continuing to disintegrate as

Speaker:

family, as stations.

Speaker:

It's causing a lot of pain.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Resilience, when not met with equal support,

Speaker:

turns into exhaustion. What's often

Speaker:

praised as strength in Caribbean women can also be

Speaker:

a quiet burden, one inherited across

Speaker:

generations. Like a well worn story that

Speaker:

was never fully told. From the forced

Speaker:

separation of enslavement to today's unspoken

Speaker:

emotional distance, the systems may look

Speaker:

different, but the impact lingers.

Speaker:

This is part of what scholars call post

Speaker:

enslavement syndrome, where historical

Speaker:

trauma and gender expectations continue

Speaker:

to shape modern family life. But

Speaker:

the call of gender justice asks for more than

Speaker:

endurance. It asks us to build balance

Speaker:

where care, emotional openness and

Speaker:

responsibility is shared not in

Speaker:

opposition, but as a shared foundation.

Speaker:

So perhaps the real work begins not just in

Speaker:

raising strong daughters, but emotionally rooted

Speaker:

sons. Not just in surviving the past,

Speaker:

but in learning how to speak through it together.

Speaker:

>> : While I really appreciate the emancipation of

Speaker:

women and I appreciate that

Speaker:

we um, able to

Speaker:

do a lot on our own,

Speaker:

I believe in the

Speaker:

working together of men and Women on

Speaker:

every front, not only in the

Speaker:

field of work, not only in the church, but more so

Speaker:

in the family unit.

Speaker:

And, um, it is absolutely necessary that,

Speaker:

um, we pause a

Speaker:

station, men and women.

Speaker:

Um, and I want to say we'll still

Speaker:

revert back to your question, that to our young

Speaker:

Stacia women, our seashore woman,

Speaker:

um, in general, we have

Speaker:

achieved a lot in terms of education,

Speaker:

achieved a lot in business. Because throughout this island you

Speaker:

see our young women and women doing well in business.

Speaker:

But I want them to take a more bold stand when it comes

Speaker:

to their relationships. You

Speaker:

know, stop taking a back seat, stop

Speaker:

accepting mediocrity, stop,

Speaker:

um, accepting the fact that he does not want to have

Speaker:

the wrong conversation, that he does not want to

Speaker:

commit. We have to force the

Speaker:

conversation. We have to find out what is

Speaker:

happening, what is happening on the deeper

Speaker:

side of our men. How can we get them to work

Speaker:

together with us so that we can build a strong

Speaker:

Stacia family. So I don't want

Speaker:

to continue to see a Stacia where

Speaker:

our women have to be so resilient, but

Speaker:

resilience almost to a point of

Speaker:

loneliness, you know, uh, we deserve so

Speaker:

much better. And, um, if it takes us

Speaker:

to push the lever,

Speaker:

then let us do that. Let us,

Speaker:

um, challenge our men, let us nurture them,

Speaker:

let us drive the conversation, Let us help them to open

Speaker:

up, let us help them to be vulnerable. Let us

Speaker:

help them to have a different

Speaker:

perspective. It will take time,

Speaker:

but let us make really concerted

Speaker:

efforts. Um,

Speaker:

um, we

Speaker:

won't achieve the common goal that we want to

Speaker:

achieve because Stacia is not

Speaker:

just about him or her. It's about us,

Speaker:

uh, together.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Across generations, a quiet truth

Speaker:

reveals itself. Resilience that

Speaker:

is not shared becomes erosion.

Speaker:

Governor Francis, Observations of imbalance

Speaker:

of Endurance stretched Too Thin traces a

Speaker:

pattern seen across post emancipation societies

Speaker:

where care becomes a woman's burden

Speaker:

and silence becomes. Is mistaken for strength.

Speaker:

Contemporary feminist thoughts reminds us

Speaker:

transformation begins not only in policy, but in

Speaker:

the emotional architecture of a society, in

Speaker:

how we raise our sons, in what we normalize, in

Speaker:

love, and in what we pass down

Speaker:

unnamed. The world is not

Speaker:

built solely in parliaments or plans. It is

Speaker:

built in the spaces between people. And it

Speaker:

is in those intimate, ungoverned spaces

Speaker:

that the true work of equality either blooms

Speaker:

or it is postponed.

Speaker:

We now turn to Mr. Richardson Syntastacia's

Speaker:

heritage Inspector. He sheds a light on

Speaker:

the generations raised by the unrelenting

Speaker:

wisdom of Caribbean women.

Speaker:

>> Mr. Richardson: You know, we all have mothers, um,

Speaker:

and sisters, um, and nieces.

Speaker:

And friends and children. I would

Speaker:

say to every Caribbean woman, do

Speaker:

not give up, firstly on yourself.

Speaker:

Um, you know, you women,

Speaker:

women are the creators. Women create also

Speaker:

men and it's the strong willingness

Speaker:

of good parenting of mothers

Speaker:

in the Caribbean on station, no matter where you are,

Speaker:

that oftentimes create, um, the type of

Speaker:

men that we will eventually become in the future.

Speaker:

At the end of the day, after years of

Speaker:

torment and the history that

Speaker:

we have of the people, you know,

Speaker:

we respect you and we see you, but we also hope

Speaker:

that, that self respect also comes back,

Speaker:

you know, from a lot of, um, women in the region.

Speaker:

And, you know, I just want, especially

Speaker:

the younger generation that are coming to not

Speaker:

forget, you know, where we came from and what we fought for

Speaker:

and that, ah, at the end of the day, the structure as we

Speaker:

know it, society as we know it,

Speaker:

um, actually have a lot to thank for

Speaker:

to all those independent, strong

Speaker:

willed women that really played a role in

Speaker:

our society. And at the end of the day,

Speaker:

always stand up for yourself and never feel

Speaker:

the need to diminish your shine

Speaker:

or to dub yourself down for anyone

Speaker:

because, you know, we have been through this

Speaker:

together for more than 400 years and

Speaker:

we would not have gotten anywhere or

Speaker:

any further without the motherly figure of women in

Speaker:

society. And

Speaker:

everyone should really know this part of the history.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): When gratitude meets remembrance, something powerful

Speaker:

takes root, a recognition not just of women

Speaker:

who shaped us, but of the histories that shaped

Speaker:

them. Mr. Um, Richardson reminds us

Speaker:

that strength is not forged in

Speaker:

isolation. It is passed down, held

Speaker:

in hands that raised families,

Speaker:

built communities, and bore witness to

Speaker:

generations of struggle and love.

Speaker:

But memory needs more than reverence.

Speaker:

It asks for recovery. Because history

Speaker:

of Caribbean women, especially those whose

Speaker:

lives were bound by enslavement, remains too

Speaker:

often unspoken, unwritten

Speaker:

or scattered across distant archives.

Speaker:

To honor the women history forgot, we must

Speaker:

research the silences they left behind.

Speaker:

And so we Turn now to Dr. Elaine,

Speaker:

historian, educator, keeper of

Speaker:

memory, who reminds us we must ask,

Speaker:

who was never named.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Elaine: Well, I think the more we know about the history of

Speaker:

slavery, the more we can understand

Speaker:

why the world is the way it is today.

Speaker:

Um, in Europe, in the Caribbean, in the United

Speaker:

States, in Canada, um, all

Speaker:

different parts of the Atlantic world, um,

Speaker:

and for a long time the history of

Speaker:

women in slavery was not something that people

Speaker:

focused on. And, um, over the

Speaker:

past few decades we've seen this incredible outpouring

Speaker:

of literature, um, in the

Speaker:

historical profession, across disciplines actually

Speaker:

on the history of enslaved women,

Speaker:

which has absolutely revolutionized how we

Speaker:

understand the history of slavery. But it's really important

Speaker:

to keep doing the research. And that's why, you know, I always

Speaker:

say if someone has the linguistic abilities,

Speaker:

do the research for the Dutch Caribbean or the Danish

Speaker:

too, because we. That's

Speaker:

something that we just really need to learn more about.

Speaker:

And I, I think it would be amazing

Speaker:

to see more people pursue that research.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): The archives hold many names,

Speaker:

but too few of them belong to women.

Speaker:

Dr. Alain reminds us, to study

Speaker:

history is not only to uncover facts,

Speaker:

but to widen the lens through which we see the world.

Speaker:

And for the Caribbean, that lens must be

Speaker:

stretched across waters and centuries

Speaker:

into silences, into absences, and

Speaker:

into the lives of women left unnamed.

Speaker:

But research is only the beginning.

Speaker:

Recovery must be lived, must be spoken out

Speaker:

loud. And here on Cintastatius,

Speaker:

the weight of unspoken histories is

Speaker:

finally beginning to lift. It is here

Speaker:

that Governor Francis takes us forward

Speaker:

into the delicate terrain where apology

Speaker:

meets accountability and memory begins the

Speaker:

work of mending m what was broken.

Speaker:

>> : Having conversations about slavery past, I

Speaker:

believe, has always been a very

Speaker:

difficult conversation for stations. But I believe

Speaker:

most people of, um, African heritage

Speaker:

living in this part of the world.

Speaker:

I must say though,

Speaker:

that the last year we have seen a lot of change

Speaker:

in that. Um, the Netherlands is one of the first countries in

Speaker:

the world, I believe, if not the first country in the

Speaker:

world where they have played a, uh,

Speaker:

leading role in the transatlantic slave trade.

Speaker:

A, uh, uh, leading role in,

Speaker:

um, trading of people in human lives.

Speaker:

That first, I believe it was on July

Speaker:

19, um,

Speaker:

2022,

Speaker:

that um, Prime Minister Mark Rotter

Speaker:

offered apology for the duchess

Speaker:

role in slavery pass, followed by,

Speaker:

I think it was December King Willem

Speaker:

Alexander also offered apology.

Speaker:

I see a lot of possibilities coming out of this because

Speaker:

it forces us now as stations, and

Speaker:

especially, um, descendants of slaves, to

Speaker:

finally start having the conversation

Speaker:

that is very difficult to um.

Speaker:

So I'm thankful for that opportunity. I've had the

Speaker:

opportunity in my former position as government

Speaker:

commissioner to speak on

Speaker:

both occasions, um, as a

Speaker:

response to the apology

Speaker:

from the Dutch government and then the head of state, the

Speaker:

king. And on both occasions I said

Speaker:

we must make room for every voice.

Speaker:

It means that we um, can see that in Stacia we're very

Speaker:

passionate people. We speak a lot about

Speaker:

freedoms and liberation. We speak a lot about

Speaker:

resilience. But in that whole construct, we know

Speaker:

that on Stacia we have different voices. And

Speaker:

even in the story surrounding slavery,

Speaker:

we will see there'd be a voice that wants to look

Speaker:

at how can we move forward. But there's going to be the voice

Speaker:

that also say, hey, don't move too fast. We want to

Speaker:

talk about it. Um, and there's the voice

Speaker:

that still needs to be discovered. And I believe we

Speaker:

must make room for every voice to be

Speaker:

heard. And in having these conversations, we must

Speaker:

display the highest level of respect for the different

Speaker:

opinions that will come out of the conversations that are

Speaker:

to follow. I eagerly look forward to

Speaker:

exploring the African part of my

Speaker:

ancestry more. It would be indeed good

Speaker:

to know where it all started.

Speaker:

So I'm looking forward to that part in the conversation.

Speaker:

And I'm also looking forward to the part in the conversation

Speaker:

where stations

Speaker:

based on the available financial

Speaker:

resources that are coming out of the

Speaker:

apology that we can look at how we can rebuild

Speaker:

our island. Let us rebuild our institutions,

Speaker:

our monuments. Let us strengthen the capacity.

Speaker:

We have so many foundations on this island, like the

Speaker:

historical foundation, the monument foundation.

Speaker:

And I must salute all those men and

Speaker:

women who, for the past 50 years, have volunteered

Speaker:

their time, never gaining a penny,

Speaker:

keeping these organizations

Speaker:

afloat without having the

Speaker:

necessary resources, oftentimes

Speaker:

not even the knowledge or the experience, but just

Speaker:

diligently for decades, preserving

Speaker:

our culture, our heritage for a time like now

Speaker:

that, uh, resources are available. So I'm looking forward to

Speaker:

the time where we can do the things that are

Speaker:

necessary to ensure that

Speaker:

we rebuild our institutions, our monuments,

Speaker:

looking forward to where more of our culture

Speaker:

and heritage is taught in our

Speaker:

schools on the island. So I see.

Speaker:

I look at it in a positive way that we

Speaker:

can achieve a lot together. So there are

Speaker:

stories still that, um, are

Speaker:

alive, but they're hidden away. What if we

Speaker:

can go delve into these stories and bring these stories

Speaker:

much more alive?

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): As Governor Francis reminds us, apology

Speaker:

alone is not the end of the road. It is a

Speaker:

threshold, a beginning. What

Speaker:

follows must be collective remembering,

Speaker:

rebuilding, and the courage to listen to the

Speaker:

voices long ignored.

Speaker:

Because some stories live in plain sight,

Speaker:

yet still remain untold.

Speaker:

Dr. Anna Hanslin, a historian and

Speaker:

professor, now brings us to that threshold

Speaker:

that even when the archives fall, silence.

Speaker:

The responsibility to uncover the lives of women

Speaker:

and the enslaved must not.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Elaine: Women historically, um, in the

Speaker:

Caribbean and the broader Atlantic world in

Speaker:

this time period, enslaved people.

Speaker:

They're not as well represented in the traditional documentary

Speaker:

archives as we've discussed as white men.

Speaker:

But that doesn't mean that we shouldn't tell their stories.

Speaker:

And I think, in fact, it makes it more imperative now that

Speaker:

we recognize the need to tell their stories, that those

Speaker:

of us who are excited by uncovering those hidden histories really make it

Speaker:

our mission to do so.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): When we search for the silences in history, we begin

Speaker:

to hear the echoes in the present.

Speaker:

Dr. Anna Hanslin reminds us that

Speaker:

uncovering the lives of those left out of the

Speaker:

archives Is not a luxury, It's a duty.

Speaker:

And when those stories rise, they don't just change

Speaker:

our past, they shift our sense of place,

Speaker:

of self. Archaeologist Dr. Morsings,

Speaker:

who has lived and worked on syntostatias, now speaks

Speaker:

to that deep connection between memory and

Speaker:

land and how the soil beneath our feet

Speaker:

can carry the rhythms of a forgotten story.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Stelton: Yeah, without your past, you're nothing.

Speaker:

That's where your culture comes from. That's where your

Speaker:

upbringing comes from. That's how you relate to

Speaker:

people and to the places where you live

Speaker:

to. Even when you walk around and you recognize

Speaker:

places, um, I'm sure

Speaker:

if you go to another island, you, feel the vibe that

Speaker:

is different. But that means also that

Speaker:

you're picking up those boots and those

Speaker:

social structures, that you take them for

Speaker:

granted. And when you're like, whoa, this is

Speaker:

different, that means that you

Speaker:

have already internalized where you grew

Speaker:

up and what you think was like a normal life.

Speaker:

So you should really take that in and then use

Speaker:

that to reflect back onto yourself

Speaker:

and your past and where you come from.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Memories live not just in books or

Speaker:

buildings, but in the way a place feels

Speaker:

when you walk through it. Familiar, yet

Speaker:

layered. The soil pressed by many

Speaker:

generations. Dr.

Speaker:

Morsinks reminds us that the belonging is often

Speaker:

felt before it's understood

Speaker:

that the land shapes us as much as we

Speaker:

shape it. But not all

Speaker:

roots are visible.

Speaker:

As we move deeper, Dr.

Speaker:

Sahidi invites us to look beneath the

Speaker:

surface to the unnamed lives that

Speaker:

shape Stacia's legacy. A free port

Speaker:

on paper, but not free for the quiet

Speaker:

weight of enslavement. To

Speaker:

truly know this island, we must learn to read

Speaker:

the land's silences.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Elaine: Stacia's history is a little bit different than a lot of other

Speaker:

islands. There were plantations on

Speaker:

stacia, but it was a free trade port. And

Speaker:

so a lot of the

Speaker:

work of enslaved people was

Speaker:

invisibilized, um, in a different

Speaker:

way than it is on other islands.

Speaker:

People were working down in lowertown, but

Speaker:

we don't really have a lot of experience

Speaker:

where we don't really have a lot of

Speaker:

detailed knowledge about people

Speaker:

who were working as porters, for example, or people who

Speaker:

were working as seamstresses,

Speaker:

or.

Speaker:

It's just different. You know, I think that stacia

Speaker:

is a really interesting place because, uh. And

Speaker:

I'm hoping that there's some young, bright

Speaker:

women on Stacia. Who are interested in

Speaker:

anthropology or archaeology or cultural

Speaker:

heritage. Because to understand the

Speaker:

history of Stacia really requires a fresh

Speaker:

perspective and looking at things very differently

Speaker:

from other Caribbean islands. It has a different legacy. In a

Speaker:

lot of ways, it's unique.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Some histories lie beneath trade routes

Speaker:

and warehouses, in names

Speaker:

unrecorded and Ah Labors

Speaker:

unrecognized. As Dr.

Speaker:

Sahidi reminds us, understanding

Speaker:

Stacia's past demands not just research,

Speaker:

but. But vision, A

Speaker:

willingness to see the invisible and ask new

Speaker:

questions of old soil.

Speaker:

But sometimes wisdom doesn't come from the

Speaker:

archives or the artifacts.

Speaker:

Sometimes it comes in the stillness of

Speaker:

someone who has lived the story.

Speaker:

Next we hear from Mrs. Rivers, a

Speaker:

respected elder and a lifelong nurse, who

Speaker:

reminds us that freedom, too, is a legacy.

Speaker:

Not always loud, not always written down,

Speaker:

but passed on. How we walk, how

Speaker:

we live, and what we choose to

Speaker:

remember.

Speaker:

>> : But what I like about Stacia,

Speaker:

you're free.

Speaker:

You're not really obligated to live the

Speaker:

life you used to live in Harlem.

Speaker:

You are more free here than there,

Speaker:

because the lifestyle there is very

Speaker:

difficult

Speaker:

here. You are more free.

Speaker:

Well, um, what I like about it,

Speaker:

I am free. And

Speaker:

you can move how you want,

Speaker:

where you want, when to go.

Speaker:

The love station. Because I born here, I think it's important

Speaker:

for the younger ones, as they

Speaker:

grow up, to know about it.

Speaker:

I think that's important.

Speaker:

So, you know, they can tell their children,

Speaker:

grandchildren, how it was

Speaker:

in those years.

Speaker:

But, uh, we didn't. My parents didn't

Speaker:

speak much about it.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): We have come full circle,

Speaker:

from the sleeping breath of the quail to the shifting

Speaker:

ground of identity and inheritance.

Speaker:

This season has been a journey,

Speaker:

not just through history, but through silence,

Speaker:

care and courage. We've

Speaker:

walked alongside voices who've made space

Speaker:

where none was given, who reminded

Speaker:

us that freedom isn't always loud. It lives

Speaker:

in the ability to walk your own road, to

Speaker:

remember what was and to imagine

Speaker:

what might still become.

Speaker:

This, too, is emancipation.

Speaker:

But the quiet kind passed from hand

Speaker:

to hand, not written in law, but felt

Speaker:

in the body. In choosing how we raise our children,

Speaker:

in refusing to forget, in making room

Speaker:

for stories that were once buried

Speaker:

as the final echoes? Fate, we

Speaker:

what is freedom when your past has

Speaker:

been silenced?

Speaker:

And who carries the cost of resilience?

Speaker:

And what kind of future do we build when we

Speaker:

finally allow memory to be whole?

Speaker:

This brings season one of whispers of the

Speaker:

past to a close.

Speaker:

But the work of listening continues

Speaker:

until we meet again. Thank you for

Speaker:

listening. May the whispers of the

Speaker:

past guide you into deeper waters where

Speaker:

memory meets truth and

Speaker:

healing can begin in the stillness

Speaker:

beyond the shores.

Speaker:

Next, in our special behind the scene episode,

Speaker:

we share the unheard moments, the

Speaker:

segments that didn't make the final cut, and the

Speaker:

journey of creating season one of Whispers of the

Speaker:

Past. From spontaneous reflections

Speaker:

to production surprises, this is where the

Speaker:

making of memory becomes part of the

Speaker:

whispers.

Follow

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube