What make's McFleshman's english porter special? Continuing our Taplist series, Gary grills Bobby and Allison about the origins and recipe for White Horse.
Patreon Exclusive Live Stream - Jan 5 @ 7 PM (CST): https://www.patreon.com/posts/146379474
PATREON SUPPORT
patreon.com/respectingthebeerpodcast
FACEBOOK GROUP
https://www.facebook.com/groups/respectingthebeer
QUESTIONS?
Email us at respectingthebeer@gmail.com
--
TIMELINE
00:00 Holday Break Announcement
00:44 Welcome!
02:54 The Tadcaster Trip
05:53 The Art of Beer Labels
09:07 Porter vs Stout
11:26 A Complex Recipe
14:02 The History of Porters
14:54 Open Fermentation and Yeast
15:46 Water Chemistry
16:42 ABVs
18:10 Second Chance Porter
20:51 White Horse Experiments
25:07 The Art of Cask Ales
26:07 Smoked Beers
27:28 We Got a Real Horse??
28:20 Support us on Patreon!
--
CREDITS
Hosts:
Bobby Fleshman - https://www.mcfleshmans.com/
Allison Fleshman -https://www.instagram.com/mcfleshmans/
Joel Hermansen
Gary Ardnt - https://everything-everywhere.com/everything-everywhere-daily-podcast/
Music by Sarah Lynn Huss - https://www.facebook.com/kevin.huss.52/
Recorded & Produced by David Kalsow - https://davidkalsow.com/
Brought to you by McFleshman's Brewing Co
Merry Christmas.
David:Happy New Year everyone.
David:A quick announcement,
David:we're gonna take a little holiday break the next two weeks, so next week we're gonna pull something out from behind the Patreon curtain for you, and then the following Monday, January 5th, we are doing a Patreon exclusive live stream.
David:So if you support us at any tier, you can watch our live stream recapping 2025, doing an off the shelf beer blind taste test, and looking forward to 2026.
David:we will come back into the main feed on January 12th with the Godfather of Craft Brewing.
David:I'll let you take a guess who that is.
David:Enjoy this episode of the Taplist series Exploring a White Horse English porter.
Gary Arndt:Hello everyone, and welcome to another episode of Respecting the Beer.
Gary Arndt:My name is Gary Arndt and with me on this episode, our Brewing magazine's 2026 Power couple of the year.
Gary Arndt:Bobby, that is the official name.
Gary Arndt:We've establish
Bobby Fleshman:that your birth name.
Bobby Fleshman:Hey, at least we're not talking about my middle name.
Allison Fleshman:That's true.
Allison Fleshman:Allison will
Bobby Fleshman:do that.
Bobby Fleshman:How many do you have?
Allison Fleshman:It's just one, but there're two names together.
Allison Fleshman:I think we've talked about this before.
Allison Fleshman:Lyndale is his middle name.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:There's a, there's a street in town.
Bobby Fleshman:There's, yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Like that.
Bobby Fleshman:So that's okay.
Allison Fleshman:Bobby Dale?
Gary Arndt:Yep.
Bobby Fleshman:Get back in
Gary Arndt:here.
Gary Arndt:Allison, middle name unknown.
Allison Fleshman:Michelle.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, technically Michelle McCoy.
Gary Arndt:Dr. Michelle?
Gary Arndt:Yeah, McCoy.
Gary Arndt:Hold it.
Gary Arndt:Michelle is your first name?
Allison Fleshman:No, so Allison, Michelle McCoy, Fleshman.
Allison Fleshman:Oh.
Allison Fleshman:And because I can't have two last names 'cause Oklahoma didn't understand that I wanted, I didn't wanna hyphenate it.
Allison Fleshman:They're like, well you can't have two last names.
Allison Fleshman:They just
Bobby Fleshman:allowed you to vote like five years before.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, you just moved away.
Bobby Fleshman:So
Allison Fleshman:I was,
Gary Arndt:do what rich people always did historically.
Gary Arndt:Which was George Walker Bush Walker is the, the, the family name from his mother's side.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:And that's what they would always do, right?
Gary Arndt:Is just use it as a middle name, but then go by that.
Gary Arndt:Yeah, that's
Allison Fleshman:true.
Allison Fleshman:So it's, so I wanted to keep the McCoy, um, but Oklahoma wouldn't let me put it as like two last names that wasn't hyphenated.
Allison Fleshman:So I was like, cool.
Allison Fleshman:So I'm just gonna add it to my middle name.
Allison Fleshman:So I have two middle names now.
Allison Fleshman:Michelle McCoy.
Allison Fleshman:Hey.
Allison Fleshman:Go
Gary Arndt:to, why do I think there's a Michelle McCoy who's like a celebrity?
Allison Fleshman:Um, because I am one and that's cool.
Allison Fleshman:I don't know.
Gary Arndt:You ever hear the story behind Harry s Truman?
Gary Arndt:Sure, there's a few.
Gary Arndt:There have
Allison Fleshman:been many.
Gary Arndt:You know what his middle name is?
Gary Arndt:Hmm.
Gary Arndt:S Hmm.
Gary Arndt:He didn't have a middle name, so he is like, well, it would sound a lot better if I had something.
Gary Arndt:So he just picked the initial s It's, it's s, that's all it is.
Gary Arndt:Harry s Truman.
Gary Arndt:Nice.
Gary Arndt:Nice.
Gary Arndt:Yes.
Gary Arndt:Stands for S.
Allison Fleshman:That's lovely.
Allison Fleshman:So speaking of lovely, what beer are we talking about today?
Gary Arndt:We are going to jump on the White horse.
Gary Arndt:The white horse.
Gary Arndt:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:This is the night for that.
Gary Arndt:So.
Gary Arndt:This is, uh, I'd say one of your better known cask beers, uh, that you have.
Gary Arndt:So why don't, why don't you describe, how would you describe Whitehorse?
Bobby Fleshman:Well, you wanna tell just a two minute recap of the trip to Tadcaster?
Allison Fleshman:Yes.
Allison Fleshman:We went to Tadcaster England.
Allison Fleshman:We, um, Bobby was there for a. Uh oh.
Allison Fleshman:The mop meeting, the magneto mop spheres of the outer planets meeting in London.
Allison Fleshman:And we rent, yes,
Bobby Fleshman:there's a gold plated or brass plated op mop op.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:That we share.
Bobby Fleshman:That they pass around.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Um, anyway, so we drive up to Leeds, we grab a car and we move over to, uh, Tadcaster, teeny tiny town.
Allison Fleshman:We, salmon Smith Brewing Company is.
Allison Fleshman:We walk in and they're like, what are you doing here?
Allison Fleshman:And we're like, we're here for the tour.
Allison Fleshman:And they're like, we don't do that.
Allison Fleshman:Go to the pub.
Allison Fleshman:And so, so we just went and hung out at the pub the whole time.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and it was the Whitehorse and Angel.
Allison Fleshman:Pub and the public in there knew we were not from around there.
Allison Fleshman:And he basically schooled us on what casks really are and anything we ordered, he just shook his head no.
Allison Fleshman:And he was like, you'll have this instead in the most glorious English accent.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and we had the Tady porter was there.
Allison Fleshman:Um, which
Bobby Fleshman:was really one of my foundational beers.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh my.
Bobby Fleshman:It was like an
Allison Fleshman:elixir.
Allison Fleshman:It was amazing.
Allison Fleshman:Pretty much
Bobby Fleshman:anything that, that Sam Smith made then, or now,
Allison Fleshman:but the cask, it was a warm, English cozy pub.
Allison Fleshman:Um, the casks were just, I think there was five of them, or six.
Allison Fleshman:I can't remember.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but each one of 'em was just as glorious and smooth and creamy as possible.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:This is the, the location that had the Shire horses, you know, that that was, that's how they delivered beer.
Allison Fleshman:And they were like, right.
Allison Fleshman:The, the Shire horses were just right where we were sitting.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Um, not in the pub, but in the little courtyard area.
Bobby Fleshman:They were incognito, they were at a booth.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and so in this, um, we'll just jump to the label 'cause we're talking about it.
Allison Fleshman:Um.
Allison Fleshman:So we named the, the beer, the White Horse.
Allison Fleshman:And there she has a little sister.
Allison Fleshman:Um, the White Horse Porter has a lighter version, which is the British mild or the English mild.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and that one's named, uh, mild Angel after the pub, which was the white horse in Angel.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and then the logo on the beer is a picture of a white horse.
Allison Fleshman:Go figure.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but that is the, um, painting that's hanging in the White Horse.
Allison Fleshman:And Alex Schultz contacted the, uh, pub there and said, Hey, we're making a beer kind of in the honor of the White Horse and Angel, would you mind if we had the picture of that and put it on our logo?
Allison Fleshman:And they said, sure.
Allison Fleshman:And so that's what the White Horse is.
Allison Fleshman:That's actually the painting that's in the pub there.
Allison Fleshman:It's a
Bobby Fleshman:really great label.
Allison Fleshman:It's beautiful.
Bobby Fleshman:I mean, it's, it's the painting.
Bobby Fleshman:But yeah,
Gary Arndt:strangely enough.
Gary Arndt:A lot of your best labels are not necessarily your bestselling beers.
Gary Arndt:Yeah.
Gary Arndt:I think your worst label is 5 47.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, that's funny.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, that's interesting.
Bobby Fleshman:I think that was meant I'm here defending the artist or trying to tell.
Bobby Fleshman:It's meant to be kind of inspired by one of the, when you take a, you press these, these art.
Bobby Fleshman:Works on paper.
Bobby Fleshman:What are they, what's it called?
Bobby Fleshman:You know what I'm talking about?
Bobby Fleshman:Where you think wood blocks and you
Allison Fleshman:woodblock prints
Bobby Fleshman:maybe?
Bobby Fleshman:Sorry.
Bobby Fleshman:You mean
Allison Fleshman:like flower pressings?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Can you, what would you des would, how do you describe 5 47 label
Allison Fleshman:as a Fillmore poster?
Bobby Fleshman:Is it,
Allison Fleshman:yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Kind of
Gary Arndt:like, it could be more psychedelic if you wanted to go that route.
Gary Arndt:Yeah, that's what I think.
Gary Arndt:But I think your best, um, label for a can is Yorkshire Round.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, that's fun.
Allison Fleshman:I,
Gary Arndt:I think that's the best one by far.
Bobby Fleshman:That is your colleague, right?
Bobby Fleshman:That did the artwork on it?
Allison Fleshman:No, that's, uh, no, Tony Conrad did the, uh, Doba.
Allison Fleshman:Doba.
Allison Fleshman:Okay.
Allison Fleshman:Uh, no.
Allison Fleshman:Christian, um, oh God.
Allison Fleshman:Christian, I'm so sorry.
Allison Fleshman:I forgot your last name.
Allison Fleshman:Um, he does the, um, uh, FSM.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Uh, um, fuck.
Allison Fleshman:Social media, right?
Bobby Fleshman:That one.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Well, I'm trying to think of what it's called.
Allison Fleshman:Well, anyway, that there's a magazine amount.
Allison Fleshman:That label was very, very abstract.
Allison Fleshman:That's,
Bobby Fleshman:that's really cool that you noticed that.
Bobby Fleshman:Um,
Gary Arndt:what 5 47 reminds me of, if you've never seen the movie Fantasia 2000.
Gary Arndt:Oh my God, that's funny.
Gary Arndt:Which you should.
Gary Arndt:With Jade, uh, there's different segments and there's one where I think it's the, I think it's Stravinsky's.
Allison Fleshman:The Rite of Spring?
Allison Fleshman:No, it's the
Gary Arndt:fireworks.
Gary Arndt:It's the, it's the finale to, um, but anyways, there's a scene from that and there's like a wooden mph and that's what that
Allison Fleshman:is so
Gary Arndt:funny.
Gary Arndt:It reminds me of, well,
Allison Fleshman:that, that artist, um, Chad Brady.
Allison Fleshman:Uh, did so many murals and he did our, uh, David Bowie mural.
Allison Fleshman:He, there's actually Chad Brady Day in Appleton 'cause he is done so many murals.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and, uh, yeah, that's the, he's the one that did our 5 4 7 label.
Allison Fleshman:But anyway, white Horse back to that.
Allison Fleshman:Um, this is the
Gary Arndt:character from I
Allison Fleshman:now looking at a picture of a, oh, she looks like the She Hulk.
Allison Fleshman:That's cool.
Allison Fleshman:Firebird Suite by Stravinsky.
Allison Fleshman:2000. But
Gary Arndt:this is, this is the, the character in the animated thing.
Gary Arndt:Cool.
Gary Arndt:Which reminds me of the 5 47 logo.
Gary Arndt:I like that.
Gary Arndt:That's nice.
Gary Arndt:Anyways, there we go.
Allison Fleshman:But you don't like the 5, 4, 7 logo.
Gary Arndt:No, but I'm saying it reminds me of this not,
Allison Fleshman:ah, I see San
Gary Arndt:Francisco.
Allison Fleshman:That's fair.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:I don't give philmore strongly from it either.
Allison Fleshman:But What do you think of the White Horse since we're speaking about White Horse?
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, I mean, it's a white horse.
Bobby Fleshman:Well, it's hard to go from now.
Bobby Fleshman:I'm in the head space of 5
Gary Arndt:47.
Gary Arndt:Uh, I think the white horse label's a good one too.
Gary Arndt:Yeah, it's very classic.
Gary Arndt:It's,
Allison Fleshman:I also appreciate that it's the, the way that they would name pubs in England.
Allison Fleshman:It's the white horse.
Allison Fleshman:It, there's a pic, there's a big sign, and it's the white horse.
Allison Fleshman:It's a, it's usually
Bobby Fleshman:an adjective and an animal.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:The queen's arms, well, black crow the,
Bobby Fleshman:yeah,
Allison Fleshman:whatever.
Bobby Fleshman:I thought of another one the other day.
Bobby Fleshman:Anyway, so here we go.
Bobby Fleshman:Um.
Bobby Fleshman:Porters.
Bobby Fleshman:I was, as you guys were talking, I was thinking, how do we frame what a porter English porter really is?
Allison Fleshman:What's the difference?
Allison Fleshman:Because we just did the episode on public house pint.
Allison Fleshman:Our stout, what's the difference between a stout and a porter?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah, so that's, I was going there.
Bobby Fleshman:So I, I, I think that malt technology of the time really created porters and brewing technology at the time, because in England you didn't have a, you didn't have microbiology 400 years ago.
Bobby Fleshman:You didn't have.
Bobby Fleshman:A sense about, you know, what was contaminated because they, every beer goes sour after a given amount of time in, in England, 300 years ago, let's say.
Bobby Fleshman:'cause no one has a sense about sanitation like we do today.
Bobby Fleshman:So they drink it fast or.
Bobby Fleshman:They can blend it new stuff with old stuff, and if it's a little tart, it, it blends away.
Bobby Fleshman:And that's sort of where Porters, uh, became their own.
Bobby Fleshman:And the color and the flavor of a porter would've been, uh, darker because the technology of kiln, the malts would have imbued these, these darker colors and flavors.
Bobby Fleshman:Smoke.
Bobby Fleshman:Smoke was every beer back then because everything's direct kiln by wood fire.
Bobby Fleshman:Um.
Bobby Fleshman:So that's kind of like the beginning of Porter's.
Bobby Fleshman:And there was, there was uh, push through modernization to make malts lighter in color, less intense, more drinkable.
Bobby Fleshman:And that's where you get your pale malts and you get pale ls coming from England, your bitters and your IPAs.
Bobby Fleshman:And then on the other extreme, somebody in Ireland created this machine called.
Bobby Fleshman:Black patent and black patent, uh, or sorry, the black, it was a roaster that created the black patent malt from, and that's where your Irish Stout came from.
Bobby Fleshman:So I think in a lot of ways that your porter kind of stands in the middle of those two directions and, and then English porter, it.
Bobby Fleshman:It has this nice little coffee ness to it that comes from the roasting process.
Bobby Fleshman:It gives those malts the same flavors like it does with actual coffee.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, my favorite malt probably of all time is Thomas Faucet Pale Chocolate Malt.
Bobby Fleshman:I'll go back and grab a handful now and bring it out here maybe in a minute.
Bobby Fleshman:And you guys will taste something that's not accurate.
Bobby Fleshman:It's just delicious.
Bobby Fleshman:It's just, uh, if, if a sort of a baker's chocolate and a and a malt had a baby, this is what would come out.
Bobby Fleshman:It's so delicious.
Bobby Fleshman:Um.
Bobby Fleshman:It's in this beer.
Bobby Fleshman:It's one of the signature malts in this beer.
Bobby Fleshman:And, and then we also put a little sweetness in there from a English, what are called a crystal malt, which is different than like a caramel malt in the United States.
Bobby Fleshman:And if I haven't described this before, caramel malts are a technology by which you can actually hydrate the kernel, the barley kernel, um, while it's going through its germination process.
Bobby Fleshman:And, and you can heat it up such that it encases the water.
Bobby Fleshman:And you're, and think of it as a teeny tiny little mash tone.
Bobby Fleshman:And inside that kernel, it's converting those sugars, those starches into sugars, and then you ramp up the temperature quickly before it cools down.
Bobby Fleshman:You can actually crystallize those sugars into tiny little candies and you'll break your teeth if you try to chew these things, but you grind them up and you throw 'em into the mash and it dissolves back into the solution and it gives you this sweetness and this flavor you can't get in any other way.
Bobby Fleshman:And we've gone on that.
Bobby Fleshman:Even the Czechs and the Germans have have simulated in the United and.
Bobby Fleshman:Here in the United States we've done the same, but the English have really done a great job with these.
Bobby Fleshman:So all that's kind of thrown in.
Bobby Fleshman:I look at the recipe of this thing and I'm like, God, did a home brewer come up with that?
Allison Fleshman:Yes,
Bobby Fleshman:and he did.
Bobby Fleshman:And it's, it's stupid.
Bobby Fleshman:There's so many malts in this particular recipe and I don't know which one I should mess with, if any.
Bobby Fleshman:So I don't really touch it.
Bobby Fleshman:It's got an annoying amount of hops and.
Bobby Fleshman:Or sorry, malts.
Bobby Fleshman:And, and to stage it up is, is just nerve wracking.
Bobby Fleshman:'cause you can, you can mess it up if you're not paying attention.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, I put two different flavors of chocolate malt in here.
Bobby Fleshman:Um, two different caramel malts.
Bobby Fleshman:I put some wheat malt in here.
Bobby Fleshman:What's that?
Allison Fleshman:I'm just shaking my head no, because now I'm got Gary sitting next to me and I'm thinking about running a business and I'm like, wait a minute, is this smart for us to do all this fancy stuff?
Bobby Fleshman:I know.
Bobby Fleshman:And then, and then, you know, I'm blaring at you right now.
Bobby Fleshman:And, and then, and then one of the most It is if you let people know you are doing it.
Bobby Fleshman:Hey, we're doing all this craziness for White Horse.
Bobby Fleshman:We're crazy stuff.
Bobby Fleshman:And then Brown Malt.
Bobby Fleshman:Brown Malt is another signature read, which is why we are doing these episodes.
Bobby Fleshman:Yes, that's so
Allison Fleshman:fair.
Bobby Fleshman:Brown Malt is a signature malt in this too.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, it, it, it linger, it, it borders on, I don't wanna say accurate, but it, but it definitely, it tends in that direction and you're, you're.
Bobby Fleshman:Trying to tease out some chocolate notes, some, some baker's chocolate, some coffee.
Bobby Fleshman:None of this is supposed to be sweet, although it definitely has a pleasant sweetness to it that blends right into those other flavors.
Bobby Fleshman:And then the base malt is a Golden Promise by Thomas Faucet, which is a very sweet, uh, it's Scottish, uh, malt malt company.
Bobby Fleshman:Fun fact.
Bobby Fleshman:Do you know
Gary Arndt:where Porter got its name?
Allison Fleshman:Ooh.
Allison Fleshman:Where?
Bobby Fleshman:I do know, but I wanna hear your answer.
Bobby Fleshman:'cause May, it was popular with Porters.
Allison Fleshman:The people that carried luggage.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah, that's fair.
Bobby Fleshman:And it, was it popular?
Bobby Fleshman:Did they serve it on the, did did they also serve as bartend?
Bobby Fleshman:Bartend was on the train?
Allison Fleshman:No, it was a, um, it was the waste product for the train.
Allison Fleshman:It was, well, that's what I was saying earlier.
Allison Fleshman:So you have the
Bobby Fleshman:sourness of these older beers.
Bobby Fleshman:You blend with new ones.
Bobby Fleshman:Um, you create, they call three, there were three threads and you could blend like new, medium and old together to get the right darkness and sweetness.
Gary Arndt:This came out before trains, so couldn't have been porters for trains.
Gary Arndt:It had to have been Oh, yeah, yeah.
Gary Arndt:Okay.
Gary Arndt:Either people doing it for coaches or Yeah, for ships or something like that.
Gary Arndt:That's cool.
Gary Arndt:Um, but,
Bobby Fleshman:and that's where it came from.
Bobby Fleshman:So it's a very democratic beer at, I would think at the end of the day.
Bobby Fleshman:Did you
Allison Fleshman:put Whitehorse, did the open fermentor?
Bobby Fleshman:Oh, all of our English beers go.
Bobby Fleshman:I should, I was gonna say that.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:So the open fermentation tank we've talked about maybe, uh, many times we've, we've converted it to simulate how beers were fermented in England back in the day and today.
Bobby Fleshman:And that is to reduce stress on the yeast and to promote these, these lightly fruity notes.
Bobby Fleshman:Um.
Bobby Fleshman:Our yeast.
Bobby Fleshman:I talked about Augustine.
Bobby Fleshman:For our laggers, for our English ales, it's all about Timothy Taylor.
Bobby Fleshman:Timothy Taylor is related to the Green King and the Sam Smith Brewing Companies, and I think it makes if, as far as Swiss Army knives go, it's, it's a, whatever it, it's the broadest, it has the utility in so many different ways with the English beers.
Bobby Fleshman:So we do the, the Timothy Taylor on all these.
Bobby Fleshman:I Water.
Bobby Fleshman:Water?
Bobby Fleshman:Ooh,
Allison Fleshman:that's a good question.
Bobby Fleshman:Well, fortunately you, you do pretty well with when you have dark beers at driving that pH down, which is another important factor in brewing.
Bobby Fleshman:And, uh, I didn't mention that previously when we were talking about the, our pilsner.
Bobby Fleshman:It's very light.
Bobby Fleshman:Well, you need a little assistance bringing that down.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, if you're, if you're doing a light beer, you're gonna want to bring in.
Bobby Fleshman:Either some calcium or magnesium, which will drive your pH down, but you're not one, you don't wanna do that when you're making a pilsner.
Bobby Fleshman:One way you'll do that with a pilsner is you can use a German acidified malt, and then you ask yourself, well, how in the hell do the Germans do that with the rein heitz boat?
Bobby Fleshman:Well, guess what?
Bobby Fleshman:You can add water to malt and let the bacteria that sit on that malt acidify it over a given amount of time, and then you can dry that and use that as an ingredient to drop the pH.
Bobby Fleshman:I'm
Allison Fleshman:raising my hand 'cause I have a question.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:What's the a BV of our hilde?
Bobby Fleshman:Um, we try to keep that one below five.
Bobby Fleshman:That's traditional.
Allison Fleshman:So it's like four point,
Bobby Fleshman:I think it's 4 7 4
Allison Fleshman:8, 4 point.
Bobby Fleshman:And that's, that's a function of the, the, the residual sugar.
Bobby Fleshman:The final.
Bobby Fleshman:That's amazing.
Bobby Fleshman:' Allison Fleshman: cause isn't the White horse 4.4.
Bobby Fleshman:Or 4.5 I think it is.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:That's amazing because one of the things that, I'm just changing the subject, not that I don't love your deep dive into all the fancy things.
Allison Fleshman:Malt.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Peach.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but I stopped paying attention as I was looking at my phone.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but a lot of folks will tell us that, um, I don't like heavy beers or dark beers because they're just too high enough alcohol.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, I don don't take their sip with their eyes first.
Allison Fleshman:Sip with their eyes.
Allison Fleshman:It's, yeah.
Allison Fleshman:And the hilde, um.
Allison Fleshman:And that we just did an episode on is very crisp and light.
Allison Fleshman:She dances on the tongue water and she's considered
Bobby Fleshman:light in the spectrum of beers, right?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah, but
Allison Fleshman:she's higher alcohol.
Allison Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Allison Fleshman:Than our heavy porter, which is not at all heavy.
Allison Fleshman:It's very creamy, but it's also 4.6.
Allison Fleshman:Another fun fact,
Gary Arndt:when they first started using, uh, hydrometers in the late 18th century, guess what the A VV was of porters at the time in London.
Bobby Fleshman:I'm gonna guess three and a half because I don't think they fermented well.
Bobby Fleshman:6.60, okay.
Gary Arndt:Yeah, so that was one of the, actually the first measurements they made was on that and it went down, I guess, in the Napoleonic era.
Bobby Fleshman:Okay.
Bobby Fleshman:That's cool.
Allison Fleshman:Oh yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Gotta ration it out.
Allison Fleshman:Oh yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:I'm, now, I'm thinking about an old World Porter recipe, how you get to six, because they didn't ferment very well.
Bobby Fleshman:Wait a minute.
Bobby Fleshman:Wasn't really high.
Bobby Fleshman:Wasn't
Allison Fleshman:the second chance Porter.
Bobby Fleshman:Second chance is.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, she's related to this beer.
Bobby Fleshman:Is she?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Okay,
Allison Fleshman:so you're good guy.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, no, no, no.
Allison Fleshman:Second
Bobby Fleshman:chance is a, is a would be bourbon age.
Bobby Fleshman:We've never done it.
Allison Fleshman:Robust Porter.
Bobby Fleshman:I want to do this Double Mash and then Age It and Bourbon Barrel.
Bobby Fleshman:We're
Allison Fleshman:talk.
Allison Fleshman:We need to tell our listeners what we're talking about.
Allison Fleshman:You
Bobby Fleshman:should you back up 20 steps.
Bobby Fleshman:Yes.
Allison Fleshman:So the second chance Porter, what was the style?
Allison Fleshman:Was it a robust porter?
Bobby Fleshman:I never made Second chance.
Bobby Fleshman:So it would've been not
Allison Fleshman:here in,
Bobby Fleshman:I never like, or four times.
Bobby Fleshman:It was never made at at all.
Bobby Fleshman:In, in the real world.
Allison Fleshman:It was, we won nationals with it.
Bobby Fleshman:Was that with Second Chance?
Bobby Fleshman:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:Hang
Allison Fleshman:on.
Allison Fleshman:I don't remember.
Allison Fleshman:Hang on.
Allison Fleshman:We're having a marriage conversation right now.
Bobby Fleshman:No, that was a would be, you have
Gary Arndt:so many Goddamn awards, you don't even know what you
Allison Fleshman:win.
Allison Fleshman:Oh my God.
Allison Fleshman:We won Silver in the National mca, the Home Brewer something, something Master competition
Bobby Fleshman:and something, yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:And the fun thing is like the medal is legit.
Allison Fleshman:Big.
Allison Fleshman:It's like, oh yeah,
Bobby Fleshman:it's, it's bigger than anything we've got.
Bobby Fleshman:It's just across
Allison Fleshman:and it's thick and it's like silver.
Allison Fleshman:I also
Bobby Fleshman:got that giant stein for that cider from, I won all of Texas
Allison Fleshman:that's in the, that's downstairs in the tap room when he won the best cider in all of Texas.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but no, the, the silver medal was um, that was our first surprised.
Allison Fleshman:It was like a spur or something.
Allison Fleshman:National win.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Um, God, that must have been 2010 time ago, maybe 2009.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but that was Second Chance Porter, which was a, I wanna say it was a robust porter, but it was like it was
Bobby Fleshman:an American porter.
Bobby Fleshman:Okay.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:And it's coming back to me now.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:So that's a hoppy.
Allison Fleshman:But this is one caramel where I told Bobby, he was like, what kind of beer do you want me to brew?
Allison Fleshman:And I was like, I want you to brew a beer that has, like when you take a bite of vanilla ice cream.
Allison Fleshman:And, but it's got drizzled hot chocolate on or hot syrup, chocolate syrup on top of it.
Allison Fleshman:You smell the chocolate, but then you take the bite with the spoon and you get the cold feeling on your tongue.
Allison Fleshman:That's the vanilla.
Allison Fleshman:I want that contrast if I'm smelling the chocolate, but tasting the vanilla simultaneously and he made this beer.
Allison Fleshman:Oh, so good.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and we need a second chance after your dog.
Allison Fleshman:We'll dig
Bobby Fleshman:that one up.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:That recipe's buried somewhere.
Bobby Fleshman:I forgot about that.
Bobby Fleshman:Anyway.
Allison Fleshman:In any
Bobby Fleshman:case, we talked about double, double strength on this beer and aging it in Bourbon Barrel, but that
Allison Fleshman:thing was like eight or 9%.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Bobby Fleshman:Also, by the way, oh, great segue.
Bobby Fleshman:We'll get back to the water question, but Whitehorse, we just put Whitehorse last year, maybe beginning of this year, we put it into uh, a cask with all 5 47 hops.
Bobby Fleshman:We were just fucking around and what came out was kind of mind blowing unanimously.
Bobby Fleshman:People were, were telling us this, this is the best black IPA, 'cause we were kind of like flying it under that name that you could ever have made.
Bobby Fleshman:'cause a black IPA is gonna look dark, it won't be.
Bobby Fleshman:Like Stout Roasty, and it should have these great, what we call Cascadian notes, these West coast, uh, hop notes.
Bobby Fleshman:And man, was it so good that we are releasing the other one or another one next week.
Bobby Fleshman:So we're gonna keep going.
Bobby Fleshman:Wait, what are we doing?
Bobby Fleshman:The, the West Coast, we're calling it hoppy horse.
Bobby Fleshman:We'll have to work on that name, but it's, I gave so many notes.
Allison Fleshman:Well these are, they don't go anywhere 'cause we suck at marketing.
Allison Fleshman:But, well,
Bobby Fleshman:well you, what is
Gary Arndt:the name of
Bobby Fleshman:this beer?
Bobby Fleshman:We don't have a good name yet, so.
Bobby Fleshman:Well, and we're Hoppy Horse is where we're, yeah.
Allison Fleshman:Well, and this is, uh, I was gonna say, we um, we have fun with the White Horse is such a good base beer to add stuff to
Bobby Fleshman:like pumpkin a
Allison Fleshman:Yes.
Allison Fleshman:So the white horse mixed with our autumn spice.
Allison Fleshman:Um, or, or, or our pumpkin nail or the, or the actual pumpkin nail, which we haven't done a pumpkin nail in a very long time because we keep doing autumn spice.
Allison Fleshman:Um, we call it the iBod crane.
Allison Fleshman:Um, just
Bobby Fleshman:iBod
Allison Fleshman:or just iBod.
Allison Fleshman:Um.
Allison Fleshman:And it's a good mix.
Allison Fleshman:It's half and half.
Bobby Fleshman:Mm-hmm.
Allison Fleshman:But then
Bobby Fleshman:little whipped cream on top, very Rhine Heights could whip brew.
Bobby Fleshman:So the beer that
Gary Arndt:you're coming out with is a,
Bobby Fleshman:it's a West coast, you call it.
Bobby Fleshman:You really could call it a black IPA.
Bobby Fleshman:Everyone would.
Bobby Fleshman:But it's,
Gary Arndt:is it a porter just aged in an IPA barrel?
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah, it's, it's, it's a porter aged on the same hops that we would age 5 47 in.
Bobby Fleshman:No, with the hops.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Blew our minds.
Bobby Fleshman:Could you just
Allison Fleshman:say dry hopped porter?
Bobby Fleshman:That's what it is.
Bobby Fleshman:It's a dry hop porter, but that's kind of pedestrian.
Bobby Fleshman:So, and at the end of the day, we didn't think we were gonna call it a black ip, but that's what we had in our glass.
Allison Fleshman:So this is called hoppy horse.
Allison Fleshman:It was
Bobby Fleshman:that good
Allison Fleshman:because mint chocolate pony.
Allison Fleshman:Is delicious.
Allison Fleshman:And this is when we add chocolate mint oht chocolate girl
Bobby Fleshman:scout cookie one.
Bobby Fleshman:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:Yes.
Bobby Fleshman:We add the
Allison Fleshman:thin mint, well, not thin mints, but we add, we
Bobby Fleshman:simulate that.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:We simulate
Allison Fleshman:mint and chocolate in the white horse.
Allison Fleshman:That's a good one.
Allison Fleshman:Chocolate.
Allison Fleshman:We, we won a beer
Bobby Fleshman:competition with that one once.
Bobby Fleshman:Did we?
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, one of the fan favorites at, in Green Bay.
Bobby Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:Anyway, water.
Bobby Fleshman:I had not forgotten that.
Bobby Fleshman:So.
Bobby Fleshman:That's how we do the pilsner.
Bobby Fleshman:We, we put acid malt in that's produced in the German way.
Bobby Fleshman:This one doesn't need that because there's an liquidity.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, there's a, there's a certain pH dropping potential with these dark malts that we use in this.
Bobby Fleshman:Otherwise, you're just looking for a balance of sulfates and chlorides.
Bobby Fleshman:So you can't just drop calcium into your beer.
Bobby Fleshman:You have to attach it to, by way of, Allison knows better than anyone their an ion, uh, whether that be chloride or sulfate.
Bobby Fleshman:And I'm not listening to you.
Bobby Fleshman:I'm sorry.
Bobby Fleshman:What?
Bobby Fleshman:Anyway, so, and each of those are flavor.
Bobby Fleshman:They, the fl they, they, they, they tilt the flavor.
Bobby Fleshman:So we drop a little bit of, of calcium chloride and calcium sulfate into this beer to get our calcium levels up, but we put 'em in an even quantity so that we don't tilt the flavor.
Allison Fleshman:You know what's funny is I'm a chemist and I can speak chemistry, but I don't never understand what Bobby's telling me about.
Allison Fleshman:Different salts that he's adding to do different flavor things.
Allison Fleshman:That's, that's a, that's on you.
Allison Fleshman:I,
Bobby Fleshman:yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:I
Allison Fleshman:don't get it.
Allison Fleshman:Well, the, I'm sorry.
Bobby Fleshman:High level is, uh, chloride gives you more mal impression and sulfate gives you more hoppy impression.
Allison Fleshman:That's fair.
Allison Fleshman:So in a
Bobby Fleshman:beer like this, I don't want to go extreme either one way or the other.
Bobby Fleshman:This is not like a Bach where it's a malt bomb and it's not like an IP where it's a hot bomb.
Bobby Fleshman:So that's really Gary, to your question about hop or, or, uh, water treatment, we're gonna drop both of those in at varying levels.
Bobby Fleshman:Alright, EV even levels.
Gary Arndt:So we talked about water, we talked about the malts, where you're getting 'em from.
Gary Arndt:Talked about how you picked the name of the beer.
Bobby Fleshman:Um, talk about how we used too many malts because a home brewer designed it and it's, it's a pain in the ass to brew day job.
Allison Fleshman:I think one of the important things to talk about though, with the white horse, um.
Allison Fleshman:Is, and Gary, you said this at the beginning about how it's one of the most prominent cask ails that we do, um, and the Cask Ale is.
Allison Fleshman:I mean, one, it's a spectacle to see it poured.
Allison Fleshman:Um,
Bobby Fleshman:Jeremy just got married this year.
Bobby Fleshman:Jeremy Deville.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:And we brought one across the alley to his ceremony Uhhuh.
Bobby Fleshman:And he tapped it himself?
Allison Fleshman:He did,
Bobby Fleshman:yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:It's a big deal.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and I think that there's, there's a ceremonial part of the cask ails, um, that have the.
Allison Fleshman:Um, kind of cascade and the, the, the beautiful bubbles and the creaminess and all that.
Allison Fleshman:Um, but nitro beers, so Nitrogenated beers are really trying to simulate the cask.
Allison Fleshman:Um, and I think the porter is this really great historical example of what beers tasted like, you know, 200 years ago.
Allison Fleshman:Um, they really, yeah, like I was saying,
Bobby Fleshman:I think they went lighter and darker from it.
Allison Fleshman:Yeah.
Allison Fleshman:They really celebrate like what a beer should feel like when you're drinking one.
Bobby Fleshman:And it makes you, it screams that we should be making a smoked porter because I think that's what they would've tasted like
Allison Fleshman:amazingly enough.
Allison Fleshman:I'm so against this idea.
Allison Fleshman:I don't like smoked beers.
Allison Fleshman:No, I
Bobby Fleshman:think we definitely need to, to do this.
Bobby Fleshman:I've been asked to make smoked beers by that certain contingent.
Bobby Fleshman:That community, we've done it a few times and they disappear really quick.
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, smoked beers have a lane, and boy, that's a vocal minority.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh.
Bobby Fleshman:Gary's control.
Bobby Fleshman:How,
Gary Arndt:what makes a smoke?
Gary Arndt:Beer?
Gary Arndt:A smoke beer.
Bobby Fleshman:The the malt is, has been, uh, smoked.
Bobby Fleshman:I mean, so you, you, you either indirectly or, but usually in modern times it's gonna be indirect.
Bobby Fleshman:And those times it would've been more direct.
Bobby Fleshman:The advent of coke and.
Bobby Fleshman:Not the drug, but the advent of Coke, the eating source and uh, indirect heating has changed malting and flavor profile beer forever.
Allison Fleshman:This is like our, um, conversation with the, um, oh goodness, what was his name?
Allison Fleshman:I'm looking to David, the historian,
Gary Arndt:uh,
Allison Fleshman:on
Gary Arndt:hows Yes.
Gary Arndt:Scotland doctor.
Gary Arndt:Um, we're playing charades.
Gary Arndt:Lewis Howes.
Gary Arndt:Yes, I think, yes.
Gary Arndt:No, it's not Anton.
Gary Arndt:Anton.
Gary Arndt:Oh yeah.
Gary Arndt:Yes.
Gary Arndt:I follow him on Twitter.
Allison Fleshman:Anyway.
Gary Arndt:Alright, I think we've kind of,
Bobby Fleshman:uh, any, any last words on the White Horse?
Bobby Fleshman:Only that it's inspiring us to get a tiny horse, which I have a lead on.
Bobby Fleshman:I want to have our own little horse.
Bobby Fleshman:We're horse.
Bobby Fleshman:We're gonna deliver beer on College Avenue.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh my God.
Bobby Fleshman:Oh yeah.
Bobby Fleshman:No.
Bobby Fleshman:Our farmer has a horse that sits idle six days a week.
Bobby Fleshman:It also could be a unicorn for birthday parties.
Bobby Fleshman:Stop it.
Bobby Fleshman:That's an add-on.
Bobby Fleshman:This is not
Allison Fleshman:okay.
Bobby Fleshman:Is it white?
Bobby Fleshman:Uh, it is.
Bobby Fleshman:Actually, now that you mention it,
Allison Fleshman:although I would really like to have a brown Horse,
Gary Arndt:wizard of Oz for this other beer that you don't have a name for, horse of a different color.
Gary Arndt:There it
Bobby Fleshman:is.
Bobby Fleshman:There it is.
Allison Fleshman:No hoppy horse.
Allison Fleshman:Just call it what it is.
Bobby Fleshman:This is where we are terrible at it.
Bobby Fleshman:We make the product, we kick it out the door, and we hope for the best.
Gary Arndt:Alright, that's gonna conclude this episode of Respecting the Beer.
Gary Arndt:The producer of Respecting the Beer is David Kalsow and without David, this show would not exist.
Gary Arndt:Please join the Facebook group to get updates between the episodes and join the Patreon page where you can get all sorts of things, like all the bits that are cut out of the regular episodes and access to special beers.
Gary Arndt:Links to both of these are in the show notes.
Gary Arndt:And until next time, please remember to respect the beer.