Artwork for podcast Automotive Field Theory
Technician Pay, Profit Sharing, and Trust [E254]
Episode 254 • 16th September 2026 • Automotive Field Theory • Matt Fanslow
00:00:00 00:36:58

Share Episode

Shownotes

Thanks to our Partners, Pico Technology and Autel

Watch Full Video Episode

Percentages Don’t Pay Bills

A prospective hire wants a meaningful increase in income. Riverside Automotive’s base wage would already beat what he currently earns, and the shop’s profit-sharing program could take him beyond his stated goal. Still, he struggles to trust the opportunity.

Is the problem the compensation plan, the way it is being explained, or the uncertainty created by years of disappointing pay systems?

In this episode of Automotive Field Theory, Matt explains how Riverside’s profit-sharing system works and why the percentage assigned to each employee matters far less than the actual dollars produced. Adding another productive person may reduce everyone’s individual percentage while enlarging the total profit pool enough that everyone takes home more money.

Matt also explores:

  • Why revenue, gross profit, and money left after expenses are not interchangeable
  • Why a business must retain profit for equipment, facilities, reserves, training, and future needs
  • How ethical profitability can grow through efficiency, inspections, communication, customer relationships, and reduced expenses
  • Why charging more does not automatically make a shop unethical
  • How every employee can influence overall shop profitability
  • Why individual production incentives may discourage collaboration
  • How poorly implemented flat-rate systems create lasting distrust
  • Why a technically good compensation plan can still feel unsafe or unfair
  • The responsibility leaders have to understand an employee’s previous experiences
  • Why shared profit can compensate people for helping the entire organization succeed, not merely for their individual billed hours

The central point is simple: percentages do not pay anyone’s bills. Dollars do. A smaller percentage of a substantially larger and healthier business can be worth far more than a larger percentage of a smaller pool.

Matt closes by asking listeners to share how they are currently compensated, what works, what creates problems, and what their ideal compensation system would look like.

Are you chasing elusive automotive problems? Pico Technology empowers you to see what's really happening. Their PicoScope oscilloscopes transform your diagnostic capabilities. PicoAuto.com

From drivability diagnostics and TPMS service to ADAS and advanced safety systems, Autel helps technicians follow OEM procedures and repair with confidence. Autel.com

Contact Information

The Automotive Repair Podcast Network: https://automotiverepairpodcastnetwork.com/

Download and Listen on Our Mobile App: https://automotiverepairpodcastnetwork.com/app/

Remarkable Results Radio Podcast with Carm Capriotto: https://remarkableresults.biz/

Business by the Numbers with Hunt Demarest: https://huntdemarest.captivate.fm/

The Auto Repair Marketing Podcast with Kim and Brian Walker: https://autorepairmarketing.captivate.fm/

The Weekly Blitz with Chris Cotton: https://chriscotton.captivate.fm/

Speak Up! Effective Communication with Craig O'Neill: https://craigoneill.captivate.fm/

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
254. Technician Pay, Profit Sharing, and Trust [E254]
00:36:58
253. How to Start a Career in Auto Repair [E253]
00:28:26
252. It’s Never Too Late to Do the Right Thing: Lessons from YouTube, Jelly Roll and Physics [E252]
00:29:40
251. Reflecting on STX 2026 [E251]
00:27:40
250. The Ethics of a Diagnosis: Navigating System Pressures and Best Practices with Danielle Fanslow[E250]
00:47:08
249. Does Experience Give You Permission to Ignore Service Information? [E249]
00:20:40
248. Automotive Field Theory: Rebranding the Podcast [E248]
00:18:36
247. Why You Can't Motivate Someone Into Training [E247]
00:25:34
246. The Power of Inspiration: From the Mat to the Shop [E246]
00:20:57
245. The Most Controversial Tool in Automotive Electrical Diagnostics [E245]
00:22:45
244. Who Should Pay for Auto Repair Tools? Shop Owner or Employee? [E244]
00:36:36
243. The Danger of Tunnel Vision in Automotive Diagnostics: Anchoring, Confirmation Bias, and Premature Closure [E243]
00:30:32
242. 7.3L Power Stroke ICP Sensor Failure and the AI Skill Atrophy Debate [E242]
00:31:16
241. The Hidden Game Running Your Auto Repair Shop: When Systems Undermine Values [E241]
00:28:53
240. Why Customers Struggle to Trust Auto Repair [E240]
00:22:15
239. From Bogeys to Blown Fuses: Navigating Self-Doubt [E239]
00:26:29
238. Game Theory for Auto Repair Shops: Pricing, Competition, and Strategy [E238]
00:43:11
237. The Targaryen Technician: When Shop Owners Become What They Once Despised [E237]
00:22:55
236. Normalization of Deviance: The Challenger Disaster and How Shop Standards Drift [E236]
00:27:56
235. Corvette Customer Communcation Confusion [E235]
00:29:41
234. Mailbag Episode: From Quantum Physics to Flat Rate Pay Plans [E234]
00:35:29
233. From Smashing Pumpkins to Shop Floors: Lessons on Mentorship [E233]
00:37:50
232. Strength Isn’t What You Think: Lessons on Resilience, Recovery, and Asking for Help [E232]
00:32:24
231. The Mount Rushmore of Automotive Trainers: Legends, Pioneers, and Rising Stars [E231]
00:32:00
230. Wrenching and Recitals: Making Time for Family in the Auto Repair Industry [E230]
00:28:35
229. Deadpool and Chuck Norris [E229]
00:31:17
228. Misuse of the Word Diagnostics [E228]
00:24:08
227. Vision 2026 Recap [E227]
00:19:17
226. Carving Out the Best: Matt Fanslow’s Mount Rushmores [E226]
00:41:43
225. No Good Deed Goes Unpunished [E225]
00:26:27
224. Beyond Cognitive Distortions: Finding Common Ground in Conflict with Margaret Light [E224]
00:57:28
223. Aliasing: Why Your Oscilloscope May Be Lying To You [E223]
00:33:32
222. What Rob McElhenney Taught Me About Shop Management [E222]
00:14:02
221. Mr. Baseball [E221]
00:21:13
220. Bubbles Everywhere: Cavitation and the Cooling System [E220]
00:19:58
219. Common Cause and Special Cause [E219]
00:18:31
218. The Part-Time Performer (And The Full-Time Lesson) [218]
00:22:26
217. A Lesson from Parkway Drive: Diamonds That Choose to Stay Coal [217]
00:14:49
216. What is the Most Misunderstood Concept in Auto Repair? And More: December 2025 Mailbag [E216]
00:33:06
215. Shop Local [E215]
00:20:03
214. When Seconds Matter: CPR at the Thanksgiving Table [E214]
00:30:31
213. No Spoon: Breaking the Matrix [E213]
00:28:48
212. Stop Searching, Start Becoming: The Right Shop Philosophy [E112]
00:17:50
211. Patience with Development [E211]
00:26:03
210. Border Patrol....I Mean Boundary Patrol with Margaret Light [E210]
00:47:27
209. Electrical Myth La Resistance! [E209]
00:17:24
208. "Yo, Adrian!" What We Can Learn From Rocky [E208]
00:21:55
207. I Hope You're Proud of Yourself [E207]
00:33:19
206. Training That Actually Trains with Brandon Steckler & Bob Leonard [E206]
01:01:00
205. Keys, Clones, and Cobra Effects with Mike Maleski [E205]
00:46:00
204. Shop Culture: Having An Attitude As Giddy As a Child [E204]
00:22:41
203. Gauge vs Absolute Confusion [E203]
00:21:35
202. Echo Chambers and Facades [E202]
00:23:10
201. Success vs Time and Relativity [E201]
00:29:25
200. Celebrating 200 Episodes: Insights and Future Paths [E200]
00:26:57
199. Understanding Psychosis: Symptoms, Support and Stigma [E199]
00:54:57
198. Are You Listening to Tom Brady? [E198]
00:25:22
197. Paper Tigers [E197]
00:23:30
196. No One's Anger Starts at 100 [E196]
00:20:04
195. Diagnosing Legends: The Impact of Ozzy Osbourne and Hulk Hogan [E195]
00:30:43
194. What We Can Learn From Jurassic Park [E194]
00:21:26
193. Music, Metal, and Shop Morale [E193]
00:26:29
192. Titan Sub, Challenger, and Data [E192]
00:20:49
191. Why Do We Really Use EGR? [E191]
00:20:58
190. Beyond the Oil Change: What I Learned at the Quick Lube [E190]
00:21:23
189. Analysis of the 2025 WrenchWay Technician Survey [E189]
00:30:06
188. Ubuntu: "I Succeed Because You Succeed." [E188]
00:23:14
187. Mailbag Episode: Exhaust Gas Analyzers, Testing Catalytic Converters, and Troubleshooting ADAS [E187]
00:23:29
186. Reverse Benchmarking: Learning From What Others Do Poorly [E186]
00:19:42
185. The Hidden Advantages of ADHD [E185]
00:22:27
184. Jeepers Creepers [E184]
00:23:02
183. Programming Update [E183]
00:29:08
182. John Thornton Part 2 [E182]
00:51:16
181. John Thornton Part 1 [E181]
00:53:49
180. Mailbag Episode: Multimeters, Electrical Diagnostics and Drivability Tricks [E180]
00:31:32
179. Leadership Lessons From "The Shot" [E179]
00:24:38
178. Automotive Diagnostics, Badgers, and ADAS Calibration [E178]
01:03:07
177. We All Want to Be Special [E177]
00:28:02
176. Pre-VisionKC 2025 Mailbag [E176]
00:25:29
175. Fuel Trims [E175]
00:34:12
174. A Billion Monkeys vs Goals [E174]
00:19:13
173. Ford APIM and Jeep WCM Adventure [E173]
00:21:58
172. Top Online Training Resources for Automotive Technicians [E172]
00:28:14
171. Insights Into Tragedy: Addressing Intimate Partner Homicide [E171]
01:18:35
170. Real Mechanic Reacts: Google's Top Auto Repair Questions [E170]
01:06:27
169. Entertaining My Granddaughter: Learning From Her Movies [E169]
00:21:01
168. Negative Gatekeeping [E168]
00:18:16
167. Auto Repair Tech Talk with Brin Kline [E167]
01:12:30
166. Storytime and Modern Validation [E166]
00:26:03
165. The Job Shadow and the Education Mountain [E165]
00:27:15
164. King Theoden and Being a Leader [E164]
00:30:53
163. What Lies Beneath [E163]
00:19:55
162. A Probing Question [E162]
00:20:18
161. Branding... like Yellowstone [E161]
00:19:46
160. Poker Theory And Automotive Diagnostics With Rich Falco [E160]
00:37:18
159. The Power of Curiosity [E159]
00:22:29
158. Great Expectations with Margaret Light [E158]
01:07:14
157. Geeking Out With The Motor Oil Geek [E157]
00:34:15
156. Integrity, Bias, and The Cobra Effect [E156]
00:22:12
155. Relatively Speaking about Relative Compression [E155]
00:38:51
154. Do You Want a Better Relationship with Clients & Employees? Go to Marriage Counselling! [E154]
00:30:01
153. Rapid Fire Questions with Tracy Capriotto [E153]
00:47:40
152. Diagnosing Truths About Tire Repair: Matt Fanslow Reacts to Consumer Video[E152]
00:14:13
151. Auto Repair Profession and the WNBA vs Caitlin Clark [E151]
00:26:29
150. What Jorge Menchu Taught Me About Diagnostics [E150]
00:27:35
149. Mailbag: Should I Put In A Two Weeks Notice? [E149]
00:22:53
148. Old Yeller and the Aging Mechanical Specialist [E148]
00:27:25
147. Sweat Equity with Bryan Pollock [E147]
00:54:51
146. Social Constructs...Game Theory...and Auto Repair [E146]
00:25:46
145. Matt Fanslow's Top Labscopes [E145]
00:32:45
144. Just Fly the Darn Aircraft - Period! [E144]
00:28:56
143. Can't We All Just Get Along? With Tanner Brandt [E143]
01:14:17
142. Are You Using DTCs to Diagnose Vehicles? [E142]
00:25:03
141. Rebounding After Failure [E141]
00:32:03
140. Tool Dealer Quid Pro Quo [E140]
00:19:27
139. The Perfect Marriage of Content and Instructor [E139]
00:39:00
138. Just Be Honest [E138]
00:23:27
137. Bill Walton [E137]
00:23:38
136. Key Questions with Elijah McMillan [E136]
01:10:58
135. Zero Sum and Pro Wrestling [E135]
00:23:57
134. The Sport of Auto Repair with Chris Jones [E134]
01:09:56
133. How Does Pornography Impact Individuals and Relationships? [E133]
01:06:38
132. How To: Talk to Kids About Careers in Automotive [E132]
00:28:23
131. Are We Setting Barometers? [E131]
00:23:36
130. That EVIL Word: Profit [E130]
00:19:02
129. Lock Labs, AutoProPad, and NASTF with Mo Ali [E129]
01:05:00
128. Gaming and Auto Repair...and Life [E128]
00:26:16
127. What Makes For a Great Class with Sean Tipping [E127]
01:19:55
126. We REALLY Need to Talk About Electricity [E126]
00:36:44
125. How Dating and Running a Shop Are Very Similar [E125]
00:23:17
124. Reflections on Vision Hi-Tech Training & Expo 2024 [E124]
00:27:56
123. Get the Most Out of Vision Hi-Tech Training and Expo - With Tanner Brandt [E123]
01:11:50
122. "Ask Us Anything" Webinar with Justin Morgan [E122]
00:54:08
121. NASTF, VSP, SDRM with Donny Seyfer [E121]
01:10:28
120. What We Can Learn From Mrs. Doubtfire [E120]
00:23:20
119. Mailbag: Why Won't My Techs Go To Training? [E119]
00:19:13
118. Aircraft Repair vs Automotive Repair with Bryan and Alicia Pollock [E118]
01:12:30
117. Ambition vs Greed [E117]
00:20:48
116. Good Grief with Margaret Light [E116]
01:00:05
115. The Dreaded 4AM Phone Call: Family Emergency [E115]
00:50:49
114. Are Benchmarks BS? [E114]
01:06:03
113. Jim Linder In Memoriam [E113]
00:31:20
112. Professionalism...And Maybe a Movie Reference [E112]
00:30:51
111. The Ripple Effect of Recognition: Lessons from Bill Hader [E111]
00:17:49
110. Matt’s Mailbag: Hiring Bonuses, Flat Rate Pay and Building a Network of Friends [E110]
00:36:52
109. Exploring Relationships, Health, and Personal Growth with Bob Heipp [E109]
00:40:31
108. Batteries, Diag Pay and Gwar, Oh My! [E108]
00:57:18
107. Psychology of Refusal to Evolve with Bryan Pollock [E107]
01:05:09
106. Kitchen Nightmares with Carm Capriotto [E106]
00:43:51
105. ASE Renewal App Rant [E105]
00:24:53
104. PSA: My Facebook Account was Hacked [E104]
00:26:25
103. Shame with Margaret Light [E103]
00:57:28
102. Opportunity Cost/Loss [E102]
00:20:43
101. Chad Austin: Get Your A/C and Diag Mojo Going! [E101]
01:29:46
100. 100th Episode with Justin Morgan and Pedro de la Torre [E100]
01:03:37
99. Legacy for Auto Repair Professionals [E099]
00:24:14
98. Thinking About Getting Into ADAS? with Andrew Gonyou [E098]
00:49:48
97. He Quit!!! with Collin Draker [E097]
00:58:12
96. Unintended Consequences: The Impact of Over Reliance on Databases and AI [E096]
00:24:38
95. Shop Foreman Frustrations with Bryan Pollack, Sean Tipping, and Matthew Skundrich [E095]
01:30:58
94. Scan Tool Webinar Live with Matt Fanslow, Keith Perkins, Tanner Brandt and Richard Falco [E094]
01:44:51
93. Compare "The Bear" with Carm Capriotto [E093]
00:57:26
92. Diagnostics From the Desk Chair [E092]
00:25:57
91. Another ASE Rant [E091]
00:18:08
90. Motivation [E090]
00:25:20
89. Shop Growing Pains with Nooh Alhamad [E089]
00:35:40
88. Unexpected Financial Surprises [E088]
00:24:05
87. Module Bricking and Other Musings with Sean Tipping [E087]
00:57:42
86. Matt Fanslow's Top 5 Scan Tool List [E086]
00:24:52
85. Improving Our Process(es) [E085]
00:28:06
84. Career Transition with Glen Forehand [E084]
01:06:19
83. Programming Q&A with Glen Forehand [E083]
01:00:08
82. Charging for Diagnostic Time or Charging for Training Time? [E082]
01:28:10
81. Dating Isn't Emotional Rehab with Margaret Light [E081]
01:11:09
80. Flat Out with the Flat Rate Master Mike Berg [E080]
00:38:44
79. "Skydiving and Diagnostics, But Not at the Same Time" with Keith Perkins [E079]
00:55:33
78. Industry Cynicism with Zack McClain and Jeff Barnes [E078]
01:01:57
77. Internet Access with Tanner Brandt [E077]
00:52:03
76. The Benefit(s) of Fads [E076]
00:27:03
75. Remembering Steve Brotherton with Seth Thorson [E075]
00:41:23
74. What is a Master Technician? With Bryan Pollack and Paul 'Scanner' Danner [E074]
01:13:02
73. Thoughts Culminated from the Last Couple Weeks [E073]
00:44:10
72. Economics and Statistics with Hunt Demarest [E072]
01:28:49
71. Being a Black Technician: The Eric Dallas Story [E071]
00:57:51
70. Luck, Egocentric Bias, Gratitude (Luck Part Deux) [E070]
00:17:39
69. Contribution of Luck to Success [E069]
00:35:19
68. From the Female Technician Perspective with Meg Lewis [E068]
00:50:11
67. Scattered Ideas with Richard Falco [E067]
00:55:53
66. Skynet [ChatGPT] in Auto Repair with Sean Tipping [E066]
00:58:21
65. Sunday Sports [E065]
00:21:06
64. 2023 Outlook [E064]
00:18:43
63. The Godfather Movie with Carm and Tracy Capriotto [E063]
00:49:34
62. Analyzing Inductors with Pico 7 [E062]
00:26:54
61. Coffee Talk with Dutch Silverstein [E061]
00:46:52
60. Uncovering Unsung Peers (and Heroes) with Tanner Brandt [E060]
01:12:46
59. Overclaiming [E059]
00:14:09
58. Relationships 101 with Margaret Light [E058]
00:53:52
57. The Lead Technician with Jeff Barnes [E057]
00:53:55
56. Stories of Forgiveness with Bryan Pollock and Paul Danner [E056]
01:05:58
55. Time [E055]
00:27:36
54. Thermal Imaging Cameras with Tanner Brandt [E054]
00:54:05
53. What Does It Take To Become An Expert? [E053]
00:22:55
52. What We Can Learn from Kid Poker [E052]
00:29:12
51. The Scoop on Scopes with Haakan Light [E051]
01:25:40
50. There is a Dr. in the House with Dr. Jamie Jackish [E050]
00:57:06
49. Automotive Technician Suicide with Margaret Light [E049]
00:51:45
48. Employee Motivation with Sean Tipping [E048]
00:55:33
47. Benefits To and From Hiring Veterans with Scott Shotton and Brandon Dills [E047]
00:55:39
46. Dutch Silverstein - Straight Talk to Technicians - Part 2 [E046]
01:14:39
45. URABUS or SUBARU - Forward or Backward with Pedro de La Torre [E045]
00:54:03
44. Control What You Can Control with Haakan Light [E044]
00:42:48
43. Technican Pay, Tools and Taxes with Hunt Demarest [E043]
00:52:38
42. Matt With Lester Kovacs from Dorman at NAPA Expo [E042]
00:37:26
41. Why Aren't We Mimicking Other Skilled Trades for Apprentices [E041]
00:20:46
40. Keyed Up About the Keys to Key with Andrew Sexton [E040]
01:10:02
39. Technicians Communicating With Clients [E039]
00:22:32
38. Economics with Dr. Joshua Rosenbloom [E038]
00:56:28
37. Observations from a Family Vacations [E037]
00:29:52
36. Over Romanticizing the Diagnostic Process with Paul Danner [E036]
01:11:32
35. Overcoming the Loss of a Child: Finding a Silver Lining [E035]
00:47:02
34. Flashlight Diagnostics with Tanner Brandt [E034]
00:59:50
33. With Sean Medbury on Jiu-Jitsu [E033]
00:46:50
32. Are You Positive Deviant? [E032]
00:27:34
31. Do You Show Appreciation With Acknowledgement? With Brin Kline [E031]
00:49:09
30. Kung Fu Hustle with Justin Morgan [E030]
01:11:21
29. Jim Kemper on Catalytic Converters [E029]
01:14:54
28. The Myth About Rock Bottom: Diagnosis of Substance Use Disorder (SUB) with Danielle Fanslow [E028]
01:44:04
27. What You Can Learn From Professional Wrestling - Part 2 with Andrew Fischer [E027]
01:25:01
26. Building and Managing Your Training Collection [E026]
00:56:45
25. Divorce Discourse with Brandon Steckler [E025]
02:03:27
24. Lessons from the Karate Kid's Bonsai Tree [E024]
00:18:48
23. Zero Turn Mowers - What Can We Learn [E023]
00:15:44
22. Circuit Loading With Sean Tipping - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E022]
01:16:46
21. When You are the Owner, Nobody Stops You From Making Bad Decisions - Nathan Bryant [E021]
00:55:07
20. Follow the Money - Inspiration from Mike Rowe [E020]
00:16:02
19. What Does a Great Steak Restaurant and Auto Repair Have in Common? [E019]
00:27:37
18. Dutch Silverstein - Straight Talk to Technicians [E018]
01:27:49
17. Wife, Mother, Diagnostician, Co-Owner - Liz Perkins [E017]
00:59:54
16. The Personal Side of Paul 'Scanner' Danner [E016]
01:15:30
15. Do We Do Enough Exit Interviews? [E015]
00:19:19
14. What Drives You to Be the Best You Can Be - With Justin Morgan [E014]
01:18:55
13. Scott Alton - From a Clients Point of View [E013]
01:20:15
12. What Didn't We Talk About! with Chris Cloutier [E012]
01:22:49
11. Mental Health with Haakan Light - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A - Z [E011]
01:05:39
10. Out of Nowhere - Pistol Pete Marravich - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E010]
00:21:44
9. Observation From a Class I Presented - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E009]
00:15:38
8. Pickpockets and Magicians - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E008]
00:23:15
7. The Road to Redemption from Substance Use Disorder with Danielle Fanslow Part 1 [007]
01:16:24
6. Electrical Theory, Talk and Myths - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E006]
01:22:06
5. What a Shop Owner Can Learn From Metallica - Matt Fanslow - Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E005]
00:27:21
4. New Technology Coming to Our Bays - Matt Fanslow Diagnosing the Aftermarket A to Z [E004]
00:20:45
2. Matt Used an Ohmmeter - Oh My! - with Guest Sean Tipping [E002]
01:00:22
1. Matt Fanslow Podcast Launch - Episode 1 with Carm Capriotto [E001]
00:30:34
3. Buyer Beware. My Learning Curve With a Marketplace Purchase [E003]
00:15:38