Artwork for podcast Now What Therapy
The Unsexy Part of Change
1st September 2026 • Now What Therapy • Amy Neufeld
00:00:00 00:07:52

Share Episode

Shownotes

In This Episode

There’s a very unsexy part of behavior change that matters more than we give it credit for: consistency.

In this episode, I’m talking about what it actually looks like to rebuild a habit after you’ve fallen out of a routine, why something that used to feel automatic can suddenly take so much effort again, and why that effort doesn’t mean you’re failing.

We’ll talk about:

  • why consistency matters more than a perfect fresh start
  • the difference between knowing how to do something and having it built into your life
  • why new habits require so much conscious effort at first
  • why missing once does not mean you’ve lost the habit
  • how to come back without shame, drama, or waiting until Monday
  • what it feels like when a behavior finally starts becoming automatic again

Your Now What

Pick one habit or pattern you’re trying to build right now.

Instead of asking yourself, “Why isn’t this easier yet?” ask:

What would make it easier for me to keep coming back to this?

Because consistency is not never missing.

It’s returning.

Stay Connected With Amy

Instagram: @amyneufeldtherapy

Website: [email protected]

Keywords

habit change, behavior change, consistency, building habits, creating routines, how to build habits, getting back on track, sustainable habits, motivation, healthy routines, self-compassion, personal growth, behavior patterns

I like this much better for the episode than the first version because it gives people enough to know exactly what they’re getting without basically handing them the whole podcast in the show notes.

Transcripts

There's a very unsexy part of behavior change that I know we all know matters, but I really don't think we give it nearly enough credit. We love the new plan or the fresh start or the new beautiful workout clothes, but the thing that actually turns a behavior into a pattern, it is a whole lot less exciting.

I have three alarms set for Pilates. Three. And they are all two minutes apart. So basically every two minutes my phone becomes an increasingly annoying mother standing in my room. And it just screams at me like Amy, get up. And then two minutes later, Amy, seriously, get up. And then, yep, one more time, Amy, get out of bed, young lady.

For a long time, 6 a.m. Pilates, it was just a part of my life. I went. I didn't have to make some giant decision about it every morning. I didn't have to motivate myself or have a conversation with myself about whether I felt like going or not. It's just what I did. And then I got a little hurt and I got out of my routine and I started staying up late. And then little by little, something that had been completely habitual for me, it just wasn't anymore.

so I had to build it back. And yeah, there was some muscle memory there. Ha, no pun intended. I knew how to do Pilates. That wasn't the problem.

I had to rebuild the habit of being someone who gets up early, like really early, and go to Pilates. And that's a really important distinction because because sometimes we've done something before and we think that it means it should be super easy to start doing it again. I used to work out all the time, or I used to I used to have a decent bedtime or cook dinner at home every night, or I used to be good at staying in touch with my friends, or I used to read a lot, or whatever the thing is.

And when it doesn't immediately fall back into place, we're confused. Or worse, we start criticizing ourselves. Why can't I just do this?

knowing how to do something, it's different from having it built into the rhythm of your life. When I was trying to get back into my Pilates routine,

I had to be really deliberate about it. I went at the same time, I set my ridiculous three alarms, I got my stuff ready the night before. Then I kept doing the same basic sequence over and over and over and over and over again, which is really not very exciting.

There's a very

unsexy part of behavior change that I know we all know matters, but I really don't think we give it nearly enough credit. We love the new plan or the fresh start or the new beautiful workout clothes, but the thing that actually turns a behavior into a pattern, it is a whole lot less exciting.

It's consistency. You do it and then you do it again and then you do it again. And at first it takes a lot of thought.

You have to remember and you have to plan and you may have to talk yourself into it sometimes. You might, like me, have to literally set three alarms because it's not automatic yet. think about anything you do now without much thought.

Brushing your teeth or making coffee or putting on your seatbelt. I don't know, whatever your normal routine looks like. You probably don't wake up every morning and think, all right, I really need to find the motivation to brush my teeth today. No, it's just built in. But new behaviors aren't built in yet. They require more attention or more effort. They require more conscious decision making.

I think sometimes we interpret that effort as a problem. Like, why is this still taking so much work? When actually the fact that you're still having to think about it, it just might mean you're still in the part where you're building it. You're practicing the pattern. And also, if you want something to actually become the habit that you're after, you have to be able to mess up sometimes without immediately turning on yourself. I overslept one morning this week. I miss Pilates. And I didn't

beat the crap out of myself over it. I overslept. I missed Pilates and that was it. Consistency is crucial, but consistency is not the same thing as never missing. You can be consistent and occasionally miss.

You can be building a habit and have a weird week or stay up too late or get sick or go on vacation or have your kidney Jew or whatever comes at you in life. You can't create such a fragile routine that one missed day or one missed whatever destroys the whole thing.

Actually, that's probably a good test of whether you're building something sustainable. Can you miss one day and just come back? Come back without kicking yourself and come back without drama. No giant restart or waiting until Monday. You just you just come back. You know how I knew I was really back in it, back in my whole Pilates routine, like the locked and loaded, back in the game

routine? I missed a class. And I was bummed. Not bummed at myself. Not like, my God, I suck. No, there was no shame involved. I was just bummed because I actually missed it and I wanted to be there. And I got the feeling like, ugh, I missed something. Something didn't feel right in my day.

That's where I knew this is part of my life again. I am getting back into my stride. the thing that had required so much conscious effort to put back into my life was starting to feel like part of my life again.

I wasn't just making myself go. I was becoming someone who just goes. I just was going again. And I think that's what we're looking for when we're trying to change something. Not perfection. Never perfection.

Not some day when you wake up incredibly motivated and never struggle again. you're just trying to repeat a behavior enough that it starts requiring a little less thought, a little less negotiation and a little less effort

until eventually it starts to feel normal or becomes the habit that you're wanting it to be. and this applies to so much more than exercise. maybe you're trying to stop scrolling at night or eat breakfast every morning. Or maybe you want to go outside every day

maybe you want to call people instead of realizing three months have gone by and you've talked to like nobody. Or maybe you're trying to respond differently when you're upset. Or you're learning to pause before you say yes to something you didn't actually want to. These all are very personal to me. But you must have your own list on something that you want to set in as a pattern. All of those are patterns. And at first, the new response is probably going to feel awkward.

You're going to have to remember it. You're going to have to catch yourself and you're going to have to do it on purpose because it's not a built-in pattern yet. It hasn't become habitual. All of that conscious effort, that is how it becomes a pattern. So now what? Okay. Now what? If you are trying to build a habit or change a pattern or just be a little more conscious about how you're moving through your day, consistency matters. You got to do the thing and you got to do it again.

And you gotta do it again and again. But but but when you miss, because you will, cut yourself some slack. Actually, you know what? Cut yourself some slack in general. Always let that be the rule.

Be consistent without expecting yourself to be perfect. And when you get off track, don't turn it into some giant story about what it says about you.

Okay, you got this, stay curious and I will be back next week.

Links

Chapters

Video

More from YouTube

More Episodes
The Unsexy Part of Change
00:07:52
No Phone Zone: What We're Missing
00:08:38
What Do You Actually Want? How to Start Investing in Yourself
00:08:39
Parenting Adult Children: How to Stop Missing Who They Were and See Who They Are Now
00:08:33
The Lie We Tell Ourselves: "I'll Start When I'm Ready"
00:10:23
If the Scale Is Making You Feel Worthless, Listen to This.
00:06:47
The Three Words that Will Make Life Easier: Don't Quit. Adjust.
00:08:44
Are You Easygoing… Or Are You Ignoring Yourself?
00:10:32
Not Losing Weight on a GLP-1? Here's What Nobody Is Telling You
00:07:25
Helping Your Kids Live in a World with Mean Girls
00:09:56
How to Stop Feeling Like You're Doing Summer Wrong
00:10:07
How to Truly Save a Moment Forever
00:11:13
Why Some Apologies Make You Feel Worse
00:14:42
The Truth About Anger That Nobody Talks About...
00:08:07
How to Make the Greatest Comeback of Your Life (That Actually Lasts)
00:12:22
The Part of Motherhood No One Warns You About
00:17:09
How to Make Your Marriage Happier and Healthier- What Most Couples' Therapists Won't Tell You.
00:34:55
Why Self-Care Isn’t Working: The Difference Between Relief and Real Emotional Repair
00:29:06
7. The Parenting Mistake That’s Creating Anxious Kids
00:39:33
6. Why It’s So Hard to Make Friends (And What to Do About It) Part 3- Did the Advice Work?
00:31:53
5. Why Is It So Hard to Make Friends? Part 2 The Hidden Patterns Sabotaging Your Relationships
00:29:39
4. Why is it so Hard to Make Friends? PART 1 -Your Patterns
00:43:25
3. Why Do You Keep Putting Things Off? Procrastination: What it REALLY is, and What You Can REALLY do About it
00:47:17
2. The Hidden Danger of Betrayal: The Story Your Brain Creates
00:35:34
1. The Mistake We're All Making with Chat GPT
00:22:32