In this special episode of Legal Judg(e)ments, host Bob Stetson finds himself in the hot seat as guest host, and seasoned real estate attorney Eric Allon takes over the interviewer’s mic. Together, they dissect a real estate dispute with far-reaching implications: McCarthy v. Young.

The case asks a pivotal question—when is an offer to purchase a binding contract? Drawing on precedent from McCarthy v. Tobin and the twists of a modern-day easement dispute, Bob walks us through the litigation strategy that led to an appeals court victory and reshapes how Massachusetts courts may view these standard forms.

Whether you’re a lawyer, broker, buyer, or seller, this episode is a must-listen. Discover why a simple form might be the most legally dangerous piece of paper in your real estate deal—and what you can do to protect yourself.