Summary:
Elaine Power, a food scholar at Queen's University, argues that the word "AgriFood" itself encodes a fundamental contradiction: the agri side serves corporate capital while the food side is rooted in care, community, and life. In this conversation with Jesse Hirsh, Power traces how invisible and undervalued labour—from racialized farmworkers to domestic cooks—holds the food system together while extracting the least reward from it. Her analysis connects feminist political economy, the ultra-processed food industry, and ecological crisis into a single, unflinching diagnosis of what is broken and why.
Show notes:
Elaine Power is a food scholar at Queen's University whose career has moved fluidly across dietetics, feminist political economy, and food systems research. In this episode, she joins Jesse Hirsh to explore a tension embedded in the very language we use to describe the sector: that "AgriFood" quietly names two opposing logics—one oriented toward capital accumulation, the other toward nourishment, care, and sustaining life. That friction, Power argues, is not incidental. It is the organizing contradiction of the modern food system, and almost everything that is broken about that system flows from it.
Power's first major insight is about the systematic invisibility of labour across the entire food chain. From temporary foreign workers doing backbreaking fieldwork in Canadian agriculture, to grocery clerks briefly celebrated as heroes during the pandemic before being returned to minimum wage and precarious shifts, to the uncompensated domestic labour that happens in every kitchen—Power argues that the people who actually feed us are consistently rendered invisible and undervalued. She connects this pattern explicitly to race and gender: agricultural labour in North America has historically been and remains largely racialized, while domestic food labour has been feminized and therefore dismissed. The feminist movement's fraught relationship with the kitchen, she notes, was a rational response to that devaluation—but it created an opening that corporate food manufacturers eagerly filled with ultra-processed products that monetized the very work society refused to honour.
A second tension Power surfaces is convenience. The agro-industrial food system did not simply respond to a demand for convenience—it manufactured and deepened that demand, replacing the social and nutritional value of cooking with cheap ingredients repackaged as food-like products. Power draws on Tony Winson's concept of "pseudo-foods" to argue that the profit logic of large food multinationals is structurally opposed to genuine nourishment. Meanwhile, the ecological costs of industrial agriculture—she cites hydrogen sulphide poisoning from seaweed blooms caused by fertilizer runoff off the coast of France as a vivid, lethal example—are externalized onto communities and ecosystems that have no seat at the table. Revaluing real food and the labour that produces it, she suggests, would require confronting capitalism's tendency to invert what actually matters.
Listeners will come away from this conversation with a sharper vocabulary for naming what feels wrong about the food system and a clearer sense of why reforming it demands more than consumer choice or technological fixes. For anyone working in or thinking about Canada's agri-food sector, Power's analysis is a necessary provocation: the sector cannot build a legitimate future without honestly accounting for whose labour it depends on, whose health it sacrifices, and whose voices it continues to exclude. In a moment when food security, trade disruption, and climate pressure are converging, this episode makes the case that the most radical thing the sector could do is take care seriously.
Topics: Labour Invisibility, Feminist Food Politics, Ultra-Processed Food, Corporate Agri-Food, Convenience Culture, Racialized Farm Labour, Food System Values, Ecological Crisis
Hi, I'm Jesse Hirsch.
Jesse Hirsh:Welcome to the Future Herd.
Jesse Hirsh:Today's episode is a banger, one of those incendiary conversations that just
Jesse Hirsh:kind of feels dangerous, that makes you wanna kind of hide somewhere, where no
Jesse Hirsh:one's gonna see how you react to it, or whether you laugh, whether you gasp,
Jesse Hirsh:whether you start to have revelations about a completely different food system.
Jesse Hirsh:Elaine Power is the kind of intellectual that not only does Canada
Jesse Hirsh:produce, but we sure need a whole lot more from, or at least we need
Jesse Hirsh:to listen to a whole lot more from.
Jesse Hirsh:And Elaine is kind of the person who, quite frankly, uh, reinvigorates my
Jesse Hirsh:desire to use this podcast as a platform for provocation, as a platform for
Jesse Hirsh:thoughtful policy as we kind of allude to at the conclusion of our conversation,
Jesse Hirsh:but also to really encourage people to think about food and our relationship
Jesse Hirsh:to food in an entirely new manner.
Jesse Hirsh:Now, full disclosure, I recorded this conversation in May and then sat on it
Jesse Hirsh:for a while, and part because it, it, it is so radical, it is so refreshing.
Jesse Hirsh:It is, if anything, kind of dangerous to the status quo.
Jesse Hirsh:And I wanted to make sure that we had a certain amount of political and, uh, uh,
Jesse Hirsh:policy diversity, uh, in the can, kind of in our knowledge base before we lit
Jesse Hirsh:fire to it all by chatting with Elaine.
Jesse Hirsh:Now, granted, I am hyping up this conversation in hopes that
Jesse Hirsh:you are excited to listen to it.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, this is where I will remind you that if this isn't the first time you've
Jesse Hirsh:listened to this podcast, go and give us a rating somewhere, anywhere that
Jesse Hirsh:other people might be able to access the episodes we're putting together.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, it certainly helps give us feedback, but more importantly, it helps give,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, the knowledge and the conversations that we're producing some traction.
Jesse Hirsh:'cause that's really the moral responsibility I felt after having
Jesse Hirsh:this conversation with Elaine, that on the one hand we face, uh, some really
Jesse Hirsh:challenging and difficult times ahead.
Jesse Hirsh:But on the other hand, there is a range of policy ideas, cultural
Jesse Hirsh:ideas, solutions that would really transform society and our food in,
Jesse Hirsh:in a way that is truly revolutionary.
Jesse Hirsh:So enough hype, uh, let's get into the episode.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, without any further ado, here's a lane power.
Jesse Hirsh:Elaine, welcome to the Future Herd.
Elaine:Thank you so much.
Elaine:I'm delighted to be here.
Jesse Hirsh:Now, I, I've kind of worked up a ritual where the first
Jesse Hirsh:question is meant to be a kind of intuitive, uh, almost roar shot test.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, what does the future mean to you?
Elaine:Oh my gosh, the future.
Jesse Hirsh:It's a loaded word.
Jesse Hirsh:What could I say?
Elaine:It, it is Jessie.
Elaine:Um, I am kind of worried about our future, I have to say, uh,
Elaine:with no matter which way you turn, uh, it feels pretty messed up.
Elaine:so I'm worried about, uh, democracy.
Elaine:I'm worried about the food system.
Elaine:I'm worried about the climate crisis.
Elaine:I'm worried about the food system.
Elaine:It's all kind of messed up.
Elaine:I have a, I have a 19-year-old, and of course I teach young people.
Elaine:I, I was teaching this past term, I was teaching, of course, on the food system,
Elaine:and I had to work really hard not to just really burden them completely,
Elaine:like, like kind of, you know, um, all in that, all encompassing sense of doom
Elaine:and dread and despair because the food, the, the dominant, the agro industrial
Elaine:food system is totally messed up.
Elaine:I, I, I'll, I'll refrain from using profanity, but, um,
Jesse Hirsh:You may,
Elaine:really is
Jesse Hirsh:this is the benefit of podcast is we could fucking square.
Jesse Hirsh:There's privileges there,
Elaine:so if a system is really fucked up, it's really fucked
Elaine:up no matter which way you turn.
Elaine:So, yeah, so,
Jesse Hirsh:on.
Elaine:my, I mean, they, they, the young people I taught this year, um, they,
Elaine:they seemed, they seemed inspired by my passion for the subject and they also
Elaine:seemed to get that I cared about them as people and this messed up system.
Elaine:So, uh, and, but one, one day after class.
Elaine:One of the very bright young women came up to me and said,
Elaine:how do you stay optimistic?
Elaine:No.
Elaine:How do you stay hopeful?
Elaine:And I, and I, I refrain from saying, well, I'm not very hopeful.
Elaine:And then proceeded to, um, to talk about, you know, watching the birds
Elaine:in my backyard, um, as a, as a way to maintain my sense of stability
Elaine:and groundedness in the world.
Elaine:Um, I, every week in the class, I would do a section, you know, that I called in
Elaine:the news about things that were happening that we generally, um, in the news about
Elaine:that had some relation to the food system.
Elaine:It's very depressing.
Elaine:And so after she asked that question, um, the next week it was March, and
Elaine:the next week I put up pictures of, you know, the robins and the crocuses.
Elaine:Like, is really the only way to stay for me anyway, to stay from
Elaine:descending into total despair.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, and there is a kind of paradox between, on the one hand,
Jesse Hirsh:I, I think a growing sense that our food system is at risk, that our, our,
Jesse Hirsh:our global climate system is at risk.
Jesse Hirsh:I'm personally feeling 2026 may be a breaking point on a number of different
Jesse Hirsh:fronts, and yet every day I'm eating food that gives me pleasure and every
Jesse Hirsh:day I'm learning more about food that makes me feel more human and makes me
Jesse Hirsh:even feel healthier as I age, which was a paradox I had not anticipated
Jesse Hirsh:or, or, and certainly welcome.
Elaine:Yeah.
Jesse Hirsh:I do try to focus our conversations here on the podcast on kind
Jesse Hirsh:of the present and the future, I do feel a little bit of kind of responsibility
Jesse Hirsh:to my audience to spend a little bit at the beginning, not so much on origin
Jesse Hirsh:story, but getting a sense of where the guest's perspectives come from.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and in your case, you've had a, a really interesting dance between
Jesse Hirsh:your political interests and your research interests, where they are
Jesse Hirsh:clearly reinforcing each other, but you're not necessarily the kind
Jesse Hirsh:of academic or politically engaged person who has focused on a specific
Jesse Hirsh:issue and stuck with that issue.
Jesse Hirsh:W. It's guided your journey.
Jesse Hirsh:And I say that 'cause you could have ended up anywhere championing any policy
Jesse Hirsh:or fighting any, you know, tyranny.
Jesse Hirsh:But the, the causes and the issues you've chosen kind of speak to maybe
Jesse Hirsh:not a logic, maybe a, a method.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I don't know.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I'm curious if, if only because I, in, in sort of learning more about
Jesse Hirsh:your background, I was blown away.
Jesse Hirsh:I was like, wow, that, that seems like you had a really fun time.
Jesse Hirsh:Even though to your point, you're dealing with issues that are kind
Jesse Hirsh:of depressing and, and, and kind of difficult, uh, on an empathic level.
Jesse Hirsh:To wrap your head around, I'm doing what I do, which is ramble.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, Elaine, uh, uh, help me out here.
Jesse Hirsh:H how, how, how did you get to where you are now?
Jesse Hirsh:Was it entirely accidental or were there some driving principles along the way?
Elaine:I think, you know, I'm from the East coast.
Elaine:I, I grew up in Nova Scotia and, uh, I, I feel like the wind blew me here.
Elaine:Um, I don't, it's funny you should say that, this, because I was just, I'm
Elaine:just working on a paper right now that has a revise and resubmit and I'm kind
Elaine:of rethinking the literature review and thinking it's only I had specialised a
Elaine:little more, but it's not in my nature.
Elaine:I, I am kind of, I'm one of those people who likes to see the, like,
Elaine:to make the connections among the, the bigger the, in the big picture.
Elaine:And so, um, you know, the, the book that got me interested in food and
Elaine:food systems was Francis Mo La Pe Diet For a Lonely Planet, or, yeah,
Elaine:no Diet For What, what's it called?
Elaine:Diet.
Elaine:Diet for a Hungry Planet, not Lonely Planet.
Elaine:That's, that's the Travel People Diet for a Hungry Planet.
Elaine:which I read as an undergraduate, which is a long time ago now.
Elaine:And, um, uh, I got really interested in the politics of food because of
Elaine:that book and the idea that, uh, you know, we had lots of food and, uh,
Elaine:we, we, we needed, you know, to figure out how to distribute it better.
Elaine:and the idea that we didn't need, you know, meat necessarily to have a, a
Elaine:healthy diet and to have enough protein.
Elaine:Um, that kind of set me on a, on a journey that is long and rambly.
Elaine:And as I say, I think the wind kind of blew me here, but, um, I don't know if
Elaine:that answers your question, but Thank you.
Elaine:Uh, uh, it's kind of reassuring, especially today to that, um, to
Elaine:think about the, you know, the, the pieces that all came together
Elaine:to, to put me here, which honestly sometimes feels like a cosmic joke.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, it does set up a natural follow up, which is why do
Jesse Hirsh:you think that food, both as an area of research, but also as an area of
Jesse Hirsh:practise, whether formally or informally, professionally or personally, why do you
Jesse Hirsh:think it lends itself to generalists?
Jesse Hirsh:Because as you were describing that, I was thinking not just of the people I've
Jesse Hirsh:interviewed as part of this podcast, but the people I've admired and I've enjoyed
Jesse Hirsh:that they were, for the most part, people who were interested in a lot of stuff and
Jesse Hirsh:they used those interests as ingredients to make themselves and the food or art or
Jesse Hirsh:research that they create even greater.
Jesse Hirsh:So I, I'm curious, given, you know, the time you spent in these circles,
Jesse Hirsh:whether you, whether you agree, whether you think that this is an area in
Jesse Hirsh:which generalists are kind of not only encouraged to thrive, do thrive.
Elaine:Yeah, absolutely.
Elaine:And I mean, uh, as you know, I, I think food is fascinating and it can lead you
Elaine:in, it can lead you in so many directions.
Elaine:I mean, from the very personal, um, you know, it's something we all
Elaine:need every day, several times a day.
Elaine:Um, it's, it's, you know, it's biological, it's physical, it's
Elaine:cultural, it's, uh, symbolic.
Elaine:It's, it can take in so many different directions into history, into art, into
Elaine:food systems, into the, you know, the, the big picture, the small picture.
Elaine:Um, I don't, I don't know, there's nothing really quite like it.
Elaine:Uh, I mean, and it's a source of pleasure, um, you know, kind of Uh, so from the very
Elaine:small, I mean, I, I did spend a few years as a dietitian, so you kind of thinking
Elaine:about, you know, nutrients and all the way through to, know, the, the climate
Elaine:crisis and, you know, global issues, and you in the news, you know, the Strait of
Elaine:Horror News, the war that's, that's going on right now, that's gonna have a huge,
Elaine:people are gonna die because food prices are gonna go up and, uh, they, they won't
Elaine:be able to afford the food that they eat.
Elaine:So it, it feels like something that connects both in both directions from
Elaine:the very, um, minutia to the, the global.
Elaine:And, and there's, like I say, there's delight and despair at
Elaine:the same moment, um, in food, in, in my pers from my perspective.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and again, you're sort of helping me understand my
Jesse Hirsh:own interests, my own appeal to here, and, and I think it is because
Jesse Hirsh:food allows us to connect the dots.
Jesse Hirsh:It, it allows us to see how politics and economics and culture and family
Jesse Hirsh:and, and, and our sense of being all kind of relate to each other, how
Jesse Hirsh:these systems all impact each other.
Jesse Hirsh:So still on the big picture piece, you know, I kind of inherited
Jesse Hirsh:the word AgriFood when I started this podcast in that it was not
Jesse Hirsh:necessarily something I thought about.
Jesse Hirsh:It was just some, a word I heard other people use.
Jesse Hirsh:And it was it by default, part of the framing of the EPIs of the podcast.
Jesse Hirsh:And you were one of the first person to kind of poke at that word when I
Jesse Hirsh:started communicating with you and, and got me thinking about where it
Jesse Hirsh:came from and the role that it serves.
Jesse Hirsh:And to phrase this in the form of a, a kind of question or observation,
Jesse Hirsh:it strikes me that there's a real contradiction in the phrase AgriFood.
Jesse Hirsh:And as I unpack it, it kind of feels that the agri side is really kind of
Jesse Hirsh:right wing in its view of the world.
Jesse Hirsh:And the food side is really kind of left wing in terms of its view of the world.
Jesse Hirsh:And I'm not sure how conscious this kind of setup is, whether it's like
Jesse Hirsh:deliberately evoking the French National Assembly or whatever.
Jesse Hirsh:Am I wrong in sensing this kind of political, uh, uh, polarisation or
Jesse Hirsh:political balance that has been created?
Elaine:Wow, that, um, I've never thought of that, Jesse.
Elaine:I think it might be a really, um, it might be kind of illuminating, uh, you know,
Elaine:certainly, uh, agro or agri, you know, we have AgriFood, um, tends to for sure
Elaine:represent, I think corporate interests.
Elaine:Uh, the, there's another little part of me that says that the national,
Elaine:the people I know who are part of the National Farmers Union would kind of,
Elaine:would object to that, because of course there are also the, the small and medium
Elaine:sized farmers, which probably you're one.
Elaine:Um, uh, but, yeah, I think you might be onto something there.
Elaine:because, you know, the agra, the corporate, the corporate side of things is
Elaine:really, um, well, capitalism in general, I think turns things of value upside down.
Elaine:So that, and in the food system, the corporate food companies, those
Elaine:big multinationals are really all about creating, I think it was Tony
Elaine:Winston who said, they're like, create pseudo foods, you know,
Elaine:because that's how they make money.
Elaine:They take cheap ingredients and they turn it into something that we, call food.
Elaine:But really, you know, certainly in terms of ultra processed um, are
Elaine:just a vehicle for making money.
Elaine:And, uh, they might have some calories in them, but are really very, you know,
Elaine:they don't sustain life, and they're very destructive planet and for the,
Elaine:for the, you know, the natural world.
Elaine:So, yeah, I think you might be onto something there.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and, and I say this only because I am trying to understand
Jesse Hirsh:these systems and the different dynamics in them, and I have always been alienated
Jesse Hirsh:from the agricultural side in that I, I don't feel that they are including
Jesse Hirsh:either the voices or the analysis or even, quite frankly, the data to,
Jesse Hirsh:to understand the sector they're in.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and a key point that, that you often bring up that I wouldn't mind
Jesse Hirsh:kind of unpacking for people, 'cause it, it, it strikes me as both self-evident
Jesse Hirsh:but also ignored is the extent to which labour in our food system is either
Jesse Hirsh:unrecognised or radically undervalued.
Jesse Hirsh:And I think farmers understand this.
Jesse Hirsh:Farmers very much feel that their labour is undervalued largely.
Jesse Hirsh:But I I'd love to hear your, your kind of, uh, insight or understanding of this.
Jesse Hirsh:'cause I suspect that it, to your point, really emphasises the values that we come
Jesse Hirsh:to the AgriFood or the food system with.
Elaine:I'm just, I'm just repeatedly struck by the, labour that's invisible,
Elaine:uh, and or undervalued, if you think right from the, from the, from the farm.
Elaine:Um, if you think about, you know, bigger, more corporate farms that
Elaine:are employing in Canada, you know, temporary foreign workers or undocumented
Elaine:workers, um, labourers whose they're doing backbreaking work, um, that
Elaine:is, uh, under totally undervalued.
Elaine:They're feed, they're, they're feeding us, and yet, and that which is, you
Elaine:know, the basis of life for humanity.
Elaine:And yet we, we treat them poorly.
Elaine:We, we don't, we, we, they're invisible.
Elaine:They're wages are low.
Elaine:They're, they have long hours.
Elaine:Um, we send them home when we don't need them anymore.
Elaine:at, you know, with, with disruption of family ties and, uh, you know, all kinds
Elaine:of, um, uh, you know, dysfunctional relationships because they're
Elaine:travelling back and forth all the time.
Elaine:So from there to the supermarket where, you know, the, we, we gave, uh, workers,
Elaine:you know, heroes pay during the pandemic for a few months and then went back to,
Elaine:you know, minimum wages, uh, broken ships not, you know, not took full-time work.
Elaine:Um, low rates of, uh, you know, unionisation and benefits and
Elaine:all the rest to the, the domestic kitchen where, you know, um, with,
Elaine:and the thing about food is that it, it's actually, it's a lot of work.
Elaine:And so, um, you know, every, it seems like those who are able to wanna
Elaine:shuffle it off onto other people.
Elaine:You know, the, the second wave feminists in the sixties and seventies
Elaine:wanted nothing to do with the kitchen because it, because it is
Elaine:undervalued and because it is, you know, invisible and it's so much work.
Elaine:Um, and so, you know, the, the big corporate aggro man, food man, quote
Elaine:unquote food manufacturers, you know, started with TV dinners, but,
Elaine:you know, have, have capitalised on, like literally on this, um.
Elaine:The, the work and the undervaluing of food.
Elaine:So in a way, um, it's like, yeah.
Elaine:So I think those of us in who are food scholars who also think of ourselves as
Elaine:feminists, you know, have had to work at, um, bringing, um, that, trying to
Elaine:point out that this is, this work is fundamental to human life and, uh, it,
Elaine:it needs to be more valued than it is.
Elaine:So, um, I don't, I, I think because it's been women who are, you know, uh, at
Elaine:least, uh, in the domestic fear sphere, I think, you know, in the, the agricultural
Elaine:sphere, they're often racialized.
Elaine:You know, we, we think, you know, I think about, in the US with, you know,
Elaine:that it was black people, slaves who laboured in the fields, um, and it's
Elaine:still, you know, mostly racialized people in the, in the fields, uh,
Elaine:whether it's in the US or in Canada.
Elaine:Um, you know, I think, I, I don't, I, you know, as you were speaking, I thought
Elaine:about France where, um, you know, there is certainly more, more emphasis put on
Elaine:the, on cultural aspects of food, but I think their food system is also still
Elaine:very much, uh, based on exploitation of, of labour and, and the environment.
Elaine:I was just reading a piece in The Guardian this morning about seaweed blooms off
Elaine:the coast of France that, um, from agricultural runoff fertilisers and,
Elaine:and manure, um, that it, you know, it's, it's actually, it's literally killing
Elaine:people who, who step on these, you know, up to five feet deep piles of seaweed
Elaine:and it's releasing hydrogen sulphide and kill, like, literally killing people.
Elaine:Um, and, you know, undoubtedly also killing fish and, you
Elaine:know, wildlife and so on.
Elaine:So, uh, back to the original, you know, this is really depressing.
Elaine:It's really dark, but, uh, but yes, I think the, you know, know what it will
Elaine:take to re if we, if we were able to revalue food and the, the, like, real food
Elaine:and the labour that produces it, uh, I think we would, we would the world because
Elaine:it's so much at the heart of, of life.
Jesse Hirsh:And as an aside, when you were at the beginning talking about your
Jesse Hirsh:students', often reaction to you and, and, and I, what I was hearing in your
Jesse Hirsh:observation was that on some level, in spite of your best efforts to help these
Jesse Hirsh:students understand the horrors that await them, you are nonetheless inspiring them.
Jesse Hirsh:And I think that inspiration partly comes from acknowledging what
Jesse Hirsh:everyone is seeing, but hardly anyone is willing to talk about.
Jesse Hirsh:And I, I, I think you did that just there.
Jesse Hirsh:And I want to unpack a little because.
Jesse Hirsh:You sort of alluded to something that I'm kind of passionate about myself, which
Jesse Hirsh:is the, the curse of convenience that, you know, we've been sold this myth that,
Jesse Hirsh:you know, convenience is good, whether it comes to our food, whether it comes to our
Jesse Hirsh:social interactions, in my case, whether it comes to our technology, when, you
Jesse Hirsh:know, there's value in making a healthy meal, uh, especially with others, right?
Jesse Hirsh:And making that meal and sharing that labour and eating that food there,
Jesse Hirsh:there's community building there, there, there's a social ritual there.
Jesse Hirsh:So I'm, I'm curious, and, and you kind of alluded to this, but I'm curious on a, on
Jesse Hirsh:a political level, both on the, the, the, the plane of community, but also higher.
Jesse Hirsh:When we think about society, how do we counter the, that culture of convenience?
Jesse Hirsh:How do we get people not just to value other people's labour when it comes
Jesse Hirsh:to making food, which is essential?
Jesse Hirsh:And, and to your point, it, it's not just agricultural
Jesse Hirsh:labour that remains racialized.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, restaurant labour, right?
Jesse Hirsh:Kitchens are also very racialized.
Elaine:Yep.
Jesse Hirsh:So while on the one hand, yes, we do need to be valuing the labour
Jesse Hirsh:of the people who produce food, we also think, correct me if I'm wrong,
Jesse Hirsh:we need to be valuing our own labour.
Jesse Hirsh:Like thinking that it is worth us spending time to make a healthy
Jesse Hirsh:meal for us and our family.
Jesse Hirsh:A lot of people don't even, aren't even there.
Jesse Hirsh:And that's one of the reasons why they're so seduced by this myth of convenience.
Elaine:Yeah, yeah, for sure.
Elaine:I mean, when you, you talked about community building, you know,
Elaine:making food for oneself and others.
Elaine:I think it's also, it's an expression of love.
Elaine:It's, um, and, uh, yeah, so, sorry, I lost the question.
Elaine:But, um, you probably know I'm an advocate for basic income.
Elaine:Um, and one of the things that I think income might be able to help us with
Elaine:is rethinking how we spend our time.
Elaine:right now, as you know, we're, we're all having to scramble to, um, make
Elaine:enough money to put a roof over our head and food on the table.
Elaine:And, you know, some, of us, it's kind of a chicken and egg, isn't it?
Elaine:Because I think about how people are really scrambling to, um, I say, do
Elaine:that work, but also raise a family potentially, or to be, you know,
Elaine:to be involved in other activities.
Elaine:And it we're so.
Elaine:We're so time crunched.
Elaine:I mean, maybe it's a product of, I was gonna say maybe it's a product
Elaine:of the choices we make, but I, choice is kind of a such a loaded word.
Elaine:You know, I think we, we have li very limited choice actually.
Elaine:and so in a way, I think basic income would open up some space
Elaine:potentially for us to make other choices and for people to rethink their
Elaine:relationship to food in particular.
Elaine:That they could rethink how to, they get their food and how much they want to, how
Elaine:much of their own food they wanna grow.
Elaine:Um, and give us some breathing space.
Elaine:I mean, in a way, capitalism kind of depends on us not having that breathing
Elaine:space, you know, so that we are buying those convenience foods and like buying
Elaine:or buying instead of taking time.
Elaine:So, you know, there's a real, obviously there's kind of a, you know, such a
Elaine:relationship between time and, and money, um, inverse relationship.
Elaine:So those of us who have some money don't have the time, and those of
Elaine:who have time don't have money.
Elaine:so anyway, it's a, it's messed up.
Elaine:But, but absolutely I think, uh, you know, we have been sold this, um,
Elaine:bill of, you know, convenience that of course we all, we all want to work less.
Elaine:and, and then we forget about the, joy, the, the, the joy.
Elaine:Also the, the, pain of the, of that work, um, of, you know, producing
Elaine:our own food of, um, you know, that.
Elaine:Uh, but I, I honestly, there's, to me there's nothing like, it could
Elaine:be very simple food, but if it's homemade, it has a different quality.
Elaine:It's like the food that you grow yourself that tastes nothing like what
Elaine:you, what you get in the, in the store.
Elaine:Um, so there's that we, it, the, the convenience gloss is over the
Elaine:delight, the joy, the pleasures of, of other aspects of, of the food.
Elaine:Whether it, particularly the taste, but also that joy and pleasure of sharing
Elaine:the food of, um, you know, of the love that comes with that, you know.
Jesse Hirsh:I kind of feel that we are, we're, we're evoking a larger culture of
Jesse Hirsh:food and on the one hand we've already critiqued the kind of corporate culture
Jesse Hirsh:of food at at least we've, you know, hit some of the edges around that.
Jesse Hirsh:And, you know, to go back to my point about this juxtaposition between the
Jesse Hirsh:politics of the agri side and the politics of the food side, I, I'm
Jesse Hirsh:curious to what extent, again, also circling back to our generalist idea, w.
Jesse Hirsh:Food studies as a larger, kinda a culture, as a larger kind of discourse
Jesse Hirsh:of researchers, of activists, of eaters, of, you know, people who
Jesse Hirsh:wanna make food more accessible.
Jesse Hirsh:What role does culture play within that work?
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I say this and playing on words that I always find it funny that the
Jesse Hirsh:word agriculture relies upon culture.
Jesse Hirsh:And of course that culture means lots of different things from fermentation
Jesse Hirsh:to, you know, how farmers do things.
Jesse Hirsh:But the food side has a culture to itself that I think you're describing
Jesse Hirsh:when you talk about affection.
Jesse Hirsh:When we talk about community, when we talk about valuing the labour that
Jesse Hirsh:goes into these things, is there a, a meta consciousness within food studies
Jesse Hirsh:around culture and psychology of food?
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, there certainly is around health and around nutrition and around policies.
Jesse Hirsh:Are there people, you know, elaborating and doing research around some of
Jesse Hirsh:the, the concepts that we're, we're currently unearthing and throwing around?
Elaine:Yeah, I think so.
Elaine:I think some, you know, you mentioned two other people that you've had
Elaine:on your podcast, and I would say both of them have, uh, you know, an
Elaine:awareness of, of cultural issues.
Elaine:Um, I think sometimes it gets buried in other, you know, I think each
Elaine:of us comes to, this, comes to food studies with our own preoccupations
Elaine:and and, you know, whether that's the environment, uh, and so on.
Elaine:So I, you know, there, I think it is in a way, maybe the substrate
Elaine:underneath a lot of what happens.
Elaine:Um, maybe again, kind maybe taken for granted somewhat, um, more than others.
Elaine:Um,
Jesse Hirsh:Well,
Elaine:yeah.
Elaine:Uh, sorry, I
Jesse Hirsh:and
Elaine:lost your question again.
Jesse Hirsh:well, you, you're not losing anything.
Jesse Hirsh:We we're, we're, we are, uh, quite joyously discussing very
Jesse Hirsh:scary and at the same time, inspiring topics at the same time.
Jesse Hirsh:Whi which kind of leads me to a follow up in, in speaking with Alyssa and speaking
Jesse Hirsh:with Charles and speaking with yourself, I feeling a sense of revolution that,
Jesse Hirsh:that, you know, within food studies there is a kind of revolutionary ethos,
Jesse Hirsh:which to go to our earlier point is a consequence of using food to connect
Jesse Hirsh:the dots and see the poly crisis that is threatening all aspects of our lives.
Jesse Hirsh:Is, is food studies, uh, explicitly revolutionary or are there just a lot
Jesse Hirsh:of revolutionaries in food studies?
Elaine:That's such a great question.
Elaine:Uh, I, I think, um, many of us identify with a critical food studies that
Elaine:is deliberately attentive to issues of power and whether that's, um,
Elaine:you know, issues of gender, of race, of class, of inequality, of wealth,
Elaine:of the corporate kind of power.
Elaine:Um, I don't know that food studies is inherently revolutionary, but it really,
Elaine:you're right, it does attract a lot of people who, know, you don't have to go too
Elaine:far in, in thinking about food to realise, you know, it, it really exemplifies and
Elaine:reproduces a lot of the systems of, um, of inequality that, that structure the world.
Elaine:So, um, yeah, so I would say more that, you know, there are more or
Elaine:less there, you know, obviously there are, there are people in food studies
Elaine:who are particularly revolutionary.
Elaine:I think in Canada especially the food studies community really has always
Elaine:had an emphasis on thinking, imagining, um, a more just world and, um, and
Elaine:thinking about thinking about that through food and through the food system.
Jesse Hirsh:And is that also true globally?
Jesse Hirsh:Because certainly from my own biassed view, it, it does seem that when
Jesse Hirsh:people focus on food, let's say outside of the agricultural industry,
Jesse Hirsh:it does also lend itself to, Hey, our current systems are inadequate.
Jesse Hirsh:We need to overthrow them and or replace them in order to sustainably
Jesse Hirsh:feed people in a socially just manner.
Elaine:Yeah, I, I think it depends how, you, probably depends how you
Elaine:define the boundaries of food studies.
Elaine:Um, know, I, I, because I, my work kind of crosses into, you know, a critique of
Elaine:food, charity in particular and, um, you know, kind of some anti-poverty work.
Elaine:There's, I think that there's actually lots of who publish in lots of food
Elaine:scholars who, or publish in food studies journals who I think are, be
Elaine:happy to tinker around the edges and make things a little bit better, but
Elaine:without a revolutionary or more radical kind of, um, agenda, I would say.
Elaine:Yeah.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and, and let's, let's unpack some of that, you know,
Jesse Hirsh:criticisms, uh, of food, charity.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I say this because I, I'm certainly familiar with the concept
Jesse Hirsh:that charity is an obstacle to justice.
Jesse Hirsh:But the fact that I just said those words means that there are people listening
Jesse Hirsh:right now who are like, what the fuck?
Jesse Hirsh:So, uh, I'd love for you to, uh, share your own thoughts on the limits
Jesse Hirsh:or problems, uh, with our current charity approach to addressing hunger.
Elaine:How long do we have?
Jesse Hirsh:We got time.
Elaine:Sorry.
Elaine:Okay, so food, charity, specifically food banks, which are
Elaine:relat relatively new in Canada.
Elaine:Uh, you know, the first one opened in Edmonton in 1981.
Elaine:uh, that's within my lifetime.
Elaine:Um, know, it's a while ago, but, uh, it was a direct
Elaine:import from the United States.
Elaine:was very, it's a very clear that there was a, you know, a food bank
Elaine:in Arizona that set up in the sixties that was, and food banks at the, the
Elaine:origin, the origins of food banks were about redistributing food waste.
Elaine:And, and the US is very much characterised by this idea that if you have hungry
Elaine:people, you give them food and their food, their, I mean, the snap, the
Elaine:what the, the current, uh, iteration of food stamps is a, is different
Elaine:than that, but it's in its origins.
Elaine:It was meant to, um, help people, you know, connect them with food surplus.
Elaine:food banks originally were also about this idea that food was going to waste horror.
Elaine:And, uh, and they're hungry people, so you wanna connect them.
Elaine:Um, it, it, it, I don't think it's a coincidence that that happened at the
Elaine:same time that, you know, neoliberal political philosophy was taking root,
Elaine:um, with the, you know, shrinking of the state and the undermining of social
Elaine:assistance and, uh, employment insurance.
Elaine:And so the, the, at that it's a perfect fit for a neoliberal kind of
Elaine:political ideology, use, um, handoff responsibility for what used to be state
Elaine:responsibilities, including income to the private sector, to the charitable
Elaine:sector, to community organisations.
Elaine:so, you know, they just took root and proliferated.
Elaine:'cause there's a, there's a kind of common sense about it.
Elaine:It's like, well, people are hungry and it's also people are hungry.
Elaine:So we give them food.
Elaine:And I mean, I think most Canadians, bye.
Elaine:Those of us who have money or have the ability to feed ourselves, it just,
Elaine:it seems hard to imagine that there are people who are food insecure in a
Elaine:country that's so wealthy and so rich where so much food is going to waste.
Elaine:So there's also something, you know, we were talking about, you know, eating
Elaine:together as part of, you know, this communal community building and a sense
Elaine:of belonging and dignity and love.
Elaine:And so we, we, I think, uh, it's very, very personally to imagine
Elaine:that you could do something that would alleviate someone's hunger.
Elaine:so, but then food banks have also taken on all kinds of other, um,
Elaine:know, functions in our society.
Elaine:So, you know, uh, we have food drives that are team building exercises
Elaine:or competitions at work, or it's a way to show that you're, you know,
Elaine:quote unquote good citizen because you bring a, a non-perishable
Elaine:food item to the football game.
Elaine:Or, you know, you drop some things in the bin at the grocery store and then, know,
Elaine:it's also now more recently, you know, a place to, again, to alleviate food waste.
Elaine:So we're not sending food to the landfill and, you know, so we
Elaine:get to be good citizens and we get to be good green citizens.
Elaine:So they serve all these other functions.
Elaine:I think that the needs of people who are food insecure completely lost in those,
Elaine:in that, so we know from survey research that, you know, probably about, only about
Elaine:a quarter of the people in the country who are food insecure ever go to a food bank.
Elaine:And, you know, food banks are limited by their donation, what they have available
Elaine:by their donations, by their labour pool, um, their, you know, people.
Elaine:They have limited hours, they have to close the doors when they run out of food.
Elaine:There's, so, there's just so many problems.
Elaine:And so the, it's, it's serving all these other functions for other, um,
Elaine:you know, groups in society, but the needs of people who actually use them.
Elaine:But that, that's not one of that, those are completely overlooked and forgotten.
Elaine:Um, and I guess that's classic in a way that the, you know, his history's written
Elaine:by the victors and, you know, food banks are run by those who, who, who already
Elaine:have, um, as a way to, know, that, that I've, in a way it kind of takes the
Elaine:pressure off, um, at, you know, at we don't have people marching in the street.
Elaine:We don't have food riots, um, because we
Jesse Hirsh:Not yet.
Elaine:Um, now yet, yeah.
Elaine:And, and there's a way in which it locks the status quo into place.
Elaine:So it, when I think about the like thousands, probably hundreds of
Elaine:thousands of volunteer hours are soaked up in food banks and, you know,
Elaine:nobody wants to see people go hungry.
Elaine:but the reality is that lots of people go hungry in this country or ha are
Elaine:worried about going hungry anyway.
Elaine:If I think about all those hours, like imagine what else we could be doing with
Elaine:the, with those hours and with that time.
Elaine:I mean there are, there are lots of other things.
Elaine:There's lots of other work and, uh, lots of other, you know, labour or, you know,
Elaine:maybe people would be out learning how to play the guitar or writing poetry or
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and.
Elaine:food.
Elaine:I don't know.
Jesse Hirsh:You know, on the one hand, I, I do think that some of the shortcomings
Jesse Hirsh:or frustrations with the kind of food bank concept are starting to encourage
Jesse Hirsh:some communities to think beyond them.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I want to come back to that in a moment, but I, I was personally shocked,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, as part of doing this podcast to learn that a lot of food banks actually don't
Jesse Hirsh:even make use of food waste, that they only buy food, which seems so illogical
Jesse Hirsh:to me, given the amount of perfectly good food that is thrown away on a daily basis.
Jesse Hirsh:I mean, as a, a, a relatively new food researcher, uh, again, I,
Jesse Hirsh:every day I am still in shock at the amount of food that is thrown away.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and my brain in, in its own kind of autistic way, is always going
Jesse Hirsh:through scenarios in which that food could be effectively redistributed.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I mean, I was, when I was younger, more familiar and, and, uh, slightly connected
Jesse Hirsh:to groups like Food Not Bombs, which were kind of very much food justice groups.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and there are some food not bombs still active in, in North
Jesse Hirsh:America today, but, but what are some, some post food bank scenarios?
Jesse Hirsh:What are some kind of radical, and, and, and, and let's do this in the context
Jesse Hirsh:of if resources were not an issue, um, what are some scenarios or, or what are
Jesse Hirsh:some concepts that that could, to your point about allocating all that goodwill,
Jesse Hirsh:allocating all that volunteer labour, what are some of the ways in which we
Jesse Hirsh:could channel that, you know, if we had both the resources and the political
Jesse Hirsh:culture slash will to make it happen?
Jesse Hirsh:A and I'll elaborate on that in a bit, but, but I'm curious to spend some
Jesse Hirsh:moments brainstorming on, on what some of these alternatives could look like.
Elaine:Could I back up just a, a bit, um, before
Jesse Hirsh:Please.
Elaine:that question, and because I wanted to talk to,
Elaine:just talk a bit about food waste.
Elaine:and, uh, you know, one of the things that is seared in my brain when
Elaine:I first moved to Toronto in the nineties, um, and I remember, um,
Elaine:talking to the head of the Daily Bank, daily Bread food bank at the time.
Elaine:Her first name is Sue, and I've lost her last name.
Elaine:But, she talked about getting two tractor trailer loads of, uh, almost, um, of,
Elaine:of oranges that were half rotting.
Elaine:And I wasn't there, but she had to kind of mobilise an army of volunteers to, through
Elaine:two tractor loads of to sort out the ones that were rotting from the ones that
Elaine:were still usable and get tho that fruit out to people as quickly as possible.
Elaine:And I've never, for, never kind of forgotten, even though I wasn't there.
Elaine:Like I, I imagine the smell and, and we've, I think probably most of us
Elaine:have had that experience of putting our fingers into an orange in the
Elaine:grocery store that's mouldy and to rot.
Elaine:And I just like, oh, oh.
Jesse Hirsh:So
Elaine:mean, she told me that story 30 years ago and I've never forgotten it.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I, if I might, uh, digress just to, to around your point.
Jesse Hirsh:A lot of it has to do with packaging.
Jesse Hirsh:So think oranges, onions, other produce where if one of them in the bag starts
Jesse Hirsh:to go, they throw the whole bag out.
Jesse Hirsh:Apples is another limes, lemons and the amount of them that they are throwing out
Jesse Hirsh:every day because one out of 10 or one out of 15 is rotten and there's no process
Jesse Hirsh:to recover all the other good ones.
Jesse Hirsh:That volume alone is unbelievable.
Jesse Hirsh:Sorry, go ahead.
Elaine:Yeah, yeah, for sure.
Elaine:And, and, and it's, it's also built into the system, right?
Elaine:Because partly like you talk about packaging and also the, the way
Elaine:that food is, you know, transported across, um, vast D distances.
Elaine:So it's actually the idea that, you know, that there's going to be food
Elaine:waste is like, it's built into the, the quote unquote manufacturing
Elaine:of, of the food that we eat.
Elaine:Um, or, you know, like the oranges, the fresh produce and so on.
Elaine:But also all the other perishable items, it's just assumed you know,
Elaine:at more than half, more than half of it is going to, um, be wa food waste.
Elaine:Um, so yeah, it, it, again, it kind of points to one of these like devastating
Elaine:critical weaknesses in the food
Jesse Hirsh:And, and, you know, to, to circle back to, to my question, I, I feel
Jesse Hirsh:that there are a, a bunch of converging trends, one of which is transparency.
Jesse Hirsh:That, that we are in an increasingly surveilled world.
Jesse Hirsh:And even those who are engaging the surveillance no longer control the
Jesse Hirsh:ability to surveil, which is to say random people are going into grocery stores and
Jesse Hirsh:sharing prices to other people causing a, a growing literacy of this stuff.
Jesse Hirsh:And I think there is gonna be a growing literacy of just how
Jesse Hirsh:much food is wasted and the way which that food could be diverted.
Jesse Hirsh:And I correlate this to what I see growing radical sentiment amongst young people
Jesse Hirsh:who are facing this poly crisis and going, what the hell are we supposed to do?
Jesse Hirsh:So that brings me back to my question of what are some of the alternatives that
Jesse Hirsh:we could be floating to people, uh, when it comes to either dealing with hunger
Jesse Hirsh:or dealing with how we distribute food, or dealing with the ways in which we
Jesse Hirsh:recognise the labour that goes into food.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I have to imagine as a politically engaged person, you've either thought
Jesse Hirsh:about this stuff or heard other smart people talk about this stuff.
Jesse Hirsh:So I'm, I'm, I'm curious as we start to, uh, uh, approach the end of the
Jesse Hirsh:episode that we give people, uh, maybe not a sense of hope that might be a tall
Jesse Hirsh:order, but a sense of fire as to their, uh, being, uh, other ways to do things.
Elaine:Yeah.
Elaine:Um, I mean, some might be less, some might be radical, some might be less radical.
Elaine:Like, I think we, we could start by reintroducing what we used to call home
Elaine:economics into the school curriculum so that people actually, you know,
Elaine:I, we maybe don't wanna call it home economics, but just so that, you
Elaine:know, have, people have a sense of confidence in their skills to actually
Jesse Hirsh:Yeah.
Elaine:food for
Jesse Hirsh:Yeah.
Elaine:Uh, maybe we wanna incorporate, you know, growing food into, uh, the
Elaine:school curriculums as well, so that people, again, have more of a sense of
Elaine:like, maybe, you know, the schools, of course are all, everything's awash in
Elaine:at this moment, but, um, maybe the way to counter that is to return to some
Elaine:really, like, some practical skills that we need to survive, um, on the planet.
Elaine:so I don't know.
Elaine:Some people might think that's more radical than other people,
Elaine:it feel, does feel like, um, but that feels like a place to start.
Elaine:I love the idea.
Elaine:I, I mean, I don't want, I, I don't waste a lot of food because
Elaine:I do cook a lot of my own food.
Elaine:Um, but, uh, given that if we're gonna stay in the current system, at least
Elaine:we could, I think we could take some of that food and maybe of, maybe, maybe
Elaine:one of the things we could do is, uh, a food not bombs kind of idea where that
Elaine:food waste is cooked or, and, or somehow redistributed, but not just for, you
Elaine:know, a small group, small proportion of stigmatised, uh, activity like a food
Elaine:bank, but actually like, you know, as like food not bombs, get they set up in
Elaine:parks or public spaces where anybody can come along and, uh, and have some food.
Elaine:Um, I've been involved in some work and some research on food insecurity
Elaine:on campus, including even at Queen University, which most people would
Elaine:not imagine would ever happen.
Elaine:And, you know, the one, some of the people that I did that research with,
Elaine:we talked a lot about, you know, having, um, quote unquote a soup kitchen.
Elaine:But, uh, you know, again, a place where students could gather with and make and
Elaine:make soup and then distribute it for, um, you know, people can pay what you
Elaine:can, you know, soup and bread in, in my idea of a university that actually
Elaine:cared about, or any institution for that matter that actually cared about
Elaine:the people, you'd have kind of have a soup pod in every corner with some
Elaine:fresh fruit and some, and some bread.
Elaine:And, and it could be really simple and anybody can help themselves at any points.
Elaine:Um, know, I, I had the.
Elaine:The principal of Queens at the time say, well, how do we
Elaine:de-stigmatize the food bank?
Elaine:It's like, well, you put it in a public place and you allow anybody to come and
Elaine:get the food, whatever they want, like
Jesse Hirsh:Yeah.
Elaine:questions asked.
Elaine:Like, anybody can just come and you put it in a public place.
Elaine:You don't make it, you don't hide it away.
Elaine:Uh, you make it the kind of normal part of.
Elaine:Um, but it's not really about the food bank.
Elaine:It's about, um, having food freely available, um, for everybody, everybody
Elaine:you know, the people who are cleaning the buildings to, uh, of the place.
Elaine:So, so that there's, again, kind of recreating a sense of community
Elaine:and communal, communal eating,
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and it.
Elaine:on your ability to pay.
Jesse Hirsh:Y you know, treating food as, as a kind of luxury I is something I think
Jesse Hirsh:we currently do, but we don't acknowledge.
Jesse Hirsh:And what you're describing is treating food not just in the context of
Jesse Hirsh:abundance, but, but treating it as if it is life, as if it is something
Jesse Hirsh:that is inherently accessible.
Jesse Hirsh:Because what I was imagining, what, while you were describing that, is some
Jesse Hirsh:of the posh conferences and events I've been at where, you know, you're there
Jesse Hirsh:with all these really important people and there's great food everywhere.
Jesse Hirsh:And when I was younger, I used to kind of describe my religion as being the free
Jesse Hirsh:lunch, that I would go to all these policy events and go to all these academic events
Jesse Hirsh:because they'd have free lunches and I'd be able to get all this great food.
Jesse Hirsh:Imagine if we could do that at a community level, at a society level where there
Jesse Hirsh:were just places you knew you could go, anyone could go and there'd be great food.
Jesse Hirsh:To me, that's not radical that that is common sense.
Jesse Hirsh:Um, I I, I'm curious to what extent as a teacher, as someone who engages with
Jesse Hirsh:young people, and of course as we age, it's easy to disparage young people,
Jesse Hirsh:and our current society is certainly doing its best, uh, to try to disparage
Jesse Hirsh:young people from all, uh, uh, sides.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I suspect you do not have that view.
Jesse Hirsh:And at the same time, I, I'm curious to get your sense of, of where the
Jesse Hirsh:young people are at a, am I right in thinking that they're, uh, uh,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, uh, open to radical ideas, itching for something different?
Jesse Hirsh:Or is that me projecting and wishing that young people were, uh, uh,
Jesse Hirsh:the way I was when I was young?
Elaine:Yeah, I, I would say, you know, guess I'm at Queens.
Elaine:Um, we don't have a particularly radical student body at Queens necessarily,
Elaine:but, uh, one of the, one of the things that I find quite delightful after,
Elaine:you know, the, the food system course that I've been talking about at the
Elaine:second year course, there's students from all different levels taking it.
Elaine:But I've had, um, you know, several students, uh, write
Elaine:to me after the course.
Elaine:I had one in particular who sent me, you know, photos.
Elaine:It, the course inspires students to grow some of their own food.
Elaine:And so, um, there, there's some that I've kept in touch with who continue to grow,
Elaine:you know, some, some of their own food.
Elaine:I think if nothing else, it gives them a sense of appreciation for the work.
Elaine:Um, and the, the struggle and the, the riskiness, you know, whether the
Elaine:rabbits eat the lettuce or, you know, the frost kills tomato plants or whatever.
Elaine:Um, also, uh, you know, one of, couple of, some of the students said this
Elaine:year, oh, look forward to seeing at the farmer's market in the summer.
Elaine:You know, so I think it does help them, and they, nothing else, they
Elaine:don't take for granted anymore.
Elaine:The, the, the things that they buy at the grocery store, they
Elaine:have a little more awareness of the, the labour and the, the work.
Elaine:Um, and also the, you know, the, the, the environmental impact potentially.
Elaine:Um, so, uh, who knows where that goes.
Elaine:It's a bit like, I feel a bit like I'm a dandelion plant, you know,
Elaine:kind of spreading seeds and who knows where those seeds land and
Elaine:how long they might take to sprout.
Elaine:But, uh, yeah, I mean, when I first came to Queens a long, long time ago, in the
Elaine:early part of this century, um, I was really struck by, at the time the, the
Elaine:kind of resources that the students have.
Elaine:They're not all the, there's food insecurity on campus, but they generally
Elaine:have a lot of resources, um, not just economic, but cultural and social.
Elaine:Um, they end up with their degree from Queens, they go on to do amazing things.
Elaine:And so it's been a real privilege.
Elaine:I'm, I'm about to retire, but it's really been an incredible privilege, um,
Elaine:to some of those seeds, whether it's, uh, about social determinants of health
Elaine:or about the food system, you know?
Elaine:Yeah.
Elaine:It's, um, when I look at, when I look at the students at, certainly
Elaine:at the, the best students, I, I, I do feel hopeful actually.
Elaine:Yeah.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and the model of the dandelion as revolutionary
Jesse Hirsh:certainly, uh, uh, holds well, uh, for the future success of the revolution,
Jesse Hirsh:given how, uh, dandelions are quite resilient and the scourge of, uh,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, many people who seek monoculture.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, as we kind of come to a close, uh, one of the questions I always like to,
Jesse Hirsh:you know, offer at the end is, is if, has there, is there anything that we
Jesse Hirsh:haven't touched upon that you would like to touch upon, uh, before we end?
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I say this more as an invitation, Les, as a lament in that,
Elaine:Hmm.
Jesse Hirsh:you know, we have covered quite a bit of ground, but that suggests
Jesse Hirsh:that maybe there's some big 800 pound gorilla, uh, in the corner that we
Jesse Hirsh:should be addressing before we conclude.
Elaine:Well, I, I did mention it, but, uh, you know, I've be, as I say, I've
Elaine:become an advocate for basic income and I feel like I have a hammer and everything.
Elaine:Basic income is the answer to almost everything.
Elaine:Um, not on its own, but, uh, you know, I do think it would, um, the,
Elaine:the National Farmers Union, for example, has at their, um, convention
Elaine:in the fall passed a resolution, um, supporting a basic income, I think
Elaine:of $50,000 a year for, for farmers.
Elaine:Um, and especially, you know, the average age of farmers is
Elaine:approaching 60, it might be 60 by now.
Elaine:Um, and so to support young, not gonna address the cost of land, but it
Elaine:will provide, uh, you know, kind of a foundation for young farmers, a financial
Elaine:foundation, foundation to, to enable them to survive all the ups and downs of,
Elaine:you know, the frost we had this morning here in Kingston, in the middle of May.
Elaine:Um, the, the vagaries of, of farming, which is, you know, it's really risky.
Elaine:I really have so much respect and admiration for people who, um, are,
Elaine:who are growing food other people.
Elaine:Um, so, so it would, it would provide an income floor for, for young,
Elaine:particularly young farmers, for, uh, and especially, you know, marginalised
Elaine:people from marginalised groups, whether in farming, whether that's
Elaine:women or, uh, racialized groups.
Elaine:Um, people who are, who want to create a different kind of world, and a
Elaine:world that's more just, and that it obviously is, is more, um, sustainable.
Elaine:Um, and of course it would, I mean, it's often thought basic income's often
Elaine:thought about as in relation to poverty.
Elaine:It would, it would create, again, an income floor if it were a livable basic
Elaine:income, it would enable people to afford, food and to be able to make different
Elaine:choices about the food that they eat.
Elaine:it could support, you know, people who want to do, you know, food,
Elaine:food processing for example, or like start small businesses
Elaine:on kind of food entrepreneurs.
Elaine:So, um, it would make a huge difference, I think, in the food system from
Elaine:production and consumption perspectives.
Elaine:Uh, I think, I honestly think it's too threatening, right now for, especially for
Elaine:you think about the low wage employers, um, including, you know, the fast food
Elaine:companies and, uh, the Amazons and all the rest who depend on a low, on a workforce
Elaine:that's desperate make some money.
Elaine:Um, and maybe, maybe that's where AI is going to push us, you
Elaine:know, quote unquote over the edge could push us over so many edges,
Jesse Hirsh:Let, let, let me jump in right there.
Jesse Hirsh:O only because, you know, AI is my domain of expertise and, and this is where I
Jesse Hirsh:would argue that the narrative around AI and unemployment is entirely made up.
Jesse Hirsh:And the reality is what you described, that the employment crisis is
Jesse Hirsh:about greed and an unwillingness to pay people a decent wage, let
Jesse Hirsh:alone give them a meaningful job.
Jesse Hirsh:Like working at an Amazon warehouse is demoralising and dehumanising on
Jesse Hirsh:so many levels that we're kind of using AI as this, you know, oh, that's
Jesse Hirsh:what's disrupting the employment.
Jesse Hirsh:That's what's disrupting the marketplace when in fact,
Jesse Hirsh:it's, it's corporate practises.
Jesse Hirsh:It, it, it's, it's terrible wages.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and more and more people are saying, no way, I, I ain't gonna do that.
Jesse Hirsh:And that is why they're having difficulties.
Jesse Hirsh:As another aside, b before I became a farmer, one of the reasons I decided to
Jesse Hirsh:get into farming was I met a farmer who said, we don't really have to worry about
Jesse Hirsh:the cities flooding from climate change.
Jesse Hirsh:We will all die way before that because of a bad frost in late May or early June.
Jesse Hirsh:And it was that kind of insight into the brittle nature of our systems that
Jesse Hirsh:made me think, I kinda wanna be at the front line of this change, so at
Jesse Hirsh:least I am having a little more agency.
Jesse Hirsh:But to that point of agency, after I've allowed those digressions of myself.
Jesse Hirsh:What are some of the strategies or tactics that either you've thought
Jesse Hirsh:about or that people in the larger policy space have thought about when
Jesse Hirsh:it comes to advancing a, a kind of universal income or a basic income?
Jesse Hirsh:Because on the one hand, I, I do think we have to acknowledge a lot
Jesse Hirsh:of gains have been made, like we're having this conversation and it's
Jesse Hirsh:no longer that radical an idea.
Jesse Hirsh:But I think you rightfully pointed out it, it does threaten a, a, a lot of the power
Jesse Hirsh:holders, the stakeholders of our economy.
Jesse Hirsh:So what's the path forward?
Jesse Hirsh:What, what are some of the ideas to, uh, really get this policy
Jesse Hirsh:concept closer to, to implementation?
Elaine:You know, I've, I've, as a social scientist, I've spent a lot
Elaine:of my career thinking that if we only have the evidence, you know, we
Elaine:have the, have a good evidence base and a strong evidence base that, you
Elaine:know, that's gonna change policy.
Elaine:And I've driven up on that.
Elaine:I, that was a very naive idea of politics.
Elaine:So, I mean, we, in the basic income movement, I've often said, you
Elaine:know, we need our Tommy Douglas.
Elaine:Like we, we actually need, someone who's willing to carry the torch and to, uh,
Elaine:at, at, at, at a, probably at a federal, well, it could happen provincially.
Elaine:I mean, we often compare ourselves to Medicare.
Elaine:You know, Tommy Douglas implemented Medicare in Saskatchewan.
Elaine:It, it, um, it was, you know, kind of took root there before
Elaine:it rolled out across the country.
Elaine:But it really did take, I mean, there were lots of other
Elaine:factors, but it took a champion.
Elaine:Um, you know, there's actually been a proposal to, uh, that's been
Elaine:costed for implementing a basic income in Prince Edward Island,
Elaine:which would be ideal because it's relatively small, lots of agriculture
Elaine:and kind of seasonal employment.
Elaine:Uh, unlikely that a lot of people are gonna uproot themselves and move to PEI.
Elaine:So they could be part of a, you know, five or seven year pilot on basic income.
Elaine:But it could work, we could work out the kinks and figure out how
Elaine:it fits or doesn't fit with some of the other systems that we need,
Elaine:like, uh, you know, PharmaCare and dental care and all the rest.
Elaine:Um, so that proposal's been, it's actually, it's a group of politicians,
Elaine:retired politicians and civil servants and economists have worked on that.
Elaine:It's there now.
Elaine:It's ready,
Jesse Hirsh:So
Elaine:go.
Elaine:It just needs federal funding.
Jesse Hirsh:l let me follow up on that and, and I kind of feel that
Jesse Hirsh:we are getting a little off track and I do have to end the episode
Jesse Hirsh:soon, but what about Kate Breton?
Jesse Hirsh:Like, what, what 'cause and, and I kind of wanted to bring up Kate Breton
Jesse Hirsh:in terms of, you know, your, your own personal history and I also kind
Jesse Hirsh:of wanted to speculate on whether farming on, on, on rocks is viable.
Jesse Hirsh:'cause I, I have some ideas as to how it could be, but could the, the
Jesse Hirsh:scenario you just described with PEI be applied to Cape Breton, but also in the
Jesse Hirsh:context of migration that this would be a way to attract people to move to
Jesse Hirsh:Cape Breton as a, a, a, a potential reversal of the, the demographics
Jesse Hirsh:there, or, or am I being ludicrous?
Elaine:No, I don't think you're being ludicrous at all.
Elaine:I mean, uh, actually, there is some good farmland in Cape Breton.
Elaine:Um, uh, and there was a little mini of migration during COVID,
Elaine:you know, uh, to Cape Breton and other parts of Nova Scotia.
Elaine:There's also, because the university in Sydney did, uh, at one point kind of throw
Elaine:open the doors to international students.
Elaine:There's a big population of people from India now who are living, who've chosen to
Elaine:live permanently uh, in, in Cape Breton.
Elaine:Um, so I think that's a grand idea of myself.
Elaine:Uh, of course it would depend on, um, you know, the provincial government,
Elaine:but then there's always, you know, the Cape Red Liberation Army that
Elaine:wants to from the mainland and, you know, set up our own government.
Elaine:And so,
Jesse Hirsh:You've heard it here on the Future Herd Podcast first.
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Elaine:I don't know if that answered your question, Jesse, but I I, of course,
Elaine:I mean, I may or may not retire to Cape Breton when, or, or Nova Scotia at some
Elaine:point, but if I do, part of it will be to work on, um, basic income for Nova Scotia.
Elaine:And, uh, you know, I think the Atlantic, Atlantic provinces in general are strong
Elaine:supporters, but again, there isn't really that kind of champion like Tommy
Elaine:Douglas to really push it forward.
Elaine:So
Jesse Hirsh:Right on.
Jesse Hirsh:Well, and coincidentally, I do have the head of the PEI Federation
Jesse Hirsh:of Agriculture booked as a guest.
Jesse Hirsh:So I will bring up, uh, the subject of, uh, basic income in PEI to at
Jesse Hirsh:least see if he's thought about it.
Jesse Hirsh:If not, nudge him along.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, uh, the path.
Jesse Hirsh:Our last question,
Elaine:love that.
Jesse Hirsh:the last question I throw out, uh, as part of every
Jesse Hirsh:episode is, uh, the shout out.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, who are the people that you look up to or that inspire you or
Jesse Hirsh:that, uh, uh, nurture your curiosity that you think the rest of us,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, should be paying attention?
Jesse Hirsh:Like the first question, this is meant to be intuitive.
Jesse Hirsh:It's not like an Academy Award.
Jesse Hirsh:Thank you.
Jesse Hirsh:List.
Jesse Hirsh:Like, just a couple of names of who first comes to mind, uh, that you want
Jesse Hirsh:to kinda, uh, pass things forward to.
Elaine:Oh, wow.
Elaine:I love that question.
Elaine:Um, you know, one of the people who's been really important for
Elaine:me, um, because of her work on Food Insecurities, Valter at the University
Elaine:of Toronto, you know, recently retired.
Elaine:I mean, she's kind of dedicated her life to providing a really solid
Elaine:evidence base on food insecurity.
Elaine:Um, some of the folks in the Canadian food studies Mustafa Cook, um, Charles
Elaine:Lev Co. Uh, they're, they're, you know, we might not agree on every, point in
Elaine:thinking about food justice or their food system or food insecurity, but
Elaine:I just really love them as people.
Elaine:Um, Jennifer Welsh, who's someone else, who's, she's retired from,
Elaine:um, what's now TMU, uh, who has had a big influence on, on me.
Elaine:Um, Heather McClain, who, uh, did more kind of women's health kinds of things.
Elaine:She, she was one of the people who introduced me to qualitative research,
Elaine:which, know, I had a, had a background in quantitative work and qualitative
Elaine:work, just like spoke to my heart.
Elaine:And that's where I've spent most, most of my career.
Elaine:uh, Joan
Jesse Hirsh:And, and
Elaine:in the United States, uh, was, uh, she died recently.
Elaine:She also, she was way ahead of her time in terms of thinking about food.
Jesse Hirsh:right on.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and, you know,
Elaine:you gonna say?
Jesse Hirsh:well, I was just gonna say, this is where inevitably the guest
Jesse Hirsh:starts to feel a moral responsibility to continue to dig deeper and deeper
Jesse Hirsh:for the names that they don't wanna leave out, in case anyone's listening.
Jesse Hirsh:And that's where I have to absolve you.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, I have to absolve you from that and say, it's really meant to be, this
Jesse Hirsh:isn't comprehensive, this is intuitive.
Jesse Hirsh:And, and I have to thank you, uh, Elaine.
Jesse Hirsh:This, this has been a, a fantastic conversation that that certainly allows
Jesse Hirsh:me to fully, uh, uh, uh, uh, deepen the, the subjects and the analysis that we're
Jesse Hirsh:trying to do here on the future herd.
Jesse Hirsh:I, I've got this current, uh, a flippant saying, uh, that, that I
Jesse Hirsh:keep throwing out, which is that we, we are currently in a society
Jesse Hirsh:where we have no thoughtful policy.
Jesse Hirsh:And the reason we don't have any thoughtful policy is not because
Jesse Hirsh:people are not putting thought into the policy they're proposing, but
Jesse Hirsh:because there is not diverse thought in the policies that are being proposed.
Jesse Hirsh:I will say that doesn't apply to basic income.
Jesse Hirsh:I actually think there is a lot of diverse thought being put into basic income.
Jesse Hirsh:But it gets back to my, uh, insight around AgriFood, where agri is the
Jesse Hirsh:right wing and food is the left wing.
Jesse Hirsh:And part of what I want to achieve in the future herd is at
Jesse Hirsh:least create the opportunity for some thoughtful policy because.
Elaine:Hmm,
Jesse Hirsh:For sure.
Jesse Hirsh:The industry right now has the reins of policy, and I'm trying to make an argument
Jesse Hirsh:that if they want their policy to actually work and be effective, they have to start
Jesse Hirsh:inviting more people to the policy table.
Jesse Hirsh:So I thank you Elaine,
Elaine:Hmm.
Jesse Hirsh:for helping to make that argument today by providing a
Jesse Hirsh:perspective that absolutely needs to be part of the larger discourse.
Jesse Hirsh:But I end by saying what I've said to a lot of others, I
Jesse Hirsh:hope we can have you back.
Jesse Hirsh:I hope that you can, uh, be part of the future herd and, and really help us shape,
Jesse Hirsh:uh, uh, our response to what I think is an escalating crisis that you so eloquently
Jesse Hirsh:articulated in the first answer.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh uh.
Jesse Hirsh:So thanks again.
Elaine:Well, thank you.
Elaine:I mean, thank you for giving me the opportunity to talk about the things
Elaine:that are I, I care so much about.
Elaine:Um, I, I, yeah.
Elaine:So I, and I don't think I ran it too much, so, um, thanks
Jesse Hirsh:No, that, that was the brilliance.
Jesse Hirsh:You didn't rant at all.
Jesse Hirsh:Like did you indict our current food system as being unjust,
Jesse Hirsh:tyrannical, and inefficient?
Jesse Hirsh:Absolutely.
Jesse Hirsh:Did you do it in the form of a ranch?
Jesse Hirsh:Not at all.
Jesse Hirsh:It was quite reasonable and
Elaine:thank you.
Elaine:Excellent.
Elaine:Thank you.
Elaine:I guess that's a good thing.
Jesse Hirsh:That was by far one of the most enjoyable conversations
Jesse Hirsh:I've had as part of this podcast.
Jesse Hirsh:And quite frankly, almost every single conversation I've had
Jesse Hirsh:on this podcast is enjoyable.
Jesse Hirsh:Perhaps my, uh, stoner mind, uh, has a short term memory bias here,
Jesse Hirsh:that it always feels like the last conversation was the best conversation.
Jesse Hirsh:Um, but this really was one that sat with me for a while, and maybe that's
Jesse Hirsh:why I didn't release it right away.
Jesse Hirsh:And I'm happy to say that there have been other conversations that
Jesse Hirsh:built upon this one that I have since had, but not yet released.
Jesse Hirsh:So I kind of feel that we're at a pivotal point here with the future herd.
Jesse Hirsh:We're, you know, starting to catch a bit of momentum as a herd, as we're moving
Jesse Hirsh:some of the, uh, technology episodes, some of the, uh, leadership knowledge episodes.
Jesse Hirsh:And now some of the research and critical studies episodes are really starting to
Jesse Hirsh:weave a picture of the Canadian AgriFood sector that I think is unique that I
Jesse Hirsh:don't think you can find anywhere else.
Jesse Hirsh:You know, people have their specialties, they have their domains, their areas
Jesse Hirsh:of expertise, but I suspect only at the future herd are we getting the
Jesse Hirsh:kind of critical perspective that people like Elaine Power bring.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, I don't know what that means for the future of the future herd, but I do
Jesse Hirsh:know that we are gonna be taking this herd into unprecedented and exciting and
Jesse Hirsh:interesting and stimulating territory.
Jesse Hirsh:So if you got any feedback that you wanna share with us,
Jesse Hirsh:please check out our website.
Jesse Hirsh:There's a link there with our email address.
Jesse Hirsh:Of course, you can see information about all the episodes we have, the knowledge
Jesse Hirsh:we're generating, and quite frankly, the research, uh, that we're engaged in.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh.
Jesse Hirsh:I'm recording this on June 18th, and as an aside, I just got into the
Jesse Hirsh:Cohere Labs Discord server today.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, cohere is kind of the Canadian AI champion, and they're, uh, labs, they're
Jesse Hirsh:open labs, uh, is kind of a place for open science, uh, researchers using ai, uh,
Jesse Hirsh:throughout, uh, society around the world.
Jesse Hirsh:And what's great is I can say, Hey, I'm from the future herd.
Jesse Hirsh:I'm a food researcher.
Jesse Hirsh:I'm a farmer.
Jesse Hirsh:I wanna see how we can use ai and I can point to the podcast as a public
Jesse Hirsh:example of the research we're doing.
Jesse Hirsh:So it was kind of a proud moment, uh, to be able to say that we are
Jesse Hirsh:building something here, something public, something accessible,
Jesse Hirsh:something interesting, and something we hope to drive change, uh, within
Jesse Hirsh:the Canadian AgriFood sector.
Jesse Hirsh:So more on this in the weeks and days to come.
Jesse Hirsh:Uh, again, uh, you can find [email protected] and let us know
Jesse Hirsh:what you think, uh, whether you like it, whether you don't, whether there's other
Jesse Hirsh:people you think we should be talking to.
Jesse Hirsh:Alright, until next time, we'll talk to you soon.