Artwork for podcast Retirement Equals Freedom
029: Your Annual IRA Contributions – When, Why & How Much!
Episode 294th January 2023 • Retirement Equals Freedom • Josh Bretl
00:00:00 00:31:24

Share Episode

Shownotes

We’re at the dawn of 2023 and Co-Hosts Josh Bretl and Dave Schmidt are here to help us all fill our buckets – financially and otherwise!

Join us for a special New Year Edition of the Retirement Equals Freedom Podcast focused on figuring out how traditional and Roth IRAs as well as 401k plans can work for you!

#TaxNerds: You’ll come away understanding the benefits, limitations and rules of the road on contributions just in time for tax season – with a little historical context about retirement investing and pensions thrown in for good measure!

Don’t miss breaking news about everything from big plans for entertaining in the Bretl’s new kitchen to Dave’s secret passion for the harmonica to some fun reading recs. Let’s make the year ahead a great one!

Check out this cool new pod link resource with all the latest and greatest about Retirement Equals Freedom and one-click access to your favorite platform for listening!

And don’t forget to join the conversation at our private Facebook group, which you’ll find here.

Click here to explore the services that FSR Wealth Strategies offers and schedule a discovery call with one of the team’s CPAs. When it comes to living your best life, it’s never too early to get started! 

Transcripts

Josh Bretl:

In the grand scheme of things, IRAs

Josh Bretl:

are relatively new.

Josh Bretl:

Your parents or grandparents never even knew what the

Josh Bretl:

heck they were, and they were totally reliant upon

Josh Bretl:

pension plans and company savings and things along those

Josh Bretl:

lines, and those went away.

Josh Bretl:

So they created these 401ks and these IRAs with the idea

Josh Bretl:

that they can travel with you, and the savings get

Josh Bretl:

built up time over time, and it can do a few things.

Josh Bretl:

One is it gives the employee more control, and two is it

Josh Bretl:

cuts cost for the employer.

Josh Bretl:

But also, they're portable, so you can take them with you.

Josh Bretl:

But we've never really talked about how we put

Josh Bretl:

money into those accounts, how we put money into IRAs.

Josh Bretl:

And should you, or should you not put money in?

Josh Bretl:

We wanted to do an episode on what we call IRA

Josh Bretl:

contributions and some of the nuances that go into it.

Dave Schmidt:

It's the dawn of 2023, and Josh and I are

Dave Schmidt:

hoping to fill your buckets both financially and otherwise.

Dave Schmidt:

Our special new year edition of the Retirement Equals

Dave Schmidt:

Freedom Podcast is focused on figuring out how traditional

Dave Schmidt:

and Roth IRAs, as well as your 401k plans, can work for you.

Alex:

Hashtag tax nerd.

Dave Schmidt:

You'll come away from this episode,

Dave Schmidt:

understanding the benefits, limitations, and rules of

Dave Schmidt:

the road on contributions just in time for tax season.

Dave Schmidt:

This is The Retirement Equals Freedom Podcast.

Dave Schmidt:

Your host, Josh Bretl, is the owner of FSR Wealth Strategies.

Dave Schmidt:

And for the last two decades, it's Josh that's been

Dave Schmidt:

helping fine folks like you thrive in your retirement.

Dave Schmidt:

Well me?

Dave Schmidt:

Hey, I'm Dave.

Dave Schmidt:

Josh's longtime friend, co-host, and fan of beef barley stew.

Dave Schmidt:

So now, let me let you let me end this introduction

Dave Schmidt:

so you can learn all about IRA contributions.

Dave Schmidt:

FSR Wealth Management is a registered investment advisor

Dave Schmidt:

located in Elmhurst, Illinois.

Dave Schmidt:

Information and opinions contained in this audio

Dave Schmidt:

have been arrived at by FSR Wealth advisors.

Dave Schmidt:

All information herein is for informational purposes

Dave Schmidt:

and should not be construed as investment advice.

Dave Schmidt:

It does not constitute an offer, a solicitation or recommendation

Dave Schmidt:

to purchase any security.

Dave Schmidt:

FSR is not providing legal, tax, accounting, or financial

Dave Schmidt:

planning advice in this audio.

Dave Schmidt:

These views are as of the date of this publication

Dave Schmidt:

and are subject to change.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, Canada.

Josh Bretl:

David, happy new year.

Dave Schmidt:

Happy new year.

Josh Bretl:

Oh.

Josh Bretl:

That just ruined everything.

Dave Schmidt:

Way to start it off, Josh.

Dave Schmidt:

We came in with the goal of being just super

Dave Schmidt:

professional and not knocking things around in the new

Dave Schmidt:

year, and what do you do?

Josh Bretl:

One of my favorite compliments that

Josh Bretl:

I get is that I'm not your average accountant or CPA.

Josh Bretl:

I'm not your average financial advisor.

Josh Bretl:

I take that as a compliment.

Josh Bretl:

And people used to say that to my dad.

Josh Bretl:

I remember hearing as a kid, " You're not what I think of

Josh Bretl:

when I think of an advisor or when I think of a CPA."

Josh Bretl:

And I always thought that was kind of weird, but

Josh Bretl:

now it makes me feel good.

Josh Bretl:

And I also feel like this podcast is another

Josh Bretl:

example of that.

Josh Bretl:

We do weird okay here.

Dave Schmidt:

You remember the story I told you when

Dave Schmidt:

I was working at the bank and the sweet old lady

Dave Schmidt:

called me out for having a beard or a scruffy face?

Josh Bretl:

Mm-hmm.

Dave Schmidt:

Bankers don't have scruffy faces.

Dave Schmidt:

"Well, ma'am, they do now."

Dave Schmidt:

Hey, look, you're human.

Dave Schmidt:

No one wants to work with someone that's

Dave Schmidt:

like, "I do taxes.

Dave Schmidt:

Ah, ah, ah."

Josh Bretl:

I agree with you.

Dave Schmidt:

Look, Josh, 2023, my new goal is to be

Dave Schmidt:

a, I don't know, a sparkling conversationalist, if you will.

Josh Bretl:

With who?

Dave Schmidt:

I don't know.

Dave Schmidt:

You, on a podcast.

Josh Bretl:

like that idea.

Dave Schmidt:

Thank you.

Josh Bretl:

We have all sorts of big dreams for the 2023 podcast.

Josh Bretl:

I don't know what we're going to execute on, because we're

Josh Bretl:

good dreamers, not always the best executors when it comes

Josh Bretl:

towards the podcast stuff.

Josh Bretl:

Maybe someday, we'll actually have a studio that...

Josh Bretl:

Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh.

Dave Schmidt:

Did it ship?

Josh Bretl:

I want to show you something.

Josh Bretl:

I haven't gotten a notification of shipping yet.

Dave Schmidt:

Aw.

Josh Bretl:

But you know how on Facebook, you can see things

Josh Bretl:

like follow them on Facebook?

Josh Bretl:

Dave.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

I think that might be us.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Dave Schmidt:

If that is, that's gorgeous.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Dave Schmidt:

What he's referring to is there is a video on Facebook

Dave Schmidt:

from the company Josh ordered this table from that has them

Dave Schmidt:

showing the table and then going from table to the truck

Dave Schmidt:

that's going to ship it here to us, so it's got to be ours.

Josh Bretl:

It's got to be ours.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Dave, I am really excited for 2023, and on many reasons.

Josh Bretl:

I've got on a personal front, on a business front.

Josh Bretl:

Hopefully by the time this podcast comes out,

Josh Bretl:

we will have finished our construction on our house.

Josh Bretl:

We'll have our house back to normal.

Josh Bretl:

We've gotten through Christmas.

Dave Schmidt:

Josh, I'm excited for your house.

Dave Schmidt:

You went home and saw your new countertops the other

Dave Schmidt:

day, and what was the first thing I asked you?

Dave Schmidt:

You remember?

Dave Schmidt:

What was I concerned about?

Josh Bretl:

So the first question you asked me probably

Josh Bretl:

had to do with something I was going to make you.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

I asked you, A) what's the first cocktail you're going to craft

Dave Schmidt:

for me on your new countertops?

Dave Schmidt:

And then, what are you going to cook me?

Josh Bretl:

I don't know, but Missy and I have decided when

Josh Bretl:

we're all done with this, 2023 is going to be the year

Josh Bretl:

of parties at our house, so-

Dave Schmidt:

Yes.

... Josh Bretl:

it's going to be fun.

Dave Schmidt:

Cocktails and steaks at Josh's house.

Josh Bretl:

I look forward to it.

Josh Bretl:

But on a business front, we've set some really cool things

Josh Bretl:

up, and we have some great listeners of the podcast.

Josh Bretl:

Our clients are doing great.

Josh Bretl:

Who knows what the economy's going to do this year?

Josh Bretl:

Don't ask me for a crystal ball.

Josh Bretl:

What I always say is be prepared for anything.

Josh Bretl:

2023's going to be a good year.

Dave Schmidt:

2023 is shaping up to be a good year.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Now, here's my big question.

Dave Schmidt:

What is it?

Josh Bretl:

Over Christmas, you and I talked about playing

Josh Bretl:

a new sport, pickle ball.

Josh Bretl:

Can you and I play pickle ball, learn how to play pickle ball?

Josh Bretl:

Because it's all the rage.

Josh Bretl:

And two, can we play basketball at least once this year?

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, I know.

Dave Schmidt:

The logistics of finding the spots to play

Dave Schmidt:

basketball, I think, are harder than pickle ball.

Dave Schmidt:

I feel like basketball, you can't just...

Dave Schmidt:

If you and I were to go to an open gym, we will

Dave Schmidt:

be dead within 30 seconds.

Dave Schmidt:

We have to find a place where you and I can just

Dave Schmidt:

kind of shoot around, get our legs out from underneath

Dave Schmidt:

us, and then start playing.

Josh Bretl:

All right.

Josh Bretl:

We'll talk about that.

Josh Bretl:

We'll get that squared away.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

But pickle ball, we've already talked about doing

Dave Schmidt:

a entire office pickle ball tournament, which I will record.

Dave Schmidt:

That would be fun to do a production around.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Well, so far, if anyone's listened this far in, you're

Josh Bretl:

bored off of your gourd, because we've talked about

Josh Bretl:

nothing for a few minutes, so-

Dave Schmidt:

Bored off of your gourd.

Dave Schmidt:

That might be a new hashtag.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm just sayin-

Josh Bretl:

Hashtag bored off your gourd.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm just saying.

Dave Schmidt:

You know what, Josh?

Dave Schmidt:

I was up late last night thinking, "What is something

Dave Schmidt:

that we just haven't done a deep dive on in a long time?"

Dave Schmidt:

And financial wizard, so I know all these things.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm like-

Josh Bretl:

Do not say Social Security.

Dave Schmidt:

No.

Dave Schmidt:

No.

Dave Schmidt:

We just finished a three part series, which we're actually

Dave Schmidt:

going to win some awards for.

Josh Bretl:

:

Especially part three.

Dave Schmidt:

Part three is amazing.

Dave Schmidt:

But what about IRAs and contributions and

Dave Schmidt:

things of that sort?

Josh Bretl:

Oh, great.

Josh Bretl:

I love talking about that stuff.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

No.

Josh Bretl:

Actually, this idea came from Erin, as do a lot

Josh Bretl:

of our ideas, apparently.

Josh Bretl:

We've done a couple episodes on conversions and Roths

Josh Bretl:

and the difference between traditionals and Roth IRAs.

Josh Bretl:

But we've never really talked about how we put

Josh Bretl:

money into those accounts, how we put money into IRAs.

Josh Bretl:

And should you, or should you not put money in?

Josh Bretl:

We wanted to do an episode on what we call IRA

Josh Bretl:

contributions and some of the nuances that go into it.

Dave Schmidt:

Such as?

Dave Schmidt:

You're going to get into that, I hope?

Josh Bretl:

Do you want me to?

Dave Schmidt:

I mean, yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Nuance is your middle name.

Josh Bretl:

In the grand scheme of things, IRAs

Josh Bretl:

are relatively new.

Josh Bretl:

Now, a lot of our clients who are in their late 50s, 60s,

Josh Bretl:

and 70s, they've been around the for the majority of your

Josh Bretl:

life, but in your working years, they probably just got started.

Josh Bretl:

They really were relatively new.

Josh Bretl:

Your parents or grandparents never even knew what the

Josh Bretl:

heck they were, and they were totally reliant upon

Josh Bretl:

pension plans and company savings and things along those

Josh Bretl:

lines, and those went away.

Dave Schmidt:

They did.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Actually, Erin did some research

Josh Bretl:

for us, and I didn't realize some of this stuff.

Josh Bretl:

It was kind of neat.

Josh Bretl:

didn't realize that the first pension in the United

Josh Bretl:

States came into existence in 1875 for American Express.

Dave Schmidt:

I saw American Express, and I'm like,

Dave Schmidt:

"The credit card company?"

Josh Bretl:

Well, first off, I didn't realize American

Josh Bretl:

Express was around in 1875.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Right?

Josh Bretl:

But also the fact that they had

Josh Bretl:

the very first pension.

Dave Schmidt:

Good for them.

Josh Bretl:

And then by 1960, half of the private sector

Josh Bretl:

workforce had a pension.

Josh Bretl:

That wasn't that long ago.

Josh Bretl:

My father graduated high school in 1970, went to

Josh Bretl:

college, graduated in '74.

Josh Bretl:

And at that point in time, pensions were

Josh Bretl:

still hot and heavy.

Josh Bretl:

They were really going.

Josh Bretl:

Due to some law changes in the '80s, the rules around pensions

Josh Bretl:

became really difficult, and we saw a major decrease

Josh Bretl:

in the companies wanting to administer pensions, especially

Josh Bretl:

for smaller companies, things along those lines.

Josh Bretl:

And the government knew that there was a

Josh Bretl:

problem with savings.

Josh Bretl:

And people were changing jobs more often, which Erin

Josh Bretl:

threw out this one too.

Josh Bretl:

I thought this was kind of interesting.

Josh Bretl:

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, that the modern

Josh Bretl:

employee will hold over 11 jobs between the ages of 18 and 48.

Josh Bretl:

And so what happens is with a pension, if you keep

Josh Bretl:

changing jobs, those pensions don't usually go with you.

Josh Bretl:

They don't accumulate the way they're supposed to.

Josh Bretl:

And one of the benefits of a pension is working a long

Josh Bretl:

period of time so you get the biggest payout and things.

Josh Bretl:

That's how you maximize those.

Josh Bretl:

So they created these 401ks and these IRAs with the idea

Josh Bretl:

that they can travel with you, and the savings get

Josh Bretl:

built up time over time, and it can do a few things.

Josh Bretl:

One is it gives the employee more control, and two is it

Josh Bretl:

cuts cost for the employer.

Josh Bretl:

But also, they're portable, so you can take them with you.

Josh Bretl:

Now, that sounds all great, but I think what we've realized

Josh Bretl:

as a country is that people don't always want control.

Josh Bretl:

They fear control sometimes.

Josh Bretl:

They don't know how to do it.

Josh Bretl:

The market's scary.

Josh Bretl:

What if you're making the wrong decision?

Josh Bretl:

So we've tried to simplify it and do things along those lines.

Josh Bretl:

But one of the overarching comments or the overarching

Josh Bretl:

themes was that you just had to save.

Josh Bretl:

Pensions weren't going to be there.

Josh Bretl:

You just had to save.

Josh Bretl:

And they wanted to give you some advantages to savings.

Josh Bretl:

401[k]s are company sponsored.

Josh Bretl:

They're run by your employer.

Josh Bretl:

And if your company has one, odds are you

Josh Bretl:

can put money into it.

Josh Bretl:

And your company can put money in.

Josh Bretl:

They don't all do that.

Josh Bretl:

But if you put money in, that there's very

Josh Bretl:

rarely any income limits.

Josh Bretl:

But your investment choices are limited to

Josh Bretl:

what the company tells you you can put money into.

Josh Bretl:

Some of them have wide choices.

Josh Bretl:

Some of them have just a few choices.

Josh Bretl:

But the choices that you have are limited to what the

Josh Bretl:

company tells you you can have.

Dave Schmidt:

Are you saying...

Dave Schmidt:

because I don't remember.

Dave Schmidt:

Last time I had a 401[k] was 12 years ago.

Dave Schmidt:

An employee sometimes can go choose how aggressive

Dave Schmidt:

their portfolio is?

Josh Bretl:

Mm-hmm.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

They might have 12 mutual funds

Josh Bretl:

they get to pick from.

Josh Bretl:

There's thousands and thousands of stocks out there, but they

Josh Bretl:

might only have 12 mutual funds.

Dave Schmidt:

I see.

Josh Bretl:

There's some limits as those come into play.

Josh Bretl:

But the other thing, and you're a great example of that, is

Josh Bretl:

you had a 401[k] when you worked for the large bank,

Josh Bretl:

but when you went to become an independent contractor,

Josh Bretl:

401[k]s don't really exist, or they're hard to exist for

Josh Bretl:

small companies or individuals.

Josh Bretl:

So the government created these IRAs.

Josh Bretl:

IRA, it's a government acronym and actually easy to understand.

Josh Bretl:

It's individual retirement account.

Josh Bretl:

And what they said was, "Just like a 401[k], you put money in.

Josh Bretl:

You'll get a tax deduction for putting money in."

Josh Bretl:

Even to this day, sometimes they make that seem like

Josh Bretl:

it's the best thing ever.

Josh Bretl:

You're getting this tax deduction to put money in.

Josh Bretl:

You're getting this tax deduction.

Josh Bretl:

Well, what you're essentially doing is you're kicking the

Josh Bretl:

tax calculation down the road.

Josh Bretl:

It could be a good thing.

Josh Bretl:

It may not be a good thing.

Josh Bretl:

I will tell you, savings is always a good thing, but just a

Josh Bretl:

matter of where are you saving?

Josh Bretl:

What happens there?

Josh Bretl:

IRAs and Roth IRAs are individual accounts.

Josh Bretl:

We want to go through some of the rules that go through this.

Josh Bretl:

So 401[k]s, if you're under age 50, you can put in a maximum

Josh Bretl:

of $22,500 this year in 2023.

Josh Bretl:

If you're over 50, they allow what they call

Josh Bretl:

catch-up contributions, and you can put $30,000 in.

Josh Bretl:

How much you should put in, that's a whole different

Josh Bretl:

topic of conversation.

Josh Bretl:

We always tell people, "Save as much as you can, but

Josh Bretl:

don't go into debt to save."

Dave Schmidt:

401[k]s, Josh, most employers, do you know,

Dave Schmidt:

can you continuously adjust how much you're contributing?

Dave Schmidt:

Or is that an annual thing you have to choose?

Josh Bretl:

It's become a lot more flexible recently.

Josh Bretl:

It's really dependent upon the company.

Josh Bretl:

The company can set limits as to how much you can put

Josh Bretl:

in and how much you can put out, or how much you can put

Josh Bretl:

in, when you can take it out.

Josh Bretl:

Now, here's a couple rules on...

Josh Bretl:

Once money goes into a 401[k], the company

Josh Bretl:

doesn't have access to it.

Josh Bretl:

They can't steal it or do anything like that.

Josh Bretl:

But they can put handcuffs as to when you can get it out.

Josh Bretl:

They may or may not allow you to borrow money

Josh Bretl:

from it, called loans.

Josh Bretl:

They may or may not let you take money out while you're working.

Josh Bretl:

Now, the one rule is you can always get money out

Josh Bretl:

when you leave the employer.

Josh Bretl:

When you leave, you can always take the money out.

Josh Bretl:

But you do have the right to leave it there too, if it's over

Josh Bretl:

a certain dollar amount, so-

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, okay.

... Josh Bretl:

there's pros and cons.

... Josh Bretl:

You have to weigh those pros and cons as to where it sits.

... Josh Bretl:

But just getting the money in is what we're

... Josh Bretl:

going to focus on today.

Dave Schmidt:

Sure.

Josh Bretl:

If you put that money in there, now,

Josh Bretl:

there aren't generally income thresholds that's

Josh Bretl:

out there for 401[k]s.

Josh Bretl:

But there are some testing and some different rules

Josh Bretl:

that go onto 401[k]s.

Josh Bretl:

For smaller companies, if you have a 401[k], they may say,

Josh Bretl:

"Hey, you've put too much in."

Josh Bretl:

There are also Roth options on a lot of 401[k]s.

Josh Bretl:

They don't all have them, but some do have Roth options.

Josh Bretl:

Roth versus traditional, we've done whole episodes on that, The

Josh Bretl:

big difference there is taxes.

Josh Bretl:

The only difference between regular and

Josh Bretl:

traditional is taxes.

Josh Bretl:

Now, let's go to IRAs, because those are a little different.

Josh Bretl:

If your company does not have a 401[k], or any retirement

Josh Bretl:

plan, to be factual there, you have the ability to

Josh Bretl:

put money into an IRA.

Josh Bretl:

And there's some specific rules.

Josh Bretl:

And you actually, if you're married, you have to know,

Josh Bretl:

if neither of you have a 401[k], pretty much you can

Josh Bretl:

put money in no matter what.

Josh Bretl:

It's deductible.

Josh Bretl:

If one of you has a 401[k], there's income thresholds.

Josh Bretl:

You can't earn too much.

Josh Bretl:

If both of you have 401[k]s, it's very restrictive.

Josh Bretl:

Very rarely can you put money into an IRA and

Josh Bretl:

have it be deductible.

Josh Bretl:

Okay?

Josh Bretl:

But there's a lot of times that putting money

Josh Bretl:

in can be beneficial.

Josh Bretl:

For You may be late in your career, maybe a retiree,

Josh Bretl:

and you may have a side job, and you earn, I don't

Josh Bretl:

know, 15,000, 20,000 bucks.

Josh Bretl:

And you're normally in the 12% or 15% tax bracket, but this

Josh Bretl:

side job just puts you up and above into the 22%, 24% bracket.

Josh Bretl:

Well, in that case, let's put the money in.

Josh Bretl:

Let's get a deduction, and then we'll take it out later at 15%.

Josh Bretl:

That makes a ton of sense.

Josh Bretl:

There also going to be some things for Medicare.

Josh Bretl:

The cost of Medicare is dependent upon your

Josh Bretl:

adjusted gross income.

Josh Bretl:

It could be helpful for that.

Josh Bretl:

There's just some things that putting 10,000 to

Josh Bretl:

15,000 bucks away in your IRA if you're married

Josh Bretl:

can be beneficial to you.

Josh Bretl:

But you have to have earned income.

Josh Bretl:

That's the key to this one, is earned income.

Josh Bretl:

Earned income is money from a job.

Dave Schmidt:

Not Social Security.

Josh Bretl:

Social Security is not earned income.

Josh Bretl:

Investment is not earned income.

Josh Bretl:

401[k] distributions are not earned income.

Dave Schmidt:

Pensions?

Dave Schmidt:

No?

Dave Schmidt:

No?

Josh Bretl:

Pensions are not earned income.

Josh Bretl:

It's income from working-

Dave Schmidt:

A job.

... Josh Bretl:

in some way.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

It could be self employment income.

Josh Bretl:

It could be W2 income, which means an employer paid you.

Josh Bretl:

It has to come from a job.

Dave Schmidt:

I read poetry on the street corner, and

Dave Schmidt:

people throw coins and dollars at me as tips.

Dave Schmidt:

Does that count as income?

Josh Bretl:

Only if you're going to claim it on your

Josh Bretl:

tax return, which legally you're supposed to, but I

Josh Bretl:

don't know what you're doing.

Josh Bretl:

I don't do your tax return, so-

Dave Schmidt:

I made $17 all of last year doing it.

Dave Schmidt:

Do I have to claim that?

Josh Bretl:

Well, legally, yes.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, man.

Josh Bretl:

Do a lot of people do it?

Josh Bretl:

No.

Josh Bretl:

But legally, yeah, you're supposed to claim that.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, okay.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Any and all income sources.

Josh Bretl:

Roth contribution limits are a little different.

Josh Bretl:

Now, if you put money into an IRA and you're above income

Josh Bretl:

thresholds, you're still allowed to put money in, but

Josh Bretl:

it becomes non-deductible.

Josh Bretl:

And you have to file a form 8606 on your tax return, because

Josh Bretl:

you have to track how much of your IRA is non-deductible

Josh Bretl:

versus deductible.

Alex:

Hashtag tax nerd.

Josh Bretl:

Oh, yeah.

Josh Bretl:

It's a fun thing, because that'll follow

Josh Bretl:

into our backdoor Roth.

Dave Schmidt:

Really quick though, if I were to ask Al

Dave Schmidt:

what form is needed to file, would he be like, "8606?"

Dave Schmidt:

Would he know what forms are needed?

Dave Schmidt:

Is he not quite that-

Josh Bretl:

You've just set my 2023 goal.

Dave Schmidt:

To teach him what form needs to be filed.

Josh Bretl:

I am not a form guru.

Josh Bretl:

I don't know which forms, what schedules, which this, all that.

Josh Bretl:

But 8606 is a common form for people who have

Josh Bretl:

non-deductible IRAs.

Josh Bretl:

We see those a lot.

Josh Bretl:

Get the 8606 out.

Josh Bretl:

Let's see the 8606.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

It's kind of fun.

Dave Schmidt:

It just rolls off the tongue, too.

Josh Bretl:

It does.

Dave Schmidt:

It's fun.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

It does.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

There's probably people listening to this

Josh Bretl:

podcast that know more about form 8606 as a client than

Josh Bretl:

some of your advisors do.

Josh Bretl:

But we'll get back to that one, but let's talk

Josh Bretl:

about the Roth limits.

Josh Bretl:

If you decide from a tax reason that you want to put

Josh Bretl:

money into a Roth versus a traditional, there are very

Josh Bretl:

strict income thresholds.

Josh Bretl:

And again, it has to be earned income.

Josh Bretl:

But for a single taxpayer, that starts at 138,000 and

Josh Bretl:

phases out up to 153,000.

Josh Bretl:

If you have less than $138,000 of earned income,

Josh Bretl:

you can put money in a Roth.

Josh Bretl:

It doesn't matter if you have a 401[k].

Josh Bretl:

It doesn't matter any of those things.

Josh Bretl:

You can put money into a Roth.

Josh Bretl:

If you get above 153, you cannot.

Josh Bretl:

And if you do, the penalties are actually very severe.

Josh Bretl:

You have some time to take it out and do what

Josh Bretl:

they call a reversal, but-

Dave Schmidt:

So if you make a mistake, you can fix it-

Josh Bretl:

You can fix it.

... Dave Schmidt:

before...

... Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

But if you leave it in there, and they catch

Josh Bretl:

you, I want to say, don't quote me, but it's close to a

Josh Bretl:

50% penalty on the earnings.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, my gosh.

Josh Bretl:

It's pretty substantial.

Dave Schmidt:

On the earnings.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Not-

Josh Bretl:

But it's still pretty substantial.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

It could be a substantial penalty.

Josh Bretl:

For a married filing joint taxpayer, that phaseout starts

Josh Bretl:

at 218,000 and goes up to 228.

Josh Bretl:

If you're a high income earner, you probably can't put

Josh Bretl:

money into a Roth directly.

Dave Schmidt:

Those numbers are pretty high for me.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

I know.

Josh Bretl:

That's a high income earner.

Josh Bretl:

Now, that brings us to the backdoor Roth.

Josh Bretl:

The way that works is people put money into

Josh Bretl:

an IRA non-deductible.

Josh Bretl:

They haven't deducted it.

Josh Bretl:

And they do an instant conversion.

Josh Bretl:

And that is essentially the third...

Josh Bretl:

We always say there's three ways to get money into a Roth.

Josh Bretl:

One is a contribution, which we just talked about.

Josh Bretl:

Two is a conversion.

Josh Bretl:

A conversion is going from a regular IRA to Roth IRA.

Josh Bretl:

And the third's a backdoor Roth conversion.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

Now, what that means though, is

Josh Bretl:

you're taking money out.

Josh Bretl:

Still it's a conversion, but you have to be very careful,

Josh Bretl:

and you really have to plan these out, because whenever

Josh Bretl:

you take money out of an IRA that has a non-deductible

Josh Bretl:

portion to it, so it has a form 8606, we have to follow what

Josh Bretl:

they call the pro rata rule.

Josh Bretl:

Okay?

Josh Bretl:

Listen to me on this one.

Josh Bretl:

Let's say your IRA is worth $20,000.

Josh Bretl:

Okay?

Dave Schmidt:

20,000.

Josh Bretl:

And your form 8606 says you've put in 10,000-

Dave Schmidt:

10,000.

... Josh Bretl:

as basis.

Dave Schmidt:

Basis.

Josh Bretl:

Half as basis, half as earnings.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Okay?

Dave Schmidt:

Totally.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm on it.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Great.

Josh Bretl:

And you do this backdoor Roth conversion for $10,000.

Josh Bretl:

You think, "Hey, I've got this basis of 10,000.

Josh Bretl:

I'm just going to convert it.

Josh Bretl:

No big deal."

Josh Bretl:

You do the conversion of $10,000, but because of the

Josh Bretl:

pro rata rule, half of your IRA was non-deductible.

Josh Bretl:

Half was earnings that you haven't paid taxes on yet.

Josh Bretl:

Your tax return's going to show $5,000 of non-deductible and

Josh Bretl:

$5,000 of actual taxable income.

Dave Schmidt:

Got it.

Josh Bretl:

Just have to be aware of the pro rata rule.

Josh Bretl:

At that level, it's not huge, but we've seen

Josh Bretl:

people make mistakes in the $100,000 range there.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Josh Bretl:

You have to be careful with that.

Dave Schmidt:

With your Roth limits though, if someone

Dave Schmidt:

earns over that 228, let's say as a couple, 228,000, can

Dave Schmidt:

they still do a conversion?

Josh Bretl:

There are no limits on conversions.

Dave Schmidt:

Could someone in theory just contribute to

Dave Schmidt:

an IRA, then the next day, convert it to a Roth, even

Dave Schmidt:

though they're over that limit?

Josh Bretl:

That is a backdoor-

Dave Schmidt:

That is a-

... Josh Bretl:

conversion.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

Or in Illinois, this is a tip or trick, tip,

Josh Bretl:

trick, this is something that people don't realize.

Dave Schmidt:

Hashtag Josh tips.

Josh Bretl:

Oh, I like it.

Josh Bretl:

That's new.

Dave Schmidt:

Thank you.

Josh Bretl:

Illinois as a state is unique, where they

Josh Bretl:

don't tax retirement income.

Josh Bretl:

So IRA distributions, 401[k] distributions are not taxed

Josh Bretl:

at the Illinois level.

Josh Bretl:

But you still get a deduction for putting money in.

Josh Bretl:

At the Illinois level, we tell everybody, "If you're choosing

Josh Bretl:

between an IRA contribution and a Roth contribution and

Josh Bretl:

you have the option for both, you are almost always better

Josh Bretl:

putting money into the IRA.

Josh Bretl:

You get a federal deduction and a state deduction.

Josh Bretl:

And converting instantly, you'll pay a federal tax,

Josh Bretl:

so those net to zero, but you won't pay the state tax.

Josh Bretl:

You will get a state of Illinois tax benefit by doing that, so-"

Dave Schmidt:

I knew there was a reason we lived in Illinois.

Dave Schmidt:

It's for that Josh tip alone.

Josh Bretl:

The Josh tip only applies to Illinois residents.

Josh Bretl:

Other states, please check your local laws, but-

Dave Schmidt:

You sound like the little disclaimers on

Dave Schmidt:

pharmaceutical commercials.

Josh Bretl:

I know.

Josh Bretl:

Every state is so different.

Josh Bretl:

It's crazy.

Josh Bretl:

If you're going to put money in, you just need

Josh Bretl:

to make sure you're making the right decisions there.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Dave Schmidt:

You've been talking here about contributions a little bit

Dave Schmidt:

too long for my liking, so...

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

What?

Dave Schmidt:

What?

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Dave Schmidt:

Hey, Mr.

Dave Schmidt:

Josh.

Dave Schmidt:

Let's take a break.

Dave Schmidt:

You've been talking for so long, and my ears are sore.

Dave Schmidt:

Let's not make them snore.

Dave Schmidt:

Listening shouldn't be a chore.

Dave Schmidt:

Let's get to know Josh and Dave and watch our ratings soar.

Dave Schmidt:

Give me the cackaw.

Josh Bretl:

Cackaw!

Josh Bretl:

Cackaw!

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

I was thinking about doing the Gritty here on camera and

Dave Schmidt:

making Landon super proud.

Dave Schmidt:

Eh, there's a better than average chance that I would

Dave Schmidt:

pull a hamstring doing it, so I opted out for episode 29.

Dave Schmidt:

There's a lot of pressure on you.

Dave Schmidt:

This is the first get to know Josh and Dave of 2023.

Josh Bretl:

I actually struggle with it a little bit.

Dave Schmidt:

Did you?

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Because, well, I read the cards, and I think it's

Josh Bretl:

a good question, but I don't know how I'm going

Josh Bretl:

to answer the question yet.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Josh Bretl:

Here's our question, and again, I think I have an

Josh Bretl:

answer for what you're going to do here, but what would you

Josh Bretl:

do with an extra hour in a day?

Dave Schmidt:

One extra hour?

Josh Bretl:

One extra hour.

Josh Bretl:

Every day, an extra hour.

Josh Bretl:

What would you do?

Dave Schmidt:

I may be overanalyzing, but

Dave Schmidt:

when does that hour fit into our day, like-

Josh Bretl:

it's your day.

Josh Bretl:

You decide.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Dave Schmidt:

An extra hour in my day.

Dave Schmidt:

First thing that comes to mind is napping, but I usually nap

Dave Schmidt:

during normal 24 hours, so I don't need extra time for that.

Dave Schmidt:

Napping is covered.

Josh Bretl:

Do you really nap?

Dave Schmidt:

Almost daily.

Dave Schmidt:

Almost daily.

Dave Schmidt:

Between 20 minutes to 40 minutes a day.

Dave Schmidt:

That's actually one of my forms of meditation

Dave Schmidt:

that we talked about.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

I don't always fall asleep, but I lay down.

Dave Schmidt:

With an extra hour a day, I do have a list of new

Dave Schmidt:

things I want to learn.

Dave Schmidt:

I want to learn a couple languages.

Dave Schmidt:

I want to learn how to play the harmonica,

Dave Schmidt:

potentially the guitar.

Dave Schmidt:

I think I would use that one extra hour and just

Dave Schmidt:

hardcore learn something new with that one hour.

Josh Bretl:

I think learning something makes sense.

Josh Bretl:

But the harmonica?

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, you know I have one, right?

Josh Bretl:

No.

Dave Schmidt:

I wanted to surprise listeners

Dave Schmidt:

with a jingle.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm just not quite at that point yet.

Dave Schmidt:

I can only make certain sounds with it, but I bought it at

Dave Schmidt:

the heart of COVID thinking, "This is what I'm going to do."

Dave Schmidt:

And-

Josh Bretl:

youTube videos?

Josh Bretl:

You're learning the harmonica via YouTube videos?

Dave Schmidt:

That was the plan, but it's kind of just

Dave Schmidt:

sitting there on my desk at home collecting dust.

Josh Bretl:

I think if I had an extra hour, I would read more.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Kind of similar to mine.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

business books, motivational books, life

Josh Bretl:

books, fiction books.

Josh Bretl:

I like all that stuff.

Josh Bretl:

And I don't think I read enough.

Dave Schmidt:

Peppa the Pig books.

Josh Bretl:

I read a lot of those.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah, I like

Dave Schmidt:

- . Josh Bretl: Actually,

Dave Schmidt:

The kids are getting a little older.

Dave Schmidt:

We're reading Harry Potter right now as a family.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

Dave Schmidt:

We still read Pig the Pug.

Dave Schmidt:

Those are still timeless.

Josh Bretl:

Oh, Zach loves Pig the Pug.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

He's the best.

Josh Bretl:

He also loves harmonicas, and so he got

Josh Bretl:

one for Christmas as well.

Josh Bretl:

We'll see.

Dave Schmidt:

Did he really?

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

We'll see.

Dave Schmidt:

Yes.

Josh Bretl:

We'll see how it goes.

Dave Schmidt:

We're totally going to start a band, Zach.

Josh Bretl:

I do learn things about you during these

Josh Bretl:

get to know Josh and Dave.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

This is back to back episodes.

Dave Schmidt:

I see mind blown.

Josh Bretl:

The one with you meditating really blew my mind.

Dave Schmidt:

Did it?

Josh Bretl:

In fact, I was listening to that episode again.

Josh Bretl:

I went, "Man.

Josh Bretl:

I knew him so well, and-"

Dave Schmidt:

I'm proud of you.

Dave Schmidt:

You've actually listened to the episode before I have.

Josh Bretl:

Oh.

Josh Bretl:

Look at this.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm really stuck on this true crime

Dave Schmidt:

called Bone Valley.

Dave Schmidt:

Man, I cannot recommend it enough.

Dave Schmidt:

It is the best true crime I've ever heard.

Dave Schmidt:

It's kind of like...

Dave Schmidt:

Dave relates to retirees.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

I'm a little nervous.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

By the way, I'm a little nervous about how you go

Josh Bretl:

from a true crime podcast right into you relating to retirees.

Dave Schmidt:

Well, listen.

Dave Schmidt:

Whenever I do this with my paper stack, Josh

Dave Schmidt:

knows he's in for a treat.

Josh Bretl:

There's notes.

Josh Bretl:

There's notes, folks.

Dave Schmidt:

There's got to be notes.

Dave Schmidt:

I take notes pre-episode and mid-episode.

Dave Schmidt:

What I learned today, Josh, was that retirees will contribute

Dave Schmidt:

to an IRA for any number of reasons, assuming they

Dave Schmidt:

qualify, of course, right?

Dave Schmidt:

But generally, they'll contribute it for

Dave Schmidt:

tax savings, right?

Josh Bretl:

Taxes are important.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Taxes are very important.

Dave Schmidt:

They contribute to something for a benefit.

Dave Schmidt:

Have you heard of the book How Full is your Bucket?

Dave Schmidt:

The kid version.

Josh Bretl:

I've heard of the kid version.

Josh Bretl:

Yes.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Dave Schmidt:

That's the only version I know, too.

Josh Bretl:

Okay.

Dave Schmidt:

To your point, I don't read enough either.

Dave Schmidt:

But we use the whole bucket philosophy in the Schmidt

Dave Schmidt:

house, and we love it.

Dave Schmidt:

And so I contribute to Carla's bucket.

Dave Schmidt:

And yes, I do it to make her happy, but I also do it because

Dave Schmidt:

I get a big benefit out of it.

Dave Schmidt:

Here's some examples.

Dave Schmidt:

Are you interested in hearing examples?

Josh Bretl:

I love examples.

Dave Schmidt:

There may be one night where she makes

Dave Schmidt:

her gluten free vegan dinner for everybody, and I eat it.

Dave Schmidt:

Now, look, I like all food.

Dave Schmidt:

I eat everything.

Dave Schmidt:

I'll eat it, but it's not my favorite food.

Dave Schmidt:

I'll do that for a few nights.

Dave Schmidt:

And I'm contributing to her bucket so then I can say,

Dave Schmidt:

"Oh, Carla, looks good.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm going to get myself a calzone, if

Dave Schmidt:

that's okay with you."

Dave Schmidt:

And her bucket is so full from me eating her

Dave Schmidt:

meals, she's like, "Yeah.

Dave Schmidt:

Absolutely.

Dave Schmidt:

You contribute to my bucket.

Dave Schmidt:

You go get that reward."

Dave Schmidt:

It's not a tax savings.

Dave Schmidt:

It's a calzone.

Dave Schmidt:

But it's still the same thing.

Dave Schmidt:

Or if there's some social things going on where I have to go

Dave Schmidt:

talk to people and hang out with people, I'll fill her bucket.

Dave Schmidt:

I'll contribute to her bucket by doing a few of these.

Dave Schmidt:

But then one night I'll be like, "Oh, Carla, it's

Dave Schmidt:

a good game on tonight.

Dave Schmidt:

I'm kind of just not feeling social."

Dave Schmidt:

And she'll think back.

Dave Schmidt:

She'll be like, "Dave contributed to my bucket,

Dave Schmidt:

so he gets the reward of hanging out in the basement

Dave Schmidt:

by himself all night."

Dave Schmidt:

Retirees, I get you.

Dave Schmidt:

I get you.

Dave Schmidt:

And now it's time for Josh to wrap it all together.

Dave Schmidt:

Pen drop.

Dave Schmidt:

Carla, I love you, by the way.

Josh Bretl:

He does love you, Carla.

Josh Bretl:

What you said about that book, and we've read this book

Josh Bretl:

since the kids were little, and for those listeners that

Josh Bretl:

aren't aware of the bucket book, the bucket book has to

Josh Bretl:

do with being kind to other people, and kindness is as

Josh Bretl:

you fill up their bucket.

Josh Bretl:

As you're being kind to them, it fills their bucket with love.

Josh Bretl:

And the more full their bucket is, the better they feel,

Josh Bretl:

and the better their life is.

Josh Bretl:

And when you're mean to them or aren't kind to them,

Josh Bretl:

it drops water out of the bucket, and they become

Josh Bretl:

miserable human beings.

Dave Schmidt:

I think equally as important to

Dave Schmidt:

that is finding what fills people's buckets, because

Dave Schmidt:

it's different for everybody.

Josh Bretl:

Yes.

Josh Bretl:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

And I was a little worried as to how you were going to try

Josh Bretl:

and equate this to retirees.

Dave Schmidt:

It's on point.

Dave Schmidt:

It is a perfect one to one connection, Josh.

Josh Bretl:

You're not too far off-

Dave Schmidt:

Oh.

... Josh Bretl:

Here's where I'm going with this.

... Josh Bretl:

Full House music.

... Josh Bretl:

I hope this resonates.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, it's been playing.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

You are putting stuff away for a future benefit.

Josh Bretl:

And like a retiree who, putting money away right now is not fun.

Josh Bretl:

I'd rather spend it on something else.

Josh Bretl:

I'd rather go out and buy something cool, a

Josh Bretl:

new toy, better food, whatever it might be.

Josh Bretl:

But I'm going to save for the future.

Josh Bretl:

I'm going to contribute to my IRA, my 401[k],

Josh Bretl:

whatever that might be.

Josh Bretl:

Now, you are contributing to Carla's bucket so that

Josh Bretl:

in the future, you can reap the rewards of this.

Dave Schmidt:

Correct.

Josh Bretl:

But here's the difference that

Josh Bretl:

I'm struggling with.

Josh Bretl:

When I contribute to the 401[k], it is truly out of

Josh Bretl:

I'm going to get something in the future out of this.

Dave Schmidt:

Okay.

Josh Bretl:

I think the theme of that story, the bucket story,

Josh Bretl:

has everything to do with making the other person feel very

Josh Bretl:

good, and has very little to do with expecting future benefits

Josh Bretl:

that you'll receive from making that person feel good, so-

Dave Schmidt:

That's just one man's interpretation, Josh.

Dave Schmidt:

All right?

Josh Bretl:

It's kind of like my daughter saying, "Well, if

Josh Bretl:

I give her a gift, then she's going to give me a gift."

Dave Schmidt:

I haven't really matured past

Dave Schmidt:

the age of nine, or 8.

Josh Bretl:

No.

Josh Bretl:

I understand where you're going, and I think the

Josh Bretl:

retirees will get it.

Josh Bretl:

But I also think that they will hope that you're just

Josh Bretl:

going to fill up Carla's bucket because you want to be a good

Josh Bretl:

person and it makes you feel good to fill up her bucket.

Josh Bretl:

And Dave, if you ever need something non-vegan, gluten

Josh Bretl:

filled, come on over.

Dave Schmidt:

Oh, I know where to go, believe me.

Dave Schmidt:

This kind of ties back nicely to the whole Bretl

Dave Schmidt:

countertop situation, where you'll cook for everybody.

Dave Schmidt:

I'll just have Carla stop and get a salad for herself-

Josh Bretl:

She does do that.

Josh Bretl:

Dave, our first podcast of 2023 is in the books, and-

Dave Schmidt:

It's in the books.

... Josh Bretl:

I'm excited to see what the year

... Josh Bretl:

holds for us and for the podcast listeners as well.

... Josh Bretl:

Please, if you like the podcast, share it with a friend, a

... Josh Bretl:

family member, someone else who you think would find us

... Josh Bretl:

entertaining and insightful.

Dave Schmidt:

Yeah.

Josh Bretl:

Well, I'm the insightful one.

Dave Schmidt:

Very insightful.

Josh Bretl:

You're the entertaining one.

Dave Schmidt:

Hey, listeners, it's as simple

Dave Schmidt:

as telling a friend, "Hey, go to pod.link/ref.

Josh Bretl:

R-E-F, Retirement Equals Freedom.

Dave Schmidt:

That is us.

Josh Bretl:

Pod.link/ref.

Dave Schmidt:

We don't own that website, but it's a cool

Dave Schmidt:

website to just send somebody to, and it's like a really

Dave Schmidt:

quick recap of everything we do.

Dave Schmidt:

It can send them to all the different podcast apps.

Dave Schmidt:

Pod.link/ref.

Dave Schmidt:

Just give it a shot.

Josh Bretl:

Well, with that, my friend, do you have

Josh Bretl:

something you'd like to say-

Dave Schmidt:

Let's see.

... Josh Bretl:

to Debbie?

Dave Schmidt:

Deb, I will say this.

Dave Schmidt:

Next time you hear our compliance message, it

Dave Schmidt:

will be from our brand new podcast desk, so what I say

Dave Schmidt:

now is just a simple bye.

Dave Schmidt:

Bye.

Dave Schmidt:

Worst ending ever,

Josh Bretl:

Which part?

Dave Schmidt:

I don't know.

Dave Schmidt:

The whole thing.

Follow

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube