Artwork for podcast Becoming Natural
Natural Bug Spray: Practical Ways to Protect Your Family
Episode 822nd July 2026 • Becoming Natural • Penelope Sampler
00:00:00 00:43:48

Share Episode

Shownotes

Natural Bug Spray can protect your family when you choose EPA-registered plant-based actives and apply them on schedule.

Read the full episode + resources here: https://becomingnatural.com/natural-bug-spray/

In this episode of Becoming Natural, we walk through which repellents have real evidence, how to use them safely on kids and adults, and when picaridin may be the wiser choice for tick country. If bite season has you reading every label in the aisle, this conversation is for you — you want protection without dousing your family in harsh chemicals, but the word natural on a bottle does not tell you much on its own.

This episode also explores:

• How oil of lemon eucalyptus with PMD performed in field trials against mosquitoes

• Why most spray failures are application failures, not product failures

• When picaridin or DEET may be the wise choice for travel or tick-heavy woods

• Why registered oil of lemon eucalyptus is not the same as essential oil from the wellness aisle

• CDC and EPA label cautions for children under three

A gentle reminder: this episode is educational and not medical advice — please check with your own provider before making changes, especially during pregnancy or nursing, with children, or if you take medications or manage a health condition.

Resources Mentioned:

Lemon Eucalyptus Insect Repellent

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B084TM6XT1?tag=becomingnat0d-20

Sawyer Repellent, 20% Picaridin

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002CMQJYU?tag=becomingnat0d-20

Some links may be affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only share resources that fit the Becoming Natural standard.

test

Transcripts

Speaker:

It was almost dark, and I was standing on the back step counting heads. Three kids, two cousins, one very determined dog, all of them barefoot in the grass because that is the wonderful law of summer. Somebody had a sparkler. Somebody else had a popsicle that was now mostly on his shirt. And over all of it, this thin, high buzzing I could feel more than hear — that little buzzing sound that means the mosquitoes have found the party and they are not leaving. And more alarming to me, they were coming for me, the mosquito magnet.

Speaker:

So I grabbed the spray bottle, the one with the green leaf on the label and the word "natural" in friendly cursive. I sprayed everybody down. We smelled like a lemon grove that had been through something all with sticky skin. And twenty minutes later my youngest came back up the steps with four fresh welts on one ankle, looking at me like I had let him down.

Speaker:

I stood there holding that bottle, and I had no idea if it worked. I bought it because the word on the front made me feel like a good mom. But I could not have told you what was inside it, whether the science was real, or whether I had just spent eleven dollars on lemon-scented hope and a prayer.

Speaker:

When it comes to bug spray, we're often told we have two choices: something that works or something that's natural. But what if that isn't the whole story? Today, we're separating the marketing from the science so you can protect your family with confidence.

Speaker:

Hey Becoming Natural friends... I'm here!

Speaker:

First, I owe you a huge apology. I know I missed a couple of episodes, and I never want to disappear without telling you why.

Speaker:

Believe me, it wasn't because I stopped working. If anything, I've been working more than ever.

Speaker:

When I started Becoming Natural, one of the things I loved most about podcasting was that I didn't have to spend my life on social media. I could pour my energy into researching, learning, and having conversations like this instead of wondering what I should post next. I'm not a fan, but the idea of having conversations with people who have common interests...thats interesting!

Speaker:

So over the last month or so that firm desire to remain off social media turned into a project that's much bigger than I ever imagined. It just keeps growing....in the best of ways.

Speaker:

I've been learning everything I can about search engines, and building smarter systems behind the scenes. Some days I felt like I was learning a new language. Other days I wondered what on earth I had gotten myself into. And somewhere along the way, my little "simplify my workflow" project became a full-time job.

Speaker:

The funny part? I started this because I wanted life to feel a little simpler.

Speaker:

Instead, it completely took over my life for the last month. My family can unfortunately vouch for that.

Speaker:

But I can finally see where all those late nights have been leading.

Speaker:

The changes I'm building aren't just helping me create show notes more effectively (the entire reason I started to investigate). They're helping me organize my research, answer the questions more people are asking, create resources I've wanted to make for years, and spend less time repeating the same work over and over again. And my laptop is getting completely organized in the process. All wins!

Speaker:

My hope is that all of this means I get to spend more time doing the part I love most—reading books and studying while sharing what I've learned with you—and less time buried in the behind-the-scenes admin details.

Speaker:

And here's the part I'm really excited about.

Speaker:

I think what I've been building may eventually help a lot of other people too. Maybe you're running a business. Maybe you're homeschooling. Maybe you're caring for aging parents or simply trying to keep your family organized. We all have those repetitive tasks that quietly steal hours from our week.

Speaker:

I've been trying to figure out how to give some of those hours back to you. Trust me, the hours are now measured in weeks....or months.

Speaker:

I'm not quite ready to pull back the curtain yet, but we're getting close, and I can't wait to share it with you.

Speaker:

For now, thank you for your patience... and thank you for giving me the grace to disappear for a couple of weeks while I studiously worked on something I never saw coming. I have had every gammut of emotion in the process, but holy hannah its coming together in amazing ways.

Speaker:

Now... let's dive into today's episode.

Speaker:

Today's episode is called "Natural Bug Spray: Practical Ways to Protect Your Family," and it came straight out of that moment on the back step — the gap between what a label promises and what actually keeps a bite off your kid's ankle and is safe for the long haul.

Speaker:

If you have ever stood in the bug-spray aisle holding two bottles, one that smells like a chemistry set and one that smells like a candle, and felt completely unqualified to choose — this one is for you. We're going to sort out which natural bug sprays have real evidence behind them, how they actually work on a mosquito, how to put them on your kids safely, and when the wiser, more loving choice is to reach for something stronger. No shaming the DEET, no worshiping the essential oil. Just clear, grounded help so you can walk outside this summer and feel like you've actually got your people covered.

Speaker:

Grab a chair, or your bug spray label, and settle in.

Speaker:

Let me start in the most ordinary place: the marketing. The word "natural" is not regulated the way you'd hope. It can mean a plant grew somewhere in the supply chain. It can mean almost nothing at all. So a bottle can say "natural" in big calm letters and still be a mystery on the inside.

Speaker:

That's the first knot we need to untie, because it's the reason so many of us feel stuck. We're not actually choosing between "safe and natural" on one side and "toxic and effective" on the other. That's the story the packaging tells, and it's a tidy story, but it's not how the science shakes out. The honest map is messier and, weirdly, more hopeful: some plant-based repellents genuinely work, some don't, and the difference between them is not how leafy the label looks. It's whether the active ingredient has been tested and registered.

Speaker:

Here's the piece that changed everything for me. In the United States, skin-applied insect repellents are regulated by the Environmental Protection Agency — the EPA. When a repellent is EPA-registered, it means the company handed over real data showing the product is both effective against mosquitoes or ticks and safe to use as directed. According to the CDC's mosquito-bite prevention guidance, the active ingredients with that kind of backing are DEET, picaridin, (pick-AIR-uh-din) IR3535, oil of lemon eucalyptus, para-menthane-diol, and a newer one called 2-undecanone.

Speaker:

Now notice something. Two of those are plant-derived. Oil of lemon eucalyptus comes from the lemon eucalyptus tree. And 2-undecanone is a naturally occurring compound found in several plants with a distinctive odor that insects dislike, but it is most famously associated with wild tomato plants. So this is the part that surprised me: you do not have to leave the world of EPA-tested protection to use something that comes from a plant. A natural bug spray and a proven bug spray are not opposites. They can be the same bottle.

Speaker:

The flip side is the part nobody loves to hear. The CDC is very direct about this: for the long list of unregistered "natural" repellents — citronella, cedar oil, geranium, peppermint, plain soybean oil, and yes, the pure essential oil version of lemon eucalyptus — the effectiveness simply is not known. Not "proven useless." Nobody has put most of them through the testing, so when you spray one on your four-year-old at dusk, you are running an experiment with no data and a kid as the test subject. gentle opinion here is that you can run your own experiment when most companies won't spend the money to test the effectiveness of essential oils for MANY things. The proof is in the pudding.

Speaker:

That distinction — registered and tested versus untested and hopeful — is the whole ballgame. Hold onto it, because it's about to make your decision in the aisle dramatically simpler.

Speaker:

Before there was a single bottle of DEET or a whole wall of sprays to make your eye balls float reading the labels, people still had to live with mosquitoes — and they were not helpless. They leaned on simple, practical strategies, and the striking thing is how many of them still make sense today. They wore loose, lightweight clothing to keep skin covered. They slept under mosquito nets. They gathered around smoky campfires, because the smoke muddled the signals a mosquito uses to find a body. And they learned to avoid marshy, standing-water areas and to head indoors around dawn and dusk, when the biting is at its worst.

Speaker:

They also reached for plants. Across a lot of cultures, people used aromatic herbs — rosemary, sage, lavender, basil, citronella, cedar — often crushing or burning the leaves to release the natural oils into the air. Some rubbed plant oils, or even animal fat, onto the skin to help mask the human scent a mosquito is hunting for. And a handful of those plant oils — citronella, lemon eucalyptus, catnip, clove, thyme — have shown some genuine repellent effect in studies since then. The catch is the same one our great-grandmothers ran into without a lab to name it: most of them evaporate quickly, so the protection doesn't last long. Simply growing the plant isn't the same as releasing the protective oils hidden inside its leaves.

Speaker:

And that's the lesson sitting under all of it. Our ancestors never pinned their hopes on one magic solution. They layered simple habits together — cover up, clear the still water, mind the hours, use what the garden offered — and many of those same strategies are still some of the smartest first lines of defense we have. We're going to build on exactly that idea in a few minutes.

Speaker:

To understand why some sprays work, it helps to understand what we're actually up against. And I find this genuinely fascinating, in a "God built some wild little systems" kind of way.

Speaker:

A mosquito is not flying around looking at you. She — and it is always a she, only the females bite, because she needs the protein in your blood to make eggs — she's mostly reading the air. Think of it as a three-step process:

Speaker:

1. They detect carbon dioxide first

Speaker:

When you exhale, you create a plume of carbon dioxide that can travel 50 to 100 feet or more, depending on wind conditions. To a mosquito, that CO₂ plume is like a giant arrow saying:

Speaker:

"A warm-blooded animal is over here." They have specialized receptors on their antennae called maxillary palps that are incredibly sensitive to carbon dioxide.

Speaker:

2. They follow your scent

Speaker:

Once they get closer, they begin "smelling" your unique chemical signature.

Speaker:

They detect compounds like:

Speaker:

lactic acid (from sweat)

Speaker:

ammonia

Speaker:

carboxylic acids

Speaker:

acetone

Speaker:

other volatile organic compounds (VOCs) produced by your skin bacteria

Speaker:

Your skin microbiome plays a surprisingly large role in the scents you naturally emit.

Speaker:

3. They use heat and vision

Speaker:

When they're within a few feet, mosquitoes switch to:

Speaker:

body heat,

Speaker:

moisture,

Speaker:

and visual contrast.

Speaker:

They tend to notice dark clothing, movement, and warm skin.

Speaker:

It's like they use CO₂ as the GPS, body odor as the address, and heat as the final landing signal. More heat, more breath, more skin compounds, more invitation.

Speaker:

This is why some people get eaten alive, while their spouse sitting next to them gets one bite—or none. I like to think that Those of us that get bit the most are truly the sweetest :) And then there are those of us who lost the lottery twice in a row. Not only do we get the sacrificial sheer increased number of bites, but my bites turn into huge welts. I learned something today. The itchy bump isn't actually caused by the mosquito biting you—it's caused by your own immune system reacting to the mosquito's saliva. That saliva contains proteins that keep your blood from clotting while the mosquito feeds. Your body recognizes those proteins as foreign and releases histamine, creating the redness, swelling, and itch. So if you've ever wondered why your spouse barely notices a mosquito bite while you end up with a giant welt the size of a silver dollar, it isn't because the mosquito liked you more. It's because your immune system responded more dramatically.

Speaker:

So a mosquito finds you by smell, essentially. And that is exactly the door that repellents walk through. A repellent like oil of lemon eucalyptus doesn't poison the mosquito and it doesn't build a force field. It works at the level of her senses. The vapor coming off your treated skin scrambles and masks those homing signals. She either can't locate you clearly or she lands, gets a strong dose of something her receptors hate, and leaves before she bites. You become, for a few hours, hard to read and unpleasant to land on. That's the mechanism. It's not magic. It's called "running interference."

Speaker:

The active ingredient in oil of lemon eucalyptus that does this heavy lifting has a clunky name: para-menthane-3,8-diol, or PMD. According to the EPA's own biochemical fact sheet on it, PMD occurs naturally in the lemon eucalyptus plant, and it's actually structurally similar to menthol, which is part of why it has that cooling, sharp, botanical smell. Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus (OLE) is an insect repellent ingredient made from the leaves of the Eucalyptus citriodora tree.

Speaker:

The oil that comes right out of the tree isn't what repels mosquitoes the best.

Speaker:

Instead, manufacturers:

Speaker:

Steam-distill the leaves to obtain the essential oil.

Speaker:

Chemically process that oil.

Speaker:

Convert one of its natural compounds (citronella) into much larger amounts of PMD.

Speaker:

PMD is the ingredient that actually does most of the mosquito-repelling work.

Speaker:

Think of it like this:

Speaker:

Tree → Essential oil → Processed into Oil of Lemon Eucalyptus → High PMD content → Insect repellent

Speaker:

And this is the cleanest way I can draw the line for you between the two lemon-eucalyptus things that get confused constantly. Oil of lemon eucalyptus, the registered repellent built around PMD, is tested and it works. Pure lemon eucalyptus essential oil — the little amber bottle in the wellness aisle — is a different product, it's not the registered repellent, and it has not been shown to protect you. Same tree, maybe the same outcome. But one is not the other.

Speaker:

I don't want you taking my word for this, so let me hand you the actual research, because it's better than I expected.

Speaker:

There's a set of field trials documented in the National Institutes of Health's research library, done with real people getting real exposure in Guatemala and Peru. A plant-based repellent built on PMD from lemon eucalyptus was put up against DEET out in the field, where mosquitoes are thick and the stakes are high. In Guatemala, the PMD-based repellent gave better than 98 percent protection for five hours. In Peru, it held around 95 percent protection for six hours. And in both places it actually outperformed the DEET products it was tested against. That's not a candle. That's serious protection, from a plant-derived active.

Speaker:

There's also a careful study published in the journal Scientific Reports comparing PMD and DEET head to head. The short version: in the controlled lab setting DEET edged it out a little, but out in real outdoor conditions over about six hours, PMD and DEET performed similarly against biting mosquitoes. So the picture that emerges across the research is consistent and encouraging — oil of lemon eucalyptus, used correctly, lands in the same neighborhood as low-to-moderate DEET for everyday protection.

Speaker:

So when a tired mom asks me, "Does natural bug spray actually work?" the fair answer is: some do, and it has the data to prove it — oil of lemon eucalyptus, the EPA-registered kind built on PMD. The trouble was never that "natural can't work." The trouble was that we were grabbing the untested bottles and assuming they were all the same.

Speaker:

As an aside, Oil of lemon eucalyptus is not always the right tool for every situation. The research gets OLE closest to DEET is everyday, backyard, evening-on-the-patio mosquito protection. When you're talking about heavy tick country, or travel to places with malaria or dengue, den-gay the calculus changes, and we'll talk about that, because protecting your family requires a little education.

Speaker:

Most "the natural spray didn't work" stories are actually application stories. The product was fine. The way we used it let us down. So this section is the heart of the episode — the practical how, straight from the EPA's guidance on using repellents safely and effectively.

First:

read the label before you spray anything, and actually do what it says. I know, riveting. But the label tells you the concentration, how long that protection lasts, and how often to reapply, and those numbers are different for every product. The whole reason an EPA-registered product can promise a protection time is that someone tested it. When you ignore the label, you throw that testing away and you're back to guessing.

First:

While you're reading that label, glance at the concentration, because it changes how long you're covered. With oil of lemon eucalyptus, products tend to land somewhere around 30 percent of the active, and depending on the formula that buys you a few hours of solid protection — long enough for a cookout, maybe not long enough for an all-day festival without a reapply. Higher concentration generally means longer protection, not stronger protection, which is a distinction worth holding: you're buying more time, not more force field. So match the concentration to your outing. A quick walk to the park is a different job than six hours at the lake, and the label will tell you which product is built for which.

Second:

reapply on schedule, not on vibes. A lot of natural repellents, oil of lemon eucalyptus included, have a strong botanical smell that fades faster than the protection does — or sometimes faster than you'd like the protection to last. So we smell it wearing off and reapply, or we stop smelling it and assume we're fine. Go by the clock the label gives you, especially if your kids are sweating, swimming, or toweling off. Water and friction take it right off the skin.

Second:

The EPA's guidance is clear and practical here. For little ones, you spray the repellent onto your own hands first, and then you smooth it onto your child's face, carefully avoiding the eyes and mouth. Keep it off their hands, because those hands are going straight into their eyes and their snack.

Second:

And now the most important safety note, Oil of lemon eucalyptus and its active PMD are not proven safe for your littlest ones. The labels — and this is echoed in both the EPA and CDC guidance — say products with oil of lemon eucalyptus or PMD should not be used on children under three years old. The EPA's fact sheet on PMD even spells out the label caution about keeping it off the face and hands of small children. This is not because they have proven to cause harm, it is because there are not enough studies on young children. So that is a call for mom and dad.

Second:

I want to gently push back on the worry that reaching for picaridin or DEET makes you a worse, less natural mom. It can be a good choice in the right circumstance, and I want to free you from the guilt on this. Lets approach this logically.

Second:

DEET is a man-made chemical that confuses insects.

Second:

It doesn't actually kill mosquitoes or ticks. Instead, it makes it difficult for them to find you. Mosquitoes locate us by sensing the carbon dioxide we breathe out, our body heat, and the chemicals our skin gives off. DEET interferes with those signals, so it's almost like putting an invisible "Do Not Disturb" sign around your body.

Second:

If your body is a radio station broadcasting "Here's a human!", DEET scrambles the signal so the mosquito can't tune in.

Second:

DEET was developed by the U.S. military in the 1940s after soldiers needed better protection from insect-borne diseases during jungle warfare. Today, it's one of the most thoroughly studied insect repellents available.

Second:

DEET does act on insect nervous systems by disrupting how insects detect hosts. At the very high doses associated with accidental ingestion or improper use, DEET can also affect the human nervous system. Rare case reports have described seizures or other neurologic effects. This is where the Deet concern has entered the bug spray world.

Second:

Picaridin (pick-AIR-uh-din)is also a man-made insect repellent, but it was designed to imitate a natural defense chemical found in pepper plants.

Second:

Like DEET, it doesn't kill insects. It simply makes it harder for mosquitoes and ticks to recognize you as a meal.

Second:

Many people like picaridin because it:

Second:

Has very little odor.

Second:

Doesn't feel as oily on the skin.

Second:

Doesn't damage plastics, sunglasses, watch bands, or synthetic fabrics the way DEET can.

Second:

Provides protection that's often comparable to DEET against mosquitoes and ticks when used at similar recommended concentrations.

Second:

That distinction helps listeners understand why applying them correctly—and reapplying when needed—is important. The goal isn't to eliminate insects; it's to reduce the chance that they choose you.

Second:

They're recommended specifically because they protect against mosquitoes and ticks that carry real disease — West Nile, Lyme, and others that can genuinely hurt your family.

Second:

So think about it less like "natural versus chemical" and more like "right tool for the setting." A backyard cookout on a mild evening? Oil of lemon eucalyptus is a wonderful, evidence-backed choice. But a hike through tick-heavy woods, a camping trip, travel somewhere with mosquito-borne illness. That's when picaridin or DEET, applied carefully and by the label, is a protective decision. Choosing the stronger option in those moments isn't a failure. But stating the obvious. If you are hiking in the backwoods of Africa, or America, more than likely you are wearing loose long sleeves and pants. Spraying either spray on your clothes vs your skin provides the same invisibility and can be the safer option.

Second:

Bug spray, even a great one, is more than one layer. The families who get bitten the least are the ones who stack a few simple habits, so here's the fuller plan, and none of it is complicated.

Second:

Start with the yard, because some of the most effective mosquito control isn't found in a bottle at all — it's found in a five-minute walk around your yard after it rains. If a mosquito could design her dream neighborhood, it wouldn't be full of flowers. It would be full of standing water. The flowerpot saucer you forgot to empty. The bucket beside the shed. A birdbath that hasn't been refreshed in days. An old tire collecting rain. Clogged gutters after a storm. The kids' toys left upside down in the grass. Even a tarp with a little puddle sagging in the middle. A mosquito doesn't need a pond — many species can lay eggs in just a few tablespoons of water, so what looks like nothing to us becomes an entire nursery in under a week. And while you're walking, notice the shady, damp corners too: overgrown shrubs, thick ornamental grasses, dense ivy. Those cool hiding spots are where mosquitoes rest through the heat of the day before they come out to feed at dusk.

Second:

And then there are the gardens. You've probably heard that marigolds repel mosquitoes. There's a little truth there, but maybe not the way social media makes it sound. Most plants don't throw up an invisible mosquito barrier just by growing in your flower bed. The oils inside the leaves usually have to be crushed, brushed against, or released into the air before a mosquito even notices them.

Second:

That doesn't mean plants have no role. I love tucking herbs around our outdoor living spaces, because they're beautiful, they're useful, and they smell wonderful when you brush past them. Lavender, rosemary, basil, lemon balm, and citronella grass all carry aromatic compounds mosquitoes don't particularly enjoy — and you can cook with several of them, which is a win in my book. One of my favorite surprises is catnip. Yes, the same plant that makes your cat lose all dignity rolling in the grass. It contains a compound called nepetalactone (neh-peh-tuh-LAK-tone) that researchers have found can repel mosquitoes in laboratory studies. I can't promise your backyard goes mosquito-free, but you may gain a few feline visitors.

Second:

Here's something even more effective than trying to repel them, though: invite their enemies. Dragonflies are incredible mosquito hunters — sometimes called the mosquito hawks of the insect world, because they eat mosquitoes both as underwater larvae and as flying adults. Swallows swoop through the evening air catching insects on the wing, and a single bat can put away hundreds of insects in a night, though mosquitoes are only part of the menu. The more balanced your backyard ecosystem gets, the less you're leaning on a spray bottle to solve every problem.

Second:

There's something beautifully biblical about that. In Genesis, God placed Adam in the garden to work it and take care of it. Stewardship was part of the design from the very beginning, and caring for what we've been given — right down to the forgotten corners of the backyard — is so often where prevention begins. The simplest change can make the biggest difference. So if you hold onto any lesson from all of this, remember that mosquitoes don't need a pond. They just need an opportunity.

Second:

Once you've taken away the opportunity, the next layers go on you.

Second:

Dress for it when you can. Loose, long-sleeved shirts and pants give mosquitoes less skin to find, and loose matters because they can bite right through fabric that's stretched tight against the skin. For serious outdoor time — camping, hiking, long evenings — lean harder on barriers instead of stronger chemicals: tuck pant legs into socks, choose lighter colors so anything crawling is easy to spot, and drape netting over the stroller or carrier for the littlest ones.

Second:

Then time your outdoors with a little awareness. Many mosquitoes are most active at dawn and dusk, so that's when your repellent and your long sleeves earn their keep. Keep window and door screens in good repair so the house stays a safe zone, and run the air conditioning or a fan on the porch — mosquitoes are weak fliers and a little breeze genuinely throws them off.

Second:

Underneath all these spray bottles, there's something I don't want to rush past.

Second:

When I stood on that back step feeling like I'd failed my kid over a mosquito bite, the feeling was way out of proportion to the welts. It wasn't really about the bites. It was about wanting to cover my people and not being sure I knew how. I think a lot of motherhood lives right there — in the ache to protect, tangled up with the worry that we're getting it wrong.

Second:

And there's something empowering in remembering that the body you're trying to protect was made on purpose. Scripture says we are fearfully and wonderfully made, and I think about that even with something as small as skin — this living barrier God designed, the way a child's body is knit together with such care. Stewarding that body, learning how to actually guard it, paying attention to the small stuff. It's a tender form of love. All that sounds a little gooey until you wake up one day and the three little humans you protected 24/7 for years became adults or adult-ish. In hindsite rubbing my kids down with bug protection was a sweet moment because how many moms do you see rubbing their 21 yo down with bug repellent?

Second:

So protecting your family from bites can be a small, faithful act of attentive care. Not hovering — just sweet attentive care. You're not trying to control every variable or build a sterile bubble. You're just paying loving attention to the people in front of you and doing the next wise thing. That's enough.

Second:

Before we close, let me answer the three biggest questions plainly, so you can grab them on the run.

Second:

Does natural bug spray actually work? One does, with real evidence: oil of lemon eucalyptus, the EPA-registered repellent built on PMD. Field research has shown it protecting better than 95 percent of the time for several hours, in the same range as low-to-moderate DEET. The other "natural" sprays — citronella, cedar, peppermint, plain essential oils — have not been tested enough for the CDC to vouch for them, so treat those as nice smells, not reliable protection. And citronella candles? The answer is yes they work —but probably not as well as we've been led to believe. They can reduce mosquitoes right around the candle, especially on a calm evening, but they don't create an invisible force field around your backyard. The citronella oil simply disperses too quickly, especially if there's any breeze. If I'm sitting on the patio, I'd actually rather have a fan blowing than rely on a citronella candle. Mosquitoes are weak fliers, so moving air makes it much harder for them to find you in the first place."

Second:

Is oil of lemon eucalyptus safe for kids? For children three and older, used by the label, yes — and that age line matters. Products with oil of lemon eucalyptus or PMD should not be used on children under three years old per the CDC. For babies and toddlers under three, you protect them with clothing, mosquito netting over the stroller or carrier, and an age-appropriate registered repellent like picaridin where the label allows, with your pediatrician's input if you're unsure. Again, not many studies using children as subjects. So no proof for or against. it.

Second:

How often do I need to reapply? Go by the clock on the label, not by smell, and reapply sooner if your kids have been sweating, swimming, or toweling off. And one habit worth keeping: when everyone comes inside for the night, wash the treated sticky sweaty skin with soap and water before bed. It's a simple way to make sure little hands aren't carrying repellent to their eyes and mouths overnight.

Second:

What about ticks? Some repellents are labeled for ticks and some aren't, so this is exactly what the EPA's search tool is for — filter for tick protection specifically, dress in long sleeves with pant legs tucked into socks in lighter colors so a tick is easy to spot, and do a careful, thorough tick-check on everyone after any wooded hike, because ticks are a different and serious game. And do those wearable bracelets and clip-on gadgets work? They tend to only protect the patch of air right around the device, which is not where the whole kid is, so I wouldn't count on them to keep an ankle bite-free.

Second:

So let's bring it home. We started on a back step with a mystery bottle and bites on a tiny ankle and a question — does natural bug spray actually protect my family, and how do I use it? And the answer turned out to be more freeing than I expected. Yes, a natural option really works — oil of lemon eucalyptus, the EPA-registered repellent built on PMD, with field research showing it can rival low-to-moderate DEET for everyday protection. The bottles that let us down weren't "the natural ones." They were the untested ones we grabbed by the label.

Second:

Your one next step, the thing to do this week: pick a single EPA-registered repellent that fits your family — oil of lemon eucalyptus for everyone three and up, picaridin or DEET when you're in tougher territory or protecting the under-threes — and actually read its label so you know how to apply it and how often to reapply. Then add the easy free layers: tip out the standing water on Saturday, throw on loose long sleeves at dusk, fix the screens. That's a protected family. That's it.

Second:

And give yourself grace here. If you've been spraying lemon-scented hope for years, you didn't fail your kids, you just did the best you could with the information you had, and now you have better information, and you get to walk outside tonight a little more equipped. That's how this whole thing works. We learn, we adjust, we keep showing up for our people.

Second:

If this helped you, would you do me a small favor and share it with one other mom who's standing in that bug-spray aisle right now feeling unqualified? That's how this little show grows, and it means the world to me.

Second:

In the mean time go back to episode 34 Valuable Sunscreen Safety You Need to Know to Protect & Support Your Health from May 2025 where we're staying in the world of summer skin and talking about sunscreen — what's actually in it, what to look for, and how to protect your family's skin without the overwhelm. I think it'll pair perfectly with today and make up for my lost time organizing and designing something great thats coming soon!

Second:

Until then, go enjoy that backyard. Count your heads, tip the flowerpot, spray the ones over three, and let the evening be good. I'm so glad you're here, and I'll see you next time on Becoming Natural.

Links

Video

More from YouTube