In Part 1 of the MacNeill Case, we unravel the depraved story of Dr. Martin MacNeill, a prominent Utah physician and former LDS bishop accused of planning his wife’s death behind a "picture-perfect" facade. This episode shows how a pillar of the community utilized his medical authority and social standing to manipulate those around him while leading a double life.
The Forced Facelift: Martin pressured a healthy Michele into an unnecessary surgery to justify his "care" for her.
The Lethal Cocktail: Martin took total control of Michelle's post-op care, insisting on a potent mix of drugs.
The $10,000 Hospital Bribe: Shocking testimony revealed Martin offered cash to a doctor to "save" Michele.
The Safety Fair Alibi: Martin aggressively sought to be photographed at a local event to create a timed paper trail.
The Instant Replacement: Within weeks of the funeral, Martin moved his mistress, Gypsy Willis, into the family home calling her the new "nanny."
00:00 The $10,000 Bribe: A Doctor’s Calculated Betrayal - Part 1
00:37 The Illusion of Pleasnat Grove
02:03 The "Perfect" Doctor. Who are the MacNeill's?
03:53 Cracks in the Facade: The Secret Life
06:11 The Forced Facelift
11:59 The Moment it All Changed
15:55 Forgery
19:18 Betrayal
22:51 A Fake Illness
25:35 Facelift Gift
26:16 The Lethal Cocktail
30:31 The Alibi: The Safety Fair Stunt
31:40 The 911 Call
36:16 The $10,000 Bribe
36:58 The Forensic Failure: A "Natural" Death
38:34 The "Nanny" Arrives
39:38 The Comprehensive Plan
Sources:
Utah Office of the Medical Examiner: Official Toxicology Report for Michele Marie MacNeill (Ref: Zolpidem and multi-drug toxicity analysis).
Utah Fourth District Court: Affidavit in Support of Arrest Warrant (August 2012) – Statement of Probable Cause detailing homicide investigation and witness statements.
Court of Appeals of Utah: Judicial Ruling, STATE OF UTAH v. MARTIN MACNEILL (2017), Docket No. 20140873-CA.
Defense Memorandum (August 2013): Motion to exclude testimony of Anna Osborne Walthall.
ABC News "20/20": After Wife's Death, Dark Secrets of Utah Doctor Revealed.
The Salt Lake Tribune: Investigation into the sentencing and subsequent murder charges of Martin MacNeill.
Deseret News: Martin MacNeill: Was his wife Michele's death accidental or murder? and official case timelines.
The Daily Herald: Reports on federal identity theft sentencing and sex abuse convictions.
CNN/HLN: Investigative coverage of the key players and trial proceedings in the MacNeill murder case.
People.com: Report on the conviction of Martin MacNeill and related family charges.
#MichelleMacNeill #MartinMacNeill #PleasantGrove #TrueCrime #thealibi
