This is part one of a two-part series on the petition created by the Harvard Law School's Animal Law Clinic on behalf of wildlife animal advocates seeking to eliminate anticoagulant rodenticides in Massachusetts. Not only are these poisons a cruel way to kill rodents, the victims of these devices extend to wildlife and even species that are protected.
Our guests will discuss how they have come together in this fight, the importance of education of the public on this issue, and what we can do together to promote species conservation and welfare. They will also share their personal experiences as they are first hand witnesses of the injuries suffered by eagles, hawks, owls, and other wildlife.
Part I guests are:
Lla Anderson, law student at the Harvard Law School
Laura Kiesel, founder of Save Arlington Wildlife
Part II guests are:
Marci Cemenska founder of Save Lexington Wildlife
James Joyce II, founder of Friends of Horn Pond
Mentioned in this episode:
Keep it Humane Podcast Network
The Animal Welfare Junction is part of the Keep It Humane Podcast Network. Visit keepithumane.com/podcastnetwork to find us and our amazing animal welfare podcast partners.
10% off Tomahawk products
Use keyword keepithumane at checkout at livetrap.com
Hi, and welcome to the Animal Welfare Junction.
2
:This is your host, Dr.
3
:G and our music is written
and produced by Mike Sullivan.
4
:This episode is actually divided into
two parts, parts one and part two.
5
:The title of this episode
is Stop Poisoning Our Birds.
6
:Massachusetts advocates fighting
against anticoagulant rodenticides.
7
:So I was scrolling through LinkedIn and
I saw this article on this petition
8
:that was created by Harvard Law School
asking the state of Massachusetts to
9
:basically stop placing rodenticides.
10
:And the main reason for it was the
damage to the environment, but in
11
:particular the damage to the birds,
how these rodenticides are actually
12
:causing damage to, to the birds.
13
:And some of these birds are birds that
are on the endangered species list.
14
:Speak about this issue, I
have four amazing guests.
15
:For part one, our guests are going
to be Lla Anderson, who is a student
16
:at the Harvard law school and Laura
Kiesel from Save Arlington Wildlife.
17
:On part two of this episode is
going to be Marci Cemenska from
18
:Save Lexington Wildlife and James
Joyce II from Friends of Horn Pond.
19
:Our first guest is going to be Lla
Anderson, who is a candidate at Harvard
20
:Law School and Harvard Divinity School.
21
:Welcome to the show, Lla.
22
:Lla Anderson: Yeah, thanks for having me.
23
:DrG: Can you give us a little bit
of information on your background,
24
:kind of where you started and
what led you to law school?
25
:Lla Anderson: Yeah, so I'm from Florida.
26
:Grew up in Florida.
27
:We just have very unique nature,
wildlife, animals, you know,
28
:alligators and, and the like.
29
:And so growing up in Florida, I
was able to just be around wildlife
30
:and that really played a role in
cultivating this love for nature for me.
31
:I wanted to be a veterinarian
when I was a kid.
32
:Um, I truly was convinced
that I would be Dr.
33
:Doolittle.
34
:And, um, I also loved Eliza
Thornberry from The Wild Thornberries.
35
:So, definitely had a strong
connection with animals.
36
:I was vegetarian the first
five years of my life.
37
:Um, fast forward, I started getting
into, uh, learning more about
38
:factory farming and slaughterhouses
when I was in middle school.
39
:So, I would watch all kinds of
videos and documentaries on it.
40
:And that was definitely something that,
I was interested in, but it sort of
41
:kind of stayed in the background and
I ended up, you know, being, looking
42
:into other things in terms of career
paths, um, like theater and music
43
:and stuff like that, entertainment.
44
:And then that all changed, uh,
sophomore year of undergrad.
45
:I interned in D.
46
:C.
47
:and I saw just, How and before this
had no interest in being a lawyer.
48
:It was kind of in the back of my head, but
I just I didn't know too much about it and
49
:I felt like lawyers seem to be just very,
you know, self serious and and type a.
50
:And that, that, that, that's true, but
there's also way more to it than that
51
:in so many different personalities.
52
:Um, but yeah, I interned in DC,
saw how much lawyers knew, and
53
:I wanted to, to be one of them.
54
:And so, um, started studying, and I,
um, um, found my way to law school,
55
:so applied to Harvard, um, ended up
culating into Harvard, um, in:
56
:I was a vegan at that point.
57
:I became vegan in undergrad, um, and yeah.
58
:Initially, uh, I was vegan
for sustainability reasons.
59
:Animals was a reason, but
it wasn't my number one.
60
:I was interested in sustainability
in undergrad, and that was
61
:my whole life in undergrad.
62
:So, um, it all changed, though, when
I joined the Animal Law Society.
63
:at Harvard and just learned more
and more about just our food systems
64
:and how animals are treated and
speciesism and how we regard ourselves
65
:and how we regard other animals.
66
:And that basically just sort of led me
back to who I was as a kid and how much
67
:I loved animals and just My, my core.
68
:And so after that, it
just changed everything.
69
:Um, and I just got into animal law
and I took the animal law course.
70
:Um, I started getting more involved in
the animal law society, uh, and I got
71
:involved in the animal law clinic, which
is how we got the rodenticide case.
72
:Um, but yeah, that's the long story,
but I've always loved animals.
73
:Took a little break from deciding
what I wanted to do, which in
74
:whether it involved animals and
then found it again in law school.
75
:DrG: That's great that you are able to
merge your loves, your love for animals
76
:and then your newfound love for law.
77
:Lla Anderson: Yeah, for
law, which is surprising,
78
:DrG: but yeah.
79
:Well, and congratulations on being at
Harvard Law School because, you know,
80
:whenever we think about the top law
schools in the country, Harvard is always
81
:one of the things that, you know, the
colleges that most everybody will know.
82
:So congratulations on, on doing that.
83
:Thank you.
84
:So tell us about this law clinic.
85
:What is, what is a law clinic?
86
:How does that work?
87
:Lla Anderson: So basically a law
clinic is very similar to a non
88
:profit, pretty much is a non profit.
89
:So what we do is we have clients
and um, law students are able,
90
:they're given the opportunity
to basically do real world work.
91
:Um, it's, it's sort of like an
experiential learning credit in
92
:college and in other, in other
opportunities, very much like a.
93
:A lab, for instance, where you're able
to learn apply what you learn in class in
94
:real life and act as a student attorney.
95
:And so basically, yeah, you,
you get to be around and get
96
:to learn more about real cases.
97
:You get to help real people and clients.
98
:You do research writing.
99
:Your work could entail interviews in
some clinics, you could go to court.
100
:Um, yeah, so it sort of runs
the gamut, but basically each
101
:clinic has its own sort of focus.
102
:You can have an environmental
law clinic, you can have a public
103
:defense clinic, and of course you
can have an animal law clinic.
104
:So that's pretty much what a clinic is.
105
:DrG: So I imagine, I mean, this is,
this is great for the individuals that
106
:are seeking this kind of help, but then
it's great for you guys as students.
107
:for being able to get experience prior
to graduating and going into practice?
108
:Lla Anderson: Definitely.
109
:You don't have to pay out of the wazoo
for, in terms of the clients, for help.
110
:And, um, the students are
able to get really as much
111
:experience as they would like.
112
:And, you know, there
is a difference in law.
113
:Um, you know, when you, when you're taking
your 1L law courses, pretty much that sort
114
:of dynamic where you're not doing clinic
work is, it leans more towards academia.
115
:It's different.
116
:theory.
117
:Um, but then in your second and third
years, um, at law school, when you're able
118
:to take clinics, then now you're looking
at law from the standpoint of an actual
119
:practicing attorney and what exactly
the day to day looks like, as opposed
120
:to being in the classroom and studying
and having the whole graduate school,
121
:um, environment, um, being the, the main
point of your law school experience.
122
:DrG: So this case that we're going
to be talking about is basically
123
:about the use of rodenticides
and how they are damaging to the
124
:environment, not only to the animals.
125
:Yeah.
126
:So.
127
:, can you give us a little bit
of background on this case?
128
:Lla Anderson: Yeah.
129
:Um, so this case, so there are a
few things to note in the case.
130
:Um, pretty much you had, we have, uh,
our clients were rehabilitators and, um,
131
:advocates, um, in different Massachusetts
areas, but specifically, um, we're
132
:dealing with a few from Arlington.
133
:And so basically the issue
is bald eagles are dying.
134
:Okay.
135
:Bald eagles, which are protected
species in this country, um, protected
136
:also, well, first of all, our national
symbol in the United States, um, and,
137
:you know, protected also, of course,
in Massachusetts under the Endangered
138
:Species Act, and they were dying.
139
:And, um, so you had a lot of advocates
and rehabilitators who were concerned
140
:about these animals just one day
just getting sick and, you know, very
141
:rapidly, um, developing very anemic
like conditions, um, bruising, bleeding,
142
:um, animals that they've observed
for years who are now acting very
143
:differently and who are very clearly ill.
144
:Um, dying.
145
:And so the rehabilitators also, more
than just the bald eagles, they've
146
:seen red tailed hawks, owls dying.
147
:So you have, you had individuals seeing
this and wanting to do something about
148
:it and trying and wanting to know, you
know, what was going on and all of the.
149
:The necropsy reports came back that
all of these animals, um, most, if not
150
:all, um, I will get there in terms of
there was a study that, um, a recent
151
:study where 100 percent of the birds
that were sick that were tested did
152
:have rodenticides, anticoagulant
rodenticides in their systems.
153
:But, um, In terms of the animals
that were dying, as I'm talking
154
:about, most of them were poisoned
with anticoagulant rodenticides when
155
:the necropsy or autopsy came back.
156
:And the anticoagulant rodenticides
off the charts in terms of the amount
157
:of poisons that were in their bodies.
158
:So these groups of people, they, they, you
know, very much on the ground, um, whether
159
:they're photographers, rehabilitators.
160
:Um, conservationists, and they were
trying to push for, um, the state of
161
:Massachusetts to do something about this.
162
:And so that is basically
how we got the case.
163
:So they ended up, you know, um, find,
you know, uh, looking up the Harvard
164
:Animal Law Clinic, saw the work that
we did, and brought this case to us.
165
:DrG: So the, the main thing
about it is about the fact how
166
:it's, uh, killing the, the birds.
167
:And I did see that study about the, I
think it was the red tailed hawks, all
168
:of the ones that they found, every single
one had evidence of rodenticide poisoning.
169
:So the, the issue is really from
the Massachusetts department
170
:of natural resources, right?
171
:That they are, uh, in charge.
172
:of determining the, the types of pest
controls that are, that are used?
173
:Lla Anderson: Yeah, the Massachusetts,
it's the department, you're close, the
174
:Department of Agricultural Resources.
175
:And they are in charge of,
determining whether this pesticide
176
:is a threat to the environment.
177
:.
DrG: So from what I was hearing, it says that they have, they do not meet the
178
:standards because they cause unreasonable
adverse effects to the environment.
179
:Lla Anderson: They do.
180
:What
181
:DrG: does that mean?
182
:What is the meaning of that?
183
:Lla Anderson: so in the law, this, this
term reasonability, it's everywhere.
184
:Um, yeah, it dictates, you know,
what is permissible and what isn't.
185
:Um, and so reasonability just means, is,
the effects of this rodenticide is it
186
:so harmful or are its effects such that
it's no longer reasonable to, you know,
187
:keep, uh, considering this rodenticide,
um, or this poison or this chemical,
188
:this substance, whatever, uh, whatever
have you as something that should be
189
:the standard or something that should
be, um, that should proliferate in
190
:our society as much as it has been.
191
:So basically, the reasonable standard
is just sort of like within means.
192
:And so, reasonability, if we're talking
about the environment, one could say
193
:a reasonable standard, an example of
something being reasonable, though this
194
:is questionable, is, um, basically,
you know, pollution from cars.
195
:Is it reasonable, um, the amount of
pollution that can come from a car?
196
:Um, And I think that people, for the
most part, would agree, okay, if a,
197
:you know, car that's putting down the
street doesn't pollute an insane amount,
198
:basically, if a car didn't pollute as
much as an 18 wheeler, then, you know,
199
:It's reasonable, whatever it's polluting.
200
:Um, but then, of course, if a cat,
if a car was polluting as much
201
:as an 18 wheeler, then I think
one would say that that is an
202
:unreasonable amount of pollution.
203
:And so the same thing sort of applies to
the reasonability of, whether the adverse
204
:effects are reasonable or unreasonable.
205
:And when you see the ecological
devastation and the just detrimental.
206
:impact that rodenticides or
anticoagulant rodenticides
207
:are having in our environment.
208
:It is very clear that, um,
it is unreasonable and it's
209
:having an unreasonable adverse
effect on our environment.
210
:DrG: As a veterinarian, uh, I worked in
emergency for many years and we would
211
:see dogs and cats that would come in,
you know, poisoned from this because
212
:unfortunately it is something that a
lot of people purchase for use in their
213
:homes and a lot of individuals don't
even know the dangers of it, right?
214
:They think, well, it's just, mouse
killer or, you know, rat poison,
215
:and they don't understand that
it's going to hurt their animals.
216
:And not only from the animals
ingesting it directly, but also
217
:from ingesting the, the mice or the
rats that, that have gotten in it.
218
:And it's such a horrible and
prolonged, cruel death, right?
219
:It
220
:Lla Anderson: is.
221
:It is.
222
:And you have, you have the primary
consumers and the secondary consumers.
223
:The primary consumers are the rodents.
224
:The secondary consumers are the
coyotes, the raccoons, the bald
225
:eagles, the red tailed hawks,
the owls, so on and so forth.
226
:And so people don't, people don't, I
mean, the thing is, it's intentional
227
:that people are not told how detrimental
these rodenticides are and how they're
228
:much worse than your typical rodenticide.
229
:Because the anticoagulant
nature of the rodenticide means
230
:that basically any animal that
consumes it, their blood clots.
231
:And so for the purpose of giving it to
rodents, it's a very cruel way to die.
232
:So these anticoagulant rodenticides
are sort of placed in these black
233
:boxes around, these rodents eat them.
234
:Well, rodents are so intelligent
that with normal poisons, if the
235
:rodent eats it and then immediately
dies, other rodents Will steer clear.
236
:They will not go.
237
:They will know exactly what it looks like.
238
:Um, and so they will not go
near whatever they presume or
239
:rightfully assumed to be poison.
240
:Well, anticoagulant
rodenticides are different.
241
:They're way more, um, uh, nefarious,
I would say, in terms of the effect
242
:on the animal, um, in the sense that
these rodenticides take a week, up to
243
:a week, to set in and for them to die.
244
:So they'll eat an anticoagulant
rodenticide, a secondary
245
:anticoagulant rodenticide.
246
:Uh, and they won't know.
247
:You know, a couple of days later,
they're still eating their fine.
248
:They don't, they don't know
that that is what poisoned them.
249
:So they're slowly being poisoned
and they could end up eating
250
:more and more and more of it.
251
:And then one day they're ways away
from where they consume that poison
252
:and they die and they don't know how,
or, or they don't know, you know,
253
:when they were poisoned, so yeah,
that's how they work in the system.
254
:DrG: So in the petition, basically, what
is it that you're asking for them to do?
255
:Lla Anderson: Well, we're
asking for two things.
256
:So one of the petitions that were
worked on by a couple of other
257
:classmates was the MDAR petition.
258
:So this was a petition to
the Massachusetts Department
259
:of Agricultural Resources.
260
:And it was for the immediate
Suspension of registrations of
261
:anti coagulant rodenticides.
262
:Um, so anti coagulant rodenticides
can still be purchased, though.
263
:There are a couple a few restrictions.
264
:They don't make.
265
:They haven't made much of a difference
in terms of the pernicious effect
266
:on our environment in Massachusetts.
267
:So it's calling for the immediate
suspension of those rodenticides and
268
:it's calling on MDAR to enact that.
269
:So that's the first one.
270
:The second one is a petition to the
Secretary of the Executive Office
271
:of Energy and Environmental Affairs.
272
:And it is a call for her to investigate
the impact of rodenticides on species.
273
:That are protected by the
Massachusetts Endangered Species
274
:Act, such as the bald eagle.
275
:Um, and so we also had another ask,
which was for the secretary to ensure
276
:that the Massachusetts Department of
Agricultural Resources, um, was basically
277
:using all practicable means to, um,
Avoid damaging, uh, the protected
278
:species again, such as the bald eagle.
279
:We're so far since 2021, four bald
eagles have died in Massachusetts.
280
:DrG: I think this is interesting because
I know that as a veterinarian, they tell
281
:us that we have to be very careful with
how we dispose of cadavers after they're
282
:euthanized with euthanasia solution.
283
:Because if, for instance, we.
284
:You know, we discard of, uh, of an
animal inappropriately and an endangered
285
:species feeds off that animal and
dies, we can be responsible, we can
286
:be held liable for the termination
of a life of an endangered species.
287
:And it, it almost sounds like that's
the same issue that's happening here.
288
:However, the, the individuals
that are doing this are not
289
:being held responsible for it.
290
:Lla Anderson: Right.
291
:Exactly right.
292
:DrG: What do you expect
will come about from this?
293
:Lla Anderson: Hopefully.
294
:So, there are hopes, and then there
are, um, you know, a certain uncertain,
295
:well, there's an uncertainty.
296
:So far we haven't heard, we
haven't gotten a response yet.
297
:I would hope that, um, Uh, anti coagulant
rodenticides are reviewed by, um, the
298
:Secretary of the, uh, Executive Office
of Energy and Environmental Affairs, and
299
:that the Secretary does look at the new
report that the EPA released stating that
300
:anti coagulant rodenticides actually show,
um, a negative impact on the environment.
301
:So I would hope that.
302
:You know, that would occur.
303
:Um, I think, you know, honestly, it's,
it's, it's sort of a wait and see.
304
:I think that ultimately there are people,
you know, we have advocates, as you know,
305
:rehabilitators who, who aren't comfortable
with the wait and see approach.
306
:And so the good news is we did have a
state representative in Massachusetts who
307
:presented a bill to ban, um, anticoagulant
rodenticides so that's something, so
308
:I think that, you know, we're, we're
waiting and seeing, uh, we're waiting
309
:on the response, uh, but I am hopeful
because there are a lot of people,
310
:whether they're senior citizens, whether
they're middle aged, um, teenagers,
311
:um, college age, what have you who
are interested in making sure that this
312
:problem, this problem is addressed.
313
:DrG: At least having, knowing that you
have the support or at least one state
314
:representative is really important, right?
315
:Because at least you know that you
have somebody up there that's looking
316
:out and that, um, is, is interested
in being a voice for these animals.
317
:Right, right.
318
:Lla Anderson: I also think it's
important to mention that these
319
:anticoagulant rogenticides are pernicious
and they Destroy our environment.
320
:Um, we mentioned it.
321
:I touched on it.
322
:But to get more specific,
coyotes are being poisoned by
323
:anti coagulant rodenticides.
324
:And the reason why coyotes are
important is because coyotes
325
:determine the health of the ecosystem.
326
:They're right in the
middle of the food chain.
327
:So if you're noticing that coyotes
have mange, they're bruising, they're
328
:emaciated, hemorrhaging, bleeding from the
insides, because that is how, that is the
329
:effect of these secondary anticoagulant
rodenticides on these animals bodies.
330
:So these animals often
choke on their own blood.
331
:Um, there was one owl in, in
Boston, in the Faneuil Hall, and
332
:he was found by some, um, some
citizens, and luckily he was because
333
:if not, he would have soon died.
334
:He was showing signs of hemorrhaging.
335
:He was blind.
336
:He still is blind now as a result of
the poisons, but he is healthy now.
337
:And so basically I'm saying that to
say, this is destroying our environment.
338
:It's destroying the food chain.
339
:Um, and that affects everything,
so we really do have to make sure
340
:that we see this for what it is,
which is, you know, an emergency.
341
:Um, I, I also want to add that this
has an effect on the rehabilitators as
342
:well, who are dealing with, you know,
The bleeding, the blood, um, the loss
343
:of motivation sometimes, um, day in
and day out because they continue to
344
:see these animals poisoned and bleeding
and there's nothing they can do there.
345
:Well, they're trying to do their
best, but right now they're very
346
:limited as to what they can do.
347
:And so, you know, we have to make sure
that this is addressed because it's.
348
:It's really detrimental and it
affects our environment physically.
349
:It also affects the mental
health of individuals, um,
350
:who work hands on with this.
351
:And it's just unnecessary.
352
:There are so many other options
to, to addressing the, uh, any sort
353
:of rodent issue that may occur.
354
:And the one last thing I'll say
is, um, uh, Flacco the Owl and the
355
:Central Park Owl just passed away.
356
:He passed away because of a window strike.
357
:So if you don't know about Flacco
the Owl, Flacco the Owl, um,
358
:is, was a, was a captive owl.
359
:who escaped captivity and basically
would fly around Central Park, and he
360
:was just a spectacle in New York City.
361
:People loved him.
362
:People got out of bed
every day to see him.
363
:Birdwatchers were excited to
see him, and he represented so
364
:much to people in New York City.
365
:Um, he was sort of like a,
the mascot of Central Park.
366
:That's how he was described.
367
:Oflaco was, you know, free for about
a year and a year and a half until
368
:he died suddenly and he died by
a window strike in New York City.
369
:He died from a window strike.
370
:Well, after a necropsy was conducted,
you can guess what happened.
371
:There were anticoagulant
rodenticides in Flacco's body.
372
:And so rodenticides
also affect the vision.
373
:Of an animal, the vision of a
bird, and they affect the way that
374
:they perceive objects, whether
they're close, not close, etc.
375
:And so that was the, that, that
is the reason why Flaco died,
376
:you know, anticoagulant or
denticides and their proliferation.
377
:And so, um, Yeah, it's just that what
I'll say is this is an issue that's
378
:so important, and I would even go
so far as to say that anticoagulant
379
:rodenticides are our generation's DDT.
380
:And we saw how DDT decimated bald
eagle populations before it was banned.
381
:And before we could start conserving
and making sure that these populations
382
:were able to flourish again.
383
:And we just got to the point now
where these populations are coming
384
:back and now, with anticoagulant or
denticides, they are threatened again.
385
:DrG: We talk about, you know,
saying devil's advocate.
386
:Well, how are we supposed to get rid of
the mice and the, and the rats and stuff.
387
:But then also we don't think about the
fact that if we're killing the raptors,
388
:if we're killing the animals that are
supposed to eliminate these to eliminate,
389
:Lla Anderson: exactly
390
:DrG: like we are just shooting ourselves
in the foot, like what do you think is
391
:going to happen if we eliminate all these
eagles and the coyotes and stuff like we,
392
:we take them out of the, out of the cycle.
393
:And then all we're going
to do is cause the.
394
:A shift.
395
:In the, in the balance, we're
going to have an imbalance,
396
:Lla Anderson: right?
397
:Well, we'll have, right.
398
:We'll have an even greater rat
problem, you know, and there are so
399
:many ways to, there are so many ways
to alternatives, making sure that
400
:your trash is away, making sure that
you plug up holes, you know, it's the
401
:integrated pest management approach.
402
:So there are so many other ways to.
403
:To, you know, solve that problem as
opposed to just putting these really
404
:horrible poisons that are killing
these beautiful animals that are
405
:affecting the entire food chain, um,
decimating the entire food chain that
406
:are affecting also kids and pets.
407
:So, yeah, yeah.
408
:And then also, of course, as you said,
again, if we keep doing this, we're just
409
:going to continue exacerbating the problem
that's already happening right now.
410
:DrG: Yeah, sometimes we cause our
own problems and then we blame.
411
:The environment for it.
412
:Yeah, the environment,
413
:Lla Anderson: exactly.
414
:DrG: But we're the one, we're the
ones doing it, so we need to take some
415
:responsibility and take some proactive
action instead of, you know, trying
416
:to, to find the, the easy way out.
417
:Because the easy way out is just never it.
418
:It is not always a band aid
solution, is not, is not
419
:Lla Anderson: a solvent.
420
:Yeah.
421
:DrG: Excellent.
422
:Well, thank you so much for
spending this time with us,
423
:for sharing this information.
424
:Best of luck in your studies.
425
:Lla Anderson: Thank you.
426
:Same to you.
427
:DrG: Yeah, thank you for being here.
428
:Lla Anderson: Thank you
so much for having me.
429
:DrG: Our next guest is going
to be Laura Kiesel, who is the
430
:founder of Save Arlington Wildlife.
431
:Welcome to the junction, Laura.
432
:Laura Kiesel: Thank you
for having me today.
433
:DrG: So can you start by letting our
listeners know about your background?
434
:Laura Kiesel: Sure.
435
:Um, so my first degree is in, in
literature and journalism, but then I went
436
:back to school to study wildlife biology.
437
:Um, and I eventually completed my
master's degree in natural resources
438
:management, um, and sciences.
439
:And so.
440
:I had worked a number of environmental
non profit jobs and also for some
441
:municipal government agencies for their
like natural resources commission.
442
:So I, I kind of come from
a wildlife biology and
443
:environmental policy background.
444
:DrG: The topic that we are discussing
here is the use of the rodenticides, and
445
:then how they are affecting wildlife.
446
:So how did you become involved with this?
447
:Laura Kiesel: Sure.
448
:So this, this issue literally
landed on my doorstep.
449
:One day in 2015, I walked out of my
apartment into my parking lot and there
450
:was a pest control professional putting,
um, 20 bait stations around the property.
451
:And I was.
452
:Somewhat familiar with these poisons.
453
:I, again, at the time I was working
for, uh, or I just completed working.
454
:I was, had recently been laid off, but
for several years I had been working for
455
:a municipal agency, um, in Massachusetts
where they had an integrated pest
456
:management plan where they had basically
all registered pesticides were not
457
:allowed to be used on their public
lands, including these rodenticides.
458
:So I had some familiarity through
my, my last, uh, job position.
459
:And I also had been.
460
:keeping track of the news.
461
:Um, you know, I'm also an environmental
journalist and I had also seen
462
:that California was doing some
more regulations of these poisons.
463
:So I was very alarmed that one day
someone was just putting 20 bait stations
464
:down and I was became increasingly
concerned because when I started to
465
:ask him questions, he was evasive and
even told me things that weren't true.
466
:First, he indicated that they were traps.
467
:And I looked at the labels and I, I
clarified, but those are not traps, right?
468
:These, this, that's poison
bait and the rodent can exit.
469
:And, um, he begrudgingly,
you know, conceded my point.
470
:And I, I said, so anything, any wild
animals that live in the area, we had
471
:red tailed hawknest, uh, down the block.
472
:I mentioned them.
473
:I said, or even my pet cat could.
474
:If a mouse gets in the unit that's eaten
this bait could get sick if he catches
475
:and eats that mouse and he flat out
denied it, but I knew that that was true.
476
:I even wound up calling the company
later and getting the EPA registration
477
:code for that particular product
that they were using and looking up.
478
:It's called like the material data
safety sheet to see the risks to
479
:make sure I wasn't like overstating
it in my mind and I was not.
480
:And then I started to lobby my landlords
to get rid of these poisons, which.
481
:Basically, it was the beginning of a
multi year battle that I didn't get them
482
:to give those poisons up until after I
moved out, and by that time I had saved
483
:Arlington Wildlife going, but, uh, for
years we just had those poisons, and
484
:I watched in a short amount of time,
you know, less than a year as these
485
:bait stations, uh, basically went from,
like, a relative rarity in my town to,
486
:like, proliferating to the point where
I would see them On every single block,
487
:sometimes several to a dozen, especially
in the more dense parts of town.
488
:So I started, I started to really worry.
489
:I started to go to board of health
meetings to talk about it with them.
490
:I started talking to my
state representative.
491
:I went to all these kinds of friends
of this or that park meeting.
492
:And I have to say for the first
several years, I was treated with, um.
493
:A lot of cynicism and even a little
bit of disdain by some places.
494
:Um, my state representative was very
supportive, but yeah, a lot of the town
495
:officials, a lot of these, uh, friends
groups, they, I was yelled at, I was
496
:told I was being a chicken little, um,
and I knew seeing the amount of poison
497
:that was being used that at some point,
like the bill was going to come due.
498
:Um, I knew that there must've
been deaths happening, but.
499
:But that we weren't seeing them, but
they started to become more apparent
500
:as more high profile wildlife cases,
um, started happening in my community.
501
:DrG: So then, you know, we're, we're
now looking at the damage that these
502
:rodenticides are doing to, to wildlife,
especially to endangered species.
503
:Um, and then I saw the, the research
about the red tailed hawks that 100
504
:percent of the ones that had been
seen that year, all of them had been
505
:exposed to rodenticide poisoning.
506
:How, how did all this, um, I say, drive
you to reach out to the law clinic?
507
:Laura Kiesel: So, um, as I mentioned,
I've been doing this for nearly
508
:a decade and, um, we're getting
increasing amounts of wildlife losses,
509
:especially in the past several years.
510
:Here in Arlington, uh, we had a bald eagle
nest They were our first bald eagles to
511
:nest in Arlington's borders in 60 years
since DDT had wiped the species out
512
:of the state and most of the country.
513
:And then, that was in 2021 when
they established the nest and
514
:within six months, uh, one of the
chicks, uh, when it was a fledgling,
515
:died of rodenticide poisoning.
516
:And then last year, in March 2023, MK,
who was the matriarch eagle, uh, the
517
:female breeding bald eagle, who was much
beloved in, Not just like the Boston
518
:metro area, but she was known throughout
the state in the New England region,
519
:like people would travel from miles and
miles away to see her and photograph her.
520
:She was very acclimated to
people, so she was comfortable
521
:being in close proximity to them.
522
:She died last year, uh, in end of February
:
523
:Um, and I think that was sort of
like the last straw for a lot of
524
:us, you know, I held a vigil and a
demonstration the day after she died.
525
:Um, or was pronounced dead.
526
:And I thought maybe a dozen or two
dozen people might show up and over 300
527
:people showed up, um, even though there
was like less than 24 hours notice,
528
:um, for this, it was a week night.
529
:It was still pretty cold
cause it was very early March.
530
:Um, but yeah, hundreds of people showed
up, um, at this time, you know, like
531
:state legislation, even very tepid
532
:bills that were proposed were kind
of stalling here in Arlington.
533
:We were the first municipality to
pass a public lands ban on the second
534
:generation anticoagulant rodenticides.
535
:And we also had submitted what's
called a home rule petition to
536
:the state to ban on private lands
because the state will not allow.
537
:Um, municipalities to ban any
pesticide on private property
538
:without special permission.
539
:And most states in the country
have that kind of law on the books.
540
:Actually, the pest control lobby a couple
of decades ago, fought really hard for
541
:what's called preemption for states
to refuse municipalities the right to
542
:restrict pesticides on private property.
543
:So Arlington had already
submitted a homerule petition.
544
:The city of Newton then
followed in our footsteps.
545
:But it still was just not enough.
546
:And so, after MK died, A concerned
group of citizens who have
547
:been very active in this issue.
548
:Several wildlife rehabbers
and other, um, people that you
549
:saw listed on the petition.
550
:We had a Zoom meeting, uh, with the
executive director of Raptors are
551
:the solution, or rats, and they're
based in California and they have
552
:a, they were successful in getting
a, getting a moratorium on SGARs
553
:in most sectors in the states.
554
:So we asked her for some ideas or or like
what some of the things that she did.
555
:And she basically had
some pro bono legal help.
556
:And so she really urged us to
look into like legal avenues.
557
:And she did mention you might want
to check out some of the student law
558
:clinics because she had gotten help,
I think, from Stanford Law Clinic for
559
:their from their environmental clinic.
560
:So and looking around.
561
:Uh, Harvard has some law clinics,
uh, there's an environmental
562
:clinic and the animal law clinic.
563
:And so we did some queries, uh, the
environmental clinic did not respond,
564
:but the animal law clinic did.
565
:And then, um, basically, they spent
the year researching this issue in
566
:depth before making a decision of
what legal avenues were available to
567
:us, um, to take action on this issue.
568
:DrG: Yeah, I mean, as I mentioned, it
just kind of hits both sides, right?
569
:Because we're concerned about the effect
on the environment in general, but then
570
:we're also concerned about the damage that
it's causing on these animals and just the
571
:torturous death that they undergo, right?
572
:It's not like they get into
this poison and they just die.
573
:Right.
574
:They get into this poison and
they bleed to death and it is a
575
:very prolonged and painful death.
576
:Laura Kiesel: Yes, it basically stops
their blood from being able to clot and
577
:even something as small as like a sneeze
or a cough or one poor owl recently,
578
:uh, bled to death after just plucking,
you know, when, when female owls or
579
:birds of prey are about to lay eggs or
have babies, they'll pluck their belly
580
:feathers out to make what's called a brood
patch so they can insulate their chicks.
581
:And just from plucking out her
feathers, her brood patch, it's
582
:called just, uh, Like hemorrhaged.
583
:So just these small little incidents
can cause like these massive, um,
584
:internal and external hemorrhaging
where they can't stop bleeding.
585
:And yes, very painful, very torturous.
586
:It can take days or weeks for them to die.
587
:So it's also a welfare concern, in
addition to being a conservation concern.
588
:And it's not just wildlife
that are vulnerable, um,
589
:pets like pet cats and dogs.
590
:are also vulnerable and there
have been a number of deaths.
591
:Um, and even Children are vulnerable.
592
:These, uh, the second generation anti
coagulants used to be available on store
593
:shelves and brick and mortar stores,
but they, uh, were banned from store
594
:shelves because young Children by the
thousands were getting into these poisons.
595
:Um, they weren't at that time,
kept in bait stations and they were
596
:getting very sick in a couple of them.
597
:I think even died, and so it
also is public health concerns
598
:for people, especially Children.
599
:DrG: How bad is the rodent problem in
Massachusetts that they're, they're
600
:going through these, um, steps of, you
know, laying so much poison around.
601
:Laura Kiesel: So, you know, as
with all the major metro areas like
602
:New York city and Philadelphia, I
know that we're getting increasing
603
:rates of rodent sightings.
604
:So I'm a little skeptical because
I know to some degree that, you
605
:know, we're, we've been in a
construction boom since:
606
:And I know that a lot of construction
can, you know, interfere with rat
607
:burrows and make them more active.
608
:So I wonder how much of it is
that we have more rats and mice.
609
:I'm sure we do have some
because climate change is also
610
:a problem and warming weather.
611
:They're having they're
having babies year round.
612
:They're having larger litters.
613
:So I'm sure there have been some
population increases from climate change,
614
:but also with the construction boom.
615
:I do think some of it just might be.
616
:We're seeing more of them because they're
their burrows are getting inter, uh,
617
:Interrupted and they're on the move more.
618
:And the same thing with COVID when the
COVID pandemic happened and a lot of
619
:the restaurants shut down, uh, some
of them might've migrated into more
620
:residential areas or because more people
were working from home telecommuting.
621
:There's a theory that it's just when
people started noticing, I mean, people
622
:started noticing a lot more of their
outdoor and, you know, nature experiences,
623
:including, oh, wow, there's a rat.
624
:Like I never noticed that before.
625
:So that's.
626
:That's part of it.
627
:I actually do think that the rat
poison makes the, the problems
628
:worse for rodent populations.
629
:Uh, as I mentioned, I'm an
environmental journalist.
630
:I've been researching this and I've
reported a number of articles on this.
631
:And I remember when I did my 2021 feature
investigative feature, I searched for
632
:weeks high and low for like a peer
review article that could, uh, You
633
:know, talk about the efficacy of these
poisons in reducing rodent populations.
634
:And I couldn't find a single study.
635
:Um, it was really interesting.
636
:I would find studies that
would call them very effective.
637
:And then in the footnote, I would
look up the study they referred to,
638
:and it would just say the same thing.
639
:But it wouldn't actually have
any kind of research behind it.
640
:So I do think a lot of it is scant.
641
:And in my experience, we have
just continued to have more
642
:rodent problems, despite having
these poisons be ubiquitous.
643
:Which indicates to me that either
these poisons are not effective or
644
:they're a contributing factor, which
would make sense because if we're
645
:killing off their predators, like the
predators are effective at usually
646
:like suppressing these populations.
647
:And so we're actually might be inflating
these populations by killing off
648
:their natural predators in the area.
649
:DrG: Yeah, that's one of the things that
I was thinking about is that, as you
650
:mentioned, just, That is, that is nature's
way of maintaining a balance, right?
651
:We have this, this whole chain,
uh, this whole food chain.
652
:And if we are doing things that are
going to affect those animals higher
653
:in the food chain that are tasked
with eliminating these animals that
654
:we consider pests, then all we're
doing is worsening our own problem.
655
:Laura Kiesel: Yeah, that was actually
what I studied in school, like was
656
:predator prey population dynamics.
657
:And I looked more at mammals, like
wolves and stuff on deer, but I can't
658
:help but think it's sort of like a
trophic cascade that we're, we're
659
:inciting when we get rid of these apex
predators like hawks and owls that
660
:were of course going to be ironically
making the rodent population worse.
661
:And they can't rebound
like the rodents can.
662
:Rodents, you know, they breed so
prolifically, they have such like
663
:so many, they can have thousands,
a single pair of rats can have
664
:like thousands of babies a year.
665
:They can outbreed the poisons and they
can build biological immunity to these
666
:poisons in a relatively quick amount
of time because they breed so rapidly
667
:and they have such short lifespans.
668
:But a bird of prey, which can live
for decades and they have short, they
669
:only have a couple of babies a year.
670
:If you like, kill off those
animals, they can't rebound.
671
:So now there's like this mismatch
where the rodents outbreed the
672
:poison, but now you've annihilated
the predators in the area because
673
:they cannot overcome the impacts of
these poisons like the rodents can.
674
:DrG: So what is it that your group is
hoping that happens from these petitions?
675
:Laura Kiesel: I mean, I, ideally, I
am hoping that, um, the Massachusetts
676
:Department of Agricultural Resources
and the Department of Energy will, uh,
677
:seriously review the science and the
case studies that are offered in them
678
:and, um, Make a decision that is, um,
that corresponds with that, because right
679
:now we're not, you know, MDAR, the M.
680
:A.
681
:Department of Agricultural
Resources, they're supposed to
682
:consider the environmental impacts
of any pesticides they allow to
683
:be used, um, the pest companies to
use in the state of Massachusetts.
684
:And that doesn't really
seem to be happening.
685
:Um, and it, it, it seems like they're
rubber stamping this without looking at
686
:it because if they would work to look very
closely, they would see these impacts.
687
:Now we already have the bald eagle
case studies of several bald eagles
688
:necropsy by the state, and there's
still a MESA listed species.
689
:They're still on under the state
endangered species act, but we
690
:had to do a lot of our own science
too, because the state is not other
691
:than those MESA listed species.
692
:The state is not testing animals.
693
:So a lot of the wildlife rehabbers on
their own dime and or with help from
694
:groups like Save Arlington Wildlife,
crowdfunding from like just rape, you
695
:know, lay citizens who want to help.
696
:We've been funding these necropsies and
basically every animal that has been
697
:necropsied has shown SGARs exposure and
almost all but one that I know of, the,
698
:the rates of SGARs exposure are extremely
high, um, and usually considered lethal.
699
:So, you know, Cape and wildlife in
particular, they've done an enormous
700
:amount of testing and data keeping
to show that this is a real problem.
701
:Aaron Hutchings.
702
:told me that at this point, rodenticide
poisoning, I think is their number one
703
:reason for intake for the birds of prey.
704
:They get, um, surpassing vehicle strikes
and a lot of their vehicle strikes.
705
:They probably do have lower levels of
poisoning that make them susceptible
706
:to those, those collisions.
707
:But, um, yeah, and she's seen a real
uptick in the past seven years or so,
708
:which have Like that's around the time
that the construction boom started and
709
:it's also around the time the EPA pulled
these from store shelves and has companies
710
:had more of a monopoly and I, in my
experience, at least here in Boston.
711
:That's when it really became something
that started to on every street like
712
:you started noticing them popping up.
713
:DrG: One of the things that that I
discussed with Ella Anderson from
714
:Harvard Law School was about an owl and.
715
:An owl in New York that died
after a window strike and then
716
:on the necropsy, they did find
out that there were anticoagulant
717
:rodenticides and these, these poisons
can cause difficulty in vision.
718
:So it can be, you know, with the
vehicle strikes, as you mentioned,
719
:they, yeah, the, the car may be the
cause of death, but the mechanism
720
:of death may be the anticoagulant
rodenticide that caused it to be blind
721
:and not be able to evade the vehicle.
722
:Laura Kiesel: Yeah, and, um, I think
you're talking about Flacco, the, the
723
:owl, the, like, the celebrity owl that
everyone, you know, like, the New York
724
:Times loved him, he was an escapee
from the Central Park Zoo, he was
725
:a Eurasian eagle owl, so not native
to New York City, and I think that
726
:sort of enthralled people about him.
727
:Um, and what the media hasn't really
talked about, though, is the poison,
728
:the main anticoagulant found in his
system, bromodiolone, the Parks Division
729
:of New York City uses that at Central
Park and their other part parks in in
730
:the New York City network, Um, and I
had a conversation with them at the end
731
:of last fall, like November ish, asking
them why they were using bromodylone.
732
:And they told me that it
was a low toxic poison.
733
:And that's not true.
734
:I said, where did you
get that information?
735
:Because the EPA and I even shared
with them the EPA classification.
736
:I was like, it's considered
moderately toxic to birds
737
:and highly toxic to mammals.
738
:And they told they eventually after
weeks told me it was their pest control
739
:contractor that told them that and it's
concerning to me that so many agencies
740
:are taking the word of the very industry
that has a conflict, you know, a vested
741
:conflict of interest in keeping the
profits running by using this product.
742
:So I don't understand why they're being
listened to at their word other than the
743
:science that exists about these poisons.
744
:DrG: Well, and to say that it's
low toxicity, I mean, toxicity
745
:is in the dosing, right?
746
:Like, a lot of poisons are not toxic
until you get to a certain level.
747
:So let's say that, yeah, it's In low
doses is not toxic, but what is it
748
:to say that these animals are not
going to ingest high quantities given
749
:the amount that is being spread?
750
:Laura Kiesel: Yes.
751
:And I interviewed, um, uh, her
name was Cynthia Hopp Dennis.
752
:She's a veterinarian with Cornell
and she's done studies on SGARs
753
:exposure rates in New York, more like
in the Ithaca region near Cornell.
754
:But she, she said the same thing you did.
755
:And she mentioned, you know, like, it
doesn't even really matter what some
756
:of the studies like lab studies are
showing because Those are very controlled
757
:and much smaller doses than what these
animals are getting in the wild, but
758
:also synergistically because they're
not just getting the bromodilone.
759
:They're getting the other anticoagulants
and other poisons in their systems too.
760
:So those are all compounding on, you know,
having a compounding impact on the animal.
761
:And I know it, uh, New England Wildlife
Center mentioned that one of the
762
:reasons they think that they're another
rehab clinic that they are having a
763
:harder time rehabbing their animals
is because usually those animals
764
:have several of the anticoagulants.
765
:In their system, and it's they're
synergistically working together to
766
:suppress the clotting at such an increased
rate than they used to see when it
767
:was maybe just one poison being used.
768
:DrG: The reading at the
Massachusetts pesticide control act.
769
:It says that it cannot cause unreasonable
adverse effects on the environment and
770
:is very clear that these rodenticides
are damaging the environment.
771
:Yes.
772
:And then the other concern as far, like
you mentioned, I mean, it's just these
773
:are, these are endangered species, right?
774
:Laura Kiesel: Yeah, it's, you know,
a lot of people ask, like, doesn't
775
:the Migratory Bird Treaty Act and
the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection
776
:Acts, they all have some language in
there about not poisoning the animals.
777
:Um, but it's just, unfortunately,
there's not a lot of, um, options for
778
:citizens to bring suits under those acts.
779
:And also, they They define the poisoning
in a way where it's usually direct,
780
:and if it's an incidental poisoning,
there's like a lot more red tape to prove
781
:it, but as you mentioned, there's all
these rules about, you know, rehabbers
782
:mentioned how they can't even release
the wildlife that they've treated with
783
:antibiotics till a certain amount of
time goes by, so that the antibiotics
784
:don't enter like the food web, you know,
you can't, under the MBTA, You can't own
785
:like eagle feathers or bird feathers,
even if you just find them in nature
786
:because of like concerns of conservation.
787
:So I just find it, you know, kind
of a contradiction that that those
788
:are so heavily regulated, but then
these poisons are just being put out.
789
:Just without almost pretty much
indiscriminately by the pest control
790
:companies and, you know, even though
they're supposed to, were supposed
791
:to be used as a last ditch, um,
effort to control rodents when other
792
:things failed, or like, they're just
being put down as preventatives.
793
:They're being put down whether or not
there are rodents present and they just
794
:leave them down, um, indefinitely, which
is against the EPA's own recommendations
795
:for how they should be applied.
796
:DrG: I think that, you know, like, like
with most things related to animals,
797
:the environment, everything, it's about
education, and I don't think that the
798
:public is truly, you know, aware of the
damage that these things are causing,
799
:you know, they see the rat problem, so
they're, of course, going to take to
800
:the turn to the government and turn to
officials and say, you got to take care
801
:of these, of these rats, these rodents,
and, um, They're, you know, this is the
802
:answer that they're giving and they're
going to be okay with it, but I think
803
:that, you know, through you guys, so
these advocacy efforts, if we can get the
804
:public in general to understand the damage
that it's happening and not only how it's
805
:affecting wildlife, but how it can affect
themselves, their family, their animals,
806
:then perhaps there's going to be a bigger
outcry for these, for these rodenticides
807
:to be taken off the, be taken off use.
808
:Laura Kiesel: I, yeah, I agree.
809
:And I, I started a new nonprofit just
like a couple of months ago called like,
810
:it's a mouthful, Save Massachusetts
Wildlife Education Fund, and I'm just
811
:wanting to, that whole nonprofit is
existing for me to try to come up with
812
:like video tutorials and other like
education campaigns to really like.
813
:Get them marketed out to the
mainstream because I feel like so
814
:much of it is people just still
don't understand some of the basics.
815
:Like what those black boxes are, you
know a surprising amount of people
816
:still sometimes don't get what secondary
poisoning is They're like, how did
817
:the wildlife get into the boxes?
818
:And you know, sometimes you have to you
know Explain to them how like no, it's
819
:the rodents themselves that are poisoning
that that are the poison product now
820
:DrG: Yeah, they're, they're used quite
frequently and people don't, it's like
821
:people don't realize what they do.
822
:Right.
823
:Like it's like a magic act, they
think that the mouse is going
824
:to go in it and just disappear.
825
:Yeah.
826
:I understand that they're going in
there, they're getting poison and
827
:then they're walking out of it.
828
:They, you know, some people think that
they just get trapped in there, that
829
:they eat it and they're trapped and they
die in there and that's not even it.
830
:Laura Kiesel: Yeah, I've spoken to a lot
of people who are confused, and again,
831
:some of the pest companies seem to
encourage that kind of ignorance, like,
832
:like I mentioned my very first, you know,
conversation, he tried to kind of, he
833
:called them traps, and I said, but the
animal, like, they leave, they leave.
834
:Right.
835
:Um, something I also wanted to
mention because I think that this is
836
:a countrywide problem, but I do think
Massachusetts, when I speak to rehabbers,
837
:to researchers on this issue, and I
tell them I'm in Massachusetts, they do
838
:say things usually like Massachusetts
has an especially bad problem with the
839
:poisoning, um, You probably have read
the Tufts Wildlife Clinic studies.
840
:You already referred to the one about
the red tailed hawks, and when they
841
:looked at other birds of prey, it was 96
percent, but recently I spoke to Project
842
:Snowstorm, and they look at snowy owls,
and they, they've been, they released a
843
:blog post a couple of weeks ago, um, or
at this point, it might be almost a month
844
:ago, Uh, where they noted like 10 years
ago, when they, because they necropsy
845
:dead snowy owls, they find they didn't
have find hardly any anticoagulant like
846
:cases in the necropsies, but in just
like the past decade, it's become like
847
:a ubiquitous problem with the samples.
848
:And when I interviewed, um, one of
their representatives, he said that
849
:Massachusetts overall had the highest
poisoning rates for snowy owls, both,
850
:I think, in the ratio of snowy owls
and in the poisoning numbers, the
851
:toxicity levels themselves found
in the liver of these AR poisons.
852
:Um, and snowy owls, they're not
like a They're not listed in
853
:Massachusetts, um, as an endangered
species or a threatened species.
854
:I don't know why, maybe because
they're a migratory species here,
855
:but they're, they're in trouble.
856
:Like they're red listed under the
IUCN, um, red list as threatened.
857
:And I know for the U S fish and
wildlife service does have them a
858
:species of conservation concern.
859
:They're under serious threats
with climate change because
860
:they're from Arctic ecosystems.
861
:So when they migrate to like the
continental North, you know, us.
862
:usually like the Northeast
or Midwest region.
863
:And if they're getting poisoned by
these rat poisons, you know, that
864
:could be a tipping point for them.
865
:DrG: What can the public do to be
better advocates in this field?
866
:Laura Kiesel: Sure.
867
:Well, in addition to, you know, talking
to your landlords, if you feel like
868
:you can do that safely, because I know
sometimes they can be retaliatory,
869
:but, you know, advocating if you do
have it at your place of residence
870
:to see if you can get them removed.
871
:Or again, if you're a business owner,
not using them or talking to businesses
872
:about not using these poisons and
trying to use other alternatives.
873
:Here in Massachusetts
specific to our petition.
874
:We're still waiting for a response before
I think we decide what our next steps are.
875
:And you know, there probably will
be a call, um, some kind of call to
876
:action depending on what the next steps
are, if they respond in the negative.
877
:But we do have the Arlington and the city
of Newton has home rule petitions pending
878
:in the state legislature right now to
ban these poisons on private property.
879
:So even though those homerule petitions
are specific to those communities if,
880
:if by some chance they passed, it would
establish a firm legal precedent for
881
:the prohibition of these chemicals.
882
:And a lot of people don't realize
because these home rule petitions
883
:are for Arlington and Newton,
they think, oh, I don't have to
884
:call or talk to my state rep.
885
:But I just, You know, I've been telling
people in Massachusetts, if you, you
886
:know, please call and write your Senator
and your state rep and tell them, um,
887
:that you want to see the, the home rule
petitions for Arlington and Newton past
888
:the state, um, the state legislature and
make it into law for our communities,
889
:because that will make it a lot easier
for other communities to do this, but also
890
:if those passed, it would lend a
lot of leverage and momentum to the
891
:legal petition we have with Harvard
because those would resonate with
892
:like, um, the politicians on the
state level, and they would see that
893
:there's a lot of public demand for
further regulation of these poisons.
894
:I mean, if you're not in Massachusetts,
you could look at what we're doing here
895
:and what states like California have done.
896
:And you can explore legal avenues,
find a coalition of people to
897
:work with here in Massachusetts.
898
:We had to go community by
community because our state
899
:legislature is a bit gridlocked.
900
:So the reason we did a lot of like, after
I started save Arlington wildlife, a
901
:lot of other communities started their
own respective save wildlife groups.
902
:And right now they're about, I think
between a dozen and 20 across the
903
:Commonwealth, um, and each one is
trying to do similar things that we did
904
:here in Arlington, that is past public
lands bans, get a home rule petition
905
:submitted to the state because the
more of that will increase pressure.
906
:So maybe in,
907
:if someone's in a state similar to us,
you could look at local level things
908
:like that, getting a public lands
ban, um, getting, um, a home rule
909
:petition, or if it's called something
else in your state, but similar to that
910
:passed, um, looking at legal avenues,
um, working on things like that.
911
:I do have on the Save
Arlington wildlife website.
912
:I do have like an activist tool kit that
I authored that kind of just has like
913
:a bullet by bullet instruction of what
we did here in Arlington when we were
914
:getting started to eventually culminate
in the achievements we did that other
915
:people are glad to borrow from and.
916
:I think that's a good springboard
even even if you're not going
917
:to try to pass municipal laws.
918
:It just also has other ideas for
raising awareness and getting businesses
919
:or residential properties to stop
using the poisons and there's also an
920
:alternatives to road and decide page.
921
:So I have a lot of resources on the
save Arlington wildlife dot org page.
922
:DrG: Excellent.
923
:Yeah, because that was going to be my
next question is, you know, we, we can't
924
:just say, well, we have a problem with
this solution, but we're not going to
925
:help with providing another solution.
926
:So I wanted to know what were the,
what were the other recommendations as
927
:far as solving the the rodent problem.
928
:Laura Kiesel: Yeah, so I do have
an alternatives to rodenticide.
929
:Raptors are the solution has a lot of
a lot of one pagers and good graphic,
930
:you know, kind of infographic or
illustrations that I think is more
931
:palatable sometimes for people to look at.
932
:I mean, at the end of the day, the
best thing and it's hard, right?
933
:Because human behavior is hard to change.
934
:I think the number one way is to really
reduce rodent populations is better
935
:waste management and sanitation, uh,
coupled with better exclusion, you
936
:know, like, so making sure homes are
less porous so they can't get inside
937
:the home because I think that's when
people really get upset is when they're
938
:finding their way inside people's
homes, um, Those are the two big ones.
939
:And I know, again, that's kind of
difficult for people because people
940
:don't necessarily want to take down
their bird feeders, but bird feeders
941
:can be a big attractant to rats, right?
942
:Um, and if you do want to keep your
bird feeders, there are a number of
943
:things you then really want to do
and be vigilant about, because you
944
:will get rats, at least in my area,
if you have a bird feeder eventually.
945
:And even if you don't use poison,
because I get these queries all the
946
:time, where someone will say, like,
my neighbor uses Uh, bird feeders.
947
:They don't use the poison.
948
:I've tried to talk to them about it, but
they have rats and the rats are coming
949
:in my yard, but they will say, but
there's two or three other neighbors,
950
:now they've begun to use poison.
951
:So even if the person with the bird feeder
doesn't use the poison, I try to explain
952
:to them that probably if you get rats,
Your neighbors will start using poison.
953
:So taking down bird feeders or
doing, like I said, a number of
954
:mitigation options with that.
955
:Um, you know, not even small, low hanging
fruit things like not taking your trash
956
:to outdoor barrels or dumpsters until
basically it's almost time for pickup
957
:would be a big thing.
958
:When I lived in Alaska, it was actually
illegal to take your trash out until the
959
:morning of pick up because of there was
a grizzly, you know, the grizzly bears
960
:would come and you also couldn't have
a bird feeders either because it would
961
:draw grizzly bears to the property and
could result in someone getting injured.
962
:So, um, I almost wonder at one point
if we're going to have to start
963
:thinking about this more at a mandated
way, but at the very least, I try to
964
:educate people about those options.
965
:And, you know, hiring somebody to do
exclusion or looking into do it yourself
966
:place, finding like the holes in your
drywall and stuffing it with steel wool.
967
:And then just other things like, um,
there's something called dry ice.
968
:I don't know if you've heard of that,
like you can put those in outdoor
969
:burrows and like as it like dissipates,
it's like carbon dioxide poisoning,
970
:so it kind of puts them to sleep.
971
:Um, so I, I, like lethal measures to
me are usually a last like You know
972
:on the last option but I always tell
people that's probably one of the least
973
:inhumane ways to get rid of them if
like you've tried other options and
974
:and even old fashioned snap traps.
975
:Um, though you do have to be really
like clever about what you bait them
976
:with and where you put them and and
careful to have them either in a
977
:bait box or in places where another
animal can't get caught in them.
978
:DrG: Well, thank you so much for being
with us and for sharing your knowledge.
979
:And thank you for everything
that you're doing.
980
:Hopefully these petitions will,
will get, you know, some response.
981
:And if not, I'm sure that you're
going to continue to battle
982
:until, until something happens.
983
:Laura Kiesel: We will.
984
:Thank you very much.