Artwork for podcast Leaving In Color
Finding Truth In Yourself (Part 1)
Episode 115th November 2023 • Leaving In Color • Christina Elmer
00:00:00 01:08:21

Share Episode

Shownotes

I’m so excited you’re here to experience the first episode of Leaving In Color. My dear friend Marcos joins me for a raw, real conversation about growing up in the Mormon church as a queer person of color. We’ll talk about grappling with your identity, and how painful it can be when being true to yourself conflicts with the faith that’s bound your family for generations. 

Our conversation was too important to cut short, and too big for just one episode. Look for the second half of this engrossing discussion in two weeks.

About Our Guest:

Marcos is a born and bred Californian who is proud of his multiple identities as a Chicano, gay man. His life experience and education has shaped his passion for social justice and care for marginalized communities. Marcos enjoys working in higher education to serve students, provide support, and pay it forward based on his own experiences as a first-gen college student navigating academia. He is an avid animal lover who also enjoys concerts, live theater, and the beach.

Mentioned: 

The Book of Laman by Mette Ivie Harrison https://www.amazon.com/Book-Laman-Mette-Ivie-Harrison/dp/0998605247 

Connect with Leaving in Color:

Instagram - @leavingincolor.pod 

Email - leavingincolorpod@gmail.com.

Music by Tucker Winters

Art by Jen Cagle Gilmore

Editing by Particulate Media

Transcripts

Christina Elmer:

Hi, welcome to Living in Color, a podcast about uncovering your

Christina Elmer:

radiant self after losing your faith.

Christina Elmer:

I am your host, Christina Elmer.

Christina Elmer:

I'm so delighted you found us.

Christina Elmer:

Hello, hello.

Christina Elmer:

Oh my god.

Christina Elmer:

Um, I can't believe it.

Christina Elmer:

We're actually finally here.

Christina Elmer:

This is the first episode of Leaving in Color.

Christina Elmer:

Wow, this has been such a process getting to this point.

Christina Elmer:

I am incredibly grateful for the support of so many people.

Christina Elmer:

My coach, Natalie, and my producer, K.O., and of course, friends and family.

Christina Elmer:

And yeah, it's just, it's a little surreal, surreal that we're

Christina Elmer:

actually here recording today.

Christina Elmer:

So, when I had the idea for this podcast, God, it was about a year ago and I was,

Christina Elmer:

working with a different coach at the time and in the coaching container,

Christina Elmer:

we were envisioning our future selves.

Christina Elmer:

And what I had envisioned for myself was to be a host of a podcast.

Christina Elmer:

And at that time, I wasn't sure what type of podcast it would be,

Christina Elmer:

but I just knew that I wanted, to be a storyteller of some kind.

Christina Elmer:

And the idea for Leaving in Color is to create a space where individuals who

Christina Elmer:

may not necessarily get the opportunity to tell their story for a multitude

Christina Elmer:

of reasons, that this space is the place where they can come share their

Christina Elmer:

experiences of leaving high demand belief systems and that their stories matter.

Christina Elmer:

Um, also being a person of color, being Japanese American, often feel

Christina Elmer:

like I don't fit in a lot of places and I want to be able to create a

Christina Elmer:

community where anybody, regardless of their skin tone, that they can feel

Christina Elmer:

like what they have to say that their experiences matter, that they just matter.

Christina Elmer:

They themselves as a human being.

Christina Elmer:

So here we are leaving in color the podcast for uncovering.

Christina Elmer:

Your amazing self after leaving your faith or losing your faith.

Christina Elmer:

Today's episode is going to be a great one.

Christina Elmer:

Um, the guest that we have today is a very...

Christina Elmer:

I don't want to say old because we're really not that old, we're actually pretty

Christina Elmer:

fucking fabulous, is my amazing kind.

Christina Elmer:

wonderful, strong friend, Marcos.

Christina Elmer:

and he has so graciously decided to join us here today to share

Christina Elmer:

with us his story of finding the strength to uncover his truest self.

Christina Elmer:

It wasn't an easy path, but here he is, and he has survived, and he is here to

Christina Elmer:

share his amazing experience with us.

Christina Elmer:

It's a little wild because we're recording on a Sunday and for a lot of

Christina Elmer:

people in Christianity and Mormonism in particular, Sunday is the day of rest.

Christina Elmer:

It's the Lord's day.

Christina Elmer:

And it's, for a lot of people that are out of Mormonism or whatever

Christina Elmer:

their journey may be, um, Sunday is considered a second Saturday.

Christina Elmer:

So it feels very serendipitous to be recording on a Sunday, but

Christina Elmer:

I would love to now introduce to you after that long spiel.

Christina Elmer:

my lovely, amazing, talented, wonderful friend, Marcos.

Christina Elmer:

Um, it's wild that we're here, um, 20 years later after meeting at the Lord's

Christina Elmer:

University, Brigham Young University.

Christina Elmer:

Welcome Marcos.

Christina Elmer:

I'm so glad you're here.

Marcos:

Thank you.

Marcos:

Thank you so much.

Marcos:

I'm very happy to be here.

Marcos:

Thank you for the invite.

Marcos:

And congratulations,

Christina Elmer:

Thank you.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

It's been, I contacted Marcos.

Christina Elmer:

When was it?

Christina Elmer:

It was back in April when I got the idea to start the podcast and it's

Christina Elmer:

been months of, I had to really muster up the courage to get into the space

Christina Elmer:

where I could just really trust my ability to say that I belong, you know?

Christina Elmer:

And so thank you for being willing to do this journey with

Christina Elmer:

me and to be the first guest.

Christina Elmer:

Um, Where do we begin?

Christina Elmer:

I

Christina Elmer:

Yeah, Marcos and I have known each other for 20 years, as I said, and, um, we met

Christina Elmer:

in college and we'll, we'll talk about a little bit about our time at Brigham

Christina Elmer:

Young University back in the late 90s,

Marcos:

The early

Christina Elmer:

uh, the early 2000s, um, we're totally aging ourselves here.

Marcos:

Yeah, the eve of the new millennium.

Christina Elmer:

My goodness.

Christina Elmer:

And the thing is just like.

Christina Elmer:

I think, I honestly feel, Marcos and I are here sitting on video and we have

Christina Elmer:

both definitely gotten better with age.

Christina Elmer:

We're both like fine wines.

Christina Elmer:

We've definitely gotten better with age, or fine cheese if you don't

Christina Elmer:

drink alcohol, but, or whatever gets

Marcos:

Right, right, right.

Christina Elmer:

But definitely, and it has also to do probably

Christina Elmer:

with the fact that, you know, we also have great genetics.

Christina Elmer:

So...

Christina Elmer:

we're both mixed.

Christina Elmer:

We're both mixed.

Christina Elmer:

I'm, I'm half Japanese and Marcos is...

Christina Elmer:

I'll let him tell his story, but um, but yeah Marcos, please tell us, who are you?

Marcos:

let's see, that's a tough question.

Marcos:

I am California local, so born and raised, um, very

Marcos:

proud to be from California.

Marcos:

I feel very fortunate to be, be here.

Marcos:

Um, my...

Marcos:

Grandparents had migrated here, um, almost a hundred years ago, from Mexico.

Marcos:

Um, so with that, there's a long and now long family history,

Marcos:

specifically in Southern California.

Marcos:

And so I'm very happy to still reside in the state and in the history

Marcos:

that we have here as a family.

Marcos:

Um, I'm very proud of my Mexican heritage.

Marcos:

Um, my, so on my mom's side, I am Mexican.

Marcos:

And then my dad's side, um, my dad is white.

Marcos:

He has a long history in this, in this country, um, as well.

Marcos:

Like, I think like his ancestry might go back to like the Mayflower.

Christina Elmer:

Cool.

Marcos:

I don't really though.

Marcos:

connect with that side of my, um, of my heritage per se.

Marcos:

Um, I'm happy for my dad and his heritage and I see that as, as all,

Marcos:

you know, very good for him, but it's not something that I fully connect to.

Marcos:

Um, and I think that works for me and I think that works for him.

Marcos:

Um, I know, um, it's all very complicated when you're mixed as I'm sure, you

Marcos:

know, um, it can be complicated.

Marcos:

So it's one of those scenes where I'm like, my dad is

Marcos:

white, but I am not, right?

Marcos:

So, very interested and involved with being Latino, Chicano,

Marcos:

Mexican American, person of color.

Marcos:

That's something that's really important to me.

Marcos:

Um, I also identify as gay, um, and, you know, I think being from marginalized

Marcos:

groups and just depending on your experience, I think sometimes the more you

Marcos:

have to battle things along your process and journey with those identities, it

Marcos:

just makes you hold on to it more dearly.

Marcos:

Um, so I think, uh, I became even more proud of my identities as I've had

Marcos:

different experiences within my life or have had to, like, defend myself and...

Marcos:

defend those identities and communities.

Marcos:

Um, so it's something that's very proud to me.

Marcos:

I know some people don't understand that.

Marcos:

But you know, like I say, if, if you don't want people to be so

Marcos:

proud of their identities, maybe you shouldn't treat them like shit.

Marcos:

Yeah.

Marcos:

Because when you treat them that way, they're going to start to be, you

Marcos:

know, be more proud of it because they have no choice but to latch

Marcos:

on to it once they realize that that's what you just need to do.

Marcos:

But I'm someone who I definitely value kindness.

Marcos:

I value empathy.

Marcos:

I value community.

Marcos:

I just try to be a better person each day.

Marcos:

Um, and when I'm not, I try the next day.

Marcos:

yeah, that's kind of me in a nutshell.

Marcos:

Um, anything else you want to know with that, or that kind of covers it?

Christina Elmer:

No, that was, that was beautiful.

Christina Elmer:

Thank you.

Marcos:

You're welcome.

Christina Elmer:

I loved when you said that, because of the way that people

Christina Elmer:

have treated you, or just people that treat people that are marginalized, that,

Christina Elmer:

you know, we need to latch onto that identity, and it makes it stronger for us.

Christina Elmer:

I think I've not actually thought about that in that way, and thank

Christina Elmer:

you for bringing that to light because it's actually something

Christina Elmer:

for me to think about now.

Christina Elmer:

Like, I identify as Japanese You know, but I feel like I haven't

Christina Elmer:

really tapped into that a whole lot.

Christina Elmer:

I also being you know, a cis Asian woman.

Christina Elmer:

I feel like I haven't experienced a lot of marginalization or even

Christina Elmer:

racism or hatred because of who I am.

Christina Elmer:

I still have a lot of privilege.

Christina Elmer:

Um, and so thank you for sharing that with me and, you know, saying that, that that's

Christina Elmer:

allowed you to, to come into who you are.

Christina Elmer:

And I, I think that's beautiful.

Christina Elmer:

And I would love to explore that more as we get, further into this podcast

Christina Elmer:

and have more of a conversation because I'm very, very curious about

Christina Elmer:

the journey of, how you came into the beautiful human that you are today.

Christina Elmer:

Not that you weren't beautiful 20 years ago, but you know, just, just

Christina Elmer:

seeing you evolve, as your friend has been just beautiful to, to watch.

Marcos:

Thank you.

Christina Elmer:

You're welcome.

Christina Elmer:

Um, So, obviously you went to Brigham Young University,

Christina Elmer:

you grew up Mormon, right?

Christina Elmer:

Um, what was that experience like growing up in Southern California?

Christina Elmer:

where there's a predominantly huge Mormon LDS, Church of Jesus

Christina Elmer:

Christ of Latter day Saints.

Christina Elmer:

We need to call them by their proper name, right?

Christina Elmer:

They don't, they don't like being called Mormons anymore.

Christina Elmer:

Um, Members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints.

Christina Elmer:

That is a mouthful.

Marcos:

It is.

Christina Elmer:

Um, but what was that like growing up, as a Chicano

Christina Elmer:

man in a predominantly white religion?

Christina Elmer:

You know, very North American white religion.

Christina Elmer:

yeah, let's start with that.

Marcos:

Very complicated.

Marcos:

Very complicated.

Marcos:

Um, you know, I, like you said, was born and raised in the church, um,

Marcos:

on my mom's side, so on my Mexican side, I'm actually fourth generation.

Christina Elmer:

Fourth generation LDS.

Christina Elmer:

Oh, wow.

Christina Elmer:

Okay.

Marcos:

Yeah.

Marcos:

So her, her grandmother, so my great grandmother, had converted when

Marcos:

some of her kids were very young.

Marcos:

So when my grandmother was very young,

Christina Elmer:

In Mexico?

Marcos:

my grandmother's...

Marcos:

Yeah, in Mexico.

Marcos:

Yeah.

Marcos:

So at this point, I believe it was still in central Mexico.

Marcos:

Um, that's where my grandmother's from and that's where they're just,

Marcos:

that's just where they originated.

Marcos:

And, my grandmother's father had, had passed away, um, when he was

Marcos:

young or when she was very young.

Marcos:

And so soon after that, I believe is when the missionaries came to my great

Marcos:

grandmother's house and she converted.

Marcos:

You know, I mean, I can get into that later, but the church has been

Marcos:

very significant, very important for generations within my family.

Marcos:

And then my dad was actually a convert, so he converted in his

Marcos:

20s, I believe his early 20s.

Marcos:

And, um, my mom and my dad, they actually met the day after he

Marcos:

got baptized, um, at church.

Marcos:

Yeah,

Christina Elmer:

Was it in, was it in a, a young single adults

Christina Elmer:

ward or a family congregation?

Marcos:

Um, good question.

Marcos:

I believe it was still the family ward.

Marcos:

I believe it was the family ward.

Marcos:

And, uh, so, yeah, they met the day after he got baptized.

Marcos:

And then soon had their courtship and, uh, they both went on missions and basically

Marcos:

let's see what happens type thing.

Marcos:

And then they came back and then soon after got married and went from there.

Marcos:

So, um, and they're still very, um, very strong on the church, very much LDS.

Marcos:

And, uh, so I grew up in very.

Marcos:

what's the word?

Marcos:

I forget the word.

Marcos:

Uh, it's funny how it works when you're a little bit far further

Marcos:

removed from religion, you forget some of the words and terms.

Marcos:

but they, they were very, it was a very faithful household.

Marcos:

They definitely ruled, um, raised us with the church's guidelines.

Marcos:

However, they weren't overly zealous about some things, which was nice.

Marcos:

Um, but they were pretty, you know, by the book in most areas.

Marcos:

So, you know, most of my ward, um, and area, well, most of the

Marcos:

ward specifically was white.

Marcos:

Um, there were a few of us who were not, few families that

Marcos:

were not, but most were white.

Marcos:

For the most part, I would say I had a good experience, like people were

Marcos:

very nice, um, you know, within time, you know, I was like a teenager, I

Marcos:

developed really strong bonds with some of the senior citizen, uh, women

Marcos:

in our ward, and we loved hugging each other, you know, most of them

Marcos:

were white, um, but there were some of like the older brown women too that we

Marcos:

connected, um, the most part it was good.

Marcos:

However, there definitely were a lot of microaggressions.

Marcos:

that you just hear from the pulpit and you encounter, in your socializing

Marcos:

with people, it's a lot of, a lot of microaggressions and racism.

Marcos:

Like even when I went to a wedding, um, probably like eight years ago of

Marcos:

a friend I grew up with in the church.

Marcos:

A very nice family, um, was there, and I was just surprised

Marcos:

by some of the microaggressions that immediately came out.

Marcos:

While trying to give a compliment, it was a backhanded, while, complimenting me

Marcos:

and my family was insulting my, you know, ethnic community, and I was like, okay.

Marcos:

So there definitely was a lot of that with my experience in the church.

Marcos:

Um, and then just hearing, and it feels odd using this term now, but all the

Marcos:

Lamanite talk that they would have, how the fetishization and, you know,

Marcos:

just all sorts of things that they do with brown people and say about

Marcos:

brown people was really frustrating.

Marcos:

Um, so it was definitely a mixed bag.

Marcos:

I'm very thankful for my experience overall.

Marcos:

I feel like it taught me about faith and prayer and provide a community.

Marcos:

And, you know, with the fact that you learn so many little skills that

Marcos:

you wouldn't have been exposed to otherwise, like as a kid, right.

Marcos:

How to make photocopies, how to, how, how

Christina Elmer:

I mean, the church library was like, anytime you got access

Christina Elmer:

to the church library, it was just like, you felt like a freaking baller

Christina Elmer:

because it had everything in there.

Christina Elmer:

It had the crayons.

Christina Elmer:

It had all the artwork and the copy machine, which was always broken.

Christina Elmer:

it was always broken, but it was just like, when you got to use it, it was just

Christina Elmer:

like, you felt like, so freaking cool.

Marcos:

That's so true.

Marcos:

Like, I remember as a kid, we would photocopy our face

Christina Elmer:

No!

Marcos:

machine.

Marcos:

Like, I never would have experienced this otherwise, right?

Marcos:

You didn't get a chance to do it as a kid in private.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah,oh

Marcos:

So you learn a lot of little skills, you know, and so

Marcos:

that was all rewarding and I, um, was very appreciative of it.

Marcos:

And so it's weird when that becomes a place of solace and peace and

Marcos:

then it starts conflicting with you and then it's no longer that.

Marcos:

Or it's like, or it could be both at the same time, right?

Marcos:

And that's where it starts getting really complicated and really, um, unfortunate

Marcos:

to where it could feel like a betrayal.

Marcos:

So it was every which experience I would say.

Marcos:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Would you mind expounding a little bit more, um, for

Christina Elmer:

listeners that may not really know kind of the theology in Mormonism

Christina Elmer:

and regarding the Lamanite people

Marcos:

yeah.

Marcos:

Um, at least at the time when I, um, was involved, I'm sure, I'm assuming most of

Marcos:

it has stayed the same, um, essentially it was believed and taught that Lamanites

Marcos:

are essentially the ancestors of present day, um, Native Americans, um, or

Marcos:

those with, you know, Native descent.

Marcos:

Um, so it can include many, you know, people from Latin America, uh, Um,

Marcos:

some also extended it to like the Pacific Islanders, in my experience,

Marcos:

my family would have been more with the native ancestry aspect.

Marcos:

Um, and my family is very much brown, um, my Mexican family.

Marcos:

So, um, definitely they were seen as like descendants of Lamanites.

Marcos:

And, um, with that, um, essentially Lamanites they descended

Marcos:

from the family, Lehi and his family who came from Jerusalem.

Marcos:

They came to what is the Americas.

Marcos:

Um, essentially the promised land.

Marcos:

Um, they arrived.

Marcos:

Lehman and Lem Lehman and Lem

Christina Elmer:

yes.

Marcos:

Lemuel, should I say it correctly now, they were, uh,

Marcos:

essentially the, the evil sons, the evil

Christina Elmer:

They were really vilified.

Marcos:

Yes, and of course, um, their followers were then known

Marcos:

as the Lamanites, were then, as they were were cursed with dark

Marcos:

skin or cursed in general, but the mark of that was the brown skin.

Marcos:

And so, there's both this deep demonization, but then also like

Marcos:

this fetishization that happens, um, with, um, these groups.

Marcos:

And so it's really, Interesting to see and just, I know like many family members

Marcos:

and I definitely were uncomfortable with some of these things that were

Marcos:

said and it wasn't until BYU, my Book of Mormon professor, who's a very nice

Marcos:

man, um, he tried clarifying it as far as like, no, the brown skin, the dark

Marcos:

skin is not the curse, that's the mark and then the curse is something else.

Marcos:

I mean, it definitely is playing semantics, um, but definitely at

Marcos:

the time it felt a little better.

Marcos:

Like, thank you for saying this in a predominantly white classroom.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

Um, because people are going around thinking that we're cursed.

Marcos:

And, you know, many Christian denominations have that

Marcos:

mentality about people of color.

Marcos:

That, you know, white is virtuous, white is pure, and we just see that

Marcos:

throughout, not just religion, but like literature and just society, right?

Marcos:

Going back, the fair maiden and all

Christina Elmer:

Always dressed in virginal white.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

Exactly.

Marcos:

So it's overlapped so much with like race, ethnicity, and gender

Marcos:

when it comes down to that.

Marcos:

And so all that was very complicated.

Marcos:

You know, being a kid, some of it was like a sense of pride.

Marcos:

Right?

Marcos:

Like.

Marcos:

You know, that's right.

Marcos:

Like, we, you know, this is where we're from.

Marcos:

This is our land.

Marcos:

Christ came to visit us as well.

Marcos:

And we matter too.

Marcos:

But now as an adult removed from that ideology, I'm like, I do not like

Marcos:

how they still like take those tours.

Marcos:

Like, no, no, no, no.

Marcos:

from my perspective, that's not your ancestor stories.

Marcos:

Those are indigenous people and these descended people's history and

Marcos:

families and stories and beliefs.

Marcos:

So I don't like how they Columbus that still.

Marcos:

Um, so that really bothers me.

Marcos:

Um, and it's also led to a lot of other, it's contributed to a lot of other groups

Marcos:

out there, um, that do, essentially pirate indigenous history and culture.

Marcos:

And, um, so it's very problematic in that regard.

Marcos:

So it's all very conflicted, right?

Marcos:

On one hand, at one point it's like, yay.

Marcos:

And then I was like, nay.

Marcos:

Um, so, um, so it's very complicated, but that, that was

Marcos:

my overall experience with that.

Marcos:

Um, but I do definitely think it's problematic.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

For sure.

Christina Elmer:

It definitely is.

Christina Elmer:

I, yeah, I can definitely relate to that.

Christina Elmer:

And it's different because being of Japanese descent, like there's not,

Christina Elmer:

you know, I didn't necessarily identify with the Lamanites per se, but I did to

Christina Elmer:

an extent, like, especially when I had children and, you know, we'd be reading

Christina Elmer:

from the Book of Mormon and it would talk about, people, because they were wicked,

Christina Elmer:

they were cursed with darker skin, and,

Marcos:

hmm.

Marcos:

Mm hmm.

Christina Elmer:

my, ex husband is of German descent, so he's very fair skinned

Christina Elmer:

and, my, my children have some color.

Christina Elmer:

But you know, it's, it was, there's the, there's a term in the book of Mormon

Christina Elmer:

that talks about white and delightsome.

Christina Elmer:

And even like as a child, just reading that, cause you know, I'm naturally

Christina Elmer:

tan, like, um, a lot of, there's different variations of skin tone

Christina Elmer:

within, you know, people, colors, you know, even within Japanese,

Marcos:

Right.

Marcos:

. Christina Elmer: And so, um, I just remember reading that and just being

Marcos:

like, what the hell, what the hell does white and dark, it's so mean, you know,

Marcos:

it feels very, and you know, there's Mormon apologists that sit there and

Marcos:

they, you know, as your Book of Mormon professor at BYU tried to recognize

Marcos:

that there was some issue with it and tried to maybe add in a little bit of,

Marcos:

there was a little bit more nuanced than, you know, it was intended, but you

Marcos:

know, I think he, he tried to make it.

Marcos:

fit into something, maybe what he was believing for himself.

Marcos:

And maybe that wasn't what necessarily what Joseph Smith intended, but I

Marcos:

do appreciate that he, he did do that because he was acknowledging

Marcos:

that there was some problematic themes within what he was teaching.

Marcos:

Um, and I, I appreciate that.

Marcos:

But yeah, some of the, just looking back and, you know, cause my, my,

Marcos:

my kids are still very active in the church because my ex husband is.

Marcos:

And so I still have a connection to it in a sense.

Marcos:

Um, but it's just very interesting kind of remembering those things that we

Marcos:

read as kids and just, you know, I...

Marcos:

I don't know if your experience was like this, but I, I didn't

Marcos:

really read the Book of Mormon.

Marcos:

Like, it was just kind of like, I read it once to get done with my young women's

Marcos:

certification, like the young women's, whatever the thing was, because it was

Marcos:

like, you know, looking for external validation because, you know, my, I came

Marcos:

from a family that wasn't necessarily fitting into the normal Mormon,

Marcos:

confines of what a perfect family was.

Marcos:

Um, and so I felt like I had to do it.

Marcos:

And so I read the book of Mormon just once, just to get, the, you

Marcos:

know, beautiful medallion with the Salt Lake temple and graved on it,

Marcos:

which they don't do that anymore.

Marcos:

So it feels less rewarding in young women's, they just did like little

Marcos:

bookmarks with ribbons and like,

Marcos:

Oh.

Christina Elmer:

You know,

Marcos:

I used to like their

Christina Elmer:

I know!

Christina Elmer:

We got some sweet swag in Young Women's

Marcos:

need something

Christina Elmer:

I know, especially with the Boy Scouts

Christina Elmer:

getting as much swag as they did.

Christina Elmer:

It was always nice as a Young Woman to get the Golden Medallion when you

Christina Elmer:

finished and Beehives and Miamades and Laurels when you finished all of it.

Christina Elmer:

So, I always loved

Marcos:

I wanted, I would have preferred a medallion over a tie tack.

Marcos:

To be honest, I'm like,

Christina Elmer:

Right?

Christina Elmer:

Yes, I know.

Marcos:

can you make this a medallion, not

Christina Elmer:

sure.

Marcos:

tie tack?

Marcos:

But I'll settle for it.

Marcos:

Fine.

Marcos:

I can wear it on Sunday.

Marcos:

But,

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

But I want to go back to what you said about like that scripture.

Marcos:

Um, I have a book right here.

Marcos:

I'm actually, there's a Mexican, a Mormon, I forgot what it's called, but

Marcos:

like Mormon Mexican history museum.

Marcos:

It's just a very small, like little

Christina Elmer:

And where's Improba?

Christina Elmer:

Okay.

Marcos:

And about 10 years ago, um, I went, I'm like, okay, I want to see.

Marcos:

Cause you know, my, my grandmother, I, as I mentioned, she was from

Marcos:

central Mexico, but they had migrated to Northern Mexico when she was

Marcos:

younger as well and after they converted and stuff and were baptized.

Marcos:

So they were actually living in the Mormon colonies in northern Mexico, so

Christina Elmer:

The colonias.

Marcos:

because Say it

Christina Elmer:

The colonias.

Marcos:

Yes, exactly.

Marcos:

Exactly.

Marcos:

Look at you, El

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

You know.

Christina Elmer:

You know.

Marcos:

You know all about it.

Marcos:

Um, and actually El Paso is where my grandparents, um,

Christina Elmer:

Oh, that's really

Marcos:

So, yeah, yeah.

Marcos:

Um, but, so we figured there would be some family history at the museum.

Marcos:

So we went, because part of like, we don't, you know, just to learn more.

Marcos:

And so we went and I was so bothered because the book that they sell there,

Marcos:

it has that scripture on the front cover.

Marcos:

And essentially, and you look like the Journal of Discourses, prophets, you

Marcos:

know, passages talking about, like, especially about Mexican people, they

Marcos:

would talk and, you know, native descended or native people in general, they would

Marcos:

talk about, and bring up like, oh, pretty much after being converted and

Marcos:

following the church, they became whiter.

Marcos:

They became lighter.

Marcos:

Can you believe it?

Marcos:

This shows how great the church's teachings are.

Marcos:

And I'm like, it's all documented.

Marcos:

So this book has it on the cover and it has a picture of a bunch of brown people.

Marcos:

And then it has that on top.

Marcos:

So I got it just for that reason, because I wanted to have proof of it.

Marcos:

And I wanted, I was tempted to email them.

Marcos:

I, I'm like, I need to calm down before doing so.

Marcos:

But I, but I didn't.

Marcos:

It's still not too late, but um, it's been sitting, you know, on

Marcos:

my bookshelf for about a decade.

Marcos:

And I'm so annoyed still about it.

Christina Elmer:

That's wild.

Christina Elmer:

Thank you for sharing that.

Christina Elmer:

Um, when you were talking and we were sharing about, you know,

Christina Elmer:

when you're talking, explaining to our listeners about, um, Laman

Christina Elmer:

and Lemuel, it was interesting.

Christina Elmer:

When I was kind of exploring different versions of Mormonism

Christina Elmer:

while in Mormonism, coming into my baby feminist stage in Mormonism.

Christina Elmer:

Um, Um, but also realizing, you know, being, what do we call Asian?

Christina Elmer:

Are we do, are Asians, are we considered brown?

Christina Elmer:

Are we considered, you know, I just, I just go with persons of color.

Christina Elmer:

Cause that's what feels most safe to me.

Christina Elmer:

Like how do, how do I fit into the grand scheme of the ideology and

Christina Elmer:

the belief system of the church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints.

Christina Elmer:

And what do I want my children to know?

Christina Elmer:

Because they're, they're like a weird percentage because

Christina Elmer:

I'm three quarters Japanese.

Christina Elmer:

And so they're like 38 percent Japanese.

Christina Elmer:

But how do I want my kids to feel in this belief system that's very,

Christina Elmer:

very, very whitewashed and feels very call, you know, has a real

Christina Elmer:

colonial colonization feel to it.

Christina Elmer:

Um, and it was interesting as I was kind of looking at, um, Mormon literature

Christina Elmer:

written by, you know, Mormon authors, people that are still believers

Christina Elmer:

within Mormonism, but had a little bit more of a nuanced take to Mormonism.

Christina Elmer:

Um, one book that I found and, um, she's a fiction writer, you may

Christina Elmer:

have to put it in the show notes.

Christina Elmer:

I can't remember her name.

Christina Elmer:

Um, but I loved the books that she wrote and there was one that she wrote

Christina Elmer:

and I, I'm going to tear up thinking about it because it just really spoke

Christina Elmer:

to me was called The Book of Laman.

Christina Elmer:

I don't know if you you ever read it

Marcos:

hmm.

Marcos:

Mm hmm.

Christina Elmer:

You may not have because I think I read it in like 2017

Marcos:

Okay.

Christina Elmer:

But it's about Laman's take on the book of Nephi

Marcos:

ooh,

Christina Elmer:

It was it still may be a very interesting read now for

Marcos:

right.

Christina Elmer:

I'm curious as to where you are now within, within Mormonism.

Christina Elmer:

Um, but when I read it, I felt such a connection to it cause it really came

Christina Elmer:

from a place of like struggle and, you know, just cause growing up, we had

Christina Elmer:

really seen it as they were very vilified, like they were wicked and they were,

Christina Elmer:

you know, rebellious and they fought against their father, Lehi, and they, you

Christina Elmer:

know, tied up their righteous brother.

Christina Elmer:

Um, but we never got the perspective of Laman and Lemuel,

Christina Elmer:

like what were they going through?

Christina Elmer:

What was their experience?

Christina Elmer:

And as I've matured as a human being, I really wanted to know

Christina Elmer:

different perspectives in the Bible or in the Book of Mormon.

Christina Elmer:

Like what are women's take on, you know, what happened when Jesus was on earth?

Christina Elmer:

Or why aren't there more stories within the Bible or Book of Mormon

Christina Elmer:

where women are actually named, you know, and I would ask friends

Christina Elmer:

about it or my spouse at the time.

Christina Elmer:

And the answer that I consistently got was, oh, there's stories,

Christina Elmer:

you just have to look for it.

Christina Elmer:

And I would look and I wouldn't find anything.

Christina Elmer:

And the thing that I really appreciated towards the end of my journey in Mormonism

Christina Elmer:

was there was a lot more coming out about women in, in the scriptures,

Christina Elmer:

you know, women in the Bible, there's, volumes of, of text of, um, people taking

Christina Elmer:

dedicated time to research women in the Bible and the Old and New Testaments.

Christina Elmer:

And I don't know if there was one that ever came out about the book of Mormon,

Christina Elmer:

but back to reading the book of Laman, it just like this story was granted, it was

Christina Elmer:

fictionalized and it was this woman's, this, the author's take of how she felt

Christina Elmer:

Laman was experiencing, you know, coming to the Americas and, you know, how he felt

Christina Elmer:

after he tied Nephi up on the ship and how he felt when, you know, he was forced to

Christina Elmer:

go and get the scriptures, you know, the brass plates from Laman and, or Laban.

Christina Elmer:

And it just was such a beautiful read.

Christina Elmer:

I almost want to go back and read it because, um.

Christina Elmer:

It's bringing up a lot of emotion for me.

Christina Elmer:

I remember reading it and thinking about it when we were on family vacation

Christina Elmer:

in southern Utah, and I just kept feeling so connected to that story.

Christina Elmer:

And even now leaving, having left Mormonism three years ago, I wish

Christina Elmer:

that there were more things like that available, whether, especially for people

Christina Elmer:

that decide to stay in Mormonism, you know, to have, um, stories written for

Christina Elmer:

them about that they can identify with more and not, you know, read the Book of

Christina Elmer:

Mormon and, and feel detached from it, but feel like they have to believe it because

Christina Elmer:

they're told that they have to believe it.

Christina Elmer:

You know what I mean?

Marcos:

hmm.

Marcos:

Mm hmm.

Christina Elmer:

It's also beautiful to see the journey that Mormonism

Christina Elmer:

has taken for a lot of people.

Christina Elmer:

Like there's a lot of people that are still in that are really working to make

Christina Elmer:

Mormonism a place where people can stay, you know, if they, if they choose to stay.

Christina Elmer:

And I, I really appreciate those, those individuals who are doing that work

Christina Elmer:

because there is something to be said about having a belief system and having

Christina Elmer:

a community and, but it's hard when you can't find yourself in a lot of,

Christina Elmer:

of, you know, the, the images, the, the pictures that are used in Mormonism,

Christina Elmer:

you know, you can't see yourself,

Marcos:

The The pioneer stories.

Christina Elmer:

which, you know, then they say, you know, you can, you're

Christina Elmer:

a pioneer in your own right, but it's like, I don't identify with those people

Christina Elmer:

crossing the plains and suffering.

Christina Elmer:

And yes, like I have ancestors on my dad's side that probably

Christina Elmer:

have crossed the plains.

Christina Elmer:

I actually have not done a lot of family history.

Christina Elmer:

That was one thing I didn't really love was the family

Christina Elmer:

history aspect of the church.

Christina Elmer:

But, you know, I did have family members that did cross the plains as I'm sure if

Christina Elmer:

you'd, anyone does any research into their family history, but it, yeah, I, it's not

Christina Elmer:

something that a lot of people of color.

Christina Elmer:

You know, brown people can really identify with, which we do have

Christina Elmer:

our own versions of our, our own people coming into this country.

Christina Elmer:

And it's not necessarily that, but it is, it does resonate with us.

Christina Elmer:

And I wish that we had more of that in, in the form of religion,

Christina Elmer:

if, if that calls to people.

Marcos:

Right.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah, it's just interesting that growing up in, even in my

Christina Elmer:

congregation in El Paso, Texas, you know, which is on the border, there was a good

Christina Elmer:

mix of, you know, we had black people, we had brown people, we had white people.

Christina Elmer:

I, but I was the only Asian in my congregation.

Christina Elmer:

and.

Christina Elmer:

I don't think I really came into my Asian ness until I got to BYU.

Christina Elmer:

And I would really love to talk about our, our time at BYU.

Christina Elmer:

Um, but yeah, we may have to come back to this.

Christina Elmer:

It's not, it's not feeling easeful, but, um, yeah, let's talk about BYU.

Marcos:

Yeah, Yeah, ha

Christina Elmer:

What, how, how did you end up there?

Christina Elmer:

Like, is it, because we know that BYU, for listeners out there, BYU is

Christina Elmer:

a church owned, supported university.

Christina Elmer:

And so, the tuition is subsidized by the monies that church members

Christina Elmer:

give in their tithe offerings.

Christina Elmer:

And so it makes it very economical for, you know, Mormon kids to go to

Christina Elmer:

Brigham Young University because tuition is subsidized and it's significantly

Christina Elmer:

less expensive than going even sometimes to the state institution.

Christina Elmer:

Um, so how did you end up at Brigham Young University?

Christina Elmer:

Provo, because they do have different campuses.

Christina Elmer:

They also have the Hawaii one, which I heard is much more

Christina Elmer:

difficult to get into, but

Marcos:

Okay.

Marcos:

I didn't

Christina Elmer:

how Provo?

Marcos:

Yeah.

Marcos:

So I always wanted to go ever since I was a kid.

Marcos:

Um,

Christina Elmer:

love that.

Christina Elmer:

I love that for you.

Christina Elmer:

I can just see you with, like, a little

Marcos:

I was quite the little Mormon boy with, I had a little BYU

Christina Elmer:

Oh my god,

Marcos:

I was so sad when, I was so sad when it flew off and I lost

Marcos:

it when we were on a family trip in Mexico in, in Ensenada, I was

Marcos:

like, oh, the wind took it away.

Marcos:

I was so sad.

Marcos:

But, so I just wanted to go there.

Marcos:

My eldest brother went there.

Marcos:

So it was something that always kind of had to, you know, to model after,

Marcos:

um, I went through a period as a kid wanting to go to BYU Hawaii.

Marcos:

Like, oh, that just sounds so cool, being in Hawaii on a tropical island.

Marcos:

Um, that dream was just very short lived.

Marcos:

But either way, I wanted to go to a BYU campus.

Marcos:

And so Provo was what I had in mind.

Marcos:

And I went to SOAR, um, which was their...

Marcos:

Um, summer of academic refinement, which was for, um, students of color, um, and or

Marcos:

I think it's since it's expanded a little bit, but it's still students of color and

Marcos:

lower income backgrounds, first generation college students, like a combination,

Marcos:

but all of us were students of color.

Marcos:

And, um, it's before your senior year of high school.

Marcos:

So I went there, and essentially they help prep you for college, help prep

Marcos:

you for admissions to BYU, prep you for the ACT, and you actually take

Marcos:

the ACT there as well, which is a standardized test for those who aren't

Marcos:

familiar with the ACT versus the SAT.

Marcos:

Um, and, so that was, that was where I wanted to go.

Marcos:

And then when I went to SOAR, that's where I got to meet the people from the

Marcos:

multicultural office and the recruiters.

Marcos:

Really bonded with some of them, made some great connections and, um,

Marcos:

relationships with some of the staff and there'll be our counselors or, um,

Marcos:

recruiters and different office personnel.

Marcos:

Some of which I'm still, you know, in communication with on social media.

Marcos:

And, um, so it was great.

Marcos:

I, the recruiter who I love so much, um, she was, she really walked me

Marcos:

through the process of admissions.

Marcos:

She actually personally told me that I was accepted to BYU over the phone.

Christina Elmer:

That's so

Marcos:

Um, because it was like a journey of like having to submit more documents

Marcos:

and have to send this and send that.

Marcos:

I was, um, a first generation college student, grew up low income, um, while

Marcos:

my parents, they had some experience, um, in college at a community college.

Marcos:

Um, you know, life happens as an adult, and so pretty much just working,

Marcos:

marriage, kids, um, that, that took over.

Marcos:

Um, so even though they didn't have the opportunity of college education,

Marcos:

they definitely encouraged it.

Marcos:

Um, so BYU felt in reach because of, you know, it was a Mormon owned church.

Marcos:

We constantly would hear about it.

Marcos:

My father went there, a lot of cousins went there, and so

Marcos:

it's just where I wanted to be.

Marcos:

So I was very thankful that I was accepted.

Marcos:

Um, it was through the Multicultural Office, so I definitely had a

Marcos:

lot of support through them.

Marcos:

Um, I was very fortunate to be granted a scholarship through them as well.

Marcos:

And this is where I wanted to be, so I was super ecstatic.

Marcos:

Overall I love the experience, uh, cause where I want it to be, a

Marcos:

fresh, being a freshmen's always an adjustment at first year, you know,

Marcos:

being out of state, um, was, it's always in being adjustment period.

Marcos:

and I was fortunate to have, you know, some cousins at the school,

Marcos:

but other cousins in the area, just extended family in the area in

Marcos:

general is very lucky to have that.

Marcos:

As well as friends, people from SOAR, people from childhood, so it

Marcos:

was very, I was fortunate to not, I knew people already, so that helped.

Marcos:

but being at a PWI, uh, so primarily white institution, is very interesting.

Marcos:

Um, very, and BYU does love their acronyms as well as, as does education

Marcos:

in general, but BYU loves their acronyms.

Marcos:

Um, it was a big adjustment for me.

Marcos:

Um, you know, I grew up in Southern California where it's very diverse.

Marcos:

I was used to have, being around all people of color, just very diverse group

Marcos:

of people at all, most of the time.

Marcos:

And being where you're by far the minority was really an adjustment for me.

Marcos:

And thank goodness for the Multicultural Office, um, and all their activities

Marcos:

and programs I was part of, and meeting you and your group of friends.

Marcos:

Um, other friendships that I, you know, had there was very helpful to make that

Marcos:

world much smaller and where most of my close friends there were people of color,

Marcos:

um, with the exception of, you know, a few token white people, um, which I,

Marcos:

which I, which I built is the opposite, right, where I built good relationships

Marcos:

with or still in touch with, right?

Marcos:

Some of our mutual friends as well.

Marcos:

So, so I am appreciative of all that.

Marcos:

It took a turn though, um, because it was around this time when I was having to

Marcos:

figure myself out and my sexual identity.

Marcos:

So it was a really difficult time.

Marcos:

It was a mixed bag because it was both so much fun and so exhilarating

Marcos:

and I loved the knowledge.

Marcos:

I loved the experience.

Marcos:

You know, with some struggles there too though because I

Marcos:

was a new college student.

Marcos:

But then being away and trying to figure it out, because, you know,

Marcos:

I was 18 and, you know, at the time, 19 was the missionary age.

Marcos:

And what I didn't want to do, and this is just for me only,

Marcos:

what I didn't want to do was...

Marcos:

go on a mission and figure it out there.

Marcos:

I wanted to have it figured out before I went, before I did the whole temple thing.

Marcos:

I wanted to be clear about who am I, where do I stand with

Marcos:

this about my sexual identity.

Marcos:

So that's why I put that on myself.

Marcos:

Looking back, I was very young.

Marcos:

I could, I had a lot more time to figure it out if I wanted, but

Marcos:

I didn't want to do that because of my belief in the church.

Marcos:

I knew that their stance on that.

Marcos:

So I didn't want to necessarily, I had to be true to myself, but without

Marcos:

what I thought was disrespecting their teachings at the same time,

Marcos:

um, which was a really hard balance.

Marcos:

So that's why at 18, essentially I kind of put that on myself, while a

Marcos:

BYU student, um, to start exploring.

Marcos:

And so with that, that doesn't really, you know, coincide being a BYU

Marcos:

student and exploring your sexuality.

Marcos:

Um, but I felt like I owed it to myself to do that.

Marcos:

Um, it was, it was a struggle though, because there's so much

Marcos:

Mormon guilt, um, that was attached.

Marcos:

So it was really hard.

Marcos:

Like, definitely looking back on it, I definitely think I had periods of,

Marcos:

of some depression there after I would explore, um, the depth, there was

Marcos:

a lot of, you know, self isolation.

Marcos:

There was, um, it was hard looking back on it and I will still try

Marcos:

to figure out what's next, right?

Marcos:

Because after freshman year, that's time to go on a mission.

Marcos:

So I had my year of trying to figure it out and exploring.

Marcos:

I didn't attach an identity to it.

Marcos:

I just attached actions.

Marcos:

Um, I didn't attach identity to the actions.

Marcos:

I just saw them as actions.

Marcos:

And at the end, uh, which is, kind of coincides with Mormonism too.

Marcos:

There's homosexual, quote, homosexual tendencies and same sex attraction,

Christina Elmer:

I hate those words.

Marcos:

versus your actual identity.

Marcos:

Me too.

Marcos:

Me too.

Marcos:

They're so frustrating.

Marcos:

So I spoke with my bishop at BYU.

Marcos:

Um, I stayed for the first summer term.

Marcos:

Um, I think you may have been

Christina Elmer:

I was there with you, yeah.

Marcos:

Yeah, and you know I was suffering in silence for the most part,

Marcos:

um, with all this, and I eventually did confide in one friend who was

Marcos:

going through something similar.

Marcos:

So thankfully we had each other at that time.

Marcos:

Um, but all in all, we were also handling it differently.

Marcos:

And so it was, it was just a very hard time for both of us.

Marcos:

And so I spoke to the Bishop and, it actually went pretty well, I would

Marcos:

say as well as it could have gone.

Marcos:

But because of the timing of it, you know, I'm about to go home for, the

Marcos:

school year now, from the school year.

Marcos:

And so I didn't now, because I had to work through it, right, like through

Marcos:

the repentance process, I would now have to tell my home bishop as well.

Marcos:

So I essentially had to tell two bishops.

Marcos:

And looking back on it, I mean, at that time, it's just the norm,

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

But looking back on it, it's so, um, not only is it so

Marcos:

vulnerable, but it's violating.

Marcos:

You are literally telling a middle aged man, or older man, what

Marcos:

you have done, giving details.

Marcos:

It feels odd.

Christina Elmer:

It's so fucking invasive.

Marcos:

can feel, yes, yes!

Marcos:

And so, long story short, essentially I would have had to have gone on

Marcos:

a mission to clear everything up.

Marcos:

Essentially, to go back to BYU to, you know, continue BYU with my scholarship.

Marcos:

you know, and then kind of go along my merry way.

Marcos:

So both bishops, all in all, were willing because they saw

Marcos:

that I did feel very guilty.

Marcos:

I did want to go on a mission.

Marcos:

I came from a family who's very missionary minded, and so I was starting the process.

Marcos:

Of course, the bishop at home was encouraging that I date girls.

Marcos:

as well.

Marcos:

And I'm like, oh, I don't really want to.

Marcos:

Um, but he was trying to be understanding.

Marcos:

He did have a scientific approach to some of his things, which the

Marcos:

first time I had heard some of that.

Marcos:

Um, so, okay, cool.

Marcos:

So he was, I think he did try.

Marcos:

I think both bishops did try.

Marcos:

Um, but all in all, once I saw like, I was figuring out if

Marcos:

this is really just who I am.

Marcos:

I stopped responding to correspondence, and then it became a big deal.

Marcos:

So, essentially, long story short, I was on the run, on the run, and what I

Marcos:

felt like on the run, for a long time.

Christina Elmer:

You were a fugitive.

Christina Elmer:

You're a fugitive from the morgue.

Marcos:

a fugitive.

Marcos:

I was a fugitive.

Marcos:

And all while virtually alone, um, thankfully at that time, as

Marcos:

I did have, I was in a long term relationship that had started.

Marcos:

And thankfully for him and his support, I started expressing bits and pieces to

Marcos:

like a close friend or to my close cousin, but without getting, giving details.

Marcos:

Um, the only one at the time that knew all the specifics were, um, my then boyfriend.

Marcos:

and I think actually my other close friend at the time who was also

Marcos:

going through something similar.

Marcos:

So those were the only two.

Marcos:

So I felt, it was very scary, you know, living at home and

Marcos:

just trying to start your life.

Marcos:

And I was working full time now at this time, not going

Marcos:

to school, because I still...

Marcos:

not telling people that I decided not to go on a mission yet and just trying

Marcos:

to prolong all these conversations, put off all these conversations as long as

Marcos:

I could, um, just trying to do my thing.

Marcos:

Um, so it's interesting because the church, my sexuality, and my personal

Marcos:

relationships, my familial relationships, so professional education, it's all

Marcos:

very intertwined for a long time.

Marcos:

And it was inevitable.

Marcos:

So it was really complicated.

Marcos:

So the life definitely took a turn that I was not, I never

Marcos:

would have expected, to be honest.

Marcos:

I had everything mapped out, you know, when you're Mormon, you kind of do.

Marcos:

And when certain things are expected of you, whether it be from the church or from

Marcos:

school or whatever, or just personally, you have it all mapped out and I did.

Marcos:

And when none of that happens or in that order or to those types, that gender

Marcos:

of people, it's really, it's really.

Marcos:

It throws you off.

Marcos:

And it took a long time for me to figure it out because I was in hiding and

Marcos:

having to protect myself and survive while still trying to move ahead.

Marcos:

Um, it was a lot.

Marcos:

it was a lot.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Wow.

Christina Elmer:

Oh, my heart, Marcos.

Christina Elmer:

Thank you for sharing that.

Christina Elmer:

It feels, like I can't imagine having to navigate all of that alone, you

Christina Elmer:

know, I know that you had a couple of people, but just, I, and maybe

Christina Elmer:

my, I'm assuming, but I, I know you to be a very social and loving

Christina Elmer:

person, you love being around people.

Christina Elmer:

So I can imagine that that was just so, probably heartbreaking, and terrifying,

Christina Elmer:

and just potentially made it much more difficult to even try to work through

Christina Elmer:

some of those things because you were so extremely isolated and you couldn't

Christina Elmer:

reach out when you needed people.

Marcos:

Thank you.

Marcos:

And you're exactly right.

Marcos:

It, it, through my young adulthood and actually adulthood

Marcos:

overall, I had to change.

Marcos:

I kept my circle very small.

Marcos:

Um, I grew up in a family that's also very private as well.

Marcos:

So I was kind of already used to, you know, being selective what I would share.

Marcos:

But that was kind of normal for me, but to have to be so selective

Marcos:

about who I can let into my life.

Marcos:

I may, I delayed on getting on social media.

Marcos:

I dreaded bumping into people because I didn't know what wasn't be said or

Marcos:

what wasn't be asked or what was heard.

Marcos:

And so it made it very, very hard, to create new relationships as an

Marcos:

adult, like friendships as an adult.

Marcos:

So thankfully, I was able to take in the circle of my then, um, my then boyfriend.

Marcos:

And we, you know, we had a very long term relationship.

Marcos:

We're still close friends.

Marcos:

I'm still good friends with his family.

Marcos:

So thank goodness for all their support that I've had for a very long time.

Marcos:

Um, and then fast forward now, you know, being married to a

Marcos:

wonderful man and having his circle.

Marcos:

And so, really, it's through them and their circles were my closest people

Marcos:

in my life, while also being selective who I would let in through work,

Marcos:

through school, um, along the way.

Marcos:

So it definitely did change, like, any, any idea of, like, developing

Marcos:

new friendships and socializing that I would have had during my time at BYU.

Marcos:

It had to shift.

Marcos:

And so it was hard, and then you kind of get used to it,

Marcos:

and that becomes your new norm.

Marcos:

Um, and when people do kind of like do you dirty along the

Marcos:

way about your sexual identity.

Marcos:

Um, and there's betrayal there that you just start to trust less

Marcos:

people and you start to just once again keep your circle even smaller.

Marcos:

And so it makes it hard.

Marcos:

It does.

Marcos:

Um, but you're right.

Marcos:

And I appreciate you seeing that and understanding that because I

Marcos:

don't think a lot of people would.

Marcos:

I, people would at the time in my early twenties, I would hear comments,

Marcos:

like they sensed a shift in me.

Marcos:

But I think it's funny because at that time we're growing up.

Marcos:

There were times where I was a little bit different than my usual

Marcos:

self and no one thought to ask why.

Marcos:

And that's what kind of hurts looking back on it.

Marcos:

That's something that recently hit me.

Marcos:

It's like, okay, I remember going through a really angsty period in

Marcos:

middle school and I remember people telling me, you're being different.

Marcos:

What's going on with you?

Marcos:

And the same thing happened when I was trying to hide my relationship and

Marcos:

hide the, prevent conversations about mission and BYU in my early twenties.

Marcos:

And I was having to be very quiet and not talk about my life, ask about their life.

Marcos:

And there were people that, that kind of called me out on being different,

Marcos:

um, or thought something was going on.

Marcos:

And so I think some people may have tried.

Marcos:

Did anyone stop to think, was I okay?

Marcos:

You know what I mean?

Marcos:

And that's what kind of hurts looking back on it.

Marcos:

Like, did anyone stop to think if I was okay?

Marcos:

Because I was on autopilot.

Marcos:

I was in survival mode.

Marcos:

And, facing it from a lot of people, it doesn't help, and it makes it hurtful.

Marcos:

Like, as a kid growing up, being perceived as gay was

Christina Elmer:

yeah, yeah, yeah,

Marcos:

Very, very hard.

Marcos:

And, and it literally started from before kindergarten, but at least kindergarten,

Marcos:

all the way up through, it never ended.

Marcos:

And that was hard, your whole educational experience, um, having to deal with

Marcos:

questions and assumptions and, and negative comments being made to you.

Marcos:

And no one, did anyone ever stop to think, was I okay?

Marcos:

Because I was sure trying to put on a happy face,

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

but at home it was, I was hard, I was struggling.

Marcos:

And so same thing as an adult.

Marcos:

So I thank you for kind of seeing that, um, because it was

Marcos:

just, definitely far from easy.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

I can imagine.

Christina Elmer:

In regards to your sexuality, was it something that you noticed,

Christina Elmer:

like you knew about yourself since the time that you were little?

Christina Elmer:

And it just, you know, because of Mormonism, it was something

Christina Elmer:

that, you know, just like, we, we don't acknowledge it.

Christina Elmer:

It's not, we're not labeling it.

Christina Elmer:

We're not putting a face to it because I can't.

Christina Elmer:

And then when you got to college, then it was like, okay, well,

Christina Elmer:

we're already on this journey of like, we're away from home, we're

Christina Elmer:

experiencing new things and people now.

Christina Elmer:

It's okay.

Marcos:

Um, great question.

Marcos:

It's so complicated.

Marcos:

It's one of those things where I'm very young, I would say probably around four

Marcos:

is when I know that I knew there was something different you know, like,

Marcos:

you don't I, at least in my experience and many others, you know, in our age

Marcos:

groups experience that I've heard, you don't necessarily attach an identity

Marcos:

to it, you don't attach a word to it.

Marcos:

But you know, it's just something's different about you.

Marcos:

And, you know, I did notice, men.

Marcos:

You know, men did catch my attention at times.

Marcos:

And, so I did know that, starting pretty young.

Marcos:

I didn't do anything with it until some online communications like later

Marcos:

in high school, but still very rare and still like trying to tune it out.

Marcos:

And then it wasn't until probably after graduation of high school when I was

Marcos:

more exploring more things online.

Marcos:

Um, and then going through early college years, um, is when I started, college

Marcos:

year, I guess, first freshman year is when I started doing more of that, um,

Marcos:

because I wanted, I still was unsure.

Marcos:

Because looking back on it, I think I was emotionally attracted to girls.

Christina Elmer:

Okay.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

So I definitely, I had the emotional, cause I had a lot of crushes

Marcos:

and this is not, and I, you know, I thought girls were pretty, and I, you

Marcos:

know, did some experimentation with girls, you know, first base type stuff,

Marcos:

um, but that's kind of where it stops.

Marcos:

Um, there wasn't anything strongly physical there, minus,

Marcos:

oh, they're a pretty girl.

Marcos:

You know, I'm supposed to marry a girl one day, so I'll get married to

Marcos:

a girl, you know, who's in this, we're gonna have a lot of kids, we're gonna

Marcos:

have a big wedding, um, of course I'll be the one to plan the wedding.

Christina Elmer:

Yes.

Marcos:

But, let me, I'm gonna pick out your dress.

Christina Elmer:

Yes

Marcos:

But, um, so it was all that type of thing, there was always a conflict,

Marcos:

everything was conflicting, right?

Marcos:

This dichotomy of this, you know, this versus that.

Marcos:

So it was complicated.

Marcos:

I did start having feelings of very young, um, but I was just trying

Marcos:

to be who I was throughout my life.

Marcos:

And it just, when you see that who you are is being ridiculed, then that's hard.

Marcos:

And that's when you start thinking about it more.

Marcos:

And I remember starting in early high school, maybe end of middle school,

Marcos:

but starting early high school, I was literally praying to be less feminine,

Marcos:

to be perceived as more as less feminine.

Marcos:

I would literally pray.

Marcos:

And I actually went to high school, my first semester of

Marcos:

high school was actually in Utah.

Marcos:

Um, cause my closest cousins had moved and we're like, oh, let's start,

Marcos:

let's go to high school together.

Marcos:

And there was some talk at the time of maybe my family moving to Utah

Marcos:

eventually, as in many Mormon families.

Marcos:

Um, and that didn't happen, but I started my first semester, um, in Utah.

Marcos:

And a lot of the reason that I never shared with anyone was, a

Marcos:

lot of them wanted a fresh start.

Marcos:

And I was basically trying to escape the comments , are you gay?

Marcos:

Or you are gay.

Marcos:

Or, and also there's nothing wrong with being gay, but at the time it

Marcos:

was definitely used as an insult, it wasn't a compliment, and, um, I wanted

Marcos:

a fresh start, and I figured if I move and start fresh, maybe I'll have that.

Marcos:

And actually I did at first, it was good, life was good, I was doing really well

Marcos:

in school, I was being more disciplined, because my cousin I was living with

Marcos:

was very disciplined, so I kind of like, followed his example with that.

Marcos:

Um, you know, there was the whole girl thing going on, there was

Marcos:

some attention, making friends.

Marcos:

This is nice.

Marcos:

And then boom, the end of that year, it started happening there too.

Marcos:

And because one of my closest friends I made there who was

Marcos:

the same, we were the same boat.

Marcos:

We were both perceived as gay.

Marcos:

Because that's who you're going to bond with or people that are very

Marcos:

similar to you and similar interests.

Marcos:

So we both had our love of divas and so we bonded.

Marcos:

And it started happening there.

Marcos:

And I was like, no, like, I obviously can't hide from this.

Marcos:

I can't run from it.

Marcos:

I should actually say I was there for the first semester.

Marcos:

So towards the end of that first semester it happened, then I ended up moving back

Marcos:

home with my parents and started back at my home school where I would have gone.

Marcos:

And it was actually worse there than ever, which was the irony, is I left to try to

Marcos:

escape it and then when I came back now in high school, it became very opposed to

Marcos:

just like individual comments, it became like systematic or systemic hearsay per

Marcos:

se, um, where there were like legit rumors now going around of things I didn't do.

Marcos:

And it's like, what is this?

Marcos:

It felt very strange to me.

Marcos:

So it was really hard.

Marcos:

That time period was very hard.

Marcos:

But the irony is through church through trying to just work like, you know, in

Marcos:

the 90s, you know, mid to late 90s when we were, at that time, um, you know,

Marcos:

kind of learning more about ourselves.

Marcos:

Self help was a big genre of reading, like all the Chicken Soup books.

Marcos:

I was diving into those Chicken Soup books.

Marcos:

I was diving into seminary.

Marcos:

I was going to all the youth activities.

Marcos:

I, um, eventually started working and, you know, extracurriculars, um, you know,

Marcos:

that really helped me come into my own, come out of my shell, feel more confident.

Marcos:

And when I was feeling more confident, I was able to tune out all the BS.

Marcos:

It still happened, but I felt more comfortable with trying to tune it out.

Marcos:

Um, and throughout the end of high school.

Marcos:

Um, so that was helpful.

Marcos:

And same thing there was very much, um, this duality of I felt very isolated.

Marcos:

I felt almost like I had no friends.

Marcos:

I was tired of feeling a certain way.

Marcos:

But on the flip side, I did have friends.

Marcos:

I did have this.

Marcos:

I did have that.

Marcos:

But it was always like an internal struggle.

Marcos:

Um, and I was, you know, that struggle became exhausting.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah, because you weren't able to show your authentic

Christina Elmer:

self to people because the fear of, you know, them finding out this big part of

Christina Elmer:

yourself, which, you know, if we can't authentically show who we are, that,

Christina Elmer:

you know, there was probably multiple layers for you and tell me where, if

Christina Elmer:

I'm wrong, but navigating as a Chicano man in Mormonism where it's completely

Christina Elmer:

whitewashed and now you have this other layer of your identity that's complicating

Christina Elmer:

things and it's just like I can't...

Christina Elmer:

where do I fit in?

Christina Elmer:

Who can I trust?

Christina Elmer:

You know, and it's just a So difficult and understandably why

Christina Elmer:

you just kind of, just went inward.

Marcos:

Yes.

Marcos:

Yes.

Christina Elmer:

Especially in, when you're talking about that stage in

Christina Elmer:

your twenties when you were navigating a relationship with a man, but also

Christina Elmer:

having to keep a lot of these things secret and just kind of running

Christina Elmer:

from, if we want to call it this, the retaliation from the church, you know,

Christina Elmer:

and, we can, we can get into that.

Christina Elmer:

But it just, trying to navigate all of that and, also 20s is a time where you're

Christina Elmer:

trying to figure out still who you are and, you know, you're wanting to share

Christina Elmer:

this part of yourself but you can't and, that's, that's a heavy, heavy load, man.

Marcos:

It honestly was.

Marcos:

And it's one of those things, I didn't even realize how heavy it was until

Marcos:

probably my early to mid thirties.

Marcos:

Um, because I was literally in survival mode for a long time.

Marcos:

Um, and.

Marcos:

It wasn't until afterwards, and there took a little, a few breakdowns,

Marcos:

and, because when you just have no, no choice but to survive, and then

Marcos:

when you kind of like can breathe.

Marcos:

I then kind of had a little mini breakdown and, um, was like, damn,

Marcos:

like, I was really young going through a lot of shit and I didn't

Marcos:

give myself enough credit for that.

Marcos:

And it wasn't until I started telling my story more to a few people that

Marcos:

I kind of saw their reactions.

Marcos:

I was like, oh, I guess I was a lot stronger than I realized,

Marcos:

or that did take strength.

Marcos:

To me, I always kind of tried to be true to myself, whatever that meant.

Marcos:

I think that's just something that maybe is through all my struggles

Marcos:

in childhood without realizing it.

Marcos:

It's just I had to develop strength and I had to be true to who I was and mixed with

Marcos:

how I was raised about always trying to do your best and be proud of who you are.

Marcos:

So maybe those things were just kind of, you know, entrenched,

Marcos:

but it took a lot of strength that I didn't give myself credit for.

Marcos:

It was hard.

Marcos:

I was essentially a kid, a very new, new adult, having to battle institutions.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Like, legitimate institutions.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

Put on us by society, put on us by religion.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Christina Elmer:

And those are, they're all consuming because they're everywhere.

Christina Elmer:

You can't escape that, you know?

Marcos:

Exactly.

Marcos:

And then having these adult adults seeking you out to check in on you

Marcos:

and come to your work and try, yeah.

Christina Elmer:

I can't imagine that.

Christina Elmer:

Must have been absolutely terrifying.

Marcos:

It was so terrifying.

Marcos:

Like and looking back on it now as an adult who works with young people, I get

Marcos:

a sliver of it of like, you're just trying to find them where they're at, see how

Christina Elmer:

Yeah, and, cause you legitimately care about

Christina Elmer:

these people as individuals, but what is the underlying purpose?

Marcos:

Exactly.

Marcos:

It was scary.

Marcos:

All of a sudden I'm at work, and then all of a sudden the bishop's there.

Marcos:

Because I wasn't responding to messages that were being left for me at home, um,

Marcos:

eventually, when I would occasionally go to church for, um, like family things,

Marcos:

like farewells, homecomings type thing, you know, the stake president would then

Marcos:

try to connect with me if he saw me.

Marcos:

And that felt weird, but all that stopped once I was no longer

Marcos:

eligible to go on a mission age wise.

Marcos:

I, I, I saw the connection.

Marcos:

So I, yes, so I think they were trying to, in one hand, still work with me to

Marcos:

see if we can get them all, quote, on the right path, get them on a mission.

Marcos:

And then the other hand is, what else can we maybe have a meeting with him about?

Marcos:

So I just, my go to at that point was just avoidance.

Marcos:

Like, I have to survive.

Marcos:

I'm not dealing with this.

Marcos:

Please stop, you know, in my head, please stop bothering me.

Marcos:

So once again, thank goodness for the support I did have.

Marcos:

Um, because I don't know if I would have survived, to be honest.

Marcos:

Um, it's really nuts to get back on it.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah, absolutely.

Christina Elmer:

It's, it's so interesting to me, the tactics and the,

Christina Elmer:

the methods that they use.

Christina Elmer:

Like, what, what, what age were you when the, the call stops.

Christina Elmer:

I, I'm assuming like most people are considered ineligible to serve

Christina Elmer:

a mission at about, what, 25 or 26?

Marcos:

Yeah, I think at that time it was 26.

Marcos:

So once I turned 27, I stopped hearing from them.

Marcos:

And I kind of noticed that a few years after it clicked, I'm like, oh

Marcos:

wait, I think that's why it stopped.

Christina Elmer:

It feels so gross to me that like, their only reason

Christina Elmer:

for, you know, granted, we're not saying that this is generalized across

Christina Elmer:

the board for churches, people for, that are members of the Church of

Christina Elmer:

Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints.

Christina Elmer:

A lot of people really legitimately do care about people.

Christina Elmer:

But just the methods that they went about to keep you in a certain space,

Christina Elmer:

in a certain box And to just like keep tabs on you in a really invasive way.

Christina Elmer:

Like, you know, instead of just respecting that, if you wanted to

Christina Elmer:

come back, you would have come back.

Christina Elmer:

And like, we were taught growing up, like, yes, the power of

Christina Elmer:

the atonement is huge, right?

Christina Elmer:

Like if we truly believe in Christ as our savior, he will fix everything, right?

Christina Elmer:

No matter where we end up, like if we end up committing, in your book,

Christina Elmer:

probably, you know, as you're looking at the ultimate sin of entering into

Christina Elmer:

a homosexual relationship, right?

Christina Elmer:

If they truly believe what they were teaching, they should have just let you

Christina Elmer:

come back and say, you know, I'm ready to do this instead of just like running after

Christina Elmer:

you in a way that just felt terrifying.

Marcos:

Right,

Christina Elmer:

it was like,

Marcos:

Right, Exactly.

Christina Elmer:

You know, I like to think of it as like, what would Jesus do?

Christina Elmer:

We used to have those bracelets growing up.

Christina Elmer:

Like, what would Jesus do?

Christina Elmer:

And that doesn't feel like something that Jesus would.

Christina Elmer:

So it's just, it's very curious to me, the tactics that they...

Christina Elmer:

take to like keep people in and using like such a fear model, right?

Christina Elmer:

Instead of just like loving people and trusting that the space that they're

Christina Elmer:

in that they'll come back if they choose to come back instead of just

Christina Elmer:

coming at it from the space of fear.

Christina Elmer:

And we know that as humans like if we approach anything with fear

Christina Elmer:

that the outcome is going to be completely different and we can't

Christina Elmer:

keep people in that space when we're coming from the space of fear.

Christina Elmer:

So, it's interesting.

Christina Elmer:

It's, yeah, it's just very, Mormonism is just very interesting.

Christina Elmer:

I feel like we could spend hours talking about it, but it's just

Christina Elmer:

like when it comes to things of like disfellowshipment or excommunication,

Marcos:

Um, Uh,

Christina Elmer:

there is a lot of stigma behind it, especially when

Christina Elmer:

you have family members that are still active in the church, right?

Christina Elmer:

Like, or you have a son that's not serving a mission.

Christina Elmer:

There's a lot of people that are sitting in the congregation, this happened to me

Christina Elmer:

with a dear friend here in town, whose son came home early from a mission,

Christina Elmer:

and she was very cautious about who she told as to the legitimate reason why.

Christina Elmer:

And fortunately, like, it happened when COVID was pretty

Christina Elmer:

at it pretty much at its peak.

Christina Elmer:

And so they kind of were able to use that as you know, COVID got too much.

Christina Elmer:

He was in an unsafe area.

Christina Elmer:

You know, it was um, even though there's a lot of people still were

Christina Elmer:

out serving missions during COVID.

Christina Elmer:

But it just like, I, my heart broke for her and I, I'm thinking about, you know,

Christina Elmer:

the perspective of your mother, as me as a mother, like how it must have been,

Christina Elmer:

and I can't speak to her experience, but I know that for a lot of women

Christina Elmer:

that have, are in Mormonism and have sons, cause mostly sons are required

Christina Elmer:

within Mormonism to go on missions.

Christina Elmer:

RIght?

Christina Elmer:

Because that's one of the boxes you check to be a worthy priesthood holder

Christina Elmer:

and worthy of being married to, you know, someone for time and all eternity.

Christina Elmer:

And it's, you know, did they serve a full time mission?

Christina Elmer:

If they didn't serve a mission, you know, what's wrong with them?

Christina Elmer:

And I just feel like the, stigma that comes from not serving a mission must

Christina Elmer:

have um, added a different layer for you as well, like, you know, looking

Christina Elmer:

at it from, um, the lens of, you know, how is this going to affect my family

Christina Elmer:

that are still very much in, um,

Marcos:

Exactly.

Marcos:

No, you're right, because I...

Marcos:

I'm the only one in my immediate family that did not go on a mission.

Marcos:

So all my siblings, my parents, um, you know, most of my cousins went.

Marcos:

Um, very missionary minded family.

Marcos:

I always wanted to go.

Marcos:

That was always the plan, you know, and looking back on it, there was a time where

Marcos:

I was seen as the goal, I think a golden boy, maybe not the golden boy, but a

Marcos:

golden boy in the family and in the area.

Marcos:

And so, I think it was expected, and, um, so I think it really surprised people,

Marcos:

and that's when tongues started wagging.

Marcos:

What's going on?

Marcos:

And for me, I just isolated and hid from it all.

Marcos:

And like, I'm just gonna do my own thing now.

Marcos:

But it was still going on until I think maybe people finally

Marcos:

found someone else to do that.

Christina Elmer:

For sure.

Christina Elmer:

Yeah.

Marcos:

Yeah, so there was a big thing too.

Marcos:

I was lucky because I didn't get as much from my family as

Marcos:

I was expecting about that.

Marcos:

But what did happen was already enough.

Marcos:

Um, and at that point was more just like, separation, and people were just saying it

Marcos:

with me not around, so it was very hard.

Christina Elmer:

Thank you so much for listening today and allowing

Christina Elmer:

us to be a part of your day.

Christina Elmer:

If you'd like more information on leaving in color or to be a guest on

Christina Elmer:

our show, please reach out to us on Instagram at leavingincolor.pod or

Christina Elmer:

email us at leavingincolorpod@gmail.com.

Christina Elmer:

If this episode resonated with you in any way or made you think of a loved one

Christina Elmer:

or a friend, please tell them about it.

Christina Elmer:

Your support generates more abundance collectively, so please

Christina Elmer:

subscribe to Leaving in Color wherever you listen to podcasts.

Christina Elmer:

Like all beautifully crafted pieces, this podcast was created

Christina Elmer:

by the most talented humans.

Christina Elmer:

Our music is by the melodic master, Tucker Winters.

Christina Elmer:

Our lovely, beautiful art is by the multifaceted Jen of

Christina Elmer:

all trades, Jen Cagle Gilmore.

Christina Elmer:

Leaving in Color is masterfully produced in conjunction

Christina Elmer:

with Particulate Media, K.O.

Christina Elmer:

Myers, executive producer.

Christina Elmer:

And I am Christina Elmer.

Christina Elmer:

See you soon.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube