Artwork for podcast The Musician's Loupe
Storytelling songs, pop culture references, and the underdog: You Don’t Mess Around with Jim (Jim Croce)
Episode 225th November 2025 • The Musician's Loupe • Elaine Chao and Trist Curless
00:00:00 00:29:58

Share Episode

Shownotes

Listen to the song

Key Takeaways

  • “You Don’t Mess Around with Jim” is a story song that cleverly shifts from the crowd narrative of warning people away from a city boy bully to celebrating Slim, the country boy who overcomes
  • Trist and Elaine delve into the musical and lyrical elements of the song, covering storytelling, orchestration, and usage of pop culture references
  • In the mailbag portion, Trist and Elaine discuss creativity and whether or not it’s influenced by the time of day, or if it’s just a personal rhythm and discipline that must be mastered

About us

Trist Curless is a Los Angeles-based vocalist, educator, and sound engineer. As a performer, Trist has toured worldwide as a co-founder of the pop-jazz vocal group m-pact and a 10 year member of the Grammy-award winning The Manhattan Transfer. In addition to these two vocal powerhouse groups, he’s also performed with Take 6, Bobby McFerrin, New York Voices, Vox Audio, Naturally 7, and The Swingle Singers. His latest venture, The LHR Project, is a new vocal group collective celebrating legendary jazz vocal group Lambert, Hendricks, and Ross.

As an audio engineer, Trist has toured nationally with several vocal groups and bands in a large variety of venues, working for Grammy award winners Pentatonix and Take 6, as well as prominent a cappella vocal groups Straight No Chaser, VoicePlay, and Accent.

Elaine Chao, M.Ed is a San Francisco Bay Area-based vocalist, multi-instrumentalist, vocal percussionist, and songwriter whose career spans a cappella, contemporary worship, and classical music. She has leveraged her training in classical and choral music over the course of her contemporary performance, including in orchestras for musical theatre and in sacred spaces. In addition to music, she also is a martial artist and published author. She currently leads a product management team at a major software company dedicated to creative expression. All statements in this podcast are her own and do not reflect the opinions of her employer.

Transcripts

Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, Trist, what do we have this week?

Speaker:

Trist: Well, this week we have a really great songwriter who had two

Speaker:

Trist: number one hits.

Speaker:

Trist: I guess this is not the only time this has ever happened.

Speaker:

Trist: It's an odd phenomenon, but he had a number one hit during his

Speaker:

Trist: lifetime, and then a number one hit after he passed away.

Speaker:

Trist: (Mm.) I'm talking about Jim Croce.

Speaker:

Trist: He was a really cool songwriter

Speaker:

Trist: who died tragically in a plane

Speaker:

Trist: crash.

Speaker:

Trist: He actually had an album in the

Speaker:

Trist: can, as it were, an album got

Speaker:

Trist: released and then, kind of an

Speaker:

Trist: album track of his from an album

Speaker:

Trist: that he'd made when he was still

Speaker:

Trist: alive that was never intended to

Speaker:

Trist: be a single, "Time in a Bottle,"

Speaker:

Trist: seemed so poignant after his

Speaker:

Trist: passing that it was released as

Speaker:

Trist: a single and was a number one

Speaker:

Trist: hit, and the two number one hits

Speaker:

Trist: are not the focus of our song

Speaker:

Trist: listening today.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, (It was just random.

Speaker:

Trist: Cool information that I wanted you to have.

Speaker:

Elaine: I mean, it is kind of sad that he passed away so young.

Speaker:

Elaine: It sounds like, you know, he really didn't realize his full

Speaker:

Elaine: potential as a songwriter.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. And the last other little thing I'll add, now that we're

Speaker:

Trist: talking about things that have nothing to do with our song,

Speaker:

Trist: it's noted that apparently a letter that he had mailed to his

Speaker:

Trist: wife that was timed in such a way that she received it after

Speaker:

Trist: he passed away.

Speaker:

Trist: He actually said he wanted to give up the music industry.

Speaker:

Elaine: Mm.

Speaker:

Trist: So that's kind of an interesting

Speaker:

Trist: little tidbit that you can find,

Speaker:

Trist: uh, more info about if you want

Speaker:

Trist: to dig.

Speaker:

Trist: But that's not this song, and it's not the reason why I chose

Speaker:

Trist: this particular song.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, so so what are we listening to?

Speaker:

Trist: This is "You Don't Mess Around with Jim."

Speaker:

Trist: (Mm.) Did you know this one?

Speaker:

Elaine: Ah, not until you mentioned it to me.

Speaker:

Elaine: You did send me, um.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I did mess up his name.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is what?

Speaker:

Elaine: Croce.

Speaker:

Trist: Croce.

Speaker:

Elaine: Croce.

Speaker:

Elaine: Croce.

Speaker:

Trist: Oh, I might have said it like crochet, but I think.

Speaker:

Trist: Croce.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. Croce. Okay. You're right.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, you shared an album

Speaker:

Elaine: with me before, but I'm not

Speaker:

Elaine: convinced that it was on that

Speaker:

Elaine: album.

Speaker:

Elaine: So this was brand new to me, and

Speaker:

Elaine: definitely the first one that I

Speaker:

Elaine: listened to so deeply, because

Speaker:

Elaine: when you recommended the album

Speaker:

Elaine: to me, you know, I was listening

Speaker:

Elaine: to it as a whole and just

Speaker:

Elaine: listening for the vibe as

Speaker:

Elaine: opposed to really deeply

Speaker:

Elaine: listening to any of the

Speaker:

Elaine: individual songs.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. I really like his songs and his songwriting style.

Speaker:

Trist: On one hand, there's things that

Speaker:

Trist: are very, you know, not not deep

Speaker:

Trist: topics.

Speaker:

Trist: We're not changing the world talking about don't mess around

Speaker:

Trist: with Jim this big bully.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, hey.

Speaker:

Elaine: No spoilers.

Speaker:

Elaine: (Yet!) Haven't gotten there yet.

Speaker:

Elaine: (Yet!)

Speaker:

Trist: Yet!

Speaker:

Trist: Just the way that he puts things together.

Speaker:

Trist: Simple yet complex and well done.

Speaker:

Elaine: All right.

Speaker:

Elaine: So with that, we are going to

Speaker:

Elaine: pause in just a moment to give

Speaker:

Elaine: you an opportunity to listen to

Speaker:

Elaine: the song.

Speaker:

Elaine: We'll drop the links to the song inside of the show notes.

Speaker:

Elaine: So we are going to ask you to pause and then hopefully return.

Speaker:

Elaine: But that being said, Trist, can

Speaker:

Elaine: you remind us about how we

Speaker:

Elaine: should be listening to this,

Speaker:

Elaine: song or any of the songs in our

Speaker:

Elaine: podcast?

Speaker:

Trist: Well, part of the mission here

Speaker:

Trist: is to have you be focusing on

Speaker:

Trist: the listening, not what we chirp

Speaker:

Trist: about, but to listen, really

Speaker:

Trist: listen.

Speaker:

Trist: And to me that involves just improving whatever you can.

Speaker:

Trist: again, I know you may be out on a walk.

Speaker:

Trist: On a run, maybe you're in your car, maybe you're about to take

Speaker:

Trist: a nap, and our dulcet tones put you to sleep.

Speaker:

Trist: I hope that's not the case.

Speaker:

Trist: anyway, you may not be in a

Speaker:

Trist: situation where you can do it,

Speaker:

Trist: but if you are in a situation

Speaker:

Trist: where you can improve your

Speaker:

Trist: listening environment, grab

Speaker:

Trist: those nicer headphones, put it

Speaker:

Trist: on the system at home, what have

Speaker:

Trist: you.

Speaker:

Trist: Please take the time to do so.

Speaker:

Trist: We're all about the listening.

Speaker:

Elaine: Awesome.

Speaker:

Elaine: Okay, we'll see you in just a moment.

Speaker:

Elaine: And welcome back.

Speaker:

Elaine: Hey, you know, I have my opinions, Trist, but I am very

Speaker:

Elaine: curious about why you chose this particular song and why you

Speaker:

Elaine: thought it was special.

Speaker:

Trist: Well, I've just once again, as as we'll see as a theme.

Speaker:

Trist: It's just.

Speaker:

Trist: I just liked it.

Speaker:

Trist: Sometimes you don't need anything super particular.

Speaker:

Trist: And while we dig into some some musical things, some societal

Speaker:

Trist: things, some form, some analysis, some chords, some

Speaker:

Trist: lyrics, etc., sometimes it's just, oh, I don't know.

Speaker:

Trist: I just like this one.

Speaker:

Trist: And I wanted to remind everyone that it exists.

Speaker:

Trist: I think a lot of our listeners

Speaker:

Trist: probably have heard this one

Speaker:

Trist: before.

Speaker:

Trist: It just I don't know why.

Speaker:

Trist: It just came up and I thought

Speaker:

Trist: this would be a good one to talk

Speaker:

Trist: about.

Speaker:

Trist: I love a good story song.

Speaker:

Trist: I don't know if it's because I'm from Wyoming.

Speaker:

Trist: This isn't a country song.

Speaker:

Trist: That's not all the music that there is in Wyoming.

Speaker:

Trist: But I think of it from childhood.

Speaker:

Trist: I have a memory of, like in the

Speaker:

Trist: story, how the story changes, as

Speaker:

Trist: it progresses.

Speaker:

Trist: And I remember noticing it.

Speaker:

Trist: And as a kid, I didn't, even though I'm told I could always

Speaker:

Trist: sing all of the lyrics, I don't think I was ever really, uh,

Speaker:

Trist: understanding what they were.

Speaker:

Trist: And this was definitely a time

Speaker:

Trist: that, in the story, obviously

Speaker:

Trist: you've got, this bully Jim and

Speaker:

Trist: even the people around are like,

Speaker:

Trist: hey, you know, don't mess around

Speaker:

Trist: with Jim, you know, don't tug on

Speaker:

Trist: Superman's cape, which it's kind

Speaker:

Trist: of made its way into the pop

Speaker:

Trist: kind of vernacular, um, pop

Speaker:

Trist: culture.

Speaker:

Elaine: Mhm.

Speaker:

Trist: At the time in the 70s.

Speaker:

Trist: So it's like a chorus of people, hey, everyone knows you don't

Speaker:

Trist: mess around with this guy.

Speaker:

Trist: (Yeah.) and then when slim does

Speaker:

Trist: take care of him and then they

Speaker:

Trist: sing, you don't mess around with

Speaker:

Trist: Slim.

Speaker:

Trist: I thought that was the coolest thing I ever heard.

Speaker:

Trist: You know, I was maybe nine, but whatever.

Speaker:

Trist: However old I was, I remember I noticed That this Slim guy took

Speaker:

Trist: care of Jim, and then they changed it to Slim in the song.

Speaker:

Trist: And I thought that was the coolest thing ever.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, so I went through the

Speaker:

Elaine: third time before I noticed that

Speaker:

Elaine: and I realized, oh my goodness,

Speaker:

Elaine: something changed.

Speaker:

Elaine: Did I not hear Jim?

Speaker:

Elaine: Like, I, you know, I don't hear

Speaker:

Elaine: words very well... always, you

Speaker:

Elaine: know, when I'm listening to

Speaker:

Elaine: songs.

Speaker:

Elaine: So of course I looked up the lyrics and I realized, oh, it

Speaker:

Elaine: did move from Jim to Slim.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I went back and had to read all of the lyrics to really

Speaker:

Elaine: understand the mastery behind the songwriting there.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. Love it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. I also loved what you said about kind of the pop culture

Speaker:

Elaine: references, and I wrote down the ones that I realized were either

Speaker:

Elaine: just slang that I'd heard about, which I'm pretty sure was, just

Speaker:

Elaine: more generic slang, but also references to things like

Speaker:

Elaine: everyday pop culture references, thinking about, you know, what

Speaker:

Elaine: we're thinking about here in 2025 with like Labubu or

Speaker:

Elaine: whatever it is that we have in today's pop, um, thing.

Speaker:

Elaine: But, you know, as we take a look at Superman's cape, I saw the

Speaker:

Elaine: word Lone Ranger in there.

Speaker:

Elaine: and then drop-top Cadillac.

Speaker:

Trist: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I was like oh man.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like honestly like I never heard the I knew what a drop-top was,

Speaker:

Elaine: but I had to look it up just to be sure, because I'd always

Speaker:

Elaine: heard of it as a convertible.

Speaker:

Elaine: Right?

Speaker:

Elaine: Like a convertible Cadillac as opposed to a drop-top.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so these are very clear images that I have in my head

Speaker:

Elaine: because of the way that I grew up, like, I grew up knowing who

Speaker:

Elaine: Superman was and, you know, understanding the whole, like,

Speaker:

Elaine: comic book history of Superman and Lone Ranger as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, even though Lone

Speaker:

Elaine: Ranger predated me, like,

Speaker:

Elaine: everyone knows what the Lone

Speaker:

Elaine: Ranger like the the character is

Speaker:

Elaine: and you know what he stood for,

Speaker:

Elaine: right?

Speaker:

Elaine: Um, there are other things in

Speaker:

Elaine: there that I just thought were

Speaker:

Elaine: just interesting references, but

Speaker:

Elaine: those were the three that I

Speaker:

Elaine: called out as like, really big

Speaker:

Elaine: pop culture references that

Speaker:

Elaine: helped to anchor the song in a

Speaker:

Elaine: particular era.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. So tell me a little bit about what you heard from, the

Speaker:

Elaine: orchestration or, like what- what you heard in terms of,

Speaker:

Elaine: instruments or vocals or, any of the other things that we

Speaker:

Elaine: normally listen for.

Speaker:

Trist: My, my favorite things musically about this song are the fact

Speaker:

Trist: that, in the first chorus, he sings it by himself.

Speaker:

Trist: (Mm-hm.) Right.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, and then in the second

Speaker:

Trist: verse, after Slim arrives and

Speaker:

Trist: asks, asks about Jim, then you

Speaker:

Trist: know, they're like, and

Speaker:

Trist: everybody say, Jack, don't you

Speaker:

Trist: know, you don't tug on

Speaker:

Trist: Superman's cape.

Speaker:

Trist: Right?

Speaker:

Trist: So there's the whole chorus,

Speaker:

Trist: there's the background singers

Speaker:

Trist: come in.

Speaker:

Trist: So it's like everyone in this

Speaker:

Trist: part of town knows this is just

Speaker:

Trist: fact.

Speaker:

Trist: You don't tug on Superman's

Speaker:

Trist: cape, you don't spit in the

Speaker:

Trist: wind.

Speaker:

Trist: You don't pull the mask off Lone Ranger.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, these are just facts that are known and Slim is showing up

Speaker:

Trist: to deal with him and doesn't care what you say, but I like

Speaker:

Trist: the fact that it's first just him and then after he shows up

Speaker:

Trist: on the scene.

Speaker:

Trist: It's like the community, the the area of people like the quote

Speaker:

Trist: unquote, "everybody knows."

Speaker:

Trist: So they they all sing it next.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, and then I love how, the quote, violence slash fight

Speaker:

Trist: slash whatever you want to say happens, in the pool room.

Speaker:

Trist: I love the music.

Speaker:

Trist: Goes to a half time feel right?

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like, I wrote that down, too.

Speaker:

Elaine: *laughs*

Speaker:

Trist: I love it, just like it's this suspense that happens.

Speaker:

Trist: And then the background vocals, the background, everything about

Speaker:

Trist: the music right there tells you something is happening.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, even though it's only for, you know, four bars, you know,

Speaker:

Trist: just just just enough of a thing like, oh, this is when it goes

Speaker:

Trist: down, you know?

Speaker:

Trist: So I just love how he was able to get all of that going and all

Speaker:

Trist: of the vibe and the feel of what was happening in such an

Speaker:

Trist: economic short amount of time.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, I mean, it was a really short song.

Speaker:

Elaine: I wrote down it's, you know, similar to to you.

Speaker:

Elaine: I didn't really pick up on the

Speaker:

Elaine: choir or the people singing in

Speaker:

Elaine: the second chorus because it

Speaker:

Elaine: was, you know, the people

Speaker:

Elaine: saying, hey, don't mess with

Speaker:

Elaine: Jim.

Speaker:

Elaine: I wrote down in my first line, half honky tonk, half

Speaker:

Elaine: enthusiastic church choir.

Speaker:

Elaine: And, I also heard a lot of, talking during the, you know,

Speaker:

Elaine: the, the so it was a commentary that was happening as people

Speaker:

Elaine: were saying, hey, you know, don't mess around with Jim.

Speaker:

Elaine: and I just thought that was

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting because I think it

Speaker:

Elaine: was very much like the culture,

Speaker:

Elaine: especially when you're talking

Speaker:

Elaine: about, like, an enthusiastic

Speaker:

Elaine: church choir.

Speaker:

Elaine: that there's there's a lot of,

Speaker:

Elaine: like, talking and feedback and

Speaker:

Elaine: engagement, like active

Speaker:

Elaine: engagement with what's going on

Speaker:

Elaine: there.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so I just thought it was, it was very I don't know if there's

Speaker:

Elaine: a word that I have for it, um, you know, familiar in some ways.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: Um, I want.

Speaker:

Trist: To point out a thing that you

Speaker:

Trist: mentioned about the about the

Speaker:

Trist: talking.

Speaker:

Trist: So in a little section that it just vamps on one chord, it

Speaker:

Trist: almost serves like a bridge.

Speaker:

Trist: It doesn't it doesn't musically function like a bridge.

Speaker:

Trist: It doesn't go to some other chords we've never heard.

Speaker:

Trist: It's not materially, we don't know.

Speaker:

Trist: But just to get something different.

Speaker:

Trist: He does talk and it's basically Slim saying like, you know, you

Speaker:

Trist: don't hustle people, stranger.

Speaker:

Trist: Even if you do, I think it's worth something.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, even if you do have a two-piece custom made pool cue

Speaker:

Trist: like that doesn't make you great, that doesn't make you the

Speaker:

Trist: boss of me, etc. it doesn't make you the boss of this town and

Speaker:

Trist: this block and this pool room.

Speaker:

Trist: You know, he found out And it's like he just has this little

Speaker:

Trist: where he's just kind of talking.

Speaker:

Trist: He's not even really trying to sing it.

Speaker:

Trist: He's just like this little verbiage and it almost serves

Speaker:

Trist: like a bridge.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, really a bridge.

Speaker:

Trist: But it's the only material

Speaker:

Trist: that's like, different from the

Speaker:

Trist: rest.

Speaker:

Trist: And that's just that he's talking and saying, hey, I put

Speaker:

Trist: him in his place.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. And in another episode, we

Speaker:

Elaine: had talked about the role of a

Speaker:

Elaine: bridge, where often it's some

Speaker:

Elaine: kind of the lesson or a

Speaker:

Elaine: reflective moment or the truth

Speaker:

Elaine: behind the song happens during

Speaker:

Elaine: the bridge.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I also found it was

Speaker:

Elaine: fascinating, that this was done

Speaker:

Elaine: as a spoken interlude because I

Speaker:

Elaine: was again reading through this

Speaker:

Elaine: and I'm like, oh, there's a

Speaker:

Elaine: lesson.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I went back and listened to it and thought, oh, that was not

Speaker:

Elaine: the orchestration I was expecting, um, in that moment.

Speaker:

Elaine: But I just thought it was

Speaker:

Elaine: interesting that it was a spoken

Speaker:

Elaine: interlude between these two

Speaker:

Elaine: choruses.

Speaker:

Elaine: It was given the time to do that as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: Um, in that you had, you know, however many bars.

Speaker:

Elaine: Was it four bars to actually talk through this lesson?

Speaker:

Elaine: So 100% with you, and I'm glad

Speaker:

Elaine: that we picked up on the same

Speaker:

Elaine: thing.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. Anyway, I think it's cool.

Speaker:

Trist: It's not it's not much deeper than that.

Speaker:

Trist: There's really cool musical things like that that help

Speaker:

Trist: outline the story.

Speaker:

Trist: But the fact that he that you

Speaker:

Trist: tell such a long, this could be

Speaker:

Trist: an hour of TV drama, and it's,

Speaker:

Trist: you know, in whatever, three

Speaker:

Trist: minutes or something, so I, I

Speaker:

Trist: love how again, how economical,

Speaker:

Trist: the lyrics are in telling the

Speaker:

Trist: story.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, it's definitely very elegant from that perspective.

Speaker:

Elaine: so other things that I heard

Speaker:

Elaine: here, I was listening to this in

Speaker:

Elaine: my studio speakers because, of

Speaker:

Elaine: course, as you said, we want to

Speaker:

Elaine: listen to it in the best

Speaker:

Elaine: environment possible.

Speaker:

Elaine: And one thing that really surprised me on the first listen

Speaker:

Elaine: was this lead acoustic guitar.

Speaker:

Elaine: So, you know, it's a very acoustic song, but there was, a

Speaker:

Elaine: lead guitar that was doing more of, I'd say, the role that an

Speaker:

Elaine: electric guitar would play in, like, modern day, rock music,

Speaker:

Elaine: where it's a little bit more of the, um, what do you call it?

Speaker:

Elaine: Like the little decorations, right.

Speaker:

Elaine: Where you're like, oh, the interstitials, that was panned

Speaker:

Elaine: really, really hard left.

Speaker:

Elaine: Mhm.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then there were, places where I was trying to figure

Speaker:

Elaine: out, oh man, am I just listening to the Rock.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like how it took me a while to figure out, that the way that it

Speaker:

Elaine: was mixed was so, one hundred and eighty degrees that it

Speaker:

Elaine: really felt like you were embedded into the storytelling.

Speaker:

Elaine: So we had, Jim Croce's voice

Speaker:

Elaine: center, but maybe slightly to

Speaker:

Elaine: the right, and then the choir or

Speaker:

Elaine: the, the chorus was, kind of

Speaker:

Elaine: center and panning slightly to

Speaker:

Elaine: the right.

Speaker:

Elaine: But then there's this hard pan left for this lead guitar, which

Speaker:

Elaine: is like, oh, wow, okay, I'm really in space here.

Speaker:

Elaine: And, thinking about when this was made, when I think you said

Speaker:

Elaine: nineteen seventy two, like, that's what the song said in the

Speaker:

Elaine: link and 1972, I mean, you're talking about some pretty

Speaker:

Elaine: rudimentary, uh, controls that you have at that point in time

Speaker:

Elaine: when it comes to that level of mixing and mastering.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm kind of curious, like what

Speaker:

Elaine: your thoughts were of of that,

Speaker:

Elaine: you know, some of the choices

Speaker:

Elaine: that were made from a recording

Speaker:

Elaine: perspective.

Speaker:

Trist: No, that's exactly the thing.

Speaker:

Trist: Just that stuff, again, being

Speaker:

Trist: this kind of a setting where

Speaker:

Trist: it's a story so helps you

Speaker:

Trist: visualize.

Speaker:

Trist: And I think that's the key, just

Speaker:

Trist: making you feel like you're

Speaker:

Trist: there.

Speaker:

Trist: especially again, the scene that goes to the pool room where it

Speaker:

Trist: goes to the half time feel, etc. the way that the chorus is like,

Speaker:

Trist: you can, you can just you can see it, you can see it, I think.

Speaker:

Trist: So I think that's I think that's pretty cool.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. The drop to half time was

Speaker:

Elaine: uh, it's my favorite thing in

Speaker:

Elaine: the song.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: well, any final thoughts about this?

Speaker:

Trist: I mean, that's it.

Speaker:

Trist: some stuff just isn't any deeper than that.

Speaker:

Trist: I just dig the song.

Speaker:

Trist: I think it's fun.

Speaker:

Trist: it's weird to talk so lightheartedly about, a story

Speaker:

Trist: where a guy gets killed, but at the same time, It doesn't land

Speaker:

Trist: on you that heavy.

Speaker:

Trist: I think probably because it does such a job setting up.

Speaker:

Trist: What a bad guy this Jim Walker was.

Speaker:

Trist: (Mm-hm.) and We like the underdog.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe that's why it's like

Speaker:

Trist: brutally murders a guy and the

Speaker:

Trist: song seems so it just, it kind

Speaker:

Trist: of happens and then we move on,

Speaker:

Trist: oddly enough.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: I love what you're saying about

Speaker:

Elaine: the underdog here, because there

Speaker:

Elaine: does seem to be a power

Speaker:

Elaine: imbalance.

Speaker:

Elaine: Just looking at the lyrics.

Speaker:

Elaine: I have them up in front of me.

Speaker:

Elaine: Um, you know, we got Big Jim Walker, of course.

Speaker:

Elaine: and he's big and dumb as man can come.

Speaker:

Elaine: He's stronger than a country hoss.

Speaker:

Elaine: .. Uh, and, you know, you know, they all call Big Jim boss.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I'm listening to all of this.

Speaker:

Elaine: And, Jim Croce is really painting this picture of this,

Speaker:

Elaine: like, big, bad guy.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then, you know, you have the underdog, out of south Alabama

Speaker:

Elaine: come a country boy.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yep.

Speaker:

Elaine: So, you know, from 42nd Street, you have this country boy who

Speaker:

Elaine: has taken advantage of.

Speaker:

Elaine: And he's not exactly your idea of a winner in this song.

Speaker:

Elaine: But he comes and he overcomes, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: And he says, look, you know, I was taken advantage of.

Speaker:

Elaine: And now he becomes the big dog.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I, you know, it's it's classic underdog there.

Speaker:

Elaine: So really good call out.

Speaker:

Trist: Love it.

Speaker:

Elaine: Awesome. Okay. Well that's it for this week.

Speaker:

Elaine: But before we leave we're going to move over to our mailbag.

Speaker:

Trist: Mailbag?

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, we're going to have to

Speaker:

Elaine: have some kind of theme for this

Speaker:

Elaine: mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: Oh, yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: so going into our mailbag.

Speaker:

Elaine: Just a reminder, you can get a hold of us via email.

Speaker:

Elaine: The musicians loop l o u p e at

Speaker:

Elaine: gmail.com or message us on

Speaker:

Elaine: Instagram.

Speaker:

Elaine: Follow us on Instagram for that matter.

Speaker:

Elaine: We would love to hear your

Speaker:

Elaine: questions, but in the meantime,

Speaker:

Elaine: we are sourcing from a number of

Speaker:

Elaine: different places, including

Speaker:

Elaine: Threads.

Speaker:

Elaine: So like shout out to the Musicians of Threads group

Speaker:

Elaine: because we're getting some really good ideas and really

Speaker:

Elaine: good conversation topics here.

Speaker:

Elaine: So this week's is from @mattlongmusic.

Speaker:

Elaine: and this was from August of 2025.

Speaker:

Elaine: And he posted: "Musicians, are

Speaker:

Elaine: you more creative in the

Speaker:

Elaine: morning, afternoon, evening or

Speaker:

Elaine: night trying to find my creative

Speaker:

Elaine: rhythm?"

Speaker:

Trist: Oh man.

Speaker:

Trist: That's a tough one.

Speaker:

Trist: I man, I, I don't know that there's a universal.

Speaker:

Trist: I suppose you could do some kind

Speaker:

Trist: of study and find patterns,

Speaker:

Trist: etc., but I think the patterns

Speaker:

Trist: also need to include where those

Speaker:

Trist: musicians are in their life, how

Speaker:

Trist: old they are, where their

Speaker:

Trist: families are, if they have them

Speaker:

Trist: or not.

Speaker:

Trist: Are they in bands?

Speaker:

Trist: Are they solo artists?

Speaker:

Trist: I think all of those things matter.

Speaker:

Trist: I tend to feel like we get in the groove of being musicians

Speaker:

Trist: who are performers.

Speaker:

Trist: Obviously those things happen more in the evenings.

Speaker:

Trist: So unless.

Speaker:

Elaine: You're a church.

Speaker:

Trist: Musician, unless you're a church musician, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm up at 5 in the morning on Sundays.

Speaker:

Trist: This proves my point even more.

Speaker:

Trist: It's like you're- If that is the time that you do, whatever time

Speaker:

Trist: that you maybe condition yourself to doing music, maybe

Speaker:

Trist: then you naturally are creative.

Speaker:

Trist: In that time, I don't know.

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't know about that.

Speaker:

Elaine: Like, I play on Sunday morning, three services on Sunday

Speaker:

Elaine: mornings and whoo!

Speaker:

Elaine: It's exhausting.

Speaker:

Elaine: Every single time.

Speaker:

Trist: Well. Do you?

Speaker:

Trist: Well, tell me this then.

Speaker:

Trist: when you're not doing that, if

Speaker:

Trist: it's during the week, if you

Speaker:

Trist: don't have to work and you had

Speaker:

Trist: to work on some kind of music,

Speaker:

Trist: is there a time of day you would

Speaker:

Trist: just naturally want to work on

Speaker:

Trist: it?

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, I, I don't think so.

Speaker:

Elaine: And, you know, I was looking at this particular question and the

Speaker:

Elaine: question was not so much about creativity as much as it was

Speaker:

Elaine: about energy for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I think about how I write,

Speaker:

Elaine: because I've been doing a lot

Speaker:

Elaine: more like book writing versus

Speaker:

Elaine: songwriting recently.

Speaker:

Elaine: and that type of creativity is

Speaker:

Elaine: really an endurance thing for

Speaker:

Elaine: me.

Speaker:

Elaine: It's more of a discipline, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: In order to be able to be creative, you actually have to

Speaker:

Elaine: be incredibly disciplined.

Speaker:

Elaine: So whether it means I need to

Speaker:

Elaine: make time to do things before

Speaker:

Elaine: work or after work, or if I have

Speaker:

Elaine: a day off to carve out a couple

Speaker:

Elaine: of hours or, you know, to meet

Speaker:

Elaine: up with someone in order to

Speaker:

Elaine: provide myself with some kind of

Speaker:

Elaine: accountability.

Speaker:

Elaine: I find that I work a lot better when I've carved out time, both

Speaker:

Elaine: mentally and physically, and make sure that I am not

Speaker:

Elaine: distracted by anything else.

Speaker:

Elaine: Know that I am in a mental

Speaker:

Elaine: space, or I've carved out a

Speaker:

Elaine: space where I'm not going to be

Speaker:

Elaine: doing housework, or seeing

Speaker:

Elaine: friends, or being distracted by

Speaker:

Elaine: online things.

Speaker:

Elaine: It is a time that I have set

Speaker:

Elaine: aside to do this one particular

Speaker:

Elaine: thing.

Speaker:

Elaine: And sometimes, you know, as I'm

Speaker:

Elaine: prepping for, you know, I was

Speaker:

Elaine: talking about being a church

Speaker:

Elaine: musician.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, I will set aside time

Speaker:

Elaine: to review my music ahead of

Speaker:

Elaine: time.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that is a discipline.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I know that you've done that as well.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, the time that I've

Speaker:

Elaine: known you, you've excused

Speaker:

Elaine: yourself from all sorts of

Speaker:

Elaine: social events to prep for the

Speaker:

Elaine: next day's gig, because that's

Speaker:

Elaine: your responsibility.

Speaker:

Elaine: That's your job, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: To prep music and make sure that you're familiar with things.

Speaker:

Elaine: So in the creation process, I

Speaker:

Elaine: think it's a very similar kind

Speaker:

Elaine: of thing where you have to make

Speaker:

Elaine: time, and the time that you have

Speaker:

Elaine: is the time that you have to be

Speaker:

Elaine: creative.

Speaker:

Elaine: Now, can I optimize for one thing or another?

Speaker:

Elaine: I find that I'm a lot less creative and disciplined when

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm super tired.

Speaker:

Elaine: So beginning of the day, end of the day.

Speaker:

Elaine: Not fantastic for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm not a morning person and

Speaker:

Elaine: when I get tired, I get super

Speaker:

Elaine: tired.

Speaker:

Elaine: So I think that there's there's something to be said about

Speaker:

Elaine: figuring out when your energy and focus is available, and also

Speaker:

Elaine: having the discipline to be able to train your mind to be focused

Speaker:

Elaine: when you need to be focused.

Speaker:

Elaine: So sometimes that's late morning to early afternoon for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: Sometimes it's after work and I need to get in a workout before

Speaker:

Elaine: I can sit down.

Speaker:

Elaine: And then I actually have to force myself to sit down and do

Speaker:

Elaine: something for an hour.

Speaker:

Elaine: And I love what I do afterwards, but it takes me prioritizing

Speaker:

Elaine: that time for myself.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, I definitely think every I think every musician is going to

Speaker:

Trist: have that for themselves.

Speaker:

Trist: So when that person posts that, you know, if I were able to

Speaker:

Trist: reply directly to them, I'd be like, hey, you gotta you have to

Speaker:

Trist: find that for yourself.

Speaker:

Trist: Finding out what's better for

Speaker:

Trist: everyone else in this particular

Speaker:

Trist: question, I don't know that it's

Speaker:

Trist: I understand someone reaching

Speaker:

Trist: out to find out what works for

Speaker:

Trist: people.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, and maybe if someone replies

Speaker:

Trist: saying, oh, I'm also a father of

Speaker:

Trist: two, etc. that might have a

Speaker:

Trist: difference.

Speaker:

Trist: Or oh, I'm also a church

Speaker:

Trist: musician or oh, I'm, I play in

Speaker:

Trist: nightclubs, etc. like knowing

Speaker:

Trist: those things.

Speaker:

Trist: then maybe the answers might help them.

Speaker:

Trist: But just generally when I'm more creative, I mean, I don't know,

Speaker:

Trist: I feel like I can be creative at any of those times.

Speaker:

Trist: sometimes it just hits you.

Speaker:

Trist: I think you're right, my initial

Speaker:

Trist: answer would be the evening or

Speaker:

Trist: night time again because I'm

Speaker:

Trist: just attuned to performing,

Speaker:

Trist: etc.. Um, so that's when I'm

Speaker:

Trist: just my body is my brain is

Speaker:

Trist: allocated, oh, this is music

Speaker:

Trist: time.

Speaker:

Trist: So that's what I'm going to be creative.

Speaker:

Trist: But, I mean, but also after I'm well rested and I've got, you

Speaker:

Trist: know, I've got the whole day ahead of me and I'm just like, I

Speaker:

Trist: can be a lot more creative than in a different way.

Speaker:

Trist: So I don't think there's a specific thing for me.

Speaker:

Trist: So I would think that everyone would just be different.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. I'm also kind of curious about the difference in

Speaker:

Elaine: creativity between writing, like actually creating something from

Speaker:

Elaine: scratch versus performing and being like, I don't necessarily

Speaker:

Elaine: see music as mechanical, but sometimes it is one of those

Speaker:

Elaine: things where you're executing, you know, a creative vision, and

Speaker:

Elaine: you're participating as a part of a creative vision.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm curious, like how that

Speaker:

Elaine: differs for you in terms of, you

Speaker:

Elaine: know, the amount of brain cells

Speaker:

Elaine: required or the amount of energy

Speaker:

Elaine: required.

Speaker:

Elaine: Do you do you see a difference for yourself?

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah. No, that's true because I would think of it.

Speaker:

Trist: I guess I think of them both the same.

Speaker:

Trist: But you're right, I think they're different.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, am I truly being creative or am I rehearsing things that I

Speaker:

Trist: just need to improve?

Speaker:

Trist: Here's this, here's this music I need to learn?

Speaker:

Trist: Well, there's nothing creative about that.

Speaker:

Trist: I just need to put in the time to learn the music, learn the

Speaker:

Trist: lyrics, learn whatever.

Speaker:

Trist: But that's different than the creative time.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, oh yeah, I told them I

Speaker:

Trist: would write the bridge for this

Speaker:

Trist: song that my co-writer is going

Speaker:

Trist: to.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, that is different.

Speaker:

Trist: I think, I need to be in a

Speaker:

Trist: different mindset for each of

Speaker:

Trist: those things.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. And I also think that there's a lot of types of

Speaker:

Elaine: creativity that we participate in as musicians because there's

Speaker:

Elaine: a lot of the social media work or editing that is creative.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it takes some of that, some

Speaker:

Elaine: of that capacity because we're

Speaker:

Elaine: spending that much time

Speaker:

Elaine: promoting and that is, you know,

Speaker:

Elaine: whether it's a visual creativity

Speaker:

Elaine: or some kind of, you know, I'm

Speaker:

Elaine: creating a skit or I'm doing

Speaker:

Elaine: this thing to help to promote my

Speaker:

Elaine: music.

Speaker:

Elaine: Those are things that I feel tap

Speaker:

Elaine: into that same kind of creative

Speaker:

Elaine: vein.

Speaker:

Elaine: Not to say that that's going to

Speaker:

Elaine: exhaust that creative vein,

Speaker:

Elaine: because I don't believe it's a

Speaker:

Elaine: zero sum game, but it is

Speaker:

Elaine: something that takes away from

Speaker:

Elaine: your energy.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: I'm kind of curious what you

Speaker:

Elaine: think about, like the other

Speaker:

Elaine: types of creativity that you

Speaker:

Elaine: need to have in order to be, a

Speaker:

Elaine: well-rounded or a self promoting

Speaker:

Elaine: musician.

Speaker:

Trist: Um.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, I do think that's different.

Speaker:

Trist: yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: I guess then for me creating,

Speaker:

Trist: you know, creating advertising

Speaker:

Trist: for shows, creating vehicles to,

Speaker:

Trist: promote music, etc., I think I

Speaker:

Trist: would think of I think of those

Speaker:

Trist: as more daytime activities

Speaker:

Trist: because they're part of like a

Speaker:

Trist: work day, like a normal business

Speaker:

Trist: world works.

Speaker:

Trist: I think I my brain

Speaker:

Trist: compartmentalizes them that way,

Speaker:

Trist: like, oh, um, I have this idea

Speaker:

Trist: to promote a show, but it

Speaker:

Trist: doesn't come to me on a Saturday

Speaker:

Trist: evening.

Speaker:

Trist: It comes to me on Tuesday at ten a m because that's when that's

Speaker:

Trist: when business happens.

Speaker:

Trist: Um, so I think my brain kind of does compartmentalize that.

Speaker:

Trist: And then it's like, I'm going to work on some music, maybe it's

Speaker:

Trist: in the afternoon, but it's probably it's closer to the

Speaker:

Trist: evening or night time for the actual music itself.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah. I'm kind of curious.

Speaker:

Elaine: Do you find it that your musical energy.

Speaker:

Elaine: So, like, thinking more of that creative energy, is like, how

Speaker:

Elaine: what's the relationship between that and your social battery?

Speaker:

Trist: Hmm. I don't know that they affect one another personally.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: I mean, the reason I ask is

Speaker:

Elaine: that, you know, I have a very

Speaker:

Elaine: my, my day job, is very

Speaker:

Elaine: relational.

Speaker:

Elaine: And a lot of times I'm in large

Speaker:

Elaine: meetings, small meetings,

Speaker:

Elaine: leading meetings, influencing

Speaker:

Elaine: other people.

Speaker:

Elaine: And it's not the mechanical stuff that will drain me.

Speaker:

Elaine: A lot of times it's the overall sense of like just spending a

Speaker:

Elaine: lot of time talking, right?

Speaker:

Elaine: There's a lot of emotional exertion that happens.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that would lead to a sense of being exhausted at the end of

Speaker:

Elaine: the day, as opposed to I've been staring at a screen and writing

Speaker:

Elaine: a document, you know, for most of the day.

Speaker:

Elaine: Um, yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: I don't have a fully baked

Speaker:

Elaine: thought about how the two

Speaker:

Elaine: relate.

Speaker:

Elaine: It just came to mind, as you

Speaker:

Elaine: know, we're talking about the

Speaker:

Elaine: types of activities that either

Speaker:

Elaine: drains or replenishes creative

Speaker:

Elaine: energy.

Speaker:

Elaine: especially when it comes to

Speaker:

Elaine: those of us who are, dual career

Speaker:

Elaine: or, multifaceted.

Speaker:

Elaine: I know that I have a lot of things going on.

Speaker:

Elaine: And so what is it that I do that

Speaker:

Elaine: restores my creative vision or

Speaker:

Elaine: restores my creativity in

Speaker:

Elaine: general.

Speaker:

Elaine: Sleep is a big one for me.

Speaker:

Elaine: And what are the things that drain that creative vision?

Speaker:

Elaine: Make me feel a little bit more

Speaker:

Elaine: emotionally exhausted or unable

Speaker:

Elaine: to tap that same level of

Speaker:

Elaine: creativity, or forces me into

Speaker:

Elaine: more of an intellectual

Speaker:

Elaine: creativity versus an emotional

Speaker:

Elaine: creativity.

Speaker:

Elaine: Lots of things to think about there.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah, I think, um, also, you could go either way.

Speaker:

Trist: Like, because you're just talking with people all day.

Speaker:

Trist: on one hand, it could make one

Speaker:

Trist: tired just in general at the end

Speaker:

Trist: of the day and not want to

Speaker:

Trist: create at all or knowing that

Speaker:

Trist: you need to be creative, you

Speaker:

Trist: have some things that you need

Speaker:

Trist: to create.

Speaker:

Trist: It might be a relief to, oh, I

Speaker:

Trist: don't have to interface this

Speaker:

Trist: way.

Speaker:

Trist: I can actually be creative.

Speaker:

Trist: I'm not just stoic now in talking to these people.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe the fact that it is you do

Speaker:

Trist: get to be creative after you

Speaker:

Trist: didn't get to be creative all

Speaker:

Trist: day.

Speaker:

Trist: Maybe that for some that might actually be a jumping off point

Speaker:

Trist: like, oh great, I finally got rid of like the work day and now

Speaker:

Trist: I can be creative.

Speaker:

Trist: Well, sometimes it's just, uh, the work day got me so dead and

Speaker:

Trist: tired that I don't want to be creative at all.

Speaker:

Trist: I think both could be the case.

Speaker:

Elaine: Yeah, well, we would love to

Speaker:

Elaine: hear- I would love to hear, I'm

Speaker:

Elaine: pretty sure we would love to

Speaker:

Elaine: hear what you think about this

Speaker:

Elaine: topic.

Speaker:

Elaine: So definitely feel free to reach out to us.

Speaker:

Elaine: We would love to hear your reaction to, um, this particular

Speaker:

Elaine: musician and what kind of response you might have to him,

Speaker:

Elaine: or what kind of reflections you might have for yourself.

Speaker:

Trist: Yeah.

Speaker:

Trist: Thanks so much.

Speaker:

Elaine: So yeah.

Speaker:

Elaine: With that, that's it for this week.

Speaker:

Elaine: Hope to see you next week.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that's it for The Musician's Loupe.

Speaker:

Elaine: See you next time.

Speaker:

Elaine: Later.

Speaker:

Elaine: You know, I will say that the

Speaker:

Elaine: voice on team sounds a little

Speaker:

Elaine: bit less AI and a little bit

Speaker:

Elaine: more.

Speaker:

Elaine: It doesn't sound human, but it

Speaker:

Elaine: does sound a little bit less

Speaker:

Elaine: digitized.

Speaker:

Trist: I don't know if that's better or worse.

Speaker:

Trist: Set me up.

Speaker:

Trist: And don't say what song.

Speaker:

Trist: Sorry.

Speaker:

Elaine: And that type of creativity is really an

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube