What is truth?

"What is truth?" Pilate asked Jesus that question and walked away without waiting for the answer. In John 18:28-40, Dr. Toby Holt examines the trial of Jesus before the Roman governor.

The Jewish leaders bring Jesus to Pilate because only Rome could carry out an execution. Pilate questions Him about being a king, and Jesus answers, "My kingdom is not of this world." The two talk past each other — one of eternal truth, the other of politics. Finding no guilt, Pilate offers to release a prisoner, but the crowd demands Barabbas. The guilty goes free; the innocent is condemned.

Questions this study answers:

1. Who was Pilate? The Roman governor of Judea, responsible for order. He found no crime in Jesus but lacked the courage to release Him.

2. Why did the leaders bring Jesus to Pilate? Only Rome could authorize an execution, and a quiet stoning was too risky at Passover. So they needed Pilate's verdict.

3. Why did the crowd choose Barabbas? They chose a guilty criminal over the innocent Jesus. In that exchange we see the gospel: the guilty go free because the innocent takes their place.

"My kingdom is not of this world… but now My kingdom is not from here." — John 18:36 (NKJV)

Dr. Toby Holt is President of New Geneva Theological Seminary, and his sermons have been downloaded more than 1.9 million times on SermonAudio. Find more verse-by-verse Bible teaching at newgeneva.org; support this ministry at newgeneva.org/give.

In John 18, Jesus was brought before Pontius Pilate, and at that time, Pilate asked Jesus a series of probing questions regarding his identity.

2

However, Christ's responses were not what Pilate expected to hear.

3

In today's study, we'll consider what Christ's words tell us about himself and about his heavenly kingdom.

4

When two people are talking, have you ever heard the phrase that they're not on the same wavelength?

5

Maybe this is a conversation you've witnessed.

6

You've seen two people talking, and you can see that they're just not communicating.

7

Maybe you've been part of that dialogue.

8

Maybe you've been part of a conversation where you haven't been on the same wavelength

9

as the individual that you're talking to.

10

Well, in today's text, we have a paramount example of that.

11

We have Jesus talking.

12

Jesus is talking about religion and philosophy and truth.

13

And Pilate's part of the conversation.

14

He's listening, and yet he's not hearing.

15

When Jesus refers to himself as a king,

16

Pilate has no grasp over what that kingdom could possibly be.

17

When Jesus says that his servants would fight for him,

18

Pilate looks around.

19

He doesn't see any servants.

20

He isn't always talking about.

21

When Jesus says he came to bear witness to the truth,

22

Pilate has to ask the question, what is truth?

23

They are talking past one another

24

the entirety of their conversation.

25

All right, let's return to verses 28 through 32

26

to see this interaction, to see this conversation.

27

Let's look at verses 28 through 32.

28

So then they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the Praetorium, and it was early morning.

29

If you remember right, they had already tried Jesus in the dark at night.

30

After dinner, he'd gone to the Garden of Gethsemane.

31

He'd prayed.

32

Then the Romans had come.

33

They'd had pitchforks and torches and all sorts of stuff.

34

They arrested him in the dead of night.

35

They took him to Annas.

36

Then they took him to Caiaphas.

37

They had this show trial.

38

They asked him questions.

39

They didn't really care what his answers were.

40

When he spoke, they slapped him around.

41

They treated him wrong because they knew they wanted this man dead.

42

They just wanted him dead.

43

With that said, the process would be strung out a little bit

44

because he would go from Annas to Caiaphas,

45

then he'd come to Pilate here, later he'd go to Herod,

46

then he'd come back to Pilate and so forth.

47

He was ping-ponged around after his initial rest.

48

So they led Jesus from Caiaphas to the praetorium

49

and it was early morning.

50

But they themselves did not go into the praetorium

51

lest they should be defiled.

52

Ah, how pious of them.

53

We will lead the Son of God to those who are going to kill him

54

with the intent that they kill him

55

and yet we're not going to go into this Gentile building, otherwise we might be defiled.

56

So verse 29, then Pilate went out to them, since they wouldn't go in, and said, what accusation do

57

you bring against this man? And they answered and said to him, if he were not an evildoer,

58

Pilate, we would not have delivered him up to you. You see this right away, you sense that their

59

interaction is not normal. The Jews don't like Pilate, and Pilate doesn't like the Jews. Pilate

60

gets up. What are these knuckleheads doing? What accusation you got against this guy?

61

And the response to him is, come on, Pilate, you know the deal. If he wasn't guilty, why would we

62

be here? Of course, he's an evildoer. That's why we brought him to you, because he's done evil.

63

Verse 31, then Pilate said to them, well, then you take him. You take him and you judge him

64

according to your laws. You do this all the time. You judge all sorts of people. Why are you bringing

65

him to me? But then they give the answer. Therefore, the Jews said to him, it's not lawful

66

for us to put anyone to death.

67

You see, they'd already established his guilt

68

in their mind's eye without any witnesses,

69

without anything.

70

They thought he was guilty,

71

and their desire was to take him to Pilate

72

that he would be put to death.

73

And so they say this in verse 32,

74

that the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled

75

when he had prophesied,

76

signifying by what death he would die.

77

Jesus had said he would be lifted up,

78

which was a euphemism for being crucified.

79

He already told his disciples that,

80

and that was God's intention,

81

that he'd be crucified and not stoned.

82

All right, let's stop there in verse 32.

83

Let's talk about Pilate. For a guy with a lot of power in Jerusalem, in Judea, Pilate was a terribly

84

unpopular man. Terribly unpopular. Now, on the one hand, the Jews hated him, which is for obvious

85

reasons. Pilate is the Roman governor. He's in charge. He is given the responsibility of oversight

86

for this province, this part of the Roman Empire. However, Pilate could be a cruel man, and he'd

87

enforce that cruelty at various times and in various ways. One of the things that Pilate had

88

done, is Pilate, initially his headquarters were over near an area called Caesarea by the Sea. It's

89

over near what modern Tel Aviv sort of area. At one point, Pilate had decided to take the Roman

90

legion, so to speak, into Jerusalem, but to do so with the banners that had the head of Caesar

91

mounted or established or demonstrated on top with a phraseology that intimated that he was God. And

92

his plan was to take this into the city. Now, of course, the Jews got a lot of stuff wrong,

93

but they did get this part right.

94

There's only one God, and any graven image on the top of a flag

95

they're going to march in, they're willing to lay down their lives to stop it.

96

So you have Pilate, he brings in his legions, got Caesar established,

97

and the idea is that Caesar is God, and he thinks he's going to go into Jerusalem,

98

and that's going to go well.

99

Well, it doesn't, and the Zealots and others rebel against Pilate,

100

and so he rounds up a bunch of them.

101

He rounds up the leadership, and I believe it was at the amphitheater,

102

near Caesarea by the Sea, but he rounds up the leadership of the Jews,

103

and he says, all right, you guys, you think you're going to rebel against me? Well, let me show you

104

how it's going to go. I've got my men right here and they've got their swords drawn and you're

105

either going to do what I say and you're going to allow my ways to go and my flags to be unfurled

106

and my banners to go forth and Rome's rule to be established in a clear way with Caesar at the top.

107

You're going to allow that or you are going to die. And the Jews, to their credit, they laid down,

108

they stretched out their necks and they said, all right, then take our heads off because we would

109

rather die than yield to the banner of Rome, than yield to you in this manner. So they called his

110

bluff. Now Pilate was in a bit of a bind because he had already had uprisings locally. And as a

111

Roman governor, he really had two responsibilities as a Roman governor. Number one, to advance the

112

money and the taxes from the people to Rome. That was job number one. Job number two was to keep the

113

peace. There couldn't be uprisings. So he had to keep uprisings down. And the Jews had demonstrated

114

in times past that they're willing to rise up against him, and that'll shade everything that

115

we're going to see in the balance of this text. So the Jews rebelled against Pilate. They didn't

116

like him, and frankly, they'd already neutered him in his powers a little bit by rebelling against

117

him in other intervals, and that's why they have the bravery and the temerity to go up to him and

118

go, yes, we brought evildoer. Of course he's an evildoer. Pilate, you should know better. The back

119

and forth demonstrates their contempt for this man, but it wasn't just the Jews who disliked

120

Pilate. It was also the Romans. If you were a Roman aristocrat and you had the opportunity to

121

be given a place to govern, you did not want to be sent to Jerusalem. You did not want to be sent

122

to this region. This was not a plum prize. This was someplace you sent someone when you just wanted

123

to get them out of the way. It was someone where you would send a mediocre man to that mediocre

124

place hoping that it all would work out. When Pilate was sent there, it was not because he was

125

the smartest, the bravest, the best. He was sent there because he was not thought that well of.

126

And the proof that Rome didn't think that well of him is that not terribly long thereafter,

127

the emperor Tiberius in 36 AD would depose Pilate, would just call him back, and his career would

128

effectively be over. So this is an unpopular man and a man that was deemed as mediocre even by the

129

very people that had sent him there. So with that said, why did the Jews take Jesus to this unpopular

130

weakened individual at this time, verse 28. As we talked about last week, the problem the Jews had

131

was that in theory they could not kill, they could not enforce capital punishment on their own, but

132

that was something that Rome had reserved for itself. You see, Rome had watched in the empire

133

that when it allowed those that it governed in various parts of the empire to enforce capital

134

punishment on their own, what they found is that the local municipalities and the local regions

135

would simply go about the process of executing their enemies, and sometimes that worked against

136

the will and desire of Rome. So they said, well, anyone who you think needs to die, we want to

137

evaluate this first in order to get a sense for the motivation by which you want them dead. So

138

Rome didn't want the Jews or didn't allow the Jews to force capital punishment on their own.

139

And yet there were other times where the Jews just went ahead and did it anyway. Can you think of

140

anyone in the book of Acts that the Jews just killed because time for a man to die? What do we

141

got? Stephen, right? You got Stephen. How did he die? By what? By stoning, right? And there was

142

other times when the Jews had picked up stones to throw at Jesus. Remember those times he said

143

things and they said, all right, this man's got to die. They start looking around for stones and

144

then he disappears in their midst. So how can it be both? How can they on the one hand say, oh,

145

Rome is the only one who can allow us to kill anybody, therefore we'll yield to Rome in this

146

matter. How can they say that here? And yet at other intervals, just go around stoning people.

147

What's the deal? Well, the deal is this, among other motivations, that on this particular

148

occasion, Christ was such a notable individual. His notoriety was so great that if they were,

149

if the Jews were to stone him of their own accord, they knew they'd have their own uprising on their

150

hands and it would be better to let the Romans do it. They're like, hey guys, hey guys, I got an

151

idea. We'll let the Romans kill him and therefore blood's not on our hands, so to speak, although

152

later on they would chant that blood can be on our hands with that said that was part of the idea

153

the other issue was that it was passover and the area there was more attention being given to all

154

the incidents in jerusalem on this particular week than throughout the rest of the year combined and

155

the reason why was because it was passover and remember the whole of the nation had come gathered

156

so if they were to have stoned or killed jesus on their own that very evening it would have caused

157

them a great disruption so they bring him to pilot with the idea that he'll do their will for them

158

but Pilate knows what's going on. He may have been an unpopular guy. He may have been a mediocre man,

159

but he wasn't an idiot. He knows what's going on here. He knows that they want him to do

160

their dirty work. He doesn't trust these Jewish leaders as far as he can throw them. They don't

161

trust him. He doesn't trust them. If they want this guy dead, they have reasons for wanting him

162

dead that are not on the up and up. So he says, all right, well, Jesus, come on in. Let's figure

163

out a little bit more about you, about what you're all about. So let's look at verses 33 through 36.

164

Then Pilate entered the Praetorium again, this is the home of the magistrate, and called Jesus

165

and said to him, are you the king of the Jews? That's interesting, interesting question. And

166

Jesus answered him and said, are you speaking for yourself about this, or did others tell you this

167

concerning me? And Pilate answered and said, am I a Jew? Your own nation and the chief priests

168

have delivered you to me, so what have you done? And Jesus answered, and he answers the first

169

question first. He says, my kingdom is not of this world. If it were of this world, my servants

170

would fight so that I should not be delivered to the Jews, but now my kingdom is not from here.

171

All right. For whatever reason, Pilate brings Jesus into the praetorium, and he has a question

172

for him. And his question is different than what he had just asked the Jewish leaders. He asked

173

the Jewish leaders, what has this man done? But that's not what he asked Jesus. He didn't say,

174

what have you done? He asked him there in verse 33, are you the king of the Jews? Which is

175

interesting. And Jesus turns around and says, hey, that's an interesting question. Are you asking

176

this because you want to know, or did someone say something to you about this? And that's the reason

177

for the question itself. Now, remember, whenever you read incidents like this that occur in one

178

gospel account, it's healthy and helpful for you to look at the other gospel accounts in order to

179

get a rounded view, a rounded understanding of what's taking place. Now, in the book of Luke,

180

we read that the Jewish leaders, when they came to Pilate, they had first saw to the ground against

181

Jesus. And they did so by saying this to Pilate. They said, we found this fellow forbidding to pay

182

taxes to Caesar and saying that he himself is Christ, a king. All right, so do you see what's

183

happened? The book of Luke says that when they went to Pilate, they knew Pilate's soft underbelly.

184

They said, we found this guy, this fellow, this Jesus, and you won't believe it, Pilate, what he's

185

been doing. He's been telling the Jews that they should not pay taxes. Can you believe it? Now,

186

why would that be an affront to Pilate? Because remember, we said he had two jobs. The one hand

187

is to extract the money from the people to send the Rome, and the other thing is to keep the peace.

188

And right here, they're saying, this Jesus, this Jesus, he's guilty of sedition. He's saying that

189

they shouldn't pay. We shouldn't pay taxes. Can you believe it? They shouldn't pay taxes. Beyond

190

that, he's saying that he himself is a king. Now, you're not going to stand for that, Pilate, are

191

You're the one who put Caesar as God, you know, the banners and all that.

192

The Roman emperor himself would not stand for this, right?

193

That this man is a king in our midst.

194

Well, that's what he's been telling everybody.

195

So you see, what they tried to do with Pilate is they tried to undermine Jesus

196

by making claims that he was a seditious individual.

197

And they thought that if we just make him look like a threat to Rome,

198

a threat to Pilate, that Pilate's such a dope that he'll go,

199

okay, gosh, I got to kill him then if he's guilty of these things.

200

However, however, Pilate decides, well, he'll just ask him himself.

201

So he asks him.

202

He says, are you the king of the Jews?

203

And the reason he asks it is because others had told him, and Jesus knew it.

204

Jesus knew it.

205

This is why Jesus said, are you speaking for yourself about this, or did others tell you

206

this concerning me?

207

Now, there on the balance of those verses, in verses 35 and 36, Jesus affirms.

208

He says, you know, Pilate, even if they are saying things against me with the desire of

209

wanting me dead, even though the Jews are not being on the up and up about things, this

210

talk about me being a king. It's true. I am a king, and I have a kingdom, but it's not the sort

211

of kingdom that you might be thinking of. So verse 36, Jesus affirms he is a king, but his kingdom,

212

he says, is not of this world. See, he's saying, he's referring to a kingdom in a way they didn't

213

understand at that time. The way that they understood kingdoms at that time were based on

214

geographical landmarks. That mountain over there, on the other side of that, is where the Moabites

215

are. That river over there on the other side is where the Philistines are. That's the way they

216

understood kingdoms as geographically bounded. But Jesus says, I am a king and I have a kingdom,

217

but it's not from here. And you can't point to a mountain or river or anything as the marker

218

where my kingdom starts. My kingdom encompasses everything. It is a transcendent kingdom,

219

a spiritual kingdom. Now, if you're a pilot, remember talking past one another, listening,

220

but not hearing. So Pilate takes all this in. You're a king then, right? But you're thinking

221

to yourself at the same time, what kind of king allows himself to be taken to chains in a garden

222

in the middle of the night? What kind of king is rolled in here in the dead of night in chains?

223

You're a king. What kind of kingdom can you possibly have? And Jesus says, well, here,

224

if my kingdom were of this world, the way that you're interpreting the term kingship and kingdom

225

to mean, my servants would be right here fighting. If my kingdom were impacted by Rome and its

226

oppression and its authorities and army, then my servants would fight back. But, but my kingdom is

227

not threatened by anything that's going on right now at all. In fact, this is all part of the plan.

228

He says, if this weren't part of the plan, if my kingdom was threatened in any way, shape, or form,

229

you can rest assured the armies of heaven would be loosened to effect the things going on right

230

here and right now. But what the Jews are doing and what you're about to do is no threat to it.

231

in fact, is part of the plan. You know, as a side note, 21st century, the world can persecute

232

Christians. The world can burn down churches. The world already crucified our Savior. But you know

233

what? In the midst of all that, not a single pebble has been loosened in heaven. The world

234

has crucified Christ. It's persecuted the church. Blood of martyrs stains the entire globe. Churches

235

have been affected. Churches have been burned down. All these manner of things have happened

236

against Christians. All these manner of things have happened against Christ. And yet, at the

237

same time as that has happened on this mortal coil, not a single pebble, not a single pebble

238

has moved or been nudged an inch in the glorious heavenly estate that Jesus came from. Psalm 2 says

239

this, why do the nations rage? And you can say this about Pilate and Rome and the Assyrians and

240

all manner of others, the Babylonians. Why do the nations rage? Why does emperors and the like do

241

these things? Is this not a vain thing? The kings of the earth set themselves, the rulers take

242

counsel together against the Lord and against his anointed, meaning Christ, saying let's break their

243

bonds and pieces and cast their cords away from us. But he who sits in the heavens shall laugh,

244

the Lord holds him in derision. Jesus was not threatened by what was going on here. The king

245

of kings, the Lord of lords, was sitting right there in chains in the praetorium of the Roman

246

council there. And in a sense, you could say this is a bad day for Jesus. Well, it wasn't going to

247

be his funnest day, that's for sure. But on the other hand, all this is part of the plan. And no

248

matter what the Romans or no matter what the Jews could do against Jesus, no matter if they smacked

249

him around, the crown of thorns or what have you, none of it, none of it could move the needle

250

whatsoever in heaven. None of it could dislodge a single pebble. The nations rage. They've always

251

raged. Pilate, the Jews, these others, they rage against God. And yet, even their raging is part of

252

his decretal will, and none of it is a threat to his throne. And so that's what he says. If I was

253

genuinely threatened by you, Pilate, trust me, trust me, my servants would be here. And you would

254

see what it means to have chariots of fire all around you, the way Elijah once saw it there

255

outside of Dothan. You'd see it with your own eyes and they'd be coming for you, but I'm not

256

threatened by this. In fact, this is part of the plan. All right, so let's look at verses 37 to 38.

257

So Pilate therefore said to him, are you a king then? Pilate's a slow learner. Are you a king

258

then? Jesus answered, yes, yes, rightly say. You rightly say that I'm a king. For this cause I was

259

born. What cause? The cause where he's standing there in chains. For this cause, for this day,

260

for this moment, for everything that's going on right now, for this cause I was born and I came

261

into the world that I should bear witness to the truth. And everyone who is of the truth hears my

262

voice. Remember that difference between talking past one another, the difference between listening

263

and hearing. Those who are of the church, those of regenerate hearts, those who are born again,

264

sons and daughters of the most high king, whose hearts have been converted and opened up and the

265

spirit indwells, they hear his voice. But Jesus is not talking to someone who hears his voice.

266

He's not talking to someone who's capable of understanding even what he's saying.

267

So he says here that for this cause I was born, this cause I've come into this world,

268

I should bear witness to the truth, and everyone who is of the truth hears my voice.

269

And Pilate has a chance. He has an opportunity, so to speak. Opportunity. Jesus just said something

270

that would have titillated the ears of ancient man, of those who had grown up in either Greek

271

or Roman societies. Jesus says something that tickles the ears of those who are philosophically

272

inclined. And he says, I came to bear witness to the truth. And in this moment, Pilate has an

273

opportunity to ask the greatest authority on truth that's ever lived to explain what truth is,

274

to unpack it for me. You came to provide the truth, to share the truth, to bear witness to

275

the truth. Oh my goodness, let's sit down. I have some questions. Greatest opportunity man's ever

276

had right here. What does he do instead? Well, we see that in verse 38, Pilate asks him very

277

sarcastically. He says, what is truth? And what does it say he does thereafter? It says that when

278

he had said this, verse 38, he went out. He went out again to the Jews and said to them, I find no

279

fault in this man at all. So Jesus has told Pilate, and they've got all the time they need right there,

280

but Jesus told Pilate, I came to bear witness to the truth. Pilate could have mined into that,

281

found out some details, learned about the truth. Instead, he mocks this idea of truth, and he leaves

282

without another word. He just leaves the room. What is truth? And he's gone, right? But when he

283

goes out, he goes to the Jews who didn't like him and he didn't like, and he says, you know what?

284

The things that you were telling me, I don't find it to be true. This guy is harmless.

285

I'm talking about truth and the like. This guy's harmless. I find no fault in him. The things you

286

were telling me, they're not accurate based on my assessment of things. All right, let's look now

287

our last verses, verses 38 through 40. Verse 38. So again, Pilate said to him, what is the truth?

288

And when he had said this, he went out again to the Jews and said to them, I find no fault in this

289

man at all, but you have a custom that I should release someone to you at the Passover. This was

290

a tradition that they had that the Roman leadership would release a prisoner at the Passover to

291

pacify the crowds, right? They'd chant someone's name and the governor would give them the man

292

they chanted for and it was a way to kind of keep the peace because remember that's one of the

293

objectives that Pilate has to keep the peace so he says you know we have this tradition we've been

294

doing this for a little while at Passover I release someone to you you chant their name and the like

295

how about it we just make it this guy let's just simplify things let's just make it this Jesus guy

296

here so he says that you have a custom I should release someone to you at the Passover do you

297

therefore want me to release to you the king of the Jews and then they all cried out not just like

298

two or three loud people but they all cried out saying no not this man but Barabbas Barabbas now

299

Barabbas was a robber and other texts also tell us he was a murderer all right let's linger on

300

this last bit with our remaining time you know six separate instances in the gospels Pilate vouches

301

for Christ's innocence now Pilate had seen guilty men before he knew what guilt was and this wasn't

302

it and other people would pick up on that too remember you had the two thieves on the cross

303

either side of jesus and for a while they're both mocking jesus but at one point the one thief turns

304

the other thief and he says you know by the way you and i deserve what we're getting we're here

305

on the crosses for a reason because we done wrong we're guilty but this man he's innocent people if

306

they spent any time whatsoever really considering the facts before them considering the ministry of

307

a man who went around healing, doing miracles, and raising the dead and the like, they would say,

308

you know, that's not the sort of man that we need to kill. In fact, we need more of this sort of guy.

309

We don't understand everything he's saying, but good things seem to flower where he goes. But

310

again, those who were threatened by those good things could not see the good things, and they

311

simply wanted him dead, whether he had done anything wrong or not. Well, Pilate says, I've

312

seen nothing wrong in him. This man is innocent as near as I can tell. And again, it's not because

313

Pilate was a saint or Pilate was trying to do the right thing. Pilate was guilty of a tremendous sin

314

at this very moment. He's guilty of the sin of pragmatism. If he believed, if Pilate believed

315

that Jesus was innocent, what should a righteous judge do? Let him go, right? It doesn't matter

316

what nation state you're in. If someone is brought before you on their presumption that they're

317

guilty, you interview them, try them, you examine them, and you determine that this man is innocent,

318

then what should you do, irregardless of what nation state or culture you're in? You let an

319

innocent man go. Pilate doesn't. He tries to barter. He could have just said, he's innocent.

320

Out you go, Jesus, and don't come back, you know, high priest, unless you got someone really guilty

321

next time. He could have sent him back, but remember, he had this relationship with the

322

Jews where he was always concerned that they were going to have this uprising. They already had the

323

zealots doing all sorts of stuff in the society, and he's trying to keep the peace. So he's like,

324

all right, all right, all right, what's the pragmatic solution to this? Surely politics

325

can save me. So he comes up with a political answer. And he sits there thinking, well, what to

326

do? What to do? Well, I know, I know. We have this tradition here by which the Jews will request that

327

I release someone, and I release someone, and then everyone's happy and the like, and they go back to

328

their Passover parties and so forth, and everyone's happy. Maybe let's do this. Let's do it with this

329

guy. I'll release him as a sign of my magnanimous and the like. I'm magnanimous, and the Jews, you

330

know, they'll be appeased, and they'll just go figure all this out on their own. So he tries that.

331

However, the Jews respond, and they respond by chanting the oddest thing.

332

They say, no, no, no, no, no.

333

Away with this man.

334

Crucify him.

335

Crucify him is what they'll say later on.

336

Let his blood be upon us and our children.

337

Man, there's bloodlust going on here.

338

So not only do they chant that about Jesus, but they chant something positive about a man named Barabbas.

339

They say, release him.

340

Barabbas.

341

We want Barabbas.

342

We want Barabbas.

343

Now, to Pilate's ears, he had to be going, oh my, good golly.

344

You know Barabbas.

345

I know Barabbas. That's the guy who's in jail for appropriate reasons. This guy is a thief,

346

and for what it's worth, no culture likes thieves, right? Roman, Jewish, otherwise. No culture likes

347

thieves. He's a thief. He's a robber and the like. He also is guilty of murder. You want that guy.

348

You want Barabbas. And they say yes. They cry out again and again, saying there in verse 40,

349

not this man, but Barabbas. Now, Barabbas was a robber. So let me close this morning by drawing

350

out the microcosm that we're seeing here. So why did Jesus come? Why was he standing here to begin

351

with? Why did Jesus come? He came to save us, right? That's the means. You and I are guilty.

352

The wages of sin is death. If God were to judge Pilate, if he was to judge any man or woman in

353

this room, we would all be judged by the same criteria, that we've all fallen short of the

354

laws and decrees of a holy God. There is none who are righteous, no, not one. So all of us stand

355

under the condemnation of a holy God who hates sin. And you don't get like, you know, what is

356

engulfed, some mulligans? You know, that's the way with this work. Even if he gave you a bunch

357

mulligans. You've already gone through them. You don't have any more. So with that said, you've

358

sinned more times than you can possibly count. You've broken the laws of a holy God more times

359

than you can count. And if God is holy and God is just and God is righteous, he has to deal with

360

that, right? He has to deal with it. Otherwise, he's not holy, righteous, or just. He's a pragmatist

361

if he doesn't. He's like Pilate, kind of looking at the circumstances differently. No. If God is

362

holy and righteous and just and you're a sinner, then you deserve condemnation. That's our problem.

363

We talk about this every time we do the Lord's Supper.

364

Our problems that we are sinners, the wages of sin is death,

365

God is holy and just, and if he is, then he has to deal with us.

366

It's a fearful thing to fall in the hands of the living God,

367

which is exactly the condition, the situation, the cataclysm we would be in

368

if not for what we see in today's text.

369

In today's text, Jesus is telling Pilate,

370

and he's telling the culture around him, whether they're paying attention or not,

371

that he is the very fulfillment of that which that passage says in Isaiah 53,

372

that out of God's love for us, he would send one to atone for us.

373

He would send one to pay our price.

374

He would send one to take our debt.

375

And on Calvary, that's just what would happen.

376

On Calvary, Jesus Christ would go to the cross.

377

Your sins, my sins would be placed and putered upon him

378

as if he's the one who did it.

379

In a very real sense, what we see here with Barabbas

380

is a microcosm of that.

381

Free Barabbas, free the guilty.

382

Free the guilty, crucify the innocent.

383

What they were chanting for in a very real sense

384

is what Jesus came to do.

385

To let guilty individuals

386

who were rightly convicted of their sins to let them be set free, spiritually speaking,

387

and he was willing to step into their place.

388

The Jews had an opportunity to have Jesus freed.

389

They say, no, crucify him, give us Barabbas.

390

Barabbas is a type of you.

391

He's a type of me.

392

He's a type of all of us who have been spared because Jesus stepped into our place.

393

The gospel, as we've said, contains a problem and solution.

394

The problem is that we are sinners.

395

the solution is that Christ came to die for sinners. We'll consider that in part this week,

396

and over the next couple weeks leading up to Easter, we will consider that at greater length.

397

Let's pray.