The Kinderhook Plates Hoax
Episode 1326th October 2025 • Unveiling Mormonism • PursueGOD
00:00:00 00:10:11

Share Episode

Shownotes

In this episode we reveal how the infamous Kinderhook Plates—once hailed by Joseph Smith as an ancient record—turned out to be a deliberate 19th-century hoax that exposes the cracks in Mormonism’s prophetic claims.

--

The Unveiling Mormonism podcast pulls back the curtain on Mormon history, culture and doctrine. Join us for new episodes every Monday.

Find resources to talk about these episodes at pursueGOD.org/mormonism.

Help others go "full circle" as a follower of Jesus through our 12-week Pursuit series.

Click here to learn more about how to use these resources at home, with a small group, or in a one-on-one discipleship relationship.

Got questions or want to leave a note? Email us at podcast@pursueGOD.org.

Donate Now

--

In 1843, Joseph Smith—the founder of Mormonism—was handed what looked like an ancient discovery: six mysterious brass plates unearthed in Illinois. But the “Kinderhook Plates” weren’t ancient at all; they were a deliberately crafted hoax designed to test Smith’s prophetic gift. In this episode, we uncover the full story—how the plates were forged, why they were presented to Smith, what he claimed about them, and how the LDS Church eventually admitted they were fake. More than a quirky historical footnote, the Kinderhook Plates pose a serious question about the foundation of Mormonism and the claims of its prophet. We’ll also point you back to the solid ground of Scripture and the simple gospel of Jesus Christ.

What You’ll Learn in This Episode:

  • The backstory of the Kinderhook Plates and why they were created
  • How Joseph Smith responded and what he claimed they revealed
  • Evidence from eyewitnesses, later confessions, and modern scientific testing proving the plates were man-made
  • How the LDS Church’s position on the plates has shifted over time
  • What the Bible says about testing prophets and why Jesus—not any modern prophet—is God’s final revelation

Why This Matters:

This isn’t just an old scandal. It’s a living test case for Joseph Smith’s credibility and for the LDS Church’s truth claims today. If a prophet can’t discern a man-made fraud, what does that say about his revelations?

Scripture Highlight:

Deuteronomy 18:21-22 – God’s own test for identifying false prophets.

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
132. The Kinderhook Plates Hoax
00:10:11
131. How Mormons Pick Their Prophets (And Why It Matters)
00:12:27
130. Temple Worthiness Interview (Part 2)
00:56:21
129. Temple Worthiness Interview (Part 1)
00:51:52
128. The Holy Ghost in the Book of Mormon
00:41:14
127. Jesus in the Book of Mormon
00:54:40
126. God in the Book of Mormon
00:38:27
125. Salvation in the Book of Mormon
00:59:22
124. A Deep Dive on 3 Nephi 11
00:45:05
123. The Missing 116 Pages Scandal
00:25:10
122. Layne’s Story: God Removed the Veil
00:55:35
121. How Mormons Get Covenants Wrong
00:33:58
120. Galatians 6 | Grace in Community
00:45:54
119. Freedom vs. Religious Control (Galatians 5)
00:43:30
118. From Slavery to Sonship (Galatians 4)
00:39:51
117. LDS Ordinances Are a Curse (Galatians 3)
00:42:12
116. Gospel Freedom vs. Religious Control (Galatians 2)
00:31:24
115. The Gospel According to Paul (Galatians 1)
00:37:53
114. Does 2 Nephi 25:23 Teach Grace or Works?
00:05:42
113. Aleck’s Story: Not Just Deconstructing
00:51:23
112. Baptism for the Dead: When Did Mormonism Start Doing This?
00:09:53
111. Preaching to the Dead? Mormon Theology Gone Wrong
00:11:20
110. Three Prophecies Joseph Smith Got Wrong
00:10:19
109. Brigham's Story: How God Found Me Before I Found the Truth
00:31:50
108. Mormonism Exposed by the Book of John
00:16:11
107. Did Mormon Prophets Believe in Moon Men?
00:08:00
106. Did Jesus Progress? Understanding Luke 2:52
00:12:05
105. Court and Becca’s Story: Beyond the Optics
00:30:40
104. Mormonism Exposed by the Book of Hebrews
00:15:42
103. Mormonism Exposed by the Book of Galatians
00:10:06
102. Rabbit Holes After Mormonism
00:27:11
101. Holli’s Story: Physically In, Mentally Out Mormons
00:29:59
100. Should You Leave the Mormon Church?
00:14:48
99. The Trinity and the Council at Nicaea
00:37:10
98. 5 Podcasts Worth Listening to in 2025
00:17:52
97. Bo and KD's Story: The Seminary Teacher Who Left the LDS Church
00:45:06
96. Do Mormons Believe in Heavenly Mother? (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:44:27
95. Jordan and Becca's Story: Escaping a High Control Religion
00:57:03
94. Who Are the Seventh Day Adventists?
00:59:34
93. Who Are the Jehovah's Witnesses?
00:57:51
92. Is Tithing Biblical or Just a Mormon Thing?
00:37:43
91. First Vision Accounts (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:47:49
90. The Masonic Roots of Mormonism (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:40:23
89. Best of UM: Coming Clean About Polygamy (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:44:37
88. Best of UM: Becoming Like God (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:41:01
87. Best of UM: Translating the Book of Mormon (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:43:17
86. Are Mormons Christians? (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:43:34
85. What Happens to People Who Have Never Heard the Gospel?
00:31:37
84. Cane Ridge Revival, Church of Christ, and Mormonism
00:21:25
83. Mormon Questions: Will I Go to Outer Darkness if I Leave Mormonism?
00:27:30
82. Mormon Questions: What If I Felt a Burning in My Bosom?
00:24:13
81. Mormon Questions: Are Families Forever in Heaven?
00:28:44
80. Mormon Questions: Did Humans Exist Before Conception?
00:26:49
79. Mormon Questions: Do Mormons Hold the Keys to the Kingdom?
00:25:53
78. Mormon Questions: Can the Bible Be Trusted?
00:48:34
77. How Did This Make It Into the LDS Articles of Faith?!
00:50:35
76. What Do Mormons Believe about the Literal Gathering of Israel?
00:39:56
75. Mormon Stories: The Couple Who Came for Community
00:46:54
74. Mormon Doctrine of Scripture Compared to Christianity
00:53:28
74. bonus Personality Types in Marriage
00:39:03
73. Spiritual Gifts through the Lens of Mormonism
00:47:41
72. Mormon Stories: The Idaho Mormon Who Found the Real Jesus
00:47:22
71. Mormon Stories: Growing Up Non-LDS in Utah
00:47:10
70. Priests, Prophets, and Apostles Explained
01:00:09
69. The Bad News about LDS Ordinances
00:53:36
68. The LDS Doctrine of Sin and Salvation Compared to Biblical Christianity
00:48:28
67. Mormon Stories: The COVID Mormon Who Found Freedom
00:43:37
66. LDS Doctrine of God Explained by a Former Mormon Missionary
00:50:13
65. The Burden of Womanhood in Mormonism
00:48:09
64. What Does Mormonism Think About Women?
00:41:29
63. If God Is Good, Why Does Evil Exist?
00:42:40
62. Does God Still Speak Through Prophets?
00:53:49
61. Is the Book of Mormon More Reliable than the Bible?
00:58:45
60. Is the Mormon Church the Only True Church?
00:45:24
59. How Good Is Good Enough in Mormonism?
00:54:41
58. Mormon Stories: The Controlling Mormon Wife Who Found Jesus
00:49:27
57. Is Mormon Priesthood Biblical?
00:44:53
56. Mormon Stories: The Journey of the Born Again Mormon
00:53:02
55. The Jack Mormon Who Finally Found the Answer
00:37:15
57. bonus The Mormons Finally Bought the Kirtland Temple!
00:19:54
54. The Mormon Lawyer and Accountant Who Stopped Checking Their Brains at the Door
00:46:15
56. Three More Passages Mormons Get Wrong
00:58:25
56. Three Passages Mormons Get Wrong
00:48:15
53. Bible Basics for LDS Investigators
00:39:22
53. bonus A Sneak Peak at 2024
00:11:31
52. More LDS Commandments and Mormon Missionary Lesson 5
00:53:59
51. The LDS Commandments and Mormon Missionary Lesson 4
00:54:51
50. Cassie’s Story: Hungry Enough to Need God
00:39:29
49. The LDS Gospel and Mormon Missionary Lesson 3
00:48:45
48. The Plan of Exaltation and Mormon Missionary Lesson 2
00:46:20
47. The Great Apostasy and Mormon Missionary Lesson 1
00:53:38
46. How Big Is Your Mormon Box of Doubts?
00:52:08
45. Explaining Bible Translations to Mormons
00:52:22
44. The Rebranding of the Mormon Church
00:42:24
43. Disciplemaker Essentials for Non-Mormons (Pursuit 12)
00:51:21
42. How to Gently Help Your LDS Friends Leave Mormonism (Pursuit 11)
00:59:56
41. Mormons Aren't the Only Ones Who Send Missionaries (Pursuit 10)
01:00:09
40. Five Habits that Actually Matter to God (Pursuit 09)
00:52:44
39. Here's Why Grace Is NOT a License to Sin (Pursuit 08)
00:47:54
38. What Every Mormon Needs to Know about Baptism (Pursuit 07)
00:43:55
37. One Moment Can Change Everything (Pursuit 06)
00:46:29
36. What Mormons Get Wrong about Jesus (Pursuit 05)
00:53:27
35. What Mormons Get Wrong about Sin (Pursuit 04)
00:45:53
34. What Imago Dei Really Means (Pursuit 03)
00:40:17
34. bonus Oh My Heck It's Pioneer Day!
00:21:13
33. Why You Can Stop Doubting the Bible (Pursuit 02)
00:42:54
32. God Loves Even Jack Mormons (Pursuit 01)
00:45:22
31. Mormon Stories: The Flirt to Convert Tactic
00:42:38
30. The Masonic Roots of Mormonism (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:40:33
29. Coming Clean about Polygamy (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:44:50
28. Mormon Stories: The Return Missionary Who Became a Youth Pastor
00:45:12
27. Becoming Like God (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:41:39
26. Translating the Book of Mormon and Book of Abraham (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:43:27
25. Are Mormons Christians? (LDS Gospel Topics)
00:41:54
24. Leaving Mormonism - Give Church a Second Chance
00:45:13
23. Leaving Mormonism - Talking with Your Family about Your Exit
00:40:52
22. Leaving Mormonism - Dealing with the Questions
00:43:00
21. Leaving Mormonism - Dealing with the Emotions
00:39:37
14. The LDS Church's Billion Dollar Investments
00:40:51
13. Mormon Stories - The Seminary Teacher Who Left the LDS Church
00:45:06
12. A Brief History of Mormon Polygamy
00:49:18
11. The Mormon Temple and Ordinances
00:48:10
10. Why Mormons Don't Drink Coffee (and Other Disctinctive LDS Practices)
00:43:17
9. More Bullet-Proof Evidence Against the Book of Mormon
00:42:19
8. Bullet-Proof Evidence Against the Book of Mormon
00:47:40
7. Polygamy, Racism, and Other Changing Doctrines of Mormonism
00:48:15
6. The Sketchy History of Joseph Smith
00:54:28
5. What Mormons Believe About Eternity
00:53:02
4. What Mormons Believe About Salvation
00:52:47
3. What Mormons Believe About Humanity
00:44:10
2. What Mormons Believe About Scripture
00:45:33
1. What Mormons Believe about God
00:43:50