Artwork for podcast Blueprints of Disruption
Social Justice in St. John's
Episode 11827th March 2024 • Blueprints of Disruption • Rabble Rousers' Cooperative
00:00:00 01:00:03

Share Episode

Shownotes

The Social Justice Co-operative in St. John's Newfoundland/Labrador has a long as resilient history. Our interview with co-chair Kerri Claire tells of a personal political journey and an organizational one. Both of which have led to an impressive collective making a meaningful impact.

With limited resources, these folks are able to contribute to wide array of local initiatives. And most importantly, they do this in a way that value members' voices and set models for community care.

__________

All of our content is free - made possible by the generous sponsorships of our Patrons. If you would like to support us: Patreon

Follow us on Instagram

Resources:

Transcripts

Speaker:

Greetings friends. My name is Jess McLean and I'm here to provide you with some blueprints

Speaker:

of disruption. This weekly podcast is dedicated to amplifying the work of activists, examining

Speaker:

power structures, and sharing the success stories from the grassroots. Through these discussions

Speaker:

we hope to provide folks with the tools and the inspiration they need to start to dismantle

Speaker:

capitalism, decolonize our spaces, and bring about the political revolution that we know

Speaker:

we need. Welcome for Try Number Two, Carrie. Can you introduce yourself to the audience?

Speaker:

Hello, my name is Carrie Clare Neal. I'm co-chair for the Social Justice Cooperative in Newfoundland,

Speaker:

Labrador. Calling in from St. John's, Newfoundland, Labrador, also known as Iggongook. The Social

Speaker:

Justice Co-op. According to your Twitter, this is a member-owned, nonprofit, anti-capitalist

Speaker:

grassroots organization. That has a lot to unpack. It's at like, at first glance, you're like,

Speaker:

oh, I can kind of picture what you guys probably get up to. We'll talk about that in details.

Speaker:

But what's it mean to be a member owned nonprofit, especially when you're talking about social

Speaker:

justice? I thought, you know, that kind of piqued my interest there. Yeah, I think we're the

Speaker:

only advocacy, not a cooperative incorporated in the province. And I don't hear about a lot

Speaker:

of them. in like other places in Canada. But it's a really cool model. I mean, I think,

Speaker:

you know, we're familiar with like worker owned co-ops, housing co-ops. I think it is like

Speaker:

a very kind of anarchist model in itself because it's kind of like everyone has a share in,

Speaker:

you know, the organization and everyone has like one member, one vote. So everyone is like

Speaker:

kind of equal. It's not like corporation where some people have more shares so they have more

Speaker:

say. Um, and generally the members like, don't get like dividends. Um, like the profits will

Speaker:

go back into the, um, cooperative in different ways. Maybe like, yeah, increasing people's

Speaker:

salaries of a worker co-op or with housing, like I think it would go into repair. Um, but

Speaker:

yeah, I guess as a nonprofit, we don't have profit. Um, but our money is kind of collectively

Speaker:

decided, um, by our members who like vote for our board. Um, and. We definitely like take

Speaker:

an extra mile to like bring members in on a lot of our financial decisions and just different

Speaker:

ways like how we govern ourselves. And there are like, because we're cooperative, there

Speaker:

are specific like rules about like how many people you need to change the official rule

Speaker:

or that kind of thing. It's I think a very democratic and equitable way to organize. Okay, I'm going

Speaker:

to ask you about that a little bit later because I want to know how you came about getting into

Speaker:

this type of organizing, because looking through your history, it's eclectic in terms of political

Speaker:

activism. You've run for the NDP, and you've sat on boards, which are far more formal institutions,

Speaker:

typically. Did this come from a reaction to that experience or were you always doing this

Speaker:

alongside the more institutional political work? Yeah, I guess like when I was a young 20 something,

Speaker:

I would like, I started in activism, kind of like trying to get more women into like playing

Speaker:

punk music. Like I was going to a lot of music shows and it was a lot of like men in the stage

Speaker:

and women in the audience. Um, and then I, from there, I was like really interested in, like,

Speaker:

I started getting into like feminist activism and using my voice more, like getting more

Speaker:

on Twitter and, you know, concerns about like the oil and gas here in the province, and I

Speaker:

ended up actually losing a non job that I got in a nonprofit that like helped women get into

Speaker:

the trade sector because of like tweets I was making about like. politicians and the oil

Speaker:

and gas industry and like its impact on climate and, you know, corruption and yeah. And I was

Speaker:

like very public about that. I kind of made this like, it was quite a moment of like, okay,

Speaker:

do I like be quiet and just like stop using this and like kind of just like become a career

Speaker:

oriented person or do I? go public about what just happened to me and just kind of lean into

Speaker:

it. And I decided to lean in. And it just happened there was a by-election happening near where

Speaker:

I lived. And the NDP were kind of like, hey, we're looking for a candidate. Looks like you

Speaker:

don't have a job. And I was kind of like, I had my tippy toes in there, but I decided to.

Speaker:

to go for it and I ended up running against two of like the richest men in the province.

Speaker:

And because it was a by-election, there was a lot of attention on it. So there was like

Speaker:

all these debates and it was... Was that provincially? Yeah, yeah. It's always interesting playing

Speaker:

against the big players, eh? Like the campaigns must have been starkly different. I find it

Speaker:

interesting though, you kind of get in a little bit of... social media hot water and the NDP

Speaker:

come to you because we've heard like many stories and I know you've had your own experience with

Speaker:

them not being particularly fond of people who stir the pot. And I'm reading an article in

Speaker:

which you're explaining why you're running for the NDP. And part of it, one of your quotes

Speaker:

there, it was, you know, you weren't doing the wrong thing. You were simply working for the

Speaker:

wrong organization. And I had... can help a cringe and I'm sure you do looking back on

Speaker:

that, that clearly the NDP isn't the right organization for you either. But we learn and then we organize

Speaker:

like anarchists I suppose is the natural cycle of that experience. But yeah, reading back

Speaker:

on that, I just wanted to maybe allow you to reflect on. trying to find a space where you

Speaker:

could act in ways that you thought were appropriate, that were meaningful. Yeah, the NEP don't want

Speaker:

anything to do with me anymore. They have blocked me on Twitter. They totally think, yeah, they

Speaker:

have to distance themselves from me as much as possible. Cause I guess the more, I think

Speaker:

I was always saying pretty radical things, but I guess as my, Twitter following has grown.

Speaker:

I get a lot more attention on the things that I say. So there have been a few things that

Speaker:

have gone viral that liberals don't necessarily like. And, you know. Like, fuck the police,

Speaker:

right? Was one of them. Yeah. Exactly. Mostly, yeah, about cops and images of cop cars on

Speaker:

fire. Yeah. Totally appropriate. I'm serious. Maybe I haven't always used the most, the nicest

Speaker:

times. Yeah, I guess a cop died and it was being shared with this blue line symbol. And I responded

Speaker:

with, fuck the police. And that did not go over well. I mean, you could have put any cab. And

Speaker:

that's how I got kicked off the border region. It could have also been. But yeah, after I

Speaker:

ran for the NDP, I guess, the social justice co-op was looking to hire someone. And that's

Speaker:

kind of when I got involved in that org. So it was all kind of standard. So finding you

Speaker:

when you're kind of in trouble, they're like, ooh, I like that, right? It's not always a

Speaker:

deterrent. The right people found you. So now you're co-chair over there and do folks organize

Speaker:

a lot around defunding the police? We have... Definitely, yeah, over the years, I guess,

Speaker:

we do a lot of different organizing. We've supported like a Cancel Canada Day events. We are doing

Speaker:

like a prison pen call project where we try and like, build relationship with people in

Speaker:

prison. And yeah, I would say right now we're doing a 10 city for change. We're involved

Speaker:

with a collective that's helping people living in tents in our city. And that is a very like

Speaker:

harm reduction, ACAB has, I mean, we're constantly dealing with the police and seeing how they're

Speaker:

treating people. And showing up, I guess, at protests where police presence is really strong.

Speaker:

Like today, a few of us went down and supported the crab harvesters where there's like, yeah,

Speaker:

police and like SWAT teams, big guns, they had the batons. And like no one in that, no one

Speaker:

at the protest was had weapons, you know? I think it's a pretty good sign of that you're

Speaker:

doing the right kind of trouble when you end up confronting the police. That's a pretty

Speaker:

good barometer for that. I gotta be honest, I have very little idea in my head when I think

Speaker:

of even just the Atlantic in general, what it's like there. But I guess... What's the environment

Speaker:

like when talking about these kind of cultural things like ACAB and all these things? How

Speaker:

receptive are people there, I guess? I honestly have no clue. It's funny, the establishment,

Speaker:

of course, is all about the police. But I do think a lot of people don't like the police.

Speaker:

There was an article that went around about a year ago, kind of encouraging people to call

Speaker:

the police more. It was like this R&C campaign and all of the comments were just people complaining

Speaker:

about times when they called the police and they couldn't do anything. It's just how incompetent

Speaker:

they are and useless. And I do think in rural areas, people aren't super trusting of the

Speaker:

police. It really can be that one issue that we should all be able to relate on. But other

Speaker:

than ACAB then, because obviously all cops are bastards everywhere, what about other kinds

Speaker:

of politics? Can you lay the groundwork for folks who aren't familiar with Newfoundland

Speaker:

politics? Is it generally conservative? Is was your election always going to be an uphill

Speaker:

battle regardless of the budget constraints of running against two rich, presumably white

Speaker:

men? Yeah, it's. I think there's a lot of cronyism here. Like the liberals, we have liberals and

Speaker:

PC's our progressive conservatives are like our two main parties. And it's very much like

Speaker:

they're the same party. Whatever one's in power, they do the same thing. Like tax cuts for the

Speaker:

rich and like a lot of money going to like massive corporations who take them out to fancy dinners.

Speaker:

The oil and gas industry is very important to our province. We have our own offshore oil,

Speaker:

but also a lot of people work over in Alberta. And for a long time, we hated conservatives

Speaker:

federally because of some stuff that happened under Harper. But we're definitely, we just

Speaker:

elected our first federal conservative in the last election and in a long time. And people

Speaker:

are expecting more of that is going to happen. St. John's was a stronghold for NEP for a long

Speaker:

time, federally. And there's a couple seats. Right now we have one provincial seat in the

Speaker:

city that's NEP and two in Labrador. It's only like five seats in Labrador. You describe your

Speaker:

organizing as anti-capitalist things, and you've described talking about tent city organizing

Speaker:

around maybe not prison abolition, but the harm reduction factor there. Is that a consensus

Speaker:

among your collective? Would you all label yourself as anti-capitalists? And is that a hard sell

Speaker:

in Newfoundland? That's a great question. I, we do have this like revolution of care manifesto

Speaker:

that kind of like directly names capitalism as the big kind of that makes us sick and is

Speaker:

kind of dividing us. And we need to take care of each other. And you know, have more co-ops

Speaker:

and work together, yeah, have different economies that are more, yeah, thinking about more about

Speaker:

the environment and each other. But we're also trying to be really decentralized and we do

Speaker:

like a lot of different things. Like we advocate for like sidewalks, no clearing. And we're

Speaker:

out on the streets supporting Palestine and we're, we have a book club and we... I think

Speaker:

we're trying to hopefully bring people in on a lot of issues and we're not like you have

Speaker:

to be anti-capitalist to join. But definitely I think enough people in the space are anti-capitalist

Speaker:

generally that I think it opens people up more to the idea that the way that we're organizing

Speaker:

this economy around like profit extraction and destroying the environment is like not helpful.

Speaker:

Okay. I have a question because we just interviewed. someone from an anarchist collective. And one

Speaker:

of the staying points with me was the practice of truly listening to everybody's voice and

Speaker:

allowing them to take action as they feel comfortable, as they feel is effective, that is meaningful

Speaker:

to them. Is that how you came about doing so many things? You probably just named a fraction

Speaker:

because I will link people to your Linktree, which is extensive. And, you know, I'm asking

Speaker:

you, are you involved in this and that before we started? Activist film collection, mutual

Speaker:

aid, the Black Mutual Aid Fund, and all the other things that you've already mentioned.

Speaker:

So are these kind of visions of all of your members and you just allow that? Yes, go for

Speaker:

it. You know, book club? Sure, start it. without having to all come to a consensus on each one

Speaker:

of these activities or even requiring the labor of each one of your members? Absolutely. We

Speaker:

kind of consider ourselves like an activist incubator. So if you're really passionate about

Speaker:

something and you want support, we're here to help. And as long as it kind of broadly aligns

Speaker:

with our values, we do have some consideration about who we're supporting and how. But I kind

Speaker:

of believe that Capitalism is such a massive, it's in every part of our life. And we need

Speaker:

to like, there are a lot of different ways that we can tear it down. And sometimes we need

Speaker:

to think about really immediate things, like getting people food when they're living out

Speaker:

in the streets. And then, yeah, sometimes we're thinking about really long-term things like

Speaker:

climate change. And how do we... you know, elect different people or how do we give people more

Speaker:

willing to try direct action in different ways? Um, how do we just even just build community

Speaker:

where we have enough trust that we could take things a step further. Um, yeah. So we also

Speaker:

do a lot of like socializing as part of our movement. This kind of sounds like the dream

Speaker:

to me. Like this is like what you guys are doing here. It's checks off so many boxes of. things

Speaker:

that we need, you know? And honestly, I wish that more communities had organizations like

Speaker:

this, because this kind of sounds quite like the blueprint of the work that needs to be

Speaker:

done. I guess, because you mentioned like when you joined it already had been around, right?

Speaker:

Can you tell me a bit about like, like what you've learned of like, what were the early

Speaker:

days of this? Like, how did this... get started to hike off the ground. This was my comic book

Speaker:

reference. We need the origin story. Well, thank you. That was very kind. Yeah, I definitely

Speaker:

feel good about the strategies that we have. SJC has a really interesting history. So it

Speaker:

originally came from out of Oxfam way back in the 60s. People like. got second mortgages

Speaker:

on their homes and like bought this building and like, we're like, we need to do organizing

Speaker:

that I guess connects like what's happening locally with what's happening globally. So

Speaker:

we're really interested in making those connections and yeah, advocating in the province. And then

Speaker:

in the 2000s under Harper, there were some rules around like what Oxfam could do as a charity,

Speaker:

like they couldn't do as much political advocacy. So they like lost some money and like pulled

Speaker:

out of. Newfoundland and Oxfam did. Oxfam pulled out. Cause yeah, they own the building. I guess

Speaker:

they had staff. Um, so everyone got laid off and the, the building was like sold to Oxfam

Speaker:

Canada with this idea that they'd have to sell back to it for a dollar to like a like-minded

Speaker:

organization if they ever like pulled out of the region. So the social justice co-op was

Speaker:

formed in like 2010. officially incorporated in 2013 to take over that building and kind

Speaker:

of continue that organizing under a new name and in that negotiation, like the building

Speaker:

burned down tragically. But, Oxfam Canada did give some like insurance money, like $50,000

Speaker:

to the SJC, which is like an amazing little like pot of gold that really helped like. the

Speaker:

organization to like hire a staff and like be independent. Because yeah, we don't rely on

Speaker:

government funding, which makes it a lot easier for us to have that voice. We do like take

Speaker:

this for certain projects, but like our core funding is all member driven. We do like a

Speaker:

monthly, we encourage our members and allies to do monthly donations. And that pays for

Speaker:

like our staff and like our core operations. being an incubator earlier and I wanted to

Speaker:

ask you, who wouldn't you support? Because, and that like, it can be a funny question and

Speaker:

some obvious answers perhaps, but again, I'm going back to the discussion we most recently

Speaker:

had and the need that you mentioned to bring in as many people as possible, but there has

Speaker:

to be a line. And I kind of wanted to ask that of our previous guests when we're talking about.

Speaker:

doing that and including like all voices because the solution has to be a collective of ideas.

Speaker:

But you know, how do you maintain a safe space for the people that you've already brought

Speaker:

in that you need to thrive without being too exclusive? Yeah, it's something that we've

Speaker:

been talking about a lot. Like right now in book club we're reading Let This Radicalize

Speaker:

You by Kelly Hayes and Marion Pabe and they kind of talk about like you have to build a

Speaker:

movement, not a clubhouse. So it's okay to organize with people that you don't agree with. But

Speaker:

I think they're also to be aligned in like, if you're advocating to like harm some of the

Speaker:

people that we're organizing with, then that then they're not in a safe space anymore. So

Speaker:

we have kind of bumped heads with people who are been involved in like trucker convoy style

Speaker:

organizing, and kind of concerned about, you know, the way that they're framing trans people.

Speaker:

Um, so as an example, so I think that would be, that's a tricky, like so far we have excluded

Speaker:

people that we know to be in the convoy from our circles. Um, cause some of them have been

Speaker:

showing up to tent city for like, and it's been an interesting of like, should we? work like

Speaker:

they're showing up bringing food and helping clean up like that's great. But should we work

Speaker:

with them? But then they're also like saying mean things about us. So we're kind of just

Speaker:

like trying to not like we've taken the strategy of just like not really talking to them and

Speaker:

like letting them do their own thing and not engaging, I guess. And keeping them out of

Speaker:

our core circles. Yeah. That's tough, especially when you see coalescing around certain issues

Speaker:

like defunding the police, perhaps, because of the experiences that they're all having.

Speaker:

And things like tent city, of course, not all aid is equal when it comes to folks helping

Speaker:

the unhoused community. We know that, right? Like some don't go in with the right motives

Speaker:

at all. But yeah, it's just a question I wanted to pose when that is the approach, right? Eventually

Speaker:

we do have to bring everybody along. So how we best do that would be from the anarchist

Speaker:

perspective, I suppose, but finding that balance as well, right? So that we can maintain safe

Speaker:

spaces. I know some people roll their eyes when I use that phrase, but it's important because

Speaker:

that's how you get every voice. And I'm going through, I warned you, I was going to go through

Speaker:

like your meeting guidelines. I'm telling you everything you need to know is like on their

Speaker:

link tree, including like the many different organizations in and around Newfoundland. St.

Speaker:

John's specifically, but it's really eclectic and yeah, so I'm on there and I'm trying to

Speaker:

figure out how you guys might do things differently and it's interesting folks should I'll link

Speaker:

specifically to that because we're talking about it, but You have mechanisms written in things

Speaker:

like the ten-second rule and Reminding people that silence is okay The ten-second rule is

Speaker:

let's say you're the person that always talks like me. I always have a question. I always

Speaker:

could contribute, could, you know, should I? Let me wait 10 seconds and see if anybody else

Speaker:

has something to say, because not everybody is comfortable being the first person. It takes

Speaker:

a few seconds for people to build up the courage to speak. So you just remind people silence

Speaker:

is okay. We can sit here staring at each other for a few minutes until a light bulb goes off,

Speaker:

like a real one, not just to fill the space. because how many meetings have you been in

Speaker:

where people are really just regurgitating what someone else has already said or simply just

Speaker:

agreeing, like standing up to take up space to agree. And it's nice when people agree with

Speaker:

you, but it's also like maybe some tension is needed. You know, maybe you don't need a cheering

Speaker:

section. You need somebody to just sit there for a minute and come up with a different idea.

Speaker:

But yeah, do you think, are there anything? And are there any other things that you folks

Speaker:

do that you think have helped you create an environment where so many different ideas come

Speaker:

up and are encouraged and then acted on? You know, they're not just, it's not just a think

Speaker:

tank. You're turning a lot of these into action, which means people are coming up with ideas

Speaker:

and then other people are volunteering their time to make it happen. So you guys are doing

Speaker:

something right. And it starts sometimes in those meetings. Yeah, I would say meetings

Speaker:

are like 80% of what we do. I'm sure a lot of organizers feel that. And being really mindful

Speaker:

about like making it an enjoyable is something that we've yet put a lot into. I would say

Speaker:

like, when we started meeting with the check-in circle, so we go around, like on Zoom, we might

Speaker:

go alphabetically so folks know like where they are in the circle. and kind of say like, you

Speaker:

know, what are your names, your pronouns and how are you feeling coming into the meeting?

Speaker:

And maybe there's like a icebreaker question. What was the last protest you went to? And

Speaker:

that some people don't like that. They're like, oh, we're spending all this time wasted when

Speaker:

we could be talking about the action items. And it's like, but that's actually really important

Speaker:

to like understanding, like knowing each other where we're all coming from. how much capacity

Speaker:

we have right now to like be involved. And you know what's bothering them or like what's on

Speaker:

their mind. And we also do like a check out circle. So at the end we kind of say like how

Speaker:

did you feel about the meeting? Were there any like actions that you're planning to take on

Speaker:

or need some support with? And I think those like relational pieces I think are often Um,

Speaker:

I went to a meeting like a couple of years ago, organized by some union and they were going

Speaker:

to kind of do like a green new deal for Newfoundland. It was like a people's deal. I can't remember

Speaker:

what it was called, but, but 60 people in the room and they, no introductions, like I just,

Speaker:

and you know, how can you share ideas if you're not like taking that time to be like, Oh hi,

Speaker:

this is me. Like where I'm coming from. if some of those are even designed to get your input?

Speaker:

You know? Yeah, it's something that people forget a lot is that the importance of building your

Speaker:

organizing spaces into communities, right? Like it's more than about just the business end

Speaker:

of things, you know? It's the relationships, interpersonal relationships, that's part of

Speaker:

it. That's part of the movement. And that's how you build something that's going to last,

Speaker:

be successful. I've seen some, like, I'm a part of organizations that very much don't do that.

Speaker:

And people, I find very quickly, find that they don't really have a voice in there, they can't

Speaker:

really, they don't feel comfortable contributing, communicating, and they end up leaving pretty

Speaker:

quickly. They start thinking, why, it's not even worth it for me to show up to this, and

Speaker:

do they even really? need me here? Does my presence do anything other than count as a number of

Speaker:

how many people were here? No. So I'm gone. And so building that kind of environment is

Speaker:

crucial. Absolutely. And then everyone has ownership too. If it's the book club was their idea,

Speaker:

even if they don't completely execute it on their own or even at all, right? Like you don't

Speaker:

necessarily have to be the person to do it, to come up with the idea. Although you should

Speaker:

be willing to do some of that. But there's ownership and pride rather than just taking orders or

Speaker:

having a real a model of activism that you just kind of want people to step into and fill that

Speaker:

role. And, you know, it's like a formula. A lot of organizations you walk into, it's this

Speaker:

formula. There's almost a ladder you can see, maybe not of power, but of progression. And

Speaker:

It just feels really stifling. It just feels like we're mimicking some of the institutions

Speaker:

sometimes that we don't want to, that we've railed against, but we just don't know another

Speaker:

way of doing it. So it's, I love that our interview actually got delayed until we had the discussion

Speaker:

with the anarchist. Because I think it set the stage for just understanding a different design,

Speaker:

especially for small... community groups. Well, I don't know how big are you? How big is your

Speaker:

organization? It's pretty small. I mean, I guess we have like 200 members, official, like shareholding

Speaker:

members. I'm sorry. Pretty small. We're talking about St. John's, Newfoundland. So what is

Speaker:

the population of St. John's? 200 members is fantastic for like, I'm in Toronto, you know,

Speaker:

like there's not that many organizations that got up to those numbers. And we have a lot

Speaker:

more people here. You know, 200, that's honestly incredible. Oh, thank you. That's, that's a

Speaker:

good perspective. I mean, not everyone is like super active, you know, um, you get a membership

Speaker:

for life kind of thing, um, and right now we're raising like $25,000 a year. Um, we did just

Speaker:

have like all of our money stolen. Um, but. Sorry, what? We have recovered. Yeah, about

Speaker:

a year ago, I should say. Well, who's asking if the kick, do we know who stole your money?

Speaker:

Yes, someone that we've really trusted. They were our treasurer, they were on the board.

Speaker:

They came to every meeting, our birthdays. Yeah, over two years. I am so sorry, cause that must've

Speaker:

hurt, honestly. Yeah. It was a real wake up call. Like I think, yeah, I've been on the

Speaker:

board and I was so focused on like the activism part of it and not, yeah, we didn't do good

Speaker:

oversight on the financial side of it and really like trusted this person who was kind of in

Speaker:

a financial, facing their own financial issues. And I guess like the temptation was there.

Speaker:

and you know they were presenting treasurer's reports and everything but like we weren't

Speaker:

looking at the bank statements and yeah finally like we did discover it um and it almost it

Speaker:

definitely like was really intense like that decision about like do we go to the police

Speaker:

was really hard and we decided not to because we didn't believe that it like went by

Speaker:

who maybe haven't been with us for every, you know, defend the police action kind of came

Speaker:

out of the woodwork and were like, what do you mean you're not going to the police? I can

Speaker:

see that, yep. Yeah, but actually I think being a cooperative kind of also helped us in that

Speaker:

moment because we were able to put forward a plan that our members were able to like give

Speaker:

input on and vote on. And I think... We like had a series of membership meetings and like

Speaker:

we were really transparent. Like we haven't shared everything publicly yet. We are hoping

Speaker:

to like put out a fraud investigation report by the summer, but we were really transparent

Speaker:

with our members and let them also talk about like, you know, what they thought was going

Speaker:

to happen. And thankfully, yeah, the, the ACAVRs in the group. We had really strong voices and

Speaker:

we're really passionate and we were able to put together a Transformer of Justice Committee

Speaker:

who are kind of helping us now, like through that process. I absolutely love this moment

Speaker:

even though it was the last thing I wanted to hear because you wanna be able to trust anyone

Speaker:

that comes forward and is willing to do the work. I'm a real believer in that. But oversight,

Speaker:

lesson learned there. But to not go to the police, to practice what you preach, that's so important.

Speaker:

And it wasn't that you just didn't go to the police as a matter of principle either, you

Speaker:

provided an alternative model for people to follow. Next time, hopefully there's no next

Speaker:

time like that. But in their lives, in their conflict resolution and how they can envision

Speaker:

a world without... police intervention for everything. So, because I imagine the temptation, we're

Speaker:

all raised to be like, no, you wronged me, bad guys, call the cops. It's very inherent in

Speaker:

how most people are raised. And so, and then when you're personally wronged, we often quite

Speaker:

see people, even though they will take the stand of defund the police, they'll call the police

Speaker:

or they'll cheer them on as a solution. And... We've talked about that before, that simply

Speaker:

just reinforces the ideology that you spend so much time trying to break down. And I don't

Speaker:

think there's any truer way to reinforce it than to be that example. Because some people

Speaker:

scramble to even envision, like, what is that going to look like? What do we do if we don't

Speaker:

call the cops? You just let her go? You know, and it's... There are other ways to kind of

Speaker:

work through the problem. Plus, additionally, it's a testament to the strength of your group.

Speaker:

That kind of thing can really... tear a group apart, you know, the fact that you came out

Speaker:

on the other side of it and you know, you're still here, you're still doing the work. That

Speaker:

that in and of itself says a lot about, you know, the dynamics that have been fostered

Speaker:

there. Yeah, definitely. Like when we were going through it, I was like, do we just like, yeah,

Speaker:

close this, start fresh? And then I was like, you know what, like, we've already built so

Speaker:

much, we're gonna have to put in better financial oversight policies than any other thing that

Speaker:

we do. We kind of just have to keep moving. We survived the building burning down. We can

Speaker:

survive having all our money stolen. And we, incredibly, a lot of our monthly donors did

Speaker:

not leave us. And so after just, I think eight months, we were able to hire back our staff

Speaker:

at the same salary. And... Having staff is so important to our organization. And I just feel

Speaker:

so lucky that like, it does feel like we're bouncing back. And that people like trusted

Speaker:

us to like figure it out and trusted the plan that we put forward. It was like really hard,

Speaker:

even on the board, like not everyone was a cab and you know, people thought like. Oh, like

Speaker:

you have, it's in the law that you have to go to the police if someone steals from you. And

Speaker:

it's like, well, actually, it's not like that is a choice. And we did meet with lawyers and

Speaker:

they were like, you know, you're probably not going to get your money back, even if you want

Speaker:

that route and you're going to have to spend like years going through that route. And, you

Speaker:

know, are we as going to be motivated to do that? Like, are we going to force our members

Speaker:

to go through that? Like, no, like. And thankfully, like. Actually, in our book club, we were doing

Speaker:

a lot of prison abolition reading. And some of our members started a transformative justice

Speaker:

working group probably a year before it happened, just to kind of start thinking through, like,

Speaker:

how do we resolve conflict outside of police? So, like, thankfully, we also had that, like,

Speaker:

people in place who were like, I I'm not an expert on this, but I'm willing to talk to

Speaker:

experts and The NL Human Rights Council here also just got funding for restorative justice.

Speaker:

Um, worker, like people who were, yeah, supporting restorative justice and teaching people about

Speaker:

it. So we were able to like lean on that. And yeah, um, I think having that in place already

Speaker:

really made it seem for people like more possible that we could do this, um, without the police.

Speaker:

I meant to bring this up earlier and now we're talking about police again. But just recently

Speaker:

a video went around from yesterday. So the same thing you went to earlier today, but clearly

Speaker:

a little more heated where police were using horses and backing them up into. Fishermen,

Speaker:

I guess the fishermen were there. They had. Although that is interesting, a cab worth worthy

Speaker:

of discussion, and we can. I kind of wanted to talk a little bit about the action itself

Speaker:

that we didn't get into because I was telling you, we don't get that a lot. Our farmers rarely

Speaker:

come up to protest anything anymore. It's been a very, very long time here in Ontario. And

Speaker:

I cannot remember the last time there was a decent effort to shut down the proceedings

Speaker:

happening inside the legislature. even when we know the most damaging things are coming

Speaker:

down the pipe and rallies have happened, never has a circle been formed, never have exits

Speaker:

and entrances been blocked. Like not a long time. You might have to go back to the Harris

Speaker:

days of action, 20 odd years ago or more now, maybe 30. Ugh. And what are you laughing at,

Speaker:

Santiago? Don't you dare. But I thought that was, and I'm not even sure what they're protesting,

Speaker:

so I don't know if I support them or not. But you're down there, you seem to, but... Besides

Speaker:

that, they're trying to stop the budget from happening. There's something in the budget

Speaker:

that they're not happy about, and they are stopping the politicians from physically getting in

Speaker:

the building so that they can't pass the budget. Does that happen a lot down in Newfoundland?

Speaker:

Because that's impressive. It was, yeah, quite something. I wouldn't say it happens a lot.

Speaker:

I don't think I've seen anything like that in the past 20 years here either. But yeah, harvesters

Speaker:

from all across the province. drove in like huge numbers. I don't think the government

Speaker:

saw it at all. It wasn't really about the budget, but I guess they realized, you know, it's an

Speaker:

important day for government and they're gonna be pissed if we show up and block the entrances

Speaker:

today. Like they showed up at dawn. They'll care today if we block the, the other day they're

Speaker:

probably not even here working, but okay, I get it. We know where they're gonna be. And

Speaker:

yeah, stop people from getting in. And I think it actually like, The whole horse thing, I

Speaker:

think, also comes from people actually not being well trained in protest management because

Speaker:

I think that was the police. You mean police or like marshals for the fish harvesters? Yeah,

Speaker:

the police. Okay. I don't think they... These folks didn't have marshals. You should have

Speaker:

seen them, Santiago. Have you seen the video? The horse is backing into them and the guy's

Speaker:

taking his cone. Ha! Get back! I was worried that horse was... like a back kick or something?

Speaker:

Well, some people did get hurt. And one of the shots in the articles I'll link is, you know,

Speaker:

the only people leaving the rally are the injured. And, you know, there were some. And these are

Speaker:

not like young folks, these are older gentlemen. It was just things we don't experience here

Speaker:

in Ontario. And I guess, yeah, it's a little bit unique in Newfoundland, but they. Their

Speaker:

determination and their their. Willingness to not back down was admirable. whatever their

Speaker:

cause, I suppose. Yeah, absolutely. And now the police are charging the people who hit

Speaker:

the horse. They're just kind of like, you know, ramming your car into a crowd and saying, oh,

Speaker:

you know, you scratched it. Like, you know, I think people have a right to- They've backed

Speaker:

it over and over. Face first, butt first. Like, and that's particularly dangerous. Oh, dear.

Speaker:

Oh, cops will charge anybody these days. Side note, the protestor that they arrested, not

Speaker:

the protestor, the picketer for QP3903 that we talked about this before, there were no

Speaker:

charges. There was nothing to charge them with, them with. And so we're seeing this over and

Speaker:

over again. They may arrest them and charge them, but I doubt that will actually go to

Speaker:

trial because it would be absolutely ridiculous. But it's just a real trend of police throwing

Speaker:

charges during these moments at... protesters and organizers and trying to shut these down

Speaker:

with horses. We see more and more use of that in Toronto as a response as well. And it's,

Speaker:

you know, it's something you got to prepare your members for going out there. But yeah,

Speaker:

it's a worrying trend for sure. Other than fish harvesters shutting down the Confederate building,

Speaker:

are there anything? Is there any other unique factors you think to organizing in Newfoundland?

Speaker:

Perhaps other than the obscene level of snow you guys get. That's not really funny because

Speaker:

that must impact 10 City. You mentioned that on Twitter and I was like, what are you worried

Speaker:

about? And she was like, snow, snow is, you know, was a huge barrier there. Yeah. We were

Speaker:

really concerned about people freezing to death this winter. We've made it through, it's spring

Speaker:

and everyone has been okay. And yeah, I mean, Ten City is interesting because there are a

Speaker:

lot of shelter spaces in the city, but a lot of them are kind of dirty, dangerous, degrading,

Speaker:

and people are protesting against them. So we're supporting that protest and people's right

Speaker:

to... to resist these like really awful options. And I think it's been really eyeopening for

Speaker:

a lot of people in this province. Like I think government kind of assumes like the poor are

Speaker:

gonna be quiet and not speak out against the oppression that they're facing because they're

Speaker:

like, like these are people who are like very, very low income. And like seeing... the community

Speaker:

support that's come around. I don't think a lot of people realized how bad it was and I

Speaker:

have been really educated and we are seeing a lot of, all of a sudden government has money

Speaker:

to build homes and repair, that was a big, huge thing. There were hundreds of government-owned

Speaker:

housing that were just in disrepair and some of them just needed a paint job before they

Speaker:

could let someone in, but they were just not putting money into it. Um, now they're, they

Speaker:

are funding all these like housing support workers and these different nonprofits and seem to,

Speaker:

I think because of the protest and, and those public support for the protest, um, they are

Speaker:

taking it like a lot more seriously. I think that is like one of the unique things about

Speaker:

Newfoundland is like, we do have like a bit of a big city, like a hundred thousand, 150,000

Speaker:

St. John's, um, maybe 200,000 kind of surrounding area. Um, but. it's still small, you still

Speaker:

kind of get to know each other. And especially around the Bay, there's the sense of camaraderie

Speaker:

and community and people are really trying to hold onto that. And so I think people are willing

Speaker:

to support each other. We are getting that Alberta influence of, especially young men are going

Speaker:

out and making a lot of money and I don't need anyone else. I can just take care of myself.

Speaker:

But I think generally where we've been, especially like a poor province too, for a long time,

Speaker:

like people are more willing to like look out for each other. And so that is definitely like

Speaker:

something that we're trying to like foster and support. One question I have is, how is it

Speaker:

that, how do people stay informed in Newfoundland? Like, how do people know about like the issues

Speaker:

that are affecting their community and stuff like that? because I imagine it's quite different.

Speaker:

And do you guys have a role in that? I guess this was a rather question. Yeah, I'm like

Speaker:

a Twitter addict, but I know the majority of people are not on Twitter. We have like CBC,

Speaker:

but there's also MTV here, which is like our news station, privately run, like pretty corporate.

Speaker:

And they also do like... they showed like Survivor, but they have their own like news program.

Speaker:

Um, and then we also have the OCM, which was started by like super rich people in St. John's,

Speaker:

but it stands for voice of the common man. And that is like a radio station that a lot of

Speaker:

people listen and in the morning they have this thing called open line and people like can

Speaker:

call in and talk about like issues that they're facing. Um, and that I would say like a lot

Speaker:

of people like around the Bay, a lot of like the older generation. Um, listen, listen to

Speaker:

that a lot. That's like the calling. I'm like scared to call in. I don't know. Yeah. You

Speaker:

gotta call in. Oh, hi. It's like nine to 12. I have the host is like hardcore. He will not

Speaker:

pop your bullshit. Um, I should call it more. And did they, did they pay much attention to

Speaker:

your efforts? Your organizing efforts? Does that tend to get coverage? Sometimes I would

Speaker:

say like 10 city is getting a lot of coverage and like when I say most St John's it's like

Speaker:

if there's a protest like you'll probably get some media attention Because like there's not

Speaker:

that much news happening But and like when So when we sent like the letter to our members,

Speaker:

so we did we get to the press So we're that important that you know, you know, it's like

Speaker:

our theft made the news

Speaker:

Um, but I, I feel like, all these press releases, you need all this coverage on really important

Speaker:

issues. And yeah, you end up getting a nice article written with the one memo you wish

Speaker:

they hadn't read. But it's just hard to get coverage like that period. So I don't think

Speaker:

it's just cause there's nothing going on. I think you guys are doing something meaningful

Speaker:

that is hitting a note with people and they're forced to cover it. because I mean, 200 members

Speaker:

and a population of like 200k? What? Because you're like, it's not small. Yes, it is, Carrie,

Speaker:

I'm sorry. This is where my Toronto center of the universe, like we come from a really big

Speaker:

city. That is small. So like what you're doing, it's big. You undersell yourself a lot. Like

Speaker:

you're telling us a lot, you're bragging to a degree, but I think you're underselling the

Speaker:

impact that you're having there. not just you, the organization, but yeah, let me just look

Speaker:

through my notes and see if there's anything else I wanted to ask about. Well, you know

Speaker:

what, let's just ask Carrie. I mean, do you have anything that, like, what do you want

Speaker:

to share with us that we wouldn't even know to ask, I guess? Yeah, I guess one thing I've

Speaker:

come, I need to tell everyone about the theft because I'm just like, it was the most horrible

Speaker:

thing that's ever happened to me. I hope it never happens to anyone else. One of my big

Speaker:

takeaways was like, you know, we want to be kind to each other in organizing. Like we need

Speaker:

to be like so grateful that other people are showing up to this space. But we also like

Speaker:

need to build the kind of trust that like we can hold each other accountable and like raise

Speaker:

questions and raise concerns like after the theft. people kind of came up to me and they

Speaker:

were like, oh, there was like this thing, like I wanted to ask and I did it. And maybe it

Speaker:

could have saved us some grief. And yeah, even though like we can trust each other so much,

Speaker:

having good accountability oversight processes in place is also, it also is taking care of

Speaker:

each other because like, our treasurer, like they're not in a better place now because of

Speaker:

like what happened. Like I think... they were dealing with their own stuff and we didn't

Speaker:

show them care by also not having good oversight. I think they wish that didn't happen and I

Speaker:

wish if we had looked at what was happening closer I don't think it would have happened.

Speaker:

So it's important in organizing to... Oversight is also taking care of each other. It's tough

Speaker:

because I mean... tons of organizations, but at the end of the day, oftentimes it's just

Speaker:

making it up as we go along, right? Like a lot of it, you learn by failing and that type of

Speaker:

thing, I think what's important is being able to bounce back from that. As I said earlier,

Speaker:

I think you guys did great job at dealing with that, just from what you're telling me. I guess

Speaker:

one thing I wanna ask is, are there other organizations in the area, or even... I'm going to use the

Speaker:

word area to mean whatever you want. Like it could be, you know, provincial. It could be

Speaker:

a bit further. But like are there other organizations that you guys have been able to like work with

Speaker:

or, you know, show up in solidarity at your events or vice versa? We are definitely not

Speaker:

doing it on our own. Like relationships and partnerships is such a big part of what we're

Speaker:

doing. I mean, one thing that's kind of funny is SBC is actually kind of like a background

Speaker:

organization, I would say, to a lot of like things that are happening. Like, we have a

Speaker:

challenge per culture coalition. We're involved in like the anti racism coalition. We're involved

Speaker:

in the migrant action collective, the indigenous activists collective. We a lot of our organizing.

Speaker:

You're not going to be able to list them all, I bet. Yeah. There's no way. There's the Fridays

Speaker:

for Futures theme song. There's a lot of stuff happening, and we're trying to keep an eye

Speaker:

on it and show up for them and like, oh, how do we share your message? Or right now, the

Speaker:

Palestine Solidarity, YYT, we're amplifying what they're doing. We wouldn't say we're organizing

Speaker:

it, but we're trying to support that. Yeah, try to be where the people are is our motto,

Speaker:

I guess. I love that. Yeah, because it's important not to double up on the work. Like, you can

Speaker:

recognize that there's areas where there needs to be advocacy or mutual aid, but you can almost

Speaker:

always bet there is a kernel of that work already being done, that with just a little bit more

Speaker:

resources, attention, whatever they need. you can grow that rather than duplicating and then

Speaker:

occasionally working together on some like-minded issue. I think this level of organizing is

Speaker:

critical. There's probably a few organizations, I think, in Toronto that sort of fit the bill.

Speaker:

The Workers Action Center,

Speaker:

the incubator. I think that's just a great analogy for it. Yeah, I really appreciate folks doing

Speaker:

that because you don't always get... Uh... It's not always glorious work, right? Doing the

Speaker:

background work and it can be hectic. So many moving parts. There is a question I did wanna

Speaker:

ask about all these moving parts and coalitions to be a part of. You only have infinite amount

Speaker:

of resources, or sorry, we wish. You have a finite amount of resources. I mean, you guys

Speaker:

are impressive in your fundraising, but still like that, that's... limited. And quite often,

Speaker:

even though you'll sit in a meeting and everyone will have great ideas, sometimes what forces

Speaker:

the sifting through ideas rather than allowing all of them to flourish is trying to find the

Speaker:

one that we can afford, the one we have people to volunteer for. And so sometimes really good

Speaker:

ideas fall by the wayside just from lack of resources. How do you keep saying all the different

Speaker:

ideas and still being able to sustain yourself as an organization? Yeah, it is challenging.

Speaker:

We have one staff who works 20 hours a week. And kind of we try to use the motto of like,

Speaker:

if there's a volunteer who's right, like willing to kind of take it on and we're gonna we're

Speaker:

there to support them and hopefully connect them with other people, like we'll do that.

Speaker:

But we don't really like. initiate anything ourselves. So, you know, if a volunteer says,

Speaker:

like, I can't organize, like, for example, I was leading a food sovereignty action team,

Speaker:

and I wasn't able to keep it on anymore. And, you know, we did all this work. And people

Speaker:

did come to meetings, but without having we didn't, if I stepped down, there was no other

Speaker:

volunteer who was like kind of willing to like, keep hosting those meetings and hosting events.

Speaker:

So we decided to just kind of let it go back to the wayside. And we have that information

Speaker:

on our website, like the work we did, I think, still matters. We still brought people together

Speaker:

to talk about issues that we cared about. But sometimes you kind of have to let things go

Speaker:

and then there's space for new things. And we really try to like... One of the things we've

Speaker:

talked about lately that we learned from Mutual Aid by Dean Spade was like the concept of like

Speaker:

no masters, no flakes. So it doesn't always work, but you know, the idea like we're not

Speaker:

here to tell you what to do. Like we're here to like try and bring you together and then

Speaker:

like, yeah, hopefully someone will take something on and with the support of others. But ideally

Speaker:

if you're gonna take something on, like you're gonna commit to it because it kind of just

Speaker:

like lets us all down. if you flake out. So that's, yeah, something we've been trying to

Speaker:

practice a little. But even myself, I want to be involved in so many things. And it's so

Speaker:

hard to know where to put your energy. I'm trying to personally right now, I'm trying to put

Speaker:

my energy in like direct action. Like I want to up the ante. So like, we're blocking an

Speaker:

entrance, like I'm showing up. Yeah, trying to figure out where I fit in the movement.

Speaker:

It's tough. There's always so many things that there's so many things that need attention

Speaker:

that need people doing the work and it's and even when you when you're doing so much, it

Speaker:

always feels like, but like, I can do a bit more. I can I can take on this one more thing.

Speaker:

I can do this one more thing and then you try it and you burn out and you know, we've been

Speaker:

there. So I definitely know how that goes. But you know, every little bit matters here. And

Speaker:

this sounds like, like I can think of so many communities in Ontario, for example, that are

Speaker:

a similar size to, like St. John's, for example, that don't have anything like this, you know?

Speaker:

Sudbury, Thunder Bay, Sault Ste. Marie, Windsor, you know, like the- There's plenty of places

Speaker:

that like this model needs to be repeated in. So honestly, like I almost feel like we should

Speaker:

bring you back some time to talk about this because I really, I really, it checks off like

Speaker:

everything that I appreciate. So I don't have much more to say. Sorry. But yeah, Jessa. I

Speaker:

love when you're in this mood though, Santiago. Every time we do a Blueprints, it's a totally

Speaker:

different feel when we get out of the studio. It's inspiring to hear the work firsthand and

Speaker:

work through some of these problems that we just collectively are trying to work through

Speaker:

in terms of moving the movement forward. But just thank you, Kerry. Thank you for coming

Speaker:

on and for persevering through all our technical difficulties and rescheduling. I appreciate

Speaker:

that. even more so appreciate the work that you do. Your firebrand is appreciated over

Speaker:

here. And yeah, all the work that's being done out in St. John's, Newfoundland. Thank you

Speaker:

very much. Oh, thank you for all your kind words. It's, yeah, it's a nice little boost to hear.

Speaker:

Yeah, and it's great to talk to folks from other parts of so-called Canada. I'm really glad

Speaker:

we got to. connect over Twitter. And yeah, hopefully I'd love to anytime anyone who's listening

Speaker:

wants to reach out and talk about our model. I'm here for it. So yeah, thank you for the

Speaker:

opportunity. I really appreciate it. That is a wrap on another episode of Blueprints of

Speaker:

Disruption. Thank you for joining us. Also a very big thank you to the producer of our show,

Speaker:

Santiago Halu-Quintero. Blueprints of Disruption is an independent production operated cooperatively.

Speaker:

You can follow us on Twitter at BPofDisruption. If you'd like to help us continue disrupting

Speaker:

the status quo, please share our content. And if you have the means, consider becoming a

Speaker:

patron. Not only does our support come from the progressive community, so does our content.

Speaker:

So reach out to us and let us know what or who we should be amplifying. So until next time,

Speaker:

keep disrupting.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube