Artwork for podcast Whispers of the Past - The Hidden History of St. Eustatius
Shadows of Suffering in Buccaneers Paradise
Episode 525th January 2025 • Whispers of the Past - The Hidden History of St. Eustatius • Fi de Wit
00:00:00 00:34:47

Share Episode

Shownotes

In “Shadows of Suffering in Buccaneers Paradise,” we travel to St. Eustatius (1700–1750), an era of booming trade, shifting European alliances, and the exploitation of enslaved labor—particularly women. Fragmented records reveal how free women inherited property and shaped local economies, sometimes defying rigid colonial norms. Meanwhile, enslaved women bore the dual burden of forced labor and reproductive exploitation yet preserved cultural traditions and asserted agency against all odds. Most intriguing is the island’s mysterious blue bead—initially just a piece of currency, it became a hidden emblem of defiance and survival. Join us as we unravel Stacia’s paradoxical prosperity and the quietly courageous acts that challenged a system built on human suffering.

Produced by Simpler Media

Transcripts

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: Because enslavement wasn't just physically abusive, it was also

Speaker:

psychologically abusive. And as a form of

Speaker:

psychological abuse, it was reliant on the alienation

Speaker:

of African people from their homeland,

Speaker:

but also from their languages and their families and their communities and

Speaker:

their traditions.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Welcome to Whispers of the Past. I'm your host,

Speaker:

Fi de Vit. In this episode, we

Speaker:

journey into the paradoxical chapter of sint

Speaker:

Eustacia's history. We find ourselves in

Speaker:

the time period between 1700 to

Speaker:

1750, a, ah, moment when the

Speaker:

island's history began to gain fame as a

Speaker:

bustling center of commerce and trade,

Speaker:

celebrated by colonial narratives as a symbol of

Speaker:

progress and prosperity. But

Speaker:

history is never one sided, and beneath

Speaker:

this glorified portrayal lies a distressing

Speaker:

reality of enslavement and the continued

Speaker:

suffering of those who endured it.

Speaker:

While Stacia's harbors was filled with ships and

Speaker:

goods and its streets bustled with trade,

Speaker:

its prosperity was built on the backs of enslaved

Speaker:

individuals whose lives were defined by

Speaker:

unimaginable hardship. This

Speaker:

period also illuminates the profound resilience

Speaker:

of women, both enslaved and free,

Speaker:

whose stories of survival and empowerment

Speaker:

challenges the colonial narrative. From

Speaker:

women who inherited property and wielded influence

Speaker:

in unconventional ways, to those who

Speaker:

preserved cultural traditions, defied

Speaker:

oppression, and led acts of resistance,

Speaker:

their legacy is a reminder that even in the darkest

Speaker:

times, there is strength and hope.

Speaker:

As we delve into this era, we'll uncover

Speaker:

Syntastacia's rapid growth, its role in

Speaker:

the chaotic web of European conflicts, and the

Speaker:

layered experience of those who lived here.

Speaker:

Together, we'll explore the complexities of history

Speaker:

often celebrated for its colonial triumphs, while

Speaker:

exposing the human costs that these narratives

Speaker:

so often overlook.

Speaker:

Historian and teacher Dr. Alain provides us

Speaker:

with the insight into how plantation economies

Speaker:

and their accompanying structures began to

Speaker:

solidify, setting the stage for both its

Speaker:

island's booming trade and the systematic

Speaker:

exploitation that underpinned it.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Anna Hanslin: Well, 1700 to 1750 is when

Speaker:

we start to see these plantation

Speaker:

economies really.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: Take off and there's a big boom.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Right.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Anna Hanslin: Uh, and then in the latter decades.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Of the 18th century, we have these.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: Very mature plantation societies with a

Speaker:

very distinct, distinct kind of culture.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Anna Hanslin: And the first, you know, five decades.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: Of the 18th century is not a

Speaker:

period that I think much has been.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Anna Hanslin: Written about with regard to gender

Speaker:

specifically.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: So I would say this is a pivotal period in which these

Speaker:

plantation economies are growing and,

Speaker:

you know, a, ah, sort of plantation society is

Speaker:

emerging, but it's not quite fully formed

Speaker:

yet.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): As, uh, Dr. Lane highlights the first decades of the

Speaker:

18th century was a critical time in the

Speaker:

establishment of plantation economies.

Speaker:

While the system was expanding, its cultural

Speaker:

and gender dynamics were still taking shape,

Speaker:

setting the stage for the entrenched inequalities

Speaker:

and systematic exploitation that would

Speaker:

follow. While the plantation

Speaker:

systems expanded, Syntostacia's role

Speaker:

as a strategic trading hub was growing in

Speaker:

equal measure. We now turn to Mrs.

Speaker:

Sutakao, long term resident of Sintostatius

Speaker:

and one of the founders of the island center of

Speaker:

archaeological research. She

Speaker:

explains that this period saw the island's

Speaker:

development shaped not only by trade, but

Speaker:

also by the ripple effects of European wars and

Speaker:

the diversity of its residents, fostering a, uh,

Speaker:

complex and ever changing landscape.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: Well, you have to remember

Speaker:

when there were wars in Europe,

Speaker:

just Europe wasn't affected. Often

Speaker:

the Caribbean was affected too. So if the Dutch

Speaker:

were at war with France or England,

Speaker:

those people were often coming here to try to

Speaker:

capture this island. So station changed hands many

Speaker:

times, and that period of time was especially

Speaker:

active. Also during that time, Stacia

Speaker:

began to grow. We began to add more

Speaker:

warehouses. As Stacia grew, more

Speaker:

people came to the island. People here on

Speaker:

Stacia were a mix of people

Speaker:

from many different nationalities because we were a trading

Speaker:

island. Unlike the English islands around

Speaker:

it, where you would find mostly only English

Speaker:

people, here you had people from all

Speaker:

over. The station was

Speaker:

part of the Dutch West Indian trading, but

Speaker:

the Dutch East Indian trading company had been in existence for

Speaker:

many years. Even people as far away as

Speaker:

Asias were actually living here. So

Speaker:

Stacia was growing and we were building more and more wire

Speaker:

home. We were also at

Speaker:

that same time establishing ourselves

Speaker:

as a trading nation among the Caribbean

Speaker:

islands. So it was a busy time.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): During the first half of the 18th century, Sinto

Speaker:

Statius found itself at the center of a growing

Speaker:

trading network shaped as much by the

Speaker:

European wars as by local commerce.

Speaker:

As Mrs. Tsutakao explains, the island's

Speaker:

strategic location and growing infrastructure

Speaker:

drew people from across the globe, creating a

Speaker:

unique, diverse population, but also

Speaker:

making it a target during times of conflict.

Speaker:

Synthesia's diverse population mirrored

Speaker:

its growing trade networks with records revealing

Speaker:

the breadth of its connection to other European

Speaker:

and Caribbean colonies. As Mrs.

Speaker:

Tsutakao shares, tax records provide

Speaker:

glimpses of the island's bustling economy,

Speaker:

but leaves much unsaid about the lives of the

Speaker:

people, especially the enslaved

Speaker:

individuals who lived and labored here.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: If you look at the records and you look at the

Speaker:

names of the people on the record, the

Speaker:

tax records, which are the best records we have,

Speaker:

you'll notice a lot of English, French,

Speaker:

um, Dutch, possibly German

Speaker:

name, other people's names. We were trading

Speaker:

with the Danish colonies. We were trading with

Speaker:

Swedish colonies. So those people may very

Speaker:

well have been here. So looking at the records of the

Speaker:

tax records tells you something about

Speaker:

the owners of properties that are here, but it doesn't

Speaker:

tell you about the whole population.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Synthastacia's tax records reveals a

Speaker:

kaleidoscope of culture and national identities

Speaker:

evident of the island's vibrant trading community.

Speaker:

As Mr. Soutakau notes, these records

Speaker:

hint at the complexity of life on

Speaker:

Cintastasius, where property ownership

Speaker:

tells us only part of the story,

Speaker:

leaving the lives of many, particularly

Speaker:

enslaved, in the shadows.

Speaker:

Yet within this fragmented history, we

Speaker:

find hints of women's significant roles,

Speaker:

both as inheritors of property and as key

Speaker:

figures navigating societal

Speaker:

constraints.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: The only things that we know are from

Speaker:

the records that we have of, um,

Speaker:

death records and records of

Speaker:

birth and stuff like that. And so we don't

Speaker:

have a lot of information, but we're beginning to compile

Speaker:

some. In many cases, the men were

Speaker:

dying young and their widows were

Speaker:

inheriting property, which would then

Speaker:

go to whoever they remarried

Speaker:

later on. But most often, the

Speaker:

property was actually passing through the women,

Speaker:

not through the men.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): The fragmented records offers glimpses into

Speaker:

women's agency during this time. Whether

Speaker:

through inheriting property or participating in

Speaker:

localized economies, women, both European

Speaker:

and free women of color, played crucial roles in

Speaker:

Stacia's social and economic fabric.

Speaker:

This echoes earlier traditions seen in

Speaker:

Amerindian societies, where land and

Speaker:

influence often passed through female lines,

Speaker:

illustrating how women's resilience persisted

Speaker:

across cultures and eras.

Speaker:

Simultaneously, this era on Sintostatias

Speaker:

saw a marked increase in the transatlantic

Speaker:

and interisland trade of enslaved

Speaker:

individuals. As Mrs. Soutika

Speaker:

explains, the island's role as both a direct

Speaker:

importer of enslaved people from Africa

Speaker:

and a, uh, hub for smaller Klein bar trade

Speaker:

place it at the heart of a system of human

Speaker:

exploitation.

Speaker:

>> Ms. Sutekau: A lot of slaves coming through Stacia,

Speaker:

but the number of slaves in Stacia itself that were

Speaker:

actually living here, that grew

Speaker:

much later than that period of time.

Speaker:

And I don't know a whole lot about it because,

Speaker:

again, we haven't had the research that we

Speaker:

should have had done here.

Speaker:

There may be research done, but a

Speaker:

lot of those records are just now being digitized,

Speaker:

and we're beginning to get hold of them. Dacia

Speaker:

was a major slave trading island. There were

Speaker:

two types of slave trade that were going on here.

Speaker:

The ones where the people were actually being brought

Speaker:

from slavery. Africa then sold

Speaker:

from here to other places, the United

Speaker:

States to other islands

Speaker:

around the Caribbean. Then there

Speaker:

was what, uh, was called the Klein Bar, a

Speaker:

small island trade where slaves

Speaker:

were being traded. Say you had slaves that you wanted

Speaker:

to sell or buy, you would bring them or

Speaker:

come to station to buy them. So

Speaker:

the small island trade between the

Speaker:

island was being done on station, even if

Speaker:

it was with the France and the French islands

Speaker:

or the Dane, who were also slave

Speaker:

traders, they were actually bringing slaves in from Africa

Speaker:

also, or the Swedish or the

Speaker:

English or other islands.

Speaker:

So there was two

Speaker:

different, although they were all the same

Speaker:

in that they were all putting people into

Speaker:

bondage.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Sintostatia's role in the transatlantic and

Speaker:

slave trade was multifaceted. The

Speaker:

Kleinbar trade, also known as small

Speaker:

island trade, functioned as a regional market

Speaker:

for enslaved individuals who had been transported

Speaker:

from Africa or neighboring colonies.

Speaker:

Enslaved individuals were brought to

Speaker:

Syntostatias not only to be sold directly to

Speaker:

buyers from across the Caribbean, but also to

Speaker:

facilitate exchanges with between

Speaker:

islands, including those under

Speaker:

French, Danish, Swedish

Speaker:

and British control. This

Speaker:

practice often meant breaking apart families and

Speaker:

communities, adding another layer of cruelty

Speaker:

to an already dehumanizing system.

Speaker:

Despite these horrors, Syntostatius also saw

Speaker:

acts of defiance and resistance. These stories

Speaker:

remind us that even in systems designed to erase

Speaker:

agency, individuals found ways to assert

Speaker:

their humanity. As we delve deeper, the dual

Speaker:

roles of commerce and exploitation on this

Speaker:

island become impossible to separate.

Speaker:

Sintostacia's strategic location and natural

Speaker:

harbor not only facilitate its role as a major

Speaker:

trading hub, but also sets the stage for its

Speaker:

participation in the transatlantic and slave

Speaker:

trade. In episode one, we touched

Speaker:

upon the natural landscape of Sinterias as a

Speaker:

key factor in its historical significance.

Speaker:

And again we turn to Dr. Ruth Stelten, an

Speaker:

archaeologist with first hand experience working here

Speaker:

on Sintostatius. He will elaborate

Speaker:

further on this topic. His insight will help us

Speaker:

understand why Sintostatius Bay was so

Speaker:

influential, shaping its rise as a bustling

Speaker:

center of trade and a pivotal player in the economic

Speaker:

and social systems of the Caribbean.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Stelton: What's perhaps most interesting from,

Speaker:

uh, a historical point of view is the

Speaker:

area to the west of town, basically Oranya Bai,

Speaker:

and especially the area basically going from

Speaker:

lower town out for about

Speaker:

two and a half, three miles, that area is a

Speaker:

very shallow, sandy,

Speaker:

submerged area landscape on the leeward side

Speaker:

of the island. That's very important. So on the relatively sheltered

Speaker:

side of the island, um, and that area

Speaker:

was used back in the

Speaker:

1600 and 1700s for ships to anchor.

Speaker:

Right. So one of the problems that you have as

Speaker:

even Though, like on Stacia, right, The social

Speaker:

and economic conditions were very conducive to turn it into a free

Speaker:

port and to receive lots and lots of trade and to become a big

Speaker:

emporium. The landscape also needs to cooperate, not

Speaker:

just terrestrial, but also marine. And it did so on Stacia,

Speaker:

because in order to house that many ships at a

Speaker:

time, you need a large bay. You need

Speaker:

either a large enclosed harbor or a large bay of some sort. Uh, what they call

Speaker:

a roadstead back in the day, right? That's the area where all these ships were dropping

Speaker:

anchor. And that roadstead needs to be pretty sandy as well, because

Speaker:

those anchors, they need to hold right anchor. If a ship drops an anchor,

Speaker:

it needs to bury itself in the sand. You need

Speaker:

a sandy sea floor for that. It cannot be

Speaker:

covered in coral reefs and rocks and things like that. The very

Speaker:

good thing Stacia is that it had just that it had

Speaker:

a large sandy area right in front of

Speaker:

Lowertown on the leeward side of the island. That

Speaker:

doesn't mean that it's always nice and calm there, because

Speaker:

if you're doing a nice sunset cruise close to the

Speaker:

waterfront, you know, in Lowertown, you'll be all right

Speaker:

usually. But if you go one and a half,

Speaker:

two kilometers out, it can get pretty rough because the island is not

Speaker:

perfectly oriented north, south, but also it is not

Speaker:

very big. So it doesn't provide a whole lot of shelter. It

Speaker:

provides some, but not a whole lot. So the further out you go, the rougher it

Speaker:

gets. So I'm sure, like a lot of people on these

Speaker:

ships, you know, that were there sometimes for a few days, but sometimes

Speaker:

for weeks or even months on end, like they were not having a good time.

Speaker:

If you're. If you're anchored further out and it's choppy and

Speaker:

it's constantly rough, like you're not going to have a good time.

Speaker:

Um, but you could still anchor there, and so that's

Speaker:

important, right? So in the Caribbean,

Speaker:

we have a few very, like, specific, like,

Speaker:

ports. Basically, if you look at St. Barts in the town of

Speaker:

Gustavia, you have a very nice enclosed area. That is

Speaker:

the harbor, right? So over there, yes, you can sail a number of

Speaker:

ships in, but it's not that many. Not as many as you would have on Stacia,

Speaker:

but you would be in a very nice, calm,

Speaker:

controlled area. But on Stacia,

Speaker:

there's all about volume. And so there is. There's

Speaker:

eyewitness accounts from the late 1700s, for example,

Speaker:

Admiral Rodney, but also Dutch sailors mentioned that There

Speaker:

are at Any time between 150 and 200 ships

Speaker:

anchored in Stacia's roadstead. That's a

Speaker:

crazy number of ships.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): As Dr. Stelton illustrates, the natural

Speaker:

features of Sinta, Stacias provides the perfect

Speaker:

condition for a bustling maritime trade.

Speaker:

The sandy seabed and the sheltered roadstead

Speaker:

offered a haven for hundreds of ships to arrive

Speaker:

each year, making Stacia a vital point

Speaker:

of connection in the Caribbean economic web.

Speaker:

But this trade was not only for goods. It was

Speaker:

also about enslaved people whose

Speaker:

life were commodified and uprooted. With

Speaker:

this context, we turn to the island's heritage inspector,

Speaker:

Mr. Richardson, who paints a vivid picture of life on

Speaker:

the island during the early 18th century.

Speaker:

>> Mr. Richardson: So it's, uh, 1720, um,

Speaker:

first of all, around 1720, I must say,

Speaker:

um, in the spatial development

Speaker:

plan, you see that the city

Speaker:

Oranya, it's blooming. They develop a spatial

Speaker:

development plan of 1720, which kind of

Speaker:

gives street names to new places,

Speaker:

buildings. The population is extremely high. It's, I

Speaker:

think it's around, it's past 8,000 at that period of

Speaker:

time. There's lots of people living on the island,

Speaker:

lots so much that the one people that are

Speaker:

visiting Sint Eustatius are referring to the

Speaker:

island back then as one of the ugliest islands in the

Speaker:

Caribbean. And that's because the minute you

Speaker:

set foot, put on the horizon.

Speaker:

One description from a French gentleman and his

Speaker:

family and his wife then that are touring the Caribbean describes

Speaker:

the island as a floating European

Speaker:

city, that the, uh, houses are

Speaker:

stories high and you can hardly see any green, that it's

Speaker:

over cultivated, it's overpopulated, and there's

Speaker:

commerce of everything and every sort happening

Speaker:

on the island. And then later on you see other letters

Speaker:

from a lady of quality called Janet Shaw, for example, who

Speaker:

also writes about the island's

Speaker:

unattractive appearance and also quite

Speaker:

smelly, but also quite noisy. And then

Speaker:

there's also another British gentleman who also

Speaker:

refers to that he has never seen

Speaker:

the extent of such debauchery and

Speaker:

trade on St. Eustatius. He hasn't seen it anywhere

Speaker:

else. So you already get an idea of what the

Speaker:

island is like. So he kind of visualize the

Speaker:

noise, the sounds, the street, and of course

Speaker:

the trading. There's a lot of trading going on.

Speaker:

The island is blooming, it's way before

Speaker:

this. American independence will be coming later on.

Speaker:

But the island is really trading and booming. And it's also trading,

Speaker:

of course, in people, in porcelain, in

Speaker:

opium. Everything that is possible is being

Speaker:

Traded. But what's also interesting is the

Speaker:

amount of plantations. The amount of plantations around then

Speaker:

are about 30. This would eventually

Speaker:

skyrocket. When, of course, the British come in

Speaker:

and plunder the islands, et cetera, it will eventually go up to

Speaker:

higher numbers.

Speaker:

But then when you look at the demographics

Speaker:

of the island's population of free and

Speaker:

colored, you also see, for example, free

Speaker:

people of color, 1200. What are they doing? Who

Speaker:

are they? But you also see on the list

Speaker:

Chinese immigrants, two Japanese immigrants living

Speaker:

on Hindu stations. What are all these people doing here?

Speaker:

But what's also interesting is that

Speaker:

when it look at the enslaved people, for example, many of

Speaker:

them are working in the custom houses. Many of them are working in

Speaker:

the warehouses. Of course, not under the best of

Speaker:

circumstances, of course, because if you look at the letters that are being

Speaker:

wrote about the island and the stench that you can also get

Speaker:

out of these letters, you know that the work, um,

Speaker:

on floor isn't the best place. The island is really

Speaker:

blooming. It's expanding and it's growing.

Speaker:

And in all of this time, like I said in the beginning, from

Speaker:

1636 to where we are now in the 1720s, the

Speaker:

island is still changing hands already. So in that

Speaker:

period, it's already been British, it's already been French, it's already

Speaker:

been Dutch, and it's going back and forth.

Speaker:

It's very chaotic.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Mr. Richardson's account reveals the paradox

Speaker:

of the 18th century. Stacia, a place

Speaker:

bustling with life and commerce, yet burdened by the grim

Speaker:

realities of enslavement and exploitation.

Speaker:

From the chatter of people to the noise of bustling

Speaker:

warehouses, the streets of Oranjestad hummed with

Speaker:

activities. But amidst the activity, the human

Speaker:

cost of progress loomed large.

Speaker:

Enslaved individuals labored in custom houses

Speaker:

and warehouses, enduring unimaginable

Speaker:

conditions. Despite this,

Speaker:

stories of resilience and defiance began to

Speaker:

emerge, offering glimpses of humanity

Speaker:

within the chaos.

Speaker:

>> Mr. Richardson: And one of the interesting things is that, of

Speaker:

course, all of the abolitionists, people are starting to speak

Speaker:

out about the slave trade also. But

Speaker:

no one ever will abolish slavery on St.

Speaker:

Eustatius until 1816. So

Speaker:

let's keep that in mind as we go through these episodes. You

Speaker:

will see that it's going to be a long period where

Speaker:

the French capture Saint Eustatius, the island becomes

Speaker:

French, and the French continue the trade where the Dutch

Speaker:

left off and the British. So it was just the fast money.

Speaker:

And that also reflected how people of color,

Speaker:

um, were being treated. But in that period, there's

Speaker:

also some, you know, very interesting stories

Speaker:

of People defying the odds. And I will,

Speaker:

of course, as we go on, expound on these very

Speaker:

interesting stories.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): By 1720, Oranjestad was a

Speaker:

hive of activity, its economy

Speaker:

thriving amidst the constant movement of goods,

Speaker:

people and ideas. Mr. Richardson

Speaker:

vividly illustrates this boom, from bustling

Speaker:

warehouses to sprawling plantations that

Speaker:

defined life here on the island. Yet beneath

Speaker:

the veneer of prosperity lay the stark realities of

Speaker:

human exploitation. These

Speaker:

untold stories of resilience and defiance

Speaker:

challenges the colonial narratives of unbridled

Speaker:

progress. They remind us that

Speaker:

Syntostatia's flourishing trade and wealth

Speaker:

was built on the labor and endurance of those who live through

Speaker:

unimaginable hardship, leaving traces

Speaker:

of their humanity in the shadows of

Speaker:

history. While the

Speaker:

bustling streets of Oranjestad and the booming trade

Speaker:

painted a picture of growth and prosperity,

Speaker:

the experience of women under enslavement continued to

Speaker:

reveal a harrowing and often overlooked

Speaker:

reality. As we keep taking a

Speaker:

closer look of the profound difference between the lives

Speaker:

of men and women, we see the

Speaker:

unique burden women bore within the systems of

Speaker:

slavery, one that extends far beyond

Speaker:

forced labor. Their roles as mothers and

Speaker:

their ability to bear children place them at the very core

Speaker:

of a system's perpetuation,

Speaker:

subjecting them to a cruel and calculated

Speaker:

exploitation of humanity.

Speaker:

Historian Dr. Anna Hanseln helps us explore

Speaker:

further this profoundly gendered dimension of

Speaker:

enslavement.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Anna Hanslin: I think women's experience under enslavement was always

Speaker:

fundamentally different from men's, and that is

Speaker:

irrespective of place and time. And that's partly

Speaker:

because in this system of transatlantic

Speaker:

African chattel slavery that rose

Speaker:

up in the 17th and 18th centuries in the

Speaker:

Caribbean in particular, as one of

Speaker:

the central focus points of where millions of people

Speaker:

were sent and lived, um, women

Speaker:

were the ones able to naturally reproduce

Speaker:

more enslaved people. And so

Speaker:

their bodies were seen as property, but

Speaker:

also as property that had the potential to create more

Speaker:

property for their enslavers. And

Speaker:

this, of course, puts women in a terrible dilemma

Speaker:

of knowing that any children they have, if they themselves

Speaker:

are enslaved, will be legally born enslaved as

Speaker:

well. And so this makes them

Speaker:

obviously the focus of, in some cases,

Speaker:

deliberate rapes, um, by enslavers

Speaker:

who want them to reproduce. And this doesn't just

Speaker:

happen in the Caribbean. We have a documented instance of it happen

Speaker:

happening in 1630s Massachusetts. So,

Speaker:

you know, this is not something that's, that's limited to the

Speaker:

Caribbean. But I think women did have this,

Speaker:

um, this potential within the eyes of enslavers.

Speaker:

And then, of course, they themselves, as human beings and

Speaker:

as mothers, this puts them often in the terrible

Speaker:

predicament of what would normally be one of the great

Speaker:

joys of most women's lives, which is having children.

Speaker:

Knowing that they're bringing children into this horrible

Speaker:

system, um, I think would have been an extra

Speaker:

burden that women had to bear, um, that

Speaker:

men did not in the same way. Because if men were raped

Speaker:

within the system of slavery, um, it was not

Speaker:

to impregnate them, which is often what happened to

Speaker:

women. And women, of course, uh, were

Speaker:

able to also have unique, um,

Speaker:

forms of resistance apart from men, in

Speaker:

the sense that, you know, sometimes these sexual relations

Speaker:

were not entirely coercive. And we do

Speaker:

have, you know, examples here and there of

Speaker:

couples who were intimate where there seems to have been real

Speaker:

affection. Although, of course, it's always hard to say if a woman is

Speaker:

enslaved, um, how much she is able to

Speaker:

exercise free will in that respect. But so you do have

Speaker:

instances of families being created. Um,

Speaker:

some enslaved women are able to parlay

Speaker:

that into freedom for themselves or freedom for

Speaker:

their children eventually. And so I think that is

Speaker:

something that, um, is a road that's more commonly available

Speaker:

for enslaved women than men. Although, of course, these

Speaker:

are, you know, a tiny, tiny fraction

Speaker:

of the experience of enslaved people, um, in

Speaker:

the Caribbean, but it's still there. Nevertheless.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Dr. Anna Hanslin offers a profound exploration

Speaker:

of a deeply gendered experience of enslavement,

Speaker:

highlighting the unique burden bore by women.

Speaker:

Their ability to bear children, cruelly reframed through the

Speaker:

lens of colonial exploitation, turned them into both

Speaker:

laborers and commodities. Yet

Speaker:

amidst such dehumanization, women

Speaker:

displayed remarkable resilience and found ways to

Speaker:

reclaim agency, leaving behind legacies

Speaker:

of strength that defy the colonial narrative.

Speaker:

This narrative of resilience is further reflected

Speaker:

in the story of Cintastatia's mysterious

Speaker:

Bluebeet. These small objects that

Speaker:

we have spoken about in previous episodes

Speaker:

were initially used as currency,

Speaker:

evolved into powerful symbols of resistance,

Speaker:

identity and cultural preservation.

Speaker:

To help us understand their profound

Speaker:

significance and their impact on the lives of the

Speaker:

enslaved here on Syntostatius, we now turn to

Speaker:

archaeologist Dr. Sahidi.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: The bluebead economy

Speaker:

was not

Speaker:

a static system.

Speaker:

The value of the beads was most likely

Speaker:

determined by the person who owned the bead. Um,

Speaker:

it wasn't like the type of official

Speaker:

currency that other people were using.

Speaker:

And so they might have used the beads for many

Speaker:

different things. I mean, of course, we know the story about,

Speaker:

um, a man needing to have enough beads to go around

Speaker:

a woman's waist to marry her, which would be a form

Speaker:

of dowry. People might have

Speaker:

also used beads for certain provisions,

Speaker:

um, if they weren't producing enough in their gardens

Speaker:

for different skills, all sorts of things.

Speaker:

Because within the wider

Speaker:

economy of the island, Enslaved villages and enslaved

Speaker:

communities had their own communities,

Speaker:

their own economies, where they were producing their own

Speaker:

goods. So it was. It was kind of like a smaller

Speaker:

economy within the larger economy,

Speaker:

if that makes sense.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): Blue beads, while primarily associated with the

Speaker:

enslaved population as a form of currency for

Speaker:

labor, May have also had a broader

Speaker:

role on the island. Questions linger about

Speaker:

whether these beads also facilitated exchanges

Speaker:

between free individuals and the enslaved,

Speaker:

Hinting at a more intricate web of economic and

Speaker:

social relationships here on cintastasius.

Speaker:

Unfortunately, much remains unknown about

Speaker:

these interactions. The use of bluebeads

Speaker:

in this context is still a mystery, and further

Speaker:

research, Particularly into free villages and their

Speaker:

historical records, could provide crucial

Speaker:

insights. But for now, this gap in our

Speaker:

understanding highlights the ongoing effort of Required

Speaker:

to fully uncover the complexity of life

Speaker:

here on stacia during that time.

Speaker:

To delve deeper into the connection between blue beads

Speaker:

and women, Dr. Sahidi continues to explore how

Speaker:

these seemingly simple objects carried profound

Speaker:

significance. Rooted in west African

Speaker:

traditions, the beads symbolize fertility,

Speaker:

femininity, and identity, Elements that

Speaker:

enslaved women brought with them to cintastasias.

Speaker:

But how did these beads shape their lives?

Speaker:

Were they merely relics of cultural memory?

Speaker:

Or did they transform into tools of resistance and

Speaker:

empowerment Within a system designed to

Speaker:

deny their sovereignty? These

Speaker:

questions guide us as we unravel the layered history

Speaker:

of bluebeads and their enduring impacts of the lives

Speaker:

of enslaved women on the island.

Speaker:

>> Dr. Sahidi: There's a prevalent story on Stacia that, uh,

Speaker:

for an enslaved man to marry a woman, he had to have enough

Speaker:

beads to wrap all the way around her waist.

Speaker:

And that tradition of wearing beads around the waist

Speaker:

or the hips Comes from west Africa.

Speaker:

It's an ancient adornment practice.

Speaker:

That practice was brought to the Caribbean and the

Speaker:

Americas. And the most famous example of that is from a grave

Speaker:

in the African burial ground in New York city, where

Speaker:

African women were buried with their waist beads.

Speaker:

So the waist beads symbolize fertility,

Speaker:

sensuality, femininity. And

Speaker:

that practice being brought to Stacia

Speaker:

is, I would say, in itself, a symbol of

Speaker:

resistance and self empowerment.

Speaker:

Because enslavement wasn't just physically abusive, it was

Speaker:

also psychologically abusive. And as a form of

Speaker:

psychological abuse, it was reliant on the alienation

Speaker:

of African people from their homeland,

Speaker:

but also from their languages and their families and their communities and

Speaker:

their traditions. And that cultural genocide

Speaker:

was a way of controlling people that was often more

Speaker:

effective in meeting colonial

Speaker:

objectives than physical violence. So even though we think about

Speaker:

something like waist beads as maybe even, um, like a kind

Speaker:

of fashion, from a contemporary perspective,

Speaker:

the truth is that these ancestral

Speaker:

feminine practices that were

Speaker:

brought to the Caribbean are anti colonial

Speaker:

through the preservation of tangible and intangible heritage

Speaker:

tradition. So when we look at the colonial

Speaker:

order, which depended on keeping enslaved people at the

Speaker:

bottom of the social hierarchy, which is why the

Speaker:

Dutch gave blue beads to enslaved people instead of money. They didn't

Speaker:

want them to participate in the wider economy. They didn't want

Speaker:

them to benefit from the prosperity experienced by members of the

Speaker:

elite. But enslaved people resisted that

Speaker:

too. They created their own economies.

Speaker:

Um, for women to then play a role

Speaker:

in how the blue beads as a form of currency were

Speaker:

valued is also a form of resistance, not only

Speaker:

against colonialism, but also as a way of exerting

Speaker:

feminine power over a patriarchal system.

Speaker:

So a woman who is well fed with a curvaceous body can then

Speaker:

have the self agency to determine her own value.

Speaker:

She can say, you don't have enough beads

Speaker:

to go around my waist, so go get more, and then maybe I'll marry you

Speaker:

if you're lucky. And that's empowering. I

Speaker:

think on a different level,

Speaker:

we can also look at, um, the way that

Speaker:

beads are worn in the contemporary period. So a lot of women on

Speaker:

station now have established new

Speaker:

meaning with the beads. They're not a symbol of oppression. They're

Speaker:

a symbol of cultural preservation

Speaker:

and ancestral connection.

Speaker:

So, um, people wear beads in

Speaker:

their hair. They wear beads as necklaces or as

Speaker:

bracelets. And that's also a way

Speaker:

of entangling the past with

Speaker:

the present and bringing those stories to life

Speaker:

and honoring women of the past.

Speaker:

>> Unidentified (Podcast Host): As we conclude this episode, we

Speaker:

reflect on the paradoxical history of sinter

Speaker:

Statius between 1700 and

Speaker:

1750, a period defined by

Speaker:

immense growth, bustling trade, and cultural

Speaker:

exchange, yet underpinned by the

Speaker:

harrowing realities of enslavement and

Speaker:

systematic exploitation. Amid the

Speaker:

noise of Oranjestad streets and the sails of

Speaker:

countless ships in the harbor, stories of resilience

Speaker:

and defiance are starting to emerge,

Speaker:

offering glimpses of humanity within the

Speaker:

chaotic and often brutal world.

Speaker:

We've explored how Syntostacia's natural harbor

Speaker:

made it a vital hub of global commerce,

Speaker:

with its plantations and warehouses fueling

Speaker:

an economy built on the backs of enslaved

Speaker:

individuals. At the heart of this

Speaker:

history are the women whose strength and resilience

Speaker:

challenges the colonial narrative.

Speaker:

Enslaved women, burdened by the dual

Speaker:

exploitation of labor and forced

Speaker:

reproduction, resisted through acts of cultural

Speaker:

preservation and empowerment.

Speaker:

Free women, both white and of

Speaker:

color, navigating societal constraint,

Speaker:

asserting influence in unconventional ways,

Speaker:

inheriting properties, and shaping Stacia's

Speaker:

social fabric. These stories remind us

Speaker:

that even the darkest chapters of history, women's

Speaker:

courage and agency, served as a quiet,

Speaker:

yet powerful act of defiance.

Speaker:

But Stacia's story is far from over. And, uh, in

Speaker:

our next episode, we'll step into the latter half of the

Speaker:

18th century, a time when the

Speaker:

island earned its name, the Golden Rock. This

Speaker:

era of extraordinary wealth and influence brought new

Speaker:

opportunities, heightened tension, and profound

Speaker:

challenges, both with the island and on a global

Speaker:

stage. Join us as we continue to uncover the

Speaker:

rise of Asia's Golden Age and the complex

Speaker:

legacy it left behind. Until

Speaker:

then, let us continue to carry the lessons of

Speaker:

history with reference. And we leave you

Speaker:

to ponder on these questions.

Speaker:

How do we reckon with the prosperity built on human

Speaker:

suffering?

Speaker:

How do we honor the resilience of those whose stories

Speaker:

remain in the margins of history?

Speaker:

And most importantly, how do these

Speaker:

reflections challenge us to, uh, critically engage

Speaker:

with the legacy of colonial power that is still

Speaker:

being celebrated today?

Speaker:

As we confront these questions, let us

Speaker:

recognize that understanding the past is not merely an

Speaker:

act of remembrance, but a call to confront

Speaker:

injustice, to challenge inherited

Speaker:

narratives, and, most importantly, a

Speaker:

catalyst for meaningful change. Sa.

Follow

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube