I have played the performance review game for my entire career. And I have been playing it wrong.
Not wrong in the obvious way — I wasn’t making things up or padding my resume. I was doing something that felt like humility and was actually closer to inaccuracy: describing real, significant work in the smallest possible terms, handing my manager a vague document, and then wondering why I didn’t feel seen.
This episode is about the game underneath the game. Because most of us think performance reviews are a documentation exercise — write down what you did, your manager writes down what they thought you did, everyone signs off, and you move on. That’s the surface layer. What’s actually happening is that your manager is taking your self-evaluation into a room full of other managers and using it as a brief to advocate for you. Or not.
The calibration room you don’t know about
In most organizations, managers sit together and compare their teams. Not résumés — narratives. Whoever’s story is clearest and most specific gives their manager the most to work with. Vague doesn’t win in that room. And if you handed your manager something weak, they might know your work was excellent, but if you can’t describe it clearly, they probably can’t either.
The Midwest humility problem
I grew up in a culture where you let your work speak for itself, you deflect compliments, and you give away credit even when it cost you. None of that is wrong as a value. But the performance review system was designed for people who know how to make a direct case for themselves. When your cultural wiring says stay small and the system rewards people who speak up, you lose ground to people who simply know the rules better.
Humility vs. inaccuracy
This is the reframe that actually helped me. Humility says: “I know I didn’t do this alone. I know I have more to learn.” Inaccuracy says: “I barely did anything.” Those are not the same statement. Most of us struggling with self-reviews aren’t exaggerating — we’re under-articulating. We know what we did. We just describe it in the smallest terms possible because anything bigger feels uncomfortable.
Four things you can do right now
One: understand the system — your review is a brief for your manager, write it that way. Two: separate accuracy from boasting — before you soften a sentence, ask yourself if it’s true. If yes, leave it alone. Three: find a translator — ask a friend, colleague, or AI to read your draft and push back where you’ve gone small. Four: keep an evidence file year-round — not a brag file, an evidence file — so you’re not reconstructing a year from memory at the worst possible time.
Your small step
Take one thing you accomplished recently — at work, at home, anywhere — and describe it out loud to yourself. Notice how you frame it. If a colleague described the same accomplishment, would you think they were bragging? Probably not. So why does it feel different when it’s you?
That discomfort is information. Pay attention to it.
Jill’s Links
http://jillfromthenorthwoods.com
https://www.youtube.com/@startwithsmallsteps
https://www.buymeacoffee.com/startwithsmallsteps
https://twitter.com/schmern
Email the podcast at [email protected]
By choosing to watch this video or listen to this podcast, you acknowledge that you are doing so of your own free will. The content shared here reflects personal experiences and opinions and is intended for informational and inspirational purposes only. I am not a licensed therapist, life coach, or mental health professional. Any habits, strategies, or suggestions offered should not be considered a substitute for professional medical, psychological, or counseling advice. Results vary — small steps look different for everyone. You are solely responsible for any decisions or actions you take based on this content.
