In this episode, the metaverse wins Christmas, we look at the metaverse in the context of the technology adoption curve, Ready Player Me raises $13 million in a recent funding round, Decentraland and UNXD are planning to host the metaverse's fashion week, and so much more!
Episode 6 Keywords: Metaverse Christmas, Technology Adoption Curve, Ready Player Me Funding, Metaverse Fashion Week
Welcome to the metaphysics podcast. The Metaverse and web three are bringing about the
Unknown:biggest revolution since the internet itself. With your hosts Paul the prophet Dawalibi And Jeff the
Unknown:juice Cohen. We will be bringing you the latest Metaverse, business news and insight into what it
Unknown:all means. The meta business podcast starts now.
Paul Dawalibi:From the boardroom to the metaverse. This is the meta business podcast. I am
Paul Dawalibi:Paul the Prophet Dawalibi. I'm joined today by my friend and co host, Jeff the juice Cohen. For
Paul Dawalibi:those of you who are new to the meta business podcast welcome. What we do here is we cover all
Paul Dawalibi:the big Metaverse news and stories of the week. We look at all of it through a business and C suite
Paul Dawalibi:lens, we dissect, we analyze the business implications of everything happening in the
Paul Dawalibi:metaverse. For those of you who are new to the podcast, welcome. If you've come here from the
Paul Dawalibi:business of esports also welcome. We encourage you guys to subscribe to the metal business podcast,
Paul Dawalibi:leave a review. If you love the content we put out every week, we really would appreciate a five star
Paul Dawalibi:review. Wherever you get this podcast on Apple podcast, Google Play Spotify, wherever. Jeff, how
Paul Dawalibi:are you doing this week?
Jeff Cohen:I'm doing well. We are we're recording this. It's the week between Christmas and New
Jeff Cohen:Year's. It's always the weirdest week of the year. You know, everyone's sort of off from work, but
Jeff Cohen:not really. You know, basically sitting on the couch watching Netflix or doing whatever they do
Jeff Cohen:spending time with family. But the news never stops and the metaverse never stops. So here we
Jeff Cohen:are excited to get going.
Paul Dawalibi:It doesn't and I can tell you I said this on the business of esports podcast.
Paul Dawalibi:Everyone thinks this is the slowest week of the year, we are crushing it literally all of our
Paul Dawalibi:content is hitting like record highs, whether it's met a business or business of esports or met a
Paul Dawalibi:woman or literally everything this is the best week ever for all of our content. So I don't know
Paul Dawalibi:if there's a business lesson in there but
Jeff Cohen:everyone will everyone's just telling you what people are doing listening to podcasts. I
Jeff Cohen:would say you know I listen to most of my podcasts when I work out which is why I don't get around to
Jeff Cohen:listening to many of the episodes that were recorded because you know I don't work out enough
Jeff Cohen:but after the new year you know that's going to be a big a big push in the Cohen household. So the
Jeff Cohen:juice of the count off on all things podcast
Paul Dawalibi:that's not totally fair for our listeners they should know that the juice himself
Paul Dawalibi:is a is a record holding like all star lacrosse player so like, it's not totally fair to say you
Paul Dawalibi:don't work out so Alright, let's let's I don't want to waste any time here. Let's jump into some
Paul Dawalibi:news because believe it or not, even though this is the week between Christmas and New Year there
Paul Dawalibi:actually was a ton of Metaverse news. I mean, the hype has not stopped, the activity has not
Paul Dawalibi:stopped. And let's start here with an article. You know, you found this one Jeff and and I think the
Paul Dawalibi:headline was very catchy here. The headline said, how the metaverse one Christmas, this may end up
Paul Dawalibi:being the title of this podcast. But But fundamentally, it has three key points in this
Paul Dawalibi:article from CNBC. And here they're talking about Mehta, which is Facebook's parent company. They
Paul Dawalibi:have the most popular app in Apple's App Store on Christmas. And that is the Oculus VR app. That's
Paul Dawalibi:like the companion app if you own an Oculus VR headset. And the second point here says it's a
Paul Dawalibi:sign metas VR headset was one of the most popular technology gifts over the holidays. This This
Paul Dawalibi:gives Mehta more opportunity to show customers the possibilities of its vision for the metaverse. So
Paul Dawalibi:Oculus having huge success, right. The article basically says Oculus one Christmas, and you know
Paul Dawalibi:they've generalized to the metaverse, but let's call it like it is Oculus, that one Christmas
Paul Dawalibi:here. What do you make of this, Jeff? Is it you know, is this a turning point is this? Are we not
Paul Dawalibi:there yet? Like the metaverse hardware.
Jeff Cohen:It's interesting. I mean, it's, it's too early to call this necessarily an inflection
Jeff Cohen:point, because I feel like we've had too many stops and starts in terms of VR, to really know if
Jeff Cohen:this is the true kind of, we're coming up the adoption curve we sort of saw, I remember, during
Jeff Cohen:the pandemic, like the very early stages of the pandemic, when HalfLife Alex came out from Valve,
Jeff Cohen:and everyone was like, Well, this is it. Finally, there's a killer app. There's a game on VR that
Jeff Cohen:everyone wants to play, it's exclusive to VR, this is it, there's going to be mass adoption boom. And
Jeff Cohen:and that sort of never really happened. And I'm not sure the exact postmortem to that maybe it was
Jeff Cohen:the game just wasn't good or the platform wasn't ready things were too expensive. You know, that's
Jeff Cohen:kind of a different subject that we don't necessarily want to get get into. But we've seen
Jeff Cohen:this before. So I do think it's a little bit too early to say, you know, the VR market. It's a
Jeff Cohen:classic, you know, platform problem where you have, you know, it's a two sided platform, you
Jeff Cohen:need users, and then you need developers, and you don't really get developers in till there's a big
Jeff Cohen:enough user base for it to be worthwhile to develop games for. And you don't get people to buy
Jeff Cohen:the Oculus until there's good games or kind of a killer app, if you will. So, it is good right now
Jeff Cohen:that you're starting to see this user base, consumer electronics are always a popular gift on
Jeff Cohen:Christmas. So this year, you know that that was the case with Oculus. The question I have is, is
Jeff Cohen:there really a killer app yet? Have we seen enough developers adopting this? And I guess the question
Jeff Cohen:moving forward will be what is usage look like? Because it could be very easily be, hey, everyone
Jeff Cohen:got this. This, you know, the Oculus for Christmas from grandma, and they're going to use it for a
Jeff Cohen:week realize, hey, there's really just not that many games on here now, and then it's going to get
Jeff Cohen:put in the closet. So I think it'll be interesting to kind of monitor how usage tracks and stuff like
Jeff Cohen:that. So I would pose that question to you. And then I think the bigger question that, you know,
Jeff Cohen:you're probably leading me towards that I didn't really cover is sort of how, how do we tie this to
Jeff Cohen:the metaverse like, is this? What if this is the you know, the kind of the coming? Coming out party
Jeff Cohen:for VR? Is that sort of important for the metaverse? I'll pose that I guess to you?
Paul Dawalibi:I'm going to get to the answering that question. I just I want to put this up on the
Paul Dawalibi:screen. And for those listening, I'll try and describe it. But this is like your standard
Paul Dawalibi:technology adoption curve. Okay. And at the bottom, sort of It's a it looks like a bit like a
Paul Dawalibi:bell curve, right? It's a it's a, what is this an inverted parabola. And then at the bottom, you've
Paul Dawalibi:got enthusiast. And there the statement is I have to be the first to try this. Then you have
Paul Dawalibi:visionaries further up the curve. I want to show you this helpful tool I found, then you have
Paul Dawalibi:pragmatists further up the curve. Why should I start using this technology? That's what they ask
Paul Dawalibi:themselves. And then conservatives on the other end, right. This is after his peak adoption is
Paul Dawalibi:piqued. I was skeptical, but I should have tried this earlier. And then finally, skeptics are the
Paul Dawalibi:toughest right to get on board. And they'll they'll tell themselves, I guess I can give it a
Paul Dawalibi:try. But I need help. Where do you think with Oculus and VR? We are on this adoption curve in
Paul Dawalibi:your mind?
Jeff Cohen:I think we're probably maybe in the second second quadrant. So visionaries. Yeah, I
Jeff Cohen:think we're probably their mid pragmatist. I don't like the name like I don't. I'm not sure. Let's
Jeff Cohen:see, why should I start using this technology? Hmm. Maybe between somewhere between two and
Jeff Cohen:three? I think we have moved past the I have to be the first to try this. Because those were the
Jeff Cohen:people that were buying Oculus 3456 years ago. Yeah, I think we're kind of in quadrant two
Jeff Cohen:quadrant three.
Paul Dawalibi:I don't know. Do you agree with that? I do agree with that. I think you know, the
Paul Dawalibi:the question you asked those a good one, Jeff, which is, what is the impact on the metaverse
Paul Dawalibi:here. And, and I'll just also mention, you know, the guests we had on the business of esports
Paul Dawalibi:podcast this week, is a software developer. And his feeling was I asked him sort of something
Paul Dawalibi:around this. And he had this sort of interesting perspective where it's a pendulum between software
Paul Dawalibi:and hardware. And we've been in this software mode, right where you have Roblox and you have
Paul Dawalibi:epic and fortnight and unreal, and you have you know, Minecraft and there's a whole bunch of
Paul Dawalibi:software being built for the metaverse and if T's and blockchain and blockchain based games and
Paul Dawalibi:right everyone's writing code, but there's this feeling like the pendulum is gonna swing back
Paul Dawalibi:towards hardware. And there's going to be sort of this era of hardware innovation, where software
Paul Dawalibi:might be relatively stagnant, but where you're gonna see a ton of innovation on the hardware
Paul Dawalibi:side. And, and and I don't know if Oculus is the one that's going to lead that. But I think what
Paul Dawalibi:Oculus has done from a price point and marketing perspective is they've made VR truly accessible to
Paul Dawalibi:anyone, right? So anyone who wants to experience the early days of the metaverse, if you want to
Paul Dawalibi:call it that can write there's really no barrier anymore. That it's not complicated, right? You
Paul Dawalibi:don't need stay like base stations in your room, the setups easy, it's totally portable, you
Paul Dawalibi:recharge it like a phone, right? Like there's literally nothing that that my own grandmother
Paul Dawalibi:couldn't figure out, right. And so I think that's a major accomplishment that we have to ascribe to
Paul Dawalibi:Oculus, which is why it's sold like hot like hotcakes during Christmas. And it's also probably
Paul Dawalibi:the only console if you want to consider it a console that was in stock, right? Like people
Paul Dawalibi:couldn't get an Xbox or a PS five, I think you could still get an Oculus. Even if people put it
Paul Dawalibi:away, like try it and put it away, like you said might be that sort of worst case scenario. The
Paul Dawalibi:fact of the matter is there's going to be this massive install base of VR headsets. And from a
Paul Dawalibi:coming of the metaverse perspective, I think that's a requirement. Right? Like even if people
Paul Dawalibi:aren't actively using it day to day That's fair. But install base.
Jeff Cohen:I guess I would pose 100% Having the install, but it's a chicken and egg problem.
Jeff Cohen:Having install base is a massive prerequisite. But I'm almost thinking to myself, is it better for
Jeff Cohen:people to not have tried it yet and have just this idea of what the metaverse is? Or try it and have
Jeff Cohen:it not be what they think it is? Because it's not the technology's not there yet. And I think you're
Jeff Cohen:the guest on the pot like the the hardware software kind of pendulum. I actually love that.
Jeff Cohen:Like, I think that that makes a ton of sense. But yeah, I'm wondering if maybe it's worse if people
Jeff Cohen:try it and are like, Well, that just wasn't that good. And then you sort of set you set yourself
Jeff Cohen:back, because now it's even harder to get those people because they're like, I already tried that.
Jeff Cohen:It's just not that interesting.
Paul Dawalibi:I mean, I see your point, right, like they, they fire beat Sabre, and they're like,
Paul Dawalibi:this is this is like it I mean, I see your point, I think I probably disagree in the sense that and
Paul Dawalibi:I know you're making the point to create discussion here. But like, I feel like better
Paul Dawalibi:expose people to it, even if it's not the end game. Because this creates more discussion. I
Paul Dawalibi:think they're more likely to buy next gen Oculus or whatever the next thing is, right. Like, I feel
Paul Dawalibi:like if you expose people to it, even if there's somewhat, and I don't know if anyone has in their
Paul Dawalibi:mind, sort of this grand vision of the metaverse like I don't think anyone buys an Oculus thinking.
Paul Dawalibi:This is going to be Ready Player One. Do you think yeah, like that's what?
Jeff Cohen:No, probably not. I guess from a more fundamental level. I don't know if we've ever
Jeff Cohen:discussed this yet on the podcast, like, do you think the metaverse? Is VR a requisite of the
Jeff Cohen:metaverse? Or is it just immersion? Is it something you know? Could you could argue playing
Jeff Cohen:a game of Grand Theft Auto you can be immersed in that game? You're not in VR, but you can be you
Jeff Cohen:know, by definition, immersed where it's like, you feel like you're in the world or do you need that
Jeff Cohen:presence? Where you're, you know, you're in VR.
Paul Dawalibi:This is tricky, because it's a it's a word definition problem, right? Like, if we
Paul Dawalibi:define VR as a headset I'm wearing with screens built into the headset. That's to me, that's not
Paul Dawalibi:the end game, right. Like if we're thinking 2030 years from now. No way. That's the endgame. I
Paul Dawalibi:think I've always been I've always described it as is Star Trek's holodeck. Like even Ready Player
Paul Dawalibi:One to me is not the end game for humanity when it comes to meta versus Star Trek's holodeck truly
Paul Dawalibi:is, in my mind, basically the end game where
Jeff Cohen:and for the people who never saw it? It's I mean, I'm just saying there might be some
Jeff Cohen:of our listeners. It's true. It's
Paul Dawalibi:a room.
Jeff Cohen:Not me. Definitely. And the room
Paul Dawalibi:can create any reality you ask of it. Right? And, and it's totally indistinguishable
Paul Dawalibi:from reality. So it's
Jeff Cohen:a requirement from Harry Potter, I get it.
Paul Dawalibi:Which, which is a reference item get but Star Trek's holodeck makes sense to me.
Paul Dawalibi:But know that like where it's where you you're, there's no hardware other than the space you're
Paul Dawalibi:occupying? To me, that's the end game right? And where space sort of loses all meaning also right?
Paul Dawalibi:You could be you could you the reality you're in could occupy a vast space. Now, I don't know if
Paul Dawalibi:you saw the Elon Musk interview with the Babylon be, you know, he sort of made fun of, of, you
Paul Dawalibi:know, I don't he didn't cease. He basically said, I don't think there's a future where we're going
Paul Dawalibi:to where TV's on are like on our faces. So he I think also doesn't believe that there's this sort
Paul Dawalibi:of VR headset long term future. But I think where he's putting his bets from, from the interview, at
Paul Dawalibi:least from where I think he thinks it's heading is more just like electrical, like where we plug in,
Paul Dawalibi:right? Where we can feed electrical signals to your brain to create the reality. You don't even
Paul Dawalibi:need a room at that point, right, we can create the reality in your own mind. If we can control
Paul Dawalibi:those electrical impulses, you know, precisely enough, you can create smell and sight and sound
Paul Dawalibi:and the whole bit so you know, those brain computer interfaces maybe are where we end up.
Jeff Cohen:The challenges are connecting your brain to because I could understand you or you can
Jeff Cohen:connect something to someone's brain and it's like, you can control what they see. But it might
Jeff Cohen:be hard, it'd be really hard to take it the next step where you're controlling everyone is, you
Jeff Cohen:know, controlling everwell brain if
Paul Dawalibi:everyone's plugged into the same system, you could see how that works. Right? Yeah,
Paul Dawalibi:it's an interface fundamentally. But anyway, so I think good on Oculus good on meta to me that
Paul Dawalibi:Oculus is metas greatest strength, right? Like, I think it's where they have clear leadership from a
Paul Dawalibi:Metaverse perspective because I think their metaphor strategy otherwise is basically so far
Paul Dawalibi:all just talk right like there's nothing really there that gives them a Some serious competitive
Paul Dawalibi:advantage other than Oculus 100% Agree. All right, we talked we mentioned Ready Player One. I think
Paul Dawalibi:it's worth talking about this next story because just because of the thing it's got a clever title
Paul Dawalibi:here in the company's called Ready Player me, blatant knockoff, obviously of the movie or the
Paul Dawalibi:book. And and here, the headline is ready player me a Metaverse avatar platform raises 13 million
Paul Dawalibi:in funding. This is a company called Wolf 3d. They have created or they're they're creating a
Paul Dawalibi:Metaverse avatar platform called Ready Player me. And their goal is to offer a customized avatar
Paul Dawalibi:that supposedly will carry over across the entire metaverse. So players build their avatar from
Paul Dawalibi:pictures or from scratch. And according to this, they can use them across. I don't know where they
Paul Dawalibi:got this number 900 Plus apps and games. And they're going to use the funding to establish
Paul Dawalibi:their place as the default avatar system for the metaverse. According to them, 2021 they grew their
Paul Dawalibi:adoption grew from 25 to 900 partner companies, where essentially they're partnering to be able to
Paul Dawalibi:use those avatars in those games. I mean, Jeff, are you are you excited by this? So you know,
Paul Dawalibi:we've talked a little bit, we've alluded to standards and things like that being important for
Paul Dawalibi:the metaverse, right capital M. Is this one of those essential building blocks? Do you think this
Paul Dawalibi:is a, you know, $50 billion company because they're there first, I'm curious how you're
Paul Dawalibi:thinking about this.
Jeff Cohen:It's hard to kind of pass judgment on the the like the specific company without kind of
Jeff Cohen:seeing their tech and whatnot. But I am very bullish on kind of digital fashion and sort of
Jeff Cohen:direct to Avatar commerce, just because if you think about it, people's appearances in real life
Jeff Cohen:are so important and kind of what we buy what we wear. If we take that to the logical extreme,
Jeff Cohen:where we're going to be spending more and more of our time in the metaverse and caring more and more
Jeff Cohen:about what our digital presence is, you're going to have digital fashion. So to me like that, that
Jeff Cohen:is 100% happening. The bigger question is, what is the tech look like? And how does the
Jeff Cohen:interoperability work? Because it's easy to say, hey, we're going to create a fashion company or,
Jeff Cohen:you know, a tech platform that allows you to, essentially, hey, you're wearing a skin and Call
Jeff Cohen:of Duty, all of a sudden you want to go play Battlefield, you go take the skin to Battlefield
Jeff Cohen:like that. In theory, I think we all agree like that is a world that makes a ton of sense and
Jeff Cohen:should exist. But there are a lot of logistical challenge like not even just like real world
Jeff Cohen:development challenges, things are built on different engines. There are different companies,
Jeff Cohen:if I buy a skin and Call of Duty that goes into Activision Blizzard's bank account. How does that
Jeff Cohen:work? When I bring it the battlefield, which is owned by Electronic Arts, which is a separate
Jeff Cohen:legal entity like that, there are very, I guess I'll use the word legit. Maybe logistical is the
Jeff Cohen:right word for it like that is a that is a challenge that is a big hurdle to overcome. And
Jeff Cohen:maybe the answer is it will it will. This kind of interoperability will only work in blockchain
Jeff Cohen:games and quote unquote, these Metaverse games, because that's just the DNA of these companies and
Jeff Cohen:everything won't be owned by the company, it'll be in the blockchain. And maybe there'll be when you,
Jeff Cohen:it's entirely conceivable when you transfer an item from one game to the other, you either pay a
Jeff Cohen:small fee, or maybe the developer from the first game pays the second developer or vice versa.
Jeff Cohen:Because it's like, Hey, maybe I can see the developer in the second game, paying the developer
Jeff Cohen:in the first game, because theoretically, you'll probably, once you're playing the second game,
Jeff Cohen:you'll be very likely to buy a second skin, which then they'll make money from. So it's a little bit
Jeff Cohen:of customer acquisition kind of thing. There's a lot of different rabbit holes, we can go down and
Jeff Cohen:discuss. But at the highest level, I think this kind of organization will exist, it's just a
Jeff Cohen:matter of how it how it will logistically shake out in terms of the value chain.
Paul Dawalibi:Well, let me let me ask you one question before I sort of give my thoughts on this
Paul Dawalibi:because I, I think this will help frame my own thought. Do you think Ready Player me can be
Paul Dawalibi:successful? If they only have some of the companies like like fast forward five years or 10
Paul Dawalibi:years, right? Like, if only 10% of the games and companies call it operating in meta versus are
Paul Dawalibi:signed up with Ready Player me? Is this a success? You think like, is this good for the industry? Or
Paul Dawalibi:do you think they have to have everything like is this an all or nothing? Kind of? No, I
Jeff Cohen:don't think I don't. I don't think they have to have everything. I do think once they
Jeff Cohen:hit a threshold, it be once they become big enough where certain portion of games have this. I think
Jeff Cohen:you're going what you're going to see is other games are going to want to get onto the platform
Jeff Cohen:because their users are going to want to get onto the platform. So imagine if you Have 10 games
Jeff Cohen:where you could, you know, bring your digital gun or your shirt or whatever your shoes from game to
Jeff Cohen:game to game. And then there's 11th game where you can't. So anything you buy in the first 10 games
Jeff Cohen:you can use in all those 10 games, but the 11th game, you have to buy something separate and you
Jeff Cohen:can't bring it into your other 10 games, I think that 11th game is going to be in theory, they're
Jeff Cohen:going to be try to be paying to get into that network, because it's going to be a barrier like,
Jeff Cohen:it will be a friction point for their users, where they you could see a world where they could lose
Jeff Cohen:users, because it's like, hey, well, I already bought this really expensive pair of shoes that I
Jeff Cohen:could wear in these 10 metal verses, but I can't wear it in that 11th. One, why would I go to the
Jeff Cohen:11th? One? So I do think there's a you know, to use the classic chart, but it's network effects,
Jeff Cohen:right, like at a certain scale you you do get those network effects.
Paul Dawalibi:Yeah, I just, I mean, the other question I sort of asked myself is, is this good
Paul Dawalibi:for the industry? Right? Is it good to have essentially a monopoly, potentially controlling
Paul Dawalibi:avatars? And, you know, if you look at, call it the web two equivalent or internet equivalent,
Paul Dawalibi:right, like, identity, basically is like an email address, right? For the most part, how you log in
Paul Dawalibi:how you get into different sites, and what sort of represents you on those sites. I'm trying to think
Paul Dawalibi:of another better analogy for identity in the web to universe but like, the way
Jeff Cohen:I'm understanding it, and just kids it's not, you know, it's sort of this whole web
Jeff Cohen:three ethos is that it's not they're going to have a monopoly, they will be providing tools, or they
Jeff Cohen:will be providing, essentially, the the rails where the things will transfer over. It's not
Jeff Cohen:like, like, I don't see them becoming a monopoly.
Paul Dawalibi:That's sort of what it sounds like, right? Because you go and you create your avatar
Paul Dawalibi:in their system, right? And then that avatar is portable to these up 900 apps and games. Okay,
Paul Dawalibi:like, to me, that's definitely a barrier. It's a it's a, it's a monopoly of sort on a, on a digital
Paul Dawalibi:avatar, how they interoperate between all the apps and games, I don't know whether you know, goods
Paul Dawalibi:and things, or they make them portable, I don't know, fundamentally, it still feels like, they're
Paul Dawalibi:gonna own a critical piece of the infrastructure. That to me should be more of a standard, rather
Paul Dawalibi:than an owned walled garden. Even if their goal is to write like, I, their, their playbook is going
Paul Dawalibi:to be obvious, right? They're gonna go to every developer under the sun, they're gonna say, hey,
Paul Dawalibi:instead of letting use the building code writing code to allow users to make their own avatars in
Paul Dawalibi:your game or your app, right, you just integrate our code, our system, all the functionality is
Paul Dawalibi:there, you don't need to worry about it. And users love it because they can bring their avatar from
Paul Dawalibi:the other things they're already signed up for. Right? Yeah, that's an easy argument to make. Long
Paul Dawalibi:term though. I don't know if that's good for the industry, right? Like, I think I've continued to
Paul Dawalibi:espouse the benefits of open standards. If we want to see a true Metaverse, right. In other words,
Paul Dawalibi:some kind of definition of what an avatar is, right? A structure a framework that companies like
Paul Dawalibi:Ready Player me can implement. But 10 Other companies can also implement if they want as well.
Paul Dawalibi:And the the, the nature, the nature of the standard makes it Emperor interoperable, not the
Paul Dawalibi:whim of a single Corporation,
Jeff Cohen:I see what you're saying you want them to be like a digital fashion company where it's
Jeff Cohen:like, anyone can technically anyone can make a pair of shoes. But Nike can make Nike shoes like
Jeff Cohen:Adidas, makes Adidas shoes. Yeah, Reebok three bucks. I think I agree with that. I think, you
Jeff Cohen:know, some sort of open source standard, and then you have all these different call them digital
Jeff Cohen:retailers, or digital fashion companies where it's like, yeah, you know, we're, we're creating this.
Jeff Cohen:Yeah, I mean, that's possible. And it's just, you know, people generally, people end up gravitating
Jeff Cohen:towards economic incentives, like who's going to create that open platform? And if they create it,
Jeff Cohen:why are they not going to want to make money off it?
Paul Dawalibi:It will be here. This is why I worry about this investment for the investors
Paul Dawalibi:because I think the natural urge of humans and what we saw if we look at the web two world and
Paul Dawalibi:how it evolved again, and I come back to this, right, there were some key players who are all for
Paul Dawalibi:profit commercial entities, right? That decided on a set of standards because it benefited all of
Paul Dawalibi:them, right, as opposed to benefiting one. And I think we will see something similar, where at some
Paul Dawalibi:point the for profit entities get together, and it's probably the meta versus right, the the plat
Paul Dawalibi:Metaverse, platforms themselves, they get together and say, Hey, let's agree on some kind of Avatar
Paul Dawalibi:framework. And everyone wins in the end, right? And, and instead of competing on all these things,
Paul Dawalibi:and hurting each other, we can all win, right? And so I think companies like this over time, get
Paul Dawalibi:marginalized a bit gets squeezed out if they if they're not on that same standard and I think
Paul Dawalibi:suspect the 900 apps and games that they're partnered with are kind of like nothing burgers,
Paul Dawalibi:right? That they're like, yeah, they're inconsequential. It's a big number. That sounds
Paul Dawalibi:nice, but fundamentally, there's not much there. So I worry a little bit from an investment
Paul Dawalibi:perspective, I probably would not have invested. Just, you know, given that I think the end game is
Paul Dawalibi:more open has to be for this vision to happen. It's fair, but I see short term how potentially
Paul Dawalibi:they benefit from this. Alright, let's let's move on. You mentioned you're a big proponent of
Paul Dawalibi:fashion in the metaverse Jeff so we have to do I think, a Metaverse fashion story here. And the
Paul Dawalibi:headline here is decentraland luxury marketplace. You NXT to host Metaverse Fashion Week
Paul Dawalibi:decentraland And you NXT are calling on fashion he says fashionistas to have their virtual
Paul Dawalibi:collections ready to show in the metaverse the fashion program, which is decentraland. First is
Paul Dawalibi:going to take place March 24 to 27th. It's essentially a Metaverse Fashion Week, they're
Paul Dawalibi:going to have catwalk shows, pop up shops, and after parties. They're calling on designers brands
Paul Dawalibi:to get collections ready. And this environment is going to be you know, what they say is this. The
Paul Dawalibi:Metaverse may represent a trillion dollars in annual revenue. According to this report. I
Paul Dawalibi:thought that was an interesting statistic. But this is the first we've heard I think of a
Paul Dawalibi:Metaverse Fashion Week, like the equivalent of a London Fashion Week or Paris Fashion Week or New
Paul Dawalibi:York Fashion Week. They also mentioned that you NXT here worked with Dolce and Gabbana to launch
Paul Dawalibi:their NF T collection. And I don't know, you know, we've talked a little bit about fashion, and the
Paul Dawalibi:metaverse colliding. Will we see? Maybe this is a stupid question. But you know what? I've been to a
Paul Dawalibi:few fashion weeks here and there around the world. Will we see Vogue covering decentraland Metaverse
Paul Dawalibi:Fashion Week?
Jeff Cohen:I think we I think we definitely will. Just because it's so novel. So you know, like
Jeff Cohen:anything else. It's the first of its kind will generally get covered. And, you know, I think we
Jeff Cohen:saw that with with fortnight and some of the concerts they did. It was like the first couple,
Jeff Cohen:it was covered by like the New York Times. And now it's sort of just occurrence that happens in the
Jeff Cohen:game decently frequently. And it's not as big of a public news story. But I do think the first
Jeff Cohen:fashion week in the metaverse is is absolutely going to get coverage because it's just for people
Jeff Cohen:who aren't as ingrained in this world as we are and listeners of this podcast are it it sounds
Jeff Cohen:crazy like it that is a headline that is going to catch people's attention. So I do think it will be
Jeff Cohen:it will be covered. I like this move for decentraland I mean, we I think in prior episodes
Jeff Cohen:we've given dissenter or at least I know I have given decentraland A little bit of hard time and
Jeff Cohen:it hasn't been clear to me what sort of drives people to that platform versus like a Roblox per
Jeff Cohen:se. And I think carving out a niche of fashion is an interesting you know, an interesting one I
Jeff Cohen:think we've seen other Roblox is sort of The Everything Store everything's there. You know,
Jeff Cohen:maybe fortnight has done a good job carving out the music scene a little bit. Obviously, there's a
Jeff Cohen:ton of other things that fortnight they've obviously been forward leading with with new
Jeff Cohen:movies and music, and maybe decentraland can kind of carve out a little bit of a niche of early
Jeff Cohen:adopters here with fashion. So I you know, in terms of risk reward and a business strategy for
Jeff Cohen:decentraland I think this is a very good one, you know, in
Paul Dawalibi:a world with $1,000, Balenciaga fortnight hoodies, right, I'll just, I'm hard to
Paul Dawalibi:disagree with you on this that, you know, especially going after luxury brands, this may be
Paul Dawalibi:by far the most profitable strategy of any sort of Metaverse kind of activation, right? If you can go
Paul Dawalibi:and get big designers, big fashion houses, all these luxury brands, I think you're going to
Paul Dawalibi:attract an audience who only care to collect Right? Like it doesn't even matter if it has
Paul Dawalibi:little utility. And an in like something that was first on the runway for Gucci and decentraland.
Paul Dawalibi:Will have buyers like guaranteed because there are people who will buy anything Gucci, right,
Paul Dawalibi:anything new, limited novel, whatever. And so your points a good one. I just I'm surprised. No one
Paul Dawalibi:else has courted the luxury brands in the same way earlier, right. Because the luxury brands have
Paul Dawalibi:shown an affinity to new technologies, right. They've shown that they have budget to try things
Paul Dawalibi:the Louie Vitanza the world have done lots of things in gaming, for example, right? Why
Jeff Cohen:can I give it so is it possible? Sorry. Is it possible that it's just about the
Jeff Cohen:demographics of the platform? No, I don't I don't know the specific demographics of decentraland.
Jeff Cohen:But given it's an early adopter kind of crypto gaming blockchain gaming marketplace, I'm guessing
Jeff Cohen:it's a bit of an older, more affluent crowd. Like, I think some of the collabs one of the criticisms
Jeff Cohen:we've had of sort of fortnight and robots when they've done collaborations with luxury brands is
Jeff Cohen:sort of like, is that really the demographic? I know the novelty and you got some press, but is
Jeff Cohen:putting a Gucci collaboration in a game where the average kid is a nine year old boy, like, what
Jeff Cohen:does that really do for you besides saying, Hey, we have a metaphor strategy? Like, is that really
Jeff Cohen:going to sell handbags? And shoes? I'm not convinced. And I'm not sure if the data is out
Jeff Cohen:there yet that that's convincing the CMOS, that, that that's good ROI on that spend. But if you
Jeff Cohen:have something like Central and which may be skews a bit of a different demographic, I could see that
Jeff Cohen:maybe being a reason why you're bringing it in here rather than
Paul Dawalibi:there. It's a it's a worthy argument. You know, I think the more and more I
Paul Dawalibi:see of this, the more and more I'm starting to believe, though, that I think we underestimate.
Paul Dawalibi:And you've I know you exaggerated to make a point, but so I'll exaggerate to make this similar point.
Paul Dawalibi:We've underestimated like the nine year old audience in the sense that like, they've grown up
Paul Dawalibi:in this, you know, fashion drops supreme Hypebeast kind of culture, right? The latest, their Jordans
Paul Dawalibi:or Yeezys or whatever. And, and so, you know, I think the Gucci's of the world, the Dolce and
Paul Dawalibi:Gabbana is the, you know, these old fashion houses that are burnt been around for 100 years. Right,
Paul Dawalibi:but they want a part of this. I think, in some ways, maybe they want that audience, right. So it
Paul Dawalibi:could be that you're absolutely right. It's a question of demographics. And they don't the nine
Paul Dawalibi:year olds aren't the buyers. That's the you know, this older more, but it could also just be that
Paul Dawalibi:we've completely underestimated those nine year olds.
Jeff Cohen:That is, I mean, that is entirely possible.
Paul Dawalibi:I do think, though, that the I guess here's my question is, does decentraland
Paul Dawalibi:cornered the market on luxury brands? Right from a Metaverse perspective?
Jeff Cohen:No. And I think I think it may be in the best interest of these luxury brands to only
Jeff Cohen:go to one platform. So I think if this is successful, you'll probably see this in other
Jeff Cohen:platforms. You know, same way we've seen it with music and other platforms as well after fortnight
Jeff Cohen:kind of popularized it. So I don't think they'll be able to this was kind of the question I was
Jeff Cohen:gonna pose to you like, even if this is successful, which we sort of both, it sounds like
Jeff Cohen:think it probably will be in terms of impressions, hype, whatever, news articles, coverage. What what
Jeff Cohen:then happens, a bunch of people go to the central end for these three days or whatever, probably
Jeff Cohen:most of them check out check in the first day, and don't go back. What happens after that, like, does
Jeff Cohen:this grow the user base? Do people do they build like a sort of like a really high end fashion mall
Jeff Cohen:in decentraland? Like, what's, what's the end game? Or what is decentraland? Getting out of
Jeff Cohen:this?
Paul Dawalibi:All of the above, but like, if the if the, if the analogy is Paris Fashion Week,
Paul Dawalibi:right? Then you're going to do it twice a year, not once a year, right? All the big houses will
Paul Dawalibi:have collections twice a year, maybe three times a year, if you throw in a you know, a cruise
Paul Dawalibi:collection or something like that. And, and, and, and retail, essentially Metaverse retail to go
Paul Dawalibi:along with it. Like, to me, that's it. And this is where I actually kind of think that if
Paul Dawalibi:decentraland is first and best with this, it becomes hard to displace a little bit in the same
Paul Dawalibi:way. Like, I can't go and create. It's hard to go and create a competitor to New York Fashion Week.
Paul Dawalibi:Right? Like, I just can't start that up. And there's a respect among the designers. It's the
Paul Dawalibi:biggest show. It's right. Like, no one wants to show at Paul Dawalibi Fashion Week, right? Like,
Paul Dawalibi:it's just
Jeff Cohen:you don't know that. I don't know.
Paul Dawalibi:But I suspect New York Fashion Week will still be the more the more popular
Paul Dawalibi:destination. So in some ways, like, I think one of the criticisms I've had of some of these Metaverse
Paul Dawalibi:platforms if you want to call them that is they're not that sticky. Right like I can go create an
Paul Dawalibi:account on Roblox and in fortnight and in decentraland and and wherever else and everything
Paul Dawalibi:under the sun we want to call even vaguely a Metaverse and move between them use them all
Paul Dawalibi:right, there's nothing that really ties me to one Yeah, some network effects because my friends are
Paul Dawalibi:here or there but friends easily move to right there's nothing really blocking. This to me is the
Paul Dawalibi:start of starting to see some real stickiness right if you can get all the fashion brands there
Paul Dawalibi:and this is the only place you can get their goods, their virtual goods and this is the only
Paul Dawalibi:place you can see the latest and greatest. Maybe there's the start of something, you know
Paul Dawalibi:relatively sticky there.
Jeff Cohen:I see your argument but i don't i don't know that sort of thing. I believe it could
Jeff Cohen:I just think the fashion houses would be incentivized to put their goods in any of these
Jeff Cohen:meta verses, particularly whichever one had the most user. So I'm not, I'm not as convinced that
Jeff Cohen:you would get that customer lock in the question I would have for you. So I agree that there isn't a
Jeff Cohen:ton of stickiness in these meta verses currently. I guess the question I have, obviously that's bad
Jeff Cohen:for them as businesses. But isn't that sort of what we want as the future we see as the metaverse
Jeff Cohen:is probably this multi Metaverse type future where it's Hey, I jumped into Roblox, then I jumped into
Jeff Cohen:decentraland. And I just have this presence that can you know, it kind of comes with me to each
Jeff Cohen:one. Isn't that sort of exactly what we want, or what we
Paul Dawalibi:think is going to happen? Yeah, you're in an ideal world. You're right. Actually,
Paul Dawalibi:it's a great it's a great counterpoint, right. And then ideal world, you don't want them to be that
Paul Dawalibi:sticky. But, but them being interconnected. And interoperable is not at odds with them being
Paul Dawalibi:sticky, right? It's like the world has different shopping malls, connected by roads. But I may go
Paul Dawalibi:to this one mall, because it has an Apple Store and the other mall doesn't right like that you
Paul Dawalibi:could still have stickiness within a specific platform, even if it's totally interconnected with
Paul Dawalibi:other platforms. So I see the business benefit of trying to create some stickiness, not just sort of
Paul Dawalibi:throwing your hands in the air and saying, hey, you know, we could we'll never be sticky because
Paul Dawalibi:this is all going to be one big Metaverse so like,
Jeff Cohen:right? Of course, as businesses they have you know, they're they're obviously trying to
Jeff Cohen:keep people in their metaverse.
Paul Dawalibi:Jeff, I can't think of a better way to wrap up the surface of that it was just I feel
Paul Dawalibi:like the these episodes fly by. And I hope they're always enjoyable for the people who listen for you
Paul Dawalibi:guys who are listening. Just if you love the show, do us a favor. Go leave a review, five star review
Paul Dawalibi:on Apple podcasts, Google Play Spotify, wherever you get it. And subscribe to the podcast like hit
Paul Dawalibi:the Follow button or subscribe button wherever it is, costs you nothing. And you make sure you get
Paul Dawalibi:the episode right when it comes out. I know Jeff and I really appreciate it. Jeff, thank you as
Paul Dawalibi:always. And we will see you guys next week. Thank you. Yes.
Unknown:Thanks for joining us here on meta business. Make sure to subscribe to this podcast
Unknown:everywhere you get your podcasts, leave a five star review and tell your friends, family and
Unknown:colleagues all about us. Also, make sure to follow metta TV on all socials to get more of the best
Unknown:Metaverse content anywhere. Tune in every week for another episode of metta business.