In this timely and careful episode of Closing Arguments, host and criminal defense attorney Jack Razumich confronts a major legal flashpoint: the fatal shooting of Renée Nicole Good by a federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent in Minneapolis and the broader questions it raises about self-defense, police authority, and the legal limits on force.
We begin by exploring a question that is at once simple and complex: Do police officers have the same self-defense rights as everyone else? What do prosecutorial processes look like in police-involved shootings, and what immunities and challenges come into play when a federal agent uses lethal force? Razumich breaks down the legal concepts and real procedural hurdles that define how these cases unfold — often far differently than public perception.
Next, we look directly at what we actually know about the Minneapolis incident — what’s confirmed, what remains unverified, and what Minnesota authorities are legally empowered to do. The fatal shot that killed Good occurred during a federal operation that has ignited protests and heightened scrutiny over law enforcement tactics, prompting calls for independent investigation even as federal agents assert a self-defense justification. We explore how these narratives intersect with legal standards and the realities of prosecuting a federal agent.
Finally, we ask the hard questions: Where do we go from here? What legal pathways exist for accountability and public trust when force is used? What lessons should lawyers and laypersons alike take from this case as it continues to unfold?
This episode offers a clear, grounded analysis of fear, force, and the law — without speculation, but with all the rigor and perspective you expect from Closing Arguments.
Chapters:
0:00 - Introduction
1:34 - Self-Defense rights among law enforcement
6:28 - Prosecuting during a police-involved shooting
13:17 - The immunities existing for law enforcement
19:04 - The shooting of Renee Good in Minneapolis
31:02 - What the State of Minnesota can actually do
45:22 - Where do we go from here?
54:10 - Parting thoughts from an attorney
57:45 - Closing remarks
