In this episode of Unwritten Law, NCLA Senior Litigation Counsel John Vecchione is joined by NCLA General Counsel Zhonette Brown to discuss Jacobsen v. Spellerberg, NCLA's newly filed lawsuit advancing a groundbreaking First Amendment argument: education is speech, and parents have a constitutional right to choose the educational speech provided to their children.

Nebraska requires parents to educate their children while directing substantial public funding exclusively toward the state's public-school system. Parents who choose homeschooling or private education because they disagree with the messages conveyed in public schools must bear those costs themselves while continuing to support the public system. NCLA argues that this amounts to viewpoint discrimination and imposes an unconstitutional condition on parents who exercise their First Amendment rights.

Zhonette explains the legal theory developed by NCLA founder Philip Hamburger, the families challenging Nebraska's system, and the century-old Supreme Court precedents recognizing parents' authority to direct their children's education. She and John also discuss what NCLA is asking the court to do and how a victory could expand educational choice in Nebraska.

Show Notes

Public Schools Shouldn’t Be Fiefdoms of Government Speech — Philip Hamburger, National Review

New NCLA Lawsuit: Nebraska’s Educational Scheme Violates Parents’ Free Speech

Education Is Speech: Parental Free Speech in Education — Philip Hamburger, Texas Law Review