In this episode of Bending the Spoon, entitled Pumpkin Pie Spice, Chef Laura discusses the spice blend that has become as popular as Santa Claus. From August through February, Pumpkin Pie Spice is used in everything from household fragrances to instant oatmeal. How did it originate and why do we love it so much? Plus Chef Laura gives you her Pumpkin Pie Spice Latte recipe to make at home.
Bio: With over 13 years of professional cooking experience with her meal delivery and catering business and restaurant, Chef Laura founded Bonicelli Cooking Club in 2018. Chef Laura brings professional cooking techniques, knowledge, great recipes, and inspiration to home cooks and food lovers everywhere. She is known for her love, support, and advocacy for local, organic, and well-sourced food, and her expertise in navigating dietary preferences and issues. Chef Laura has a cookbook coming out in the Spring of 2023.
Timestamps
Key Takeaways
If you love recipes, we have a huge searchable recipe library that you can access for only $5 per month. You can sign up and learn about all of our memberships here!
You can sign up for our email list and get five free recipes if you fill out the pop-up form here!
For the video format of this podcast go to my channel on Youtube - please like and subscribe.
If you like what you're hearing, please leave a positive review on Podchasers.com and your favorite podcast venues.
Links mentioned in the episode:
In the next episode of Bending the Spoon, "Leftover Love", I'll discuss creating a thriving business out of a creative use for leftovers. We'll talk about the history of leftovers and the relationship leftovers have with food waste. I'll give you some rules I have for creating the leftovers I really want and minimizing the ones that I don't. This episode drops the day after Thanksgiving at 6:30 am CT to help with your Thanksgiving leftovers.
Pumpkin pie, spice.
Laura:We all grew up with it.
Laura:We all love it, and one company made over 100 million in just one fall
Laura:season because they use it in a latte.
Laura:We'll talk about the magical Pumpkin Pie Spice, and much, much
Laura:more today on Bending The Spoon.
Laura:But before we get to that, I'd like to remind you that if you like recipes, go
Laura:to bonicellicookingclub.com and sign up for my email list and check out all of
Laura:the options for participating in the club.
Laura:And if you like what you hear today, hop over to podchaser.com
Laura:and leave Bending The Spoon.
Laura:A positive review.
Laura:Also for the video version of the podcast, subscribe to Bonicelli Cooking Club on.
Laura:Now let's talk about Pumpkin Pie Spice.
Laura:Before we get into this, I should mention that I switched topics for this podcast.
Laura:I just had to get Pumpkin Pie Spice in before Thanksgiving, so I
Laura:moved all about fat into January.
Laura:Now, Pumpkin Pie Spice or Pumpkin Spice.
Laura:Same thing When I was growing up in
Laura:She's in Minnesota.
Laura:My mother always had a small can of pumpkin pie spice in the cabinet.
Laura:Although I suspect it was the same can the entire time I was growing
Laura:up because she just didn't use it.
Laura:Not even in her absolutely perfect pumpkin pies and I can't think of any other
Laura:recipes she made with Pumpkin Pie Spice.
Laura:However, her pie recipe has the same spices as pumpkin pie, spice, cinnamon,
Laura:ginger, nutmeg, all spice and cloves.
Laura:And I think she liked controlling the amounts of the spices
Laura:and her pies were her thing.
Laura:I still use her recipe.
Laura:It tastes great, but I'll never master a picture perfect crust like hers.
Laura:They were so perfect, they look machine made.
Laura:There are a few things that I find remarkable about pumpkin pie spice.
Laura:It definitely is a cold weather combination.
Laura:It's made of warming spices.
Laura:Spices that make you feel warm.
Laura:And also I'm sure, because even without the rest of the pie ingredients,
Laura:it smells like pumpkin pie and pumpkins are a fall vegetable.
Laura:So even though you can buy pumpkin puree year round, I'm willing to bet that most
Laura:pumpkin in puree sales happen around the.
Laura:When we're all making pumpkin bars and pumpkin pie and it's cold outside, people
Laura:associate its aroma and flavor with comfort, which is why Starbucks Pumpkin
Laura:Spice Latte is so popular, so popular.
Laura:It has its own Instagram account.
Laura:Before Starbucks introduced their famous fall concoction, the seasonal
Laura:pumpkin spice scent was primarily used for candles in home fragrances.
Laura:That's something I never bought into.
Laura:I like my home to smell like a baked pie when I'm baking.
Laura:Only when I'm baking one.
Laura:Now you can find pumpkin spice flavors in almost every type of food you can imagine.
Laura:From Cheerios to Oreos, pancake mixes to protein shakes.
Laura:I even saw some pumpkin spice.
Laura:Jelly beans.
Laura:Jelly beans at Christmas time.
Laura:Wrong holiday for jelly beans, I think.
Laura:Now here's the interesting thing.
Laura:When you smell the pumpkin pie spice combination, you smell sweet.
Laura:That's partly because the cinnamon and nutmeg trick your brain into
Laura:thinking it is sweet, but if you taste it, it isn't sweet at all.
Laura:There also may be some association.
Laura:It smells like pumpkin pie, so you think sweet, but I think it's just a
Laura:phenomenon with some spices that they smell sweet when they just aren't.
Laura:That brings us to our featured ingredient.
Laura:This week's featured ingredient is actually two ingredients, nutmeg and mace.
Laura:Nutmeg is a key ingredient in pumpkin pie.
Laura:Spice Mace is not.
Laura:So why feature both nutmeg and mace come from the same seed?
Laura:Nutmeg is the kernel inside of the seed, and mace is the aril or the
Laura:blade that is wrapped around the seed shell while similar in flavor.
Laura:Maces much more delicate and expensive than nutmeg.
Laura:Nutmeg is typically used in baked goods and sweet and savory dishes worldwide.
Laura:While mace is more often but not exclusively used in savory dishes, they're
Laura:similar enough to use interchangeably.
Laura:Nutmeg and mace are native to the Spice Islands of Indonesia.
Laura:They're cultivated in the Malukas, the West Indies,
Laura:Africa, Grenada, and Sri Lanka.
Laura:Although many stores carry both spices ground, it's best to buy the nutmeg
Laura:kernels and mace arils hole and grind them in your spice grinder, or use a
Laura:microplane to great them as you need them, store them in a cool, dry place
Laura:in an airtight container away from heat.
Laura:And if you can buy them in small quantities buy what you need
Laura:for a few months at a time.
Laura:I assumed pumpkin pie spice had been around since the 1950s
Laura:because that's when food started being packaged for convenience.
Laura:After all.
Laura:What could be more convenient than using one spice in a pie instead of five?
Laura:But the earliest versions of the Premix combo were actually introduced by
Laura:Thompson and Taylor's Spice Company and McCormick and Company in the early 1930s.
Laura:Now, that's for a premade blend that was named Pumpkin Pie Spice, but pies
Laura:and other recipes using that combination of spices date back to the 17 hundreds.
Laura:Now that's in America, but around the world, it goes back way further,
Laura:and it's not just used for pumpkin.
Laura:Mid Eastern cultures used a similar spice combination in spiced
Laura:meats, rice dishes, and tagines.
Laura:In England, mince meat pie, which usually contain mutton and dried fruit.
Laura:Also plump pudding.
Laura:And think of meads and spiced wine.
Laura:Because our American palettes associate the spice combination with
Laura:sweet treats, some of the savory dishes may not be well received.
Laura:Remember that even if there is no sugar in a dish, say a pork dish with
Laura:cinnamon, we still perceive sweetness.
Laura:Which isn't something that everyone cares for, but there is one thing
Laura:that everyone does like, and now it's time for our tip of the week.
Laura:The tip of the week is how to make your own Pumpkin Pie Spice Latte.
Laura:Usually I'm not a sweet coffee drink person, but this time of
Laura:year I will occasionally have a mocha with a smidge of Mintz syrup.
Laura:And around Thanksgiving, I'll make pumpkin pie spice lattes
Laura:on a cold Sunday afternoon.
Laura:A couple of episodes ago, I gave you my pumpkin pie spice recipe,
Laura:and I believe that was episode one.
Laura:It's a delicious combination of spices, so, so go and grab that.
Laura:If you don't have Pumpkin Pie Spice on hand.
Laura:Now let me walk you through my recipe.
Laura:You need two coffee cups or mugs.
Laura:Now in a small sauce pan mix three tablespoons of pumpkin puree and
Laura:two tablespoons of water, and a half a teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice.
Laura:That's a boiling, stirring for two minutes to bring out the flavor of the spices.
Laura:Mix in two tablespoons of granulated sugar and keep stirring until
Laura:it looks like a thick syrup.
Laura:Put a shot of espresso in each mug.
Laura:Divide the pumpkin mixture between the cups and stir into the espresso broth.
Laura:One cup of milk and one tablespoon of vanilla extract and divide
Laura:the froth milk between the cups.
Laura:Top that with slightly sweetened whipped cream and sprinkle
Laura:with more spice for a garnish.
Laura:I usually skip the whipped cream, but it is delicious.
Laura:And I should mention this probably seems like a lot of
Laura:vanilla, but I promise it's not.
Laura:The vanilla is what makes it taste like pie.
Laura:I use my Breville Milk Cafe to froth my milk, which, which I absolutely love.
Laura:But if you don't have a frother, try using your immersion blender.
Laura:Make your own homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Latte, and that is your tip of the week..
Laura:You are listening to Bending the Spoon, the podcast dedicated
Laura:to making you a better cook.
Laura:I'm Chef Laura Bonicelli and I want to remind you that if you like recipes, go
Laura:to bonicellicookingclub.com and sign up for my email list and check out all of
Laura:the options of participating in the club.
Laura:And if you like what you hear today, hop over to podchaser.com and leave
Laura:bending the spoon of positive review.
Laura:Also for the video version of this podcast, subscribe to
Laura:Bonelli Cooking Club on YouTube.
Laura:Now, back to our episode.
Laura:We can't deny the positive impact and nostalgic feelings
Laura:that Pumpkin Pie Spice evokes.
Laura:It makes us feel warm and fuzzy and safe, even loved.
Laura:But let's remember that with the spices usually comes sugar,
Laura:fat, and often white flour.
Laura:So is it good for us?
Laura:As you all know, I'm in the once in a while camp when it comes to sweet treats.
Laura:I have had them in a more featured place in my daily diet and it didn't go well.
Laura:So I do limit them, but I don't wanna end up like the mayor in Chocolat,
Laura:so much deprivation, one day I just crack up and go on a crazy binge.
Laura:Here is the good news.
Laura:The spices themselves are good for you.
Laura:They lighten your spirits because they make you feel happy.
Laura:They all have warming properties and increased circulation, perfect
Laura:for fall and winter weather When our circulation goes down and
Laura:the days get shorter and shorter.
Laura:A reduced flow of oxygen can make you feel tired and lethargic.
Laura:But after having a Pumpkin Spice Latte or another pumpkin spice flavored food
Laura:or beverage, our blood vessels expand and we feel warmer and more energized.
Laura:If you look at any of the ingredients in Pumpkin Pie Spice individually,
Laura:they all have a long list of benefits.
Laura:Take our featured ingredient, for example.
Laura:This is a culmination of things I found from a number of sources,
Laura:including Healthline and WebMD.
Laura:Nutmeg is rich in antioxidants, and because of that, it is believed to
Laura:have the ability to relieve pain, sooth and digestion, strengthen cognitive
Laura:function, detoxify the body, boost skin health, alleviate oral conditions,
Laura:reduced insomnia, increase immune system function, and improve blood circulation.
Laura:I don't know about all of that or how much nutmeg you need to actually get
Laura:those benefits, but let's sum it up with saying spices are good for you.
Laura:It's time for our top tool.
Laura:I love cappuccino and lattes, so frothing milk at home is very important to me,
Laura:and the quality of the frothed milk, the texture, the foam, it being really hot
Laura:are things I'm really concerned about.
Laura:Now over the years I've had a number of espresso machines with
Laura:frothers and also quite a few separate home frothing devices.
Laura:Two of them quit working after about a year, and parts were almost
Laura:expensive as buying a new one.
Laura:But, I'm on my third year with this one, the Breville Milk
Laura:Cafe, and I absolutely love it.
Laura:It does take longer than any of the other frothers, you know,
Laura:maybe three to four minutes.
Laura:But it's worth the wait.
Laura:It also has a larger capacity than the other frothers, and it has separate
Laura:frothing devices for cappuccino and latte because they're not the
Laura:same, and it's dishwasher safe.
Laura:Not that I ever put it in the dishwasher, but apparently I could.
Laura:So here's another perk, you can control the temperature of the milk from warm
Laura:at under 120 degrees Fahrenheit, all the way up to over 160 degrees Farenheit.
Laura:And you have the option to cold stir as well.
Laura:This is my top tool, the Breville Milk Cafe, and you can find
Laura:out more on my bendable site.
Laura:There is a link in the show notes.
Laura:Pumpkin Pie spice has definitely found a permanent place in our culture.
Laura:As I close this episode, sipping my Pumpkin Pie Spice Latte.
Laura:I'm feeling a little bit sorry for the other spices in the mix.
Laura:I really did give nutmeg all of the attention making it
Laura:featured ingredient and all.
Laura:So here is a little respect for the others.
Laura:Cinnamon, you are literally bark.
Laura:You and nutmeg are in equal standing as comfort spices.
Laura:And again, you make the world sweeter with no actual sweetness of your own.
Laura:Ginger.
Laura:You are spicy with heat, so we have to be a bit careful with you,
Laura:but we miss you if you were gone.
Laura:Same with you.
Laura:cloves, you aren't hot and we have to remember a little of you goes a very long.
Laura:And finally allspice.
Laura:You really do have it all with notes of cloves and nutmegs star anus,
Laura:fennel, black pepper, and cinnamon.
Laura:You really belong in this mix.
Laura:Next week's episode is called Leftover Love.
Laura:Look for it.
Laura:I wish you a wonderful Thanksgiving and holiday season.
Laura:Thank you so very much for listening to this episode of Bending the Spoon.
Laura:If you like this episode or if you think someone else would find it,
Laura:Please leave a review on pod chaser.com and if you have any questions for
Laura:me, find me on Instagram or YouTube or go to bonicellicookingclub.com
Laura:and leave me a message.
Laura:Thank you, and go and make some magic in your kitchen.