🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store

In 2023, police showed up at the door of Steven White. They had pics of him robbing someone's home the night before. He didn't deny it but then told them that the woman who lived there was a murderer.

That'll get your attention.

The woman who lived there was Marsha Allen and her husband, Harold "Peanut" Allen, had died at home five days before Christmas in 2022 after being sick for weeks and with more than one trip to the ER.

HIs death was attributed to heart problems but no one tested his blood for poison until this burgler gave police a tip and the whole mother / daughter plan fell apart.

🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO:

🔔 YouTube: https://youtube.com/@TrueCrimeFM_Official

🎵 TikTok: https://tiktok.com/@truecrimefm_official

📸 Instagram: https://instagram.com/TrueCrimefm

👥 Facebook: https://facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM

🎧 Podcast: https://truecrime.fm

🛒 Merch: https://tcfm.store

00:00 The Break In

02:27 Meet Harold "Peanut" Allen

05:32 Harold Gets Sick

06:43 Death Ruled Natural

08:13 The Break In

12:20 Marsha's Interview

17:15 The Text Messages

20:10 Root Beer Floats

23:29 Search Warrant for Marsha's Place

25:58 Marsha Found Dead

27:26 Ashley's Interrogation Begins

36:29 Charges and Money Motive

46:24 Sentencing and Aftermath

48:54 Ty’s Death Revisited

Probable cause affidavit, Lt. Adam Nicholson, Jackson County Sheriff's Department (Oct. 26, 2023)

Charging information and MyCase docket, Jackson Circuit Court, 36C01-2310-MR-000001

Bodycam and interrogation footage

Seymour Tribune (Oct. 28, 2023; Aug. 16, 2024; Aug. 23, 2025; Sept. 27, 2025)

Nexstar / WANE / Fox59 (Aug. 2024)

Law&Crime (Oct. 19 and Oct. 27, 2023)

106.1 The River (Sept. 24, 2025)

CBS News, 48 Hours, "The Root Beer Float Murder" (April 2026)

This episode discusses suicide. If you're struggling or worried about someone, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (US).

#TrueCrime #TrueCrimeFM #Indiana