Why Nat King Cole and Donny Hathaway Dominate Christmas Playlists
Episode 16924th December 2024 • Queue Points • Queue Points LLC
00:00:00 00:22:22

Share Episode

Transcripts

Speaker:

DJ Sir Daniel: and welcome back to another episode of Queue Points podcast.

Speaker:

I am DJ Sir Daniel.

Jay Ray:

And my name is Jay Ray, sometimes known by my government

Jay Ray:

as Johnnie Ray Kornegay the third and Sir Daniel time flies.

Jay Ray:

We are back in the holiday season, the holiday spirit, sir.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Absolutely.

Jay Ray:

It's that time of year.

Jay Ray:

Go ahead and double fist that hot cup of cocoa that you have right now.

Jay Ray:

And just cozy on up to another episode of Queue Points podcast because Jay

Jay Ray:

Ray after years, and I do mean years, like especially for me after years of

Jay Ray:

experiencing the holidays and You know, all the stuff that comes along with it.

Jay Ray:

Does Christmas music still give you, you know, the warm fuzzies?

Jay Ray:

And does it, you know, make you feel holly and jolly still?

Jay Ray:

Cause I'm trying to think, does that still do it for me?

Jay Ray:

How about you?

Jay Ray:

So the short answer to your question is yes, but I feel like I

Jay Ray:

need to explain for because I was too cool for school for like a long

Jay Ray:

time, I would say things like, I'm not really into holiday music, right?

Jay Ray:

That was a lie.

Jay Ray:

think what think what soured me to holiday music is as a person who

Jay Ray:

worked in retail for many, many, many, many, many, many, many, many years.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Talk about it.

Jay Ray:

In November, actually it was, so back then it was like November,

Jay Ray:

like you could time it, one, all of a sudden the dang Beatles started playing

Jay Ray:

and would hear holiday music all day.

Jay Ray:

ad nauseum an entire month, uh, the entire two months.

Jay Ray:

So it was like November to December.

Jay Ray:

so I think I internalized that experience with, I don't like holiday music.

Jay Ray:

I do like holiday music and it does still give me the warm and fuzzies.

Jay Ray:

But I think what's interesting about it, Sir Daniel is I

Jay Ray:

still like the classics, man.

Jay Ray:

The classics still do it for me.

Jay Ray:

I can listen to them classics every day, all the time.

Jay Ray:

Don't matter.

Jay Ray:

Yes.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: had a chokehold specifically on the black community

Jay Ray:

since they dropped, um, last century, cause it's been, it's been a whole

Jay Ray:

nother century since these songs dropped, but they've been recycled.

Jay Ray:

They've been covered.

Jay Ray:

They've been, you know, fizzed up for new generations.

Jay Ray:

The originals still hold, hold a magic over us the years.

Jay Ray:

And I'm talking about, of course, the Christmas song by Nat King Cole and

Jay Ray:

this Christmas by Donnie Hathaway.

Jay Ray:

And Jay Ray, since, uh, well, what is that hold that it has

Jay Ray:

over us in the black community?

Jay Ray:

Those two songs in particular, I have my, I have some theories around it, but

Jay Ray:

you know, and you know me, I'm a, I guess I'm a theorist over here on Queue Points,

Jay Ray:

but I want to hear, you know, your take on why these two songs in particular

Jay Ray:

kind of have a choke hold on us.

Jay Ray:

Hmm.

Jay Ray:

That is a really interesting question.

Jay Ray:

So what's interesting about the Christmas song?

Jay Ray:

First and foremost, it was written by Robert Wells and Mel Tormé.

Jay Ray:

Um, but of course, made famous by Nat King Cole.

Jay Ray:

Um, and I think that song has a chokehold on our community because one, it was,

Jay Ray:

um, It was a song by a black artist released at a time when black artists

Jay Ray:

didn't have like the cachet and like the general pop community at the time.

Jay Ray:

So, Nat King Cole, I think, represented the possibility

Jay Ray:

of the American dream, right?

Jay Ray:

And so black people were like, this.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: give me that.

Jay Ray:

Yeah.

Jay Ray:

Give me more of that, please.

Jay Ray:

And also, it's well sung, and it's a beautiful song.

Jay Ray:

And they did their big one on that.

Jay Ray:

So that's, for the Christmas song, I think it's that.

Jay Ray:

For this Christmas, I think this Christmas is just like a

Jay Ray:

quintessentially black Christmas song.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

And I think that's why it has a chokehold on the black community.

Jay Ray:

And it's also a groove.

Jay Ray:

I mean, who can't did it, it did it, did it, did it.

Jay Ray:

It's got all the stuff that black folks want in that song.

Jay Ray:

Yeah.

Jay Ray:

I think that's why those two songs have a chokehold.

Jay Ray:

What are you, what is your theory?

Jay Ray:

What is your

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: So I'm gonna hold my theory just a little bit because You um,

Jay Ray:

you brought up a couple things regarding both songs, but preparing for this

Jay Ray:

episode, Jay Ray, you and I discovered some things regarding these records

Jay Ray:

that I don't think a lot of people know.

Jay Ray:

And that's what key points is here for.

Jay Ray:

Um, both songs are synonymous with the holidays, but we discovered that

Jay Ray:

they were not immediate hit records.

Jay Ray:

Not at all.

Jay Ray:

So a couple of quick history notes for the Christmas song.

Jay Ray:

So the Christmas song was, um, first recorded, which might surprise people.

Jay Ray:

It was first recorded in 1946 by the Nat King Cole Trio.

Jay Ray:

It was written in 45, recorded in 1946 by the Nat King Cole Trio.

Jay Ray:

And actually, the Christmas song has Four distinct recordings.

Jay Ray:

So the first recording happened at WMCA Studios in 1946, as we mentioned.

Jay Ray:

There was another recording at Studios in, um, so one was recorded in June,

Jay Ray:

one, one was recorded in August of 46.

Jay Ray:

The second recording there included the Nat King Cole trio and a choir.

Jay Ray:

they were like

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Yeah.

Jay Ray:

fourth, recording of the song, which was actually recorded in 1961.

Jay Ray:

In the studio at Capitol Studios.

Jay Ray:

And that is the one that we're most familiar with.

Jay Ray:

It's Nat King Cole.

Jay Ray:

It wasn't even the Nat King Cole trio then.

Jay Ray:

It was just Nat King Cole, the band, the, the, the orchestra, et cetera.

Jay Ray:

Interesting tidbit about the Christmas song is there actually are four

Jay Ray:

different recordings of that song that all kind of have their own feel.

Jay Ray:

We are the most familiar with the last, so that's that on that one.

Jay Ray:

This Christmas, of course, written by one Donnie Hathaway, who is credited

Jay Ray:

as Donnie Pitts, uh, for this song and co written by Nadine Teresa McKenner.

Jay Ray:

Now Nadine is really important to this song because the

Jay Ray:

song really starts with her.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Right.

Jay Ray:

She's working in, um, as the story goes, she

Jay Ray:

was working in the post office

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

Nat King Cole in her head.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: So through line.

Jay Ray:

Yes.

Jay Ray:

through line.

Jay Ray:

So she's in there thinking about Nat King Cole and she's humming along this

Jay Ray:

Christmas, da, da, da, Nat King Cole.

Jay Ray:

We're doing a whole thing, trying to get herself through the day.

Jay Ray:

And here comes the opportunity.

Jay Ray:

And that's 1967, by the

Jay Ray:

they wrote the song initially,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: I think that's very important.

Jay Ray:

That is really important, right?

Jay Ray:

So this is, what, six years after the most famous version of Nat King Cole's song.

Jay Ray:

So that's still a contemporary song by the time they record this Christmas.

Jay Ray:

Donny Hathaway's, uh, uh, to this song is that Donny Hathaway

Jay Ray:

wanted a quintessentially black Christmas song, right?

Jay Ray:

And, um, by 1970, they record this song And Sir Daniel, we learned this.

Jay Ray:

We were both surprised by this.

Jay Ray:

this Christmas was not a hit when it dropped.

Jay Ray:

Like, this

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: paid it

Jay Ray:

y'all paid this Christmas dust.

Jay Ray:

This Christmas did not become a hit song until after Mr.

Jay Ray:

Hathaway's death.

Jay Ray:

This Christmas was just like, It languished for

Jay Ray:

years before becoming a hit.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: And the thing about that with very popular songs, um, that

Jay Ray:

sometimes really great songs essence, sometimes they don't automatically

Jay Ray:

become a commercial success.

Jay Ray:

Mm

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: They're like crock pots.

Jay Ray:

And I think a lot of producers and musicians back then wrote songs

Jay Ray:

Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: for the crock pot generation.

Jay Ray:

Meaning that they were, they were allowed, yeah, those songs were allowed to simmer,

Jay Ray:

to stew, to, to, to, to double up on the flavor and really get ingrained.

Jay Ray:

And then they have this longevity that goes on for years, so much so

Jay Ray:

that in doing research for this, um, topic, I discovered that there

Jay Ray:

are like 80 covers and counting.

Jay Ray:

Of the Donny Hathaway classic this Christmas, 80 covers and counting.

Jay Ray:

Cause I'm sure I'm certain when y'all is out there cooking up a remix right

Jay Ray:

now that we may not need, but go ahead, do your thing, do your big one.

Jay Ray:

it in the mix.

Jay Ray:

You see what happens.

Jay Ray:

Maybe it'll become a hit for you.

Jay Ray:

But yes, there's like 80 plus covers of this Christmas.

Jay Ray:

There are approximately 1, 709 covers of the Nat King Cole

Jay Ray:

classic, the Christmas song.

Jay Ray:

That's

Jay Ray:

makes

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: industry is all about collecting dollars.

Jay Ray:

And sometimes if it ain't broke, fix it.

Jay Ray:

do, you know, don't recreate, you don't have to recreate the wheel, just do what

Jay Ray:

works and give the people what they want.

Jay Ray:

So we come to the end of, um, as we get ready to wrap up on this episode,

Jay Ray:

I kind of want to go back to what I was asking you in regards to why these

Jay Ray:

songs have such a chokehold on us, specifically in the black community.

Jay Ray:

you hit the nail on the head.

Jay Ray:

Silence.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: this Christmas reflect two distinct eras in black America's history.

Jay Ray:

Yes.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: of the things that affected black Americans deeply in the

Jay Ray:

Jim Crow era, the post civil war era, the, you know, right up until the civil

Jay Ray:

rights movement, there's this, like you said earlier, this need to feel Um,

Jay Ray:

like you're entitled to the American dream and whatever that looks like.

Jay Ray:

Well, back then it looked like class.

Jay Ray:

It looked like pearls.

Jay Ray:

It looked like, you know, a starched suit and, you know,

Jay Ray:

mom with her pin curls and 2.

Jay Ray:

5, 2.

Jay Ray:

5 kids and a dog.

Jay Ray:

All of those things that we were told is the American dream.

Jay Ray:

I don't know that this is something that they just kept telling

Jay Ray:

us while we were growing up.

Jay Ray:

what did that mean?

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Well, I think back then you were encouraged, like

Jay Ray:

it was, they were encouraged for population reasons to have 2.

Jay Ray:

5.

Jay Ray:

It's like two in a possible.

Jay Ray:

I don't know what that meant either.

Jay Ray:

And the dog, don't forget the dog.

Jay Ray:

You gotta have that.

Jay Ray:

the dog.

Jay Ray:

You have to have a dog.

Jay Ray:

Right.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: And so, so yes, that's why we get this picture of, and Nat

Jay Ray:

King Cole fit the bill, you know, he was a, a beautiful, Dark skinned black

Jay Ray:

man, but he had that clonk was on point.

Jay Ray:

It was slanted to the side and he had a part, you know, he was, you know, the

Jay Ray:

suit and tie just very classy set, you know, something that we as black Americans

Jay Ray:

could aspire to and white America felt comfortable around, which is really the

Jay Ray:

biggest deal is that they felt comfortable with that representation of black.

Jay Ray:

This and yeah, and so that's why they were, they were on fine with that.

Jay Ray:

And I think that's what propelled that song to heights.

Jay Ray:

then this Christmas was the opposite, but go ahead.

Jay Ray:

I see you

Jay Ray:

Yeah,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: to say something.

Jay Ray:

Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

Mm hmm.

Jay Ray:

Mm.

Jay Ray:

So I know that I've mentioned this in past holiday

Jay Ray:

episodes, but it bears repeating.

Jay Ray:

Um, for me, the Christmas song represents like the, the start of the

Jay Ray:

holidays because my father, he had that old tattered Nat King Cole album

Jay Ray:

with all the Christmas, like it would be like the cover was falling apart.

Jay Ray:

Cause he had had it since the night, this is 1961, right?

Jay Ray:

But he would pop that neck King Cole on as we were decorating the

Jay Ray:

tree or doing whatever we were doing around the house during the

Jay Ray:

holidays, especially if he was home.

Jay Ray:

Um, during that time, if he worked first shift during the holidays, we knew

Jay Ray:

that that evening dad was going to want to do lights and do the tree and that

Jay Ray:

King Cole was going to start playing.

Jay Ray:

Even though I couldn't smell it, right?

Jay Ray:

Even though I'm sorry, even though we didn't have it, I could smell

Jay Ray:

chestnuts roasting on an open fire.

Jay Ray:

I don't know what that smelled like, but I, I do know what it smelled like

Jay Ray:

because we was smelling it in my house.

Jay Ray:

It wasn't no chestnuts roasting on Wayne had no open flyers, no

Jay Ray:

open fires other than the stove.

Jay Ray:

It wasn't no chestnuts on there, but the feeling, right?

Jay Ray:

You smelled it.

Jay Ray:

You felt it.

Jay Ray:

My father never played.

Jay Ray:

I don't know that he even owned this Christmas.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: That's wild that you say that, because from what I understand,

Jay Ray:

a lot of, a lot of us don't include the Christmas song on their list of

Jay Ray:

like favorite Christmas Black Christmas holiday music, I think, and this is where

Jay Ray:

this Christmas comes in this Christmas is post civil rights era is very much

Jay Ray:

in the, you know, the Black Panther movement is going on and we're in this

Jay Ray:

era of I'm black and I'm proud and, you know, we're moving into the future.

Jay Ray:

We're moving in front into the seventies and, you know, Black

Jay Ray:

people are feeling empowered and a lot of those respectability

Jay Ray:

politics were out of the window.

Jay Ray:

And this Christmas, whereas the other song was patent leather shoes and pearls,

Jay Ray:

this Christmas is definitely an Afro pick and a leather jacket, you know,

Jay Ray:

and maybe a turtleneck because it's reflecting a reflection of the time.

Jay Ray:

And, you know, Donnie Hathaway, of course, that image of him

Jay Ray:

with the big Applejack hat.

Jay Ray:

Yes.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: dream is starting to feel like, wait a minute, is that real?

Jay Ray:

Or is it a fantasy?

Jay Ray:

You know, I'm, I'm here trying to pursue it, but I don't know if I'm

Jay Ray:

actually going to have it, but.

Jay Ray:

it comes to Christmastime, can create this moment of togetherness, of longing

Jay Ray:

togetherness, and longing for a feeling of warmth and soul through this song, and

Jay Ray:

we are forever grateful for Donnie and Mr.

Jay Ray:

McKinnon for putting pen to paper and creating this holiday classic for us.

Jay Ray:

Black America to enjoy,

Jay Ray:

Yeah.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: um, the diaspora, you know, like I said, you can't have a

Jay Ray:

song that's been covered over 80 times and not have different flavors of it.

Jay Ray:

Sir Daniel, I got a question then.

Jay Ray:

Let's, let's, let's, let's, let's, let's talk about it.

Jay Ray:

I'mma just share my, my perspective.

Jay Ray:

I actually think this Christmas is so good that people don't need to cover it.

Jay Ray:

I feel like this Christmas as I get why people cover the, the, the

Jay Ray:

Christmas song because it's a standard.

Jay Ray:

Like, it's a standard at

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: Yes.

Jay Ray:

In the culture, right?

Jay Ray:

It has an arrangement, you know, where the notes land, you

Jay Ray:

know, what the structure is.

Jay Ray:

Whereas this Christmas is a groove it could be a lot of things, but I think

Jay Ray:

the original is actually so perfect that we should just leave it there.

Jay Ray:

are your thoughts on people covering this Christmas?

Jay Ray:

Cause I don't like none of the covers.

Jay Ray:

I heard a cover of this Christmas that I like.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: You know,

Jay Ray:

I forget who said this, but it's like a running joke.

Jay Ray:

At least you tried.

Jay Ray:

It's very much.

Jay Ray:

At least you tried.

Jay Ray:

We get it.

Jay Ray:

Um,

Jay Ray:

that's the thing about covers and we're going to talk about covers

Jay Ray:

in the upcoming episodes soon.

Jay Ray:

So make sure you stay tuned to Queue Points and subscribe.

Jay Ray:

So when that episode drops, you'll get to chime in on that as well.

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: But

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: the feeling around covers is.

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: one of those things that nobody really asks

Jay Ray:

for, but I believe just artists

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: have this feeling in themselves, like

Jay Ray:

Uh, Uh, Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: that I need to take on.

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: somebody else's music.

Jay Ray:

Some might cover a classic

Jay Ray:

Uh,

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: and it's also, again, it also is business.

Jay Ray:

industry realizes.

Jay Ray:

that covers Christmas albums, generate, um, money every single year.

Jay Ray:

McThank you, Mariah Carey.

Jay Ray:

They, you know, we really,

Jay Ray:

out November 1st.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: you know, she started out already, so she's ready to go.

Jay Ray:

And so I think that's just something that the industry is crew

Jay Ray:

has created for another carrot.

Jay Ray:

For artists to, to chase after.

Jay Ray:

a lot of times they don't even really want to participate in it.

Jay Ray:

They just do it because it's something that they're told that

Jay Ray:

they have to do contractually.

Jay Ray:

So a lot of times this not even there, they're not even wanting to do it.

Jay Ray:

So, you know, I can take or leave a lot of covers.

Jay Ray:

It's very rare that somebody comes along and is like, Oh yeah, you know,

Jay Ray:

you put your foot in that and shout out to people like Brandy and Robert

Jay Ray:

Glasper and people like that, that have.

Jay Ray:

Put out new Christmas music with different spins on it.

Jay Ray:

And I don't know if it'll catch on to be a classic, like these two songs

Jay Ray:

that we've discussed, but the fact that they've attempted and that they are

Jay Ray:

inserting new, um, Christmas music in the American songbook is to be commended.

Jay Ray:

And we hope that new artists follow suit and give us some, you know, give us

Jay Ray:

something else, try and give us something that can become your own classic.

Jay Ray:

Yeah, absolutely.

Jay Ray:

Y'all, thank you so much for tuning in as we wax poetic about, uh, the

Jay Ray:

Christmas song and this Christmas.

Jay Ray:

you all so much.

Jay Ray:

If you can hear us, if you can see us, please subscribe.

Jay Ray:

Tell a friend about the show.

Jay Ray:

Friends, family, colleagues, if you enjoy Queue Points, chances are they

Jay Ray:

will enjoy Queue Points as well.

Jay Ray:

the question.

Jay Ray:

And Which song is your favorite?

Jay Ray:

Do you like the Christmas song?

Jay Ray:

Do you like this Christmas?

Jay Ray:

Is there another Christmas classic that you really enjoy?

Jay Ray:

Let us know.

Jay Ray:

You can always email us at info at Queue Points.

Jay Ray:

com.

Jay Ray:

Find us on social media at Definitely hop in our DMs and let us know.

Jay Ray:

We would love to share your favorite Christmas song.

Jay Ray:

it out.

Jay Ray:

If you want to support Queue Points, head on over to our website at Queue Points.

Jay Ray:

com.

Jay Ray:

You can do a lot of things over there.

Jay Ray:

You could subscribe to our newsletter.

Jay Ray:

You could get additional content over on our sub stack.

Jay Ray:

That's magazine.

Jay Ray:

Queue Points.

Jay Ray:

com.

Jay Ray:

While you're over there, you can also read, um, other stories and other content

Jay Ray:

that we have in the Queue Points universe.

Jay Ray:

And last but not least, you can go ahead and you can shop our store at store.

Jay Ray:

Queue Points.

Jay Ray:

com.

Jay Ray:

We'd really appreciate it.

Jay Ray:

Helps to keep the lights on in Queue Points land.

Jay Ray:

We love y'all.

Jay Ray:

We appreciate y'all.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: That's right.

Jay Ray:

And what do I say at the end of every episode in this life?

Jay Ray:

You have a choice.

Jay Ray:

You can either pick up the needle or you can let the record play.

Jay Ray:

My name is DJ Sir Daniel,

Jay Ray:

My name is Jay Ray, y'all.

Jay Ray:

DJ Sir Daniel: and this has been Queue Points podcast, dropping

Jay Ray:

the needle on black music history.

Jay Ray:

We'll see you on the next go round.

Jay Ray:

Peace.

Jay Ray:

Peace, y'all.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube