Speaker:
00:00:01
Welcome to Voices of NCAJ.
Speaker:
00:00:03
We're talking to members of the North
Carolina Advocates for Justice about what
Speaker:
00:00:07
it means to be a trial lawyer, what it
takes to be great at the practice of law,
Speaker:
00:00:11
and how being a part of NCAJ
enriches their lives and careers.
Speaker:
00:00:16
Produced and powered by LawPods.
Speaker:
00:00:22
Welcome everyone to Voices of NCAJ,
Speaker:
00:00:25
the podcast for the North Carolina
Advocates for Justice. I am Amber Nimocks,
Speaker:
00:00:30
your host and director of
external affairs for NCAJ.
Speaker:
00:00:34
Before we get started,
Speaker:
00:00:35
I'd like to thank our circle of leadership
members for supporting NCAJ's mission
Speaker:
00:00:40
and this podcast. If
you're watching on YouTube,
Speaker:
00:00:43
you can see a list of Circle of Leadership
firms at the end of the podcast.
Speaker:
00:00:47
To find out how your firm can join
the circle, go to ncaj.com/circle.
Speaker:
00:00:53
My guest today is Zack Kaplan.
Speaker:
00:00:55
He's an associate attorney at the
Raleigh Firm of Ballew Puryear,
Speaker:
00:00:59
where his practice focuses on state
and federal constitutional claims,
Speaker:
00:01:03
police and prison misconduct,
and appellate litigation.
Speaker:
00:01:07
He is also co-chair of NCAJ's
Law School Outreach Committee and
Speaker:
00:01:12
program co-chair of the
CLE, Overcoming Immunity:
Speaker:
00:01:16
Pro Tips for Success in
Civil Rights Litigation.
Speaker:
00:01:20
That program is coming up on
January 29 at NCAJ headquarters in
Speaker:
00:01:25
Raleigh.
And if you want to attend,
Speaker:
00:01:27
you can register for it or any of the
other terrific CLEs we have coming up in
Speaker:
00:01:32
January and February at ncaj.com/events.
Speaker:
00:01:37
Zack, welcome to the podcast.
Speaker:
00:01:38
Thank you very much. Amber, happy New
Year. And I'm a longtime listener,
Speaker:
00:01:42
first time caller, as they say,
Speaker:
00:01:44
so I'm excited to chat a bit and to talk
specifically about our upcoming CLE.
Speaker:
00:01:49
Great. Well, I'm so glad to know you
listened to the podcast. That's awesome.
Speaker:
00:01:54
So before we get into the CLE,
Speaker:
00:01:57
I'd love to know a little bit about you.
Speaker:
00:02:01
I know that you're one
of our NEXT fellows,
Speaker:
00:02:04
so somewhat familiar
with you and your bio.
Speaker:
00:02:09
And I know that lawyer
was not your first career.
Speaker:
00:02:13
You spent some time in the classroom
before you headed to law school.
Speaker:
00:02:18
What influenced your decision
to become a teacher first?
Speaker:
00:02:21
Yeah, that's right.
Speaker:
00:02:22
I was a fifth grade teacher at a public
school in East Durham for three years in
Speaker:
00:02:27
between college and when I went to
law school and then became a lawyer.
Speaker:
00:02:32
And I loved it. In a
lot of ways, I miss it.
Speaker:
00:02:35
And I think that it will
end up being, in some ways,
Speaker:
00:02:38
my best and most challenging
job of my career I
Speaker:
00:02:42
anticipate. But yeah, in
terms of how I got into it,
Speaker:
00:02:46
it was really while I was in college,
Speaker:
00:02:49
I went to UNC Chapel Hill
and my scholarship program
Speaker:
00:02:53
required all of the students
to do between 10 and 15
Speaker:
00:02:58
hours a week of work at a
local community partner.
Speaker:
00:03:03
And so I served for all four of
my years as a sort of community
Speaker:
00:03:08
organizer in two different historically
black communities in Chapel Hill in the
Speaker:
00:03:12
north side in Rogers Road,
Speaker:
00:03:15
the neighborhoods are called. And part
of my work there was being a tutor for
Speaker:
00:03:18
elementary school students
and middle school students.
Speaker:
00:03:21
And over the course of my years there,
Speaker:
00:03:25
I kind of had a practical
insight and then a more
Speaker:
00:03:30
theoretical insight.
Speaker:
00:03:31
The practical insight was that I just
loved working with young people and
Speaker:
00:03:35
engaging with students.
Speaker:
00:03:37
And I found that to be a really
challenging, like I said,
Speaker:
00:03:41
but enjoyable and meaningful way
to spend my time and my energy.
Speaker:
00:03:46
And so I knew that I was drawn
to the classroom for that reason.
Speaker:
00:03:50
But then sort of on a
more theoretical level,
Speaker:
00:03:53
I really came to
understand public education
Speaker:
00:03:58
as a bedrock,
Speaker:
00:04:00
this kind of foundational principle
for building a multiracial democracy.
Speaker:
00:04:04
And I knew that I wanted to
do work that had that sort of
Speaker:
00:04:09
civil rights bend.
Speaker:
00:04:11
And so I had in the back of my
mind that one day I might more
Speaker:
00:04:16
look into the policy
world or the law world,
Speaker:
00:04:19
but at least at the
beginning of my career,
Speaker:
00:04:22
I knew that I didn't want to get
into policy or get into law or
Speaker:
00:04:27
governance or anything like that without
having first had some significant
Speaker:
00:04:31
classroom experience and kind
of that boots on the ground,
Speaker:
00:04:34
ground level experience. Like I said,
I really enjoyed my time as a teacher.
Speaker:
00:04:39
I miss it today. Working
with adults is great,
Speaker:
00:04:42
but it's in a lot of ways less exciting
and less dynamic than working with 10
Speaker:
00:04:47
year olds every day.
Speaker:
00:04:48
And I hope sometime a little bit further
down the road in my career to get back
Speaker:
00:04:53
into the teaching world
one way or another.
Speaker:
00:04:55
That's such a great age, that
late elementary school age,
Speaker:
00:05:00
you can really see their
brains start to sort of pop.
Speaker:
00:05:04
That's right. And the school that I
taught at was actually K through eight.
Speaker:
00:05:08
And so we were really fifth grade
with really this transition year where
Speaker:
00:05:13
you were on the older side of elementary
school and on the younger side of
Speaker:
00:05:17
middle school.
Speaker:
00:05:18
And we definitely saw a lot of
transition in that fifth grade year.
Speaker:
00:05:22
And actually, I live in Durham still,
Speaker:
00:05:25
and I've lived there for a
little over 10 years now.
Speaker:
00:05:27
And so I still run into former students
of mine all the time. They are now,
Speaker:
00:05:31
they have graduated from high school
and most of them are college age.
Speaker:
00:05:35
So if they still live or work
around town, every once in a while,
Speaker:
00:05:39
I'll hear a Mr. Kaplan and there's only
a select group of people that call me
Speaker:
00:05:43
Mr. Kaplan. So I know that it must be one.
Speaker:
00:05:45
Of them. Oh, that's great. That's great.
Speaker:
00:05:48
So you knew you wanted to
do something policy related,
Speaker:
00:05:51
but was there a certain circumstance
or a certain event that moved you
Speaker:
00:05:55
towards the legal profession?
Speaker:
00:05:59
As with any big kind of
life or career transition,
Speaker:
00:06:02
there's a lot of kind of factors
that went into it and the
Speaker:
00:06:07
timing and everything. But honestly,
Speaker:
00:06:09
I would say if I had to
give a one word answer,
Speaker:
00:06:12
it would be Leandro,
Speaker:
00:06:14
which is the major education
litigation in North Carolina that's
Speaker:
00:06:19
been going on for well over 30 years
now, or almost 30 years now, I suppose,
Speaker:
00:06:25
and is a long running
lawsuit where a group of
Speaker:
00:06:30
marginalized students and families
or students and families from
Speaker:
00:06:34
marginalized school districts and
counties are seeking to enforce their
Speaker:
00:06:39
constitutional right to a sound basic
education against the state under the
Speaker:
00:06:44
provision involving education
in our Carolina Constitution.
Speaker:
00:06:48
And I would say it was about my
second year in the classroom when I
Speaker:
00:06:53
kind of had my feet on the ground enough
and knew my bearings enough to start
Speaker:
00:06:58
learning more about the education
law and policy world. And Leandro was
Speaker:
00:07:03
something that kept on coming
up. I would read articles,
Speaker:
00:07:06
I would see people speaking about it,
Speaker:
00:07:08
I would see in the news occasionally if
there was something going on with the
Speaker:
00:07:11
litigation.
Speaker:
00:07:12
And I was just exceptionally
curious about what this
Speaker:
00:07:17
was.
Speaker:
00:07:18
And I didn't even know that there was
a constitutional right to a free public
Speaker:
00:07:23
education under our North
Carolina constitution.
Speaker:
00:07:26
And the more I dug into
it, the more it really,
Speaker:
00:07:30
that mission and that purpose
really resonated with me.
Speaker:
00:07:34
And I started talking to some folks
who were either involved in advocacy or
Speaker:
00:07:38
involved in the litigation itself, and
of course, many of them were lawyers.
Speaker:
00:07:43
And so I began to see a
clearer pathway towards,
Speaker:
00:07:48
okay,
Speaker:
00:07:48
maybe this is a different angle at
which I can kind of approach this same
Speaker:
00:07:53
civil rights issue.
Speaker:
00:07:56
And so how you began to be drawn
towards civil rights as a focus
Speaker:
00:08:01
for your practice?
Speaker:
00:08:02
Yeah, that was definitely one of
the elements. It's interesting.
Speaker:
00:08:06
And we just finished up with the holiday
season and now moving into the new
Speaker:
00:08:10
year.
Speaker:
00:08:11
So it's a perfect time to kind
of reflect on kind of the path
Speaker:
00:08:16
behind and the path ahead. And
like so many people, I really,
Speaker:
00:08:20
when I look back at my career
path in some ways, my life,
Speaker:
00:08:25
there's this mysterious alchemy
to it in a lot of ways where
Speaker:
00:08:30
on the one hand you can see
certain elements very clearly that
Speaker:
00:08:35
one led to two, led to three, and
now I'm here. But on the other hand,
Speaker:
00:08:39
there's also some instances of
right time and right place and
Speaker:
00:08:45
kind of a sense of the
pieces falling into place.
Speaker:
00:08:48
And so when I think about my
trajectory becoming a civil
Speaker:
00:08:53
rights lawyer, it's a little bit of that.
Speaker:
00:08:56
There are definitely some elements
that stand out in my experience in the
Speaker:
00:09:00
classroom and my experience as a community
organizer before the classroom is
Speaker:
00:09:04
definitely one of them.
I also think that from
Speaker:
00:09:09
a very early age,
Speaker:
00:09:11
there were a couple of things that
kind of pointed me in that direction.
Speaker:
00:09:14
One is faith.
Speaker:
00:09:16
I am Jewish and one of
the kind of key pillars or
Speaker:
00:09:21
principles in Judaism,
it's called Tikkun Olam,
Speaker:
00:09:24
and it means repairing the world.
And it kind of, to me at least,
Speaker:
00:09:29
it means that everybody
has an obligation to do
Speaker:
00:09:34
what they can to improve their community.
Speaker:
00:09:38
It's not just about volunteering,
Speaker:
00:09:42
picking up trash on the side
of the road once a year,
Speaker:
00:09:45
although that can be
one way of contributing.
Speaker:
00:09:47
It's about really finding
what your lane is,
Speaker:
00:09:52
that kind of intersection of your passion
and your skills and seeing what you
Speaker:
00:09:56
can do to contribute in your community.
Speaker:
00:09:58
And so that was always a part of
my very much encouraged part of my
Speaker:
00:10:03
upbringing, trying to find that angle.
And another thing that I think
Speaker:
00:10:08
maybe everybody in NCAJ
will have in common is
Speaker:
00:10:14
I just have a sort of
intrinsic commitment to
Speaker:
00:10:20
standing up for the little guy.
Speaker:
00:10:22
I just have always had a sense of
injustice and things that appear fair or
Speaker:
00:10:26
unfair. I'm also a middle child,
so that might play into it as well.
Speaker:
00:10:31
But like I said, I think in some
ways everybody in NCAJ is like that.
Speaker:
00:10:35
I don't know if I've met anybody in our
organization who doesn't feel some type
Speaker:
00:10:39
of way about somebody who
for one reason or another is
Speaker:
00:10:44
marginalized,
Speaker:
00:10:45
going up against some
big institutional power.
Speaker:
00:10:51
And so in that way, I
think really everybody,
Speaker:
00:10:53
obviously the folks in the
civil rights section like me,
Speaker:
00:10:56
we have particular types of constitutional
rights that we're often litigating in
Speaker:
00:11:01
Section 1983 and all
that. But more broadly,
Speaker:
00:11:05
I really think that everybody in NCAJ is
a civil rights lawyer. And I mentioned
Speaker:
00:11:10
that I listened to the podcast.
I recently listened, for example,
Speaker:
00:11:13
to your episode with Karma Henson,
Speaker:
00:11:16
and I would challenge anybody
to listen to Karma talk
Speaker:
00:11:21
about her work in nursing home
litigation and say that she is
Speaker:
00:11:26
not a civil rights lawyer or a
civil rights advocate. I mean,
Speaker:
00:11:30
that work is not Section
:
1983
Speaker:
00:11:35
but that to me, writ large, that's what
civil rights litigation is all about.
Speaker:
00:11:39
And so there's been
elements of all of that,
Speaker:
00:11:42
including my time as a teacher that
have kind of brought me to where I am.
Speaker:
00:11:48
Yeah. That is interesting to hear you
say because when I try to tell people,
Speaker:
00:11:53
we were talking before we
got onto the recording about
Speaker:
00:11:58
trying to explain to my son what I do,
Speaker:
00:12:02
it's not until you become sort
of older and begin to understand
Speaker:
00:12:07
the civil justice system as you become
more sophisticated in your understanding
Speaker:
00:12:11
that you do realize that fighting on
behalf of the individual against the
Speaker:
00:12:16
system, whether or not it is
Speaker:
00:12:19
in a traditionally understood civil
rights way or just in human rights
Speaker:
00:12:24
way, just for justice for the
individual against who has been wronged,
Speaker:
00:12:29
who has had their rights violated,
Speaker:
00:12:33
that is the bedrock of what we do.
Speaker:
00:12:35
That's pretty much we have just come
through the holidays and you go to parties
Speaker:
00:12:39
and be, "What do you do?
Speaker:
00:12:40
" So I'm the communications director for
this group of people and this group of
Speaker:
00:12:45
people does this. And when you put
it that way, people go, "Huh, okay.
Speaker:
00:12:50
All right.".
Speaker:
00:12:50
Yeah. And I think that, like I said,
Speaker:
00:12:54
writ large,
Speaker:
00:12:56
it's about standing up
for and advocating for the
Speaker:
00:13:02
little person, the David
versus the Goliath, right?
Speaker:
00:13:05
The marginalized person or community
against this system of power,
Speaker:
00:13:09
whether it's the state, an insurance
company, a police force, a jail,
Speaker:
00:13:12
an employer, the government.
And something that I have found,
Speaker:
00:13:16
you mentioned our work with the
law school outreach committee,
Speaker:
00:13:20
something that I found through
connecting with law students,
Speaker:
00:13:23
and that is true of my own experience,
Speaker:
00:13:24
is that there's such a pull now
more than ever in law schools,
Speaker:
00:13:29
there's such a pull towards big law,
Speaker:
00:13:31
towards large corporate
insurance defense law firms that
Speaker:
00:13:36
anybody who finds their
way into this profession,
Speaker:
00:13:40
it's highly unlikely that they just
kind of stumbled their way into it.
Speaker:
00:13:44
So it tends to really draw people who,
Speaker:
00:13:49
like Karma or like Sam, who I
know you had on recently, I mean,
Speaker:
00:13:52
like so many others, and
my colleagues at NCAJ NEXT,
Speaker:
00:13:56
it tends to draw in people
who really have some type of
Speaker:
00:14:01
chip on their shoulder about advocating
for folks who have been marginalized and
Speaker:
00:14:06
kind of standing up to some
of that institutional power.
Speaker:
00:14:09
You know,
Speaker:
00:14:09
that's one of our challenges as an
organization at the law school level
Speaker:
00:14:14
is trying to make sure that
we educate and spread the
Speaker:
00:14:19
word about the fact because
you're looking law school and
Speaker:
00:14:24
you've just incurred a great deal of debt.
Speaker:
00:14:26
And so often the path is that
you feel like you have to go
Speaker:
00:14:32
work for insurance or as an
insurance defense litigator in
Speaker:
00:14:37
order to do that. And you don't even ...
Speaker:
00:14:40
Presenting law students with
the option of going into
Speaker:
00:14:45
plaintiff's work first and
making sure they know that that's
Speaker:
00:14:50
even an option is really important.
Speaker:
00:14:52
That's right.
Speaker:
00:14:53
Because big law is out there.
Speaker:
00:14:56
It's not only out there,
Speaker:
00:14:58
it is increasingly
recruiting and signing up
Speaker:
00:15:03
students earlier and earlier and earlier
in your law school career, including,
Speaker:
00:15:07
by the way, like now,
Speaker:
00:15:09
like January of your 1L year,
Speaker:
00:15:13
your first year of law school.
Speaker:
00:15:14
I was in touch in the last couple of
weeks with law students at a couple of
Speaker:
00:15:18
different North Carolina law schools
who are in the middle of interviews,
Speaker:
00:15:22
not only for positions this coming summer,
Speaker:
00:15:26
but for the summer of 2027, right?
Speaker:
00:15:30
The summer in between their second
and third year of law school,
Speaker:
00:15:32
that will then turn
into return job offers.
Speaker:
00:15:36
And then they're set for when they
graduate in the spring of:
2028
Speaker:
00:15:41
And that once you ... Of course,
Speaker:
00:15:44
it's always possible to make a pivot if
you start to go down that path and then
Speaker:
00:15:48
change your mind.
Speaker:
00:15:49
But it is much harder to do that
as opposed to deciding now when
Speaker:
00:15:54
you're at this crucial fork in the road.
As you can tell,
Speaker:
00:15:56
this is kind of a pedestal
that I like to stand on,
Speaker:
00:15:59
but I really do think that it's
important to kind of spread the word
Speaker:
00:16:04
among law students at our
North Carolina law schools,
Speaker:
00:16:07
that this is a viable career path.
Speaker:
00:16:09
You can do work that aligns with your
values and you can make enough money
Speaker:
00:16:14
to pay your bills because often it is
presented as a total dichotomy where
Speaker:
00:16:19
you can either go into big law and of
course you don't have to worry as much on
Speaker:
00:16:24
the finance side. You'll be able to
pay your law school loans and all that,
Speaker:
00:16:29
and you can do work that maybe you
have some interest in one type of
Speaker:
00:16:34
that law or another,
Speaker:
00:16:36
but generally you're probably less
likely to be super passionate about that,
Speaker:
00:16:40
or you can go into maybe
a government position or a
Speaker:
00:16:45
nonprofit position or become a public
defender or an assistant district attorney
Speaker:
00:16:50
or something and do more work
that you're passionate about,
Speaker:
00:16:53
but at the expense of paying the bills.
And for people
Speaker:
00:16:58
who are not independently wealthy,
Speaker:
00:17:02
they don't have maybe other lawyers
in their family and they aren't
Speaker:
00:17:06
super aware of the different
career paths that are out there,
Speaker:
00:17:11
that's a really daunting decision
to have to make so early on.
Speaker:
00:17:15
And so I do think that now more than
ever it is important for folks in
Speaker:
00:17:20
NCAJ in formal ways, but also in informal
ways to make some of those mentor,
Speaker:
00:17:25
mentee connections with law
school students and kind
of show them that there's
Speaker:
00:17:30
this middle path out there.
Speaker:
00:17:32
Yeah. Yeah. Well,
Speaker:
00:17:33
we're definitely thankful
for all of the work that
Speaker:
00:17:38
you've been doing on that front as
co-chair of the Law School Outreach
Speaker:
00:17:43
Committee. And we've boosted
our efforts there a lot,
Speaker:
00:17:47
but I think that we've got to
continue to be out there and just be
Speaker:
00:17:52
present. There's so many
people who don't even know ...
Speaker:
00:17:57
Even as far into your second
or third year in law school,
Speaker:
00:18:00
they don't even have a ...
Speaker:
00:18:02
Someplace like Campbell would be an
exception where they have a very active
Speaker:
00:18:07
trial lawyer or their
advocacy program is so huge.
Speaker:
00:18:11
But there are a lot of schools where
understanding really what a plaintiff's
Speaker:
00:18:15
attorney is is not ... We're not
competing as well as we should be.
Speaker:
00:18:19
No. And in fact,
Speaker:
00:18:20
that was my experience and that was the
exact reason why I was interested in
Speaker:
00:18:24
joining the law school outreach
committee in the first place.
Speaker:
00:18:27
I guess a year and a half ago now when
it was our first time doing that with the
Speaker:
00:18:31
new lawyers division,
Speaker:
00:18:32
this is only our second school year
with the law school outreach committee.
Speaker:
00:18:35
So I went to Duke for law
school, stayed around in Durham,
Speaker:
00:18:39
although I will note for the record that
I am a Tarheel. I had a great, really,
Speaker:
00:18:44
really great experience at Duke Law,
Speaker:
00:18:46
but that experience had
absolutely or basically no
Speaker:
00:18:52
knowledge or understanding or instruction
about the fact that this career path
Speaker:
00:18:57
was out there,
Speaker:
00:18:57
that you could go to a smaller plaintiff's
civil rights oriented law firm.
Speaker:
00:19:02
And I mentioned that in touch
with a lot of law students,
Speaker:
00:19:06
I am proud to say that Duke Law,
Speaker:
00:19:08
actually I was just in touch over the
holidays with a student who is starting up
Speaker:
00:19:13
a plaintiff's law association at Duke.
And so to your point,
Speaker:
00:19:17
those sorts of organizations have been
established for many years at places like
Speaker:
00:19:22
Campbell. I think they're
similar at UNC Law,
Speaker:
00:19:25
Elon and NC Central, for example, a civil
rights society at Central that's very,
Speaker:
00:19:30
very active.
Speaker:
00:19:32
But even in some of the schools that
are North Carolina law schools that are
Speaker:
00:19:37
less well known for placing folks in
that career path are starting to get the
Speaker:
00:19:42
word out a little bit. So
I'm excited about that.
Speaker:
00:19:45
Yeah. Well, we will keep at it with
you for ... And hopefully we can ...
Speaker:
00:19:50
I read somewhere that law school
applications are through the roof this
Speaker:
00:19:55
year. There's like a bumper crop,
Speaker:
00:19:59
so there's going to be more
and more ... I don't know.
Speaker:
00:20:02
I think that was a nationwide
statistic that I read,
Speaker:
00:20:05
but I'm sure that it will be
spread throughout the country.
Speaker:
00:20:08
And so there's even more folks
we can target for getting
Speaker:
00:20:12
into the profession.
Speaker:
00:20:14
That's right. We will
never, as smaller firms,
Speaker:
00:20:17
and even as an NCAJ organization
or kind of coalition,
Speaker:
00:20:23
we will never have the
exact same approach or exact
Speaker:
00:20:28
same sort of infrastructure that some
of the big law firms have in their on
Speaker:
00:20:32
campus interviews and
recruitment and stuff like that.
Speaker:
00:20:35
But I Think that actually
makes the mentorship
Speaker:
00:20:40
piece even more important,
Speaker:
00:20:42
that we don't have as much of that
infrastructure to rely on. And again,
Speaker:
00:20:46
going back to my experience,
Speaker:
00:20:48
I really only became aware
that this career path
Speaker:
00:20:53
was out there and was viable and was
something that would really align with my
Speaker:
00:20:58
values and the work that I want to be
doing because I had the great privilege
Speaker:
00:21:03
and fortune of clerking for some judges
who were former plaintiff's lawyers,
Speaker:
00:21:08
and they were the ones who kind
of steered me in that direction.
Speaker:
00:21:12
And so it was a direct result of that
mentorship and that kind of guidance that
Speaker:
00:21:17
I didn't get in law school,
Speaker:
00:21:18
but that hopefully more and more
people will be getting in law school.
Speaker:
00:21:22
That's right, because you were
clerked for Justice Robin Hudson,
Speaker:
00:21:28
who was a longtime member of NCHA.
Speaker:
00:21:32
That's right. Before it was
NCHA even. Yep, that's right.
Speaker:
00:21:35
Yes, yes. She was a longtime member
of the Academy of Trial Lawyers.
Speaker:
00:21:40
I'm sure that she pointed
you in our direction.
Speaker:
00:21:43
She did. Yeah, she absolutely did.
Speaker:
00:21:45
She was largely a workers' comp attorney
Speaker:
00:21:50
before she was on the bench,
when she was in private practice.
Speaker:
00:21:53
And then of course,
Speaker:
00:21:55
as any of our workers' comp
practitioners and NCHA know,
Speaker:
00:22:00
use that experience once
she was on the bench,
Speaker:
00:22:03
she was always the one that when she was
on the court of appeals that the panel
Speaker:
00:22:07
turned to and when she was on the Supreme
Court that the rest of the justices
Speaker:
00:22:10
turned to for a lot of not
just workers' comp issues,
Speaker:
00:22:14
but plaintiff's issues generally.
Speaker:
00:22:16
You will very often find her name at
the top of a lot of those opinions,
Speaker:
00:22:20
medical malpractice opinions,
workers' comp opinions,
Speaker:
00:22:24
and really even civil rights opinions
writ broadly. I mean, gerrymandering,
Speaker:
00:22:29
the most recently Andrew opinion Justice
Hudson authored. And so selfishly,
Speaker:
00:22:34
she had a huge impact on my career,
but more importantly than that,
Speaker:
00:22:37
she's also had a really big impact
on the plaintiff's bar and on
Speaker:
00:22:42
the jurisprudence and civil
rights in North Carolina.
Speaker:
00:22:46
Yeah.
Speaker:
00:22:47
And then you also clerked for
Judge James Wynn on the US Court of
Speaker:
00:22:51
Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.
Speaker:
00:22:53
That's right. That was another
... Both of those opportunities,
Speaker:
00:22:56
kind of going back to the serendipity
point earlier where I kind of
Speaker:
00:23:01
felt like I was struck by
lightning where right place,
Speaker:
00:23:04
right time with Judge Wynn in particular,
Speaker:
00:23:07
I clerked for him briefly while
one of his other clerks was out
Speaker:
00:23:12
on parental leave and he
knew Justice Hudson and
Speaker:
00:23:17
this was relatively shortly after
my time with Justice Hudson.
Speaker:
00:23:21
And so that relationship kind of made
the connection from my time with Judge
Speaker:
00:23:26
Wynn and very, very
similarly to Justice Hudson.
Speaker:
00:23:29
He was a plaintiff's lawyer
out in Eastern North Carolina.
Speaker:
00:23:31
He had a law firm with Congressman
Butterfield and a few other folks out
Speaker:
00:23:36
there,
Speaker:
00:23:38
and they did a lot of
whatever came in the door,
Speaker:
00:23:43
whether it was workers' comp, whether
it was kind of more commercial stuff,
Speaker:
00:23:47
lots of smaller claims and
working their way up. And then
Speaker:
00:23:52
when he was on the bench, and he's of
course still on the federal bench now,
Speaker:
00:23:56
has had a huge impact when he was in the
North Carolina appellate courts and on
Speaker:
00:24:00
the Fourth Circuit in state and
then federal civil rights issues.
Speaker:
00:24:04
So I have been very,
Speaker:
00:24:06
very fortunate over the last several
years to have some really incredible
Speaker:
00:24:11
mentors who not only told me
about, "Hey, this is what NCAJ is,
Speaker:
00:24:16
this is what being a
plaintiff's lawyer is,
Speaker:
00:24:19
is what being a civil rights lawyer is,
Speaker:
00:24:20
" but also had more personalized
encouragement where they
Speaker:
00:24:25
got to know me enough to say,
Speaker:
00:24:26
"I really think that you should consider
this and let me connect you with a few
Speaker:
00:24:30
folks you might want to talk to about it.
Speaker:
00:24:32
" So I just think that I had my
own examples in my own life and
Speaker:
00:24:37
career of how valuable that mentorship is.
And so that's one of the reasons why
Speaker:
00:24:42
I love being able to connect law
students with people in NCAJ or judges or
Speaker:
00:24:46
clerks or other folks who can kind of
provide some of that guidance for them.
Speaker:
00:24:50
And now you're with a firm which
has a couple of really great
Speaker:
00:24:55
NCAJ members at the top as well.
Speaker:
00:24:57
That's right. Yeah.
Speaker:
00:24:58
Matt Ballou and PJ Perier are our founding
partners here at the firm and they
Speaker:
00:25:03
are both NCAJ members.
Speaker:
00:25:04
Matt has been an NCAJ member
and leader for at least 15
Speaker:
00:25:10
years now. And I have two
co-associates now, Trent Turk,
Speaker:
00:25:14
who was in the class of 2025
Speaker:
00:25:18
cohort of NCAJ NEXT and Catherine
Copeland who recently wrapped
Speaker:
00:25:23
up her clerkship with Justice Riggs,
Speaker:
00:25:26
who if we do have a
future NCAJ new cohort,
Speaker:
00:25:30
we will definitely be
encouraging her to join as well.
Speaker:
00:25:33
So hopefully we'll do a sweep
with the associates there.
Speaker:
00:25:36
Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. For 2026,
Speaker:
00:25:39
we're going to do the NEXT Steps program,
Speaker:
00:25:41
which will be sort of a recap for all
of the fellows who've come through the
Speaker:
00:25:45
past few years. But for 2027,
Speaker:
00:25:48
I'm sure we'll be doing it again because
it's been such a tremendous success for
Speaker:
00:25:53
us. We've had such great folks come
through and so many of you have
Speaker:
00:25:58
stepped into tremendous leadership
roles in the organization that we've
Speaker:
00:26:03
just, it's been NEXT has
been just a great program.
Speaker:
00:26:07
I know for me, it was really
impactful on several levels.
Speaker:
00:26:11
Obviously connecting with my friends
and colleagues who are in our cohort and
Speaker:
00:26:15
kind of having that
group of people who now,
Speaker:
00:26:18
even though it's been two years since
we were in the program together,
Speaker:
00:26:20
we can still be in touch and still
bounce ideas off of each other. Plus the
Speaker:
00:26:25
mentorship piece with folks
in NCAJ who have been in NCAJ
Speaker:
00:26:31
for a while.
Speaker:
00:26:31
David Henson was my NCHA NEXT
mentor and I owe a whole lot to him
Speaker:
00:26:37
in terms of being able to navigate this
early stage of my career in a lot of
Speaker:
00:26:42
ways.
Speaker:
00:26:42
And then just getting to know the
history of the organization and the
Speaker:
00:26:47
mission of the organization,
Speaker:
00:26:49
it's something that it sounds
really basic when you say it,
Speaker:
00:26:53
but it makes it so that it's not just
a listserv and it's not just convention
Speaker:
00:26:58
once a year.
Speaker:
00:26:59
I felt very fortunate to be able to begin
my career in private practice with an
Speaker:
00:27:04
experience like that.
Speaker:
00:27:07
Wow, that's great. That is great.
Speaker:
00:27:09
Everything that NCAJ has done
for NEXT has like yielded
Speaker:
00:27:14
like twice as many blessings back.
So it's been a great program for us,
Speaker:
00:27:19
including the fact that you're
co-chairing this upcoming CLE,
Speaker:
00:27:23
which has an incredible lineup.
Speaker:
00:27:26
Yeah. We are really excited about it
and thank you for highlighting it.
Speaker:
00:27:30
And we hope,
Speaker:
00:27:30
obviously we hope that a lot of members
of the civil rights section will attend,
Speaker:
00:27:34
but it's also designed such that
you don't have to be a civil rights
Speaker:
00:27:38
practitioner in order
to get a lot out of it.
Speaker:
00:27:42
So we heard a lot from
our civil rights section
Speaker:
00:27:47
members at convention last year
that they were interested in
Speaker:
00:27:51
particular in having,
Speaker:
00:27:54
or in hearing from current judges
and current appellate judges if
Speaker:
00:27:58
possible, because so much of civil
rights litigation ends up up on appeal.
Speaker:
00:28:03
And then also this one was a
little bit of a curveball for me,
Speaker:
00:28:06
but I think it makes good sense.
Speaker:
00:28:08
There was a big express interest
from the section members to
Speaker:
00:28:13
hear from somebody who's traditionally
opposing counsel on the other side of the
Speaker:
00:28:18
V and who has experienced defending
civil rights claims on behalf
Speaker:
00:28:23
of either municipalities or
insurance companies or kind of our
Speaker:
00:28:28
classic civil rights litigation
defendants. And so we
were able to kind of check
Speaker:
00:28:33
both of those boxes or fulfill both of
those requests with our panelists and
Speaker:
00:28:38
speakers at the event.
Speaker:
00:28:39
We're going to have Justice Trey Allen
from the North Carolina Supreme Court
Speaker:
00:28:44
talk about state law immunities.
Speaker:
00:28:48
So things like sovereign
official, excuse me,
Speaker:
00:28:51
sovereign immunity or
public official immunity.
Speaker:
00:28:54
And he was a long time and
is a longtime expert in that
Speaker:
00:28:59
field from back when he worked
at the UNC School of Government,
Speaker:
00:29:02
wrote a really insightful treatise or kind
Speaker:
00:29:07
of pamphlet about state level immunities
that civil rights claims often come
Speaker:
00:29:12
up against. And then our second
program will be from David Coats,
Speaker:
00:29:17
who if NCAJ folks recognize that name,
Speaker:
00:29:20
it will either be from being on the
other side of the V as defense counsel,
Speaker:
00:29:24
or he also does a lot of
great mediation work as well.
Speaker:
00:29:27
So we were excited to hear his
perspective. He'll be speaking about
Speaker:
00:29:32
navigating insurance policies,
Speaker:
00:29:34
whether it's a municipality
or a police department,
Speaker:
00:29:37
kind of some of the modern
twists or wrinkles that you
Speaker:
00:29:42
might find in these insurance policies
and how to navigate your way through them
Speaker:
00:29:47
or around them. And then
last but certainly not least,
Speaker:
00:29:51
Justice Anita Earls from the North
Carolina Supreme Court is going to be
Speaker:
00:29:55
speaking to us a little bit more broadly
about how civil rights litigation
Speaker:
00:30:00
Negators can use the North
Carolina constitution in
Speaker:
00:30:04
civil rights claims and
recent developments in North
Carolina constitutional
Speaker:
00:30:09
law as it relates to certain civil
rights claims. Things like, well,
Speaker:
00:30:13
Leandro obviously is a state civil
rights state constitutional claim,
Speaker:
00:30:18
but also especially after the pandemic,
Speaker:
00:30:21
there was a lot of litigation that
some of our section members were really
Speaker:
00:30:25
leading in a lot of ways behind
the fruits of the labor clause,
Speaker:
00:30:28
which is another kind of niche clause
of the North Carolina Constitution. Of
Speaker:
00:30:32
course, we have our own version of
equal protection and due process.
Speaker:
00:30:38
So Justice Earls will be speaking
about how you can consider those
Speaker:
00:30:43
claims and how those types of
claims have developed over time.
Speaker:
00:30:46
Yeah, that's going to be great. That
is going to be a terrific program.
Speaker:
00:30:49
And I could definitely see how it would
be something that have an appeal beyond
Speaker:
00:30:54
the civil rights section for sure.
Speaker:
00:30:56
Yeah. Thank you. Like I said,
like we talked about earlier,
Speaker:
00:31:00
there is an element in the
work that all of us do in NCAJ
Speaker:
00:31:05
of advocating for somebody who for one
Speaker:
00:31:10
reason or another has been put in kind
of this marginalized position going up
Speaker:
00:31:15
against this larger institutional power.
Speaker:
00:31:18
And the CLE that we'll have
later this month is designed to
Speaker:
00:31:23
help folks navigate some of
the complexities in that,
Speaker:
00:31:26
because there are always going to
be systemic barriers when you are
Speaker:
00:31:31
doing that type of work. And so
we're hoping that in a small way,
Speaker:
00:31:35
this will be useful in
those types of claims.
Speaker:
00:31:37
Yeah. Terrific. Terrific. Well, Zack,
Speaker:
00:31:42
thank you for your work on this and
for helping us spread the word to
Speaker:
00:31:48
potential plaintiff's lawyers in law
school and for everything you do for NCAJ.
Speaker:
00:31:52
No, thank you very much for having
me on and for highlighting our CLE
Speaker:
00:31:57
January 29th, and I hope a lot of your
listeners will be able to join us.
Speaker:
00:32:02
I do too. I do too. As Zack said,
Speaker:
00:32:05
that program is on January 29.
Speaker:
00:32:08
It is at NCAJ headquarters in
Raleigh, or you can attend virtually.
Speaker:
00:32:12
And there will be a social after
the CLE where you can chat with the
Speaker:
00:32:17
attendees and potentially
the presenters as well.
Speaker:
00:32:21
You can register for that or any of
the other terrific CLEs we have coming
Speaker:
00:32:26
up in January and February
at ncaja.com/events.
Speaker:
00:32:33
Before we go, I'd like to thank today's
episode sponsor, Advocate Capital.
Speaker:
00:32:38
Advocate is passionate about helping
plaintiff's attorneys get better results
Speaker:
00:32:41
for clients, mainly through their
AdvoTrack case expense funding service.
Speaker:
00:32:46
It allows firms to track case
expenses and recover borrowing costs,
Speaker:
00:32:51
which makes the net cost of
borrowing zero on cases they win.
Speaker:
00:32:55
Learn more at advocatecapital.com.
Thanks everyone for listening.
Speaker:
00:33:00
And if you're watching on YouTube, don't
forget to subscribe to this channel.
Speaker:
00:33:07
Thank you for joining us on
this episode of Voices of NCAJ.
Speaker:
00:33:10
For more information on the North Carolina
Advocates for Justice and how to join
Speaker:
00:33:15
or support NCAJ,
Speaker:
00:33:16
please visit our website at www.ncaj.com.