Artwork for podcast Close The Loop
What is the ROI of Marketing?
Episode 3511th July 2022 • Close The Loop • CallSource
00:00:00 00:53:25

Share Episode

Transcripts

Kevin Dieny:

Hello and welcome to the Close the Loop podcast.

Kevin Dieny:

I'm your host, Kevin Dieny and today we're gonna be talking about finding

Kevin Dieny:

the ROI of marketing and practical ways to be able to prove that marketing

Kevin Dieny:

is effective for your business.

Kevin Dieny:

With us today, I have a special guest, someone that I met at a conference,

Kevin Dieny:

someone that I met and we just hit it off at one of those networking activities.

Kevin Dieny:

And his name is Glenn Schmelzle.

Kevin Dieny:

And Glenn is someone whose focus is always about helping businesses, B2B

Kevin Dieny:

organizations get their marketing to the point where it's profitable, his agency

Kevin Dieny:

marketing what's new leverages digital channels to generate leads with technology

Kevin Dieny:

to track funnels in dollars and cents.

Kevin Dieny:

Cause it's really difficult to track it, but we're gonna be talking about

Kevin Dieny:

that his funnel reboot podcast, which I had the honor being on

Kevin Dieny:

not too long ago, uh, has served.

Kevin Dieny:

As an educational platform where over a hundred fellow plus marketers have

Kevin Dieny:

shared their digital marketing ideas.

Kevin Dieny:

Glenn has a BA from the university of Toronto and an MBA from Clarkson

Kevin Dieny:

university and lives with his wife and three sons in Ottawa, Canada.

Kevin Dieny:

So welcome, Glenn.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Thank you so much for having me on Kevin.

Kevin Dieny:

So, we're gonna dive right in.

Kevin Dieny:

We're talking about, you know, finding the ROI marketing.

Kevin Dieny:

We're talking about the practical ways to measure marketing and be able to

Kevin Dieny:

prove its effectiveness to the business.

Kevin Dieny:

Just to kick it off.

Kevin Dieny:

Why should a business take the measurement of marketing seriously?

Kevin Dieny:

Why does that impact the success of marketing?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah, I'm happy to kick that one on.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I'm speaking both as a business owner, as well as a.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Guy who wears a marketing hat.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So for people who run a business, it doesn't matter if you're

Glenn Schmelzle:

talking HR, marketing, how you get your coffee supplies.

Glenn Schmelzle:

A business is built around having to make a profit.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And so there is no reason why marketing should.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let itself be held to a different standard than the rest of

Glenn Schmelzle:

a company is being held to.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We're gonna get into some of the quirks that make it not easy to do, but I want

Glenn Schmelzle:

us to remember that end of the day, we're trying to make something profitable.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That means that it has future potential for growth, that there

Glenn Schmelzle:

is perhaps an opportunity to reinvest and make more of this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Marketing is something that we are doing in the here and now

Glenn Schmelzle:

that if done properly, should be able to move us in that direction.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I say, let marketing be held to measurement standards.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Don't just let marketing happen on its own without any accountability.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, I think accountability is really important and also the reason

Kevin Dieny:

I like accountability is if you think about it, marketing is taking the, some

Kevin Dieny:

of the business' cash or taking some of the business' capital and it's using it.

Kevin Dieny:

It's putting it to a use.

Kevin Dieny:

Now business is like, well, I could be using that to hire more people.

Kevin Dieny:

I could be taking that and creating a new product or doing anything with the money.

Kevin Dieny:

So at the end of the day, it's like, well, why should the

Kevin Dieny:

business decide that marketing.

Kevin Dieny:

Powerful and proper avenue for spending money.

Kevin Dieny:

And why should it put it into marketing?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah, absolutely.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We all to also have to remember that marketing is one of those fields.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's not like, you know, ultra sonography or some other field where.

Glenn Schmelzle:

All of the work happens behind the scenes.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We walk through a world full of marketing.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We are, you know, both, sometimes the people behind it, but we're always

Glenn Schmelzle:

the people in front of it, right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That it is reaching.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I think we have to contend with some things that can

Glenn Schmelzle:

distort our vision with this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And, you know, you were talking about how a business needs to take money away

Glenn Schmelzle:

from profits and put it into marketing, or they can put it into other things.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Why should they have to put it into marketing?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Well, if you have anything more than something that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I can click on Amazon and immediately order, or it's within arms reach

Glenn Schmelzle:

when I'm at the grocery store.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you have something like that, then you are having to reach someone at a time.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's a little different from the time that they're deciding to buy it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's good because actually you now have some breathing space to influence

Glenn Schmelzle:

their decision of who they're gonna buy from, but here's the challenge you

Glenn Schmelzle:

have to part with those dollars now.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And you have to wait until the revenue comes back and that dollar is recouped.

Kevin Dieny:

So that lag time, right.

Kevin Dieny:

That's sort of the function.

Kevin Dieny:

That's sort of a.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Oh, it's a killer.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's a, it's a byproduct of it's it's excruciatingly long.

Kevin Dieny:

It's sort of like, uh, well, we, you know, we need to buy this

Kevin Dieny:

part for our product or we need to have.

Kevin Dieny:

A piece of our service requires us to have, you know, steps in it.

Kevin Dieny:

That's just part of the steps.

Kevin Dieny:

The way I look at it is, okay, there's invested money day one.

Kevin Dieny:

At some point, you know, it, hopefully it gets delivered.

Kevin Dieny:

Sometimes you invest money in things and they just never come to fruition.

Kevin Dieny:

They never even get to the market.

Kevin Dieny:

So let's look at it from the other side too, which is so

Kevin Dieny:

why we decided to spend money.

Kevin Dieny:

Let's say a business is like, well, I get marketing.

Kevin Dieny:

I get what it's trying to do.

Kevin Dieny:

I get that when we're spending money, it's gonna have a lag time toward the impact.

Kevin Dieny:

The problem is for a lot of businesses, which is where like we're really wanting

Kevin Dieny:

to narrow for this episode is why is it so difficult to measure marketing

Kevin Dieny:

and measure the success of marketing as it aligns with the business' goals?

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's difficult because you're normally involving others, right?

Glenn Schmelzle:

So if you are a manager or perhaps an owner of a business, you're probably not

Glenn Schmelzle:

doing all of the creative or all of the.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Add platform implementation or the emails, you know, that fall into, uh, the realm

Glenn Schmelzle:

of marketing, but you are the person who has to judge its effectiveness.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And you're a pretty good judge because you have gotten this far offensively

Glenn Schmelzle:

because you've made good judgements in the past on similar kinds of decisions.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So it requires some letting go.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I think that that's, that has a lot to do with the difficulty.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's not something that you can necessarily do.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If, if you are, for example, a person who's moved from, let's

Glenn Schmelzle:

say you were a good technician or consultant, but now you have a small

Glenn Schmelzle:

army of people who do that job.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They are good at understanding how, how long it takes to do a certain job.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You know, multiply that by a rate.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They're probably good at understanding, you know, how much revenue that

Glenn Schmelzle:

job's gonna be worth, but it's a different thing altogether.

Glenn Schmelzle:

When you try to swing over to the cost side and you say, all right, I need

Glenn Schmelzle:

to now gauge how cost beneficial it's going to be to get in front of people.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And yet you're gonna have to tie it back to that revenue at some point.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I think that that's jogging back and forth between those two.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's a really big part of why it is difficult.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And then I'll slide my own industry.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We have made it unbelievably jargon filled and technically complex, uh,

Glenn Schmelzle:

and that doesn't do anyone any favors.

Kevin Dieny:

So I had a guest on one time, say you have to look

Kevin Dieny:

at marketing like an investment.

Kevin Dieny:

Yes, it does all investments have the time lag also all investments have risk, right?

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

So what is it that, you know, a business in terms of, well, they're not

Kevin Dieny:

confident about marketing, let's say because maybe marketing hasn't worked

Kevin Dieny:

before, maybe they don't think it will work for their type of business, their

Kevin Dieny:

type of industry, whatever it is.

Kevin Dieny:

So, to that I would normally say, well, what is success for you?

Kevin Dieny:

What does success for marketing look like?

Kevin Dieny:

Because it's possible that marketing, in some ways doesn't

Kevin Dieny:

always lift revenue per se.

Kevin Dieny:

It doesn't always lift sales per se.

Kevin Dieny:

Sometimes targeted marketing is done for other purposes.

Kevin Dieny:

So it's like if marketing was to be successful for your business,

Kevin Dieny:

what would that look like?

Kevin Dieny:

What does that have to look like?

Kevin Dieny:

And so, you know, for you, you run your agency.

Kevin Dieny:

So.

Kevin Dieny:

Are usually the ways that we look at marketing being successful.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah, so glad you asked.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, and it is different by companies in a conversation.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I had a long time ago that kind of showed me the foolishness of thinking

Glenn Schmelzle:

that marketing should just, uh, serve, you know, all my needs all at once.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I was sitting down with a person and they were just beginning, uh,

Glenn Schmelzle:

for a maybe dozen person company.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And they.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Kind of carved out some marketing budget and I said, well,

Glenn Schmelzle:

what do you wanna do with it?

Glenn Schmelzle:

And they said, I just wanna make some noise.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Frankly, that was, uh, the conversation didn't last much longer after that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The truth is that you may see big companies doing that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And this is part of where I said, even though you're walking through a

Glenn Schmelzle:

world where you see marketing, please try not to take some of what you

Glenn Schmelzle:

see out there and imagine that it is appropriate for your own business's goal.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's probably not.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You're probably better to start with a blank sheet of paper.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And you, you would ask things like.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Do I have an existing customer base that I feel I could make more revenue out of.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If just, if the same people engage with me, either buying more things

Glenn Schmelzle:

or there's a higher dollar value per.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Order.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This is a way that you would absolutely want a telemarketer and

Glenn Schmelzle:

say, I want that to be my objective.

Glenn Schmelzle:

At least for now another one could be brand new business.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Another one could be, I don't even want to go for end clients.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I want to reach partners who will become a channel.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And resell or refer people my way.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Each of those is marketing objectives, but they stem from

Glenn Schmelzle:

what you want your business to do.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And a marketer worth their salt should be able to make that translation.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But I'm gonna complete the thought by saying there's one thing in

Glenn Schmelzle:

this bargain that you've gotta be ready to, you know, come back

Glenn Schmelzle:

towards you with when that marketer.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Does what you asked for that business objective, they're going

Glenn Schmelzle:

to probably show you some metrics.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Those metrics don't look immediately like your business goals, but I'm

Glenn Schmelzle:

gonna ask you to let that high blood pressure that you're feeling surge up.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Just let it pass and hear them out because what's likely if a good marketing KPI

Glenn Schmelzle:

can be found that serves as a lever.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That by focusing on that marketing KPI, the byproduct is that your business'

Glenn Schmelzle:

key performance indicator and what you had as the original objective

Glenn Schmelzle:

that that's gonna move, but it's not a direct, it's only as an indirect and

Glenn Schmelzle:

marketing is what brings the cause to it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And the effect is found on your bottom line.

Kevin Dieny:

Right, something like you are describing there to me is like, I

Kevin Dieny:

look at it like there's top line, like maybe, uh, lagging metrics and leading

Kevin Dieny:

metrics where there are data points that are telling us if the marketing

Kevin Dieny:

is effective within the channel.

Kevin Dieny:

And then there's metrics that are telling us if the marketing is effective at

Kevin Dieny:

generating and aligning with business goals, which might be revenue, sales,

Kevin Dieny:

brand awareness, um, things like that.

Kevin Dieny:

And.

Kevin Dieny:

To me, the more limited your budget is.

Kevin Dieny:

And I I've faced some very limited budgets.

Kevin Dieny:

The more I feel like I have to get closer to those metrics that are

Kevin Dieny:

describing how they're affecting sales or revenues or profits or gross profits.

Kevin Dieny:

And the reason is is that if I start there and I'm like, okay, I can prove.

Kevin Dieny:

Give me a dollar and it's equating a dollar in a certain amount of time

Kevin Dieny:

period and paying it back and how much that's gonna drive business, you know,

Kevin Dieny:

continually then it's like, okay, I can get more budget, but at some point you're

Kevin Dieny:

gonna need to fill the middle and the top of the funnel in a marketing funnel way.

Kevin Dieny:

And a lot of doing those things, isn't gonna directly lead to sales.

Kevin Dieny:

There's too far of a distance.

Kevin Dieny:

Helping people get educated.

Kevin Dieny:

Let's say on like the types of cars will help them figure out eventually what car

Kevin Dieny:

they want to buy, but it might be very difficult to be like, oh yeah, the guy

Kevin Dieny:

we showed like a brochure two, three years ago, ended up buying the car.

Kevin Dieny:

Like, there's, there's certain things.

Kevin Dieny:

So in marketing, there's extremely accurate data points.

Kevin Dieny:

I'd say they're probably closer to the end, probably closer

Kevin Dieny:

to the sale a lot of times.

Kevin Dieny:

And then there's stuff in the middle and the top.

Kevin Dieny:

That's just so hard.

Kevin Dieny:

So a lot of times I've heard, man, measuring marketing

Kevin Dieny:

just seems so inaccurate.

Kevin Dieny:

So how do you deal with that, Glenn?

Glenn Schmelzle:

You break it down and, and you did a beautiful job just there of,

Glenn Schmelzle:

you know, describing it by funnel stage.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If there are people who.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe already have awareness of you, maybe there's even, you know, out of home brand

Glenn Schmelzle:

touchpoints that cause them to see and know about, but maybe your website is not

Glenn Schmelzle:

structured for that activation, right?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe there's something that you could be doing to at the time

Glenn Schmelzle:

when they are ready, which we call bottom a funnel, then you have a.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Very intuitive means of letting them take that action.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This is something that a marketer, you know, back to what we were saying

Glenn Schmelzle:

about a marketing metric, their KPI could be how well are we converting

Glenn Schmelzle:

people from one stage to another?

Glenn Schmelzle:

And it's maybe, you know, as you say, it could be very close to the

Glenn Schmelzle:

point where a cash register ring.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And yet the nature of something inbound is that you are reaching

Glenn Schmelzle:

people when they're interested and their interest is going to work.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Just like the way that we always make decisions.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm thinking about something it's in the future.

Glenn Schmelzle:

There are times where I just want to know enough to satisfy my

Glenn Schmelzle:

current haziness about it, but that doesn't mean that I'm ready to buy.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And so the marketer has to reverse engineer that and say, what are

Glenn Schmelzle:

the things that could help me just get them to consider me.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe put me in the short list or make some association.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So they say, yeah, when I have that problem, that's who I'm going to,

Glenn Schmelzle:

this is different from the activation, you know, or decision making at one.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And as you said at the very top there's awareness so a marketer has to make

Glenn Schmelzle:

decisions and budget allocations that try to serve all of those needs.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I'm not gonna disagree with you.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It has some difficulties in it, but there are ways to at least get a directional

Glenn Schmelzle:

sense of whether or not it's working.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, so I think like in terms of like the business leader, I

Kevin Dieny:

have seen ads come across in front of me who are targeting me that say, Hey.

Kevin Dieny:

Look, we got a 15 X ROI on this ad for this company.

Kevin Dieny:

We can do the same for you, or Hey, check out our email click rate.

Kevin Dieny:

It's over 50%.

Kevin Dieny:

We could do that for you.

Kevin Dieny:

And I've been like, wow, well, how did they do that?

Kevin Dieny:

Everything you wanna compare everything, right?

Kevin Dieny:

Wow.

Kevin Dieny:

They're doing so well.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, they're doing so many things, but just like you're saying, right.

Kevin Dieny:

Like if I send an email.

Kevin Dieny:

To current people in pipeline who are really close to buying that says like, you

Kevin Dieny:

know, Hey, would you like 20% off more?

Kevin Dieny:

And you're already at the finish line.

Kevin Dieny:

They might be, they might be interested in opening that email.

Kevin Dieny:

So I could say, Hey, look at this email, got like a hundred percent open rate

Kevin Dieny:

and like a hundred percent click rate.

Kevin Dieny:

And so it could be very misleading.

Kevin Dieny:

So.

Kevin Dieny:

If you're the business owner, a business leader out there, marketer

Kevin Dieny:

of any type you're seeing these ads, you're seeing the marketing done by

Kevin Dieny:

agencies, by businesses, by freelancers.

Kevin Dieny:

That's going out there and saying business owners, look what we can do.

Kevin Dieny:

And so.

Kevin Dieny:

What we're talking about with these metrics is like having a really good

Kevin Dieny:

understanding in their business.

Kevin Dieny:

What kind of marketing is going out and what expectations to have, cuz if you,

Kevin Dieny:

like you said, inbound and outbound, if you email people cold, outbound,

Kevin Dieny:

you're not expecting the greatest open rate or the most engaged rate or

Kevin Dieny:

the most connected rate or whatever it is, inbound, it's gotta be higher.

Kevin Dieny:

So, all of those things, right?

Kevin Dieny:

Change the expectation of how marketing is performing.

Kevin Dieny:

So you run the agency, Glen.

Kevin Dieny:

So how do you help business owners or how do, how do business owners get around?

Kevin Dieny:

What are expected, proper successes, ways of what, what are the most

Kevin Dieny:

important types of things they should be looking at in their business?

Kevin Dieny:

They can put the blinders on and be like, okay, that's, that's, everything

Kevin Dieny:

I'm seeing is not necessarily reality or wouldn't be reality for my business.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I don't wanna sound like I'm hedging it, but let, let me approach

Glenn Schmelzle:

the first, how it should be approached.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And then we'll get into the, the dots and bolts of, uh, what should be

Glenn Schmelzle:

measured, how it should be approached.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let's remember that you are working in a world full of people and humans don't

Glenn Schmelzle:

make particularly good lab test subjects.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Anyone in the social sciences.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You know, if we remember back to maybe college courses, we

Glenn Schmelzle:

are very hard to pin down.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We are not necessarily as predictable as you know, two plus two equals

Glenn Schmelzle:

four is so we have that difficulty.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I guess I have to also say that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

There are now reasons why data is being either removed from what a marketer

Glenn Schmelzle:

can see by privacy regulations, or some of the tech giants are obscuring

Glenn Schmelzle:

it because serves their needs.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And so, you know, there, there is less information that we have here and, and

Glenn Schmelzle:

those are just sober realities, but I don't want someone to lose heart.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You asked about the agency thing.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It starts off with something as woo woo.

Glenn Schmelzle:

As your philosophy and your culture.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So what you don't want to do is you don't want to create a pressure cooker

Glenn Schmelzle:

environment where sales, but, you know, to include marketing where they feel that

Glenn Schmelzle:

they just have to make a bell ring, you know, like a lab, subject wood Pavlos

Glenn Schmelzle:

dogs, because what's gonna happen.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They're gonna do things like.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The landscape is strew with examples of, for example, people who are

Glenn Schmelzle:

searching for a product and they can go straight to the website.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And it's the sort of thing.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Like they can book an appoint.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So that's the, the action and they could, if they've already thought

Glenn Schmelzle:

of that company's name, they're just going to Google and typing

Glenn Schmelzle:

it in and Google's just gonna show them in the organic search results.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This is what you're looking for.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Here you go.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And they will a marketer who is feeling pressured and who doesn't

Glenn Schmelzle:

have the ethical scruples can make a paper click ad with your company's

Glenn Schmelzle:

brand name and it appears up top.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The person who types that and is just about to go to your website anyway, cause

Glenn Schmelzle:

they already remember your name is seeing an ad and they click on the ad and then

Glenn Schmelzle:

they go through and make their, you know, purchase or their appointment to purchase.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The marketer comes away and says, look at me, I've done this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

pat on the back for me and the business owner.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If they find out about this, uh, I'm sure aren't none too happy.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So, you know, but really is it entirely the marketer's fault?

Glenn Schmelzle:

They were given this, you have this quota to make you must

Glenn Schmelzle:

by any and all means possible.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Failure is not an option.

Glenn Schmelzle:

and that's what you're gonna get.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I, I think we need to clear the air there, Kevin on maybe

Glenn Schmelzle:

what shouldn't be set instead.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's going to be a mindset for experimentation and a mindset

Glenn Schmelzle:

for let's track what we can.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And let's be a little bit scientific about it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If I do these things, it ought to lead to those things, but I may be wrong.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I'm gonna give it a shot.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, so that's a really important aspect of marketing that.

Kevin Dieny:

For me has come more as like something that it's come over time that I've

Kevin Dieny:

learned because in the beginning, it, to me, it was like, well, it's all

Kevin Dieny:

about the straight up performance in the here and now, and as quickly as

Kevin Dieny:

possible, which is absolutely what a business has to be able to recover.

Kevin Dieny:

You know, it's it's expenses, especially the smaller it is.

Kevin Dieny:

It's like, my budget is very limited.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, no doubt.

Kevin Dieny:

But I've come to realize like at least 80% of the budget, you know, at max

Kevin Dieny:

is in performance to me and 20% of.

Kevin Dieny:

Is sort of like research.

Kevin Dieny:

And by that, I mean, when I spend a dollar 80 cents of that is gonna be dedicated

Kevin Dieny:

probably to the performance of that ad.

Kevin Dieny:

But in addition, 20 cents is gonna be wasted on learning from the mistake

Kevin Dieny:

on figuring out, oh, there's had the wrong keywords, or this was

Kevin Dieny:

the wrong audience or this, this page there's something off or.

Kevin Dieny:

Because a marketer is not really after quantity as much as they are

Kevin Dieny:

after quality, but there's a balance there because if you go too much in

Kevin Dieny:

either direction, you're super high quantity, like you said, the bell

Kevin Dieny:

ringing, getting people to just, you know, get an appointment, but

Kevin Dieny:

then you find out none of them are.

Kevin Dieny:

None of them are a fit is a total waste on the other end.

Kevin Dieny:

You trust is bad.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

You have one only one person that came in your whole budget pulled just one person.

Kevin Dieny:

It may not be able to float the thing, even though it's okay.

Kevin Dieny:

This person's a really good fit.

Kevin Dieny:

it's just one person.

Kevin Dieny:

So what can we let go of on the quality side to increase the quality

Kevin Dieny:

to me, marketing is always that scale.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I've got a suggestion for you there, and I'm gonna end up at

Glenn Schmelzle:

scale, but I wanna absolutely underline what you said about, uh, experimenting.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let us not forget back to human beings.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You know, those Shamira creatures that, you know, uh, are always doing new

Glenn Schmelzle:

things and you know, when a new piece of tech shows up there on it, They are

Glenn Schmelzle:

gravitating or drifting away, depending on your vantage point from platforms,

Glenn Schmelzle:

what we call marketing channels.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So if you thought that Twitter advertising or Facebook, or, you know, name

Glenn Schmelzle:

your platform, your social platform.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's just your rock solid.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm putting 80 cents of the do the dollar on that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

In fact, I'm just gonna put a hundred cents on the dollar on that, because

Glenn Schmelzle:

it's always going to deliver for me, there's this unending stream of people.

Glenn Schmelzle:

What you're gonna find out if you don't parcel away.

Glenn Schmelzle:

A little of that money for experimentation is that human beings

Glenn Schmelzle:

may drift away and not to get to kind.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Philosophical here, but we have to acknowledge that the data

Glenn Schmelzle:

that we have is incomplete.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's a little bit.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Walking through the dark and we have a flashlight turned on

Glenn Schmelzle:

just a few steps ahead of us.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So what you may not notice while you are so busy walking down that path

Glenn Schmelzle:

is that many of them are leaving for another platform or there's

Glenn Schmelzle:

a different kind of a tactic.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And if you don't pay attention to that, if you don't move the flashlight

Glenn Schmelzle:

around a little bit, Maybe 20% of the time, then you are not gonna notice

Glenn Schmelzle:

that they've gone elsewhere to learn about solutions to their problems.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The effect of that is that your tried and true workhorse method will no

Glenn Schmelzle:

longer have as much effectiveness and you don't have anything else that

Glenn Schmelzle:

looks like a candidate to replace.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I'll, I'll pause there for a quick second, and then I'll come

Glenn Schmelzle:

to your scale notion so far.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So good.

Kevin Dieny:

I'm totally on board with that.

Kevin Dieny:

I was even gonna say it makes sense a lot of times, because a business might be

Kevin Dieny:

like, well, okay, you spent the money, you got the results, but what can you tell me?

Kevin Dieny:

That's a such a great question.

Kevin Dieny:

What can you tell me about what you've discovered?

Kevin Dieny:

What have we learned?

Kevin Dieny:

What have we discovered that will help us.

Kevin Dieny:

You know, cuz there's sort of like a, not necessarily a forecasting, a trending,

Kevin Dieny:

but there's sort of like, like what you've described there's insights in marketing

Kevin Dieny:

that are signals that are telling you things about the market, telling

Kevin Dieny:

you things about your own business.

Kevin Dieny:

That may go way beyond just the current marketing campaign.

Kevin Dieny:

You've run there's insights in there.

Kevin Dieny:

And if you have a relationship with the agency or with the marketer in house

Kevin Dieny:

or whoever it's doing your marketing, they should be able to deliver.

Kevin Dieny:

a, here's the results of what you've spent, you know, budget in

Kevin Dieny:

and some measurable success out, but also here's what we've learned.

Kevin Dieny:

And I think that was, that's something you've mentioned and

Kevin Dieny:

touched on there that I think is really important before you move on.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah, I completely agree.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And if we were, let's say doing everything in a business ourselves, especially

Glenn Schmelzle:

the sales, uh, this is something that, you know, we would just intuitively do.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We would understand.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We would get some of those insights in those conversations,

Glenn Schmelzle:

marketing, sadly doesn't have as many opportunities like that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe things like chat bot.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Kind of come close.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe analytics kind of tells us, but we have to be on platforms

Glenn Schmelzle:

that are really unfamiliar.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If anybody is unsure that they are unfamiliar.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, I'll ask you and I want anybody listening to take a moment.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Now we're in middle of 2022.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Please go and get your website or instruct someone to get your

Glenn Schmelzle:

website on Google analytics four.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You need to have it, but I don't want you to be under the illusion

Glenn Schmelzle:

that if you just put it on there and you open it, these insights are just

Glenn Schmelzle:

gonna spring out, like, you know, old faithful at, uh, at a national

Glenn Schmelzle:

park, but what can we do for that?

Glenn Schmelzle:

And here's how I think we can do it and get scale.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you have, uh, this kind of purchase where there is a customer

Glenn Schmelzle:

journey and you think that they are.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you look over several of the last successful sales that you had and you

Glenn Schmelzle:

come up with a hypothesis that well, gee, every single one of them first

Glenn Schmelzle:

wanted to kind of know about this broad problem question, and then they want,

Glenn Schmelzle:

they moved kind of into a more narrow.

Glenn Schmelzle:

All right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But I could solve this several ways.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Now.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I have questions on why and how much I would solve it for.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And then they come into, well, why would you.

Glenn Schmelzle:

be the right solution out of the ones that are very similar to you.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And then to a decision, if they're going along into things like that or

Glenn Schmelzle:

whatever it is in your business, the way you can look at scaling it is to work

Glenn Schmelzle:

with the marketer and to try to come up with cues for those conversations.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But not at an individual level.

Glenn Schmelzle:

These are at a group level.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So this is what for example, might be in a series of drip emails.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This may take the form of maybe a message that a marketer, if they tell you they've

Glenn Schmelzle:

used retargeting, this might be that retargeting message that is saying you.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Come along and, and try this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

These are almost like breadcrumbs that are left at various times

Glenn Schmelzle:

along the customer journey.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And if the marketing is actually getting traction, these are things that

Glenn Schmelzle:

should move the person from whatever stage they're at to the next one.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But I'm gonna repeat if I have to nauseum, this is done at a group level, we have to,

Glenn Schmelzle:

as marketers make this so that it handles.

Glenn Schmelzle:

As many conversations and we're going to write it once we're gonna

Glenn Schmelzle:

set it up once and we have to then measure to see whether or not the

Glenn Schmelzle:

customer is picking up the trail.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, so I would say, I agree with everything there.

Kevin Dieny:

In fact, I would say if you're a business starting out and you're thinking,

Kevin Dieny:

okay, I want to get marketing tracked.

Kevin Dieny:

I wanna have a, I wanna feel more confident about it.

Kevin Dieny:

I want to have more information about how it's working, what's going

Kevin Dieny:

on, where maybe there's a drop off.

Kevin Dieny:

Right.

Kevin Dieny:

I think sometimes I've come in and been like, well, here's a drop off.

Kevin Dieny:

And the business has been like, If the drop off's there, let's fix it.

Kevin Dieny:

And then it's not necessarily about fixing marketing budget

Kevin Dieny:

or having that conversation.

Kevin Dieny:

It's like, wow.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

Marketing's creating leads.

Kevin Dieny:

The leads are dropped off because there's some hole, some black holes somewhere in

Kevin Dieny:

the past, in the process for the business.

Kevin Dieny:

So I usually go, I start like this.

Kevin Dieny:

So you start at the end, you have a sale.

Kevin Dieny:

Cause that's something good happened there and go back.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

How did you get the sale?

Kevin Dieny:

You go one step back.

Kevin Dieny:

Well, We sold him a contract.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

How did you sell him?

Kevin Dieny:

The contract go a step back beyond that?

Kevin Dieny:

Well, we had to tell 'em about it.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

How did you tell 'em about it?

Kevin Dieny:

Well, they call, was that a yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

Phone conversation?

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

You, you just go back, back, back, and then as far as you can, or if you hit a

Kevin Dieny:

point where you're like, you know what.

Kevin Dieny:

I don't know exactly how this came in or what happened then for there.

Kevin Dieny:

It's like, okay, that's the missing tracking point.

Kevin Dieny:

Once you can get back to a certain degree now, I'm not saying you're gonna be able

Kevin Dieny:

to go, oh yeah, that's the moment on the couch when the guy decided, you know,

Kevin Dieny:

I don't think it's gonna be like, go back that far, the farther you go back.

Kevin Dieny:

No, you know, it's gonna be harder and harder to get gray and gray

Kevin Dieny:

to the point where, you know, you're just making guesses, but

Kevin Dieny:

stop at the point where you're.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

I would say I'm below a confident point for myself of whether

Kevin Dieny:

what really happened here.

Kevin Dieny:

And is it really important that you need to track this point?

Kevin Dieny:

You might just be like, well, look, I got the last eight steps.

Kevin Dieny:

That might be a lot and just focus there for now.

Kevin Dieny:

But if you have, at some point, you're gonna have the end.

Kevin Dieny:

All tracked and measured.

Kevin Dieny:

And if you do, you can see how many people are in each successful point

Kevin Dieny:

in that progression to being a sale.

Kevin Dieny:

And if you see, okay, the numbers drop off significantly

Kevin Dieny:

between one step and another.

Kevin Dieny:

For me as I'm marketing analyst at heart, it's like, okay, that's narrow there

Kevin Dieny:

because if we can get that up, Right.

Kevin Dieny:

the whole pipeline radically changes.

Kevin Dieny:

And is to me, is a, is that spending money on ads?

Kevin Dieny:

No, that's just, being able to track the process and seeing what's going on

Kevin Dieny:

in the business and narrowing it down.

Kevin Dieny:

That's sort of operational work, but marketing is so tied to

Kevin Dieny:

the operations of a business.

Kevin Dieny:

That's why we're talking about tracking, measuring marketing's effectiveness.

Kevin Dieny:

You don't do marketing.

Kevin Dieny:

I would say.

Kevin Dieny:

Until you're confident you're putting a lead into a process that's properly

Kevin Dieny:

tracked this is my 2 cents there.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You, if you can't go in a room and write it all out.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yes.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, then you're right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Mar marketing is more back to the guy I talked about.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let's make some noise so right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, so a caution here, uh, and that is.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let's say it is all written out and now we're at the point of

Glenn Schmelzle:

saying, okay, I think that some parts of this would be aided by

Glenn Schmelzle:

specifically spending money on media.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right?

Glenn Schmelzle:

So for anybody listing, if you're putting something out, like you put up a webpage,

Glenn Schmelzle:

Google's gonna see it organically.

Glenn Schmelzle:

You didn't have to pay for that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you're putting it on a social network, anybody who is following your page.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And the algorithm smiles on them.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They'll see it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So we're not talking that we're talking about where you, this is sometimes

Glenn Schmelzle:

called boosting, but you know, I think the more appropriate term is

Glenn Schmelzle:

that there is targeted advertising.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So where does it make sense to do that?

Glenn Schmelzle:

And how long does it make sense to do that?

Glenn Schmelzle:

For first thing, I'm going to caution people on is to.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Use the accountants ROI measure as their be all and end all for how this works.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Why?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Let's be clear.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm going back to my own, you know, days when they taught me this, but in

Glenn Schmelzle:

school, I remember them saying that ROI is it's the difference from your

Glenn Schmelzle:

revenue after cost has been taken out.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Divided by the cost.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So revenue minus cost divided by cost, right?

Glenn Schmelzle:

What did I get for what I gave, you know, by taking out, uh, what I gave,

Glenn Schmelzle:

I am only, you know, I'm only looking at what the difference is here and

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm comparing that difference over my original couple of cautions for that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But the main one I have is this could be used to defend.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Ideas that don't make sense in real life.

Glenn Schmelzle:

What do I mean if I let's take ROI of me as a person and let's

Glenn Schmelzle:

think of me spending money on food.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I could say to myself, I want to have, um, I don't want to have any,

Glenn Schmelzle:

um, outbound cost because that's on the, you know, bottom of that equation.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I don't really want to, uh, you know, I, I wanna venture very little here

Glenn Schmelzle:

because I want to keep, you know, my calorie count low so I can starve myself.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But I didn't spend any money on food.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So I kind of gained the formula and by the formula, I'm looking pretty good.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But in reality, my body is now in real trouble.

Glenn Schmelzle:

ROI by its own self is just an efficiency metric.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I could say, yes, I'm, I'm so efficient.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I didn't even have to buy any food, but don't ask me to get up and do

Glenn Schmelzle:

anything because I I'm basically exhausted just lying on the couch.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So let's not fall into that trap of saying, I must have

Glenn Schmelzle:

this kind of a high ROI.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It just means you were efficient at doing nothing.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So what I'd like to think about is instead is effectiveness.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And effectiveness.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This is back to that, you know, lever, you know, Emma is marketing,

Glenn Schmelzle:

actually moving a lever that in some part of that big process, that you've

Glenn Schmelzle:

operationalized, that we can see a different number, you know, moving and

Glenn Schmelzle:

it's moving down pipeline towards revenue.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's a really important point.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I wanna, uh, leave with the listener here, yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

That's really important because.

Kevin Dieny:

You know, in my head there's marketing budget, it's never zero, but in

Kevin Dieny:

some businesses it is, you know, especially a business starting out.

Kevin Dieny:

It starts at zero, but it's really also important when it's like, well, okay.

Kevin Dieny:

The spending 5,000 versus spending 50,000, that's a 10, 10 X difference.

Kevin Dieny:

There that's a lot.

Kevin Dieny:

So what you're getting at is.

Kevin Dieny:

It's gonna be, let's say a business is spending money on marketing and it

Kevin Dieny:

could think, well, we could just cut that budget slash it and something,

Kevin Dieny:

we have that recuperation we make.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

We make that efficiency look really good.

Kevin Dieny:

Um, sometimes the business does have to slash budgets across

Kevin Dieny:

the board or let people go.

Kevin Dieny:

It happens because they, they are beholden to shareholders, but.

Kevin Dieny:

And they'd need to stay alive.

Kevin Dieny:

I mean, a business that dies because it, you know, it pushed out all its budget and

Kevin Dieny:

ads that didn't work is also problematic.

Kevin Dieny:

What you're really getting to, which is something that I really like to focus on

Kevin Dieny:

too, is like the health of a business.

Kevin Dieny:

So a business should have a goal.

Kevin Dieny:

We need to grow to this point or this number.

Kevin Dieny:

This is what we want to get to, or this is how we wanna grow our company.

Kevin Dieny:

You know, we're gonna grow in sales, but we're gonna grow in staff.

Kevin Dieny:

We're gonna grow in product.

Kevin Dieny:

We're gonna grow in services or whatever it is.

Kevin Dieny:

And so.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Or, or in these specific markets, like, as you say, it's, it's

Glenn Schmelzle:

got something that a, uh, a strategy that the company as a whole is embracing.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

And, and achieving that.

Kevin Dieny:

Does that require growth in something?

Kevin Dieny:

Yes.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

How are we gonna grow it?

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

Well, marketing is probably one way it could grow, but

Kevin Dieny:

other alternatives yes or no.

Kevin Dieny:

So marketing.

Kevin Dieny:

I think at its best when it can deliver you the information about how marketing

Kevin Dieny:

could work, what you get from using it, it's gonna give you efficiency.

Kevin Dieny:

It's gonna give you effectiveness.

Kevin Dieny:

It's gonna tell you how effective it was.

Kevin Dieny:

And you could take that and be like, well, okay.

Kevin Dieny:

If I market in this channel versus that channel, right?

Kevin Dieny:

This is how it's kind of, this is kind of what I might expect.

Kevin Dieny:

If I do both.

Kevin Dieny:

You know, I might expect, you know, different result too.

Kevin Dieny:

And that at the end of the day is the information, businesses need to decide,

Kevin Dieny:

you know, how it's gonna grow, how it wants to grow and what budget to allocate,

Kevin Dieny:

because there's some risk in everything.

Kevin Dieny:

So if it decides it's gonna have slash all of marketing, I'd be like, well, what is

Kevin Dieny:

it gonna do to still achieve its growth?

Kevin Dieny:

You know?

Kevin Dieny:

And is the amount budgeted realistic?

Kevin Dieny:

To get and obtain that goal.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

So, yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

So anyway.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Yeah, I, I couldn't agree more and yet I see this is

Glenn Schmelzle:

not something that companies, um, Gets to this epiphany all at once.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Um, it, it takes weeks and months and sometimes years, but there is

Glenn Schmelzle:

one common pattern that I've seen.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And, and I'm so glad you raised the, the notion of, you know,

Glenn Schmelzle:

how the budget should be looked.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm used to seeing that a company goes from that $0 to,

Glenn Schmelzle:

uh, a limited time campaign.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So they're kind of thinking, you know, like the work campaign

Glenn Schmelzle:

comes from the military, right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So we're gonna go, you, storm that beach.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But you know, after we've done, you know, taken that one beach,

Glenn Schmelzle:

then we're gonna take a rest.

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's an okay stage.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I think in terms of metrics, it would probably be, did we see some

Glenn Schmelzle:

number, like, I don't know, raw leads.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Go up, did something happen?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And if it did, you know, maybe that BOS our confidence to get to the next

Glenn Schmelzle:

stage for me, the next stage is that we are seeing marketing cost return

Glenn Schmelzle:

or lend some help to closed revenue.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And we see that enough to the point where the company says, this is a regular line.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This is now not a, do we turn it off?

Glenn Schmelzle:

You know, because of the change of seasons, we can see a regular

Glenn Schmelzle:

stream of people and we expect there to be more like them.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So that's kind of the next one, uh, where I think you spoke about at the end there,

Glenn Schmelzle:

it takes a different kind of thinking, uh, to me, instead of thinking about, we put.

Glenn Schmelzle:

This many thousand on our marketing budget, instead it becomes, you're asking

Glenn Schmelzle:

how healthy was that, you know, marketing applied in the acquiring of one customer.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, this is, you know, you may wanna start with averages for this, although

Glenn Schmelzle:

that's probably not going to be granular enough, you know, as you get on, but,

Glenn Schmelzle:

you know, just take and you take an average order and you kind of break down

Glenn Schmelzle:

the unit economics into, alright, I'm getting this much revenue out of it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And I have a certain amount set aside, my fixed costs.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And then I have my marketing acquisition costs and.

Glenn Schmelzle:

What's left over her profit.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Oh, in this last month, it doesn't look like any was left over.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Okay.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Bummer.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But we've said it's kind of a, now a regular part of our spending.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So what can we do to make that acquisition cost on a per customer

Glenn Schmelzle:

basis effective enough so that we do.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Our target margins.

Glenn Schmelzle:

What is it that we need to do?

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's the kind of inquiry that takes companies to tremendous scale.

Kevin Dieny:

Yes, yeah, yeah.

Kevin Dieny:

And if you think about it, if a company found that they spend a

Kevin Dieny:

dollar and they get $10 out of it, why wouldn't they be doing it all day?

Glenn Schmelzle:

They wouldn't they would just put it right back in the top.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Exactly.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But I, I don't want people to, you know, cuz people might be

Glenn Schmelzle:

a little depressed thinking.

Glenn Schmelzle:

All right.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm so far away from that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

, you're not as many steps as you think, but, but you, and, and even those

Glenn Schmelzle:

companies that are at the top and, and just plowing it back in, they now have

Glenn Schmelzle:

like this institutional discipline of measuring things like maniacs.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So you're gonna have to build up that muscle.

Glenn Schmelzle:

At some point along, I would encourage you to do it at the early stages

Glenn Schmelzle:

cuz you know, you're gonna need it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Right?

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, so I want to there's one last thing I wanted to get to.

Kevin Dieny:

I know, uh, we've been on, uh, there's some time, but you know,

Kevin Dieny:

this is just something I thought was really important and that is

Kevin Dieny:

I, it is my belief that marketing has to be something that's managed.

Kevin Dieny:

It's not something you turn on and sort of.

Kevin Dieny:

Turn it on and forget type of a situation.

Kevin Dieny:

Marketing does have the, even if it's performing well today does have

Kevin Dieny:

the requirement of managing that marketing campaign, effectiveness

Kevin Dieny:

budget, making sure even if it's all set to just do what it's been doing,

Kevin Dieny:

everything has entropy into case.

Kevin Dieny:

That's been my experience.

Kevin Dieny:

It's, that's shown me to be true across every channel, every marketing

Kevin Dieny:

thing I've ever done, it starts to decay people see the same message

Kevin Dieny:

and they start to ignore it.

Kevin Dieny:

So.

Kevin Dieny:

It leads me to.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay, well then that means it needs to be managed.

Kevin Dieny:

That needs to be managed at some frequency.

Kevin Dieny:

If it's, you know, someone from an agency, a freelance, in-house

Kevin Dieny:

a manager, just taking a look at it once a week or once a month.

Kevin Dieny:

So some frequency of it has to be on a always recurring basis

Kevin Dieny:

when there's marketing happening, spend going out the door.

Kevin Dieny:

So.

Kevin Dieny:

If that's happening.

Kevin Dieny:

If marketing spend, if you're a business where marketing spend is a regular part of

Kevin Dieny:

your day, regular part of your business, what are the practical tips or practical

Kevin Dieny:

strategies for measuring the effectiveness of marketing that you would have?

Kevin Dieny:

Maybe just like a few tips or anything you'd have for businesses

Kevin Dieny:

who are doing that today?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Definitely, I think the key is to, um, uh, unless I, you know,

Glenn Schmelzle:

reread the same ground that you have, um, an area where open conversations

Glenn Schmelzle:

can happen and where that marketer who may start to see a tapering off

Glenn Schmelzle:

of results, be saying to themselves, I wanna do something about this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

There has to be enough freedom and admission of.

Glenn Schmelzle:

What's not working so that they will say I'm okay to tell the person managing

Glenn Schmelzle:

me that we have to try something new.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I have to switch it up, uh, or I maybe have to kill a program

Glenn Schmelzle:

that we worked really hard on.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And that it's it's time beyond that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

The, I think the real gems come out of asking.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Within each one of these channels that we're using within each one of

Glenn Schmelzle:

the different types of headlines and messages that we're giving to our

Glenn Schmelzle:

prospects, it takes a willingness, particularly by the non marketer to

Glenn Schmelzle:

listen and probe how well those things are doing, because that's usually an

Glenn Schmelzle:

early warning sign of a need for a change.

Glenn Schmelzle:

How does that get measured?

Glenn Schmelzle:

The most practical thing that I wanna leave people with is if they are using

Glenn Schmelzle:

any marketing that is happening off of the website, but that is bringing someone

Glenn Schmelzle:

to the website, then they need to check out something called UTM parameters.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And we can include some information in the show notes on what those

Glenn Schmelzle:

are and how to build them.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Very simply though, they will.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Quietly ride along with that person as they make their way to your website.

Glenn Schmelzle:

But your analytics will now tell you so much about what

Glenn Schmelzle:

you were doing to bring them.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Were you talking about something that is seasonal in a post?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Were you talking about something that is a story of, you know, each one of

Glenn Schmelzle:

the frontline service people that you have and had a human interest angle?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Was it something that.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Raised a new regulation and, you know, had that, you know,

Glenn Schmelzle:

kind of spoke to people's heads.

Glenn Schmelzle:

There are so many of these things.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you start to track them more than just at the level, that would come

Glenn Schmelzle:

outta the box, by adding these little snippets, you can start to understand

Glenn Schmelzle:

what is really doing the heavy lifting it'll help you perhaps lighten your load

Glenn Schmelzle:

and get away from things that aren't.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Working for you, no matter how emotionally attached to you are to the creative,

Glenn Schmelzle:

but more importantly, it's going to give you that sense of I am managing this.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I, I absolutely know.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I've been listening out in the field and the stuff that I'm

Glenn Schmelzle:

hearing in the last couple of weeks is different than the marketing

Glenn Schmelzle:

that we designed three months ago.

Glenn Schmelzle:

We need to start plowing that into what we're doing in our marketing.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And we need to see if we can detect a change.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, that's really good.

Kevin Dieny:

I think what you're describing is like the feedback, uh, cycle

Kevin Dieny:

for marketing, which is deploy.

Kevin Dieny:

See how it went test.

Kevin Dieny:

If you can improve and then redeploy or deploy multiple and see how they're doing

Kevin Dieny:

and how they help each other, there, it, it can become a very complicated web of

Kevin Dieny:

attribution and, and also incre mentality of what's going on with marketing and

Kevin Dieny:

its effectiveness, but at its very basic, very basic core, I would say, I

Kevin Dieny:

mean just a kind of quick summarize here too for listeners is ask this question

Kevin Dieny:

yourself, do you know the effectiveness of your marketing in your business?

Kevin Dieny:

Do you know how effective it's being and, and when I say effective, what's

Kevin Dieny:

the first thing that pops in your head?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it sales?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it leads?

Kevin Dieny:

Uh, is it, is it a true prospect, someone who's a qualified fit for your business?

Kevin Dieny:

You know, is it just ringing the bell that's leads?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it a qualified lead, right?

Kevin Dieny:

That's a little different.

Kevin Dieny:

Is it, you know, the size of the sale, the average order value?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it the frequency, how often they're coming in?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it a specific product you're trying to move?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it a new area or territory you're trying to expand?

Kevin Dieny:

Is it, uh, The interactions engagements on the website and emails and social

Kevin Dieny:

there's so many things it could be.

Kevin Dieny:

Maybe it's all these things.

Kevin Dieny:

How well do you understand the effectiveness of your marketing today?

Kevin Dieny:

Great.

Kevin Dieny:

Okay.

Kevin Dieny:

So how often are you updating it then?

Kevin Dieny:

Okay, great.

Kevin Dieny:

It's effective today.

Kevin Dieny:

It may not be effective three months from now.

Kevin Dieny:

So what does that take to have an engine, right.

Kevin Dieny:

A marketing department in your business or an agency or whatever

Kevin Dieny:

that is that is generating a frequent.

Kevin Dieny:

Set of campaigns that either needs to be refreshed or parts of it that need to be

Kevin Dieny:

refreshed so that it's always gonna be delivering, improving, and, and guiding

Kevin Dieny:

your business and delivering back to you, insights, performance, results.

Kevin Dieny:

I think that all needs to be considered when you're looking at what's the

Kevin Dieny:

ROI of marketing and also that it aligns with your business goals.

Kevin Dieny:

I think marketing that just rings a bell, but that has night and to do with

Kevin Dieny:

the way the business wants to grow.

Kevin Dieny:

Is a, is sort of a waste because it's gotta align now.

Kevin Dieny:

Obviously things nobody's perfect ever, like Glenn said, human beings

Kevin Dieny:

are wildly unpredictable, so you'd need to just have feelers out there

Kevin Dieny:

and testing and feeling it out.

Kevin Dieny:

Was there anything else Glenn that we didn't say, or we didn't

Kevin Dieny:

mention before we close out here?

Glenn Schmelzle:

I love how you're, you know, committed to the process.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Maybe the one takeaway here is the answer to, you know, does it work?

Glenn Schmelzle:

Does it not work?

Glenn Schmelzle:

That's not gonna make anybody truly satisfied and we all

Glenn Schmelzle:

have a profit imperative.

Glenn Schmelzle:

So the sooner that we commit ourselves to learning all the things you said,

Glenn Schmelzle:

and watching this loop happen, the better off we're gonna be for it.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And, you know, I really do believe that marketing serves a business.

Glenn Schmelzle:

It's not the other way.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And so, you know, if you are either a principal or have been

Glenn Schmelzle:

entrusted as a manager in a business and you know that it is meant to

Glenn Schmelzle:

grow, then it'll just go better.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If you decide to take in what marketing can do and follow along on.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Process of inquiry that will eventually help your company.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I wholeheartedly believe it will, but I want you to see it, you know,

Glenn Schmelzle:

in proof in your actual numbers and in staff that can be hired and in

Glenn Schmelzle:

good things that can be done in the community in which the company is, this

Glenn Schmelzle:

is where it all ultimately should go.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Uh, and marketing is I think, an essential element to get you there.

Kevin Dieny:

Yeah, I'd like to echo that and also say, marketing is

Kevin Dieny:

something that, yes, it might, there are specialists, but it is a hat that

Kevin Dieny:

anyone can put on and reporting it, measuring it, seeing if it's successful.

Kevin Dieny:

It doesn't take a, a tech genius that you could do it.

Kevin Dieny:

And I, and I would like to echo that too, that what we're talking about

Kevin Dieny:

isn't only for all of the biggest companies or the most complicated

Kevin Dieny:

setups, anyone can do that.

Kevin Dieny:

So, Glenn, let's say someone wants to reach out to you, contact you and learn

Kevin Dieny:

more about you, your agency, or anything, your abouts, check out your podcast.

Kevin Dieny:

How can people find you?

Glenn Schmelzle:

And thanks for the opportunity, Kevin.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They're welcome to reach out to me.

Glenn Schmelzle:

I'm pretty, uh, visible on social media.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If they are into LinkedIn, they can come and look for Glenn Schmelzle.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They can look for, 'Hey GlennS' on other social platforms.

Glenn Schmelzle:

If they want to, go check out a podcast.

Glenn Schmelzle:

They can go on to whichever platform they're listening to this show on

Glenn Schmelzle:

and listen to Funnel Reboot, where we talk more to the marketer on

Glenn Schmelzle:

what they can do to get better.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And, uh, They're welcome to use any and all of those.

Kevin Dieny:

Well, Glenn, thank you so much for coming on and talking about

Kevin Dieny:

this topic and really, you know, I think putting some polish on marketing and ROI

Kevin Dieny:

on, you know, what it is, marketing's goals are how it fits into a business.

Kevin Dieny:

What success is we've really tackled and talked about.

Kevin Dieny:

A lot of we've been into some rabbit holes too.

Kevin Dieny:

So I think it's a really great.

Kevin Dieny:

Resource for our listeners to that, want to get more out of marketing

Kevin Dieny:

and wanna put marketing into a better position in their company.

Kevin Dieny:

So thanks, Glenn.

Glenn Schmelzle:

Thank you.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And that's what I hope to do.

Glenn Schmelzle:

And if anybody wants to reach out and carry it on farther, even if they want

Glenn Schmelzle:

to just find out more, uh, what's down one of those rabbit holes I'm game.

Kevin Dieny:

Oh, that sounds great.

Kevin Dieny:

All right, Glenn have, have a great day.

Kevin Dieny:

Thank you listeners for chiming into the Close the Loop podcast.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube