Artwork for podcast Become A Calm Mama
The Screentime Dilemma
Episode 14317th October 2024 • Become A Calm Mama • Darlynn Childress
00:00:00 00:34:11

Share Episode

Shownotes

In this episode I'm talking about what I call the screentime dilemma - basically the overwhelm and frustration you feel around figuring out screens. I’m helping you understand why it feels so hard and why it actually falls outside of your wheelhouse as a parent. 

You’ll Learn:

  • Why figuring out screentime is so confusing
  • How screentime is following in the footsteps of driving, smoking and dietary recommendations
  • Current best practices for kids and screens
  • What I’d do about screens if I ran the government

With tech and screens, we’re all making it up as we go along. And - news flash! - it’s not working out very well. Listen to learn how to handle this confusing topic in your family.

-----------------------------------

There are a lot of areas of parenting where you know what’s best. Adults need about 8 hours of sleep every night. You shouldn’t eat a bunch of sugar at every meal. Your kid can’t drive until they have a license. For these things, there are laws or guidelines that give you a mental map for how things should go.

The Screentime Dilemma

In my opinion, screentime limits are a little above our pay grade as moms. It’s kinda the Wild West of parenting, because there aren’t a lot of guidelines or oversight. So, you have to be the sheriff in a house full of robbers that want it all the time. 

You don’t really know what the rules are supposed to be or how to enforce them. There’s no Surgeon General’s warning or food pyramid of screens. And you’re (probably) not an expert on childhood development and the human brain.

So we, as regular people, are left trying to figure out what’s normal and what’s best for our kids. No wonder you’re overwhelmed!

Guidelines in Our Society

In this little history lesson of rules and guidelines in our American society, you’ll see that when something new comes around, it takes almost an entire generation to set clear rules around it. And until the government realizes that something is causing a problem or that our kids need to be protected, we’re pretty much on our own.  

Here are a few examples…

Cars. The first car was invented by Carl Benz in 1886. It was 20 years before states slowly started to require a driver's license, and it was even longer before age restrictions came into play. It was 30 years before the first stop sign was installed and 66 years until the seat belt was created. 70 years after the first car, driver’s licenses were required nationwide in the United States.

In the beginning, there were no rules or restrictions, and now there are a lot. As a society, we agree that an 8-year-old shouldn’t drive a car. We’ve decided that somewhere around 16 or 17, people are mature enough to handle a vehicle, but we don’t yet know how old someone should be to handle the internet.

Food. Prior to the 1960s, most food was prepared at home with basic ingredients. After World War II ended, manufacturing shifted from creating machinery and supplies for the war to machinery for the home and agriculture. The way we processed, stored and distributed food changed. More cheap, processed foods solved the problem of there not being enough food to go around, but we also created poorer quality food in order to get it to more people. 

20 to 30 years later, the Surgeon General started to notice that nutrition and health were decreasing in our society, and chronic diseases were on the rise. Mandatory nutrition labeling on all packaged food went into effect in the 1990s, but a lot of consumers didn’t really know much about carbs, fiber, sugar or calories, so they created food guides.

When I was a kid, we had the 4 basic food groups as our guideline. Then came the pyramid, which was just confusing, and now we have the simplified “My Plate” model. The purpose of these is to help you, the consumer, make an informed decision about what food you are serving to yourself and your family. 

I think that this is what technology guidelines will ultimately look like - the “My Plate” of screentime. The government essentially says, “Here’s all the food at the market. You can have it all, but these are the best practices for your children.”

Smoking. The technology and agricultural revolution also made cigarettes easier to get, so more people started smoking. Again, the government started to see the impact on health in the form of a lung cancer epidemic. When the evidence became so clear it could not be ignored or denied, more rules came in.

First, we saw the Surgeon General’s warning published in 1964 and added to labels the following year. TV and radio advertising were banned and age limits were put into place. 

Screentime Best Practices

The Internet has been around for about 20 years now (more intensely since smartphones became common), and we’re starting to see that there is foundational harm to kids. They are deprived socially, sleep is impacted, attention is fragmented and it creates addictive tendencies. 

The good news is that answers are coming. The Surgeon General of the United States is creating recommendations, and we are moving towards having guidelines.

U.S. Surgeon General, Vivek Murthy, states, “The mental health crisis among young people is an emergency, and social media has emerged as an important contributor.” 

Until then, here are some best practices to help you decide how to handle screentime in your own home.

  • Wait Until 8th. No smartphone until 8th grade. I would take this a step further and say no personal devices of any kind, including iPads, etc.
  • No social media until age 16. 
  • No screens before school. This will help your morning routine go more smoothly and help your kid be in their body before they go sit in a classroom.
  • On school days, I recommend no screentime. If you decide to give some, wait at least an hour after they’ve been home. 
  • Collaborative or social viewing. Rather than each kid being on their own device, learning to compromise and watch or play something together creates a shared experience. 
  • Challenge social norms. If our schools and communities could come together on some of these commitments, we could normalize more responsible screen use.
  • Demand government action. So much of the change we need will have to come from regulation or changes on a government or platform level. 

Out here in the Wild West, you get to decide and you get to enforce those limits. Your kids hate limits, but deep down, they love them. Rules make us feel safe. Think about your own rules and what works for you. 

I hope you walk away from this episode feeling a little better about yourself. You’re not a failure as a parent because you struggle with screens. In fact, you’re a trailblazer - a 1st generation parent in this new tech environment. 

Imagine me giving you a big hug (‘cause this shit is hard) and a pat on the back. You’re doing great, Mama!

Resources:

Get your copy of the Stop Yelling Cheat Sheet!

In this free guide you’ll discover:

✨ A simple tool to stop yelling once you’ve started (This one thing will get you calm.)

✨ 40 things to do instead of yelling. (You only need to pick one!)

✨ Exactly why you yell. (And how to stop yourself from starting.)

✨A script to say to your kids when you yell. (So they don't follow you around!)

Download the Stop Yelling Cheat Sheet here

Connect With Darlynn: 

Transcripts

Speaker:

Welcome back to become a calm mama. I'm your host. I'm Darlyn Childress,

Speaker:

and on this episode I'm going to talk about what

Speaker:

I'm calling the screen time dilemma. It's essentially

Speaker:

the conflict or the overwhelm or the frustration

Speaker:

you have as a parent when trying to figure out screen time limits.

Speaker:

I'm gonna normalize that and help you understand

Speaker:

why it's so hard and also why maybe this is,

Speaker:

like, outside of your wheelhouse as a parent. I

Speaker:

kinda say sometimes, like, screen time limits are a little bit

Speaker:

above our pay grade as a parent because, really,

Speaker:

screen time is sort of the Wild West of parenting where there's not

Speaker:

a lot of guidelines. There's not a lot of oversight. You're just

Speaker:

one sheriff in a house full of screen

Speaker:

robbers, and they want it all the time. And you don't really even know what

Speaker:

the rules are or how to enforce them. And I wanna give you some perspective

Speaker:

on why that is and give you some, like, a little tiny bit

Speaker:

of history about how rules and limits and

Speaker:

governments establish guidelines and kind

Speaker:

of explain to you that when it comes to screens,

Speaker:

this technology of devices for you and

Speaker:

your family, The reason why it's so overwhelming and so

Speaker:

confusing is because there are not guidelines

Speaker:

yet. There is no license. There's no

Speaker:

surgeon general's warning. There's not a, you know, a

Speaker:

pamphlet, a food guide pyramid, if you will, or a my

Speaker:

basic four food groups of how to manage screens

Speaker:

for families. Because there aren't those

Speaker:

guidelines yet that are out there,

Speaker:

you are trying to figure it out all the time. What's

Speaker:

normal? What's best? What's too much time? What's not enough

Speaker:

time? What are the benefits of screen time? How much should my kid get?

Speaker:

What devices? Is YouTube kids okay? Is YouTube okay?

Speaker:

Should they have a phone? What age? Is it 10? Is it 12? You are

Speaker:

making all of these decisions that are extremely

Speaker:

challenging to figure out because you're not an expert

Speaker:

on the brain, on child development, on the

Speaker:

ways that algorithms work around AI. Right? You're just a regular

Speaker:

person trying to figure it out. That is why it's

Speaker:

so overwhelming. I wanna go through and give you some background, like,

Speaker:

almost like a little history lesson about a couple of different topics,

Speaker:

like, how driver's license were created, how nutrition

Speaker:

facts and food guidelines were created, and how, you know,

Speaker:

smoking guidelines were created. Because I want you to see

Speaker:

that whenever a new tech comes in, whenever

Speaker:

something hits the streets, right, it

Speaker:

takes almost an entire generation. We're gonna see

Speaker:

until the government recognizes, oh, this is a

Speaker:

technology that's causing a problem. We probably need to

Speaker:

protect children. We probably need to give

Speaker:

the consumer more information. We might need

Speaker:

to add regulation to this product or to this

Speaker:

technology. And this has been true throughout time. So I'm

Speaker:

gonna give you a little background on a couple things. Hopefully, it won't be too

Speaker:

much of a history lesson. I hope to make it interesting. I used to teach

Speaker:

history. Did you know that? I was a middle school and high school teacher before

Speaker:

I was a parent and before I was a parenting coach. So I do like

Speaker:

to talk about history and put things in perspective. I think it's really helpful

Speaker:

to understand the way something has worked in the

Speaker:

past and, like, the process that we went through as a society

Speaker:

in the past and kind of apply that to today. Really, I want you to

Speaker:

understand that you are in the Wild West of parenting.

Speaker:

And for the most part, some other

Speaker:

areas of parenting, you kind of know what's best. Like, you

Speaker:

we've heard many times that 8 hours of sleep for

Speaker:

adults is really good. Right? And it's coming out that women need 8 and a

Speaker:

half. Right? And so we kind of have this idea. Like, we

Speaker:

know in general, you shouldn't have sugar at every meal,

Speaker:

and there's not kind of no balanced diet. Like, you should have fiber in your

Speaker:

diet, and you should have fruits and vegetables. Right? Lean meats.

Speaker:

You know, just because your kid wants to drive a car at age 12, they

Speaker:

can't because they need a driver's license. So there's a lot of things in

Speaker:

parenting that there are, like, there's a mental map for how it

Speaker:

should be. But when it comes to tech and to screens,

Speaker:

there's no social mental map.

Speaker:

We are all making it up as we go along.

Speaker:

And news flash, it's not working out very well. Okay? It's

Speaker:

hurting our children, As you know from my previous series in the

Speaker:

summer based on Jonathan Hite's book, Anxious Generation, and I

Speaker:

give you a lot of screen time practices in those episodes. So go

Speaker:

back if you're really, you know, wanting to dive deep into

Speaker:

whether the problems and all that, go back into those episodes and listen to them.

Speaker:

But today, I want you to walk away from this episode feeling

Speaker:

like an exhale, but really like a self esteem boost.

Speaker:

Like, I want you to be able to not feel like you

Speaker:

are a failure as a parent because you can't

Speaker:

get screen limits managed in your family or that your kids keep doing

Speaker:

sneaky screens or you break your own rules or whatever

Speaker:

it is. I don't want you to feel so bad. I want you to

Speaker:

understand, oh, I am a trailblazer.

Speaker:

I am a 1st generation parent parenting in

Speaker:

a tech environment. I am a vanguard.

Speaker:

Right? I'm at the forefront. The next few generations,

Speaker:

they're gonna have it easier. I'm figuring it out

Speaker:

without a guideline. And I want you to really kind of

Speaker:

give yourself, like, a pat on the back because I do deeply

Speaker:

believe that in the next 10 years, there are

Speaker:

going to be government guidelines and even regulations

Speaker:

about how tech is talked about and communicated to

Speaker:

children, what is allowed for children, and all of these things. So

Speaker:

in 10 years from now, that doesn't help you. Right? If you have a 4

Speaker:

year old and at 14, they come out with some guidelines and you're like, well,

Speaker:

I wish I would have known that at 4. I have 18 20 year olds.

Speaker:

I my kids are Gen z. This I was in the Wild West of parenting.

Speaker:

Like, I did not have an iPhone when they were born, and

Speaker:

then I had an iPhone. And so I'm figuring out the tech

Speaker:

alongside of figuring it out with them. I did my best. Right? As

Speaker:

you are. And so I wanted to normalize that you're in the Wild West of

Speaker:

parenting. You're doing your best. You don't have a social mental map. What's right?

Speaker:

What's wrong? What's good? What's bad? Best practices. So I will give

Speaker:

you some best practices at the end of this episode. But I wanted to go

Speaker:

through and talk about some of this history that I was talking

Speaker:

about. So first, I wanna start with cars, and I promise I won't get too

Speaker:

into the weeds on the details because, you know, historians love dates.

Speaker:

But I want you to see that the first

Speaker:

modern car, what we generally regard as the first

Speaker:

modern car was invented by Carl

Speaker:

Benz. Right? Like Mercedes Benz, kind of that Benz, b

Speaker:

e n z. And it was in 1886.

Speaker:

Okay? So just kind of like I don't even know. Was that a 150 years

Speaker:

ago ish? Right? So the first car kind of was registered.

Speaker:

The patent was registered. Over time, more people

Speaker:

got them because of the Model T with Henry Ford. Cars

Speaker:

started replacing horses and started replacing horse drawn

Speaker:

carriages. Now we did not need to create

Speaker:

rules for of who could ride a horse. We didn't have to

Speaker:

create licenses for who could own a

Speaker:

horse or drive a horse into town because they're they weren't

Speaker:

that unsafe. They weren't motorized. But then think about this,

Speaker:

that the first stop sign was not installed

Speaker:

until 1914 in Detroit. You have,

Speaker:

like, how many years is that? 14, 30 years ish

Speaker:

of cars on the roads

Speaker:

without stop signs. That was, like, kind of the beginning. It took a long

Speaker:

time before some city, the city of Detroit is, like, we put a stop

Speaker:

sign here and, like, make there be some sort of traffic pattern

Speaker:

or regulation. The government of Detroit, right,

Speaker:

the city does not get involved for a long time because they don't even know

Speaker:

the problems that are gonna be created. The first car that had a seat belt,

Speaker:

1950. We're talking 66 years later,

Speaker:

we create a seat belt. That's a long time to have a technology without a

Speaker:

safety mechanism. So the safety mechanisms were happening on the

Speaker:

car, right, like, and some things in the city. And then over time, it was

Speaker:

decided that maybe we needed driver's licenses. About 20 years

Speaker:

after the car was invented, we start to see

Speaker:

driver's licenses. The first was in New York, then Massachusetts,

Speaker:

and then slowly over time, you know, more and more states create

Speaker:

driver's license. 20 years of having cars before we have a driver's

Speaker:

license. It wasn't until the 19 fifties

Speaker:

until all states had a driver's license

Speaker:

system. So you have vehicles

Speaker:

for 70 years before the

Speaker:

entire, you know, United States has driver's license. If you're

Speaker:

listening in other countries, I don't really know the statistics of other countries.

Speaker:

When did we decide that children shouldn't get

Speaker:

their driver's license? When was that established?

Speaker:

And it was in Pennsylvania was the first state that said

Speaker:

drivers needed to be at least 18 years old. So

Speaker:

now you start to see 30 years after the car is invented, there's some

Speaker:

rules around when children should be able to get a driver's

Speaker:

license. Start to really think about 30 years, an

Speaker:

entire generation of children

Speaker:

probably trying to drive cars, which is kind of like what we're

Speaker:

experiencing is like children trying to navigate screen

Speaker:

rules for themselves. It's not

Speaker:

possible. We don't want children driving cars nor do we really want children

Speaker:

driving the Internet. But we don't have any rules yet about it. It

Speaker:

wasn't until 1966 that

Speaker:

the federal government of the United States created the

Speaker:

National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act. That was

Speaker:

78 years after the car was

Speaker:

patented. 78 years. That's an

Speaker:

entire lifetime. Right? That's 3 generations before

Speaker:

we have really strong regulatory rules. I thought this was kind of

Speaker:

funny. In California, the, they created a little

Speaker:

booklet of, like, rules for the road. And that

Speaker:

was like, a really, really thin booklet, and now it's a 1,000 pages.

Speaker:

So I think that we might have gone overboard on creating

Speaker:

rules. I'm not sure. I don't know. I've never read the

Speaker:

California vehicle code. But now we're like in this oh, I

Speaker:

mean, a lot of government regulations when it comes to driving. But my point is

Speaker:

that in the beginning, there were none. And now there's a lot.

Speaker:

So in the beginning, nobody knew who should drive. And how do

Speaker:

we prove that they can. And then eventually, it was like, oh,

Speaker:

we need a learner's permit. Oh, we need to, have them do a

Speaker:

written exam. Oh, we need to have them do a physical exam. There was, like,

Speaker:

more and more guidelines. That's my whole point. Okay?

Speaker:

Also, they changed the laws a lot of states from 18

Speaker:

to 15 or or 16 or 17. Different states have different

Speaker:

licensing agreements, but we all agree. Right? We all

Speaker:

agree 8 year old shouldn't drive cars. Right? We all

Speaker:

agree that you should be an adolescent before you even

Speaker:

get permission to be behind the wheel.

Speaker:

Now I know really rural places, those

Speaker:

rules are less applicable because people drive

Speaker:

farm trucks and things like that. Young people will participate in

Speaker:

the, like, homesteading and things like that. But we're talking

Speaker:

about for public safety, in general, what is

Speaker:

the best practices. And we've all decided

Speaker:

somewhere between 16 17, we think

Speaker:

that people are mature enough to handle a vehicle.

Speaker:

But we have no guidelines yet for how old someone

Speaker:

should be able to handle the Internet. I was talking to my

Speaker:

husband about this topic just a few minutes ago, and I was telling him

Speaker:

what I was gonna talk about. And I said, do you remember when I used

Speaker:

to tell the kids, like, they'd be like, mom, can I have a phone? Mom,

Speaker:

can I have a phone? And I'd be like, no. I'm not giving you

Speaker:

the www. And they'd be like, what? And

Speaker:

I'd be like, I'm not giving you the www. I'm not giving you the

Speaker:

World Wide Web. I said, we have the

Speaker:

entire world on the Internet. I'm not handing you the

Speaker:

world. You're not ready. You're not ready for the world. I would make it a

Speaker:

joke. Right? And I'd be like, you can't handle the world, the w w

Speaker:

w. But it is true. Do I think an 8 year old can

Speaker:

handle navigating the entire World Wide Web?

Speaker:

Nope. I do not. I do not think they should have unlimited access to

Speaker:

that. Now, a couple other examples I thought were kind

Speaker:

of interesting was one was around food. So

Speaker:

this could get it could bother people. I don't know. But in general,

Speaker:

prior to the 19 sixties, most

Speaker:

food was prepared at home with basic ingredients,

Speaker:

which means it was like whole food like butter or

Speaker:

wheat or, you know, sugar, but you could see how much you were pouring into

Speaker:

something. You had beef. You had chicken. You had eggs. Like,

Speaker:

you had the ingredients. You had the whole ingredients, and then you were preparing the

Speaker:

food. But after World War 2,

Speaker:

when there was all this revolution in terms of

Speaker:

creating technology for the war, basically,

Speaker:

for, you know, ammunition and I don't know all the words for

Speaker:

war stuff, but, like, you know, war stuff, airplanes and

Speaker:

bombers, and I don't know. A lot of technology was created in

Speaker:

order to create that machinery. And then

Speaker:

when the war was over, production shifted

Speaker:

to creating new types of machines

Speaker:

for home life. So that's when we started to see a washing machine

Speaker:

and refrigerator and refrigeration and, different things like

Speaker:

that. Not only did they create consumer goods, but

Speaker:

they also created a lot more machinery for agriculture.

Speaker:

This is the end of the history less than I promised. But there was a

Speaker:

revolution in agricultural technology and

Speaker:

food science was developed, advancements in food

Speaker:

science. So we had this technology being created

Speaker:

that increased the amount of food and

Speaker:

farming changed. How we produced food changed. How we

Speaker:

processed food, stored food, and distributed food.

Speaker:

Then there was also advancements in terms of freeze drying, juice

Speaker:

concentrates, artificial sweeteners, coloring agents, preservatives.

Speaker:

All these different things happened at the same time as the food

Speaker:

industrial revolution was happening. So all of a

Speaker:

sudden, there is a glut of

Speaker:

cheap processed foods on the market.

Speaker:

And we start to see that the processed foods

Speaker:

become common in the marketplace. Then

Speaker:

alongside of that, the surgeon general

Speaker:

starts to notice in the eighties, so, like, you know,

Speaker:

30 years later, they start to notice that we

Speaker:

as a society have decreased nutrition,

Speaker:

poor health, chronic diseases going up, and they're starting

Speaker:

to look at the diet of the American people and saying, hey, we might have

Speaker:

some problems here. We probably need to do some education.

Speaker:

Right? They don't really put any limitations on what can be allowed to be

Speaker:

produced. They don't. They don't create any guidelines

Speaker:

around what the producers can put out there. So you

Speaker:

can have, I mean, there's, like, titanium dioxide and

Speaker:

Skittles. Right? Like, there's not a lot of guidelines about what gets

Speaker:

put out, but there was a lot of consumer education

Speaker:

provided. So you had the FDA,

Speaker:

the Federal Drug Administration, or Food and Drug Administration

Speaker:

saying we need to have nutrition labels. That happened in 1990

Speaker:

that there was published proposed rules for the

Speaker:

mandatory nutrition labeling of almost all packaged food. That was so

Speaker:

that consumers could make good choices. But if you're a consumer

Speaker:

and you don't know what any of those things mean, you don't know what

Speaker:

carbohydrate is or fiber or sugar or calories.

Speaker:

That means we need to create education for the consumer. So that's when

Speaker:

you start to see food guides. Before World War 2, food

Speaker:

guides were created in order to make sure you got enough nutrition. They were

Speaker:

like, you need to make sure your children get enough calories. So they

Speaker:

started to tell people, hey. This is the bare minimum of what you need to

Speaker:

provide because there was a great depression. There was a dust bowl. There was all

Speaker:

these problems in our society where there wasn't enough food. Then slowly,

Speaker:

there's a lot of food. So the education shifts from

Speaker:

make sure your kids get these basic nutrients to actually make sure you

Speaker:

limit these other types of foods.

Speaker:

Let's make better food choices. So I

Speaker:

think it's fascinating that you can see and I'm not,

Speaker:

like, miss government regulation bring it all on. I'm

Speaker:

only wanting to point out that technology

Speaker:

comes out, and it has an effect on

Speaker:

society. And we don't always know what those effects

Speaker:

are gonna be. For 1, if you look at the food thing, you

Speaker:

don't have people starving. Amazing. Right? That's a good thing. We

Speaker:

wanna have a plethora of food. But we also created

Speaker:

poor quality food in order to get it to more people. And then

Speaker:

we had health. So then you need education and

Speaker:

then you start to see, like, when I was a kid, it was the 4

Speaker:

basic food groups. Right? And they were like, you have to have the 4 basic

Speaker:

food groups. And they were just a rectangle with 4 squares and that was what

Speaker:

you put on your plate. Then they created the food guide pyramid and it was

Speaker:

super confusing. Nobody really understood what it meant.

Speaker:

And now they have my plate, which is simplified

Speaker:

everything. So you see my that the government

Speaker:

is like, uh-oh. We probably need to give guidelines. And then as

Speaker:

the person in the home who is

Speaker:

purchasing food and preparing food and serving

Speaker:

food to your children and yourself, you can make an

Speaker:

informed decision. So you look at cars. You have an

Speaker:

the ability to make an informed decision about when your child should

Speaker:

drive. At the bare minimum, your kid cannot get their driver's

Speaker:

license or their permit until the certain age. 14,

Speaker:

15, 16, depends on the state. But around

Speaker:

adolescence, that is the rule. And it's

Speaker:

to protect the children and protect others

Speaker:

on the streets. With food, the government is like

Speaker:

here is all the food. You can have everything at the market. There it

Speaker:

is. And in general, this is the best

Speaker:

practices for your children. This is what they should make sure that they have

Speaker:

access to at each meal. So there's guidelines.

Speaker:

But we look at screen time and there are no

Speaker:

guidelines. You're making it up. You're like what is the food guide

Speaker:

pyramid version of tech screen

Speaker:

limits? What is my plate for my tech?

Speaker:

And there's no answer yet. Right? The good news is that

Speaker:

answers are coming, that the surgeon general of the United

Speaker:

States is creating recommendations,

Speaker:

and we are moving towards having

Speaker:

guidelines. Okay? The last one was smoking. I won't go too far into it

Speaker:

because it's so obvious, but I thought this was interesting that there was some

Speaker:

changes in the way that cigarettes were made, and it made it a

Speaker:

lot easier to get cigarettes. And that kind of was

Speaker:

part of the, you know, tech and agriculture revolution is

Speaker:

that you could, get packaged

Speaker:

cigarettes a lot easier. You didn't have to just get tobacco and get

Speaker:

paper and roll it yourself. That there was, like, almost, like, processed ready

Speaker:

made cigarettes, and then more people start smoking. The

Speaker:

government starts to see a lung cancer

Speaker:

epidemic. And, of course, the cigarette manufacturers are like, no.

Speaker:

We didn't cause these problems. That's not us. Who knows what's going

Speaker:

on? But over time, the evidence became something you cannot

Speaker:

ignore, and that's when you start to see rules.

Speaker:

You start to see that, like in 1964,

Speaker:

the surgeon general publishes smoking is bad for you. And

Speaker:

then they put a label within that year. They put a

Speaker:

label on the cigarettes, and then they just start

Speaker:

banning advertising on television and radio.

Speaker:

Then they start to establish a minimum age of legal access.

Speaker:

So at first, that legal access was and this was in

Speaker:

1920, by the way, that the legal access was 21 years

Speaker:

old. You could not get cigarettes a 100 years ago unless you were

Speaker:

21. Then it went down to 18. And now as of

Speaker:

2019, a 100 years later, it went back to 21.

Speaker:

President Trump signed that legislation when he was president in

Speaker:

2019. We see that we have

Speaker:

rules around when children can smoke, when children can drink,

Speaker:

when children can drive. We've given families,

Speaker:

parents guidelines of what are the best practices when it comes to feeding

Speaker:

your children. You know, in general, how much sleep they should get. Now,

Speaker:

here's the thing with the Internet. The Internet, I

Speaker:

thought this was so fascinating, came out in 1993. The

Speaker:

www became public. I graduated high school in

Speaker:

1993. So kind of my adult life, I've been,

Speaker:

like, learning about the Internet. Right? I've been but it's all been

Speaker:

in my adulthood. The Internet is a fairly new technology,

Speaker:

and then we don't have smartphones or handheld devices that

Speaker:

access the Internet until, like, 2008, 2009, 2010,

Speaker:

something like that. And they don't become ubiquitous for a while

Speaker:

being in everybody's hand. But now that it's

Speaker:

been 20 years or so, we can

Speaker:

start to see that there are foundational

Speaker:

harms on children when they have access to Internet

Speaker:

based activities. They are deprived socially.

Speaker:

Their sleep is impacted. Their attention is

Speaker:

fragmented and it creates addictive tendencies. This is from

Speaker:

Jonathan Haidt, the author of anxious generation. We

Speaker:

have quote from Vikvak Murthy who is

Speaker:

the Surgeon General of the United States. And he says, this is a

Speaker:

quote, the mental health crisis among young people is an emergency

Speaker:

and social media has emerged as an important contributor.

Speaker:

And he's mostly talking about adolescents. And he says a surgeon general's

Speaker:

warning label, which requires congressional action,

Speaker:

would regularly remind parents and adolescents that social media

Speaker:

has not proved safe. We

Speaker:

need more regulation when it comes

Speaker:

to technology in our children's hands. I actually

Speaker:

don't think a warning to protect

Speaker:

adolescents is enough. I think we need to go to younger ages and

Speaker:

create guidelines for younger ages

Speaker:

before they get to 14 or into adolescence.

Speaker:

So I have some best practices, which I do

Speaker:

talk about in my previous episode. But I think, in

Speaker:

general, no child should have a

Speaker:

smartphone or a handheld device until 8th grade.

Speaker:

There is a movement called wait until 8th. And if

Speaker:

we can get more and more people to commit just to say to their

Speaker:

friend group, hey, we're not gonna do devices until 8th grade.

Speaker:

That is a powerful statement, and it will be contagious.

Speaker:

You can influence the people around you by saying we are gonna

Speaker:

wait until 8th. No smartphone. And I'm gonna go further to say

Speaker:

no iPad. I think this is iPad is a cheat that a

Speaker:

lot of parents will use is they get an iPad and then the

Speaker:

kid has this handheld device with the iPad.

Speaker:

It's not maybe they're looking on Instagram because they're 7,

Speaker:

but they're getting accustomed to having an individual handheld device

Speaker:

at a young age that they think is theirs. No

Speaker:

devices. No no child should own a device. Be

Speaker:

honest with you, my kids each had back then, they were called

Speaker:

Itouches, and they were allowed to use those on car

Speaker:

rides longer than an hour and a half and airplane flights.

Speaker:

And that was it. So it was road trips and flying. And

Speaker:

then when we get to our destination on the vacation, they would get put away.

Speaker:

We actually would put them in the safe in the hotel safe or whatever because

Speaker:

I didn't want my kids on those devices, on, individual handheld

Speaker:

devices. Another really important guideline, no

Speaker:

social media until 16. I didn't do that.

Speaker:

I'd I don't know. I think my kids got

Speaker:

smartphones in 8th grade, and then I don't know. I just didn't even really know

Speaker:

how to put limitations on social media. But I think, you know, it's

Speaker:

really good recommendation. And if everybody does it,

Speaker:

then everybody does it. Just like you could let your

Speaker:

14 year old drive a car, but everyone would be like, you're crazy.

Speaker:

And you almost want to create that you're crazy to be like, you don't

Speaker:

let your kids go on social media. You're crazy. We wanna flip

Speaker:

that to be like, what? You let your kids go on social media? You're

Speaker:

crazy. Right? We kinda need to change our social

Speaker:

understanding of what's good and bad for kids.

Speaker:

Other, recommendations, no screens before school.

Speaker:

That is not a great time for kids to be watching TV or on devices.

Speaker:

Absolutely. They need to be getting ready for school so your morning routine

Speaker:

goes smoothly and kind of doing a little play, being in their body before

Speaker:

they go sit in a classroom. I would recommend no

Speaker:

screens on school days at all. But if you do, do them, wait for an

Speaker:

hour after they've been home from school before they get their device or get

Speaker:

to watch TV. I love collaborative or

Speaker:

social viewing or watching. So I would recommend having instead

Speaker:

of individual devices that kids learn to compromise to

Speaker:

sit in their living room, pick something to watch, pick something

Speaker:

to play, and, participate together and have

Speaker:

a mutual experience, a shared experience because that

Speaker:

creates a little bit more of that social cohesion and also compromise

Speaker:

and things like that taking turns. Making a commitment, I said that, like,

Speaker:

as a community, if schools could take on commitments,

Speaker:

principals and teachers really talking about this and and committing

Speaker:

as a school. Let's do screen for your weeks. You know, let's not do tech

Speaker:

in the morning. No children should have a phone before 8th grade. If we

Speaker:

had more social normalizing of that in our communities, that

Speaker:

would be great. And then we should be demanding government action. We

Speaker:

really should. And, I'm trying to think if there was one other one.

Speaker:

I can't remember. Okay. The other thing, like, I was,

Speaker:

like, writing if I was in charge of the government, what would I do?

Speaker:

I don't know. I'm not in charge of the government, but I was thinking we

Speaker:

should have universal hardware bans. So, really,

Speaker:

the technology available to kids in 8th grade, you can

Speaker:

do hardware bans where certain serial numbers

Speaker:

of devices are not allowed to download social

Speaker:

media. But the hardware bans only happen at the

Speaker:

platform level. Like, the Snapchat can do a hardware

Speaker:

ban on your phone. But not so it's not with your

Speaker:

IP address, not your Internet address. It's the actual serial number of the

Speaker:

hardware itself. When I learned that, I realized we could probably be

Speaker:

doing hardware specific for children

Speaker:

that you can't put, social media apps on there and

Speaker:

limit the ability for kids to circumvent family screen time

Speaker:

limits, you know, through your own, like, screen time app and the

Speaker:

aura and the eero and all those things. Really kind of

Speaker:

having it be like you purchase a kid friendly phone. Wouldn't

Speaker:

that be amazing? Because a lot of you want your kids to have

Speaker:

access to phones, but you know that they'll be able

Speaker:

to get on, like, you know, sneaky screens and stuff like that.

Speaker:

But if there was hardware bans, it would be helpful. I was thinking

Speaker:

about this. I was like, why don't we have an Internet license? Like,

Speaker:

you have to have a license to drive or an age limit for smoking.

Speaker:

Why do we not have an age limit for phones?

Speaker:

You can buy this phone once you've taken this class and you've

Speaker:

shown me that you know how to, like, I don't know, navigate bullying or I

Speaker:

don't know. I don't know what the rules would be. But I was like, why

Speaker:

don't we create an Internet license? I told you. I'm raking it

Speaker:

up. No screens or tech in schools. I don't know why it's

Speaker:

necessary for kids to have a Chromebook. The Chromebook is a huge problem for

Speaker:

parents. It's a big old issue at home to get them off of it. They

Speaker:

lie. They sneak. They tell us we have homework all the time. If you wanna

Speaker:

have device use in the school, have it in the school, but don't

Speaker:

put that on the family to also have device use. I know the

Speaker:

intention was to make sure that everybody had access to technology.

Speaker:

I love that making a more cool society and more

Speaker:

equitable access to tech. I get it. It is important,

Speaker:

and it's creating a lot of social harm. So I don't know

Speaker:

which is more important. We we kinda need to think about that. So getting rid

Speaker:

of Chromebooks or only having Chromebooks at school, something like

Speaker:

that. I was thinking maybe we have face ID,

Speaker:

right, to determine your age before you can launch YouTube or

Speaker:

Discord or TikTok or Snapchat or Instagram or whatever technology

Speaker:

is coming down the pike. There are better face

Speaker:

ID scans. I don't really love the idea of having children's faces

Speaker:

on the Internet. So I don't know. I don't know how to do it properly,

Speaker:

but I just was thinking it would be cool if you

Speaker:

could verify somebody's age through a verification

Speaker:

system that was kind of established. We need

Speaker:

a universal kids messaging app probably or something like that. If kids

Speaker:

are gonna have devices and they wanna talk to each other through devices, we

Speaker:

probably need to figure that out. Maybe that is on the television. So

Speaker:

it's kinda like old school. You know who they're talking to. You can

Speaker:

hear them talking. You can see that person's face.

Speaker:

It's I don't know. Some sort of messaging app or

Speaker:

some kind of way to communicate FaceTime, things like that. But in the

Speaker:

family environment, not on tiny little devices that are easy

Speaker:

to hide. And then, of course, I'm full favor of a

Speaker:

surgeon general warning, but not just on apps. I think we need a

Speaker:

surgeon general warning on the devices themselves.

Speaker:

Okay. This episode is to know is for you to know that

Speaker:

you are not alone If you're struggling

Speaker:

with screen limits and not knowing and feeling confused and

Speaker:

overwhelmed, I hope some of these suggestions I gave at the end

Speaker:

and, like, in previous episodes are helpful. But I also want

Speaker:

you to know you're in the Wild West of parenting. You are

Speaker:

a trail blazer when it comes to tech in in children,

Speaker:

and you're doing your best. And

Speaker:

I'm here to help guide you and create your family

Speaker:

limits. Find out what actually works for your family and what

Speaker:

you need. So that's some of the things we do in the Com Mama Club.

Speaker:

You know, we talk about we talk about screens a lot. We talk about homework.

Speaker:

We talk about chores. We talk about tidying up. We talk about bedtime.

Speaker:

We talk about all the basics, right, that families struggle with in

Speaker:

their homes. And, of course, screen screen limits. This is

Speaker:

new generationally, and it's a challenge. And I

Speaker:

I just wanna give you, like, I wanna give you a hug because

Speaker:

it's so hard. And I also wanna give you a an

Speaker:

attaboy. Right? Like, I wanna give you, like, a, you know, slap on the back.

Speaker:

Like, good job. You're doing great. And, and then, like, a

Speaker:

little, swat on the tush. Like, get back out there. You can do it.

Speaker:

So, apparently, I just wanna hug you and support

Speaker:

you. So think about your own rules and what works

Speaker:

for you. You're in the Wild West. So that means you get to make it

Speaker:

up and you get to decide and you get to enforce those limits. And remember,

Speaker:

your kids hate limits because people do, but deep down they love them.

Speaker:

I don't love a speed limit on

Speaker:

a freeway, but I also do like a speed limit. Because

Speaker:

when somebody goes really fast near me and they're going a 100 and I'm going,

Speaker:

you know, 70, I'm like, woah, they're going so fast. Jeez. They're

Speaker:

totally going past the speed limit. Like, it makes me feel unsafe.

Speaker:

So I like speed limits. I like rules,

Speaker:

because it helps us all kind of trust each other a

Speaker:

little bit more, and we know that we're healthy and

Speaker:

thriving as a society. So don't

Speaker:

be afraid to put those rules in place, mama. You've got it. And if

Speaker:

you need any help, I'm here. Reach out. Book a consult with me. Free

Speaker:

discovery consultation or just join the comm mama

Speaker:

club. $30 a month. You can join anytime. Show up at a Tuesday

Speaker:

call, and I'll get right into coaching you. Alright.

Speaker:

Greetings from the Wild West, and I will see you next time.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube