In this episode I share practical ways HR professionals and managers can better support employees at risk of redundancy throughout the process and not just procedurally, but personally too.
Drawing on my experience in HR, coaching and outplacement support, I explore the small actions that often make the biggest difference. From communication and empathy to financial signposting, job search support and helping people regain confidence, this episode has lots of thoughtful and practical ideas for organisations that want to handle redundancy with compassion and dignity.
Visit the Wildwood Coaching website
Sign up to hear about our next FREE 1 hour Redundancy Lunch and Learn
Financial well being episode: Apple Season 3 - Episode 4 Redundancy and Financial Wellbeing: Supporting People Through the Shock
Spotify: Season 3 - Episode 4 Redundancy and Financial Wellbeing: Supporting People Through the Shock
Preparing line managers episode: Apple Season 1 - Episode 8 Preparing line managers for redundancy consultation meetings
Spotify: Season 1 - Episode 8 Preparing line managers for redundancy consultation meetings
Why empathy matters: Apple Season 1 - Episode 5 Why empathy matters in redundancy
Spotify: Season 1 - Episode 5 Why empathy matters in redundancy
If you found this episode of Redundancy Matters helpful, please rate and review it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
If you’re kind enough to leave a review, please let June know so she can say thank you. You can always reach her at: [email protected]
Be notified each time a new episode of Redundancy Matters is released and get access to other free tools and resources by signing up to receive a free regular email from Wildwood Coaching.
Welcome to Redundancy
Matters with me, June Hogan.
2
:This is the podcast where I help
HR professionals and leaders
3
:managing redundancies to put
people at the heart of the process.
4
:And if you've not tuned in before,
it's really great to have you
5
:here, and thanks for listening.
6
:I'm a qualified career coach.
7
:I'm also an outplacement specialist, and
I've got a background in HR, and I've been
8
:working with individuals and organizations
navigating redundancy since:
9
:So today, I'm talking about some of the
practical things that you can do during
10
:a redundancy process that sit outside
of the formal consultation meetings.
11
:These are practical ideas that I hope
will help ensure that people feel heard
12
:and supported throughout the process.
13
:Now, I know from my own experience what
it can feel like to feel isolated during
14
:a redundancy process, and how much of
those kind of seemingly small things
15
:would've had a big impact on me, not
only, only during the process itself, but
16
:also afterwards when I began the work of
rebuilding my confidence and really trying
17
:to figure out what I was gonna do next.
18
:So these things that I'm sharing are
from my own experience on both sides
19
:of the redundancy table, from the years
of supporting clients with outplacement
20
:support, and reflecting on their feedback
on processes that landed well and
21
:maybe those that didn't land so well
22
:So I think sometimes we might
underestimate how much the small
23
:things really matter when you're
planning a redundancy process, or maybe
24
:you're focusing on the legal aspects.
25
:Perhaps there's pressure from the
leadership team to get all of this
26
:completed as soon as possible, as
there's a focus on cost and a focus
27
:on the timeline and all the planning.
28
:But there are lots of things that you
might not see on a spreadsheet or see
29
:on a plan that really make a difference.
30
:Things like the line manager who checks
in outside of those formal meetings,
31
:who's available, who really understands
and wants to speak to those members of
32
:their team who are at risk and offer
them support and guidance where they can.
33
:Then there's the HR manager who might
take a few minutes of their time to
34
:explain how recruiters shortlist CVs,
for example, because there'll be lots of
35
:people at risk of redundancy who haven't
had to look for a role in some time.
36
:Some people have never had to look for
a job, and I certainly see that when I
37
:work with individuals in outplacement
support who have had very long careers in
38
:some cases, and in some cases very, what
you would call successful careers, up
39
:to senior manager, director, and beyond,
and they've never had to look for a job.
40
:So that opportunity to just sit down
and spend some time with people,
41
:again, can make a big difference.
42
:Also, there's the willingness to
listen to what's going on for someone
43
:outside of those consultation meetings,
or perhaps someone who makes a warm
44
:introduction to their network and
offers insights on feedback and
45
:potential career direction for somebody.
46
:Really making sure that individuals
know that they matter even though
47
:they're going through a redundancy
consultation process because at that
48
:time nothing is final, no decisions
have been made, and they're still an
49
:employee and a member of the team.
50
:It could be the LinkedIn recommendation
or the support or comment on someone's
51
:open-to-work posts, for example,
or just the conversations around
52
:rebuilding confidence and recognizing
that redundancy doesn't affect
53
:everyone equally, and so some may need
more specific support than others.
54
:And those are some just a few of the
things that really matter to people
55
:that I know from my own experience and
also experience supporting clients.
56
:Because those are often the things that
people remember years later, and they're
57
:things that people share with me where
they felt like they were really treated
58
:like an individual and not just like a
number on a spreadsheet in a process.
59
:One of the things I also notice is
that there's often a misconception
60
:that communication can only happen
during formal consultation meetings.
61
:'Cause unfortunately, when communication
disappears or slows down, then people
62
:will fill in the gaps themselves,
and they'll usually do that with
63
:worst case scenario situations.
64
:So depending on the timeline for
consultation, there might not be much to
65
:say for a while after the announcement.
66
:But I'd recommend not leaving that void
for people to fill in the gaps themselves.
67
:So my recommendation would be to
communicate even when you have nothing
68
:to say, which might sound a bit weird.
69
:But reinforcing messages that might
not have landed completely the first
70
:time, and letting people know that
this is still on your radar, things
71
:are happening in the background, and
encouraging line managers to stay
72
:visible and accessible at all times.
73
:And for some line managers, this could
be their first time leading a process.
74
:They might not feel confident about
having informal meetings, but people
75
:don't necessarily expect their
managers to have all the answers.
76
:What they're looking for is their
presence and their support, and not
77
:the avoidance that I've sometimes
heard clients share with me that
78
:can happen after an announcement.
79
:Because they want someone to know that
they haven't disappeared just because
80
:the situation might feel a bit awkward.
81
:And some managers can get this
wrong because they become frightened
82
:of saying the wrong thing, so
then they say very little at all.
83
:But even if the line managers aren't
sure, then they can say so, and they
84
:can arrange to get answers or set up a
meeting with a member of the HR team.
85
:But being visible and supportive
is what really matters.
86
:It's not about knowing
everything, and it's also not
87
:about making things up either.
88
:Now, in terms of support, most
people don't need that kind of
89
:forced positivity at these times.
90
:The kind of, "Oh, you've got this, you'll
be fine," messaging, which comes from
91
:a place of good intentions, but doesn't
actually help anyone in that moment.
92
:Because honesty and empathy are
way more important than that.
93
:And I recorded a separate podcast on
the power of empathy in redundancy
94
:situations, and I'll put a link to that
in the show notes, because there's a huge
95
:difference between sympathy and empathy.
96
:So some line managers, and indeed,
you know, we, we're all, um,
97
:sort of guilty of this, I guess.
98
:And, um, empathy is harder than sympathy.
99
:But sympathy can be things like, "Oh,
well, at least you've got some money.
100
:At least you've got a good payout.
101
:I'm sure you'll land on your feet,
and everything happens for a reason."
102
:Now, these are unintentional because
they're not, that they don't come
103
:from a place of well-meaning.
104
:But what they do serve to do is
kind of push away what someone
105
:might be feeling and try to get
the conversation to move on.
106
:So if you've ever been on the other
end of one of those statements,
107
:you'll sort of think, "Oh, okay.
108
:Well, maybe you're right.
109
:Yeah.
110
:I, I have got some
money so that, that's...
111
:Yeah, I'll just stop talking
about that now, shall I?"
112
:Um, or, "Everything happens for a reason."
113
:Yeah, okay.
114
:Hmm.
115
:Yeah.
116
:Well, you might think that,
but, but maybe I don't.
117
:So- it's about moving the conversation
forward from that individual's
118
:perspective, rather than encouraging
the, uh, individual to open up and to
119
:talk more about what might be going on.
120
:So that sympathy can kind
of create the distance.
121
:Whereas empathy is more about
things like, "I'm, I can appreciate
122
:this is a difficult time for you.
123
:There's a lot of uncertainty,
and I guess that's very hard."
124
:Or things like, "You don't need to
have everything figured out right now."
125
:So those are sort of sometimes
reflective statements, but they just
126
:allow the individual to know that
you're happy for them to continue
127
:talking about what's on their mind.
128
:And also using silence is hugely
important as well to give the individual
129
:some time just to reflect and to think
about what they might want to say next.
130
:And one thing that I've learned from
coaching people through redundancy
131
:is that everyone is carrying often a
lot more than we might all realize.
132
:So I've worked with people who are
worried about their finances, people who
133
:on the surface of it you might not think
might be worried about their finances.
134
:I've worked with people who are worried
about their age, people who are wondering
135
:if their skills are still relevant, some
who haven't interviewed in 15 years or
136
:more, or ever, some who are trying to hold
everything together for their children
137
:while pretending that they're coping,
and others who are having to provide care
138
:and take on additional responsibilities
for their children, their relatives,
139
:and people within their community.
140
:And so that's a lot to deal
with when you've got redundancy
141
:on top of all of that as well.
142
:So it's about being able to support
people, to look for the signs, to
143
:have those open conversations, and
to importantly signpost where there
144
:might be extra support or specialist
support that might be needed.
145
:And again, I'll put a link in the show
notes to a free download that I've got
146
:that gives some guidance on signposting.
147
:And we'll come on to talk about financial
signposting in a minute as well,
148
:'cause I think that's something that's
really important to help to support
149
:people through the process as well.
150
:So there might be some people
for whom redundancy is a relief,
151
:so I certainly have worked with
individuals in that situation.
152
:So for some people who were planning
to leave anyway perhaps, but just
153
:didn't know how to or had the courage
to, it could be that they are excited
154
:and looking forward to leaving, maybe
financially this is the best thing for
155
:them So those people are gonna need
support too in how to manage their
156
:reactions and their emotions in front
of others for whom this is devastating.
157
:And so I think they can still be
empathetic towards colleagues, but
158
:they might need some support from
yourselves or from line managers
159
:on how they do that in the best
way, and what does that empathetic
160
:approach really look like for people.
161
:So as well as these things, I
think there's some real value
162
:in asking what people, what
support would actually help them.
163
:So asking those at risk what
support they need, and then
164
:gathering topics for group sessions.
165
:So you can use the employee reps for
this, um, if you're in collective
166
:consultation, or you can do it in
individual meetings if you're not.
167
:And what this does is it really
helps to give people a sense of some
168
:control when the process can feel
out of control and overwhelming.
169
:You're asking them what would they
want and helping them to make some
170
:decisions and have some agency
and advocacy over these things.
171
:Because the support that you're
going to offer, and you may have
172
:already lined up some support, you
may already have an outplacement
173
:provider in place, for example, it's
only supportive if it feels relevant.
174
:So if you are using an outplacement
provider, then I'd encourage you to ask
175
:them if they can tailor their support.
176
:Or if you're doing things internally,
then really making sure you're
177
:providing what people actually need,
not what you think they might need.
178
:So for example, I recently
worked with a client who was...
179
:who had asked for a workshop,
and they wanted to include a
180
:section on presentation skills
as part of a recruitment process.
181
:This is something that came up during
collective consultation, and so I was able
182
:to adapt and tailor the workshop to suit.
183
:I've also had requests in the past for
specific support in specialist areas such
184
:as the design and creative space, and
I've been able to arrange that for people.
185
:So if you're in doing this internally,
you could set up something simple like
186
:informal lunch and learn sessions,
and you can use the internal talent
187
:team if you have a talent team or
working with the HR team yourselves.
188
:And this is an opportunity to bring some
really great value to people because we
189
:often forget what feels obvious to us
is completely unfamiliar to someone who
190
:hasn't had to look for a job in a while.
191
:People don't really know how
recruitment works, and there's lots
192
:of noise online about some things
which are completely untrue and other
193
:things which are just made up for
kind of clickbait on social media.
194
:So people don't know how
applicant tracking systems work.
195
:People don't understand how AI
fits into a recruitment process.
196
:They don't really get that recruitment
might be very different to how it was when
197
:they were previously looking for a role.
198
:There's the kind of one-page CV advice
conflicting with the two-page CV advice
199
:And maybe when they last applied for
a role, it wasn't about tailoring your
200
:applications and CVs, you just kind of had
one and you sent it off to lots of people.
201
:So when people un- don't understand
something, then particularly when
202
:there's a lot of ghosting within the
recruitment process at the moment,
203
:there's a lot of people putting time
and effort into applications and then
204
:hearing nothing, then they can assume
that it's a kind of a personal thing.
205
:Maybe they're not good enough.
206
:Maybe, you know, that's it,
they'll never find another job.
207
:So I think bringing some reality to
how the recruitment process works
208
:is a really useful thing that the HR
team can do for people, um, just to
209
:prepare them and to bring them up to
date with best practice, et cetera.
210
:And I think it's also great to be
realistic about this with people
211
:from the start so they're not
building up false hope about what
212
:that landscape might look like.
213
:Now, practical support is super
helpful and so some of those things
214
:that I've just described really
focus on things that are practical.
215
:And bringing in an outplacement provider,
they can do this, that's their specialism,
216
:that's what they do, or you can ask,
uh, to have individual support if that's
217
:more appropriate or if you're only
running, um, a small reorganization.
218
:But it's about helping people to build
their confidence at what can be a
219
:difficult time with a lot of uncertainty.
220
:Another area I think organizations
sometimes underestimate is the
221
:financial fear that redundancy creates.
222
:So I've worked with, you know, what on
the surface of it are highly capable,
223
:senior or financially stable employees.
224
:They can still experience huge
anxiety when the uncertainty about
225
:their regular income appears.
226
:And often people won't openly admit
that they're worried about these sorts
227
:of things 'cause there can be a huge
amount of shame attached to redundancy.
228
:So they'll talk about things like
updating their CV or applying for jobs,
229
:but underneath all of that, there might
be a panic about mortgage payments,
230
:childcare costs, their pensions, or
maybe even just how long their savings
231
:are realistically gonna last them.
232
:So practical financial wellbeing support
can make a huge difference, not just
233
:kind of a general wellbeing message,
but it's the practical guidance.
234
:And I'll put a link in the show notes to
a really great session that I had with
235
:money expert Abi Birch, who's got some
super useful and practical tips on how
236
:to signpost and support people at risk
without treading over those boundaries.
237
:Because this isn't about you as a HR
professional or as a line manager digging
238
:into someone's finances and offering
them personal advice and information.
239
:It's about having the opportunity to
signpost them to those people who can.
240
:But you could include sessions from a
specialist around budgeting, bring in
241
:your pension provider, for example,
explaining how redundancy pay and tax
242
:implications work, and then signposting
to debt, mortgage advice support, or
243
:simply just helping people understand
what financial resources and potential
244
:benefits that could be available to them.
245
:Because when people are emotionally
overwhelmed, then that kind of financial
246
:uncertainty just really increases.
247
:And of course, there's the emotional
impact of redundancy, which I talk
248
:about a lot on the podcast, and I've
coached senior leaders who suddenly
249
:feel completely lost after redundancy
because work was a huge part of their
250
:identity, a huge part of their life,
and that emotional side of redundancy
251
:is something that organizations might
unintentionally overlook because
252
:they're really focused on the process.
253
:But redundancy for anyone, no matter how
senior you are, is emotional, even when
254
:people expect it, because it's still
attached to way more than an income.
255
:It's still attached to identity and
self-esteem and how people show up
256
:in the world and their place in the
world and their sense of purpose.
257
:And even when maybe they dislike their
job or they got a good package, those
258
:emotions can still come out, maybe not
straight away, but they will come out
259
:because there's the grief, the loss of
routine, and sometimes even the shame of
260
:redundancy, no matter how it's come about.
261
:So there's a lot of unpacking there
to do, and I think that's one of
262
:the benefits of career coaching
as part of outplacement support.
263
:And so when redundancy can feel
like it's out of control for people,
264
:then regaining a sense of control is
something that's in your gift that you
265
:can do during the consultation process.
266
:So often res- decisions are
happening behind closed doors, maybe
267
:timelines might feel a bit uncertain.
268
:People might be having incomplete
information because decisions haven't
269
:been finally made, and so this can all
compound the feelings of confidence
270
:and powerlessness So I think if you
can actively look for ways to help
271
:people regain that sense of control,
and that might mean maybe allowing
272
:flexibility for interviews so everyone's
entitled to reasonable time off
273
:if they're at risk of redundancy.
274
:So being flexible as much
as you can about that.
275
:It might mean encouraging managers to
protect some time during the week to
276
:support people with looking at their CVs
or helping them to have access to the
277
:technology to sign up for job updates and
to do recruitment research, et cetera.
278
:It might mean offering different
types of support for different
279
:groups of people so that they can
feel that they're being treated
280
:according to their particular needs.
281
:And simply giving people choices as
well and asking them that question,
282
:you know, "What do you need right now?"
283
:Because depending on how long the
consultation process is depends on
284
:how long you've got to offer people
support, and that support might change
285
:at times during, uh, the consultation.
286
:'Cause that choice really matters, and
even those small moments of autonomy can
287
:really help to restore some confidence and
give people that sense of dignity as well.
288
:I've talked a lot about line managers
throughout all of this because they do
289
:have to carry very much of the process.
290
:Yes, as an HR team, we're there
to support people, but they will
291
:be seeing members of their team
go, and that can be really hard.
292
:And some of them can be
delivering messages that they
293
:fundamentally disagree with.
294
:Some of them are quietly
terrified of upsetting people
295
:because it's a difficult message.
296
:Maybe they've not had to do it before.
297
:And some will just emotionally
detach because they don't know how to
298
:handle difficult conversations, and
others become a bit kind of overly
299
:optimistic because they really can't,
uh, tolerate sort of sitting with that
300
:discomfort and that uncomfortableness.
301
:So managers need coaching through this
too and real guidance to communicate
302
:like a person, not like a robot,
not like someone reading a script.
303
:And I'll put a link in the show notes
to a couple of episodes that can help
304
:in terms of preparing line managers
for redundancy consultation meetings.
305
:Because as I said before, people
don't expect perfection from their
306
:managers during this situation, but
they do notice when they're absent.
307
:They do notice when they're avoiding them.
308
:And they do notice when
they're not showing up.
309
:So it's important to maintain that
connection and not just to move
310
:into sort of a cold procedural
mode because line managers are
311
:afraid of saying the wrong thing.
312
:So building in this coaching up front,
checking in with them during the process,
313
:and making time for them along the
way just to check in on how they're
314
:doing as well is an important part of
supporting people through the process
315
:And of course, I talk a lot
about this on the podcast.
316
:It's important to remember that how an
organization handles redundancy really
317
:shapes the trust during the process,
but also after the process ends.
318
:Because the people who
remain are still watching.
319
:The future candidates who will be joining
your organization will hear those stories.
320
:It's a very small world.
321
:And beyond that kind of reputation and
employer brand that is important, it's
322
:just about humanity and being a human
and doing the right thing for people.
323
:Because most people understand that
businesses will need to restructure.
324
:But what most people struggle to
forgive is that feeling of feeling
325
:discarded during that process.
326
:And so sometimes the support someone
receives during redundancy becomes the
327
:thing that helps them rebuild faster.
328
:And whilst you won't be able to remove
the pain of redundancy entirely because
329
:it's a necessary business decision,
you can change how someone feels about
330
:it while they're going through it.
331
:And that's what I hope that this podcast
helps people to do, to support people
332
:through redundancy with kindness,
with compassion, and with dignity.
333
:And so I hope that help- the episode's
been helpful today, and really thank
334
:you so much for listening, and I
hope you'll tune in again soon.
335
:Thank you so much for listening
to the Redundancy Matters podcast.
336
:I hope you found today's episode helpful.
337
:It would mean a lot to me if you
would follow rate and review this
338
:podcast wherever you listen to your
podcasts, as this helps it reach more
339
:people who are managing redundancies.
340
:Let me know what you thought,
and if you have ideas for future
341
:episodes, I'd love to hear from you.
342
:You can find me on LinkedIn, June
Hogan, and get in touch via my
343
:website, wildwood coaching.co.uk,
344
:where you'll also find more resources
to help you manage redundancies.
345
:I hope you'll join me again soon for
the next episode of Redundancy Matters.