Your brain is a lying machine—and that's the only reason you're alive. This episode dives into imagination, not the Disney sparkle-fingers kind, but the prehistoric survival software running in the background of your skull 24/7. We'll explore why Navy SEALs are basically aggressive theater kids, how a crow named Betty outsmarted Oxford scientists by inventing tools on the fly, and why your anxiety might actually be an evolutionary flex. Turns out, the paranoid storyteller survived while the guy doing probability calculations got eaten by a saber-tooth.

We'll also unpack why your New Year's resolutions fail by January 19th (hint: you're asking your brain to direct five movies at once), what Admiral Nelson's "I don't care how you win, just win" strategy can teach you about planning, and why somewhere between 3-12% of adults are secretly maintaining detailed goblin kingdoms in their heads while doing your taxes. Plus, today's Dumb Word of the Day and challenge for the week.

Sign up for the Dumbify newsletter: https://www.david-carson.com/

Dumbify celebrates ideas so weird, wrong, or wildly impractical… they just might be brilliant. Hosted by David Carson, a serial entrepreneur behind multiple hundred-million-dollar companies and the go-to secret weapon for companies looking to unlock new markets through unconventional thinking. Dumbify dives into the messy, counter-intuitive side of creativity — the “dumb” ideas that built empires, broke rules, and ended up changing everything.

Here's something nobody tells you. Right now, as you're listening to this, your brain is writing fan fiction about your life. Not metaphorically, literally. It's creating elaborate stories about what might happen in the next five minutes, the next hour, tomorrow.

And here's what's kind of mind-blowing, if it ever stops doing this, you're probably going to die. Welcome to Dumbify. I'm your host, David Carson, and today we're talking about imagination, but not the whimsical Disney sparkle fingers version. We're talking about the prehistoric survival software that runs your life. We're going to talk about why Navy SEALs are basically just aggressive theater kids, why a bird is probably smarter than your cousin, and why your brain is technically a lying machine that keeps you alive. So, let's do this. Let's get dumb.

Dumbify, let your neurons dance. Put your brain in backwards pants. Genus hides in daft disguise. Brilliance wears those googly eyes. So honk your nose and chase that spark. Dumb is just smart in the dark. Dumbify. Yelling like a goose. It's thinking wrong on purpose with Juice.

So, I want you to imagine you're in Cape Fear, North Carolina, in a swamp. It smells like pine needles, swampy things with just a scent of regret. There's a team of special operations guys, human weapons, basically, and they've been awake for 72 hours. They're hallucinating, they're cranky, and they're studying intel reports about a fake guerrilla warlord named, I don't know, let's call him Gary. The special ops guys think this is a test, a drill, having something to do with Gary's criminal empire, his opium farms, his illegal Beanie Baby smuggling ring, whatever. These guys think they're being tested on strategy. But nope, suddenly a bomb goes off. And then they hear a child screaming in the dense fog of the blast. Any plans they had about how they were going to deal with Gary go out the window. Done. No more plan, just chaos. And where it gets interesting and kind of insane is that every single one of these special ops guys deals with this chaos differently. One guy goes full Rambo and just kicks down a door. Another guy tries to hastily negotiate with Gary, while another guy basically becomes Gary's therapist, asking him about his relationship with his father until Gary cries and hands over the kid. These guys aren't using a checklist. Their to-do list got blown up after that bomb exploded, so they're improvising. They're basically doing an armed improv class in a swamp. Because do you know what your brain is not doing in a crisis? It's not doing math. It's not doing logic. We like to think we're logical. We like to think our brain is some kind of computer just going beep-boop, 73% probability of survival if I turn left. If your ancestors did that, they would've been eaten, because logic is too slow. Logic is buffering. While logic is sitting there trying to carry the one, a saber-toothed cat has already turned your skull into a soup bowl. Logic asks, "Is it statistically probable that a predator is behind that rock based on migratory patterns?" But something like story asks, "What if a monster is behind that rock? Run." Guess which guy passed on his genes? The paranoid storyteller. The guy doing calculus, well, he got eaten by a saber tooth. It turns out that the possible is better than the probable. The possible lets you operate with zero data. You don't know there's a monster. You just imagine one. And hey, look at that. You didn't die today. Good job, anxiety. So okay, it gets even weirder. We share this superpower with crows, birds that are essentially flying goth teenagers. In 2002, a crow named Betty became the first animal ever shown to create a hooked tool by bending a piece of wire. No training. No demonstration. She just figured it out. She stared at a piece of wire and a tube with meat inside, and she bent the wire into a hook to fish out the food. Scientists at Oxford were stunned. One researcher, Alex Katzelnic, described what he thinks is happening. The crows use some form of virtual simulation of the problem as if different potential actions were played in their brains until they figure out a viable solution, and then do it. They are running mental rehearsals. They are writing fiction to solve physics. More recently, researchers in New Zealand gave New Caledonian crows a three-step puzzle where each stage was hidden from the others. The crows couldn't see the whole problem at once. They had to hold the pieces in their minds, tools they'd seen, locations they'd visited, and mentally map out a sequence of moves, like a chess player thinking three steps ahead. One crow, named Saturn, never made a single mistake.Another crow, Mango, built compound tools out of three and four separate parts without any training, because she could picture how the pieces would fit together before she touched them. This is not instinct. This is imagination. And here's what should really mess with you. Birds and mammals evolved their brains separately. Our common ancestor lived over 300 million years ago, before dinosaurs, before most of what you'd recognize as life. Birds took a completely different evolutionary path, but they arrived at the same destination, mental simulation, the ability to build a little theater in your head and run scenarios before you commit to action. Evolution invented imagination twice. Because it's that useful, this software is older than mammals. It is older than language, which showed up maybe 135,000 years ago, a blink of an eye in evolutionary terms. You evolved the ability to play make-believe millions of years before you evolved the ability to say, "My back hurts." So there was this brilliant researcher named Anna Craft. She spent her career at the Open University and the University of Exeter hanging out in preschools, watching kids pretend to be dinosaurs or doctors or dinosaur doctors, and she realized something the crow researchers would have recognized instantly. Kids aren't learning to imagine. They imagine to learn. She called it possibility thinking, the transformation from what is to what might be, the "What if" question, and she figured out that this is the operating system of human consciousness. We are all just running stories constantly. Every time a toddler pretends a banana is a telephone, they're doing what Betty did with that wire, simulating a reality that doesn't exist yet in order to understand how reality works. And then she died of cancer in 2014 at 52. Over a hundred publications, the concept of little c creativity, a framework that explained how ordinary people, not just geniuses, use imagination every single day. And you've probably never heard of her. Why? Because she studied toddlers. If she had studied how to make a line on a graph go up for Goldman Sachs, she'd have a statue. She discovered the source code of the human mind, and the academic world was like, "That's cute, Anna, but look at this guy who invented a new way to bundle subprime mortgages." So your story machine runs two programs. Program one is the origin story. This is you looking backward, trying to figure out why you are the way you are.

I am afraid of clowns because of my fifth birthday party. I don't trust people because my college roommate stole my mini fridge. You're constantly writing your own biography, editing the rough draft, trying to make the narrative make sense. Program two is the choose your own adventure. This is you looking forward, simulating futures. What if I eat this yogurt that expired three weeks ago? What if I text my ex at 2:00 A.M.? What if I finally quit and open that goat yoga studio? This is your imagination doing what it evolved to do, running scenarios so you don't have to actually live through every possible mistake. I want you to picture an arrow. The shaft of the arrow is your past. It gives you momentum, direction, a sense of who you are and why. The head of the arrow splits into five different possible futures, paths you could take. When this system works, when the origin story and the choose your own adventure are in sync, you have what the special ops guys call liquid tenacity, which sounds like a terrifying energy drink that would give you a nosebleed, but actually means something beautiful. You know where you're going, but you don't care how you get there. You're committed to the destination, but flexible about the route. Traffic jam? Fine. I'll take the side streets. Bridge is out? Cool. I'll swim. That's the ideal. That's the dream. But most of you, most of you don't have liquid tenacity. You have chunky flaccidity. Your arrow doesn't look like an arrow. It looks like a sparkler on the 4th of July, sparks flying in every direction, very exciting, absolutely no forward momentum. Think about your New Year's resolutions. You're going to lose 20 pounds and learn Japanese and save for a house and stop doom scrolling and finally read Infinite Jest. You just gave your brain five different movies to direct at the same time, starring the same exhausted actor, you. You're trying to film a rom-com and a gritty documentary and an action movie simultaneously, and somehow they're all due on Friday. No wonder you end up just eating cheese on the couch. Your brain isn't lazy, it's overwhelmed. It's a director who showed up to set and found five different scripts, no craft services, and a producer who keeps asking, "Can we add a car chase?"

And here's the thing. Your brain knows it can't do all five, so instead of picking one and disappointing you, it just doesn't pick. It stalls. It opens Netflix. It tells you that you'll start Monday, because Monday is a mythical land where you have more willpower and fewer snacks in the pantry.... 19. This is why most resolutions fail by January 19th, not because you're weak, because you asked your imagination to write five screenplays at once, and it threw up its hands and wrote none of them. I remember meeting this Forbes top 50 CEO once, big deal guy, wears a vest, probably has a morning routine that involves ice baths. And he was really kind of failing at the time, and he told me very seriously that he had 15 essential priorities. 15. I wanted to grab him by the fleece vest and say, "Priority is singular." The word comes from the Latin prior, meaning first. You literally cannot have 15 first things. That is not a strategy. That is a panic attack formatted into a PowerPoint deck. That is a to-do list cosplaying as a vision. And this guy ran a company, thousands of employees all looking up at him waiting for direction, and he was pointing in 15 directions at once wondering why nobody was moving.

Dumb, dumb, dumb, dumb, dumb word of the day. Dumb word of the day. It's a word. It's dumb. Use responsibly.

Oh, yeah. It's time for my favorite part of the show. It's time for the Dumb Word of the Day. And today's dumb word is paracosm, spelled P-A-R-A-C-O-S-M. Paracosm. It sounds like a bacteria you'd get from a sketchy hot tub, but it's actually the technical term for a detailed imaginary world that lives inside your head. We're not talking about a daydream. We're talking detailed maps, history, politics, currency, trade disputes, a whole civilization living rent-free inside your skull. And here's the wild statistic. Researchers estimate somewhere between 3% and 12% of adults still have one right now, active and running. These aren't fantasy writers. These are accountants, dentists, bus drivers, people walking around doing your taxes, filling your cavities while secretly maintaining a detailed mental simulation of a goblin trade war in the Kingdom of Zorp. They have opinions about Zorp's monetary policy. And guess what? Having a paracosm is a massive predictor of being a great strategic planner, because that's all strategy is. It's making up a fake world and then figuring out how to live in it. Every business plan is just a paracosm with a revenue model. So here's where this gets practical. Most people think good planning means having a detailed script, step one, step two, step three, color-coded calendar, Gantt charts, the whole type A fantasy. But that's not how imagination is supposed to work. Your story machine didn't evolve to write screenplays. It evolved to run simulations, to ask, "What if?" and then adapt when reality doesn't cooperate. The best strategic thinkers in history understood this. They didn't plan harder. They planned looser. Let's talk about Admiral Nelson from the British Navy in the early 1800s. This guy is basically the GOAT of naval warfare. We're talking a career record that sounds made up. The Battle of the Nile, destroyed an entire French fleet. The Battle of Copenhagen, won while technically being ordered to retreat. He just pretended he didn't see the signal. This guy put a telescope up to his blind eye and said, "I really don't see the signal." Absolute legend behavior. And speaking of that blind eye, he lost vision in one eye during a siege, then lost his entire arm in a different battle, learned to write left-handed, was back commanding ships within months. This guy treated catastrophic injuries like minor inconveniences. So yes, he was tough, comically, absurdly tough, but that's not why he kept winning. He'd learned a few secrets about strategy over the years, and his real secret wasn't tactics. It was trust. His strategy was called the Nelson Touch, and it was basically the opposite of how everyone else did military planning. At the Battle of Trafalgar, he's outnumbered. The math does not math. Every traditional playbook says he should lose. So he gathers his captains and says something that would get you fired from most corporations. "Here is the goal. We win. Here's how you do it. I don't care. Figure it out. Go nuts." No script. No step-by-step. Just a destination and permission to improvise. He captured two-thirds of the enemy fleet without losing a single ship. Why? Because the French and Spanish were following a rigid script. When X happens, do Y. And Nelson's guys were playing jazz, violent cannonball jazz. The enemy couldn't predict them because they couldn't predict themselves. Every captain was running his own simulation, adapting in real time, making it up as he went along. And it turns out that's really hard to defend against. You can't counter a strategy that doesn't exist yet. This is what your paracosm is training you for, not to predict the future, to be ready for any future, to hold the goal loosely enough that you can find a new route when the first one explodes. Nelson didn't have a better plan. He had a better imagination.

So here's your homework, and I don't say that lightly because I hate homework and I hate people who assign it. But this week, I want you to notice your paracosm. You have one. Maybe it's not a goblin kingdom. Maybe it's the future version of your life you rehearse in the shower, the argument you keep replaying with better comebacks, the business you've built 17 times in your head, but never on paper. That's not escapism. That's your brain doing what it evolved to do. That's your inner crow bending a wire before it touches the metal. The problem isn't that you're imagining. The problem is you might be imagining the wrong things, or you're imagining so many things that your brain throws up its hands and picks Netflix instead. So, one goal, loose grip. Let your captains improvise. And now, let's use our dumb word of the day in a sentence. "I don't have anxiety about the future, I have a paracosm, and right now, there's a trade war going on in there. Should I max out my 401[k] or buy a decorative sword? The sword keeps winning and I don't know what that means." That was weird. And that's our show. But before we go, I wanna leave you with something that blew my mind. You know why humans run this planet? It's not because we're strong. A chimp could rip your arm off like a breadstick. It's not because we're fast. It's because we are the only species that can hallucinate something that doesn't exist, and then force the universe to make it real. A crow can imagine using a stick, but a human can imagine a rocket ship. We looked at the moon, a cold, dead rock, and wrote a fan fiction where we walked on it, and then we did the math, built the metal, and actually walked on it. We imagined democracy in a world of kings. We imagined antibiotics in a world of plague. So, the next time you catch yourself daydreaming or worrying or zoning out, don't feel guilty. You aren't wasting time. You are revving the engine that built the pyramids. Your brain is a story machine. Keep your stories flexible. Keep your goals simple. And for the love of God, stop trying to learn the banjo and Japanese at the same time. I'm David Carson, and thank you for getting dumb with me today. Let's do it again next week.