Unlock real podcast progress by defining clear results, not chasing someone else’s idea of “success.”

If your podcast leaves you discouraged, you might have unspoken, undefined expectations dragging you down.

Most podcasters judge their show by downloads, growth, or what the loudest voices online claim “working” should look like.

But unclear, unrealistic expectations are what create discouragement—not the results themselves.

Let’s break it down.

You need expected results that align with your podcast’s "why."

Here’s the approach I use with my clients:

• Human Results: Are listeners emailing, commenting, or mentioning the show on calls?
• Business Results: Are right-fit clients mentioning your podcast when they sign up, or is the show shortening the time from new listener to new client?
• Metric Results: Are downloads and listener retention growing steadily—not explosively, but enough to show forward motion?

Define what “working” actually means for you—not for everyone else.

Set one or two concrete expectations for each area, rooted in your why and your business strategy.

Examples:

• Human: Aim for one meaningful listener message each month.
• Business: Aim for a small but growing percentage of new clients to say “I found you through the podcast.”
• Metrics: Look for steady but modest growth.

You don’t need a 50-point dashboard—just a handful of honest, reasonable expectations.

Choose one primary result to measure for the next 90 days.

Let it be your focus this season.

Are your expectations supporting your Podcast Why, or are they silently telling you nothing you do is ever enough?

Define aligned results, and you’ll regain clarity and confidence on your own terms.

Here are three key takeaways:

• Define your own milestones: Don’t default to what “success” online looks like. Identify results that match your why and strategy.
• Track Human, Business, and Metric Results: Look for real listener impact (messages, feedback), tangible business shifts (clients referencing your show), and steady, realistic growth—not just viral spikes.
• Let one metric lead for a season: Choose a result that best aligns with your mission and let it guide your focus for the next 90 days.

You can book a clarity call with me—just head over to My Podcast Guy and look for the Book A Clarity Call link. We’ll talk through where you’re stuck, what your real why might be, and how to build your podcast around it.

Connect with me on LinkedIn

Recorded at 511 Studios - Columbus, OH (and you can too!)

Subscribe to get my latest content in My Podcast Guy Newsletter

Podcasting is a MARATHON, not a sprint. Be patient, take action, and apply yourself.

Let’s talk about what podcasting can do for your business in the next 12-months. Whether you’re B2C or B2B, we can create a content marketing strategy that will work for you.

Connect with me if you would like to talk more about this. My calendar is available on my Circle 270 Media® Podcast Consultants business website.

Brett Johnson is the owner and lead consultant at Circle 270 Media® Podcast Consultants. With over 35+ years of experience in Marketing, Content Creation, Audio Production/Recording, and Broadcasting, the podcast consultants at Circle 270 Media® strategically bring these strengths together for their business Podcast clients.

Email us at podcasts@circle270media.com to set up a time to talk more about your new or established business podcast.

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/4.0/

Copyright 2026 My Podcast Guy

Defining the results you expect from your podcast. Welcome back to The Podcast Why. I'm Brett Johnson, My Podcast Guy, your trusted friend in podcasting. This show is here to help you reconnect with the real why behind your podcast so you can keep showing up with clarity and confidence. We're walking through five components of your strong why this season. Your podcast description, your podcast purpose, how your show ties into your business and marketing strategy, the expected results you're looking for, and your approach to creating the show today is about that fourth component, the expected results you're looking for from your podcast. This is where a lot of frustration and discouragement live. Many podcasters have unspoken expectations.

Downloads will grow at a certain rate, clients will start flowing in, and opportunities will appear. When those expectations don't match reality, it's easy to feel like the show isn't working. The problem is not having expectations. The problem is having undefined and unrealistic ones that don't match your why or your strategy. Your why is your compass, but your expected results are like the milestones on a map. If you don't consciously choose them, you'll default to whatever the loudest voices online say, quote, unquote success should look like. In this episode, I want to help you define what working actually means for your podcast in a way that supports your why instead of constantly undermining it. Here's a composite story drawn from many client calls.

Imagine a host. We're going to call him Leo. Leo runs a podcast tied to his coaching business. His why is solid. He wants to help a certain kind of person break out of stuck patterns and pursue a more intentional life. His podcast's purpose is clear, and his episodes are pretty thoughtful. But every time we talk, he says some version of I don't know if the show is working. When I ask him what working means, he shrugs and says, I thought I'd have more downloads by now.

Or I see other shows posting big numbers. Maybe mine just isn't landing. So we slow down and I ask, what results are you actually expecting from this podcast? At first, his answers are vague. Growth, more leads, more visibility. Then I ask, okay, but what would that look like in the real world? How would you know? He realizes he never actually defined it. He's chasing a feeling bigger, more, without any clear markers. We go back to his why and his business strategy. His podcast role is to build trust and give potential clients a sense of how he thinks and works.

So we start to define results. In that Context, we identify three types of results. 1. Human results what's happening for listeners? Are they emailing? Commenting? Mentioning the show on calls? Are you hearing stories that match your why? Two Business results are right Fit clients mentioning the podcast when they book Is the show shortening the time from I just found you to I'm ready to work with you? 3 metric results downloads, Listener retention Basic growth over time. Not as a verdict, but as feedback. We set reasonable expectations in each area based on his current stage and niche. For example, human Aim to get one meaningful listener message a month that shows the show is helping business. Aim for a small but growing percentage of new clients to say I found you through the podcast or I binged your episodes before reaching out.

Metrics Aim for steady modest growth over a quarter, not explosive viral spikes. Once we did that, Leo's relationship with his show shifted. Instead of constantly thinking it's not working, he could say, okay, in the last three months, I've had three sincere emails from exactly the kind of person I want to help and two new clients mentioned my podcast. My downloads are growing slowly but steadily. By my own definition, this is working. He didn't stop caring about numbers, he just stopped letting the undefined expectations crush the progress he was actually making. Let's talk about your expected results. You don't need a 50 line KPI dashboard.

You just need a small set of clear, honest expectations that match your why and your stage. Here's a simple way to start that Step one Write down your why and your podcast role in your business in one or two sentences each. This is your context. Step two Underneath, create three headings Human Results that's Listener Impact Business Results how it supports your work Metric results downloads, growth, etc. Under each heading, ask yourself in the next three to six months, what would working look like in this category? Be concrete examples would be in the human category, at least one personal note from a listener every month, or listeners mentioning specific episodes. Back to me in the business category, a few discovery calls where people could say they've been listening for a while or My best fit clients are nearly always podcast listeners in the metrics column. Slow, consistent growth or holding steady while I improve my clarity and consistency. Now, here's today's Podcast why question Right now, are your expectations for your podcast supporting your why or silently telling you nothing you you're doing is enough? If you could choose just one result to measure for the next 90 days, which one would best reflect your real mission? Circle that one.

Let it be your primary focus for a season. Let the others be secondary for now. If you'd like help Defining realistic y aligned results for your podcast so you're not constantly disappointed by someone else's definition or success. That's exactly the sort of strategic conversation I have with podcasters. You can book a Clarity call with me. Just head over to My Podcast Guy online and look for Book A Clarity Call link. We'll line up your why, your business and your expectations so they stop biting each other. Thanks for listening to The Podcast Why. I'm Brett Johnson, My Podcast Guy, and I'll talk to you in the next episode.