Artwork for podcast Different, not broken
Are You an Order Muppet or a Chaos Muppet?
Episode 3524th December 2025 • Different, not broken • Lauren "L2" Howard
00:00:00 00:15:53

Share Episode

Shownotes

Nobody really explains this part of relationships either.

That a lot of the friction isn’t about love, or communication, or effort.

It’s about order.

And chaos.

And which one of you is quietly losing your mind because the other one will not, under any circumstances, make a plan.

Hi, I’m Lauren Howard. You can call me L2. Like other people do.

And in this episode of Different, Not Broken, I introduce you to the single most accurate relationship framework I’ve ever found.

It comes from the greatest relationship philosopher of our time.

Jim Henson.

I’m talking Order Muppets and Chaos Muppets.

Who they are.

Why they keep finding each other.

And why once you see it, you genuinely can’t unsee it.

We get into partners, kids, siblings, colleagues, and the moment when an Order Muppet finally snaps and goes full feral Kermit.

We talk about why chaos isn’t a flaw.

Why order isn’t control.

And why most conflict is really just two nervous systems speaking completely different languages.

There’s also a listener question about masking.

What it costs.

Why it’s exhausting.

And how to start noticing who you actually are underneath all the coping.

It’s funny.

It’s unreasonably accurate.

And it will absolutely ruin the way you look at the people in your life, in the best possible way.

If you’ve ever thought “why am I the only one holding this together?”

Or “why does this person make everything harder?”

Congratulations. You’re probably a Muppet.

Let’s figure out which kind.

Useful stuff

Stuff that helps you become awesome even if you’re different: https://stan.store/elletwo

My grown up job: https://lbeehealth.com/

Timestamped summary

00:00 Are You an Order Muppet or a Chaos Muppet?

02:18 Jim Henson’s accidental relationship genius

05:04 Why opposites don’t just attract, they survive

08:41 Families, kids, and chaos tolerance

11:22 When Order Muppets finally lose their shit

13:09 Listener question: masking and exhaustion

14:05 How to start unmasking without blowing up your life

Mentioned in this episode:

Build Your Better course

Build your better course - https://stan.store/elletwo/p/build-your-better

Brag on yourself

Wanna brag on yourself for something you've done which you're proud of? https://differentnotbrokenpodcast.com/voicemail

Transcripts

Speaker:

Are you an

Speaker:

order

Speaker:

Muppet or a chaos Muppet?

Speaker:

if beaker's involved, shit is gonna end up on fire.

Speaker:

And Every person is either an order muppet

Speaker:

or a chaos muppet.

Speaker:

so obviously

Speaker:

I work in mental health.

Speaker:

I run a mental health company.

Speaker:

I have spent a lot of time around incredible clinicians who have taught me.

Speaker:

Lots of really amazing things about relationship dynamics and how people

Speaker:

interact with each other and how they work together, and how communication works best

Speaker:

and what

Speaker:

types of personalities tend

Speaker:

do

Speaker:

well together, et cetera, et cetera.

Speaker:

Like

Speaker:

all of that is, kind of germane to being in this field

Speaker:

and I

Speaker:

Have never found a theory more accurate or more appropriate.

Speaker:

That helps me describe almost any

Speaker:

pair

Speaker:

of people quite like this one, which relies on a lot of.

Speaker:

understanding of relationship dynamics, that we're.

Speaker:

kind

Speaker:

crafted

Speaker:

by the greatest relationship philosopher of our time.

Speaker:

Jim Henson

Speaker:

It was an article in, I

Speaker:

wanna say slate

Speaker:

in

Speaker:

2013,

Speaker:

That still guides pretty much

Speaker:

everything.

Speaker:

Not everything,

Speaker:

but a lot of

Speaker:

how I understand relationship dynamics.

Speaker:

It

Speaker:

is an article called

Speaker:

Chaos Theory,

Speaker:

A Unified Theory of Muppet Types,

Speaker:

and it sorts everybody into one

Speaker:

of two camps.

Speaker:

Are you an

Speaker:

order

Speaker:

Muppet or a chaos Muppet?

Speaker:

Every

Speaker:

Muppet

Speaker:

Has their

Speaker:

counterbalance in the Muppet universe.

Speaker:

Whether they're order

Speaker:

chaos that balances

Speaker:

out their order or their chaos.

Speaker:

Ms. Piggy has Kermit

Speaker:

Ms. Piggy,

Speaker:

definitely the Chaos.

Speaker:

Muppet Kermit

Speaker:

Order.

Speaker:

Muppet Kermit tries

Speaker:

keep

Speaker:

things calm until he eventually loses his shit

Speaker:

Usually at the hands of Miss

Speaker:

Pig.

Speaker:

Miss Piggy has no interest in calm, no interest in order, and together they

Speaker:

balance each other.

Speaker:

Same thing with buns and beaker, Bunsen, calm, scientific,

Speaker:

great

Speaker:

mind

Speaker:

brain's so big.

Speaker:

he's bold.

Speaker:

Beaker is so chaotic.

Speaker:

he can't

Speaker:

even speak an established language.

Speaker:

He's all meeps and moops.

Speaker:

It may be an established language that I'm not familiar with.

Speaker:

You're right, that's shortsighted.

Speaker:

I should give him more credit than that.

Speaker:

But if beaker's involved, shit is gonna end up on fire.

Speaker:

And

Speaker:

And it's rarely a bun's

Speaker:

fault,

Speaker:

but

Speaker:

they need each other.

Speaker:

Abundance needs a beaker and a beaker needs a,

Speaker:

We

Speaker:

can look at our old pals.

Speaker:

Umbert

Speaker:

and Ernie, public television's, first out gay couple.

Speaker:

but you

Speaker:

know

Speaker:

that Bert

Speaker:

Iron Irons, his underwear, you know, he does.

Speaker:

if you got the

Speaker:

reference,

Speaker:

get at

Speaker:

me where the reference is from.

Speaker:

You know, besties.

Speaker:

If you got that reference and Ernie has probably never done laundry in his life.

Speaker:

He's wearing the same shirt.

Speaker:

They

Speaker:

They

Speaker:

need each other.

Speaker:

This is not just a theory of Muppets.

Speaker:

Your life is probably

Speaker:

guided by Muppet Chaos Theory in my house.

Speaker:

I am the Order Muppet.

Speaker:

My husband is unmitigated

Speaker:

chaos.

Speaker:

Muppet,

Speaker:

my

Speaker:

husband has never met a plan

Speaker:

he could

Speaker:

tolerate.

Speaker:

I

Speaker:

am like all plans.

Speaker:

I'm only plans.

Speaker:

That gives me an idea.

Speaker:

I'm gonna walk.

Speaker:

I'm gonna walk away from

Speaker:

I'm gonna walk

Speaker:

away from that, but I'm gonna come back to it later.

Speaker:

I'm gonna come back to it later.

Speaker:

Okay.

Speaker:

I'm just saying.

Speaker:

I'm just saying

Speaker:

a

Speaker:

service to watch

Speaker:

people build spreadsheets and call it only plans.

Speaker:

Anyway, that just came to me.

Speaker:

Trademark.

Speaker:

I'm trademarking that step

Speaker:

away.

Speaker:

Internet.

Speaker:

Anyway,

Speaker:

My husband is all chaos.

Speaker:

He only has chaos.

Speaker:

It's all he is capable of.

Speaker:

we balance each other mostly, sometimes, occasionally.

Speaker:

if I look at my brother and my sister-in-law,

Speaker:

he

Speaker:

is all chaos Muppet.

Speaker:

He is only chaos Muppet.

Speaker:

She is all order Muppet.

Speaker:

That's all.

Speaker:

She's got all order.

Speaker:

Sometimes a chaos muppet can become an order Muppet often when order muppets

Speaker:

get pushed to the brink of insanity and become full chaos muppets by just

Speaker:

like going full.

Speaker:

angry Kermit and smashing things with flailing

Speaker:

puppet arms.

Speaker:

That does happen, but it usually requires a

Speaker:

catalyst.

Speaker:

Every person is either an order muppet

Speaker:

or a chaos muppet.

Speaker:

once you start

Speaker:

understanding this, your understanding of relationship dynamics will change.

Speaker:

Fundamentally,

Speaker:

it's so important.

Speaker:

This is how I judge all

Speaker:

relationships.

Speaker:

My children, I have one order Muppet and one chaos

Speaker:

mpe.

Speaker:

my oldest, full

Speaker:

order Muppet.

Speaker:

she can't go to sleep unless things are organized and straight on her desk.

Speaker:

My

Speaker:

youngest

Speaker:

only

Speaker:

chaos Muppet, she does not give a shit where anything is.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

Nothing bothers her.

Speaker:

She will sleep on top of mess.

Speaker:

She does not care.

Speaker:

She doesn't care.

Speaker:

Whereas my oldest is like,

Speaker:

something is outta place.

Speaker:

Everything's gonna burn down.

Speaker:

It's

Speaker:

not gonna burn down.

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

I mean,

Speaker:

Probably not, probably not gonna burn down.

Speaker:

Probably not.

Speaker:

Anyway, it's been what,

Speaker:

13

Speaker:

years and I still use this as the guidepost for all

Speaker:

things relationship dynamics.

Speaker:

So I encourage you to go read the article,

Speaker:

Which is at this point literature,

Speaker:

like, it's history.

Speaker:

It's

Speaker:

an important part of our zeitgeist.

Speaker:

we must accept it as

Speaker:

a philosophical tome.

Speaker:

But tell me if you

Speaker:

are an Order Muppet or a Chaos Muppet, and then look at the people around you and

Speaker:

find me one

Speaker:

person who doesn't fit.

Speaker:

Find me one.

Speaker:

I I bet you can.

Speaker:

I bet you can.

Speaker:

it

Speaker:

is the way that I judge all relationships in my existence despite

Speaker:

being around people who can give me

Speaker:

in theory, better

Speaker:

ways to assess relationships.

Speaker:

None of them hold up this one does.

Speaker:

This one is the best guide by which you can judge all

Speaker:

relationships, and I stand by that.

Speaker:

And now we'll go to Allison who has this week's small talk.

Speaker:

Hi L two.

Speaker:

I've been listening for a few months and keep pausing episodes

Speaker:

because it feels like you're talking directly to me, which is unsettling,

Speaker:

but also kind of comforting.

Speaker:

I'm realizing how much I mask at work, especially in meetings.

Speaker:

I come home absolutely wiped and still feel like I didn't do enough.

Speaker:

How do you start unpacking masking when it's basically become your personality?

Speaker:

Okay, so the first thing is that that a lot, like,

Speaker:

a lot, like almost daily, that people say that

Speaker:

don't know how I knew they needed to hear something or something like

Speaker:

that.

Speaker:

I didn't know, but I know what I needed to hear at some point.

Speaker:

And the whole premise kind of

Speaker:

of all of this is that.

Speaker:

I got

Speaker:

this place in my life thinking that things were just me.

Speaker:

And it wasn't until I started talking about them that I

Speaker:

realized that there were other

Speaker:

in almost identically the same

Speaker:

situation.

Speaker:

so point didn't know you needed

Speaker:

hear it.

Speaker:

I didn't know that anybody needed to hear it.

Speaker:

It's what I needed to hear at some point.

Speaker:

And the only

Speaker:

compass I have reference.

Speaker:

So

Speaker:

I, glad

Speaker:

that is working out for you and that you're getting what you need out of it.

Speaker:

And also, I'm sorry.

Speaker:

'cause I know sometimes

Speaker:

it

Speaker:

like you're being personally attacked and I don't mean to, I apologize.

Speaker:

the question which is how to, you know, figure out when you're

Speaker:

masking and when you're not.

Speaker:

so masking is frequently a function of neurodivergence, and it's how

Speaker:

a people who identify as neurodivergent or don't realize they're neurodivergent, make

Speaker:

themselves quote unquote, normal enough to

Speaker:

in neurotypical environment.

Speaker:

Normal exist.

Speaker:

Normal's bullshit.

Speaker:

It's

Speaker:

a

Speaker:

non-existent standard, but it's the

Speaker:

that, that people use to put themselves through that.

Speaker:

so that's,

Speaker:

you know, a real thing, that's valid thing.

Speaker:

it's not only neuro divergent people who have to shrink to fit

Speaker:

or change their personality to

Speaker:

try to make friends or, or

Speaker:

fit in.

Speaker:

I think that be a very universal experience.

Speaker:

and it is really

Speaker:

easy to forget

Speaker:

are in those environments

Speaker:

to actually are.

Speaker:

in some cases you've been doing

Speaker:

the years

Speaker:

your life you're not sure who you are.

Speaker:

there's no right way to do that

Speaker:

except to start taking a

Speaker:

back and

Speaker:

clocking what feels

Speaker:

and what doesn't.

Speaker:

What feels

Speaker:

something you want to do and what feels like something you don't want to do.

Speaker:

Does that

Speaker:

just stop doing all the things you don't

Speaker:

wanna do?

Speaker:

No, of

Speaker:

of those like be done.

Speaker:

Like, can't think of people who are like, I'm so excited to

Speaker:

at five o'clock in the morning and

Speaker:

go to today.

Speaker:

That doesn't

Speaker:

great a lot of people, but you still have to if you have to pay bills.

Speaker:

can't think of anybody who's like, man, the DMV sounds great,

Speaker:

you still need a so you still have go do it.

Speaker:

But are there ways to make it more comfortable?

Speaker:

Are there ways to.

Speaker:

Adapt so that you care less about what the people around you think

Speaker:

and more about what makes you comfortable in that situation.

Speaker:

So some examples

Speaker:

like you to ride the train

Speaker:

work every day.

Speaker:

And

Speaker:

because

Speaker:

are other people around you know, you

Speaker:

make sure that you

Speaker:

are dressed professionally and that you're wearing uncomfortable shoes

Speaker:

because they nice with your outfit.

Speaker:

And

Speaker:

you don't take a seat if there's else around who needs the seat or whatever.

Speaker:

There's all

Speaker:

things that you do

Speaker:

to be socially

Speaker:

in that situation.

Speaker:

And should you take From the elderly and infirm, not.

Speaker:

Please give them chair.

Speaker:

But

Speaker:

also.

Speaker:

is it okay to

Speaker:

down once in a

Speaker:

a while

Speaker:

you are tired too?

Speaker:

And if there's a chair available and

Speaker:

you know you're not sure it's an

Speaker:

to somebody,

Speaker:

but else going for take the seat.

Speaker:

been plenty of situations where I've been in

Speaker:

something like that where I'm like, it would more convenient for me do thing,

Speaker:

but I'm worried about inconveniencing

Speaker:

strangers

Speaker:

who are not a problem, so I'm not that thing.

Speaker:

And you can make a decision that the that you in that situation, you are gonna do.

Speaker:

Don't listen to your music on speaker, your headphones in.

Speaker:

But also like if the noise on the train bothers you

Speaker:

and

Speaker:

overstimulated

Speaker:

you're on the train, you can get earplugs even if you think that's gonna

Speaker:

rude to the people around who

Speaker:

you would normally interact with

Speaker:

because that's way you were taught.

Speaker:

You can get earplugs, you ignore people, you can read a book, you can to podcast.

Speaker:

You can all of

Speaker:

things that sometimes don't do in semi-public environments

Speaker:

because they feel like it's,

Speaker:

you know,

Speaker:

or inappropriate or whatever.

Speaker:

so it's really about, not about very

Speaker:

who you are and who you are not or even who wanna

Speaker:

because that's a question that's probably a little far away from you at this point.

Speaker:

But what good to my What gives anxiety?

Speaker:

tamps down my anxiety?

Speaker:

What makes

Speaker:

feel chaotic?

Speaker:

What makes feel like I'm in control of chaos?

Speaker:

How do I limit my stress?

Speaker:

Whatever,

Speaker:

and just leaning

Speaker:

that.

Speaker:

And

Speaker:

are times where

Speaker:

I am certain doing something way is

Speaker:

way I wanna it.

Speaker:

And in actual,

Speaker:

practice.

Speaker:

I hate it.

Speaker:

And I don't wanna do it that way, even though I think

Speaker:

that's the way I wanna do it.

Speaker:

so be ready to find out new

Speaker:

about yourself because you might not, I mean, if you've doing this since you were

Speaker:

were 13,

Speaker:

15, especially for women, 'cause that's actually even earlier than that, that's

Speaker:

when we tend to assimilate into groups because girls tend to be more sensitive

Speaker:

social pressures than, boys are.

Speaker:

And, whole nother story

Speaker:

don't identify as either, because there's a, there's a whole beast there about

Speaker:

assimilation to norms when you don't as but people who do not identify as male,

Speaker:

put that way,

Speaker:

tend to to the

Speaker:

in their life where they start looking into either neurodivergence or

Speaker:

a diagnosis or even of just decide like.

Speaker:

don't like the way that their life is going and, the way they taught to

Speaker:

act and engage with people, and they want to find

Speaker:

they actually are in those things.

Speaker:

Sometimes

Speaker:

see this as of You see it when people get out bad relationships.

Speaker:

You see it when people move from one environment another and have to

Speaker:

start figuring out who are and how

Speaker:

are.

Speaker:

and so about listening

Speaker:

your body, which may have never done before, your brain, anxiety,

Speaker:

your sensory overload, and going

Speaker:

there.

Speaker:

there.

Speaker:

Thanks for being here guys.

Speaker:

Have a good day.

Speaker:

Love you meeting

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube