Artwork for podcast The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove
Episode 355 - QEII Funeral- Souvenir Edition
21st September 2022 • The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove • The Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove
00:00:00 01:06:50

Share Episode

Shownotes

In this episode, we look at the funeral and the lead-up and what these tell us about our society.

How to support the Podcast.

Make a per episode donation via Patreon

or

Donate through Paypal

and

tell your friends.

Mentioned in this episode:

Website

Transcripts

Speaker:

We need to talk about ideas, good ones and bad ones.

Speaker:

We need to learn stuff about the world.

Speaker:

We need an honest, intelligent thought provoking and entertaining review of

Speaker:

what the hell happened on this planet.

Speaker:

In the last seven days, we need to sit back and listen to the

Speaker:

Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Welcome back.

Speaker:

Dear listener, episode 355.

Speaker:

I'm Trevor, the Iron Fist with me, Joe, the tech guy.

Speaker:

How are you Joe evening?

Speaker:

All.

Speaker:

Mm, well, dear listener queen Elizabeth second is dead.

Speaker:

I'm not, but it feels sometimes like I'm close to it.

Speaker:

Cause I got COVID when I was in Sydney.

Speaker:

And I've been sick for nine days, 10 days, like really bad, bad,

Speaker:

clogged up head, even my nose.

Speaker:

Now you can probably hear my voice is not normal.

Speaker:

And, I've just been spending the last 10 days sitting around, lying in bed and

Speaker:

doing nothing, cuz I can't do anything.

Speaker:

I literally, cannot do anything.

Speaker:

So yeah, it's pretty rough.

Speaker:

And it's just a cold Trevor, just man up and get over it.

Speaker:

No, I have to say that, you know, they say that the vaccine really, has helped

Speaker:

in terms of the symptoms that you feel.

Speaker:

And I've had four shots.

Speaker:

I tell you what I felt pretty darn crook and I'm a reasonably

Speaker:

healthy guy for a 58 year old.

Speaker:

So I mean everybody's experience is different, but I really

Speaker:

would not have liked to have.

Speaker:

had that dose of COVID without having had four shots, if everything they say

Speaker:

about the shots alleviating the symptoms is true, cuz I would've been in hospital.

Speaker:

So, as it was I, well, you know, I didn't have to go to hospital.

Speaker:

Well, didn't really think about it, but still very unpleasant.

Speaker:

So my advice to your listener is if you can avoid a dose of COVID then

Speaker:

avoided you haven't had it yet.

Speaker:

Joan, have you?

Speaker:

I don't know.

Speaker:

So my daughter and her boyfriend were staying here, and they

Speaker:

both tested positive for COVID.

Speaker:

I was in the same house cooking with them.

Speaker:

the child at one stage was snuggled up on my bed, watching a movie.

Speaker:

So it wasn't like there was any distance between us and I had some mild

Speaker:

symptoms, but never tested positive.

Speaker:

So possibly I'm on immunosuppressive drugs.

Speaker:

So I would've thought I was at high risk of yeah.

Speaker:

Have you got the antivirals, if you were to get COVID, would you get the special

Speaker:

antiviral treatment that's around?

Speaker:

Possibly.

Speaker:

I don't know.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Cause I was talking to Robin Bristo, AKA brother Samma demo go.

Speaker:

And because he's got issues.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

He had lined up with his GP in advance to say, if I get COVID you've

Speaker:

gotta be ready to get these for me.

Speaker:

And he got them very, very quickly once he got COVID.

Speaker:

So yeah.

Speaker:

Anyway, I'm still a few days off.

Speaker:

Remember as a 20 year old getting flu and it put me in bed for three weeks.

Speaker:

Yeah, go.

Speaker:

So yeah, we, we laugh about man flu, but he's a serious disease and my daughter's

Speaker:

teenage friend who had COVID I think six months on is still getting breathless

Speaker:

if she does any form of exercise.

Speaker:

Yes it's.

Speaker:

Yeah, it does.

Speaker:

And I think there's, there's.

Speaker:

Evidence there's more and more evidence of long-term damage.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

So this was,, 10 days ago.

Speaker:

I was coming back from Sydney and I think there was maybe three or four

Speaker:

people on the plane with a mask on and I was one of them, but, and in the

Speaker:

airport, virtually one out of a hundred was wearing a mask, at that point.

Speaker:

So I, on the way down to Sydney, it was mandatory to have the

Speaker:

mask on the plane, but by mm-hmm, , I'd spend a week in Sydney.

Speaker:

By the time I came back, it was no longer mandatory.

Speaker:

And, and yeah, literally just a handful on the plane and maybe one or two in

Speaker:

every a hundred people in the airport, the masks on saying, there we go.

Speaker:

Anyway, in my trip, we were mandatory.

Speaker:

So nobody wore them at the airport, but when we got on the plane,

Speaker:

they told us it was mandatory.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

And then admittedly, the plane was packed.

Speaker:

And on the way back, the plane was sparsely populated and the,

Speaker:

the mask laws had been changed.

Speaker:

So we had to wear it in the airport, but not on the plane.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

What, what, yeah.

Speaker:

At the airport, they insisted that we wear the masks and then we got

Speaker:

on the plane and they said, oh, you don't have to wear your masks anymore.

Speaker:

okay.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

. Thank you for the messages in the chat room, by the way, Julia and John Watley,

Speaker:

jungle juice, jungle juice says I've had two shots and still haven't had it.

Speaker:

So there we go.

Speaker:

well we've got talk about, well, Elizabeth II, the funeral, the whole shebang.

Speaker:

And what does it say about our society?

Speaker:

Well, as somebody said, you know, out with one li with another Liz Trump in with an.

Speaker:

Liz.

Speaker:

Yes, that's right.

Speaker:

For those of us who recognize her saying yes, cause she appeared and the poor

Speaker:

old channel nine commentators from Australia were like, who's that lady

Speaker:

don't know, just least a minor Royal.

Speaker:

My understanding was it was from a distance.

Speaker:

They couldn't actually see her face.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Well, the point was they were commenting on it from a position

Speaker:

where they probably had a worse view than what we had on the BBC feed.

Speaker:

This was the crazy part about some of the decision making around all this.

Speaker:

Like I think the ABC sent 23 people across there to cover this, , funeral.

Speaker:

And what do we end up getting at the BBC feed, which is of course exactly

Speaker:

what we would've wanted to get.

Speaker:

Anyway, mm-hmm, a complete waste of money.

Speaker:

Like I've just, I'm really losing sympathy with the ABC on a number of issues.

Speaker:

And when they cry poor about.

Speaker:

not having enough money and their budget being slashed.

Speaker:

I really am gonna look at this 23 people sent to the UK and go,

Speaker:

well, what was that all about?

Speaker:

Seriously?

Speaker:

You couldn't have done that.

Speaker:

Just relying on the BBC feed and having people in Australia comment

Speaker:

over the top of it, occasionally for an Australian perspective on some issue.

Speaker:

But I think for goodness sake, it was just, I wonder how many of those were

Speaker:

senior people and it was a junk it, yeah, just a junk it, no respect for

Speaker:

other people's money, anyway, you didn't watch it, Joe, I don't think.

Speaker:

Yeah, but, I've done my best to avoid it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Lots of speculation about Megan Markle and what faux PAs she committed and

Speaker:

yeah, I, I see the headlines again.

Speaker:

Can't be bothered.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, I mean, we'll try and talk about these issues and find the

Speaker:

broader context where we can.

Speaker:

Here's my hot take from the whole thing is that basically , our hard

Speaker:

wide pro-social emotions overrule cold, hard, rational thinking.

Speaker:

I think people really enjoyed, you know, let's face it.

Speaker:

A majority of people enjoyed the whole show and were probably in favor of

Speaker:

everything that happened, the lead up, and a lot of people, very emotional

Speaker:

with very positive views towards queen Elizabeth II and, and felt

Speaker:

everything was all very appropriate.

Speaker:

So there's a little, you know, a lot of what was done was definitely

Speaker:

in favor by the majority of people.

Speaker:

And you know, on the one hand you can say, this is an unelected ancestral, right?

Speaker:

Basically because her ancestors out fought and outlasted some other group

Speaker:

in some battle and going descendancy and you know, in a modern context,

Speaker:

the whole thing makes no sense at all.

Speaker:

But on the other hand you go, well, I think people look at the cooperation

Speaker:

and they're coming together.

Speaker:

And the prosocial aspect of that gives such good vibes to people

Speaker:

that that's what they like.

Speaker:

And they are enjoying that coming together as a community over something.

Speaker:

It doesn't really matter what it is.

Speaker:

So it's like, you know, football is a pretty silly thing.

Speaker:

When you think about it at the end of the day, kicking a piece of leather

Speaker:

around, but it's more the people coming together over things that is

Speaker:

a thing that really gets people in.

Speaker:

So, you know, if you want to affect change in this world, you have

Speaker:

to take into account emotion and.

Speaker:

and, and that's been one of the biggest things.

Speaker:

I mean, that was the reason for, whatever it was, atheist church.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Sunday assembly or whatever it was called.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Camera islands.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Was, was people, people missing the cohesiveness of a religious group?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

And even if they didn't believe they still wanted to belong to a tribe?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

For some reason it didn't work for Cam's Sunday assembly, although

Speaker:

it does work in some places.

Speaker:

So, it tends to work in the us where they're a lot more cohesive and there's a

Speaker:

lot more, social built around your church.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And, and I think we've managed to replace it enough over here.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And maybe people who had grown up with that who had left the church who were

Speaker:

looking to replace it with something.

Speaker:

whereas there were a lot of people here who.

Speaker:

Aren't looking to replace it cuz they never had it.

Speaker:

So yeah.

Speaker:

So I think that's my hot take is just, it impresses on me the value of people's

Speaker:

prosocial emotions, wanting to feel like they belong to something, the bringing

Speaker:

together of people, it's a hardwired prosocial feature of human beings and it

Speaker:

was on full display there and it accounts for a lot of what happened essentially.

Speaker:

so yeah, that's the hot take?

Speaker:

let's talk about other different things.

Speaker:

ah, bagpipes, Joe, I've got this standard joke about bagpipes.

Speaker:

I heard years ago, which was what's the difference between

Speaker:

bagpipes and a bag of onions.

Speaker:

And the answer is people cry when you cut up a bag of onions mm-hmm . But I have

Speaker:

to say the bagpipes were very, very good.

Speaker:

Like as they got ready to March off with her and all the rest of it and

Speaker:

the bag pipes came down at different times, is it I've learned from this

Speaker:

whole, if I've learned one thing from this joke is there is a time

Speaker:

and a place for bagpipes in oh yeah.

Speaker:

The Royal funeral.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Having been to the Edinborough, military tattoo, the lone

Speaker:

Piper up on the Ram parts.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Is, is certainly, but you know, these people practice for hours

Speaker:

and hours, whereas your next door neighbor, who's just learning to play.

Speaker:

I, I can very much understand.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Roman says, Hey, don't criticize the musical traditions of my ancestors.

Speaker:

Oh, I'm well, , I'm being a little bit positive if I can about the bagpipes.

Speaker:

So that was one thing to come out of it.

Speaker:

It's interesting.

Speaker:

Bagpipes.

Speaker:

Aren't just Scottish.

Speaker:

Briney and France has a big, historical, linking to bagpipes.

Speaker:

I, I assume it was the Celtic thing.

Speaker:

Right because Scott's the Welsh, and the bras are all kelps and the Irish.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

There go.

Speaker:

oh look, I've got such a mismatch of things here and dear, isn't it, I'm

Speaker:

not operating at a hundred percent.

Speaker:

So we might be all over the shop in how we deal with this.

Speaker:

the whole media reaction to this.

Speaker:

I mean, it's been relentless and crazy , the sort of 24 hour continuous

Speaker:

rolling coverage of this event in the lead up that I would've thought

Speaker:

has been over the top, but today saw a poll come out from essential.

Speaker:

And the question was, which of the following best described how you

Speaker:

feel about the media coverage of the death of queen Elizabeth II

Speaker:

and the Ascension of king Charles.

Speaker:

The media coverage has given me more information than I need about

Speaker:

the right amount of information or less information than I need.

Speaker:

And the more information that I need was only 48%.

Speaker:

The about right.

Speaker:

Was 42.

Speaker:

And people who wanted more information was 10% based on that poll Joe.

Speaker:

Well, the majority wanted the same or more information than what they got.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But just, yeah, there's been multiple coverage, but how much

Speaker:

information has been in that coverage?

Speaker:

So you might have wanted more information and less coverage, less speculation

Speaker:

about who walked in front of who and broke protocol because of that.

Speaker:

And possibly a little more information about yeah.

Speaker:

Important stuff.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Could have been a different question.

Speaker:

Have they gone overboard with coverage is a different yeah, exactly.

Speaker:

They true.

Speaker:

What have I got here?

Speaker:

Has this campaign, this, this media campaign, this relentless

Speaker:

coverage, has it reflected the majority view or is it out of step?

Speaker:

and which would be scarier?

Speaker:

So if it is outta step with the majority view, if we've got too

Speaker:

much coverage than what we wanted, then we are seeing an overt

Speaker:

demonstration of culture being imposed.

Speaker:

If it reflects the majority view, then we are seeing a demonstration of irrational

Speaker:

culture that has against all odds successfully been imposed or maintained.

Speaker:

It's probably it's one or the other, and I'm not sure which one is, is, is scarier.

Speaker:

you know, if you are wanting the existing power structures to be

Speaker:

maintained, then you would be encouraging the maintenance of the monarchy

Speaker:

and you would be encouraging this conservative coverage of everything.

Speaker:

I mean, there was barely, well, I, I have to admit, I didn't watch much

Speaker:

mainstream media in the lead up.

Speaker:

I watched the actual funeral service, but I didn't watch any of the lead

Speaker:

up, but my feeling is that there was no discussion at any point on the

Speaker:

ABC about the role of the monarchy.

Speaker:

And there was no criticism or critique of queen Elizabeth II

Speaker:

and what she's done other than.

Speaker:

very, very, very positive reflection of what she'd done.

Speaker:

There was nothing negative.

Speaker:

There was no even handed coverage of this.

Speaker:

It was just a very pro Elizabeth II coverage.

Speaker:

And what are you there for ABC?

Speaker:

If, if not, to give us, is this the time to be doing that?

Speaker:

I think of all of the people there have, you know, there there's been

Speaker:

very little to reflect badly upon her.

Speaker:

I think, she has been incredibly, positive in terms of what she has

Speaker:

done and what she's been unlike other members of the Royal family.

Speaker:

. Hmm.

Speaker:

and.

Speaker:

When Steve Irwin died, were, were there comments in the press

Speaker:

about whether he was really the bloke that he was held up to be?

Speaker:

And I, I think when people have died and, and it's a funeral

Speaker:

time, we tend to sanctify people.

Speaker:

Don't we?

Speaker:

Yeah, I guess it was just seven days of it or however long it was.

Speaker:

I guess in all that time that you've got to fill, at least you could put it

Speaker:

on and people don't have to watch it.

Speaker:

You know what I mean?

Speaker:

Like they could choose to watch something else at that point, there might be

Speaker:

other people who want to watch it.

Speaker:

So, you know, I agree there is a time and a place, but, the relentlessly positive.

Speaker:

Propaganda really graded with me, I guess I'd say.

Speaker:

So I felt it needed a balance of some sort, which you could only find on Twitter

Speaker:

or in the, I don't know the far outskirts of, of the web in obscure areas that

Speaker:

you really had to go hard looking for.

Speaker:

So, or, or getting arrested.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Well, let's talk about that.

Speaker:

There was one young fellow, just in a crowd and he just started yelling out

Speaker:

something, the one lone voice, and he just got dragged out by police and.

Speaker:

Handcuffed and led away.

Speaker:

And there was another protestor who was silently holding up a sign

Speaker:

saying not my king mm-hmm and, also got led away by police.

Speaker:

And, so I'm kind of okay with that in terms of particularly people who

Speaker:

are yelling out, doesn't have to be abusive, but just yelling out,

Speaker:

not my king or something like that.

Speaker:

I'm kind.

Speaker:

How do you feel about that one, Joe?

Speaker:

I, so they were arrested for acting in a manner likely to

Speaker:

cause a breach of the peaks.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

A and that is true enough.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

I, I think there was a real risk that they would've been lynched.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

so I, I, I don't object to their voice.

Speaker:

I just think that there are possibly different places

Speaker:

rather than picketing a funeral.

Speaker:

Or outside Buckhouse that this should be speakers corner, for instance, which

Speaker:

is, you know, historically where you entered and spoke out politically.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

one of these guys was shouting at prince Andrew, I think making comments about him

Speaker:

being a pedophile or something like that, was sort of comment that he was making.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I, I don't know again, had that been an average day.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

but when it's a, when somebody's loved one has just passed, I don't know

Speaker:

that that's necessarily appropriate.

Speaker:

It's like picketing at funerals.

Speaker:

Mm, yep.

Speaker:

I, I, I think it it's, you have a right to a voice, but there's a time and a place.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Well, if it happens in here in Queensland, Joe, we've got a summary of fences

Speaker:

act, section six, subsection two.

Speaker:

you commit a public nuisance offense.

Speaker:

If you behave in a disorderly way or an offensive way, and your behavior

Speaker:

interferes, or is likely to interfere with the peaceful passage through or enjoyment

Speaker:

of a public place by member of the public.

Speaker:

So, a disorderly way or an offensive way for conduct to be

Speaker:

disorderly, it must be sufficiently ill mattered, or in bad taste.

Speaker:

It does not only have to meet with the disapproval of well conducted and

Speaker:

reasonable men and women, but also tend to annoy or insult such person

Speaker:

sufficiently deeply or seriously to warrant the interference, of the police.

Speaker:

So.

Speaker:

Ill mattered, bad taste, meet with the disapproval of well conducted

Speaker:

and reasonable men and women do that.

Speaker:

And you're on your way to a disorderly, well, public nuisance based on disorderly.

Speaker:

and how old was that law?

Speaker:

Oh, it's current.

Speaker:

Isn't it?

Speaker:

Queensland.

Speaker:

So I just wondered if it was a, yeah.

Speaker:

It's commonly used law, I believe.

Speaker:

Oh, it's not obscure.

Speaker:

Yeah, that was, that was the Canadian.

Speaker:

That was a female blonde Canadian who was very right wing.

Speaker:

Who was walking through some very Muslim area of Sydney.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Who got moved on by the police and told that she'd be arrested for

Speaker:

disorderly conduct or something?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

ill mattered, bad taste meet with the disapproval of well conducted

Speaker:

and reasonable men and women.

Speaker:

and it's all done in the circumstances.

Speaker:

So I think with that guy yelling out at prince Andrew, that he's a

Speaker:

pedophile, you know, amongst a crowd of people who were there just to enjoy

Speaker:

the procession and the higher risk that the crowd would turn on him.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm and that the high risk that, that would lead to some sort

Speaker:

of minor,, fight, breaking out.

Speaker:

Good idea by the police.

Speaker:

I think, and those who are sort of in favor of freedom

Speaker:

of speech is so important.

Speaker:

It it's cannot be,, restricted in any way.

Speaker:

It's, it's the ultimate thing that we must keep free at all times.

Speaker:

Well, you know, we'd restrict speech for different things.

Speaker:

I mean, just for foul language, if the guy was there.

Speaker:

just saying horrible, terrible foul language and all the rest of it.

Speaker:

We could, it could be carted away because of just a breach of,

Speaker:

of a public norm, essentially.

Speaker:

So back to how we value it, value public norms, probably

Speaker:

slanderous statements as well.

Speaker:

accusing him of being a pedophile.

Speaker:

The allegations were that he had sex with a woman who was over the age of consent.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Maybe he was consensual or not.

Speaker:

That's different, but, technically to call him a pedophile, I think

Speaker:

he's is definitely slanderous.

Speaker:

I think he was shouting at prince about his recent troubles.

Speaker:

I dunno, the word Peter fol was used, but right.

Speaker:

I think it was just, it has been, it has been liberally used about him.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And I think you need to be very careful.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Because I think those charges wouldn't stick.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I mean, certainly it's morally reprehensible and there are possibly

Speaker:

other criminal charges, but I don't think that particular one is, is relevant.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

So the free speech advocates out there, I think I'd say, you know what,

Speaker:

that guy could go back there the next day and shout amongst to anybody,

Speaker:

whatever he wants to, sometimes there are just occasions because of what

Speaker:

the rest of the community is doing.

Speaker:

That maybe you don't get to have your free speech.

Speaker:

And if that was happening every day where you were restricted.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

But, well I think it's, the protests are about abortion places.

Speaker:

Abortion clinics.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Plenty of opportunity to protest wherever you like, just

Speaker:

not right there at that time.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

So yeah, that's all part of that.

Speaker:

I, Yeah.

Speaker:

Broman said initially, personally, I'm concerned about attempts to

Speaker:

silence, voices with a different view about the monarchy.

Speaker:

It's like reasonable free speech had to be suspended, but then goes on to

Speaker:

say, take your point, Joe and others after all, I'm sure no one here liked

Speaker:

that awful church used to pick at the funerals and gay service people in the us.

Speaker:

So there we go.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So you do have to sort of take him to count the circumstances and, and I

Speaker:

think that was a correct decision by the British police on that occasion.

Speaker:

mind you other forms of protest Joe and there were some good ones in,

Speaker:

now this I will find, let me just, find this particular video, which

Speaker:

was, I was a bit concerned by a lot of us Twitter commenters, right?

Speaker:

They were blaming her for colonialism.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

and a she's the Monarch and doesn't have any power, but also B the

Speaker:

empire dissolved under Elizabeth, almost all of the colonies got

Speaker:

their freedom under Elizabeth.

Speaker:

So of all the people you could blame, I would say that

Speaker:

she's the least responsible.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Is.

Speaker:

I mean, if you're gonna have a Monarch, she was one of the better typed to

Speaker:

have in that she wasn't the, she kind of looking at Australia and going,

Speaker:

why the hell haven't you guys left?

Speaker:

You know, that was the sort of view she had.

Speaker:

It seemed so she wasn't, power grabbing in that sense, wanting

Speaker:

to accumulate more colonies.

Speaker:

not that she would have any say in it.

Speaker:

You're right.

Speaker:

So I think she did look at it and think, well, that makes sense

Speaker:

if that's what you wanna do.

Speaker:

So give her credit for that.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm yeah.

Speaker:

Some of the, so Joe, apparently at football games, , they will sometimes

Speaker:

have a minute silence, but the alternative is that will have a minute of clapping.

Speaker:

Have you heard of this before?

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, and sometimes I would've a minute silence followed by minutes clapping.

Speaker:

So at some football stadium, I think it was in Scotland or

Speaker:

it might have been Ireland.

Speaker:

I'm not sure where it was, but, the crowd knew that they were about to

Speaker:

have a minute of clapping for the queen and the crowd started singing.

Speaker:

if you hate the Royal family, clap your hands during the one minute clapping

Speaker:

session, I'll show you a bit of it here.

Speaker:

So.

Speaker:

I have given four marks for being clever.

Speaker:

I knew that these guys were compelled to clap for a minute and then

Speaker:

started a song saying if you hate the Royal family, clap your hands.

Speaker:

So, full marks for that one in terms of cleverness.

Speaker:

I wanna read some.

Speaker:

Twitter comments.

Speaker:

see if you agree with some of these, I think ABC news is misjudging the public

Speaker:

with their insufferable psycho Fantic and endless rolling coverage of the queen.

Speaker:

Who's going to tell them that we don't care that much about it turns out.

Speaker:

Obviously it turns out people did care, watching ABC news and wondering

Speaker:

if they now have deference police ensuring the Queens coverage is a

Speaker:

hundred percent foreign and gro without journalists ever asking the necessary

Speaker:

tough, but respectful question about the continued relevance of the monarchy

Speaker:

and it's placed in our constitution.

Speaker:

So Joe, you would say not the time yet for that, Marky lawyers.

Speaker:

It would've been nice to see just some genuine reflection on the Queen's life

Speaker:

and death, but instead our media is drowning us in performative perfunctory

Speaker:

D it's embarrassing and meaningless.

Speaker:

It was very syrupy, psycho over the top climb, but I was from what I saw.

Speaker:

Yes, it did seem to be Vaus I think is the word.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

You could have been positive and respectful without

Speaker:

being so goddamn forming.

Speaker:

I think would've been possible.

Speaker:

I think, look, how does the queen rate, I mean, you, as you were

Speaker:

saying, she wasn't that bad.

Speaker:

I wrote here, she's an unelected Relic of an unfair medieval practice and has died.

Speaker:

She performed her ceremonial duties diligently her most notable achievement

Speaker:

was the length of her tenure.

Speaker:

I'll say it, it wouldn't be that hard to be in Monarch with no real power.

Speaker:

You just put on a show and leave the real problems up to the parliament.

Speaker:

So I'll excuse her from being complicit in the various atrocities of the

Speaker:

British empire during her reign, not a bad old bird, really for what she

Speaker:

had to do minded her own business, largely as far as a queen does, I

Speaker:

think she worked bloody hard actually.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm I mean, she, yeah, she lived her, her life for luxury mm-hmm , but

Speaker:

I don't think it was an easy life.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm I think there was a lot of expectation on her to always be smiling

Speaker:

and cheerful and, you know, opening public things or visiting sick people

Speaker:

in hospital and doing all those.

Speaker:

It's little but little things, you know, but she wasn't flipping hamburgers

Speaker:

at McDonald's no eight hours a day.

Speaker:

Like there's a lot of jobs, a lot harder than being queen.

Speaker:

There would've been tedious moments, but what job?

Speaker:

Doesn't no, but you know, it's not like she retired at 65 and had a pension.

Speaker:

Yes, that's true.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

so I don't, I think it's a very different life.

Speaker:

I don't think any of us can really understand.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

what it's like, I mean, you, you talk to the stars and they are very

Speaker:

well compensated, but you can't understand being chased everywhere

Speaker:

by the media who wants to take a photo of you in a compromising

Speaker:

position so they can splash it across the, the front page the next day.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

There's, there's a whole load of things that you just, until you've

Speaker:

lived it, you can't understand.

Speaker:

Mm, very different life.

Speaker:

I agree.

Speaker:

But, you know, I could think of a lot of, lifestyles that

Speaker:

would be a hell of a lot worse.

Speaker:

Oh, absolutely.

Speaker:

And, you know, growing up poor in some housing commission blocking in, in

Speaker:

somewhere in the UK or being the queen and you go, gee, you know what, there's

Speaker:

gonna be some tough moments being queen.

Speaker:

I think I'll take it.

Speaker:

I I'll run the risk.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, ah, okay.

Speaker:

I mean, that's, that's the arguments I get into about prince Philip mm-hmm

Speaker:

uh, look, the man commanded a vessel in the second world war and then was

Speaker:

playing second fiddle to the queen.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And I think he was bored.

Speaker:

I think he made his comments in the full knowledge.

Speaker:

I think he was just being a little mischievous because that

Speaker:

was the only freedom he got.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

I suspect he was quite bored and And probably cocooned in a bubble.

Speaker:

Like he was, maybe didn't realize exactly how some of his comments

Speaker:

would quite be taken as well.

Speaker:

So combination of that,

Speaker:

we've been very positive about Dan Andrews over the years.

Speaker:

Love Dan Andrews.

Speaker:

He's doing a good job down there.

Speaker:

Mostly.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So there's a hospital, Joe in Victoria, the Maronda hospital named after

Speaker:

some indigenous, it's an indigenous name of some sort dunno it's named

Speaker:

after actually region name or human.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I don't know, but it's an indigenous name.

Speaker:

It's currently called the maroon hospital and it's gonna be upgraded.

Speaker:

And when they upgrade it, they're then gonna call it the QE two.

Speaker:

Why?

Speaker:

Cause cruise wasn't enough.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

There's, you know, there's already QE two hospitals running around.

Speaker:

Honestly.

Speaker:

I dunno if that decision will stick, what's wrong with, I mean, whatever

Speaker:

it was named for in the first place, just leave it at that, improve it.

Speaker:

We just don't need more things named after queen Elizabeth II.

Speaker:

Surely all goes down to this, cultural propaganda.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm , it's this, you know, just yet another public institution named

Speaker:

after a Monarch, just entrenches the whole rock show even further.

Speaker:

And, it, it's not meaningless.

Speaker:

These things add up and count at the end of the day.

Speaker:

So leave it as it is.

Speaker:

that's the sort of thing I'd have expected from Scott Morrison.

Speaker:

Like you would've expected him to come out and rename something after QE two, after.

Speaker:

All this and we would've sat back here going you typical bloody Monicas bastard.

Speaker:

Dan would never do that.

Speaker:

And then look at that.

Speaker:

He's kind of done it.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Braw reckons.

Speaker:

It's just a, Gazo the, the liberals.

Speaker:

Oh, okay.

Speaker:

He doesn't have to before they could.

Speaker:

No, he doesn't.

Speaker:

He doesn't have to.

Speaker:

They're already in strife.

Speaker:

So, because they've got an opposition leader, right?

Speaker:

Run stacking.

Speaker:

No, they've got an opposition leader.

Speaker:

He thinks king Arthur is a real thing.

Speaker:

Joe.

Speaker:

Hear about this one.

Speaker:

I'll play this clip.

Speaker:

Hang on.

Speaker:

It was time to remember the queen alongside myths and legends in all those

Speaker:

times in all those monarchs from figures.

Speaker:

Well known king Arthur, Henry the eighth.

Speaker:

And so on the longest reigning of them all was queen Elizabeth.

Speaker:

The second God save the king.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

King Arthur.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Interestingly, the French claim king author is theirs.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Really?

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

I mean, that's what Dan's up against.

Speaker:

He didn't have to rename hospital QE two to get him over the line when you're up

Speaker:

against umbling Phils, like they've got the Victorian opposition, ah, just the

Speaker:

prince Charles hospital in Queensland.

Speaker:

Get an upgrade to the king Charles hospital.

Speaker:

that's what I wanna know.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Good point.

Speaker:

Maybe it does.

Speaker:

in the show notes for the patrons will be links to a thing about the palace letters.

Speaker:

So these were letters between, the, governor general, sir, John Kerr and,

Speaker:

queen Elizabeth through her private secretary at Martin charters around the

Speaker:

time of the 1975 constitutional crisis.

Speaker:

And.

Speaker:

queen Elizabeth tried hard actually to have those kept hidden, kept

Speaker:

secret saying they were private.

Speaker:

And Jenny Hawking had to go to the high court to get them revealed.

Speaker:

And it did show a high level of communication between, John Kerr

Speaker:

and prince Charles and the queen, basically indicating that they

Speaker:

knew what he was about to do and didn't do anything to stop it.

Speaker:

So if you're looking for a black mark against the queen, you could

Speaker:

head towards those palace letters.

Speaker:

You know, I actually read the sections they were talking about in the letters,

Speaker:

kind of wasn't as compelling as what the commentators were saying to some extent.

Speaker:

So there's a whole book about it that I haven't read.

Speaker:

but some people have said, oh, this is complete proof that, the queen knew what

Speaker:

was happening and did nothing about it.

Speaker:

And maybe it is, but just.

Speaker:

The bits that I read, not quite as compelling at first blush, when

Speaker:

you read it, maybe the book makes a better case than, than that.

Speaker:

I dunno, exactly was always 2020 anyway.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm and I've just been too sick to get into the weeds on that one.

Speaker:

So there is the area for people who really wanna complain about maybe

Speaker:

something the queen did, the palace letters, there's a bit of smoke

Speaker:

there, maybe there's fire as well.

Speaker:

saw this tweet, which said, please be respectful when talking about

Speaker:

the queen, she was ahead of state a Monarch, a mother to multiple

Speaker:

pedophiles, and most importantly, a devoted cousin to her husband.

Speaker:

So the cousin to her husband vet was the vet that got me.

Speaker:

so they were related.

Speaker:

Were they cousins?

Speaker:

Well, Prince Phillip, third cousins.

Speaker:

They were third cousins.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So prince Phillip was related to queen Victoria, as a great, great

Speaker:

grandson through his maternal side.

Speaker:

And queen Elizabeth was related to the same queen Victoria

Speaker:

through her paternal family.

Speaker:

So I had the same great, great, grandmother, which

Speaker:

makes them third cousins.

Speaker:

And Joe, I know what everyone's thinking.

Speaker:

How does that third cousin once removed type stuff, actually work,

Speaker:

keep hearing it all the time.

Speaker:

And are you up to, up to speed with all that?

Speaker:

I, I worked, trying to figure out family links a while back with my

Speaker:

second cousins and whether yes, they were multiple removed and who was what?

Speaker:

I actually looked it up.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

But yeah, it's, it's not obvious.

Speaker:

So do you listener first cousins share a grandparent.

Speaker:

Second cousins share a great grandparent.

Speaker:

Third cousins share a great, great grandparent and fourth cousins share

Speaker:

a, great, great, great grandparent.

Speaker:

So what you gotta do is count how many greats are in your common

Speaker:

ancestor and add one to find out what number cousin your relative is.

Speaker:

That's the easiest way.

Speaker:

And then the other issue is what does it mean when you say once removed?

Speaker:

And, the answer to that is think of it this way.

Speaker:

Your parents, first, second, and third cousins are also your first, second

Speaker:

and third cousins, but once removed that is because your parents and

Speaker:

their generation are one above yours.

Speaker:

So it basically takes into account where there's a generational difference.

Speaker:

So.

Speaker:

You might, share the same great, great grandparent.

Speaker:

And for the other person, it is just a great grandparent.

Speaker:

So your cousins, but it's a once removed situation.

Speaker:

So the once removed takes into account a generational difference

Speaker:

between you and the other person once removed twice removed, et cetera.

Speaker:

So, so anyway, they were, the queen and prince Phillip third cousins

Speaker:

and not removed at all because they were at the same generational level.

Speaker:

So I guess, his parents, for example, would've been her

Speaker:

third cousin once removed.

Speaker:

There you go.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

what else have we got here?

Speaker:

Funeral event itself?

Speaker:

I quite enjoyed it, Joe actual funeral in the chat room to enjoy the funeral.

Speaker:

I mean, PO ceremony.

Speaker:

Also mentions to God.

Speaker:

I'm sure.

Speaker:

Well, this is, this is what I'm gonna get to, references to God in a funeral

Speaker:

are so depersonalizing, like a funeral should be about, the person who's died.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm stories about them and things like that for your average

Speaker:

person, Joe, for your commoner.

Speaker:

Like I hate going to funerals that are dominated by religion.

Speaker:

Not just because I disagree with religion, but because it takes up

Speaker:

time where people could have been talking about the deceased person.

Speaker:

And, I think though, in the case of the queen, this might

Speaker:

have been the rare occasion.

Speaker:

It was okay to have some religion because we've heard enough about her life.

Speaker:

I didn't really need to know any, this might have been the one

Speaker:

occasion where it was okay to do it.

Speaker:

because we just already, I, I was thinking Bron, she was head of the church.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

exactly.

Speaker:

She was head of the church references, unavoidable and where normally

Speaker:

at a funeral, I want to hear stories about the deceased things.

Speaker:

I didn't know, stories from their childhood or things that come

Speaker:

out where you think, oh man, I never knew that about then.

Speaker:

I didn't.

Speaker:

That's interesting.

Speaker:

I didn't really want any of that from the queen.

Speaker:

So the, the religious hymns and readings were not annoying in that sense of taking

Speaker:

time away from hearing about the deceased, but still Joe, the, just the, the readings

Speaker:

from the Bible are such nonsensical rubish that, that people are just a room full of

Speaker:

people just accepting and listening to.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Honestly, I was tempted to just start reading extracts from

Speaker:

the first Corinthians verse.

Speaker:

That was one of the first readings.

Speaker:

I, I can't go.

Speaker:

I can't go there.

Speaker:

What a bunch of just gobbledygook nonsense.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Mishmash of just rubbish.

Speaker:

I mean, it's like jazz singers doing this scat, like just

Speaker:

making up words D do to be duh.

Speaker:

they may as well be these things make no sense as you're reading king James Bible.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Oh, I dunno which one it was.

Speaker:

yeah, it just, accepted by the masses.

Speaker:

What can do, I, I understand that Chuck has actually made a sensible, speech.

Speaker:

England or Britain being a multicultural country.

Speaker:

And although he was head of the church, he wasn't just looking after the Christians.

Speaker:

He was, responsible for all faiths and those of no faith.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Charles was probably quite progressive on a bunch of things like that.

Speaker:

Well, I heard he had a bit of a fetish for, for Islam, but it could

Speaker:

do, I mean, he was a bit wacky, you know, years ago talking about how he

Speaker:

would talk to plants and things, but he was probably an environmentalist

Speaker:

ahead of his time to some extent.

Speaker:

So like, let's face it, he's got some weirds shit happening there,

Speaker:

but probably got some aggressive things happening as well.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

All sorts of just crazy stuff.

Speaker:

And I mean, having been brought up in.

Speaker:

A household and a lifestyle that he is, you know, you cut people some slack in

Speaker:

the way that I was giving, cutting some slack for, prince Philip earlier that

Speaker:

mm-hmm he's gonna say things that I gonna offend people because he's in a bubble

Speaker:

and he's got no idea of the outside world.

Speaker:

Charles is in a bubble.

Speaker:

Ah,

Speaker:

I mean full marks of the queen, I guess she was in that bubble as well,

Speaker:

but seemed to be relatively normal in many respects, full marks for that

Speaker:

enjoyed her dogs and her ponies and whatnot people who said that she was

Speaker:

incredibly up on current affairs.

Speaker:

If she had, she had weekly meetings with whoever was prime minister at the time.

Speaker:

And apparently she was across what was going on.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

Give occurred for that.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm yep.

Speaker:

My wife was worried.

Speaker:

She said, you look like to get on this podcast and just bagged the queen.

Speaker:

Are you.

Speaker:

No, I don't think I have.

Speaker:

I think I'm understanding.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And you're keeping me in line, Joe.

Speaker:

Just good.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I mean, I remember the queen mum, when she died mm-hmm and I, I think there were a

Speaker:

lot of people who didn't understand, but, during the second world war, the, the two

Speaker:

of them as in the queen mother and the king at the time, mm-hmm, had chosen to

Speaker:

remain in London to live with the people.

Speaker:

And she was regularly out with the victims of the blitz and it

Speaker:

was, they could have chosen to disappear off and hide away and they

Speaker:

it's that that's the unifying thing.

Speaker:

It's the, they may be.

Speaker:

Born rich and, and live a life of luxury, but they are still part of the country.

Speaker:

They still come and see us in, in hard times.

Speaker:

Mm yep.

Speaker:

If you see sparks of humanity like that, it goes a long way.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm bit like David Beckham stood in the queue and , didn't,

Speaker:

pull the VIP card and go through the VIP Q, but, went the hard way.

Speaker:

Stood there, 12 hours, whatever did hear that.

Speaker:

people have been selling tickets right.

Speaker:

To see the, the coffin.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

It hasn't come out that he did that.

Speaker:

So, no, no, not that he did that.

Speaker:

Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Because it was free.

Speaker:

Just queue up and go.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

People sold their ticket.

Speaker:

If they left the queue.

Speaker:

I know, but you could leave the queue and go and get a coffee or

Speaker:

go to the toilet or something.

Speaker:

And then come back into the queue.

Speaker:

There was some way of.

Speaker:

Right regulating that.

Speaker:

But I, I think people were just selling tickets online as a commercial venture.

Speaker:

Oh.

Speaker:

To people who thought they could buy a ticket, right?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

Scalping for a ticket.

Speaker:

Oh God.

Speaker:

That's probably true.

Speaker:

Did you hear what, Donald Trump said?

Speaker:

I heard something about how the queen had never been so amused by

Speaker:

him at some state dinner on what a great time she'd had or something.

Speaker:

No, that, wasn't the thing I was thinking of.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

I mean, that's, that sounds perfectly plausible.

Speaker:

But he looked at where Joe Biden was sitting in the, in the, in

Speaker:

the AEY or wherever it's called.

Speaker:

He was quite a way back.

Speaker:

Wasn't a front row seat by any means it was way back.

Speaker:

And, Trump said, you know, if I was still president.

Speaker:

They wouldn't have put me back there.

Speaker:

I would've been up the front.

Speaker:

So it's just, he saw that as a slight on America, which would never have happened.

Speaker:

Had he still been president, right.

Speaker:

Would've been seated in a far better position than what they gave Joe Biden.

Speaker:

He'd been choked out.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah, here it is.

Speaker:

so he's not allowed to tweet anymore.

Speaker:

So this must be on his Trump social.

Speaker:

He posted this truth, truth.

Speaker:

Social.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

So instead of tweeting you truth, you send truths, send truths.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So he truth.

Speaker:

This is what happened to America in just two short years, no respect.

Speaker:

It's a picture of Biden way down the back.

Speaker:

However, a good time for our president to get to know the leaders

Speaker:

of certain third world countries.

Speaker:

If I were president, they wouldn't have sat me back there and our country would

Speaker:

be much different than it is right now.

Speaker:

That's the hot take from , Donald Trump.

Speaker:

What an awful man.

Speaker:

What an awful man.

Speaker:

Well, everything's always about him, isn't it?

Speaker:

Yeah, indeed.

Speaker:

It is.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

And Joe, did you see the piece of paper that fell?

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

Oh, okay.

Speaker:

Well, I'll bring you up to speed on this one then.

Speaker:

So here we go.

Speaker:

So remember just blinking this over.

Speaker:

Yeah, it just, it's quick to remember how long.

Speaker:

So just during the middle of the ceremony, this Bishop dropped a piece

Speaker:

of paper and the paper then sitting on the floor and it's in the worst

Speaker:

possible spot for a piece of paper to sit because just the camera view of the

Speaker:

coffin and just slightly behind to the right is where this piece of paper is.

Speaker:

That's then just obsessed myself and my wife and probably 2 billion other

Speaker:

people watching the damn show going well, how's he gonna pick that up?

Speaker:

Like it was just a little bit too far.

Speaker:

You'd have to take.

Speaker:

A couple of steps forward to actually get to it.

Speaker:

And you're thinking, how are they gonna retrieve this paper?

Speaker:

And, oh my goodness.

Speaker:

And the, like, everything had been conducted with such military precision

Speaker:

and, and, yeah, one guy, basically, I dunno if he was a Bishop, but he

Speaker:

certainly had a Bishop's hat and the comments on Twitter were, well, he

Speaker:

couldn't move forward and pick it up being a Bishop, he had to move diagonally.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm is the problem.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So when can we start talking about a Republic?

Speaker:

How long have we got we've got our official morning period has ceased and,

Speaker:

the Royal family's got another seven days.

Speaker:

And really, I think what will have to happen is.

Speaker:

it's a bit like a shock doctrine.

Speaker:

You've just gotta wait for the moment when emotionally people will be

Speaker:

ready to discard the monarchy and it's just gonna take some incident

Speaker:

of some sort and then people need to sort of strike at that point.

Speaker:

So, cause it's just too much Goodwill at the moment.

Speaker:

I, I think Charles is probably the biggest risk.

Speaker:

I think if William gets in relatively soon, things will be shored up.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Because William is the child of St.

Speaker:

Diana.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

whereas Charles was tarred with being the bastard who did her in.

Speaker:

True.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So I, I, I think now is it now is gonna be the dip if it comes.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

It would, it would require some event of some sort, I think, to shift the

Speaker:

mood, cuz there's just a lot of positive vibe for the monarchy at the moment.

Speaker:

So the Republican movement may as well, just cool its heels for a while.

Speaker:

I think until something happens and be ready.

Speaker:

I don't know.

Speaker:

But certainly if you're listening to sky news, they're not ready for

Speaker:

a Republic, Joe, so you shut me.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

This is what you'll get.

Speaker:

If you're listening to sky news.

Speaker:

I'll tell you what if you're Frank about the historical record guys,

Speaker:

decolonization was a bigger disaster for so many countries around the world.

Speaker:

So much more bloodshed violence, all sorts of chaos and Michigan that, that

Speaker:

you know that the empire itself didn't cause, oh, I wanna talk about this as

Speaker:

well, because it drives me nuts that, we educate people that the empire was bad.

Speaker:

I'm all for it.

Speaker:

Let's start a new movement.

Speaker:

Bring back the British empire, bring it back.

Speaker:

You look at countries like Zimbabwe.

Speaker:

You look at countries, in Africa like Uganda, where they

Speaker:

decolonized, as James says.

Speaker:

Disastrous results.

Speaker:

You look at countries like India and Pakistan, which have

Speaker:

struggled since the colonial era.

Speaker:

It's fine.

Speaker:

That's though.

Speaker:

That's, it's fine to say there were bad things that happened.

Speaker:

Of course there were bad things that happened, but look at the rule of law,

Speaker:

the establishment of look at what's happening now of infrastructure and so

Speaker:

on, and look at the opposite that has happened since the British empire with,

Speaker:

through, with that road, the British empire was a great engine of civilization.

Speaker:

Absolutely.

Speaker:

If you look at other empires, if you look at other empires, the French, the

Speaker:

Belgians by God, all of these other countries, the Spanish, you know, no

Speaker:

other European power created so many successful successor states to the empire.

Speaker:

There we go.

Speaker:

That's that's what LL friend Rowan, deans up to.

Speaker:

So no many, no other empire created so many successful states,

Speaker:

but all the states have failed.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And you know, this argument, well, you know, Sure they went in and colonized, but

Speaker:

then they left and look what a mess was.

Speaker:

Look, what a mess happened when they left.

Speaker:

Well, gee, you know what, when you tear down all the institutions that were

Speaker:

there previously and then, put in your own and then leave leaving a vacuum,

Speaker:

and maybe you've also reconstructed some borderlines along the way.

Speaker:

of course you're gonna get a chaos afterwards.

Speaker:

That's, that's what happens when you come in completely dismantle

Speaker:

a society and, and then leave.

Speaker:

So, so anyway, that's, that's the conservative view over at, sky news

Speaker:

getting quite rabbit over there.

Speaker:

yeah, I, I think that's a valid question in terms of, do we.

Speaker:

Take a poll saying, do we replace the current system with something else?

Speaker:

And that's our straw poll and that's a, yes, we go ahead and then decide what

Speaker:

model of government it's going to be, or do we side the model of government

Speaker:

upfront and then take that to the people?

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

Because the problem last time was, yeah, people said, John Howard was being

Speaker:

cynical by putting too many options.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

but the question is, do we have a yes, no.

Speaker:

If you vote yes.

Speaker:

Does that mean you're painted into a corner with whatever

Speaker:

people decide afterwards?

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

And possibly get, you know, if, if, if the post monarchy system

Speaker:

is divided up 34, 33, 30 3%.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

Do you go with what 34% wanted.

Speaker:

Or do we say, right?

Speaker:

Not until we have a working model and we then take that to the pulse.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm, I've just lost faith in people's capacity to examine these things

Speaker:

rationally in any sense, Joe, like it just, it's all gonna be on emotion.

Speaker:

Isn't it?

Speaker:

Absolutely salesmanship of whoever's around at the time.

Speaker:

well of course we'll, we'll have so many millions back if we

Speaker:

leave, leave the Commonwealth.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And we won't have all those filthy foreigners coming over.

Speaker:

Oh, no way.

Speaker:

That was Brexit.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

well, I'm about done with the Queens funeral, I think.

Speaker:

and we're gonna keep this as a relatively short one about a week ago.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

We're gonna run through some other topics and and she's dead.

Speaker:

It's done and dusted.

Speaker:

I think the Republic will just have to let things cool down for a while.

Speaker:

Wait for.

Speaker:

Charles to make lots of mistakes potentially.

Speaker:

and wait for some trigger because there's a lot of good will for the

Speaker:

monarchy at the moment after all that that's gonna continue for a while.

Speaker:

So, alright.

Speaker:

Let's talk about some other things.

Speaker:

Joe, since we met KTOV died.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Any thoughts, feelings about goov the accidental bringer of democracy?

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

I, I hear that it was totally unplanned.

Speaker:

It just happened.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

All of the, Russia watches, all of the people paid lots of money,

Speaker:

to examine the Soviet union.

Speaker:

None of them predicted the breakdown of the Soviet union

Speaker:

in such a short period of time.

Speaker:

Nobody saw it coming.

Speaker:

Essentially.

Speaker:

I've heard that.

Speaker:

The problem was they had spies inside the Soviet system and the Soviets

Speaker:

themselves were lying to the poll bureau.

Speaker:

And, and so they were getting primary information that was going to the poll

Speaker:

bureau and they were believing it.

Speaker:

And they thought that the Russian economy was in a better state than it was.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Well, my understanding is that nobody knew that Goel would do what he was gonna do.

Speaker:

That any idea that he would do what he did, there's no way they would've made

Speaker:

him leader, but, he got through a system when nobody thought he was that sort of

Speaker:

character and had they had any idea that he was, he would never have made it.

Speaker:

So he was an accident of history in a sense go job.

Speaker:

So, unfortunately that just led to us corporate Raiders, and the mafia.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

basically.

Speaker:

Grabbing hold of that country, stripping the common wealth out of it.

Speaker:

And you get a cutin type character as a response.

Speaker:

Did you see the, who was the Russian opposition leader?

Speaker:

Noel nervous.

Speaker:

yeah.

Speaker:

Noel.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

his documentary, which was incredibly badly dubbed, but was quite interesting.

Speaker:

And effectively what he said was Putin was put in power by the mafia

Speaker:

as a puppet and learned to their cost that Putin wasn't actually a puppet.

Speaker:

He took power and then demanded huge amounts.

Speaker:

And I mean, I, I almost half of their wealth, I think, right.

Speaker:

For them to carry on.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

So it's, it's now a mafia run system where Putin is.

Speaker:

Hoarding huge amounts of wealth, right?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

If they thought he was gonna be a puppet, then they really got, well,

Speaker:

he was mind a functionary in the KGB.

Speaker:

But once a guy.

Speaker:

Well, and then he was in the mayor's office.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

He was involved in the war in Cheney though.

Speaker:

So I think he showed some tough policies there.

Speaker:

So, anyway,

Speaker:

it was unforeseen what Gobi child would do that then led to a stripping

Speaker:

of the common wealth within Russia and then a response like we've seen, he

Speaker:

was close to ELs and I did see that.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

And, he sold off all the state assets at bargain prices to his.

Speaker:

Political mates.

Speaker:

Hooton did.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Ah, dear, another Russian oil executive died, fell from, died in hospital.

Speaker:

Well, actually just outside of when he fell out the window.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So, yeah.

Speaker:

And he's the latest in a long line of, potential Putin

Speaker:

opponents who have met misfortune, falling out windows and whatnot.

Speaker:

The daughter of one of Putin's allies died and it was allegedly

Speaker:

some Ukrainian spy and people were laughing about, I can't remember.

Speaker:

There was something funny that, the FSB had claimed about this person.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

I can't remember it was a silly name or something.

Speaker:

There was, there was obviously no way they could have done it.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

So reveal mag OV He, fell from a window at a central clinical hospital, died

Speaker:

from his injuries that he sustained.

Speaker:

And, it wasn't immediately clear whether it was an accident suicide or caused by

Speaker:

foul play, but it did happen in, it did happen the day that, Putin visited him.

Speaker:

So anyway, and he had been outspoken against the war in Ukraine?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

A lot of things adding up there.

Speaker:

what else have we got here?

Speaker:

Biden gave a rally, which had a lot of fascist imagery in it.

Speaker:

A lot of red stuff behind a lot of military.

Speaker:

Trump is having a rallies lately and his supporters are holding up a single hand

Speaker:

and a finger in something that looks like it's an imitation of a Nazi style.

Speaker:

Salute is happening now regularly at Trump rallies.

Speaker:

So the United States continues to deteriorate, is in the EU is taking

Speaker:

140 billion worth of taxes, from energy companies and winful tax.

Speaker:

Yes, I think I did see that.

Speaker:

So, so they just took 'em off it and said, took it off them

Speaker:

and said, thanks very much.

Speaker:

I believe they're passing it back onto consumers, right?

Speaker:

Liz trust.

Speaker:

I mean, since we've been talking since last we spoke, Liz trust, I think is even.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think you as well.

Speaker:

Yeah, she wasn't a prime minister.

Speaker:

I mean, just, just another one of these Boris Johnson, Donald Trump, Scott

Speaker:

Morrison, people who shouldn't be in charge of a used car sales yard, let alone

Speaker:

a country, the caliber of people that is getting into the position of power.

Speaker:

It should be frightening to people.

Speaker:

and she's just another example of it.

Speaker:

And as a particular fascination with Margaret Thatcher and neoliberalism, so

Speaker:

UK fucked at the end of the day, like it's there bang you was a great woman.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Well, their removal from the EU, the difficulty in exporting stuff.

Speaker:

the power costs are leader.

Speaker:

Like Liz trusts.

Speaker:

They're just heading to rack and ruin.

Speaker:

And it's just gonna be a question of how long will it take, climate change

Speaker:

wise, Joe, we're seeing lots of stuff.

Speaker:

We've I think mentioned before, droughts in UK, France, parts of

Speaker:

Europe, the Midwest in America.

Speaker:

I was gonna say somewhere in America, they're finding bodies in a lake

Speaker:

that hasn't been it's it's down to 30% capacity, which hasn't been

Speaker:

since it was built in the seventies.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

And they keep finding bodies in there.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

As bits, dry out.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

Flooding in Pakistan.

Speaker:

like we are now seeing some enough events.

Speaker:

I think maybe climate change has reached, a bit like voluntary assisted dying,

Speaker:

managed to get through legislation.

Speaker:

When enough politicians had had real life experience of a

Speaker:

relative, it had a tough death.

Speaker:

They could go, oh, I understand this because it's happened to me or it's,

Speaker:

it's happened to somebody close to me and maybe with climate change, we're starting

Speaker:

to get to the point where, where our leaders are gonna know enough firsthand

Speaker:

experience of climate change events and massive sort of, climate events that,

Speaker:

and people will that they're, they'll be ready for voting for some change.

Speaker:

Maybe I, I dunno.

Speaker:

I, people have always had tough deaths.

Speaker:

It's not like suddenly dying became harder.

Speaker:

So I, I don't know that that was what changed it.

Speaker:

You don't think so.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm and with the climate change, they always, they, they just fall

Speaker:

back on the old, we've had hot spells before we've had droughts before.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm it, it's not till you, I mean, there was a, a graph I saw very recently,

Speaker:

which was the number of excessive heat days or something in California.

Speaker:

And you go back to the 1950s and there was one every two or three years,

Speaker:

and now there's 20 a year and you can see the increment through the years.

Speaker:

It's not that high temperatures have got any more high.

Speaker:

It's just the number of days where you have these extreme weather events

Speaker:

just becomes more and more each year.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm I think.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think the, and, and the same with Alania.

Speaker:

This is the, apparently there were three triple year S on record

Speaker:

mm-hmm and the last one was 74.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And we're ready for our third one now.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm yeah, just going back to though, we've always had tough deaths, just,

Speaker:

modern medical science, enabling people to hang on longer than, longer and

Speaker:

longer when they're in a bad state.

Speaker:

I think that's a relatively recent sort of thing that.

Speaker:

I, I also think we've become less used to death.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

yeah.

Speaker:

Historically you'd have lost a sibling or you'd lost.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I, I remember at school, one of my classmates died of leukemia.

Speaker:

I, I think we are much more shielded from death than historically.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

So I think, we've been shielded from the climate through air conditioning

Speaker:

and through, other mechanisms of civilization, but there's gonna be some

Speaker:

events coming up soon and are happening now that I think that's starting to

Speaker:

turn people around, but we'll see.

Speaker:

I, I did see the second, passive house is being built up

Speaker:

Toowoomba and that is a building.

Speaker:

It's a European building standard where effectively, I think they said.

Speaker:

The whole house can be called with four kilowatts of air conditioning, right?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

it's just building to proper standards rather than, I mean, I was shocked when

Speaker:

I moved over here about how lightweight building is compared to Europe.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

I, I say to people like coldest winter you'll ever spend is in a worker's cottage

Speaker:

in Brisbane, in the middle of winter.

Speaker:

Cause the wind just rattle through in the chat room, noisy, Andrew says, did

Speaker:

Bob Polk not have a drug affected son?

Speaker:

And that's why Australia got at least harmed drug policy

Speaker:

rather than zero tolerance.

Speaker:

Maybe not sure.

Speaker:

So, a noisy, Andrew also says I've us mates who swears that

Speaker:

the us civil law is not over.

Speaker:

That's true.

Speaker:

They're heading for one, Botley the wizard also the amazing Aboriginal actor

Speaker:

died, but Queenie drowned that out.

Speaker:

No respect.

Speaker:

That's true.

Speaker:

Lots of other news has been completely drowned out and

Speaker:

we're guilty of that as well.

Speaker:

I guess in my defense, I've been really sick and I'm gonna call a time on this

Speaker:

podcast earlier in the normal cuz.

Speaker:

I'm still not quite a hundred percent as you can probably tell.

Speaker:

and Braman had said you wait Trevor, it's not over yet.

Speaker:

The coronation is next year coronation next year.

Speaker:

Is that for prince Charles?

Speaker:

Would that be, they would be for Charles.

Speaker:

So do they wait that long?

Speaker:

Do they?

Speaker:

probably right.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

All right.

Speaker:

Ah, look, there's lots of things on the list there, but I'm gonna call it

Speaker:

a quick one cuz I'm still scrambled in my head and I can tell that we are

Speaker:

just all over the shop on this podcast.

Speaker:

, but I think I'll be back to a hundred percent next week and we'll

Speaker:

see what we'll come up with then.

Speaker:

So sorry for this short abrupt end, but I'm done.

Speaker:

signing out.

Speaker:

Talk to you next week.

Speaker:

Have some rub that'll help.

Speaker:

Yeah, I'll do that.

Speaker:

Bye now.

Speaker:

Bye.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube