Does a good DM need a Code of Ethics? Long-time listener, Dr. DM himself, Jason, brings Tony, Chris, and Dave a question that reaches beyond rules and encounter design: when a player dominates the spotlight, cheats, crosses a boundary, or simply stops having fun, what responsibility does the DM have to act?

The 3 Wise DMs discuss the DM’s influence over the table, the responsibilities players share, and the value of setting expectations before play begins. Along the way, Tony recalls a treasure dispute that went spectacularly wrong, while the group considers character agency, honest feedback, and Shadowdark’s “Pact” of goodwill, respect, and fellowship.

2:45 Dr. DM’s question about a DM Code of Ethics.

5:54 Spotlight sharing, cheating, and when a DM should intervene.

7:58 DM Chris distinguishes table etiquette from professional ethics.

11:58 The elegance of Shadowdark’s “The Pact.”

14:15 Character conflict vs Player conflict.

19:11 Curating your table.

22:35 “Back in the Day with DM Tony”: Treasure gone wrong.

27:07 Fairness, Session Zero, and a shared responsibility for the fun.

29:43 Player agency: how to handle when a character’s goals are sidelined.

37:23 Checking in with players: The Open Door Policy.

40:15 Players responsibility for raising concerns with the DM.

41:40 Final Thoughts.