Artwork for podcast 1,000 Waking Minutes
29 - How to Clear Your Mind (and Mouth) of Criticism
Episode 3023rd April 2025 • 1,000 Waking Minutes • Wendy Bazilian
00:00:00 00:38:29

Share Episode

Shownotes

We all do it — the comment under our breath, the sharp thought in traffic, the eye-roll during a conversation, or the self-judgment in the mirror. In this episode,Dr. Wendy Bazilian invites you to go beyond just pausing the inner critic — and start replacing it with something better.

Join Wendy for a refreshingly real and research-backed exploration of why criticism shows up so often (even when we don’t mean for it to), and what we can gently practice instead. Learn my CLEAR™ method for pausing and redirecting criticism, hear what neuroscience and behavior change research have to say about shifting our habits, and take part in a mindful minutedesigned to create space, soften your thoughts, and reconnect with curiosity, calm, and clarity.

Together, we’ll make room for a more thoughtful, compassionate, and grounded way of moving through our 1,000 waking minutes.

 WE DISCUSS:

(1:32) A morning moment with my daughter that sparked this episode — and the wisdom of ‘practicing the practices’

(10:01) Why criticism feels so automatic — and why it’s not really our fault (hello, brain wiring)

(14:00) Quieting the negativity loop and understanding habit loops with Dr. Judson Brewer

(18:29) The two systems of thinking from Daniel Kahneman — and how criticism comes from the faster one

(20:28) Beginner’s mind and Zen teachings on curiosity over certainty

(22:50) Why self-compassion matters: Science-backed benefits of positive internal dialogue 

(24:55) A Mindful Minute: A short guided practice to shift from critique to curiosity

(28:39) The CLEAR™ method: A 5-step process to catch and shift the pattern of critique

(34:47) Encouragement to try this with a friend — and how even one day of trying can create ripple effects

CONNECT WITH WENDY:

PLEASE SUPPORT:

If you’re enjoying 1,000 Waking Minutes, help us grow!

  • Subscribe so you never miss an episode

  • Rate & Review the show — your feedback helps others find the podcast

  • Share it with a friend or colleague who could use a little less noise and a little more clarity today

Thank you for tuning in to 1,000 Waking Minutes and being part of this journey—together. A huge thank you to our amazing collaborators including our production and marketing teams, and Gabriela Escalante in particular. To the ultra-talented Beza for my theme music, my lifelong friend and artist Pearl Preis Photography and Design, to Danielle Ballantyne, Jen Nguyen, Joanna Powell, and of course, my family and everyone working tirelessly behind the scenes.

HEALTH DISCLAIMER:

The information shared in this podcast is for educational purposes only and should not be considered individual medical or health advice. Always consult with your trusted healthcare provider before making any changes to your diet, exercise, or medical treatment.

Transcripts

Speaker:

You become what you practice.

Speaker:

And if you've been moving

Speaker:

through your day with a

Speaker:

little more criticism than calm

Speaker:

lately, maybe it's time to

Speaker:

press pause.

Speaker:

And that's what I'm exploring

Speaker:

today.

Speaker:

We experience 1,000 waking

Speaker:

minutes on average every day.

Speaker:

How are you spending yours?

Speaker:

I'm Dr. Wendy Bazilian and

Speaker:

you're listening to 1,000

Speaker:

Waking Minutes.

Speaker:

I can't wait to connect

Speaker:

with you here with practical

Speaker:

ways to eat well, move

Speaker:

daily, and be healthy.

Speaker:

To optimize every waking minute

Speaker:

you live for a happier,

Speaker:

healthier life.

Speaker:

Thank you for sharing some

Speaker:

of your waking minutes with

Speaker:

me today.

Speaker:

Let's get started.

Speaker:

I'm saying yes to better

Speaker:

days, yes.

Speaker:

I'm on my way, yes.

Speaker:

It's gonna be okay, yeah.

Speaker:

Welcome back to 1,000

Speaker:

Waking Minutes.

Speaker:

I'm Dr. Wendy Bazilian and

Speaker:

I'm so glad you're here.

Speaker:

Today we're doing something that

Speaker:

sounds simple, but is actually

Speaker:

kind of radical.

Speaker:

Today we're taking a break

Speaker:

just one day from criticism.

Speaker:

Not forever, not even for

Speaker:

a week, but just for

Speaker:

today.

Speaker:

A pause to pointing out

Speaker:

what's wrong with the world,

Speaker:

with other people, and yes,

Speaker:

with ourselves.

Speaker:

Funny enough, this came up

Speaker:

recently with my six-year

Speaker:

-old daughter, whom I love

Speaker:

to talk with and also

Speaker:

talk about at times.

Speaker:

It came up when we

Speaker:

were talking about words and

Speaker:

getting a start on our

Speaker:

day and what was coming

Speaker:

up.

Speaker:

We have a little saying,

Speaker:

a little routine in the

Speaker:

morning, typically.

Speaker:

In fact, I had it

Speaker:

made into wooden letters that

Speaker:

are posted on a wall

Speaker:

in a room in our

Speaker:

house.

Speaker:

I say, "what's in store

Speaker:

for today?

Speaker:

I wonder..."

Speaker:

One of us says one

Speaker:

part and one says the

Speaker:

other, but it always starts

Speaker:

with, "what's in store for

Speaker:

today?

Speaker:

I wonder..."

Speaker:

That morning I asked her

Speaker:

what she was thinking about

Speaker:

for school and what the

Speaker:

day might hold, what week

Speaker:

it is.

Speaker:

We have A weeks and

Speaker:

B weeks and different things

Speaker:

happen on them.

Speaker:

Then she turned it around

Speaker:

to me, as we often

Speaker:

do.

Speaker:

She says, "well, what about

Speaker:

you, mama?

Speaker:

What's in store for today?

Speaker:

What's your podcast about this

Speaker:

week?"

Speaker:

She asked.

Speaker:

I said, "well, it's about

Speaker:

criticism and how we all

Speaker:

kind of need to take

Speaker:

a break from it from

Speaker:

time to time," starting with

Speaker:

myself.

Speaker:

This is the impetus here

Speaker:

because we all get wrapped

Speaker:

in that routine.

Speaker:

But at that moment, she

Speaker:

looked at me, learning so

Speaker:

many words, understanding things and

Speaker:

certainly experiencing them.

Speaker:

But she said, "what's criticism?"

Speaker:

She's experienced it.

Speaker:

We all have.

Speaker:

She's witnessed it.

Speaker:

And she's still learning about

Speaker:

sort of nuance and definitions

Speaker:

and hearing context and everything.

Speaker:

So we talked about it

Speaker:

just a little and I

Speaker:

tried to make it.

Speaker:

I found it actually somewhat

Speaker:

challenging to verbalize a little

Speaker:

bit more about criticism, which

Speaker:

helped me for today, hopefully,

Speaker:

to explain it and what

Speaker:

we're going to do with

Speaker:

you.

Speaker:

But I explained it to

Speaker:

her as simple as I

Speaker:

could about when someone says

Speaker:

something that makes you maybe

Speaker:

feel small.

Speaker:

Or when you're corrected, but

Speaker:

not to help, but to

Speaker:

point something out just to

Speaker:

do it.

Speaker:

And we even touched a

Speaker:

little bit on constructive criticism,

Speaker:

which is where I sort

Speaker:

of turned next, because sometimes

Speaker:

the feedback, the constructive criticism

Speaker:

that we're trained to do,

Speaker:

it helps us grow.

Speaker:

And it's kind and it

Speaker:

can be kind.

Speaker:

And it's even asked for.

Speaker:

So she listened and she

Speaker:

nodded and then out of

Speaker:

nowhere she asked, but "how

Speaker:

do you keep from criticizing

Speaker:

the world?"

Speaker:

And that just sort of

Speaker:

stopped me.

Speaker:

It sort of floored me

Speaker:

because isn't that the question?

Speaker:

But how do we stop

Speaker:

from picking apart the world

Speaker:

when there is at times

Speaker:

seemingly so much that frustrates

Speaker:

us or disappoints us or

Speaker:

just gets under our skin?

Speaker:

So I told her, I

Speaker:

don't exactly know all the

Speaker:

time.

Speaker:

I don't always stay away

Speaker:

from it.

Speaker:

But that's why I'm making

Speaker:

this episode, because it reminded

Speaker:

me of some of the

Speaker:

practices and how we can

Speaker:

better ourselves from making the

Speaker:

practice.

Speaker:

But then she said, and

Speaker:

I'll never forget this.

Speaker:

I think I'll probably take

Speaker:

this into episode after episode

Speaker:

and you'll hear me say

Speaker:

this again.

Speaker:

Okay, well, "tell me the

Speaker:

practices," she said.

Speaker:

"Tell me the practices.

Speaker:

Then I'll start practicing the

Speaker:

practices."

Speaker:

So I wrote that one

Speaker:

down.

Speaker:

I mean, "tell me the

Speaker:

practices so I can start

Speaker:

practicing the practices."

Speaker:

That is just gold.

Speaker:

It's so good.

Speaker:

And that's what we're going

Speaker:

to do today.

Speaker:

I'm going to share some

Speaker:

practices.

Speaker:

We're going to talk about

Speaker:

a little bit about why

Speaker:

we fall into the 'criticism

Speaker:

trap'.

Speaker:

We're going to talk about

Speaker:

how we can take breaks

Speaker:

from it and what happens

Speaker:

when we do.

Speaker:

And I'm going to share

Speaker:

those practices, the ones that

Speaker:

I'm working on as well.

Speaker:

Because the truth is, let's

Speaker:

think about it for a

Speaker:

second.

Speaker:

We're all doing it.

Speaker:

Criticism.

Speaker:

It shows up everywhere.

Speaker:

And it shows up all

Speaker:

the time.

Speaker:

It's not just those big

Speaker:

dramatic critiques that we make

Speaker:

or that others make.

Speaker:

It's the little ones.

Speaker:

It's the ones that sneak

Speaker:

in.

Speaker:

It's the ones we don't

Speaker:

even clock as criticism.

Speaker:

Because they're just like part

Speaker:

of the day.

Speaker:

They're like the running thoughts

Speaker:

that go through our mind.

Speaker:

It's like a low-grade,

Speaker:

constant hum or musical background.

Speaker:

Not a happy musical background,

Speaker:

mind you, because I love

Speaker:

music.

Speaker:

But like a constant commentary

Speaker:

that rides alongside.

Speaker:

Like, for example, when you're

Speaker:

driving.

Speaker:

Let's pick some scenarios here.

Speaker:

You're driving.

Speaker:

The person in front of

Speaker:

you is going just slow

Speaker:

enough to be annoying.

Speaker:

But not slow enough for

Speaker:

you to pass them.

Speaker:

And you start narrating the

Speaker:

life choices through your windshield

Speaker:

of what they could be

Speaker:

doing right now.

Speaker:

Anyone relate?

Speaker:

Or how about the customer

Speaker:

service calls?

Speaker:

It seems endless.

Speaker:

Certain days, certain weeks.

Speaker:

You're on hold with the

Speaker:

customer service line.

Speaker:

And the recording is saying,

Speaker:

"your call is very important

Speaker:

to us."

Speaker:

And you're like, is it

Speaker:

though, Mr. Amazon Automaton?

Speaker:

You know, is it?

Speaker:

Is it really?

Speaker:

The weather?

Speaker:

Oh, my goodness.

Speaker:

Talking about the weather.

Speaker:

It's too hot.

Speaker:

It's too cold.

Speaker:

What even is this wind

Speaker:

outside today?

Speaker:

It's too dark, too early.

Speaker:

And daylight savings... don't even

Speaker:

get me started with that

Speaker:

one.

Speaker:

So we do it also

Speaker:

to other people.

Speaker:

We criticize other people we

Speaker:

don't even know.

Speaker:

You know, we do it

Speaker:

in the coffee shop when

Speaker:

we're in line behind someone

Speaker:

and we're overhearing someone ordering

Speaker:

what we think is overly

Speaker:

complicated, double latte, grande, cinnamon,

Speaker:

syrupy, foamy, you know.

Speaker:

I sort of made that

Speaker:

up just a little bit

Speaker:

for effect, of course.

Speaker:

And we do it sometimes

Speaker:

when children are having meltdowns

Speaker:

in public.

Speaker:

We see eyes roll or

Speaker:

commentary happening.

Speaker:

Maybe you've even done it

Speaker:

at times.

Speaker:

And we do it when

Speaker:

someone dares FaceTime in a

Speaker:

waiting room when we're just

Speaker:

trying to take a moment

Speaker:

to breathe.

Speaker:

And, oh, my gosh, I

Speaker:

think we've all experienced the

Speaker:

loud speaking individual in a

Speaker:

seat when people are boarding

Speaker:

the plane, making the deal

Speaker:

and having to get it

Speaker:

done before the plane takes

Speaker:

off.

Speaker:

Really?

Speaker:

We all need to hear

Speaker:

that?

Speaker:

The neighbor.

Speaker:

Think about the neighbor, our

Speaker:

lovely neighbors who bring in

Speaker:

their trash, not just the

Speaker:

way that you would do

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

Sometimes we critique things as

Speaker:

simple as that.

Speaker:

And then there's ourselves.

Speaker:

We do it in the

Speaker:

mirror.

Speaker:

We do it to our

Speaker:

bodies.

Speaker:

We do it about our

Speaker:

jammed up inboxes and the

Speaker:

'to do' list.

Speaker:

Oh, my gosh.

Speaker:

The to do list.

Speaker:

We critique it.

Speaker:

Then we do it when

Speaker:

we forget to call someone

Speaker:

back and when someone forgets

Speaker:

to call us back.

Speaker:

So really, these are real

Speaker:

things.

Speaker:

Some of it's fair.

Speaker:

Some of it's fair and

Speaker:

real frustrations.

Speaker:

Some of it's real inefficiencies

Speaker:

with the world.

Speaker:

But do we need to

Speaker:

critique it?

Speaker:

And do we get into

Speaker:

sort of a cycle of

Speaker:

it being so easy, that

Speaker:

systematically, as they say with

Speaker:

the brain, the nerves set

Speaker:

fire together, wire together.

Speaker:

It becomes easier and easier

Speaker:

to replicate that as we

Speaker:

move through a day that

Speaker:

as we look back can

Speaker:

be filled with criticism.

Speaker:

So we're not wrong.

Speaker:

Our Wi-Fi should not

Speaker:

drop mid-Zoom.

Speaker:

People should merge together politely

Speaker:

on the highway in zigzag

Speaker:

fashion or whatever that's called.

Speaker:

And I will openly admit

Speaker:

that Daylight Saving Time is

Speaker:

not my favorite.

Speaker:

But when you add it

Speaker:

all up, we can spend

Speaker:

hours of our precious waking

Speaker:

minutes each day commenting and

Speaker:

critiquing, noticing what's off and

Speaker:

sharing it.

Speaker:

Sort of clogging our 'mental

Speaker:

inbox', so to speak.

Speaker:

Online, at work, in text,

Speaker:

in our own heads.

Speaker:

It becomes almost like a

Speaker:

background noise.

Speaker:

And sometimes even a way

Speaker:

we connect with others, like

Speaker:

venting and bonding or laughing

Speaker:

over what's not working.

Speaker:

Here's the thing, though:

Speaker:

A lot of us are

Speaker:

actually trained to do this.

Speaker:

And this is something that

Speaker:

I think about at times.

Speaker:

And it's a really interesting

Speaker:

contrast or not quite a

Speaker:

conflict, but something to reconcile.

Speaker:

In school, we actually learn

Speaker:

to analyze and assess... to

Speaker:

edit.

Speaker:

In work, we're expected to

Speaker:

find problems and fix them.

Speaker:

Critique is sometimes seen as

Speaker:

a sign of intelligence and

Speaker:

even leadership.

Speaker:

But when the skill spills

Speaker:

over into everything all the

Speaker:

time, it becomes the lens

Speaker:

we start to see the

Speaker:

world through.

Speaker:

And it can get exhausting.

Speaker:

It's like running a Yelp

Speaker:

review of your entire day.

Speaker:

Can you imagine?

Speaker:

And sometimes we can forget

Speaker:

to just live it or

Speaker:

focus on some alternatives that

Speaker:

we could be practicing instead.

Speaker:

So today's episode really is

Speaker:

like a little mini reset

Speaker:

on that.

Speaker:

And you can do this

Speaker:

periodically.

Speaker:

It's a break or a

Speaker:

little breath in that kind

Speaker:

of momentum.

Speaker:

And it's certainly not about

Speaker:

pretending that everything's great with

Speaker:

the world.

Speaker:

It's not about toxic positivity

Speaker:

or keeping quiet when something

Speaker:

really matters.

Speaker:

But it's about choosing when

Speaker:

to engage and when to

Speaker:

maybe soften the moment.

Speaker:

It's about noticing instead of

Speaker:

having the critical voice just

Speaker:

show up.

Speaker:

Noticing there may be a

Speaker:

choice on what comes next.

Speaker:

And maybe just letting one

Speaker:

or two of those moments

Speaker:

go.

Speaker:

Because here's an idea I

Speaker:

want to leave you with.

Speaker:

You become what you practice.

Speaker:

And most of us have

Speaker:

gotten quite good at practicing

Speaker:

criticism.

Speaker:

But what if just for

Speaker:

a day we practice something

Speaker:

else?

Speaker:

So that's what we're exploring

Speaker:

today.

Speaker:

The science of why we

Speaker:

do it.

Speaker:

The benefits from taking a

Speaker:

break.

Speaker:

The personal cost of staying

Speaker:

in that loop.

Speaker:

But the possibilities of what

Speaker:

opens when we take a

Speaker:

pause.

Speaker:

And I'll show you the

Speaker:

practices that if I share

Speaker:

you, you can "practice the

Speaker:

practices,"

Speaker:

as my daughter will say.

Speaker:

With a simple five-part

Speaker:

framework.

Speaker:

I keep it simple.

Speaker:

And hopefully a mindful and

Speaker:

memorable statement that will help

Speaker:

you.

Speaker:

I'm right in the middle

Speaker:

of real life.

Speaker:

One day without criticism.

Speaker:

And it can have profound

Speaker:

ripple effects.

Speaker:

So take a breath.

Speaker:

And let's settle in.

Speaker:

This might be your "Can

Speaker:

I just get a minute?"

Speaker:

type of moment.

Speaker:

The kind where you're not

Speaker:

asking for miracles on this.

Speaker:

But just taking a pause.

Speaker:

And the pause is about

Speaker:

criticism.

Speaker:

Let's now talk about what

Speaker:

happens when we actually try

Speaker:

this.

Speaker:

I'm going to talk about

Speaker:

the ROIs.

Speaker:

The benefits.

Speaker:

Some science when we step

Speaker:

away from the constant hum

Speaker:

of critiquing.

Speaker:

Even if just for a

Speaker:

day.

Speaker:

So while there's no specific

Speaker:

study entitled the effects of

Speaker:

a criticism free day.

Speaker:

Yet.

Speaker:

I love the word yet.

Speaker:

Not yet.

Speaker:

What we do have is

Speaker:

some research that comes from

Speaker:

neuroscience.

Speaker:

Behavioral psychology and mindfulness that

Speaker:

points to the power of

Speaker:

taking a break from the

Speaker:

negative loops and reactive patterns

Speaker:

that happen in humans.

Speaker:

And it shows what can

Speaker:

happen when we create even

Speaker:

a little space and choose

Speaker:

a different way of showing

Speaker:

up.

Speaker:

So here are some benefits.

Speaker:

I have five of them

Speaker:

or the returns on investment

Speaker:

of giving yourself a criticism

Speaker:

free day.

Speaker:

You might even start to

Speaker:

feel the shift in a

Speaker:

few minutes of trying.

Speaker:

And let's start by thinking

Speaker:

about the brain.

Speaker:

So ROI number one.

Speaker:

The benefit number one is

Speaker:

quieting the negativity loop.

Speaker:

In other words, breaking our

Speaker:

reflex to critique.

Speaker:

One of the first things

Speaker:

that happens when we pause

Speaker:

criticism, even a little, is

Speaker:

we begin to quiet the

Speaker:

negativity loop in the brain.

Speaker:

Dr. Rick Hansen, a psychologist

Speaker:

and a senior fellow at

Speaker:

UC Berkeley's Greater Good Science

Speaker:

Center.

Speaker:

Isn't that a cool name?

Speaker:

And a New York Times

Speaker:

bestselling author.

Speaker:

And he explains that the

Speaker:

brain is evolved to focus

Speaker:

more on negative experiences than

Speaker:

positive ones.

Speaker:

And why is that?

Speaker:

Well, because our ancient ancestors

Speaker:

had to survive.

Speaker:

So the brain developed a

Speaker:

kind of like hyper vigilance,

Speaker:

a focus and a bias

Speaker:

really toward what's wrong or

Speaker:

what could go wrong.

Speaker:

And so this negativity bias

Speaker:

means that we tend to

Speaker:

dwell in the criticism and

Speaker:

problems of ourselves, of others,

Speaker:

of the world, of our

Speaker:

environment.

Speaker:

It may have helped us

Speaker:

avoid danger and might still

Speaker:

actually in the past.

Speaker:

In modern times, it can

Speaker:

actually promote and lead to

Speaker:

chronic stress or self-doubt

Speaker:

or fatigue, emotional and physical,

Speaker:

really.

Speaker:

But the good news is

Speaker:

that Dr. Hansen has always

Speaker:

said that we can deliberately

Speaker:

build positive experiences in the

Speaker:

brain.

Speaker:

We can actually rewire the

Speaker:

patterns over time.

Speaker:

As he puts it, and

Speaker:

this is a quote, "weave

Speaker:

good experiences into the fabric

Speaker:

of your brain and yourself,"

Speaker:

so that you can weave

Speaker:

those good experiences.

Speaker:

And it really starts with

Speaker:

awareness and a little practice,

Speaker:

of course.

Speaker:

So when you take a

Speaker:

pause from that critical loop,

Speaker:

when you catch yourself, even

Speaker:

choose a different path, you're

Speaker:

not just being nice.

Speaker:

You're literally shifting the wiring

Speaker:

in your brain towards something

Speaker:

more positive and even more

Speaker:

resilient.

Speaker:

So benefit number two, another

Speaker:

major benefit of trying a

Speaker:

criticism-free day is that

Speaker:

it helps us break the

Speaker:

habit loop, that automatic cycle

Speaker:

of critique that many of

Speaker:

us don't even realize that

Speaker:

we're running in.

Speaker:

So Dr. Judd Brewer, he's

Speaker:

an MD and PhD researcher

Speaker:

at Brown University, and he's

Speaker:

a leading expert on mindfulness

Speaker:

and behavior change.

Speaker:

He talks about how our

Speaker:

brains form what he calls

Speaker:

habit loops.

Speaker:

And here's how it works.

Speaker:

There's a trigger, a behavior,

Speaker:

and a reward.

Speaker:

Maybe that sounds familiar, and

Speaker:

maybe that sounds very animalistic,

Speaker:

us humans as animals.

Speaker:

A trigger, a behavior, and

Speaker:

a reward.

Speaker:

So in this case, the

Speaker:

trigger might be a mistake.

Speaker:

The behavior is criticizing yourself,

Speaker:

maybe silently, but maybe out

Speaker:

loud.

Speaker:

And then the reward is

Speaker:

a sense of control over

Speaker:

that, or certainty, or maybe

Speaker:

just a familiar feeling of,

Speaker:

well, that's what I always

Speaker:

do, that type of criticism.

Speaker:

But over time, these loops

Speaker:

can become automatic.

Speaker:

We react without even realizing

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

And the problem is, it's

Speaker:

a false sense of control,

Speaker:

and it's really not relief

Speaker:

at all.

Speaker:

It doesn't actually help.

Speaker:

It just keeps the loop

Speaker:

going.

Speaker:

It's sort of like the

Speaker:

hamster wheel, just running, running,

Speaker:

running.

Speaker:

So when we break from

Speaker:

criticism, when we concretely and

Speaker:

purposely do, even just once

Speaker:

or twice during a day,

Speaker:

we can interrupt the cycle.

Speaker:

We can create space between

Speaker:

trigger and reaction.

Speaker:

And in that space, that's

Speaker:

where freedom lives.

Speaker:

That's where change can begin.

Speaker:

So Dr. Brewer, and I

Speaker:

want to quote him as

Speaker:

well, he says, "A habit

Speaker:

loop forms as the brain

Speaker:

cycles and stores information to

Speaker:

simplify tasks.

Speaker:

It's important to understand how

Speaker:

these loops occur and identify

Speaker:

how some habits become problematic

Speaker:

in your life."

Speaker:

So it's not about any

Speaker:

kind of magical perfection, but

Speaker:

about pattern recognition, about the

Speaker:

power of choosing something different

Speaker:

and building that awareness as

Speaker:

we break the habit loop.

Speaker:

So another benefit from stepping

Speaker:

back from criticism is giving

Speaker:

yourself a chance to shift

Speaker:

from snap judgments to thoughtful

Speaker:

choices.

Speaker:

So psychologist and Nobel laureate

Speaker:

Daniel Kahneman, he wrote the

Speaker:

book, you may have heard

Speaker:

of it as a wild

Speaker:

bestseller around the world, 'Thinking:

Speaker:

Fast and Slow.'

Speaker:

He explains about two systems

Speaker:

that we have in our

Speaker:

brains.

Speaker:

System one is fast and

Speaker:

automatic.

Speaker:

It runs on instinct.

Speaker:

It's the one that blurts

Speaker:

out, "what were we thinking?!"

Speaker:

before you've even had the

Speaker:

thought sometimes.

Speaker:

And then there's system two.

Speaker:

It's slower.

Speaker:

It's more deliberate.

Speaker:

It's the part that pauses

Speaker:

and considers and says, you

Speaker:

know, "what else could be

Speaker:

going on here?"

Speaker:

Or let me think about

Speaker:

that for a moment.

Speaker:

So here's the thing with

Speaker:

this.

Speaker:

Criticism usually comes from the

Speaker:

first quick fire system.

Speaker:

Fast.

Speaker:

It's automatic.

Speaker:

It's the mental version of

Speaker:

like slamming on the brakes

Speaker:

without checking the mirrors first

Speaker:

and seeing if it's necessary.

Speaker:

But if you give yourself

Speaker:

a second, a breath, you

Speaker:

can enter into system two

Speaker:

and you can call it

Speaker:

in.

Speaker:

And that's where you can

Speaker:

get some perspective, maybe some

Speaker:

empathy.

Speaker:

And let's be honest, a

Speaker:

little more wisdom probably as

Speaker:

well.

Speaker:

So taking a break from

Speaker:

criticism isn't just about being

Speaker:

nicer.

Speaker:

And I said that before.

Speaker:

It's about really building mental

Speaker:

muscle and can let us

Speaker:

choose our response instead of

Speaker:

reacting without thinking through that

Speaker:

fast automatic system.

Speaker:

And it's a shift from

Speaker:

reacting on autopilot to choosing

Speaker:

and getting yourself back in

Speaker:

the driver's seat.

Speaker:

Those drivers out there, right?

Speaker:

We talk about the criticism

Speaker:

that I mentioned before.

Speaker:

Other drivers.

Speaker:

And then we get out

Speaker:

of the car and we

Speaker:

go, oh, hi, friend.

Speaker:

You know, we've just been

Speaker:

talking about what they were

Speaker:

driving.

Speaker:

And then we get out

Speaker:

and we see it's someone

Speaker:

that we know.

Speaker:

We're going to break some

Speaker:

of that today and laugh

Speaker:

at ourselves a little bit

Speaker:

because we're human.

Speaker:

So the next benefit of

Speaker:

a criticism free day is

Speaker:

you can choose curiosity over

Speaker:

certainty by inviting what's called

Speaker:

a beginner's mind.

Speaker:

So you're choosing curiosity about

Speaker:

the situation over certainty that

Speaker:

this is something worth criticizing.

Speaker:

And this idea comes from

Speaker:

Zen Buddhism and especially from

Speaker:

the teacher Shunryu Suzuki, who

Speaker:

helped bring Zen philosophy to

Speaker:

the West.

Speaker:

He passed in 1971, but

Speaker:

he's largely attributed to really

Speaker:

bringing many of the ideas

Speaker:

and philosophies of Zen Buddhism

Speaker:

to the West originally.

Speaker:

And he talked about something

Speaker:

called the Beginner's Mind.

Speaker:

It's a mindset of approaching

Speaker:

life and people and conversations

Speaker:

and even mistakes with openness,

Speaker:

with a sense of maybe

Speaker:

you don't know everything.

Speaker:

There's more to see and

Speaker:

more to learn, that there's

Speaker:

more possibilities than you assumed

Speaker:

at first.

Speaker:

And Suzuki famously said, "In

Speaker:

the beginner's mind, there are

Speaker:

many possibilities.

Speaker:

In the experts, there are

Speaker:

few."

Speaker:

And I don't know about

Speaker:

you, but that really makes

Speaker:

me pause.

Speaker:

Because the truth is, criticism

Speaker:

often comes from a place

Speaker:

of certainty, like you're for

Speaker:

sure.

Speaker:

Because we think that we

Speaker:

know already what someone meant.

Speaker:

We think we know why

Speaker:

they did what they're doing

Speaker:

or are doing what they're

Speaker:

doing.

Speaker:

And we think we already

Speaker:

know how the story is

Speaker:

going to play out.

Speaker:

But when we practice letting

Speaker:

go of the tight grip

Speaker:

maybe of being right or

Speaker:

being the expert in the

Speaker:

moment, again, we can create

Speaker:

some space.

Speaker:

We create that Beginner's Mind,

Speaker:

the openness for listening and

Speaker:

for learning and something softer

Speaker:

and maybe more gentle to

Speaker:

yourself and for others.

Speaker:

So stepping back from critiques

Speaker:

is also stepping into curiosity.

Speaker:

And you know I always

Speaker:

like to turn us away

Speaker:

from the negative toward something.

Speaker:

If you're taking something away,

Speaker:

what are you stepping into?

Speaker:

What do you create space

Speaker:

for?

Speaker:

It's about stepping into curiosity.

Speaker:

And this shift is not

Speaker:

just philosophical.

Speaker:

It changes how you can

Speaker:

relate to people and how

Speaker:

you may relate to yourself.

Speaker:

And finally, the most personal

Speaker:

benefit of all, when you

Speaker:

pause your criticism, especially your

Speaker:

self-criticism, you can create

Speaker:

space for self-compassion.

Speaker:

So Tara Brach, a clinical

Speaker:

psychologist, a renowned thought leader

Speaker:

in this space, and also

Speaker:

a trained Buddhist teacher, and

Speaker:

has a podcast who I

Speaker:

can aspire to.

Speaker:

She has over millions of

Speaker:

people listening to her every

Speaker:

episode.

Speaker:

But she talks a lot

Speaker:

about this.

Speaker:

She reminds us that one

Speaker:

of the most powerful ways

Speaker:

to break the cycle of

Speaker:

judgment is to treat ourselves

Speaker:

with the same kindness we

Speaker:

might offer to a good

Speaker:

friend.

Speaker:

You've heard a version of

Speaker:

this before, certainly.

Speaker:

Not pity on someone, not

Speaker:

letting ourselves off the hook

Speaker:

in a hollow way, but

Speaker:

real compassion.

Speaker:

And she says, and I

Speaker:

quote, "Whenever we're trapped in self-judgment, our first and wisest step toward freedom is to develop compassion for ourselves." And

Speaker:

I think that's just such

Speaker:

a beautiful way to put

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

Because so often we say

Speaker:

things to ourselves we would

Speaker:

never say out loud to

Speaker:

someone else.

Speaker:

Things that are sharp and

Speaker:

dismissive and defeating.

Speaker:

But when we choose to

Speaker:

stop even briefly and ask,

Speaker:

"what would kindness sound like

Speaker:

right now?"

Speaker:

We can shift the entire

Speaker:

tone of our day.

Speaker:

So a criticism-free day

Speaker:

isn't just about being less

Speaker:

reactive on the outside.

Speaker:

It's about being more caring

Speaker:

on the inside.

Speaker:

It's a practice, and it's

Speaker:

one that can pay you

Speaker:

back the returns on investment

Speaker:

every time you choose.

Speaker:

Okay, so maybe you've been

Speaker:

nodding along with some of

Speaker:

these ideas.

Speaker:

Maybe you've even been noticing

Speaker:

how your own inner voice

Speaker:

and what it's saying, you

Speaker:

might be noticing a little

Speaker:

more closely as we're talking

Speaker:

about this topic.

Speaker:

And all of this is

Speaker:

part of the practice as

Speaker:

well.

Speaker:

So right now, before we

Speaker:

actually get into the practices

Speaker:

that will help you practice

Speaker:

the practices, I want to

Speaker:

offer a moment, you know,

Speaker:

our Mindful Minute, so that

Speaker:

we can practice this a

Speaker:

little bit in real time.

Speaker:

It'll be our opportunity to

Speaker:

pause and anchor ourselves and

Speaker:

gently explore what it feels

Speaker:

like to create space from

Speaker:

criticism.

Speaker:

And maybe enter and put

Speaker:

into it something that can

Speaker:

be softer.

Speaker:

So our Mindful Minute today

Speaker:

is about moving from criticism

Speaker:

to clarity.

Speaker:

So let's first prepare briefly.

Speaker:

If you're safe to do

Speaker:

so, get yourself comfortable.

Speaker:

If you're driving, still pay

Speaker:

attention, but come back to

Speaker:

this later.

Speaker:

Let your feet rest gently

Speaker:

on the floor.

Speaker:

Feel grounded.

Speaker:

Maybe dig your toes in

Speaker:

for a second, then release.

Speaker:

Dig your heels in for

Speaker:

a second.

Speaker:

Release so you know you're

Speaker:

grounded.

Speaker:

Let your hands settle wherever

Speaker:

you are.

Speaker:

Maybe soften your gaze or

Speaker:

you can gently close your

Speaker:

eyes if it feels okay.

Speaker:

Let's take one slow preparation

Speaker:

breath in together through the

Speaker:

nose and out through the

Speaker:

mouth.

Speaker:

Okay, let's begin.

Speaker:

Bring to mind a recent

Speaker:

moment today or this week

Speaker:

when you felt that tug

Speaker:

of criticism.

Speaker:

Maybe it was toward someone

Speaker:

else.

Speaker:

Maybe it was toward yourself.

Speaker:

Nothing dramatic, just a quick

Speaker:

reaction or maybe a judgment

Speaker:

that you made.

Speaker:

Continue to breathe.

Speaker:

Just notice that moment.

Speaker:

And see it without fixing

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

Label it maybe like judging

Speaker:

or reacting.

Speaker:

Sort of breathe through it.

Speaker:

Invite in a different voice.

Speaker:

What else might be going

Speaker:

on here?

Speaker:

Could I meet this moment

Speaker:

with curiosity?

Speaker:

And let that phrase, curiosity,

Speaker:

echo quietly through your last

Speaker:

couple breaths.

Speaker:

Now let that moment go.

Speaker:

Let it be.

Speaker:

There we have it.

Speaker:

A little bit more than

Speaker:

a minute there.

Speaker:

I had to let go

Speaker:

of the thing that was

Speaker:

coming into my mind.

Speaker:

It took a minute.

Speaker:

Sometimes it does.

Speaker:

But we just created a

Speaker:

little space.

Speaker:

You can shift something even

Speaker:

just by noticing.

Speaker:

And that's going to be

Speaker:

the practice.

Speaker:

It's about awareness.

Speaker:

It's about taking a breath.

Speaker:

It's about softening how our

Speaker:

mind is thinking at that

Speaker:

moment.

Speaker:

It's how we begin.

Speaker:

Thank you for sharing that

Speaker:

Mindful Minute with me.

Speaker:

So now it's time to

Speaker:

put it into practice.

Speaker:

We talked about why, why

Speaker:

stepping away from the constant

Speaker:

criticism can shift how we

Speaker:

feel and how we relate

Speaker:

and even how our brains

Speaker:

function.

Speaker:

And we've taken that minute

Speaker:

together to notice, get sort

Speaker:

of lost in that, and

Speaker:

to release it, stepping into

Speaker:

and toward clarity and into

Speaker:

curiosity.

Speaker:

So now how we bring

Speaker:

this into real life, into

Speaker:

our 1,000 waking minutes

Speaker:

each day.

Speaker:

As you may know already

Speaker:

if you've listened before, I

Speaker:

like to try to keep

Speaker:

things simple and hopefully memorable,

Speaker:

something that you can tuck

Speaker:

in your back pocket for

Speaker:

when you need it most.

Speaker:

You say, oh, I remember

Speaker:

that.

Speaker:

Sometimes it takes a little

Speaker:

practice, but then we get

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

So I've come up with

Speaker:

a little framework.

Speaker:

And it is one of

Speaker:

those rare moments when an

Speaker:

acronym actually kind of emerged

Speaker:

that actually is a word

Speaker:

that makes sense.

Speaker:

And it's a word that

Speaker:

fits the theme of today.

Speaker:

And the word is clear.

Speaker:

C-L-E-A-R.

Speaker:

Because when we step back

Speaker:

from criticism, especially the quick

Speaker:

and reactive things, we do

Speaker:

start to feel a little

Speaker:

clearer.

Speaker:

Our relationships, our choices, even

Speaker:

our inner dialogue that chatter.

Speaker:

So here it is, five

Speaker:

steps to help you create

Speaker:

a criticism-free day or

Speaker:

at least a few criticism

Speaker:

-free moments.

Speaker:

But I encourage you to

Speaker:

try the whole day.

Speaker:

Just keep coming back to

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

Keep coming back to it.

Speaker:

And the best part is

Speaker:

you don't need anything fancy

Speaker:

here at all.

Speaker:

You just need a little

Speaker:

intention, little awareness to bring

Speaker:

to it, and five letters.

Speaker:

C in clear is Catch

Speaker:

it.

Speaker:

This is the first step

Speaker:

just to notice.

Speaker:

Catch the moment that the

Speaker:

critical thought shows up.

Speaker:

It might be about someone

Speaker:

else.

Speaker:

It might be about yourself.

Speaker:

It might be about that

Speaker:

coffee order or that driver

Speaker:

who cut you off.

Speaker:

Whatever it is, notice it.

Speaker:

Label it gently if that

Speaker:

helps like we did in

Speaker:

the mindful minute.

Speaker:

Is it judging?

Speaker:

Is it wanting to fix

Speaker:

something?

Speaker:

Here it is again.

Speaker:

Awareness is the first step

Speaker:

of beginning to change.

Speaker:

Catch it.

Speaker:

L - Let it pause.

Speaker:

Oh, my gosh, the pause.

Speaker:

Here's the part that feels

Speaker:

small but makes so much

Speaker:

difference.

Speaker:

Do nothing.

Speaker:

Take a beat.

Speaker:

Take a breath.

Speaker:

Close your lips.

Speaker:

Whatever it is, take a

Speaker:

pause.

Speaker:

Let it pause.

Speaker:

Don't react yet.

Speaker:

Don't post the comment.

Speaker:

Don't speak the sentence.

Speaker:

Take a breath and let

Speaker:

the moment breathe too.

Speaker:

You're starting to interrupt the

Speaker:

pattern when you take pauses.

Speaker:

We use this all the

Speaker:

time in all kinds of

Speaker:

things that we want to

Speaker:

make change in our behaviors,

Speaker:

in our workplace.

Speaker:

It's take a pause.

Speaker:

Let it pause.

Speaker:

And it can be powerful.

Speaker:

E, Explore with curiosity.

Speaker:

Here's that curiosity.

Speaker:

Explore.

Speaker:

Instead of defaulting to critique,

Speaker:

get curious.

Speaker:

Ask, what is going on

Speaker:

here?

Speaker:

What else might be true?

Speaker:

Always love that one.

Speaker:

What's missing?

Speaker:

What else might be true?

Speaker:

Or even, why is this

Speaker:

bothering me right now?

Speaker:

Why?

Speaker:

One of my favorites from

Speaker:

earlier that I talked about

Speaker:

is, I wonder what's behind

Speaker:

that choice.

Speaker:

I wonder what's behind that.

Speaker:

This is the Beginner's Mind

Speaker:

in action.

Speaker:

You're going to choose to

Speaker:

be open, curious instead of

Speaker:

certain.

Speaker:

Next, A - Ask.

Speaker:

Is it necessary or helpful

Speaker:

to criticize, to say something?

Speaker:

Not every thought needs to

Speaker:

become an action.

Speaker:

Not every reaction needs a

Speaker:

reaction.

Speaker:

Ask, is it necessary or

Speaker:

helpful?

Speaker:

Ask yourself, is this for

Speaker:

connection or correction?

Speaker:

Is this true?

Speaker:

Is this kind?

Speaker:

Is this needed?

Speaker:

This is a little nod

Speaker:

to that Buddhism's right speech

Speaker:

right there.

Speaker:

Sometimes the answer is yes.

Speaker:

And sometimes it's just not

Speaker:

the moment for that.

Speaker:

And R, Release or Rephrase.

Speaker:

Now you have a choice.

Speaker:

Because you have a choice.

Speaker:

You can let it go.

Speaker:

Release it.

Speaker:

You can let it go

Speaker:

entirely.

Speaker:

Maybe with a big breath.

Speaker:

Exhale.

Speaker:

On the exhale.

Speaker:

Or you can reframe it

Speaker:

into something kinder or more

Speaker:

useful.

Speaker:

Release or Rephrase.

Speaker:

You might try like a

Speaker:

phrase, "May I be well,

Speaker:

may they be well."

Speaker:

It's like a metta phrase

Speaker:

or a little mantra that

Speaker:

you can work through.

Speaker:

Or you might choose silence.

Speaker:

Or you might choose humor.

Speaker:

Or you might choose patience.

Speaker:

You can let it move

Speaker:

through.

Speaker:

And you're actually in control

Speaker:

here.

Speaker:

Because you have a choice

Speaker:

to release or rephrase.

Speaker:

So that's the practice.

Speaker:

Catch it.

Speaker:

Let it pause.

Speaker:

Explore.

Speaker:

Ask.

Speaker:

And release.

Speaker:

Clear.

Speaker:

C-L-E-A-R.

Speaker:

When you want to clear

Speaker:

your mind of criticism, even

Speaker:

just for a moment, this

Speaker:

is your guide.

Speaker:

And maybe this becomes your

Speaker:

mantra for the day.

Speaker:

Maybe this is your mini

Speaker:

reset when something gets under

Speaker:

your skin.

Speaker:

Or even the way you

Speaker:

shift how you speak to

Speaker:

yourself, especially when no one's

Speaker:

listening.

Speaker:

Because the truth is, when

Speaker:

we make room for this

Speaker:

kind of clarity, for using

Speaker:

clear, you can free so

Speaker:

much space up as well.

Speaker:

For your creativity.

Speaker:

For your compassion.

Speaker:

For calm.

Speaker:

Just being a little more

Speaker:

human with each other, perhaps.

Speaker:

Clear.

Speaker:

C-L-E-A-R.

Speaker:

So here's the thing I

Speaker:

hope you take with you

Speaker:

today:

Speaker:

'You become what you practice.'

Speaker:

And for my daughter and

Speaker:

you, hopefully I've given you

Speaker:

the practices in a way

Speaker:

that you can go practice

Speaker:

the practices to help start

Speaker:

to break the cycle of

Speaker:

criticism that we all find

Speaker:

ourselves in from time to

Speaker:

time.

Speaker:

By the way, if you,

Speaker:

like so many of us,

Speaker:

have been practicing criticism even

Speaker:

unintentionally, then it makes sense

Speaker:

that it shows up so

Speaker:

easily.

Speaker:

So don't criticize that about

Speaker:

yourself.

Speaker:

But what if just for

Speaker:

a day you practice something

Speaker:

else?

Speaker:

Maybe it's catching one critical

Speaker:

thought before it leaves your

Speaker:

lips.

Speaker:

Maybe it's pausing before an

Speaker:

eye roll.

Speaker:

Maybe it's choosing curiosity or

Speaker:

even compassion instead of a

Speaker:

usual reaction.

Speaker:

Even one small shift can

Speaker:

start to change the tone

Speaker:

of your day.

Speaker:

And that's the invitation.

Speaker:

Try it.

Speaker:

I sure am.

Speaker:

I do and I am

Speaker:

and I remind myself when

Speaker:

I need it most.

Speaker:

And sometimes it comes up

Speaker:

when the timing of episodes

Speaker:

happen as well.

Speaker:

So try it with someone.

Speaker:

This can be really cool

Speaker:

to try with a friend

Speaker:

and check in and even

Speaker:

reflect and even marvel, sometimes

Speaker:

laugh about it later.

Speaker:

And remember, this is not

Speaker:

about creating some idealized version

Speaker:

of a world that's free

Speaker:

of criticism, but it's about

Speaker:

practicing toward releasing some of

Speaker:

the noise, lowering the background

Speaker:

music of critiques, and turning

Speaker:

up the volume on awareness

Speaker:

and the happy and joyful

Speaker:

music you really want to

Speaker:

listen to.

Speaker:

It's about your presence.

Speaker:

It's about giving the people

Speaker:

around you and yourself just

Speaker:

a little more space to

Speaker:

be human.

Speaker:

Do you feel like you

Speaker:

might need this?

Speaker:

I know I do every

Speaker:

so often.

Speaker:

So if you do give

Speaker:

it a try, I'd truly

Speaker:

love to hear from you.

Speaker:

You can always find me

Speaker:

at wendybazilian.com.

Speaker:

That's my website.

Speaker:

Or you can write me

Speaker:

at 1KWM@wendybazilian.com.

Speaker:

And again, you might try

Speaker:

this with a friend or

Speaker:

share, if you would, the

Speaker:

episode with someone who might

Speaker:

like this.

Speaker:

And as always, thank you

Speaker:

for sharing a few of

Speaker:

your waking minutes with me

Speaker:

today as we explored the

Speaker:

simple but powerful practice of

Speaker:

a criticism-free day.

Speaker:

Until next time, be well.

Speaker:

Thank you for tuning in

Speaker:

to 1,000 Waking Minutes.

Speaker:

A huge thank you to

Speaker:

our amazing collaborators, including our

Speaker:

production and marketing teams, and

Speaker:

Gabriela Escalante in particular.

Speaker:

To the ultra talented Beza

Speaker:

for my theme music, my

Speaker:

lifelong friend and artist, Pearl

Speaker:

Preis Photography and Design.

Speaker:

To Danielle Ballantyne, Jen Nguyen,

Speaker:

Joanna Powell, and of course

Speaker:

my family.

Speaker:

And everyone working tirelessly behind

Speaker:

the scenes.

Speaker:

And to you, our valued

Speaker:

listeners, I so appreciate your

Speaker:

support.

Speaker:

If you enjoyed today's episode,

Speaker:

please consider leaving a comment,

Speaker:

writing a review and giving

Speaker:

1,000 Waking Minutes, that's us,

Speaker:

a five-star rating.

Speaker:

And please hit subscribe on

Speaker:

Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever

Speaker:

you enjoy your podcasts.

Speaker:

Please follow and stay connected

Speaker:

at wendybazilian.com.

Speaker:

And don't forget to share

Speaker:

with your friends.

Speaker:

Your support helps us grow

Speaker:

and bring you more great

Speaker:

content.

Speaker:

Until next time, find some

Speaker:

simple opportunities to optimize those

Speaker:

1,000 Waking Minutes each day.

Speaker:

I'm saying yes to better

Speaker:

days, yes.

Speaker:

I'm on my way, yes.

Speaker:

It's gonna be okay, yeah.

Speaker:

I'm saying yes to better

Speaker:

days, yes.

Speaker:

I'm on my way, yes.

Speaker:

It's gonna be okay, yeah.

Follow

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube