Artwork for podcast Vertical Farming Podcast: CEOs & Founders in AgTech and CEA
S1E4: 004 Henry Gordon Smith - Exploring the Socioeconomic Divide in Agriculture
Episode 4 • 10th June 2020 • Vertical Farming Podcast: CEOs & Founders in AgTech and CEA • iGrowNews
00:00:00 00:54:06

Share Episode

Shownotes

Henry Gordon Smith is a global AgTech leader, speaker and founder of Agritecture, a global leader in urban agriculture consulting services. Join Harry Duran, host of Vertical Farming Podcast, as he and Henry discuss the business model of vertical farming and urban agriculture. They expound on the racial and socioeconomic divide within agriculture as well as the ongoing ‘food apartheid.’ Finally, Henry speaks to upcoming events and projects he and his organization are working towards.

Special thanks to our Season 1 Sponsor

IGS – https://intelligentgrowthsolutions.com/


Key Takeaways



  • 00:01 – Henry shares his origin story and how he originally became interested in vertical farming and podcasting


  • 07:52 – The biggest challenges Henry has faced as an entrepreneur and how investments have shaped the vertical farming business model


  • 13:04 – Complex questions about vertical farming that Henry is seeking answers to


  • 20:23 – Henry shares his definition of vertical farming and solutions he suggests for the industry


  • 29:13 – Henry’s speaks to the mission of his company Agritecture, and some of its offerings


  • 36:15 – Henry’s unique perspective on race, the ‘food apartheid’ and urban agriculture


  • 42:49 – Upcoming vents Henry is launching with Agritecture


  • 45:29 – Henry expounds on what excites him about the future of vertical farming and AgTech in general


  • 50:25 – Where listeners can follow Henry

Tweetables


“As I was exploring my interest in doing business solutions to sustainability challenges, I created three blogs to kind of test the market and to see what people responded to.” (03:38)


“I’m not about hype. I’m happy to encourage and talk about the benefits of urban agriculture and vertical farming, but I really want to talk about the complex questions.” (12:49)


“My definition is really about three dimensional farming. It could be one floor, it could be a container, it could be a basement. It’s really about saying, ‘Ok, when we think three dimensionally about agriculture and the potential to photosynthesize plants using LEDs, what could we do and what could we do with this space?’” (22:25)


“We have the third urban agriculture director in the United States that was just put into place in [Washington] D.C., to join Atlanta and Philadelphia. That’s really exciting…I’m really excited to see how policy accelerates the industry and starts to structure it a little bit.” (48:00)


Links Mentioned:


Henry’s LinkedIn


Agritecture


Agritecture Designer


Agritecture Event Link


Henry’s Instagram – @theagritect


Henry’s Twitter – @TheAgritect


Books Mentioned:


The Vertical The Vertical Farm: Feeding the World in the 21st Century - Dr. Dickson Despommier


Intelligent Growth Solutions


Website | Twitter | YouTube

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Mentioned in this episode:

2025 Precision Ag Report by iGrowNews

2025 Precision Ag Report

2025 Precision Ag Report by iGrowNews

2025 Precision Ag Report

Transcripts

Speaker:

$680 million poured into precision ag last year.

Speaker:

Autonomous weeding robots dominated, and John Deere made 2 acquisitions in 3

Speaker:

months. A food company, not an equipment maker, bought a

Speaker:

robotics startup to protect its own supply chain. The deals are

Speaker:

accelerating, the money is moving, and the winners are already separating from the

Speaker:

pack. If you're investing, building, or buying in this space,

Speaker:

you need the full picture before your competitors get it. The 2025

Speaker:

Precision Agriculture Intelligence Report from iGrow News is now

Speaker:

available. Get your copy today at

Speaker:

igrownews.com/precision. Special thanks to

Speaker:

our title sponsor this season, IGS. Founded in

Speaker:

2013, IGS develops Industry 4.0 solutions in the

Speaker:

global agtech and commercial lighting markets. As an industry innovator,

Speaker:

they make revolutionary controlled environment growth products. For more information,

Speaker:

visit intelligentgrowthsolutions.com. We have a model

Speaker:

in society, there's a lot of pressure to grow at astronomical speeds, and I had

Speaker:

to make a decision early on about what kind of entrepreneur I wanted to be

Speaker:

and what kind of business I wanted to build. Welcome to the Vertical Farming

Speaker:

Podcast, weekly conversations with fascinating CEOs,

Speaker:

founders, and agtech visionaries. Join us every week

Speaker:

as we dive deep into the world of vertical farming with your

Speaker:

host, Harry Duran. So, Henry Gordon-Smith

Speaker:

of Agritecture, thank you for joining us on the Vertical Farming Podcast.

Speaker:

Thank you so much for having me. So, what's fun here is that we're both

Speaker:

fellow podcasters, so maybe we'll start there. When

Speaker:

did the podcasting Yeah, I kept getting questions from

Speaker:

our blog audience, when are you starting a podcast? And then we

Speaker:

went internally about 6 months ago and started brainstorming what we could do to

Speaker:

contribute, and we decided to pick a format which is really focused on

Speaker:

specific cities. We wanted to kind of complement the other podcasts out there,

Speaker:

and we wanted to showcase how agriculture thinks about local food and urban

Speaker:

agriculture, specifically, you know, what data is going to make it work or not, right?

Speaker:

What's the climate? What's the demand? what are the challenges that various

Speaker:

urban farmers are facing in cities. So our podcast, Locally Grown In, we do one

Speaker:

episode a month, so, you know, not crazy active. We try to do

Speaker:

really cool interviews and we focus on a city at a time. So it's Locally

Speaker:

Grown In Dubai, Locally Grown In Miami, and we're really

Speaker:

excited to kind of spread and do every city in the world. Yeah, I've been

Speaker:

trying to get caught up. I'm up to New York City now, which is near

Speaker:

and dear to me because I grew up in New York. I grew up in

Speaker:

Yonkers, just outside, and I'm And then I've lived in LA and

Speaker:

I'm currently in Minneapolis. So I've basically got all

Speaker:

parts of the country covered. So we'll dive a little bit deeper in the podcast,

Speaker:

but maybe for the benefits of folks, I don't know that there's many who haven't

Speaker:

heard of you, but can you tell folks a little bit of your background and

Speaker:

how you ended up in agtech? Sure. So I grew up

Speaker:

around the world. I had the privilege of being born in Hong Kong and growing

Speaker:

up in Tokyo, Germany, the Czech Republic, and I graduated high school in Russia.

Speaker:

I'm a very global citizen from birth, and, you

Speaker:

know, that really kind of created this really exciting interest in big cities

Speaker:

and what big cities could do. I always wanted to be an architect, and so

Speaker:

I started exploring a little bit about how cities could respond to climate change in

Speaker:

my undergraduate degree. And in that process, I found there was a really big gap

Speaker:

around the knowledge of urban agriculture. People were thinking— this was back

Speaker:

2010, 2011— people were thinking about urban agriculture just as community

Speaker:

gardens and maybe rooftop farms. But there's so many ways to do this, and I

Speaker:

was really excited about the diversity of them, and I really wanted to share, you

Speaker:

know, the variety so that people involved in it— meaning entrepreneurs

Speaker:

that want to build them, or policymakers that want to encourage it, or architects that

Speaker:

want to design it— are really armed with, you know, the full

Speaker:

spectrum of what's possible. Because, you know, I don't want to repeat the same mistakes

Speaker:

of the past where we just kind of create monoculture and we say

Speaker:

there's one way to do this. There's actually so many different ways to do this

Speaker:

in agriculture, and really our mission at agriculture is to

Speaker:

educate and inform and accelerate low-carbon solutions to

Speaker:

localization of food. So the blog was really about that, and then essentially my

Speaker:

audience started requesting consulting services from me, and I started getting referrals

Speaker:

from people that were saying, oh, somebody has a question, you know, can you answer

Speaker:

it? And no one was providing a consulting service that was independent of selling

Speaker:

equipment. So I said, well, there's an interesting opportunity here. You know, people need

Speaker:

to get technology-agnostic advising. The decision as to do greenhouse

Speaker:

or vertical is a very important first decision, or soil is a very important

Speaker:

first decision. How can you do that if you're not open to all of the

Speaker:

technologies available? So we created a methodology for that, and we've been

Speaker:

really accelerating really, really cool urban farms around the world.

Speaker:

And to date, we've consulted on over 110 projects in 26 countries.

Speaker:

So we've really fomented our place as the leading urban agriculture consulting firm, and

Speaker:

it's been very, very exciting. And I'm proud of my team for being able to

Speaker:

respond to this niche and this very important issue. When did this

Speaker:

become a passion of yours? Because you said you started

Speaker:

the blog, but like, can you talk a little bit about just— and you talked

Speaker:

about AgriTechture's mission. When did this become your mission? Yeah, you

Speaker:

know, as I was exploring my interest in doing business

Speaker:

solutions to sustainability challenges, I created 3 blogs

Speaker:

to kind of test the market and to see what people responded to and also

Speaker:

what I cared about. As an entrepreneur, it's very important you are passionate about what

Speaker:

you do because You're working crazy hours. You have to inspire your team.

Speaker:

You have to inspire your investors. You have to inspire your customers. So, you know,

Speaker:

I had to find something that really fit with me. So I did one that

Speaker:

was called Technology Water, another one that was called Urban Layering, which was about new

Speaker:

density solutions for urban development, and then agriculture.

Speaker:

And agriculture just had an overwhelmingly positive response, and the traffic

Speaker:

grew, and the actual activity that people were doing related to the content

Speaker:

was really good. People were finding jobs through the blog and things like that. So

Speaker:

I kind of dropped the other 2 and focused on it. And I think the

Speaker:

passion really came from how urban agriculture embodies my passion

Speaker:

for cities, my interest in solving sustainability challenges, but also I'm a

Speaker:

wannabe architect. So by creating architecture, I get to do

Speaker:

architectural-type work without being an architect. And if you talk to

Speaker:

architects, most of them will say, don't be an architect, the hours are crazy, the

Speaker:

pay is low. So I kind of responded to a lot of that feedback and

Speaker:

went this route. I mean, honestly, before this, I thought I was going to be

Speaker:

a diplomat. I was very interested in policy and I was doing some policy work

Speaker:

related to climate change and migration, but it was just too slow. It wasn't enough

Speaker:

action. So I kind of came to the conclusion that basically

Speaker:

through these requests that, you know, yeah, I think I would be a really good

Speaker:

consultant because I love to help solve people's specific problems. I love

Speaker:

project-based work. I want a global practice. And

Speaker:

so that really fit well with that passion. And, and I just get so excited

Speaker:

when I see our clients take their ideas to reality. I get so excited when

Speaker:

I get to visit farms and report on the great work they're doing. I get

Speaker:

really excited to do podcasts like this and share ideas. So, you know, 10 years

Speaker:

in, I'm still as passionate as ever for this topic. I mean, I really, really

Speaker:

believe that urban agriculture isn't just about growing some food in the city and

Speaker:

creating some jobs. I think it's really about unlocking sustainable urban

Speaker:

development. You know, anyone listening can ask themselves this question:

Speaker:

what is an emerging technology that embraces the food, water, energy,

Speaker:

and waste nexus better than urban agriculture? Solar panels hit one part of it,

Speaker:

biodigesters hit another part of it, you know, biking and rainwater

Speaker:

catchment hit another part of it, but urban agriculture brings that all together.

Speaker:

And so imagine a future where we have people in cities asking

Speaker:

those questions and developing businesses around that. They're going to unlock a

Speaker:

lot of other things we need to figure out to develop our cities sustainably to

Speaker:

be resilient to climate change. And that's the bottom line for me. That's why I'm

Speaker:

so passionate about this topic. Do you have a consulting background when you started

Speaker:

this? No, I didn't. I mean, I did. I had a blogging

Speaker:

background, right? So I was a blogger. I was recruited to be a blogger for

Speaker:

my university, and then I won a competition with Royal

Speaker:

Bank of Canada to be a video blogger for them for a while. And then

Speaker:

I started doing some freelance consulting for people who were self-publishing books and needed

Speaker:

to do that. And I was an executive assistant to an entrepreneur that was building

Speaker:

a sustainability brand, and I was doing their media strategy. So I started

Speaker:

learning how to market my brand and sell

Speaker:

myself individually and doing freelance work. And that was really the the baseline for

Speaker:

the consulting. But my mom is a talented consultant in the areas of HR,

Speaker:

diversity, and emotional intelligence. So I got a little bit of

Speaker:

advice from her too. It sounds like those skill

Speaker:

sets would come in handy as you start having these sessions with your clients,

Speaker:

especially that emotional intelligence and people getting excited about what they're trying to do and

Speaker:

you helping manage expectations about what's actually possible. That's exactly my

Speaker:

job. So a lot of, you know, I've got a really great team including horticulturalists,

Speaker:

agronomists, agriculture engineers, sustainability managers, you know,

Speaker:

really across the spectrum to provide interdisciplinary services to our clients. But a

Speaker:

lot of what I do is the business development and, hey, tell me your idea.

Speaker:

I'll tell you in a few minutes what you should change about that idea

Speaker:

and how you can make it more realistic. And yeah, you absolutely want to be

Speaker:

sensitive to that because there's really amazing people coming into the space from

Speaker:

software, technology, finance backgrounds, and they have a lot of

Speaker:

areas of skills that I don't have. So I have to really match their

Speaker:

abilities with our abilities. and make sure that we're getting to a better result. So,

Speaker:

you know, I do a lot of that part of it. And I think also,

Speaker:

you know, you need emotional intelligence in any leadership position, you know, with my

Speaker:

team and with my clients throughout that process. So, thanks, Mom.

Speaker:

As an entrepreneur, I'm just curious, what's been the biggest challenge with

Speaker:

growing the company? Well, you know, I think the

Speaker:

biggest challenge is growth itself. You know, we have a model in society

Speaker:

in the Elon Musk era and you know, all of these things with crazy

Speaker:

rapid growth, the Theranos stuff. And so there's a lot of pressure to grow

Speaker:

at astronomical speeds. And I had to make a decision early on about what kind

Speaker:

of entrepreneur I wanted to be and what kind of business I wanted to build.

Speaker:

Do I want to build, you know, an enormous global IPO-style

Speaker:

business? Do I want to build a business that's just about me that maybe has,

Speaker:

you know, a lot more flexibility? Or do I want something in between where I

Speaker:

have a really strong company culture, a global brand, and we can

Speaker:

be profitable. And that's really what I selected. So I selected to

Speaker:

develop a really tight and dynamic firm with a really strong

Speaker:

culture. Probably my favorite part of my job is, in addition to working with our

Speaker:

clients on their ideas, is creating that company culture and maintaining it.

Speaker:

So I think I took a really deep look into myself about what kind of

Speaker:

business I wanted to run and what was going to make me happy on a

Speaker:

daily basis. And part of that is just doing work to try and change and

Speaker:

improve the world. But I think also the day-to-day of working with a global

Speaker:

and smallish team is what I really like. So the greatest challenge I would

Speaker:

say is how do we take the responsibility

Speaker:

to our employees, the business, and our investors towards

Speaker:

growth and balance that with our values and our culture? And I

Speaker:

think it's really a constant discussion that I have with my fellow directors at the

Speaker:

company. And thankfully, we have early investors that are really

Speaker:

passionate about the topic with us and have that long-term vision. So I've had to

Speaker:

make some really good choices about team, really important choices about investors,

Speaker:

And I think, you know, that's always the challenge. Every year we have higher growth

Speaker:

numbers than the last year, and that's how a business should be run. And I

Speaker:

believe that a business can't be sustainable without being profitable, so you have

Speaker:

to have a growth model in there. So I think that's probably the greatest challenge,

Speaker:

but we're handling it, but it's a challenge. You mentioned the investing, and

Speaker:

obviously the amount of money that's coming in has been really interesting, and it's probably

Speaker:

changed dramatically since when you got started as well. When you look at what's happening

Speaker:

with, like, money coming into Plenty and the AeroFarms and the Bowerys of

Speaker:

the world, do you see that also? Do you see, like, an uptick Oh,

Speaker:

definitely. There's been uptake. I mean, when I started the blog, there were no

Speaker:

commercial vertical farms in North America that were advertised and marketed that way.

Speaker:

There was no major VC money coming into the space. So I've seen dramatic

Speaker:

changes, I would say, in the past 5 years. Honestly, the first 5 years of

Speaker:

me exploring this and blogging about it was like a nerdy kid in his

Speaker:

dorm room and, you know, whatever, 1,000 visitors a month kind

Speaker:

of thing, you know. And, and, and so, but as that interest grew,

Speaker:

And as people read Dickson's book, Dickson Despommiers, author of The

Speaker:

Vertical Farm, and started saying, oh, I'm going to build a farm too, and people

Speaker:

started making mistakes, and people started learning from those mistakes, and overall,

Speaker:

the understanding of vertical farming, for example, has been more democratized, in part by

Speaker:

our blog, but also by other players, and even those that have not succeeded.

Speaker:

So people kind of know the basics now more than before, and so that

Speaker:

elevates the whole discussion, and that elevates the kind of investment, and and the proof

Speaker:

of concepts that exist there. So, you know, AgFunder has some really good reports

Speaker:

on the growth in this space. But yeah, we're seeing, you know, over

Speaker:

100% every year increase in the amount of investment in the space. I mean, I

Speaker:

think it was 340% year over year, 2017 to

Speaker:

2018, you know, and a lot of the size of those are getting bigger into

Speaker:

the $100 million, you know, levels. So what do I think about that? I mean,

Speaker:

I think it's obviously very exciting. It's great that there is money going

Speaker:

into the space, because as a new technology, you know, we need to get the

Speaker:

cost down, and we need people who are pioneers and experimenting with that.

Speaker:

And that's what a lot of these, these companies are doing, is they're developing new

Speaker:

data solutions, automation solutions, getting consumers excited about this

Speaker:

product and aware of this product, getting policymakers. So it's all kind of a

Speaker:

really great thing to solve, solve, solve the greater challenge at hand that I

Speaker:

think we're all aware of. But part of my concern is some of this

Speaker:

investment is VC folk, VC, VC type investment. And so with my

Speaker:

detailed understanding of how these operations work, I

Speaker:

get concerned about that in some ways because the rapid growth that's expected of

Speaker:

them, you know, those kinds of funds, is really not really in

Speaker:

alignment with the vertical farming model, which is about raise a

Speaker:

good chunk of money, like let's say at least $500,000, build a pilot,

Speaker:

prove that you can make that work, raise more money, grow from there. But you've

Speaker:

got to do a lot of things. You've got to get consumers excited about the

Speaker:

product. You've got to advance technology. You've got to manage labor. You've got to manage

Speaker:

distribution. You've got to build an amazing brand that's going to be the winning one.

Speaker:

All of that takes a lot of time. It's not, it's not an app. It's,

Speaker:

it's not a software company, you know. So you have to do all of that

Speaker:

plus have investors that are like, get that this is so new and

Speaker:

so pioneering that they're going to be patient because it's inevitable that you're going to

Speaker:

make mistakes. It's inevitable that your build deadlines are going to be late. It's inevitable

Speaker:

that you're going to have costs that were higher than you expected. So it's

Speaker:

really interesting to see You know, what kind of investment's coming in, but I also

Speaker:

want to be careful because I think some of that investment pushes the hype story

Speaker:

around vertical farming, and I'm not about hype. I'm happy to

Speaker:

encourage and talk about the benefits of urban agriculture and vertical farming,

Speaker:

but I really want to talk about the complex questions, you know, and I think

Speaker:

that some of this investment drives more hype, and that's not

Speaker:

necessarily a good thing. What are some of those more complex questions

Speaker:

that you're looking to get answered? Yeah, I think some of the complex questions are,

Speaker:

can vertical farming meaningfully impact food security, right? When we talk

Speaker:

about feeding people, what is the difference between feeding people and producing

Speaker:

salad greens? I have nothing against vertical farming, obviously,

Speaker:

but I do want to talk about, again, going back to these models and the

Speaker:

complexity we're trying to communicate, that there are many tools in the toolbox to

Speaker:

solve problem X, aka food security. Vertical

Speaker:

farming is one of them. Is it the best one? Maybe, in some

Speaker:

climates. For example, if you look at northern climates, in the northern part of Canada,

Speaker:

they have a lot of obesity issues. They have a lot of issues with vitamin

Speaker:

deficiencies because they import all of the food. Vertical farms could

Speaker:

provide a really interesting nutritional solution to that that could

Speaker:

actually make economic sense. So that's great. That's a specific

Speaker:

solution. But in the end, people need calories.

Speaker:

People need a diverse set of nutrients, and vertical farming today

Speaker:

doesn't provide that. a specific solution to a specific

Speaker:

problem in some places. I think another complex question is,

Speaker:

are vertical farms really green? I mean, are they really good for the environment?

Speaker:

You've got a lot of equipment. I studied sustainability management at Columbia, and one

Speaker:

of the things we looked at a lot was embodied energy. What is the carbon

Speaker:

footprint of all of that equipment? And I think that, you know, vertical farming—

Speaker:

one of the complex and difficult discussions is vertical farming gets away with being

Speaker:

seen as green because it saves a ton of water, saves a ton of space,

Speaker:

uses no pesticides. You've got this list of all these benefits that kind of makes

Speaker:

the embodied energy of the construction and also the carbon

Speaker:

footprint from the lights if the energy is sourced from, you know, a

Speaker:

carbon-intensive energy source. So in America, most of our energy, or a

Speaker:

lot of energy today depending on where you are, comes from coal. So if you're

Speaker:

taking coal and powering a farm that's growing salads, are you really

Speaker:

green? And I think life cycle analysis is lacking in this space

Speaker:

to really look at that. There's a lot of problems with traditional agriculture growing lettuce,

Speaker:

right? So I think there are cases where vertical farming

Speaker:

can be more carbon competitive from a sustainability

Speaker:

assessment, but I think that that needs to be defined pretty specifically. And

Speaker:

so that's, that's another one of the complex questions. Another one is around equity.

Speaker:

When you build farms that are very capital intensive, like vertical farms are, so

Speaker:

if this is urban agriculture, this is low tech, low investment, this is high tech,

Speaker:

high investment. Vertical farming is here, right? And automated

Speaker:

vertical farms are here, right? So the robot farms in the future. future. Will

Speaker:

there be a future where those farms are actually solving not food security, but

Speaker:

I'd say food access issues? For example, Atlanta has

Speaker:

25% of its population lives in food deserts. Will vertical farms solve that

Speaker:

problem if they're so expensive? I hope so, but let's have a

Speaker:

complex discussion about what they're doing to do that today and when and where

Speaker:

they could do that in the future. So those are some for you all to

Speaker:

think about. Yeah, it's helpful because I think a lot of people, when they

Speaker:

first introduced to the concept and the idea of it, it's really glamorous and it

Speaker:

is very futuristic, but it is really like a a lot of the phase— what

Speaker:

we call the phase 1. I interviewed Steven Pankhurst who did a really interesting

Speaker:

session, 3-part series on YouTube that talked about the viability of

Speaker:

these different— starting out with leafy greens. And then, I know you talked to the

Speaker:

Agricool folks doing strawberries now in Dubai. So, it's

Speaker:

interesting. So, it seems like there is a push. And I think there was just—

Speaker:

I just posted something today on Twitter about the bunched

Speaker:

tomatoes now as well, which is interesting. So, there's some interesting—

Speaker:

it's almost like adopting the crop to benefit the most from

Speaker:

something like a vertical farm environment? Well, you're absolutely right there. I'm not

Speaker:

saying— I think all of these solutions, these

Speaker:

challenges or critiques can be solved. And I think, again, it's about— I

Speaker:

don't know, I'm very proud of our methodology and how we approach that question at

Speaker:

the beginning. Like, what is the right— what is your problem that you're trying to

Speaker:

solve? And what is the right solution to match that problem? And I think, you

Speaker:

know, a lot of the companies in the space obviously have an incentive to say

Speaker:

their way is the best. Every time. And I think, I think

Speaker:

that's not where I'm at. You know, I prefer to take a step back. And

Speaker:

I think another part of what you mentioned that's really interesting is, is yes, right

Speaker:

now most of the— almost all of the seeds used in

Speaker:

vertical farms are seeds intended for field growing.

Speaker:

So, for example, I was meeting with Rijkswaterstaat recently. They're one of the biggest seed

Speaker:

companies, and they are breeding for indoor farming and want to be the

Speaker:

leader in this indoor farming kind of seed question. I think the

Speaker:

other piece is genetic engineering, which has huge, huge potentials to impact

Speaker:

vertical farming. Like you said, growing more dense tomatoes. I was at the University of

Speaker:

Guelph recently, and they've been able to breed a plum tree

Speaker:

that basically fruits like a tomato. So imagine kind of like that tomato you

Speaker:

saw in that picture, the article you're talking about. Imagine that, but with plums,

Speaker:

and it's constantly fruiting year-round. So they

Speaker:

showed it to me, and it kind of grows flat like a vine as opposed

Speaker:

to like a tree. So, it could work in controlled environments. They're

Speaker:

doing it for space because apparently there's something about

Speaker:

plums and bone density that they need for the astronauts. So, there's a huge

Speaker:

future for that, but again, that's a bit of a conflict with some of the

Speaker:

consumer ideas around GMOs. Does Europe want a bunch of

Speaker:

genetically engineered vertical farms growing food because it's more dense and more

Speaker:

efficient? Will they accept that? Will the Middle East accept that?

Speaker:

Maybe. Europe, probably not. The US, Maybe some places, maybe not.

Speaker:

So, you know, vertical farming has this thing where it's, you know, it needs to

Speaker:

be about integrating agriculture, not vertical farming, in

Speaker:

my opinion, because vertical farming is just one, one approach. I think when you take

Speaker:

a step back, you can be more open about, you know, solving that problem. Yeah,

Speaker:

it's funny because even this idea about GMOs, I was talking to

Speaker:

Louisa Burwood-Taylor from AgFunder about this, and just even the definition

Speaker:

and the education for the public about— there's different

Speaker:

types of genetically— even the word genetically modified could mean if you're

Speaker:

genetically modifying something so that it grows in a more

Speaker:

fruitful fashion for the environment, as opposed to like changing the inherent

Speaker:

nature of that, you know, which is the one that people have a problem with.

Speaker:

And I think that's going to be part of the challenge as well, because I

Speaker:

think there are going to be some benefits to, you know, quote unquote,

Speaker:

genetically modifying a crop so that it grows better in these

Speaker:

types of environments. Yeah, and I think genetic

Speaker:

modification, like you said, there's different kinds, and breeding versus different versus genetic

Speaker:

modification, and then there's also cellular biology and

Speaker:

that approach, which is kind of a next-level thing. Breeding

Speaker:

has been happening forever, pretty much, so consumers don't seem

Speaker:

to have a problem with that, and genetic modification is kind of just the next

Speaker:

step for that. There's levels of genetic modification, like are you taking animal

Speaker:

DNA and putting it into a plant, or are you just taking other plant

Speaker:

DNA. So, it's complicated in that way. And, I think a lot of consumers

Speaker:

or a lot of people even that are in agriculture approach me and they say,

Speaker:

you know what, vertical farming, it's just not natural, hydroponics is just not

Speaker:

natural. And, I like to say to them, I said, well, can you tell me

Speaker:

when was agriculture natural? It's always been

Speaker:

engineered unless we're going to just go around and gather. The minute we

Speaker:

started organizing rows of farms or started analyzing soil,

Speaker:

we said that engineering plays a role in agriculture. Yeah. So, to

Speaker:

draw a line in the sand and say, this is the end of man

Speaker:

using technology for agriculture, you know, there's no way we're going to feed

Speaker:

9 billion people with that. And so, we have some real

Speaker:

problems that we may need to make some compromises for. So, let's talk a

Speaker:

little bit about the actual definition, because we were chatting a bit in the pre-chat

Speaker:

about, you know, what is a vertical farm? So, and I know that

Speaker:

some of your colleagues, you have a friendly disagreement on what

Speaker:

that is, but when people come to you, right, what are you thinking of, and

Speaker:

what are the solutions you're presenting when comes to vertical farms? Because I know that

Speaker:

can cover things like container farms as well. Yeah, so, you know, this

Speaker:

discussion point really comes from a mentor of mine, Dr. Dickson Nopamee, author of The

Speaker:

Vertical Farm, who I'm sure will be on this podcast. And he's amazing, and I

Speaker:

respect him and adore him. And we, we worked together, and we, we

Speaker:

designed a vertical farm together. And I remember one of the conflicts we had was

Speaker:

I picked a site in the Bronx, and I was really curious

Speaker:

about the kind of urban planning part of it. So I wanted to find There's

Speaker:

no zoning for vertical farming or even agriculture in most cities. So I said, well,

Speaker:

what kind of zoning does a vertical farm fit into? And I settled on the

Speaker:

light manufacturing zoning based on its definition would be the easiest one to fit into.

Speaker:

So then I found 10 sites and I narrowed that down to one site that

Speaker:

I was going to choose for my canvas. And I worked with Dickson to design

Speaker:

for that. And, you know, Dickson Despommiers' book is about literally

Speaker:

skyscraper farms. I mean, these are skyscraper, you know,

Speaker:

beautiful ecosystems, really, you know, amazing futuristic stuff that

Speaker:

I'm a big fan of. But, you know, in reality, there are

Speaker:

constraints that happen. For example, your floor-to-area ratios that are

Speaker:

required for different building sites. So, you know, how far are you from the

Speaker:

curb after your first floor? How in-depth does your building need to be?

Speaker:

And that changes the actual area of your building. And that's how places

Speaker:

like New York and major cities plan their buildings. So the point I'm trying to

Speaker:

make was Dixon was like, make it taller, make it bigger. And I was like,

Speaker:

well, literally the site doesn't allow for that. And then that

Speaker:

kind of evolved into when my design was finished and fit my attempt to

Speaker:

fit code and zoning requirements. We then had this

Speaker:

discussion about what vertical farming is. And so he defines it as

Speaker:

basically farming that's stacked and is 2 floors or higher.

Speaker:

So moving towards the verticality of the structure is very important in

Speaker:

Dixon's definition. My definition is really about

Speaker:

3-dimensional farming, that it could be 1 floor. It could be a container, it

Speaker:

could be a basement. It's really about saying, okay, when we think

Speaker:

3-dimensionally about agriculture and the potential to photosynthesize

Speaker:

plants using LEDs, you know, what can we do and what could we do

Speaker:

with this space? And again, I think it's more of a planning architecture perspective because

Speaker:

there's plenty of lazy spaces in cities. There's different kind of areas you could fit

Speaker:

it into. Typically those farms are hydroponic, but they don't have to be. Typically

Speaker:

those farms are LED lit, but you could imagine You know, greenhouse structures that have

Speaker:

vertical use of space, I think that embraces vertical farming.

Speaker:

With that said, I didn't coin the term vertical farm. You know, Dickson was the

Speaker:

first public person to really go big on that. There were some vertical farms that

Speaker:

existed before, you know, Dickson wrote about that, so he gets

Speaker:

to define it really. But, but if you're asking me, I think it's about, again,

Speaker:

taking a step back, thinking 3-dimensionally, and how you can use existing technologies

Speaker:

to, to do 3D farming. Yeah, when you were

Speaker:

on the Atlanta episode, you were stressing the importance of keeping the farms

Speaker:

close to the energy source, which I thought was interesting as well. I love that

Speaker:

you're a mega fan of Locally Grown In. You've listened to multiple episodes. So Atlanta

Speaker:

was really cool. Yeah, so, you know, again, going to the

Speaker:

carbon footprint question, there are parts of the world that,

Speaker:

because of energy efficiency advancements in lighting and

Speaker:

various systems, they actually have excess energy on the grid. And they

Speaker:

sell that energy to other people, other states, other countries in some

Speaker:

cases, at a lower cost. And as energy moves across these

Speaker:

transmission lines, those transmission lines emit energy and they actually

Speaker:

lose that energy. So if, if you're Alabama and I'm

Speaker:

Georgia and I'm going to send you excess energy, I may lose 30% of the

Speaker:

energy along that way. That is a sustainability issue. So if we can

Speaker:

keep all 100% in Atlanta, in Georgia, and turn that

Speaker:

into edible product for consumers, that's basically taking free

Speaker:

energy on the grid and turning it into a product that

Speaker:

benefits the community. And I think that's very circular economy thinking.

Speaker:

And, and I think that that's a really exciting play for this, is what are

Speaker:

the regions where we can get free energy? I mean, another one is in New

Speaker:

York State and Pennsylvania. There are thousands— I think 3,000

Speaker:

was the estimate Cornell gave— where there's small natural

Speaker:

gas wells that are too small to make money off of, meaning to

Speaker:

build piping to send it to a refinery, but they also kind of create some

Speaker:

geological issues, so they burn it. So they're just burning gas at these

Speaker:

3,000 locations. What if we just put greenhouses on all of those locations?

Speaker:

Well, Cornell estimates— a researcher at Cornell estimates that we can grow all of the

Speaker:

Northeast's leafy greens with those greenhouses, and

Speaker:

30 to 40% of the energy for those greenhouses would be free. That's where I

Speaker:

get excited. And that's, and that's again why, for anyone listening, you have to take

Speaker:

a step back from vertical farming because that's— those are the opportunities where you get

Speaker:

the biggest wins. You know, nobody wants to fit a square within a triangle,

Speaker:

right? You remember that game when we were a kid with the little cubes? That's

Speaker:

what you're doing when you say vertical farming is the solution. I'm going to fit

Speaker:

it here and there. You take a step back and use design thinking. You mentioned

Speaker:

the circular energy because you talked about that on the Brussels episode, and that, that

Speaker:

seems to be the location where they're more

Speaker:

focused

Speaker:

Yeah, it's not

Speaker:

just energy, it's also water and waste. So what we're talking about is a circular

Speaker:

economy, is that, you know, cities and spaces have resource flows, they have inputs and

Speaker:

outputs. You as an individual have inputs and outputs. So, you know, how

Speaker:

can we make sure that the source of inputs for buildings and the outputs from

Speaker:

them, wastewater, etc., can be used for something else

Speaker:

instead of, you know, in New York, We produce trash and then we send it

Speaker:

to Ohio. How can we take some of that trash and make it something useful?

Speaker:

That's kind of circular economy thinking. And I think what Belgium and Brussels

Speaker:

shows is the power of culture

Speaker:

around what is sustainable and the role of leaders and

Speaker:

policies to drive that culture. So the EU has made circular economy a big

Speaker:

part of their initiatives. Europeans have a long history of being

Speaker:

particularly efficient with space. and particularly thoughtful about

Speaker:

the earth in ways that maybe North America hasn't because of the abundant

Speaker:

resources it had when it was colonized. So that culture can

Speaker:

drive the behavior of entrepreneurs. And what we see in Brussels is that

Speaker:

there was not one farm I visited that was like, yeah, we

Speaker:

just produce greens and then sell them. You know, it was like we— vertical

Speaker:

farms were capturing rainwater in Brussels, which I've never seen in the

Speaker:

United States. They were partnerships with mushroom farms nearby

Speaker:

to share. There was, you know, fish farms that are growing

Speaker:

indoor fish and then selling their waste to greenhouses in decoupled

Speaker:

aquaponic systems. And I was like, wow, within a week I've seen 10

Speaker:

examples, 20 examples of different farms, all with

Speaker:

different incentives. Like, some of them want to go big VC, some of them want

Speaker:

to be community-focused, some of them are restaurant-focused, and all of them

Speaker:

considered it. And that's because Brussels, the EU, and

Speaker:

Belgium have created even small, like you'll get $1,500

Speaker:

a year if you can prove you're doing something with circular economy, you know, or

Speaker:

you'll be on a list of circular economy initiatives and entrepreneurs

Speaker:

do it based on that. So I think it's cultural. I think it's leadership and

Speaker:

policy focus, but very cool and something I'd like to see more of here. Yeah,

Speaker:

I saw that Plenty in one of the blog posts was doing a bit of

Speaker:

research into figuring out like a fully compostable clamshell, right? Because that's one

Speaker:

of the like, like the hidden secrets of like all these greens is like all

Speaker:

this plastic we're generating. Have you heard of any companies that are making some inroads

Speaker:

there? Honestly, it's a really difficult challenge. I mean, they're all looking

Speaker:

at it. You know, you've got energy to also create those new packaging

Speaker:

products, and those methods can also have negative consequences. You know,

Speaker:

you have to gather the waste, you have to process the waste, you have to,

Speaker:

you know, maybe sometimes add some chemicals to it, you know. And then when

Speaker:

it's compostable, do consumers compost it properly? Do they understand

Speaker:

where to compost it? What's the speed at which it degrades relative to other food

Speaker:

products and compostable products? Right now, there is not a clear solution for

Speaker:

that problem, and it's a big problem. So whoever solves that one will be very

Speaker:

rich. Yeah, it sounds as alluding to our earlier topic of

Speaker:

VC money. I think if there's a company that's in that space with all these

Speaker:

folks, I think they'll get a lot of people's attention. Well, I mean, I like

Speaker:

Ecovative. They're a company in Brooklyn that does— they do mushroom

Speaker:

containers and packaging, but the costs are pretty extreme. When you think about

Speaker:

salad mix and those products kind of need to breathe in a different

Speaker:

way, and so the packaging is actually pretty refined. There's actually a lot of perforations

Speaker:

in the packaging to allow it to breathe. Nobody— when you go to the

Speaker:

store and you see a salad mix and it's so humid in the product you

Speaker:

can't see the product, that's a problem. And so a lot of these

Speaker:

companies, they obviously want to focus on making sure the consumer

Speaker:

likes the product and wants to buy it. Packaging is a huge part of that,

Speaker:

and the fact is that we want everything pretty, we want everything

Speaker:

convenient and clean, and those things tend to require

Speaker:

toxic chemicals. Can you talk a little bit about your process? I think in

Speaker:

one of your podcast interviews, you mentioned how you've collected so much data at

Speaker:

AgriTechture that you're now actually— I don't know if open sourcing is the right term,

Speaker:

but you're providing a lot of that data for people to use. And I think

Speaker:

if they've got ideas about a type of farm they want to grow and a

Speaker:

location, they can actually do a little bit of the the research using

Speaker:

some of the heavy lifting you guys have already done. Can you talk a little

Speaker:

bit about that? Yeah, so, you know, AGRITECTURE's mission is to

Speaker:

accelerate urban agriculture globally as a response to climate change for

Speaker:

adaptation. We want to empower anyone anywhere to get involved in

Speaker:

that. So we began that through the blog, Chapter One, where we

Speaker:

share free knowledge, and we continue that. So we have, you know, my talks, these

Speaker:

podcasts. I'm really trying to add value for free to anyone who's interested in

Speaker:

this space so that you can make a difference. So that's something we do, that's

Speaker:

something we continue. Chapter 2 is for those people that are really serious about building

Speaker:

farms and really want to build some of the best brands and the best

Speaker:

technologies and the best solutions. We've compiled an expert team to advise

Speaker:

on that for a consulting fee. But obviously, having done this for a minute now,

Speaker:

I've learned that there's a lot of people out there that are too early for

Speaker:

consulting, or they are just curious, but

Speaker:

genuinely curious. Maybe they're just earlier on their journey. Maybe they're in a region where

Speaker:

they can't afford a New York City consultant, and that's fine. That doesn't mean we

Speaker:

don't want to solve their problems. So what we've done is we've taken

Speaker:

our approach, which has really started from when I started the blog, which was as

Speaker:

I reported on companies, I built an archive about my observations.

Speaker:

You know, what was the amount of money they raised? What's their typical yield? How

Speaker:

many workers did they have? You know, nothing proprietary, but things that

Speaker:

really help me understand how they relate to each other. Again, going back to that

Speaker:

methodology. That archive then has been really refined and developed with

Speaker:

the horticulturalists I work with on my team and engineers and the economists.

Speaker:

So we have a really exciting database of models

Speaker:

that are viable for agriculture around the world. So what we decided to do

Speaker:

was to create a way for people to access those models. So

Speaker:

Agriculture Designer, which is launching very soon, it's right now being tested in

Speaker:

beta. It's been built, at least the version, the beta version of it. It has

Speaker:

2 parts to it. One is a free concept development tool for anyone who

Speaker:

wants to think about an urban farm or urban garden. You can enter in your

Speaker:

budget, you can enter in if you're interested in greenhouse or vertical or soil, you

Speaker:

can enter in how big your team is, you can enter in your location, you

Speaker:

can enter in what crops you're curious about, you can enter in your goal. Do

Speaker:

you want a for-profit farm? Do you want a community-focused farm? And after you enter

Speaker:

that information, for free you're going to get a vision report, which is a report

Speaker:

of your idea on one paper. So you can kind of have like, this is

Speaker:

my idea, and you can share this with people. You're going to get a project

Speaker:

timeline, a typical timeline for a project of your scale and the inputs you gave.

Speaker:

So you can think about what is it going to take from you and who

Speaker:

might you want to join your team to do this. And you're going to get

Speaker:

a list of 3 different farms based on our algorithm that are relevant

Speaker:

to your inputs. And so anyone anywhere will be able to do that for free.

Speaker:

If you want to go further with your idea, let's say you talk to your

Speaker:

friend and you want to be co-founders and you say, you know, we should start

Speaker:

drafting a business plan. You can subscribe and you can become,

Speaker:

you know, we have different subscription levels, but essentially the subscription is going to be

Speaker:

based around a set period of time where you can build an unlimited number of

Speaker:

projects. Because again, we want you to practice that methodology of observing

Speaker:

data and experimenting and finding your right fit. And basically you can build 10-year

Speaker:

economic models. So you can access our database by

Speaker:

inputting again more details about your market, specific pricing for your

Speaker:

products that you do. We're going to encourage you to do market research. And go

Speaker:

through our methodology online, independent of a consultant. And

Speaker:

what you're going to get in the end is what's your payback, what's your yield,

Speaker:

what's your overall CapEx, how much of your OpEx is going towards

Speaker:

seeds, for example. And you're going to really know what it's going to take from

Speaker:

you to develop that business. And we're going to invite you to keep going and

Speaker:

build unlimited projects until you get to your best version. And that's going to hopefully

Speaker:

make you better prepared for 2 things. One, going out on your own and building

Speaker:

your farm. Or 2, if you do want to talk to us, you're going to

Speaker:

be better prepared and you'll be able to have a lower-cost engagement with us because

Speaker:

you've already done your homework. So we're allowing you to do that homework in a

Speaker:

very low-cost way. In addition to that thing, we've also created

Speaker:

classes. So we've taken our commercial urban farming classes and put them online. So you're

Speaker:

not just on your own experimenting with this. We're going to teach you the different

Speaker:

types of urban farms. We're going to teach you the main technologies that will make

Speaker:

or break your business. We're going to teach you how do you do market research

Speaker:

and how do you think about finding your customer. We're gonna teach you about

Speaker:

aquaponics and organic certification. So, all of that is gonna be online, and

Speaker:

combined, I think that's really gonna democratize some of the basic knowledge.

Speaker:

And again, talking about those complex questions, I think it's gonna elevate the

Speaker:

discussion globally to get us to a more sophisticated level of discussion about

Speaker:

vertical farming and greenhouses. That sounds amazing, and I'm excited about the

Speaker:

beta as well, because I've been thinking about this idea for something in New Orleans.

Speaker:

My brother lives there, and I've been kind of like getting his feedback on

Speaker:

the the market there. He actually works in food distribution. So yeah, when you talk

Speaker:

about the last mile, like, like, that's part of the challenges, I'm sure. Like, it's

Speaker:

great, you know, you have the planning, you're gonna, you have to make it, you

Speaker:

know how you're gonna harvest it and the model you're gonna use. But and then

Speaker:

you have to actually like make the connections to like the rest if you're doing

Speaker:

a smaller, like the restaurants and the chefs. And, you know, I wonder, would the

Speaker:

courses cover some of that from a marketing perspective? Or is that something that, you

Speaker:

know, that's a bit more challenging? Totally. So, so the way the courses are broken

Speaker:

out is we kind of talk about specific models. So for example, if you're looking

Speaker:

to do a farm one style model, which is like a boutique, you know, chef

Speaker:

garden farm, we talk to you about what you should expect from your sales perspective.

Speaker:

You know, like, you're going to be spending a lot of time just talking to

Speaker:

chefs and building a cool brand and doing collaborations. And if you're

Speaker:

excited about that, go for that model, right? Or create your own version of that,

Speaker:

of that idea. If you are really excited about, you know, signing

Speaker:

2-year deals with Kroger to buy your product at, you know, a million pounds a

Speaker:

year, okay, you need to go towards the big warehouse vertical farming model. If you're

Speaker:

excited about having customers come to you and have an experience and

Speaker:

buy products on site and do a market, that's another option. So

Speaker:

we're never going to tell people this is— I mean, if we're consulting

Speaker:

you and we get to the conclusion, we'll tell you. We're never going to tell

Speaker:

people like, this is what you should do right away. Instead, we want to arm

Speaker:

people with the tools and the methods to help them make their own

Speaker:

conclusion, because that's what's going to make them really good entrepreneurs. They have to really

Speaker:

be excited about their decision and excited about the work they're going to do on

Speaker:

a day-to-day basis. And a big part of that is the marketing. So I'm so

Speaker:

glad you're excited about it because I am so excited about this

Speaker:

product. I'm, you know, I'm on the edge of my seat to get it out

Speaker:

there and share with people. Yeah, if there's a beta or something, I'd love to

Speaker:

be able to test it because it's just— I'm a bit of a systems,

Speaker:

like, kind of nerd and just like geeking out on systems and I love stats

Speaker:

and I used to manage like a customer service reporting team back in the day.

Speaker:

So I love like spreadsheets. Let's put it that way. Yeah, well,

Speaker:

we're working through some bugs. It's being tested by beta users right now.

Speaker:

If you look, if you shoot me an email and And we'll see what we

Speaker:

can do. But if anybody here is interested in the product, it's called Agriculture

Speaker:

Designer. You can learn about it a bit more at agriculture.com/designer,

Speaker:

and you can actually sign up to be notified once it goes public or as

Speaker:

we release more beta users. So, take a look, and we'd love to

Speaker:

see what you think. Yeah, we'll make sure we get all those links in the

Speaker:

show notes. One thing that's interesting, because I'm Latino, I was born in El Salvador,

Speaker:

so this idea of minority-owned businesses, entrepreneurial culture, building

Speaker:

up that And you sort of touched on it a little bit in your episode

Speaker:

with Maurice, and you mentioned how you were in one of these sessions and you

Speaker:

were in like a community forum. Can you talk a little bit about what happened?

Speaker:

Because I don't want to spoil it. I'd rather have you tell it because I

Speaker:

thought it was fascinating and your reaction to it. Yeah, I'm happy

Speaker:

to. It's a bit, it's a bit sensitive, so I want to talk about it

Speaker:

in the right way. I'm a white man. I grew up in an upper middle

Speaker:

class family, so I have a lot of privilege. And I think growing

Speaker:

up internationally, I was pretty unaware of race

Speaker:

issues because I grew up in international schools where I had people from

Speaker:

all over the world that were both my teachers and my fellow colleagues. With that

Speaker:

said, I probably didn't interact with other wealth categories and

Speaker:

didn't get the connection between race and wealth gaps. Now, when

Speaker:

you are working in urban agriculture, you have to understand that there,

Speaker:

as Karen Washington says and calls it, credit to her, there's a

Speaker:

food apartheid. There have been decisions made to

Speaker:

elevate certain populations and exclude other populations, and

Speaker:

food is one of the many representations of that kind of

Speaker:

apartheid, of that division. So even the

Speaker:

idea of a food desert as a name from USDA is considered by many as

Speaker:

very disrespectful and almost racist because

Speaker:

it's talking about these places that are deserts, even though

Speaker:

a lot of people who are making that definition were part of the problem. So

Speaker:

when I come in and I'm a white male and I'm like,

Speaker:

asked by the city of Brooklyn, the Brooklyn Borough President's Office asked me

Speaker:

to compile a list of individuals to invite and to have a roundtable

Speaker:

about the future of urban agriculture and resiliency. And I was honored

Speaker:

by that. It was, it was 5 years ago, so it was pretty early on.

Speaker:

And I sent invitations out to women and men and the people

Speaker:

I had known. Others were invited too. So, you know, we had pretty good

Speaker:

representation at that meeting, but there's always people that are excluded and some of those

Speaker:

people are on the ground. They don't have time. They don't have the financial

Speaker:

means to maybe get places. Maybe they don't have the same abilities with technology

Speaker:

to respond to certain invitations. So some people are excluded. And so

Speaker:

I kind of became a representative of this group in some ways and was leading

Speaker:

it and answering questions for it. And in that sense, I was put in a

Speaker:

position to think about the future of urban agriculture in New York City,

Speaker:

but I don't represent a lot of the populations that need that. And so

Speaker:

As I was speaking at some of these events, in one particular one,

Speaker:

several people of color were extremely aggressive to me

Speaker:

about the fact that I was proposing ideas

Speaker:

for their food security and their community's food security. Things like, what

Speaker:

right do you have? Or, you're co-opting urban agriculture, which was a

Speaker:

very community kind of guerrilla grassroots

Speaker:

history to it. I was called a white biotech farmer. You know, to

Speaker:

my face. I'm neither a farmer and I don't work in biotech,

Speaker:

right? So these were difficult things for me. I was interrupted several

Speaker:

times and said, you know, someone said to me, you know, I know I interrupted

Speaker:

you several times, but you know what, I've been interrupted by white men my whole

Speaker:

life, so I'm not going to apologize. So things that were shocking

Speaker:

for me because I didn't grow up in the United States. I sound

Speaker:

American, but I'm not American, so I don't understand a lot of those race issues.

Speaker:

And previously, as I mentioned, I grew up in a very international background and a

Speaker:

privileged background, so I didn't get to experience that. I took a breath and I

Speaker:

let it happen, and I kind of dealt with my

Speaker:

whatever trauma from that afterwards individually, because I don't understand, but I

Speaker:

respect that they're standing up for themselves. I empathize as much as

Speaker:

I can. And the relationship with those individuals has improved since.

Speaker:

There's no problems. And I've learned a lot about how to be more sensitive to

Speaker:

that. But I guess as somebody who's creative and is like, hey, let's solve this

Speaker:

problem and let's do this, I mean, I can be very naive about trying to

Speaker:

solve communities' problems that don't want my help or don't,

Speaker:

you know, there's a lot of trust that needs to be built to do that,

Speaker:

even if I have a lot to offer. And that was— that's really hard for

Speaker:

me because I just want to solve the problems and I have a lot to

Speaker:

offer. So we kind of changed the format of leadership there, and

Speaker:

we had women as part of our for-profit agricultural

Speaker:

collective, a group of for-profit farms in New York. That as a woman of

Speaker:

color and a CEO, so she stepped in for me. So I wasn't able to

Speaker:

be part of that process anymore simply because of my sex and the color of

Speaker:

my skin. I mean, I was literally removed because of that. So,

Speaker:

so that was difficult for me, and I wanted to get Maurice's advice on that.

Speaker:

And I think his advice on that podcast was really good and open. And, and

Speaker:

again, if I've said anything to offend anyone or be offensive, I, I

Speaker:

do apologize. I'm, I'm just communicating my experience and

Speaker:

And that I'm trying to do the best for my communities. Yeah, I think it's

Speaker:

an important discussion to have because, to your point, the optics on even something

Speaker:

like agtech, like when you see conferences and you see speakers and

Speaker:

you're like, whoa, that's a very white male panel

Speaker:

of folks. Are those the only people doing interesting things in this space? So I

Speaker:

think having these conversations early on, and when you were talking about

Speaker:

the access to the blueprint and people getting started with how they want to grow

Speaker:

their farms, Even maybe ideas about partnering with, you know, because you can be a

Speaker:

minority-owned business and grants and that sort of stuff. And I wonder if there's some

Speaker:

opportunities to kind of position this as something that, you know, minority

Speaker:

business owners can look at as an opportunity that they can delve further into.

Speaker:

Oh, definitely. I mean, RFPs are coming from cities. The city of Philadelphia had an

Speaker:

RFP for their local food system plan. We gathered, you know, we

Speaker:

have female advisors and female team members, and we also found

Speaker:

local people of color and females to join our team for

Speaker:

that. But I still think we lost that in part

Speaker:

because they had a local, more diverse team than us.

Speaker:

Okay, great. And I love those initiatives. And I think that that's great.

Speaker:

And I support that fully. We don't do enough

Speaker:

to encourage diversity. And we still don't have enough diversity. If you look at the

Speaker:

news that's happening with the Oscars right now, you know, and agtech is

Speaker:

especially especially bad at this. But look, Agritecture does a lot of

Speaker:

work to try and change that in our own way. We've created women in

Speaker:

agtech panels, we've created women in agtech roundtables, we

Speaker:

have diversity goals for our company. I, as a keynote speaker,

Speaker:

when I get invited to panels that's only men on it, I say, I will

Speaker:

not be on a man-all. You need to find a woman or replace me with

Speaker:

a woman. So those are the things that we need to do, and I'm certainly

Speaker:

not perfect. But I think, to your point, look, I want a lot more people

Speaker:

in urban ag, and there's a lot of problems to solve. If you're a woman

Speaker:

or minority-owned business or potentially can be that, try to find a specific gap in

Speaker:

your community, your region, or with your expertise. You can build a business around

Speaker:

that because there are opportunities for you, as

Speaker:

there should be. You mentioned some of the events that you're doing with Agritecture.

Speaker:

We'll use that as a segue to the— you

Speaker:

run an event, a week-long event in New York City as well, right? Yeah, so

Speaker:

Agritecture both produces events and creates programming for

Speaker:

events. And is a media partner for some events. You can find all of the

Speaker:

events on our events page, agritecture.com/events. And what

Speaker:

we do is we— the week-long event you're referring to is NYC AgTech

Speaker:

Week, which we do with other members of the NYC Ag Collective. And

Speaker:

that's like an anti-conference. We basically said, let's not have a single location,

Speaker:

let's not rent out a space, let's just use our community to

Speaker:

showcase what's possible. So we kind of go all over the city. The

Speaker:

first year was crazy ambitious that we did it, We did all 5

Speaker:

boroughs. We had farm tours in all 5 boroughs, and it was 6 days.

Speaker:

And yeah, it was so exciting because people get to like really

Speaker:

interact with the farmers and really, you know, we did like tech demos and we

Speaker:

did policy panels. So it's really, really fun. And, and we've been doing that, um,

Speaker:

ever since. I think we're doing our 5th year probably in September.

Speaker:

So, but that's not just agriculture anymore. We have a lot of people that, that

Speaker:

work together on it that, that's really exciting. And if you want to keep up

Speaker:

to date with that, you can go to farming.nyc and see the collective's website.

Speaker:

We are going to Abu Dhabi in March to do the biggest agtech event in

Speaker:

the region, Global Forum for Innovations in Agriculture. We're looking for sponsors

Speaker:

for that to join us to do a special program there. We are doing our

Speaker:

really big event. Well, I guess I'll say a couple more. I'm doing a mega

Speaker:

trends panel at Indoor AgCon in May, which is going to be really kind of

Speaker:

bringing in big companies, but I can't mention who they are yet, to talk about

Speaker:

how they're looking at this. So non-ag companies looking at indoor ag. So I'm excited

Speaker:

about that. I'm going to be at Greentech, biggest horticultural fair in

Speaker:

the world, in Amsterdam, working on the programming for their vertical farming

Speaker:

pavilion. And then September is NYC AgTech Week. And then

Speaker:

December is— we're just about to announce it— is the Agriculture

Speaker:

Exchange, which is an event that we're producing in Toronto, December

Speaker:

1st and 2nd, 2 days, 6 thematic areas across

Speaker:

agtech, really amazing pavilions and thematic focus areas.

Speaker:

Really, really exciting event that I am stoked to see you at. Yeah, I'm gonna

Speaker:

try to make it to New York in September. I was talking to Louise about

Speaker:

it. So yeah, yeah, we'll, we'll broadcast live some sessions there.

Speaker:

So I mean, it sounds like you've got your finger on the pulse of everything

Speaker:

that's happening. As you know, as part of the research for this podcast, I've been

Speaker:

collecting— I've got an Airtable full of like a ton of conferences

Speaker:

and speakers and companies. But yeah, I mean, just in looking at the conferences, there's

Speaker:

There's so many happening, and there's a lot of interest in the space, it seems,

Speaker:

all across the country as well, because you just described, I think, like events in

Speaker:

like 2 or 3 different countries alone. So, as we

Speaker:

wrap up, what would you say has got you— you know, because you've got your

Speaker:

finger on the pulse with what's happening, with what companies are developing, and even some

Speaker:

stuff that you probably can't talk about, but I'm wondering what has you excited when

Speaker:

you think about, you know, talk a little bit about vertical farming, but you can

Speaker:

talk about the general agtech space as well, when you think about the next 12

Speaker:

months. Yeah, what am I excited about in 2020 for agtech?

Speaker:

There's some big companies that have been around for a while,

Speaker:

like Preva, which is a really great company. They've been doing a lot of

Speaker:

research and announcing some new technologies and solutions,

Speaker:

both software and hardware, for the space. I'm very excited to see those announcements

Speaker:

coming soon. And they also have launched a new foundation called the

Speaker:

Sustainable Urban Delta Foundation that kind of really thinks about cities as Productive

Speaker:

Landscapes, that I'll be in a documentary with them that's coming out this, this year,

Speaker:

and it's gonna be really, really exciting to see that. And, and I'm really excited

Speaker:

to see what comes from them. I think I'm really mostly excited about automated racking

Speaker:

systems in 2020 as it comes to vertical farming. We've seen a lot of

Speaker:

advancements in that area, but there's still a lot of room for improvement. But I

Speaker:

think the companies are getting really smart in finding partners who have established

Speaker:

automation solutions to bring them in, as opposed to building everything in-house. And

Speaker:

so I'm really excited as we move from no automation to

Speaker:

semi-automated. You know, I don't think we're going to get to automated yet, even though

Speaker:

a lot of them are marketing that, but we're moving towards semi-automated more

Speaker:

consistently. So I'm excited to see the difference that's going to make once the

Speaker:

operations are running and some of those metrics to see, you know, how is it

Speaker:

worth the CapEx in scenarios? Sometimes when we're

Speaker:

modeling them, sometimes it's worth it and sometimes it's not. So all that

Speaker:

CapEx is an additional risk. used to sell more lettuce. So I'm curious to see

Speaker:

if that happens, because that's always been like the future of this. So I think

Speaker:

2020, we'll see some advancements in that area. I'm excited about the genetic research piece.

Speaker:

I don't think there's gonna be that much advancement. I think we're still looking at

Speaker:

a 5-year trajectory for a lot of that genetics and breeding research to be applied

Speaker:

to the market specifically, but I'm looking forward to seeing more of

Speaker:

that. I think food safety is really exciting. We've had a lot of food safety

Speaker:

scares in Australia, Europe, more Australia and the

Speaker:

US, certainly in other parts of the world too, but in the US it's

Speaker:

been, it's been really prevalent around leafy greens. And so I'm really excited to see

Speaker:

how food safety policies change and the new Food

Speaker:

Safety Coalition, which is run by a couple different big vertical

Speaker:

farming and greenhouse companies. And it's really cool to see them collaborate on something like

Speaker:

food safety that's so important to consumers and to the industry. So I'm really

Speaker:

excited to see that kind of change things and maybe drive more people indoors.

Speaker:

And I guess the last category is policy. Like, you know, we have the

Speaker:

3rd urban agriculture director in the United States that was just put into place

Speaker:

in D.C. to join Atlanta and Philadelphia. That's really exciting.

Speaker:

You know, we have the Minister of Food Security in the UAE that's really going

Speaker:

to be launching a bunch of things in the coming year in the UAE. We've

Speaker:

got policy really advancing as well in Singapore in the space. You

Speaker:

know, Australia now is going to have to think about these things. New Zealand is

Speaker:

thinking about these things a bit more. So, I'm really excited to see how policy

Speaker:

accelerates the industry and starts to structure it a little bit, because

Speaker:

it can really formulate a policy decision like the one we referred to in

Speaker:

Brussels, really formed the kind of farms we saw. So, I'm excited to see how

Speaker:

those different policies will actually drive the kind of integrations that we see.

Speaker:

And, of course, I'm excited about the launch of Agriculture Designer in 2020. Hell yes.

Speaker:

Sounds like a lot of stuff to be excited about, and it feels like

Speaker:

you're at— I mean, your company's at the next of what's happening because

Speaker:

you're touching and you're engaging with so many different folks in the space. So

Speaker:

it's almost in the catbird seat in terms of seeing what's possible and seeing

Speaker:

what's coming in. So it seems like just really exciting times to be in the

Speaker:

space. And I think when you think about the development that can happen, I think

Speaker:

some of it is we can't even imagine the things that people will develop

Speaker:

in this sort of agtech space and new companies that'll arise

Speaker:

to meet needs. I talked a little bit with Louisa about the idea of

Speaker:

modular is companies moving towards modular. So companies like Soft Robotics,

Speaker:

making the grippers for the ripe fruit, and companies

Speaker:

like Intelligent Growth Solutions, right? And I guess that's something you're seeing as

Speaker:

well in your analysis. When people want to put something together, it's probably better

Speaker:

to think modular because the innovation is happening so fast. Oh yeah. I mean,

Speaker:

there's a whole podcast about that, but it saves on some of that embodied energy

Speaker:

if you can do prefab and modular solutions, which I like. And then actually, you

Speaker:

can also compartmentalize and solve certain problems, HVAC

Speaker:

challenges, reduce certain costs in that way. And bottom line, you

Speaker:

know, we did a global census around controlled environment agriculture with

Speaker:

Autogrow, our partner for this year or last year, and

Speaker:

41% of the, of the farmers in CA are new. So if

Speaker:

you're a new farmer, you know, you're not going to be building your own turnkey

Speaker:

solutions every time. You need some turnkey, modular, easily shippable

Speaker:

solutions, and, and the market needs that. And we're going to be seeing more of

Speaker:

those coming All right, that's probably a good place to put a pin in

Speaker:

there for now, but that's a lot of great information happening, so it's really exciting.

Speaker:

I'm sure I could probably geek out for another— we'll save that for a future

Speaker:

podcast episode. So where's the best place for folks to track you down and

Speaker:

connect with you online? Yeah, I definitely want you to check out agriculture.com.

Speaker:

We've got research articles on there, we've got podcasts, we've got

Speaker:

videos, we've got blogs for 7 years I think are on there in the

Speaker:

archive already. You know, our newsletter is a really, really good resource as well to

Speaker:

know about the events and what's happening. So just dig through Agritecture. Let me

Speaker:

know what you like about it, what you don't, what you'd like to see. I'm

Speaker:

always looking to talk to our audience and anyone curious about this space. You

Speaker:

can connect with me on LinkedIn, just search Henry Gordon-Smith, or you can connect with

Speaker:

me directly on social media by looking for The Agritech

Speaker:

on Instagram and Twitter. And Henry is active on social, I can vouch for

Speaker:

that. Thanks so much for this podcast. I really appreciate you

Speaker:

inviting me on. I love to see a vertical farming-focused podcast like this. And, and

Speaker:

really great questions. So I really appreciate it. I appreciate you taking the time for

Speaker:

joining me on the show. Thanks again to Henry for sharing his journey

Speaker:

of the founding of AgriTechture and how he and

Speaker:

his company have come to play an important role in helping

Speaker:

me and others understand the agtech industry. It's clear from

Speaker:

the conversation and from Henry's social posts that it's a

Speaker:

topic that he's really passionate about. I'm excited next week for

Speaker:

a conversation with John Friedman. He is the Chief Operating

Speaker:

Officer of Freight Farms. It was one of the companies that I was looking

Speaker:

forward to learning more about, and John did not

Speaker:

disappoint with his interview. So stay tuned for that. That's going to be episode 5.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening. To hear all past episodes and read the episode

Speaker:

summaries, which includes any links mentioned in the episode, as well as

Speaker:

the full show transcripts, Visit

Speaker:

verticalfarmingpodcast.com. There you can sign up for our

Speaker:

email list to be notified when new episodes are published.

Speaker:

$680 million poured into precision ag last year.

Speaker:

Autonomous weeding robots dominated, and John Deere made 2 acquisitions in

Speaker:

3 months. A food company, not an equipment maker, bought a

Speaker:

robotics startup to protect its own supply chain. The deals are

Speaker:

accelerating. The money is moving, and the winners are already separating from the

Speaker:

pack. If you're investing, building, or buying in this space,

Speaker:

you need the full picture before your competitors get it. The 2025

Speaker:

Precision Agriculture Intelligence Report from iGrow News is now

Speaker:

available. Get your copy today at

Speaker:

igrownews.com/precision.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube