In the fifth episode of the International Solidarity Movement podcast we are joined in the village of At-Tuwani by two ISM volunteers - Herbie and Maria - who both spent several months volunteering as internationalists in Palestine. They tell us from a personal perspective what it's like to be an international volunteer in Palestine, and especially in the South Hebron Hills. ISM is focusing it's presence here because of to the ongoing demolitions of Palestinian homes and infrastructure by the Israeli occupation.
We ask Herbie and Maria what brought them to Palestine, what they would say to people who are thinking of joining ISM but aren't sure yet, and also what it's been like witnessing some of the violence of the occupation.
View the episode transcript here
Links:
If you would like an explanation of the terms used in this podcast, you can find a useful glossary on pages 140-154 of Shoal Collective's Ebook Interviews with Radical Palestinian Women.
Supported by Shoal Collective.
Hey, welcome to international solidarity
Introduction:movement podcast [followed by Arabic translation]
Hazel:azeazeaHello and welcome to the fifth episode of the
Hazel:International Solidarity Movement podcast.
Hazel:Today we are joined in the village of At-Tuwani by two ISM
Hazel:volunteers - Herbie and Maria - who both spent several months
Hazel:volunteering as internationalists in Palestine.
Hazel:they tell us from a personal perspective what it's like to be
Hazel:an international volunteer in Palestine, and especially in the
Hazel:South Hebron Hills, where ISM is focusing it's presence, due to
Hazel:the ongoing demolitions of Palestinian homes and
Hazel:infrastructure by the Israeli occupation.
Hazel:We touch on what brought them to Palestine, what they would say
Hazel:to people who are thinking of joining ISM but aren't sure yet,
Hazel:and also what it's been like witnessing some of the violence
Hazel:of the occupation.
Hazel:At the end of the interview, Herbie and Maria discuss the
Hazel:culpability of Western states in the ongoing colonisation of
Hazel:Palestine and - in opposition to this - how we can directly take
Hazel:action to stand with and struggle alongside the
Hazel:Palestinian people in their fight for autonomy and freedom.
Nicole:So we're really happy to be joined by two volunteers from
Nicole:ISM, the International Solidarity Movement, who have
Nicole:been in Palestine for several months this year at different
Nicole:points. And we're going to be asking them some questions about
Nicole:their experiences here, some of the challenges, things they've
Nicole:learned, and also enjoyed since they've been here. But yeah, if
Nicole:you'd like to introduce yourself, that would be amazing.
Maria:Hi, everyone. So I’m Maria, and yeah, I've been, I'm
Maria:almost at the end of my visa. So I've been here for three months
Maria:now. And I was here a month over the Summer.
Herbie:Hi, everyone, I'm Herbie, I've been here for
Herbie:nearly two months now. And I've got about another month left of
Nicole:Can you share a little bit about how your experiences
Nicole:my visa.
Nicole:have been here?
Maria:Yeah. So I think the situation in general is very
Maria:challenging on the ground. I was here for the first time this
Maria:summer. And it was quite mind blowing. I've been campaigning
Maria:for Palestine in the UK. But I think when you see things on the
Maria:ground, and you live them, and you experience them, and you
Maria:talk to people, it's... it's completely different.
Maria:I think you get used to like the rhythm quite quickly. But yeah,
Maria:I think overall it has been amazing. I've met lots of very,
Maria:very interesting people. The Palestinian activists are great.
Maria:The international activists are all amazing. And we've also met
Maria:lots of Israeli activists, which are really nice. So I think
Maria:generally, like very recommended experience and very positive,
Maria:but yeah, it's, it's challenging. And ISM is very
Maria:often on the first line. So you are, yeah, very often like, in
Maria:[a] conflict situation. And some of them can be very challenging,
Maria:but I think you develop as a person as well. So yeah,
Maria:positive in general.
Nicole:What's your kind of like day to day, what would like an
Nicole:average day look like here?
Herbie:I mean, to be honest, like, every day is different.
Herbie:And it's very dependent on where we are. At the minute, we're in
Herbie:Masafer Yatta. And we're kind of based in a couple of different
Herbie:villages. In one of them, we do the like morning and afternoon
Herbie:school run, because some of the children have to walk through a
Herbie:settlement, Havat Ma’on – sorry, [it’s] an illegal outpost - to
Herbie:get to school, and they sometimes get attacked by
Herbie:settlers. So they have a military escort. And then we are
Herbie:also there waiting for them on the other side, to make sure
Herbie:they've arrived safely. But things often pop up very
Herbie:unexpectedly - like you, you can never predict what's going to
Herbie:happen in a day. For example, on Monday, everything was very
Herbie:lrelaxed. I, like, didn't have a lot to do. And then the next
Herbie:day, I was at three different demolitions in different
Herbie:villages in Masafer Yatta. And there was also a fourth
Herbie:demolition, and then I went to another village to visit some
Herbie:children whose school was recently demolished. So it
Herbie:varies a lot.
Nicole:We’ve been interviewing in some of the villagers we hear
Nicole:about the demolitions and their experiences, but could you share
Nicole:a little bit about what your - your role is, while that's
Nicole:happening, and what you've observed?
Herbie:Yeah, so I suppose the most important role for us and
Herbie:and what the locals want is that we're there to document what's
Herbie:happening. Because we're like, in the area, we can, we're
Herbie:either like, already living in that village, or we can get
Herbie:there very quickly. We can get there like, a lot faster than,
Herbie:you know, the UN can or anyone else. So we're there to like,
Herbie:document the whole thing so that the world can hear about what's
Herbie:happening otherwise. You know, most people would just never
Herbie:know that these people's homes and villages are being
Herbie:destroyed.
Herbie:In an ideal world, if there was enough of us here, then we could
Herbie:take direct action to actively resist the demolitions for
Herbie:example, like going on the diggers, blocking vehicles,
Herbie:surrounding the house. But unfortunately, since lockdown
Herbie:there is like a very low number of volunteers here. And it's
Herbie:just not safe or effective for us to try to do those things if
Herbie:we don't have the numbers for it. So yeah, it's quite, it's
Herbie:quite difficult just standing there filming instead of trying
Herbie:to resist it happening. Another thing we can do is try to
Herbie:de-arrest Palestinians if they're being taken by the
Herbie:police.
Nicole:And I know like some people in the UK that have
Nicole:considered coming - like maybe they're nervous because they
Nicole:don't know what to expect or they have health issues. They
Nicole:don't feel like they can do it. Or like mental health
Nicole:challenges… Like do you feel like it is accessible for
Nicole:everyone here or do you feel like there are different roles
Nicole:people can do, or do you think it has been quite kind of
Nicole:physically demanding, the work here? Like what's the kind of,
Nicole:yeah, experiences in terms of like your own health and your
Nicole:own well being.
Maria:Yeah I think as an organization it is quite wide.
Maria:And there are roles for everyone. And you can show
Maria:solidarity in lots of different ways, even only just living in a
Maria:village and like showing people that, you know, internationals
Maria:are there, and they're aware of the situation. And they are
Maria:filming, if needed, then that gives Palestinians strength and
Maria:like, is a push for them to continue the fight. If you feel
Maria:like physically able, then there is of course, like more
Maria:challenging - physically challenging - work to do. But
Maria:like, it's, it's nothing crazy. And we've got media roles,
Maria:international coordinator roles.
Maria:So yeah I think the good thing of ISM is that everyone, yeah,
Maria:so the good thing of ISM is that like everyone can participate in
Maria:the capacity that they feel they can. So if you want to be more
Maria:based in the flats, or like in house in a village, you can do
Maria:that. Again, if you feel like being in the front line, and
Maria:like, put yourself more at risk, you can also do that. So it's
Maria:really up to the person. Mentally it is a challenging
Maria:situation, but you will always, always have support from people
Maria:on the ground. So I think it's, I think it's generally
Maria:accessible to most people.amar
Herbie:Yeah, I would, I would agree that like the ISM will,
Herbie:like, try and accommodate for people's health needs. But I do
Herbie:think it is important to consider that like, it is a very
Herbie:mentally challenging situation. I'm definitely someone who's
Herbie:like struggled with my mental health. And I really had to
Herbie:think hard about whether I was like mentally stable enough to
Herbie:deal with this context. And it has been a challenge. And I
Herbie:think it's also really important to look after yourself whenever
Herbie:you go home as well, because I think also, although being here
Herbie:is difficult, I think also leaving and going back to
Herbie:‘normality’, and having to process everything is - can be
Herbie:quite difficult for people.
Herbie:And I think it's also important to consider that like, a lot of
Herbie:the work here is quite physical, like we do a lot of like,
Herbie:walking from village to village, we don't have - we can’t always
Herbie:get a lift to places. There is like, you know, like, yeah,
Herbie:physical work to do, as well. And at demos you might have to
Herbie:run if there's like, gunfire and things. So, yeah, it is
Herbie:accessible to different people's needs. But it is also important
Herbie:to like consider what you're able to do before coming. And,
Herbie:like, not put yourself in dangerous situations.
Nicole:A lot of people will see Palestine on the news. And yeah,
Nicole:like, for someone that's never been here before, like I think,
Nicole:it does feel like extremely intimidating. Of, “oh my god, am
Nicole:I gonna get shot? Am I gonna witness someone else getting
Nicole:shot?” Like, it's really got this kind of like, I mean, it is
Nicole:a conflict zone, right? But I think it's been very different
Nicole:being here and seeing the kind of normality in the day to day
Nicole:things, even though everyone is like, relentlessly affected by
Nicole:the occupation. And it kind of defines everyone's lives. I just
Nicole:wondered like, how it's been for you in terms of violence and
Nicole:like, you don't have to disclose what you don't feel comfortable
Nicole:with but, like, yeah, how has it felt being here and seeing the
Nicole:occupation and how it affects people?
Nicole:For me, that has been a bit challenging. I think, especially
Nicole:over the summer, I've been to a couple of demos where two kids
Nicole:were shot, and they died. So we've been to funerals as well.
Nicole:And like, the funerals are, like a whole experience here. Because
Nicole:there are like, thousands of people that attend and, you
Nicole:know, it's like, sort of a national mourning. So it's a
Nicole:very intense experience. I don't know if that's the right, like-
Nicole:[it’s] very beautiful on one side in the sense that there are
Nicole:all these communities that come together, and you know, like
Nicole:mourning the martyrs. But yeah, I mean, in terms of violence,
Nicole:you might experience some here and witness some and that's very
Nicole:hard. As I say. So seeing like people getting shot or like
Nicole:seeing settlers’ violence. We've ended up in a couple of
Nicole:situations where we thought that we're gonna get injured, then
Nicole:that didn't happen. But yeah, I think, again, ISM tries to cover
Nicole:this situation – there are a lot of different lines. It's then up
Nicole:to the volunteer if they want to go, if they want to participate,
Nicole:and things like that.
Nicole:Especially like demonstrations this summer, they were very
Nicole:intense. I was here when they - the two or three days that they
Nicole:bombed Gaza. So like they were doing demonstration here in the
Nicole:West Bank and those like, they were quite tough and they were,
Nicole:like, repressed horribly, by the IOF [Israeli Occupation Forces].
Nicole:So that was harsh. And I think in general, like I think as
Nicole:Herbie said, the situation can kick off anytime, so... and
Nicole:soldiers and settlers don't like to see international[s] filming
Nicole:and being here. So you often are the targets of of soldiers -
Nicole:like not in a physical way, but you know, like them trying to
Nicole:scare you, or like making you leave. So you kind of need to be
Nicole:mentally prepared for that sort of violence as well.
Nicole:I think I've been very - not surprised here, but people
Nicole:have really been like, “oh, we need internationals to talk
Nicole:about this, we need pressure, like… things are getting worse,
Nicole:because there needs to be more pressure from the international
Nicole:community”. And I think maybe I hadn't come previously in my
Nicole:life because of, I guess, okay, like, you know, there's a lot of
Nicole:language around like white saviourism, or people traveling
Nicole:abroad when there's like, oppression in the UK, you know,
Nicole:like the prison system or racism or how like refugees and
Nicole:migrants are treated in the UK and stuff. So I think I've never
Nicole:been like a natural internationalist, if that makes
Nicole:sense. But I'm - it's kind of very interestingly, like,
Nicole:massively made an impression on me that people seem so
Nicole:welcoming, like just buying us coffees on the street, or, you
Nicole:know, like sweetcorn from a stand or just people -
Nicole:everyone's interested in us and asking questions and people are
Nicole:like, “thank you for coming.” And there seems to be this like
Nicole:amazing, like openness and hospitality. I just wondered if
Nicole:you had any kind of thoughts about that. Maybe someone is
Nicole:listening, and they're like, “Oh, I feel weird about going”,
Nicole:or, like, has that stuff come up for you?
Herbie:Yeah, the whole like, white savior thing is definitely
Herbie:something that I was quite worried about. You know, if that
Herbie:if you think that you're going to come here and save people and
Herbie:free Palestine, like that is very much not the case. You're,
Herbie:you're here to learn from the people and be led by them and
Herbie:show solidarity with them. And yeah. So it is important to
Herbie:think about your intentions for coming for sure. But my
Herbie:experience of being here, as you said, like everyone is, like, so
Herbie:welcoming. And I think just grateful that we're here because
Herbie:you know, there is just such a lack of coverage of what is
Herbie:really happening here. So it's so important for us to be here
Herbie:and to see the reality on the ground and to go home and share
Herbie:that with people.
Maria:Yeah, completely agree. And ISM is 100% Palestinian led.
Maria:We're non-violent, of course. But we would never ever take the
Maria:initiative of doing anything if the Palestinians around us are
Maria:not – like we’ve not consulted them before. So that's an
Maria:important point. And yeah, I think as Herbie was saying,
Maria:like, we're not saviours. But I think the Palestinians
Maria:understand how isolated they are outside this... the situation on
Maria:the ground, and like in Western countries, and whatever. And
Maria:because like, Israel has all these ties with like Western
Maria:countries and countries outside, I think they need this sort of
Maria:connection with the outside world. So it's, yeah, it's not a
Maria:matter of us coming here and being saviours, but more like
Maria:documenting in, and then try to like, lobby and do diplomacy
Maria:when we're back home.
Nicole:Amazing. What was the trigger for coming here? Like
Nicole:what inspired you to join? Obviously, there's lots of
Nicole:places you could have gone or things you could have done,
Nicole:like, what was it that kind of called you here?
Maria:So I've been campaigning for Palestine in the UK, quite a
Maria:lot. It’s something that I've been knowing about, lately
Maria:shap[ing] my life, but like, I don't know, I just feel that
Maria:this is so much dependent on like behaviors of Western
Maria:countries, and we can actively do something to stop what's
Maria:happening here. So that made me like more and more involved back
Maria:home. And then I just thought that it would have been good to
Maria:actually come and see the situation on the ground. And
Maria:this, for me, is the first time that I find myself in a
Maria:situation like this or like in a conflict area, and like having
Maria:to deal with soldiers or this violence. So it's been an
Maria:interesting growth. But yeah, I think knowing things from
Maria:outside... it just fed naturally then to come and see things on
Maria:the ground. But yeah, um, first time that I’m in like this sort
Maria:of situation.
Herbie:Yeah, that's, like, coming here has been, like, a
Herbie:long time coming for me. So I was like, very much raised as a
Herbie:Zionist. My, like, most of my family are Israeli. And I've had
Herbie:to do a lot of like unlearning. And yeah, finding out the truth
Herbie:about the situation here. And yeah, I think, I mean,
Herbie:obviously, I want to be here to show solidarity with
Herbie:Palestinians, but also like to, like, see, for myself, to be
Herbie:able to, like, communicate with my family and like, try and
Herbie:explain to them what's really happening here because like,
Herbie:although some of them are sympathetic to the cause,
Herbie:they're very inactive. And it's, it's very easy for them to just
Herbie:like, live their lives, sort of ignoring what is happening just
Herbie:like a few miles away from them. And yeah, I want to try and show
Herbie:them what's really going on and hopefully inspire them to - and
Herbie:empower them to - actually stand in solidarity with Palestinians.
Herbie:And yeah, I think also as a Jewish person, it's particularly
Herbie:important to, for me to - I guess I have, there's definitely
Herbie:guilt there. And I feel like I almost need to like show that
Herbie:not all Jewish people are Zionists.
Nicole:Yeah like a final question, I guess is, what would
Nicole:you say to someone who's maybe like, on the fence about coming,
Nicole:like thinking about it, maybe they're saving up for it, but
Nicole:they're just not quite sure whether to come on up. And you
Nicole:know, there's only a handful of us here. And I know from
Nicole:friends, they've talked about this history of ISM, where there
Nicole:was like hundreds of people here all over the West Bank doing
Nicole:different things. And it's quite – like you said at the beginning
Nicole:with the pandemic, it's really affected the amount of people
Nicole:coming. So, obviously, you know, we're hoping with this podcast
Nicole:that people will listen, and that will inspire them to join
Nicole:ISM here, but yeah, what would you say to anyone that was
Nicole:considering it, but not quite sure yet?
Maria:Yeah. I mean, I guess it's individual cases. But I
Maria:And yeah, we're saying like, there are challenges there, like
Maria:would generally encourage people to come. It's, even though it's
Maria:people should think about so again, depends on individual
Maria:a tough experience, but you grow a lot as a person. And there's
Maria:situation. But yeah, I think just think that you will never
Maria:so much to learn from people here on the ground. And I think
Maria:just seeing things with your own eyes is so much different than
Maria:be forced to do things or to be in situation where you don't
Maria:like reading or listening to stories. And yeah, like
Maria:Palestinians are absolutely amazing. And there's lots of
Maria:want to be in. So if you want to start with like a lighter
Maria:support on the ground.
Maria:approach and just understanding the situation. There will be
Maria:room to do that and maybe just go around and talk to families
Maria:like without necessarily being involved in maybe [a] conflict
Maria:situation, although that might happen. I mean, it is at risk
Maria:that you need to consider. But I think in general, it's been such
Maria:a like eye opening experience. That yeah, I cannot think of one
Maria:reason not to come here.
Herbie:Yeah, coming here for me was like such a daunting
Herbie:challenge. But one that I like… I'm 100% so glad that I made. I
Herbie:think that if you're like, unsure and you probably have
Herbie:like a lot of questions and uncertainties, like you can get
Herbie:in touch with ISM by email and attend a training and they'll
Herbie:answer all of the questions that you have. Yeah, as Maria said,
Herbie:like, it's just I mean, for me, it's like definitely been like a
Herbie:life changing experience in a good way. And yeah, you're
Herbie:stronger than you think you are. And you can, like, you know, I
Herbie:think the Palestinian people are incredibly resilient and face
Herbie:these things every day. And I think we are in a very
Herbie:privileged position to be able to like, come here and witness
Herbie:this and then go back home. And I think you won't regret coming.